Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010269772022
2026:GAU-AS:4341
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/136/2023
2IC SECOND IN COMMANDANT/CHIEF/DENTAL SURGEON SUMAN
NO. ARDS-6100013 PRESENTLY SERVIG AT NO. 4 DENTAL UNIT ASSAM
RIFLES UNDER THE HEAD QUARTER INSPECTOR GENERAL ASSAM
RIFLES (EAST) SRIKONA SILCHAR C/O 99 APO PIN-932553
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HOME
AFFAIRS NORTH BLOCK NEW DELHI PIN-110001
2:UNIO OF INDIA
REP.BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HEALTH
AND FAMILY WELFARE AND DEPTT. OF PERS AND TRAINING NORTH
BLOCK NEW DELHI PIN-110001
3:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL ASSAM RIFLES
SHILLONG MEGHALAYA
4:DIRECTOR MEDICAL
MEDICAL BRANCH HEAD QUARTER DIRECTOR GENERAL ASSAM RIFLES
SHILLONG MEGHALAYA
5:INSPECTOR GENERAL
ASSAM RIFLES (EAST) HEAD QUARTER DIRECTOR GENERAL OF ASSAM
RIFLES (EAST) SRIKONA SILCHAR ASSAM
6:THE COMMANDER 23 SECTOR ASSAM RIFLES
C/O 99 APO PIN-93242
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR V KUMAR, MR. B PATHAK,MR B HAZARIKA
Page No.# 2/11
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., MRS S BARUAH
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved : 19.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 26.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. B. Pathak, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. S.
Baruah, learned Central Government Counsel for the respondents.
2.
By filing this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for a direction to the
respondent authorities to grant her promotion to the post of Deputy
Commandant
(Senior Dental Surgeon)
with retrospective effect, w.e.f.
29.11.2024 along with all consequential benefits as per her seniority.
3.
The case, in brief, is that the petitioner was enrolled in the Assam Rifles on
29.11.2010 as an Assistant Commandant (Dental Surgeon) as per the Central
Paramilitary Forces Combined (Dental Surgeon Cadre) Recruitment Rules, 2010
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Recruitment Rules, 2010’ in short). After completion
of basic military training from 06.12.2010 to 20.12.2010, she was posted to 9 th
Page No.# 3/11
Dental Unit Assam Rifles and thereafter, posted at various places in the North
Eastern Region of India.
4.
While serving as Assistant Commandant (Dental Surgeon), a baby boy was
born to the petitioner on 01.02.2013. In the meantime, the respondent
authorities have detailed the petitioner to undergo the Medical Officers’ Basic
Course (MOBC in short) at Officer Training College, AMC Centre & College,
Lucknow. However, the petitioner, vide W.T. message dated 16.12.2013,
submitted her unwillingness to attend the said course due to the birth of her
baby as the doctor advised her to avoid hard physical activities for at least one
& half year. Subsequently, the petitioner applied for Child Care Leave and
accordingly, she was granted Child Care Leave for 580 days w.e.f. 18.07.2014 to
17.02.2016. Upon her rejoining, the petitioner was again detailed for MOBC at
AMC Centre and College, Lucknow, wherein she underwent the said course of
MOBC from 18.02.2016 to 20.04.2016 and successfully completed the same
with over all “B” grading.
5.
Thereafter, the petitioner was promoted to the rank of Deputy
Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) vide dated 02.06.2016 w.e.f. 02.06.2016.
The petitioner submitted a representation on 15.06.2017 stating that as per the
Recruitment Rules, 2010, the criteria for promotion from Assistant Commandant
(Dental Surgeon) to Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) is completion
of 4 (four) years of service in the grade and being in medical category SHAPE-I,
and on completion of Basic Combatisation Training.
6.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that she had already undergone
Page No.# 4/11
basic military training at the Assam Rifles Training Centre & School from
06.12.2010 to 20.12.2010 and therefore, upon completion of 4 (four) years of
service, she became entitled to promotion w.e.f. 29.11.2014. The representation
of the petitioner was rejected by the respondent authorities. The petitioner
thereafter, submitted another representation for reconsideration of her
promotion as no clear cut grounds were provided for rejecting the grievance of
the petitioner as the rejection only reflected that the promotion from Assistant
Commandant (Dental Surgeon) to Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon)
can be done only upon fulfilment of the complete eligible criteria prescribed in
the Recruitment Rules, including the prescribed training requirement.
7.
In response, the respondent authorities informed the petitioner that the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) for promotion from Deputy
Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) to the rank of Chief Dental Surgeon
(Second-In-Command) was held on 14.10.2019 and the recommendations were
forwarded to Ministry of Home Affairs on 17.10.2019 for approval. It has been
further informed that before convening of DPC for the year 2020, a query was
made to the Ministry of Home Affairs regarding consideration of the petitioner’s
case for promotion to the rank of Second-In-Command (Chief Dental Surgeon),
which was replied to the extent that “senior-junior” clause has been deleted
from the Dental Posts Recruitment Rules, 2019 and further directed to conduct a
Review DPC without considering the name of the petitioner as the petitioner had
been promoted to the rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon)
w.e.f. 02.06.2016. Accordingly, it was indicated that the petitioner would be
considered for promotion to the rank of Second-in-Command (Chief Dental
Surgeon) in the DPC for the year 2022, with effect from 02.06.2021.
The
Page No.# 5/11
petitioner, being aggrieved, again submitted representation seeking grant of
promotion from the date of her eligibility.
8.
Mr. B. Pathak, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the
petitioner had completed the mandatory basic military training at the Assam
Rifles Training Centre & School during the period from 06.12.2010 to
20.12.2010 and as per the said Recruitment Rules, 2010, the criteria for Basic
Combatisation Training would mean basic military training for promotion from
Assistant Commandant (Dental Surgeon) to Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental
Surgeon). However, despite fulfilling all the eligibility criteria for promotion, the
respondent authorities has denied the promotion w.e.f. 29.11.2014 as Deputy
Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) and Second-In-Command (Chief Dental
Surgeon) w.e.f. 29.11.2019. As per the Rules of 2010, the basic criteria for
promotion to the rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) is from
amongst the Assistant Commandant (Dental Surgeon) on completion of 4 (four)
years of service in the grade and being in medical category SHAPE-I and on
completion of Basic Combatisation Training. The petitioner having been
completed 4 (four) years service and being in medical category SHAPE-I and
completed the Basic Combatisation Training, the authority ought to have
granted the promotion to the rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental
Surgeon) as per her seniority w.e.f. 29.11.2014.
9.
He submits that the action of respondent authorities in denying promotion
to the petitioner to the rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon)
from the date of her eligibility is arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the provisions
of the Recruitment Rules, 2010 and as such, the respondent authorities are
Page No.# 6/11
liable to be directed to consider the case of the petitioner for granting
promotion to the post of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) as per
the seniority w.e.f. 29.11.2014, along with all consequential benefits and to
higher promotional posts.
10.
Per contra, Ms. S. Baruah, learned CGSC, for the respondents, submits
that the petitioner, having been appointed and joined in the Assam Rifles as
Assistant Commandant (Dental Surgeon) on 29.01.2010, was eligible for
promotion to the rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) on
29.11.2014 after completion of 4 (four) years of service in the grade, subject to
her being in the medical category SHAPE-I and on completion of Basic
Combatisation Training. Accordingly, the petitioner was detailed to undergo the
MOBC w.e.f. 23.01.2014 to 26.03.2014. However, the petitioner expressed her
unwillingness to attend the said training on account of the birth of her child on
01.02.2013 and on advice of the doctor to avoid her physical activities for a
period of at least one and a half years. After accepting her unwillingness, the
petitioner was again detailed to attend MOBC w.e.f. 14.07.2014 to 13.09.2014,
which she again did not avail. Subsequently, after rejoining duty from Child Care
Leave on 17.02.2016, the petitioner underwent the MOBC from 18.02.2016 to
20.04.2016. It is, therefore, the petitioner was fully aware of the fact that the
Basic Combatisation Training was a mandatory requirement for promotion to the
rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) and she was detailed for
such training only after 18 (eighteen) months of her delivery as advised by the
Doctor.
11. She submits that the petitioner was considered for promotion to the rank
Page No.# 7/11
of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) in the DPC for the year 20152016 on completion of the requisite Basic Combatisation Training, i.e., the
Medical Officers’ Basic Course (MOBC). The Basic Military Training conducted at
Assam Rifles Training Centre & School is conducted immediately after
recruitment of Assam Rifles Medical Officer in order to familiarize the newly
recruited Assam Rifles Medical Officers to the basics of Military life and
functioning of Assam Rifles. Such Basic Military Training, is different from Basic
Combatisation Training which is required as per Recruitment Rules, 2010 for
promotion from Assistant Commandant (Dental Surgeon) to Deputy Surgeon
(Senior Dental Surgeon). Therefore, mere completion of 4 (four) years of
service and being in medical category SHAPE-I would not, by itself, render an
officer eligible for promotion unless the mandatory requirement of Basic
Combatisation Training is fulfilled in terms of the Recruitment Rules, 2010.
12. I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and
also perused the materials available on record, including the Rules of 2010.
13. The method of recruitment to the Group ‘A’ Combatised (Dental Surgeon)
posts in Central Military Force under the Ministry of Home Affairs is regulated by
the Central Paramilitary Forces Combined (Dental Surgeons Cadre) Recruitment
Rule, 2010.
14.
As per column 12 to the schedule of the Central Paramilitary Forces
Combined (Dental Surgeon Cadre) Recruitment Rule, 2010, promotion to the
post of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) is to be made from
amongst the Dental Surgeons (Assistant Commandant- Dental) on completion of
Page No.# 8/11
4 (four) years of service in the grade and being in medical category SHAPE-I on
completion of Basic Combatisation Training. The said provision further contains
a stipulation to the effect that where juniors who have completed their
qualifying or eligibility service are being considered for promotion, their seniors
would also be considered provided they are not short of the requisite qualifying
or eligibility service by more than half of such qualifying or eligibility service or
two years, whichever is less and have successfully completed their probation
period for promotion to the next higher grade alongwith their juniors who have
already completed such qualifying or eligibility services.
15. Perusal of the aforesaid Rules clearly reflects that promotion to the post of
Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) is to be made from amongst the
Dental Surgeon (Assistant Commandant- Dental) on completion of 4 (four) years
of service in the grade and being in medical category SHAPE-I and on
completion of Basic Combatisation Training. However, the expression “Basic
Combatisation Training” has not been defined under the said Rules. There is no
dispute that the petitioner had joined Assam Rifles as Assistant Commandant
(Dental Surgeon) on 29.11.2010 and she would be eligible for consideration for
promotion to the rank of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon) on
29.11.2014 on having been completed 4 (four) years of service in the said
grade, subject to fulfilment of the other prescribed conditions.
16.
In the above backdrop, the core and narrow issue that arises for
determination is as to whether the Basic Military Training undergone by the
petitioner at the time of her induction can be construed as “Basic Combatisation
Training” under the Recruitment Rules, 2010, or is it the Medical Officers’ Basic
Page No.# 9/11
Course (MOBC) alone which would satisfy the said requirement.
17.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner has completed the Basic Military
Training w.e.f. 06.12.2010 to 20.12.2010 and has undergone MOBC w.e.f.
18.02.2016 to 20.04.2016. Having been considered that the expression “Basic
Combatisation Training” is not defined in the Recruitment Rules, 2010, this
Court granted several opportunities to the learned Central Government Counsel
to clarify the stand of the respondents in this regard. In response, the learned
Central Government Counsel submitted that the Basic Combatisation Training
referred to in the Recruitment Rules, 2010 would mean the Medical Officers’
Basic Course (MOBC) and therefore, an officer is required to undergo the said
course to fulfill the training prescribed for promotion. In other words, according
to the respondents, the Basic Combatisation Training is to be understood as the
Medical Officers’ Basic Course (MOBC) and not basic military training.
18. Upon consideration, it is the view of this court that the expression “Basic
Combatisation Training”, which has not been defined in the Recruitment Rules,
2010, cannot be equated with the Medical Officers’ Basic Course (MOBC) merely
on the basis of the interpretation advanced by the respondents. The
terminology “combatisation training” prima facie suggests training relating to
combat orientation and it cannot automatically be presumed to be synonym
with MOBC. At the same time, it would also not be appropriate to equate Basic
Military Training undergone at the time of induction with Basic Combatisation
Training, as both appear to serve distinct purposes. Had it been the intention of
the rule-making authority to treat Basic Military Training as Basic combatisation
training, the same would have been expressly provided in the Recruitment
Page No.# 10/11
Rules, 2010. Thus, in the absence of a clear definition or adequate supporting
material on record, neither Basic Military Training nor the Medical Officers’ Basic
Course (MOBC) can be conclusively held to constitute “Basic Combatisation
Training.” Under such circumstances, it would not be appropriate for this Court
to substitute the view of the rule-making authority, particularly in matters
concerning paramilitary forces. It is also noticed that after joining service as
Dental Surgeon (Assistant Commandant-Dental), the petitioner has completed
the Basic Military Training and was thereafter posted to various places.
Subsequently, upon being detailed for the third time, the petitioner underwent
and successfully completed the Medical Officers’ Basic Course (MOBC) from
18.02.2016 to 20.04.2016.
19. Having considered that the expression “Basic Combatisation Training” in
the Recruitment Rules, 2010, appears to be not capable of either being “Basic
Military Training” or “MOBC” and considering that it would not be permissible to
read in between the lines, I am of the considered view that the issue as to
whether “Basic Combatisation Training" would include either of the aforesaid
trainings/courses, would require reconsideration by the respondent authorities.
Accordingly, it would be appropriate to direct the respondent authorities to
examine and determine as to whether the “Basic Combatisation Training”, as
contemplated under the Recruitment Rules, 2010, would mean Basic Military
Training or MOBC and to take an appropriate decision in that regard as the
parties in the present proceedings have failed to brought on record any
sufficient materials to determine the issue, despite several opportunities
provided to them.
20. In view of above, this writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the
respondent authorities to reconsider and determine whether the Basic Military
Page No.# 11/11
Training or the Medical Officers’ Basic Course (MOBC) would be the “Basic
Combatisation Training” in terms of Column 12 of the Schedule to the
Recruitment Rules, 2010. In the event if the Basic Military Training is considered
as Basic Combatisation Training, the case of the petitioner shall be reconsidered
for promotion to the post of Deputy Commandant (Senior Dental Surgeon)
w.e.f. 29.11.2014. If, on the other hand, it is held that MOBC constitutes the
requisite Basic Combatisation Training, appropriate order shall be passed in
accordance with law. The exercise, as directed hereinabove, shall be completed
within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
21. Writ petition stands disposed of in term above.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review