Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.15
REGULAR CAUSE LIST
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CRM(M) 213/2020
CrlM (762/2020)
ABDUL GANI NAJAR
Through:
…Petitioner(s)
Mr. I. A. Sofi, Advocate for Petitioner Nos. 1 to 5.
Mr. Hayat Sikander, Advocate for Petitioner Nos. 6&7.
Vs.
UNION TERRITORY OF JAMMU
AND KASHMIR THROUGH POLICE
STATION TREHGAM, KUPWARA
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Mr. Faheem Nisar, Shah, GA
Mr. Tabir Hussain, Investigating Officer belt No.
334/KP present in person.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
26.09.2026
1. Heard the counsel for the parties and examined the case diaries.
2. The present FIR arises out of an incident dated 23 rd July 2020. The
revenue authorities, comprising the complainant and the Naib
Tehsildar, Executive Magistrate 1st Class, Kowari Laderwan,
District Kupwara, submitted a written complaint to the SHO of the
Police Station concerned, alleging that the petitioners had reencroached upon land falling under Survey No. 249 of Village
Mirhama, recorded in the revenue record as Kachahri land with the
classification “Gair Mum kin Rasta”.
3. It was alleged in the complaint that the encroachment over the
aforesaid survey number had been removed earlier on the same day
by the revenue authorities in the presence of the SHO concerned
and the field staff. According to the complainant, however, the
1 | Page
petitioners thereafter re-encroached upon a portion of the said land,
thereby obstructing the passage used by the residents of Najar
Mohalla. On the basis of these allegations, a request was made for
registration of an FIR.
4. Ld. counsel for the petitioners contends that the offences under
Sections 147 and 447 of the IPC are not made out from the
allegations contained in the FIR. It is submitted that the FIR does
not contain any specific allegation that the petitioners had
constituted an unlawful assembly with the object of committing
rioting and, therefore, the essential ingredients of the offence under
Section 147 IPC are absent.
5. It is further contended that the petitioners had already instituted a
civil suit seeking protection of their property and that the villagers,
at whose behest the criminal proceedings are alleged to have been
initiated, were attempting to carve out a pathway through the land
of the petitioners.
6. Per contra, the counsel for the respondents submits that the matter
has been duly investigated and that the material collected during
the course of investigation discloses the commission of offences
punishable under Sections 147 and 447 IPC.
7. It is further submitted that the civil suit relied upon by the
petitioners pertains to land falling under Khasra Nos. 246 and 247
of Village Mirhama, Tehsil Trehgam, District Kupwara, whereas
the subject matter of the present FIR related to Khasra No. 249.
According to the respondents, the petitioners, under the cover of
the aforesaid civil proceedings, sought to encroach upon a public
pathway situated over Kahcharai land. It is submitted that the
2 | Page
revenue authorities, while removing the encroachment, were
merely discharging their official duties pursuant to directions
issued by the competent superior authorities.
8. Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that the
investigation conducted thus far has also disclosed the commission
of an offence punishable under Section 353 IPC against the
petitioners. It is, however, submitted that the said offence had not
initially been incorporated by the Investigating Officer.
9. In rebuttal, the counsel for the petitioners submits that the criminal
case has been falsely foisted upon them. According to the
petitioners, it was they who had approached the superior revenue
authorities seeking demarcation of their land. It is contended that,
without awaiting such demarcation, the respondents, in connivance
with certain villagers who intended to carve out a pathway through
the petitioners’ land, caused the impugned FIR to be registered.
10.I have heard the counsel for the parties and considered the material
on record. At the outset, it deserves to be noticed that the FIR has
not been registered at the instance of any private villager. Rather,
the occurrence was reported by the revenue authorities themselves.
According to the allegations, the revenue authorities had removed
the encroachment on the date of the occurrence, but the petitioners
thereafter, having allegedly formed an unlawful assembly, reencroached upon the same land and committed trespass upon the
public pathway. Whether the material collected during the course
of investigation ultimately establishes the commission of the
offences alleged against the petitioners is a matter to be examined
by the competent trial court at the appropriate stage.
3 | Page
11.It may also be noticed that, pursuant to the earlier directions passed
by this Court, the investigating agency was permitted to continue
with the investigation, subject to the condition that the chargesheet would not be filed without leave of this Court.
12.Learned counsel for the respondents submits that the investigation
now stands concluded and the charge-sheet is ready to be presented
before the competent trial court. It is further submitted that all
defences available to the petitioners may appropriately be raised
before the trial court. The submission merits acceptance.
13.The inherent jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 CrPC to
quash an FIR or criminal proceedings is required to be exercised
sparingly and in exceptional circumstances. Where the allegations,
taken at their face value and considered along with the material
collected during investigation, disclose the commission of
cognizable offences, this Court would ordinarily refrain from
undertaking an assessment of the sufficiency or reliability of the
evidence at the stage of considering a petition for quashing. In the
present case, the mere pendency of a civil dispute between the
petitioners and private respondent Nos. 5 to 8 does not, by itself,
establish that the criminal proceedings arising out of the
occurrence in question are merely an attempt to give a criminal
colour to a civil dispute.
14.Significantly, the civil suit relied upon by the petitioners is pending
between the petitioners and the private respondents. Although an
order of status quo was passed therein on 2nd July 2020, the said
order did not operate against the revenue authorities, who
admittedly were not parties to those proceedings. More
4 | Page
importantly, the civil suit concerns land falling under Khasra Nos.
246 and 247, whereas the occurrence giving rise to the present FIR
pertains to Khasra No. 249. The latter, according to the revenue
record, is recorded as Kahcharai land under the classification “Gair
Mum kin Rasta” and is stated to constitute a pathway on the spot.
15.The specific allegation against the petitioners is that they had
encroached upon the aforesaid pathway. The encroachment was
removed by the revenue officials in the discharge of their official
duties. Notwithstanding such removal, the petitioners are alleged to
have thereafter trespassed upon the said land and attempted to reencroach upon it after forming an unlawful assembly.
16.Learned counsel for the petitioners has strenuously contended that
the ingredients of the offence punishable under Section 147 IPC
are not made out. This Court, however, while exercising
jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC, is not expected to undertake a
meticulous examination of the evidence collected during
investigation or determine whether such evidence would ultimately
be sufficient to frame a charge or secure a conviction. These are
matters falling within the domain of the trial court and are required
to be considered at the appropriate stage of the proceedings.
17.It is also pertinent to notice that, as is evident from the C.D file
produced before this Court, an offence under Section 353 IPC has
also been found to be attracted during investigation. The allegation
in this regard is that the petitioners obstructed the revenue
authorities while they were discharging their official duties in
connection with the removal of the encroachment over land falling
under Khasra No. 249.
5 | Page
18.The matter has been investigated in detail and, upon completion of
the investigation, material is stated to have been collected
disclosing the commission of offences punishable under Sections
147, 447 and 353 IPC against the petitioners. At this stage, it
would neither be appropriate nor permissible for this Court to
embark upon an appreciation of such material as if exercising the
jurisdiction of the trial court.
19.The contention that the petitioners had themselves approached the
revenue authorities seeking demarcation of the disputed land has
also been considered. Nothing has been brought to the notice of
this Court, at this stage, to demonstrate that the demarcation sought
by the petitioners extended to land falling under Khasra No. 249.
On the contrary, the material placed on record indicates that the
demarcation proceedings pertain to the land forming the subject
matter of the civil suit, namely, Khasra Nos. 246 and 247.
20.The plea of the petitioners that the criminal proceedings have been
falsely instituted might have required consideration on a different
footing had the FIR been lodged by the private respondents with
whom the petitioners are admittedly embroiled in a civil dispute.
The position in the present case, however, is materially different.
The occurrence was reported by the revenue authorities
themselves, who claim to have witnessed the acts forming the
subject matter of the FIR while discharging their official functions.
No specific allegation of mala fides or abuse of authority has been
levelled against the said revenue officials so as to justify
interference with the criminal proceedings at this stage.
6 | Page
21.In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no ground
warranting exercise of its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482
CrPC for quashing the FIR or the consequential proceedings. The
petition is, accordingly, dismissed. The investigating agency shall
be at liberty to proceed with the filing of the charge-sheet before
the competent court in accordance with law. It is, however, made
clear that the petitioners shall be at liberty to raise all pleas and
defences available to them before the trial court, including by
seeking discharge at the appropriate stage. Any observations made
herein are confined to the adjudication of the present petition and
shall not prejudice the trial court while considering the matter on
its own merits.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
SRINAGAR:
26.09.2026
Shaista-PS
7 | Page
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review