Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
I3301 I
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
:i
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO:21556 OF 2024
D
CONTEMPT CASE NO: 2047 OF 2025
w.P.NO
F
Between:
A.Venkateshwarlu, S/o. A.Sathaiah, Aged about 55 years, occ. Assistant
Conservator of Forests/Deputy Director, FCRI, Mulugu, Siddipet
PETITIONER
AND
'1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal
to Govemment,
Envilgnment, Forests, Science and Technology Depa
Secretariat,
Hyderabad -500022.
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Govemment,
Municipal Administration and Urban Development Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad - 500022.
3. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests and Head of the Forest Force,
Telangana, Aranya Bhavan, Saifabad, Hyderabad - 500 004
4. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (GHMC), Head Office,
Tankbund, Hyderabad Rep. by its Commissioner
5. The Director, Greater Hyderabad Municipal'Corporation (GHMC), Urban
Forestry' lndira Park' Hyderabad
...RES'.NDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ or direction more particularly one in the Writ of Mandamus
declaring the aition of 2nd Respondent in issuing impugned Article of Charges in
GO Rt.No.81, MA and UD (Vig.ll) Department, dated 18.02.2016 issued on the
recommendation of the Alert Note No.118 (c) No.10874/ and E/NR.ll/11, dated
15.04.2014 given by the General Administration, V and E Department and the 2nd
Respondent is neither the appointing authority nor the disciplinary authority as per
Rule 2 and 9 of Telangana Civil Services Classification, Control and Appeal Rules,
1991 to issue disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner, declare the same as
arbitrary, illegal, without jurisdiction, set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 20L4
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the rbspondents; to consider and promote the petiti6ner to the post of Deputy
Conservator of f:orest forthwith without reference to the Article of Charges issued
by the second respondent in GO Rt.No.81, MA and UD (Vigil) Department, dated
18.02.2016 for tre incident pertaining to the year 2009 in view of the long delay
caused, pending disposal of the above writ petition.
Between
'l
. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Municipal l\dministration and Urban Development Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad -5OO022.
2. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests and Head of the Forest Force,
Telangana Aranya Bhavan, Saifabad, Hyderabad - 500 004
...pETlTlONE
RESPONDENTS
AND
1. A.Venkates hwarlu, S/o. A.Sathaiah, Aged about 55 years, occ. Assistant '
Conservator of Forests/Deputy Director, FCRI, Mulugu, Siddipet
...RESPONOENTS/
PETITIONERS
2 The State of telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Environmerrt, Forests, Science and Technology Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad - 5OO 022.
3. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (GHMC), Head Office,
Tankbund, l'lyderabad Rep. by its Commissioner
4. The Directo', Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (GHMC), Urban
Forestry, lndira Park, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS/
RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed n support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the lnterim order dated. 14-08-2024 in W.P.No.21556 of 2024 and dismiss
the Writ Petition.
counsel for the Petitioner: SRI P.SURESH REDDY, sENloR coUNsEL FoR
SRI GUNDRATI RAMAN GOUD
Gounsel for the Respondent Nos.1 TO 3: GP FOR SERVICES-I
counse! for the Respondent Nos.4 & 5: SRt G.NARAYANA, sc FOR GHMC
C.C.NO: 2047 OF 2025
' Between:
A.Venkateshwqrlu, S/o. A.Sathaiah, Aged about 56 years, occ.Assistant
Conservator of Forests/Deputy Director, FCRI , lVlulugu, Siddipet
AND
... PETITIONER/PETITIONE R
1- Sri Ahmed Nadeem, l.A.s.,Principal secretary, State of rerangana,
Environment, Forests, science and rechnolojy Department, S-6cretariat,
Hyderabad - 500 022.
2. Dr.C.Suvama Chandrappagari lFS, Principal Chief Conservator of Forests
and Head of th_e_F_orest Force, Telangana, Aranya Bhavan, saifabad,
Hyderabad - 500 004
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS 1 & 3
Contempt Case under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts Act 1g7t to
punish the respondents herein for willfully violating the Hon'ble Court order in
dated 14.08.2024 passed in WP.No.21556 of 2024.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI GUNDRATT RAMAN GOUD
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES-I
-The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
a
IN THE II.IGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA I{ARTHIK
WRIT PETITION No.2 1556 0F 20.24
and
CONTEMPT CASE No.2O47 OF 2O2S
Dated 9tt Januliv . 2O26
Between:
A.Venkateshvrarlu
Petitioner
A}ID
The State of Telangana,
Rep. By its Principal Secretary to Government,
Environment, Forests, Science & Technologr Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad & (4) others
Respondents
COMMON ORDER:
Since the grievance of the petitioner in both these matters is
inter se connected with each other, they are taken up together and
being disposect of by this common order.
2)
Heard Sri P.suresh Reddy, learned senior counsel,
representing sri G.Raman Goud, learned counsel for the petitioner,
learned Government pleader for services-l appearing for
respondents -, to 3, and Sri G.Narayana, learned Standing
Counsel, appeering for respondents 4 and 5.
PK, J
w_2r556_2024
and
cc_2047_2025
3)
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that an
Article of charge vide G.o.Rt.No.g1, MA & uD (vig.Il) Department,
dated 18.02-2016, was issued by respondent No.2 to the petitioner
alleging that while the petitioner was working on deputation as
Forest Range officer in the office of respondent No.4 during the
period from 06.09.2008 to og.l2.2oog he has not put the date
under his initial recorded in the Measurement Book at a few places
during check measurement of four works out of many works,
without jurisdiction and after a lapse of g years, for which, the
petitioner has submitted his explanation denying ,_1. charge.
However, without considering the said explanation, an enquiry was
ordered. The Enquiry officer has conducted the enquiry in
violation of Rule 20 of relangana civil services (ccA) Rule, lggl
(in short 'ccA Rules, lggl) and submitted the Enquiry Report
dated 05.03.2023 holding that the charge against the petitioner is
proved. But, so far, no fina1 orders are passed, pursuant to the
Enquiry Report. Learned senior counsel has contended that
though the petitioner is eligible for promotion to the post of Deputy
Conservator of Forests, the respondents are not considering his
case for promotion on the ground that departmental enquiry is still
/
/
a
PK, J
J
wp_2t556-2024
and
cc_2047_2025
pending. Le'arned senior counsel has further contended that the
very initiatio::r of departmental proceedings against the petitioner is
violative of Flule 2 of CCA Rules, 1991, inasmuch as Respondent
No.2 is neither the Appointing Authority nor Disciplinary Authority
of the petitioner. Learned senior counsel has also contended that
in case of the petitioner, respondent Nos.1 and 3 are the appointing
authorities. Therefore, the impugned G.o.Rt.No.g1 dated
L8.02.2023 lacks jurisdiction and therefore liable to be set aside.
Reliance has oeen placed on:
a) Union o"'f India u. J.Ahmedt;
b) Inspecttr Prem Chqnd. a. Gottt. of NCT of Delhiz;
c) order dated 17.o4.2o2s passed by this court
1n
W.P.No.29O66 of 2024; and
d)
J.Ro,m,o,chondro;io,h u. Gouerttment of Andhrq. prad.eshs.
4)
Per contra, the learned Government pleader has submitted
that based orL the Alert Note No.118 (c.No.l0g7lv&E/NR.2/ttl,
dated 15.04.2014, respondent No.2 has issued an Article of charge
to the petitioner vide G.o.Rt.No.81, Municipal Administration and
urban Develolrment, (vig.ll) Department, dated lg.o2.2ot6, in
r AIR 1979 SC 1022
2 (2OO7l4 SCC 566
3 (2OL2 SCC Online l,p 730
PK, J
wP_21556_2O24
and
cc_2047_2025
respect of the error caused by the petitioner in not putting the date
under the initial recorded in the measurement book duiring check
measurement while working as Forest Range Officer, Director
Urban Forestry, GHMC, Hyderabad, on deputation basis. Further,
the petitioner himself has agreed that he has made negligible error
in his affidavit. As such, the Article of Charge has been issued by
the Government in tune with the Rules and Regulations. It is
further submitted that the Enquiry officer has conducted enquiry,
the Inquiry Report was sent by respondent No.4 vide endorsement
dated 19.0 1.2024 to the PCCF (HoFF), Hyderabad, dated
13.03.2024, and the same was acknowledged by the petitioner on
1O.O4.2O24. However, the petitioner has not submitted his written
representation/further defence statement to the findings in the
Inquiry Report. Therefore, the petitioner himself delayed
finalization of
'the
case. However, on the other hand hq is claiming
for promotion without reference to charge memo as well as
challenging the charge memo on the ground of delay.' Therefore,
owing to delay in conclusion of charges, the charges cannot be set
aside and the charges have to be concluded on their own merit.
/
a'
:
PK, J
w21556-2024
and
cc-2047-2025
5)ItisfurtlrercontendedthataSperRule12ofCCARules,
1991,theGov€:rnmentinMA&UDisempoweredtoissueArticleof
issuance of Article of charge
charge to the 'cetitioner. Hence, the
tothepetition.erisvalidandisinconformitytotheCCARules,
lggl.Therelbre,itisvehementlycontend'edbythelearned
Government Pleader that there
is no violation of Rules in issuance
of Article of charge to the petitioner
to be dismisserl as devoid of merits
and the writ petition is liable
and thus prayed to dismiss the
writ petition. Ileliance has been placed on:
b)
orderdated04.06.2010passedinW.P.No.227:I4of2009&batch;
of 2023; arrd
Order dated 16.06'2025 in W'P'No'12329
6)
On 14.Ct8.2O24, this Court while issuing notice
a)
admission to 1.he respondents has passed
the respondents to consider the case of
before
interim orders directing
the petitioner for promotion
to the post of Deputy conservator of Forests,
without reference to
pend.encyofc.hargememodated|3.02.2016issuedbyrespondent
No.2.
7l
Alleging non-compliance and willful disobedience
of the said
interim order dated 14.08.2024, tt,le petitioner has filed
Case No.2O47 of 2025'
Contempt
PK, J
w_21556_2O24
and
cc_2047_2025
8) This Court has taken note of the submissions made by
respective counsel and perused the material on record.
9)
I
A perusal of the record reveals that admittedly the petitioner
is an employee of Forest Department having appginted by
respondent Nos.1 and 3. While so, he worked on deputation basis
as Forest Range Officer in the office of respondent No.4 from
06.09.2008 to O3.l2.2OOg. Thereafter, he was repatriated to his
parent d.epartment i.e. Forest Department. Further, an Article of
Charge vide G.O.Rt.No.81, dated 18.02.2016, was lssued by
respond.ent No.2 after a lapse of 8 years alleging that he exhibited
lack of integrity, devotion to drty, to which, the peti{ioner has
submitted his reply denying the charge. However, an Erlquiry was
cond.ucted and the Enquiry Officer has submitted his rQport, but,
so far, no final orders are passed.
1O) Learned senior counsel has attacked the impugned
proceedings mainly on two grounds uiz., (1) competency of
respondent No.2 in issuing the impugned G.O.Rt.No.8 1, dated
18.02.2016; and (2) delay in conclusion of proceedings
/
r'
itl
I
PK, J
!
w_21556_2024
and
cc_2047-2025
11) For adjudicating the first ground, it is necessary to
refer
Rule 2 (al of CCA Rules, 1991, which reads as under:
" 'appointing authoritg in relation to a Gouernment Seruant, means
(i) the authority which actually made the temporary or
officiating ,)r substantive appointment, as the case may be, of the
Government Servant, to the post held by him at the time of initiation of
disciplinary proceedings; or
(iil the authority which is, under the rules regulating the
recruitmenl: to the post. which the Government servant for the time
being holds, competent to make an appointment.
whichever e.uthority is higher;"
l2l Further, Rule 1 I of ccA Rules, 1991, stipulates the
Disciplinary r\uthorities in respect of state services. As per subclause (26) (e) thereof, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests
i.e. respondent No.3 herein may impose on Assistant conservator
of Forest any of the penalties specified in clause (i), (ii) and (iv) of
Rule 9.
13) The specific assertion of the learned Government Pleader is
that as per Flule t2 of the ccA Rules, 1991, respondent No.2 is
empowered to issue the charge memo. To adjudicate upon this
contention, th:e said provision of 1aw is extracted. hereunder:
PK,J
wp_2L556_2024
"" rffil zo*
"Rule 12. Government's power to impose penalties on members
of state senrices:- Notwithstanding anything in Rule 11, the
Government may impose any of the penalties specilied in Rut. g o.,
members of the State Services."
r4l on perusal of the above provisions of law, this court is of the
view that as the petitioner being the employee of Forest
Department, the powers vested under Rule 12 of ccA Rrrles, lggl,
are conferred on respondent No.1 only but not on respondent No.2,
as contended by the respondents for the reason that the
Government means the principar secretar5i of the concerned
department i.e. respondent No.l in case of the petitioner, as
admittedly his parent department is Forest Department.
15) tn the case on hand, admittedly, the charge memo has been
issued by respondent No.2 in respect of the incident pertaining to
the perio d 2oog while the petitioner was working on deputation
basis in the office of respondent No.4. Admittedly, on the date of
issuance of the impugned Charge Memo, the petitioner is working
under the centrol of respondent Nos.1 and 3 only.
16) It is relevant to refer to the decision of the Division Bench of
the Madhya Pradesh High court in B.L. satgantht u. state of
ii'--:l--r^+--
t
rl
i
.
PK, J
w_21556_2024
and
cc_2047_2025
Madhga Pro,desh and anothefi wherein the Division. Bench has
elaborately interpreted Rule 20 of the Madhya Pradesh Civil
Services (CClr) Rules, 1966, which is per se analogous to the Rule
20 of the C(lS (CCA) Rules. The relevant portion of the said
decision is extracted hereunder:
"12. Ruk: 20 of Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (CCA) Rules, 1966 as
applicable to the State of Madhya Pradesh and reproduced
hereinab,rve gives power to the borrowing department to take
disciplinrtry action against a Government servant who is on
deputaticrn and the powers to the appointing authority and the
disciplinztry authority are conferred on the borrowing department.
The Rule contemplates that the borrowing department shall have the
powers of the Appointrng Authority for the purpose of placing the
governm€:nt servant under suspension and for taking disciplinary
action against him but the proviso contemplates that the action taken
has to br: forthwith communicated to the parent Department. When
power is given to any authority to suspend a Government servant or
initiate disciplinary action against him an assumption has to be
drawn that the power can be exercised so long as the relationship of
master arrd servant, employer and employee subsists or the contract
of emplo5,ment is in existence. Once the relationship of master and
servant c,r employer and employee or the contract of service itself
comes to an end, the question would be as to how disciplinary action
or power to suspend can be exercised by an authority with whom the
contract of employment of the employee concerned is no more in
existence, Rule 20 therefore, has to be interpreted by holding that the
power conferred under Rule 2O to the borrowing department or
authority to suspend a Government servant or to take a disciplinary
action against him can be exercised only if the relationship of master
and servzmt or the contract of employment between the borrowing
departmeet and the deputationist employee subsists. When an
employee who is a government servant and holds a lien in a
Governmr'nt departmenl. is sent on deputation to Foreign Department
or a Corporation, then during the period of deputation a temporary
contract of service is brought into force between the borrowing
departmerrt and the employee concerned and so long as its contract
of employment subsists the borrowing department can invoke the
provision of Rule 20 but. once the emplogee ls repatrlated. back to
the forelgn deparament then the contract of emplogment
temporanllg created. durlng the perlod of d,eputatlon ceases o;id
lf that bct the posltlon, then the borroutlng depantment does not
hqae ang authot'ltg to take actlon agalnst the emplogee
4 2Ot5 (1) MP LJ 153
l0
PK, J
w_2I556_2O24
and
cc_2047_2025
concerned. Apart from the above a perusal of Rule 20(2) and the
proviso to Rule 20{2l.(1) and (iii) also clarifies the position. After the
departmental proceeding initiated by the Borrowing Department is
completed and the finding of enquiry is recorded, in the light of the
finding if the Borrowing Department wants to impose any of the
penalties specified in clause (i) to (iv) of Rule 10, then after
consultation with the lending department the punishment can be
imposed. However, the proviso to Rule 2o(21(il indicates that if there
is any difference of opinion between the Borrowing Department and
lending department that the service of the employee has to be
replaced at the disposal of the lending department. This clearly shows
that action under these Rules can be taken only when the employee
is on deputation not otherwise as the stipulation in proviso to Rule
2o(2l,(il speaks about replacement of the employee to the lending
department. Similarly in Rule 2o(21(il and proviso thereto also it is
clearly provided that if the punishment to be imposed is a major
punishment as provided in Rule 10(v) to (ix), then the employee has
to be replaced to the lending depar'tment and it is only the lending
department which can take action. The stipulation in this part of the
rule for replacement of the employee to the parent department clearly
indicates the intention of the rule maker. In case Rule 20 was
applicable to a employee who is already repatriated to the parent
(lending) department then the provision for replacement of the
employee to the lending department as contained in both the provisos
to Rule 20(2[0(iii) would not provide for replace the service of the
government employee to the lending department. This in I our
considered view would be the interpretation which can be given to the
powers that may be exercised by the borrowing department under
Rule 20."
(Emphasis supplied)
l7l From the above it is clear that the contract of employment,
which was temporarily created during the period of deputation,
ceases automatically once the employee is repatriated back to his
foreign department. In view of the sarne, the issuance of impugned
charge memo by respondent No.2 to the petitioner after completion
of deputation period, cannot be sustained.
,-€
{'
f
PK, J
wp-2L556_2O24
and
cc_2047_2025
18) As regrards the ground of delay, it is gathered from the record
that admitterdly, the charge memo was issued in the year 2oL6 in
respect of th.e incident pertaining to the year 2oog i.e. after a lapse
of 7 years end till date the proceedings are not concluded. The
Government, from time to time, has issued Government orders
directing the early conclusion of disciplinary cases and to adhere to
the time sctredule. Vide G.o.Ms.No.6T9, General Administration
(Services-c) Department, dated 01.11.200g, the Government has
stipulated as under:
"
on allegations made against the Government employees
disciplinarl/ cases are initiated in accordance with the rules in force,
and where'/er necessa-ry inquiring auttrorities are appointed to inquire
into articlel; of charge against such employees. Instructions were issued
for expeditious completion of the inquiries and normar time of 3
months
and 6 months is allowed in simple and complicated cases, respectively.
Government of
the administrative Department concerned. at
Government level shall review all the disciplinary cases against
employees in rbspect of Head of the Departments under his
control and
also at the field level and shall submit a note to the chief secretarJr
to
Government duly recording the reasons for non-completion of
the
enquires arrd to circulate the same to the Hon,ble chief Minister.
It is
also the responsibility of the inquiring authority to complete
the inquiry
within the allowed time, otherwise, such inquiring authority shall
held responsible for the delay, which d.eserves penar action.
2.....
be
t2
PK, J
w_21556_2024
and
cc_2047_2025
3. Government direct that the disciplinary cases initiated agfiinst the
Government employees shall be completed as expeditiously as'possible
and the existing instructions read above shall be adhered to. The
Departments of secretariat shall review the status position of the
pending disciplinary cases against all the employees with which they are
concerned and submit a note to the Chief SecretarSr to Government as
per the instructions in force. It is also the responsibility of the inquiring
authorities to complete the inqurry as per the allowed tinae. The
Competent Authority, after receipt of the inquiry report shall conclude
the disciplinary proceedings within 6 months of its initiation an$ in case
of abnormal delay in conducting the disciplinary proceedingB; action
shall be initiated against concerned inquiring authority.
19) Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Sto:te of
htnjab a. Cho;mo;n La.l Goycrls has held that the disciplinary
proceedings must be conducted soon after the alleged irregUlarities
are committed and if the delay is too long, the charges are liable to
be quashed.
2Ol In the instant case, admittedly, the charge memo was issued
in the year 2016 for the incident pertaining to the year 2OO9. The
only ground urged by the respondents for the delay is that though
the Enquiry Report was furnished to the petitioner on 10.04.2024,
the petitioner himself has failed to submit his defence statement.
But, the said ground cannot be countenanced for the reason that
s (199s) 2 SCC 570
/
{',
l3
PK, J
w_21556_2O24
and
cc_2047_2025
while comrnunicating the Enquiry Report, admittedly, the
respondents have not directed the petitioner to submit his
objections, if any. Therefore, the respondents are restrained from
taking the said plea for the delay caused as the respondents are
admittedly empowered to proceed further in the matter in
accordance with law even in the absence of any such defense
statement from the delinquent employee. Hence, the impugned
proceedings are hit by delay.
2l) Further, the learned Government Pleader has urged that the
petitioner himself has admitted in his affidavit that he committed
negligible er:ror and therefore the disciplinary proceedings are
sustainable under the law. Here, it is relevant to state that the
Hon'ble Supreme court in state of htnjab a. Rann singh, ExConstqble6.:ras observed as under:
"5- Misconduct has been defined in Black's Law Dictionary, 6tr, Edn.
At p.999, thus:
'1. transgression of some established and definite rule of action,
a forbidden act, a dereliction from duty, unlawful behavior, willful in
character, improper or wrong behavior; its s5mon)rms are misdemeanor,
misdeed, misbehavior, delinquency, impropriety, mismanagement,
offense, bu t not negligence or carelessness,.
u gsez14
scc s4
t4
PK, J
w_21556_2O24
and
cc_2047_2025
Misconduct in oflice has been delined as:
'Any unlawful behavior by a public oflicer in relatibn to the
duties of his office, willful in character. Term embraces acts
which the
office-holder had no right to perform, acts performed improperly,
and
failure to act in the face of an affirmative duty to act."
22) Further, in P.Ramanathq. Aigar's Law Lexicon, 3d Edn., at
p.3o27, the term "misconduct" has been defined as und.er:
"The term 'miscond.uct'implies a wrongfur intention, and. not
a mere
error ofjudgment.
Misconduct is not necessarily the sarne thing as conduct involving
moral turpitude.
The word 'misconduct' is a relative term, and has to be construed
with reference to the subject-matter and the context wherein the term
occurs, having regard to the scope of the Act or statute which is
being
construed. 'Misconduct' literafly means wrong conduct or improper
conduct."
23) Relying on the above definitions, the Hon,ble supreme court
in J.Ahemd.'s cq,se (refe*ed. s-.tpra), has held as under:
"11. code of conduct as set out in the conduct Rules clearly
indicates the conduct expected of a member of the service. It would
follow that conduct which is blameworthy for the government servant
in
the context of conduct Rures would be misconduct. If a servant
conducts himself in a way inconsistent with due and faithful discharge
of his duty in service, it is misconduct. A disregard of an essential
condition of the contract of service may constitute misconduct. This
view was adopted in slnrd.aprasad onkarprasad rhtari u. Diui,sional
supdt. central Rlg., Nagpur Dui.sion, Nagpur
-,
C,
[(19s9) 61 Bom LR 19s6]
{
PK, J
wp_2L556_2024
cc_2O47_2025
and satubha K.vaghela u. Moosa Roza [10 Guj LR 231. The High court
has noted the definition of misconduct in Stroud's Judicial Dictionary
which runs as under:
"lvlisconduct means, misconduct arising from ill motive; acts
of neglillence, errors of judgment, or innocent mistake, do not
constitut-e such misconduct."
24j' comin6J to the case on hand, the fotlowing charge has been
framed against the petitioner:
"That sri A. Venkateswarlu the then Forest Range officer, Urban
Forestry, ()ircle-10, GHMC as a recording officer for the works
pertaining rrt circle No-lo has made signatures without date. He failed
to record the date of commencement of work and date of completion of
work in thr: M. Book, and thus he violated the procedure as per Ap
Public worl<s Accounts code and by this above act he has exhibited
lack of integrity, devotion to duty conduct unbecoming of Government
servant anc thereby contravened Rule 3 91) and (2) of A.p. civil
Services (Conduct) Rules 1964-"
25l. rhus, the allegation against the petitioner is that he made
signatures without mentioning the date arid tailed to record date of
commencement of work and date of completion of work in the
M.Book, which can be construed as negligible error on the part of
)
\
the petitioner ilnd same d.o not constitute any misconduct.
/
I
,r
r6
PK, J
vtP_21556_2024
and
cc_2047_2025
26) For the afore-mentioned reasons, the impugned charge memo
dated 18.02.2016 is not sustainable under the law and therefore
liable to be set aside.
27ll Accordingly, the impugned G.O.Rt.No.S1, MA & UD (Vig.II)
Department, dated 18.02.2016, issued by respondent No.2 is set
aside.
28) Insofar as the Contempt. Case is concerned, as the
respondents have filed Interlocutory Application seeking to vacate
the interim order dated L4.08.2024 and the main writ petition itself
is disposed, this Court is not inclined to entertain the Contempt
Case
29lr In the result, the Writ Petition is allowed and the Contempt
Case is closed.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
No costs.
SD'.4.V.S. PRASAD
DEPUTY REGIS TRAR
//TRUE COPY/
To
2.
3.
SECTION OFFICER
f
5. The Dinrctor, Greatgr.l-.lv{era.bad Municipal corporation (GHMC), Urban
\
Forestry, lndira park, Hyderabad
6. ONC CC tO SRI GUNDHATI BAIY4ry GOUD, AdVOCAIC TOPUC]
-c;;ril;;
T - Two ccs to Gp FoR SERVTCES-I,
Hish
iildt"ie-Jteungana, at
Hyderabad. [OUTI
B. ONC CC tO SRI G.NARAYANA, SC FOR GHMC
TOPUC]
9. Two CD Copies
PSK.
BS
1r4
a
HIGH COI'RT
DATED:09/01 12026
I
l
{t tE SII
COMMON ORDER
WP.No.21$56 of 2024
AND
CC.No.2047 of 2025
2 4 JAil 2026
C)
t
*
L].OWI N Gi TH E_WRIT_P+T{T{ O N AN D
CLOSING OF THE CONTEMPT CASE
WITHOUT COSTS
@t
e4 r\M
(
*
a
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review