Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 519 of 2018
Date of Decision : 30.01.2023
Vs.
A. Basumatari & Ors.
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Kharshiing, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSG with
Mr. B. Shangrit, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
By way of this instant writ petition, the petitioners 221 in
number, are before this Court, praying for directions to order the
respondents to grant and release ration money allowance to the writ
petitioners from their date of entitlement. Orders dated 7th September, 1998
and 24th February, 2009, issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, whereby,
the grant of ration money allowance has been allowed only to combatised
non-gazetted Central Para Military Forces, upto the rank of Battalion
Commander, have been impugned.
2.
The brief facts are that, the writ petitioners are serving in the
Assam Rifles in various capacities and have been posted in operational
areas, in the state of Manipur, Tripura, Nagaland and some districts of
Arunachal Pradesh, alongside combatised personnel. The grievance of the
writ petitioners is that, though they are posted in these hazardous areas,
they have not been extended the benefit of ration money allowance, which
is however granted to the combatised personnel posted in the same station.
3.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms.
A. Kharshiing, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that, ration
money allowance as per the report of the 5th Central Pay Commission dated
30th January, 1997, is an additional allowance, attached to discharge of
arduous duties in hardship areas, which is unconnected with the normal
service conditions of personnel. The Ministry of Home Affairs, he submits,
vide a resolution dated 30th September, 1997, decided to extend the same
to personnel working alongside with army personnel in these areas,
however, leaving the review and scale of rations to be decided by the
Ministry of Home Affairs. Learned Senior counsel submits that, however,
the respondent No. 1(the Ministry of Home Affairs), by the impugned
orders dated 7th September, 1998 and 1st September, 2009, did not extend
this benefit to the non-combatised personnel, such as the petitioners. It is
contended by the learned Senior counsel that, these decisions run contrary
to the resolution dated 30th September, 1997, wherein the recommendation
of the 5th Central Pay Commission had been accepted.
4.
The learned Senior counsel contends that, the granting of
ration money allowance only to uniformed combatised personnel, and
depriving the civilian personnel posted in the same hardship areas, wherein
they discharge similar duties as the uniformed nurses, teachers, etc., and
put their lives at risk, is an irrational and unreasonable classification. It is
further submitted that, the recommendations of the Assam Rifles for the
6th Pay Commission, had at Para – 43 under the caption ‘Ration Allowance
to Civilian Staff’, had recommended the grant of free ration to be made
applicable to the civil staff of the Assam Rifles. Other similar services, he
submits, such as the Special Service Bureau, are granted the benefit of
ration money allowance. In this context, the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in the case of Union of India vs. Ram Gopal Agarwal &
Ors. reported in (1998) 2 SCC 589, has been cited by the learned Senior
counsel, who submits that the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court,
affirming the extent to which non-combatised CRPF personnel were
granted ration money allowance is still holding the field and, in this regard,
this judgment is squarely applicable to the case of the writ petitioners.
5.
The learned Senior counsel has also placed a letter dated 30th
May, 2022, brought on record by way of an additional affidavit to show
that the respondents (Assam Rifles), have a provision, whereby free rations
on a scale applicable to combatants are allowed to Defence Civilians
working in Field Areas and Modified Field Areas. In closing his
arguments, the learned Senior counsel submits that, the refusal to grant
ration money allowance to the writ petitioners by the respondents is highly
discriminatory and arbitrary, and it is further submitted that, the relief
sought by the writ petitioners is not hit by the principles of delay and
laches, by placing reliance on the case of Union of India vs. Tarsem Singh
reported in (2008) 8 SCC 648, wherein, it has been held that, in cases of
continuing wrong, a writ petition can be entertained despite delay.
6.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSG assisted by Mr. B. Shangrit,
learned counsel for the respondents has at the outset submitted that, the
claim at this stage, is highly belated and is liable to be rejected. He submits
that, the writ petitioners are seeking to set aside and quash the Office
Memorandum dated 24.02.2009, after a period of more than 9 years, and
that too after getting benefits of pay and allowances under the 6 th Central
Pay Commission w.e.f. 01.01.2006 and 7th Central Pay Commission w.e.f.
01.01.2016. Learned DSG submits that the matter has been considered by
the 5th and 6th Central Pay Commission, which is an expert body, and it
allowed the benefit of ration money allowance only to combatised
personnel of the Central Para Military Forces. He submits that there is no
further government order, such as the one dated 24.02.1989, thereafter, to
allow ration money allowance to civilians/non-combatised working in
operational areas, as by order dated 07.09.1998, ration money allowance
was allowed only to combatised personnel. The learned DSG submits that
on the implementation of the report of the 6th CPC, Office Memorandum
dated 24.02.2009, was issued stating that, ration money allowance shall
continue to be paid to only those categories of Central Para Military Forces
personnel, who are presently in receipt of the allowance as conveyed by
order dated 07.09.1998.
7.
Learned DSG submits that, though the Assam Rifles had
recommended to the 6th CPC, to allow ration money allowance to the
civilian staff of the Assam Rifles, on the ground that they are performing
their assigned duties side by side with their combatant staff counter parts
in the Field Areas of NE region, and that, the duties performed was similar,
the same was not accepted by the 6th CPC, nor by the government. He
reiterates his submissions, that after 24.02.1989, there is no government
order allowing ration money allowance to civilian staff.
8.
The learned DSG then submits that similar prayers for
benefits by other civilian staff of the Assam Rifles had been turned down
by the High Court, in the case of Samir Chandra Kar vs. Union of India,
reported in 2017 SCC OnLine Megh 319, wherein it has been held that,
classification between combatised and non-combatised personnel, is a
valid classification because of their separate job responsibilities. On the
application of the decision rendered in UOI vs. Ram Gopal
Agarwal(supra), the learned DSG submits that, in this decision which was
passed with regard to the CRPF, the Supreme Court noticing a clear
distinction, in the terms and conditions of service, nature of work and
service tenure between combatised and non-combatised personnel, had
held that, the two groups of CRPF personnel were unequal and that,
treating unequals as equals would be discriminatory, and as such, the
principle of ‘Equal Pay for Equal Work’ would have no application.
9.
In countering the statements made in the additional affidavit
filed by the petitioners, the learned DSG submits that, the document dated
30th May, 2022, produced by the petitioners, was applicable only to the
Defence Civilians, who are under the Ministry of Defence, whereas, the
petitioners are governed by the Central Civil Services (CCS) Rules and
come under the Ministry of Home Affairs, and as such, no comparison can
be drawn between the Assam Rifles civilian employees and defence
civilians. It is also submitted that, though civilian employees are working
in sensitive areas, they are not exposed to risks faced by combatants who
are covered by the Assam Rifles Acts and Rules, which are not applicable
to the civilian employees. He finally submits that, there being a clear
distinction, which is a reasonable classification, there is no question of the
writ petitioners being discriminated against, or that there is any
arbitrariness on the part of the respondents.
10.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and have
considered their submissions and examined the materials on record. The
only point in contention in the instant writ application, is to whether the
petitioners who are civilian personnel, are being illegally and arbitrarily
deprived of the ration money allowance which is being afforded to other
combatised personnel while serving in operational areas. It has been urged
as noted above by the petitioners, that the nature of duties discharged by
them is similar to the duties discharged by the combatised personnel in all
respects and as such they are entitled to similar benefits.
11.
The Court at this stage is therefore to examine as to whether
the denial of ration money allowance to the petitioners is a result of a
reasonable classification or otherwise. In this context, it is necessary to
examine the sequence of events and orders apart from relevant judgments,
to discern as to whether the denial is founded on valid grounds. It is noticed
from the materials, that the only document that specifically accorded this
benefit to non-combatants of ration money allowance to non-gazetted
ministerial and hospital staff, was a letter dated 24.02.1989 issued by the
Ministry of Home Affairs. However, it is also noticed that the said benefit
was only extended to the CRPF, and there is no other order with regard to
other CPMFs. Though by a resolution dated 30.09.1997 the Ministry of
Finance, had conditionally accepted the grant of such ration money
allowance, the same was however, subject to the directions of the Ministry
of Home Affairs, as to the scale of rations permissible to entitled personnel,
working in difficult areas/hazardous conditions alongside army personnel
(Annexure-2 to the writ petition). The Ministry of Home Affairs thereafter
by the first impugned order dated 07.09.1998, allowed the ration money
allowance based on the army scale of rations, only to combatised nongazetted CPMF personnel up to the rank of Battalion Commander.
Subsequently pursuant to the recommendations of the 6 th Central Pay
Commission, the respondent No. 1 similarly in continuation of the order
dated 07.09.1998, granted ration money allowance only to combatised
CPMF personnel vide the second impugned order dated 24.02.2009.
12.
The matter was then agitated by one Samir Chandra Kar and
118 others, before the Gauhati High Court by way of WP(C) No. 5881 of
2010, assailing the order dated 24.02.2009, which is the same order
impugned herein. WP(C) No. 5881 of 2010 came to be dismissed by order
dated 20.11.2018 passed by a Single Bench of the said Court wherein, in
the said judgment reference was made, to other similar matters where the
same petitioner, by way of WP(C) No. 365 of 2014, had come before this
Court for grant of risk/hardship allowance to non-combatant employees of
the Assam Rifles. The said writ petition, was dismissed along with two
other similar petitions being WP(C) No. 84 of 2015 and WP(C) No. 120
of 2014, vide order dated 15.10.2017. These matters were then carried on
appeal before the Division Bench of this Court by way of WA No. 2 of
2018, which was also dismissed on 13.06.2018.
13.
The ratio of the earlier decided cases clearly held that there
was no parity between non-combatised and combatised personnel on
account of their nature of service, duties and also the fact that they were
governed by separate Rules. In the judgment dated 15.10.2017, reference
has also been made to the judgment of Union of India vs. Ram Gopal
Agarwala (supra), especially para-10 which is for the sake of convenience
is reproduced hereinbelow to substantiate the findings arrived at:-
“10. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and we
find that there is clear distinction in the terms and conditions
of service, the nature of work and even tenure of service inter
se between combatised and non-combatised personnels. The
combatised personnel retire at the age of 53 while the noncombatised personnel retire at the age of 55. The nature of
work, so far as combatised personnel are concerned, is
arduous in nature in the operational and sensitive areas. In
fact even the non-combatised personnel while working in the
operational areas and such sensitive, places are granted the
ration allowances. It is only when they are working in `static
areas there is no provision for this allowance. Even terms
and conditions, service conditions are totally different. The
combatised personnels are governed by Central Reserve
Police Force Act and Rules which is an army rule more
stringent in nature while non- staff is governed by the
civilian law, namely, C.C.S. Rules made by the Government
of India under Article 309 of the Constitution. The question
of discrimination in the matter of allowances has to be listed
differently even inter se between those falling under class of
"equal pay for equal work". In cases where some perform
overtime duties, night duties, duties in hazardous places viz,
mountain, terrain at heights or at sensitive border areas an
additional allowance is made applicable to the nature of
work they perform. Similarly, when option is given it is with
clear intention of there being plus and minus points in the
two categories. That by itself differentiates inter se between
the two. Once not opting to enjoy the benefit, as in the present
case, to continue in service of one category upto larger
length of service (55 years) and not to involve in the
hazardous nature of duties with stringent service conditions
cannot come forward to claim the benefit of the other
category also on the ground of discrimination. In fact,
treating unequal to be equal itself would be discriminatory,
Thus, we conclude it is neither a case of "equal pay for equal
work" nor a case of discrimination or violation of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.”
14.
The case of the petitioners therefore being covered by the
earlier pronouncements of this Court, as also the judgment of the Gauhati
High Court, which has great persuasive value, inasmuch as, as the same
order is under challenge herein, i.e. the order dated 24.02.2009, and taking
into consideration the clear distinction in the conditions of service, the
principle of ‘Equal Pay for Equal Work’ would clearly have no application
in the instant case, and the non-grant of ration money allowance to the
petitioners who are non-combatants, cannot be said to be unreasonable or
arbitrary. Further, with regard to the document dated 30 th May, 2022, the
submissions of the learned DSG are accepted, inasmuch as, the same
would not be applicable to the case of the petitioners who are governed by
Central Civil Services (CCS) Rules and are under the Ministry of Home
Affairs, whereas the Defence Civilians which the document applies to, are
under the Ministry of Defence.
15.
In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, there is no
merit in the instant petition and the same is dismissed.
16.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
30.01.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review