Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:903
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 171 of 2021
Date of Decision: 04.10.2024
1. Shri. Aban Momin
Son of (L) Welson Sangma,
Resident of: Rongrekgiri,
Post Office and Police Station: Williamnagar,
District: East Garo Hills, Meghalaya
2. Smti. Jostina R. Marak,
Wife of:- Aban Momin,
Resident of: Rongrekgiri,
Post Office and Police Station: Williamnagar,
District: East Garo Hills, Meghalaya
………Petitioners
-Vrs1. The Garo Hills Autonomous District Council,
Tura, represented by the Secretary, Executive Member,
Garo Hills District Council, Tura.
2. The Executive Member, I/C Land and Revenue, Garo Hills
Autonomous District Council, Tura.
3. The Chief Executive Member, Garo Hills Autonomous District
Count, Tura.
4. Smti. Nerinjinjing R. Sangma,
Wife of:- Late Withing Marak,
R/o: Rongrekgiri
Post Office and Police Station,
District: East Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
..….Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
2024:MLHC:903
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. A.H. Hazarika, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Dey, SC, GHADC (For R 1-3)
Mr. P. Nongbri, Adv.
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv. (For R 4)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
A dispute between the petitioners and the respondent No. 4 as
regard the status of Nokmaship of Rongrekgiri Akhing is the subject
matter wherein, on an application before this Court registered as
WP(C) No. 26 of 2014, vide order dated 08.03.2018, the matter was
remanded to the Executive Member, Garo Hills Autonomous District
Council (GHADC) to allow cross-examination of the petitioner’s
(therein) witnesses and a further direction was also given to the Chief
Executive Member to dispose of any appeal arising thereto within one
month.
2.
On such remand, the learned Executive Member, GHADC took
necessary steps in this regard and finally after hearing the parties, has
passed the order dated 17.12.2019 holding that the respondent No. 4 is
the Nokma of the Rongmutu clan and as such is entitled to be the joint
Nokma of the Rongrekgiri Akhing along with the petitioners who are
the Nokma from the Raksam clan. On being aggrieved by such order,
the respondent therein has preferred an appeal before the learned Chief
Executive Member, GHADC, who after hearing the parties has passed
2024:MLHC:903
the order dated 16.10.2020 by dismissing the appeal and in effect,
upheld the order of the learned Executive Member, GHADC.
3.
The petitioners herein being aggrieved by the order of the
learned Executive Member dated 17.12.2019 as well as the order of the
learned Chief Executive Member dated 16.10.2020 have now once
again approached this Court with a prayer that the orders impugned
herein be set aside and quashed.
4.
According to the petitioner, the background story of the case is
that Rongrekgiri Akhing No. IV 56(10) in the East Garo Hills District
was purchased from late Jingnang Nokma of Rongbibggiri village by
the predecessor-in-interest of the Raksam Clan of the petitioners, late
Sanna Sangma and late Jimra Sangma for a sum of ₹ 800/- (rupees
eight hundred) on 08.01.1918.
5.
Soon after the said purchase, the buyers then intimated the then
Deputy Commissioner, late F.E. Jackson about the said sale transaction,
who then directed the Mouzadar and Laskar to prepare a map and to
erect boundary pillars, which was done so on 21.01.1918, thereby
recognising the said sale transaction and the right of the Raksam clan
over it.
6.
In due course, late Jenang Sangma and his wife Smti. Binis
Marak, Nokma had filed an application before the Executive Member
Incharge Revenue, GHADC for registration of their heiress Smti.
Jostina R. Marak and her husband Aban Momin as Nokma of the said
Rongrekgiri Akhing and the matter was registered as GDC-Rev No. 71
2024:MLHC:903
A/C of 1987, whereupon, an order dated 15.04.1987 was passed
allowing the same.
7.
In the meantime, one Shri. Nephilson Sangma filed an
application before the Executive Member Incharge Revenue, GHADC
dated 13.12.1996 seeking appointment of Shri. Withing Marak and his
wife Smti. Nerinjing Sangma (respondent No. 4 herein) as Nokma of
the said Rongregiri Akhing, which application was registered as GDC
Rev No. 82 A/C of 1996-97. The said application was allowed vide
order dated 22.08.1997, being aggrieved, the petitioners herein filed an
appeal before the learned Chief Executive Member, GHADC which
appeal was dismissed vide order dated 23.09.2003.
8.
Again, the petitioners herein not being satisfied with the said
orders dated 22.08.1997 and 23.09.2003 (supra), this Court was
approached with a writ petition being WP(C) No. 340(SH) of 2005 and
this Court vide order dated 31.07.2006, set aside and quashed both the
impugned orders aforementioned and remitted the matter to the learned
Executive Member to decide the matter afresh after giving due
opportunity to both the parties to adduce evidence and to make
oral/documentary submission.
9.
Accordingly, the learned Executive Member then started fresh
proceedings and after hearing the parties and on perusal of both oral
and documentary evidence produced by the parties has passed the order
dated 23.07.2012 rejecting the claim of the respondent No. 4 herein
and allowed the petitioners to continue as Nokma of the said Akhing
land in question.
2024:MLHC:903
10.
Yet again, the respondent No. 4 being aggrieved by the order
dated 23.07.2012 (supra) preferred an appeal before the learned Chief
Executive Member, who vide order dated 19.12.2013 set aside the
order of the learned Executive Member.
11.
It is this order dated 19.12.2013 that was challenged before this
Court in WP(C) No. 26 of 2014 resulting in the passing of the said
order dated 08.03.2018.
12.
The learned Executive Member on receipt of the order dated
08.03.2018 had caused notices to be issued to all the parties involved
and on their appearance, after filing of documents and examination of
their respective witnesses, after hearing the parties, the learned
Executive Member has passed the impugned order dated 17.12.2019,
whereupon on being aggrieved by such, the petitioners have filed an
appeal before the learned Chief Executive Member who has then
passed the impugned order dated 16.10.2020 in GHADC-Rev Appeal
Case No. 12 A/C 2020 whereby the order dated 17.12.2019 passed by
the Executive Member was upheld. Hence this petition.
13.
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, learned counsel for the petitioners has
advanced his arguments by leading this Court to the history of the
dispute between the parties and has submitted that since the year 1918
when late Sanna Sangma and late Jimra Sangma who were married to
two sisters of the Raksam clan, the Nokmaship of Rongrekgiri No.
56(10) Akhing has always been under the control of the Raksam clan.
14.
The petitioner’s parents, in the year 1987 have filed the
application before the Executive Member Incharge Revenue only for
2024:MLHC:903
registration of their names as Nokma of the said Akhing which was
done so vide order dated 15.04.1987.
15.
However, after a lapse of 75 years or so, the respondent No. 4
and her deceased husband Withing Marak were appointed as Joint
Nokma of the said Akhing, purportedly on an application made by one
Shri. Nephilson Sangma. The related order dated 22.08.1997 whereby
the said application was allowed, an appeal was therefore preferred by
the petitioners before the Chief Executive Member, GHADC which
was not allowed, leaving the petitioner no choice but to approach this
Court at the relevant point of time. In this regard, the claim of the
respondent No. 4 that the said Akhing was jointly purchased by late
Sanna Nokma, who paid ₹ 400/- and late Khanam Nokma of the
Rongmutu clan who paid ₹ 400/- for the same cannot be substantiated
by documentary evidence, further submits the learned counsel.
16.
The learned counsel has submitted that the fact being that when
the then Deputy Commissioner, F.E. Jackson vide his order dated
09.01.1918 has confirmed the Nokmaship of the predecessor-in-interest
of the petitioners herein over the said Rongrekgiri Akhing, the
members of the Rongmutu clan of the respondent No. 4 has not made
or file any objection to the same, challenging the purport of such order
after 75 years or so would only attract the application of the principle
of res judicata, the case of Smti. Dore Sangma v. The Chief Executive
Member, Garo Hills District Council, Tura and Ors. reported in (1988)
2 Gauhati Law Report 120 at para 23 was cited in support of this
contention.
2024:MLHC:903
17.
Finally, after going through a process of the dispute being
adjudicated by the forum of the learned Executive Member and on
appeal by the learned Chief Executive Member, the culmination of the
process resulting in the passing of the last impugned order, dated
16.10.2020 by the learned Chief Executive Member was evidently
based on incorrect appreciation of the factual aspect of the dispute
between the parties and furthermore, was a violation of the principle of
natural justice inasmuch as the petitioners were never given the
opportunity to be heard by the learned Chief Executive Member while
passing the impugned order dated 16.10.2020, submits the learned
counsel.
18.
The learned counsel has further submitted that in view of the
bias attitude of the concerned Executive Member and the Chief
Executive Member, this Court may be pleased to remand the matter for
reconsideration by the Court of the Judge, District Council, GHADC.
19.
Also heard Mr. P. Nongbri, learned counsel who has presented
the version of the respondent No. 4 as far as the dispute between the
parties are concerned.
20.
It is the submission of the learned counsel that the Rongrekgiri
Akhing was purchased in the year 1917 for an amount of ₹ 400/- each
contributed equally by late Sanna Nokma of Raksam clan and Khaman
Nokma of Rongmutu clan. The Deputy Commissioner of Garo Hills
vide order dated 25.04.1938 has also observed that Sanna and Khaman
are Nokmas of the said Rongrekgiri Akhing with the consent of the
Maharis of Rongmutu and Raksam clans.
2024:MLHC:903
21.
The learned counsel has further submitted that the present
controversy arose from an application that was filed before the
Executive Member Incharge Revenue and vide order dated 22.08.1997,
Withing Marak and his wife, the respondent No. 4 are recognised as the
joint Nokmas of Rongrekgiri Akhing representing the Rongmutu clan.
Even on appeal by the petitioners herein, the appellate authority, that is,
the Chief Executive Member has upheld the order dated 22.08.1997.
However, the matter did not end there since the petitioners have then
approached this Court by way of a writ petition and what followed is
that on the strength of the relevant orders passed by this Court, finally,
by order dated 08.09.2018 passed in WP(C) No. 26 of 2014 the
adjudication of the dispute between the parties was once again referred
to the learned Executive Member Incharge Revenue, to continue
proceedings by allowing the petitioner’s witnesses to be examined.
22.
The learned Executive Member after observing due procedure
and after finally hearing the parties has passed the impugned order
dated 17.12.2019 with a finding that the said Rongrekgiri Akhing is to
be controlled jointly by one Nokma from the Raksam clan and one
from the Rongmutu clan. Again, on appeal, the learned Chief Executive
Member vide order dated 16.10.2020 has confirmed such order.
Therefore, there being no pleadings on any alleged procedural lapse,
the petitioners have not been able to make out a case in their favour
and as such, this petition is liable to be dismissed, submits the learned
counsel.
23.
Mr. S. Dey, learned Standing Counsel, GHADC on behalf of the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 respectively in his reply has refuted the
2024:MLHC:903
contention and submission made by the petitioners to say that the
factual situation is that when the said Rongrekgiri Akhing was
purchased, half of the consideration amount was paid by the fore
parents of the respondent No. 4 and throughout, this fact has not been
able to be dislodged and was confirmed even in the impugned orders
herein.
24.
It is also submitted that there the learned Executive Member has
not committed any procedural lapse in the proceedings before him and
the order was passed based on sound principles of Garo Customary
Law.
25.
As to the contention of the petitioners that they were not heard
by the learned Chief Executive Member in the appeal and the same was
passed exparte, the learned SC has submitted that this statement is not
correct since records would show that both parties were heard and their
respective written argument was also taken into consideration while
passing the said order dated 16.10.2020.
26.
To the prayer of the petitioners that this Court be pleased to refer
the entire matter to the court of the Judge, District Council Court for
proper adjudication, the learned SC has submitted that this prayer
cannot be accepted as there is already an express bar for civil court to
take up matters involving Nokma issues as is seen from Section 11 of
the Garo Hills Autonomous District (Social Customs and Usages)
Validity (Amendment) Act, 1972.
27.
In view of the submission made, the learned SC has submitted
that this petition being devoid of merits, the same be dismissed as such.
2024:MLHC:903
28.
This Court has given careful thought to the case of the parties
and from the submission made as well as from the materials available
on record, including the relevant records of the proceedings before the
learned Executive Member and the learned Chief Executive Member, it
is evident that the fact that Rongrekgiri Akhing was purchased on
09.01.1918 for a sum of ₹ 800/- (rupees eight hundred) only is not
disputed, the purchasers being Sanna Nokma and Jimra Nokma. This
transaction was confirmed by F.E.J, said to be the then Deputy
Commissioner, F.E. Jackson. Annexure-2 of this petition being a copy
of the said acknowledgment. However, another version of the said sale
transaction emerged in the form of a report dated 12.12.1927, by one
J.M. David filed before the then Deputy Commissioner, G.D. Walker,
wherein it was said that Sana and Khaman Nokma are the Akhing
Nokma of Rongrekgiri since the said land was purchased in the year
1917 from Shri. Jingnang Nokma of Rongbingiri, for an amount of ₹
400/- (rupees four hundred) only each.
29.
The dispute that ensued thereafter between the members of the
Raksam clan and the Rongmutu clan is precisely on this issue, as to
what exactly is the nature and mode of the said sale transaction,
whether the Akhing in question was jointly purchased by Sanna and
Jimra or by Sanna and Khaman.
30.
In the impugned order dated 17.12.2019, the learned Executive
Member has indicated that records were perused and deposition of the
witnesses duly noted to come to a finding that the report dated
12.12.1927 confirmed the fact that the Akhing was jointly purchased
by Sanna Nokma and Khaman Nokma who paid ₹ 400/- (rupees four
2024:MLHC:903
hundred) only each. However, the findings of the learned Executive
Member also include an observation that the respondent No. 4 belongs
to the Rongmutu clan and whatever is decided by the clan as regard to
who can be its Nokma cannot be questioned by the petitioners and their
clan, that is, the Raksam clan.
31.
On appeal, the learned Chief Executive Member has also
extensively dealt with the issues raised by the contesting parties and
has also confirmed the findings of the learned Executive Member. This
Court on perusal of the said order dated 16.10.2020 cannot find fault
with the same as the same is a well-reasoned one.
32.
On the contention of the petitioners that they were never heard
by the learned Chief Executive Member on the date the related appeal
came up for hearing, as was submitted by the learned SC, GHADC and
also on perusal of the relevant records wherein on the said date of
hearing, that is 16.10.2020 it is seen that the petitioner/appellant Aban
Momin has filed his hazira on the said date, which would only indicate
that he was present before the learned CEM. Therefore, such
contention by the petitioners cannot be accepted by this Court.
33.
In a case dealing with the issues of dispute as regard the
Nokmaship of an Akhing land, this Court while refusing to go into the
merits of the case of the parties as regard statement of facts and their
evidentiary value, has reiterated the principle governing judicial review
and in this regard has cited the case of Mohammed Hanif v. State of
Assam, (1969) 2 SCC 782 wherein at para 5, extracts of which is
reproduced herein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as follows:-
2024:MLHC:903
“5. It is true that the jurisdiction of the High Court under Article
226 is an extraordinary jurisdiction vested in the High Court not
for the purpose of declaring the private rights of the parties but
for the purpose of ensuring that the law of the land is implicitly
obeyed and that the various tribunals and public authorities are
kept within the limits of their jurisdiction. In other words, the
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 is a supervisory
jurisdiction, a jurisdiction meant to supervise the work of the
tribunals and public authorities and to see that they act within the
limits of their respective jurisdiction. In a proceeding under
Article 226 the High Court is not concerned merely with the
determination of the private rights of the parties; the only object
to such a proceeding under Article 226 is to ensure that the law
of the land is implicitly obeyed and that various authorities and
tribunals act within the limits of their respective jurisdiction….”
34.
Even as the respondent No. 4 has questioned the stand of the
petitioners herein, wherein no specific pleadings have been made to
challenge the decision-making process of the learned EM as well as
that of the learned CEM vis-à-vis the impugned orders herein, this
Court on an overall analysis of the facts and circumstances of this case
has found nothing wrong with the said decision-making process.
35.
On the prayer of the petitioners that the matter be referred to the
civil court, that is, the court of the Judge, District Council Court, Tura,
this prayer is contradicted by the petitioners themselves as at para 3 of
this petition, Section 11 of the Garo Autonomous District (Social
Customs and Usages) Validating (Amendment) Act, 1972 was quoted
to say that since no suit or proceedings falling within the purview of
the Act can be entertained by a civil court, the only remedy available to
the petitioners is to approach this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution. Therefore, there is no question of matters of this kind to
be adjudicated by a civil court.
2024:MLHC:903
36.
In view of the above observations, this Court hereby finds that
the petitioners have not been able to make out a case to upset the
concurrent findings of the learned Executive Member and the learned
Chief Executive Member as is found in the impugned orders referred to
hereinabove.
37.
This petition is accordingly dismissed as devoid of merits.
38.
The relevant records are handed over to the learned Standing
Counsel, GHADC on receipt duly acknowledged.
39.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2024.10.04 16:48:30
PDT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review