Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 1st October, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010423342026
+
W.P.(C) 13064/2026 & CM APPLs. 60787/2026, 60788/2026
ZOOM INSURANCE BROKERS PVT LTD
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Mukesh Gupta, Advocate.
versus
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 25 1
& ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC with Mr.
Anant Mann, JSC & Mr. Pratyuksh
Gupta, JSC.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE ADITI CHOUDHARY
JUDGMENT
DINESH MEHTA, J. (ORAL)
1.
By way of the present writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the
order dated 30.06.2026 passed under Section 148A(3) of the Income Tax
Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as „the Act of 1961‟) so also notice of the
even date issued under Section 148 of the Act of 1961 for Assessment Year
2020-21 on various counts.
2.
Mr. Anant Mann, learned Junior Standing Counsel, at the outset
submitted that the petitioner had challenged identical notice dated
23.06.2025 issued by the Assessing Officer for assessment year 2019-20, by
the way of writ petition and this Court had refused to entertain petitioner’s
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
writ petition and therefore, the instant writ petition should also be dismissed.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner though accepted the fact that the
information and the allegation in the instant notice issued under Section
148A(1) of the Act of 1961 so also the allegation and the information
mentioned in the notice dated 23.06.2025 for assessment year 2019-20 are
almost identical, but submitted that while rejecting petitioner’s earlier writ
petition bearing W.P.(C) 14027/25, the Coordinate Bench of this Court had
not properly considered the order of this Court rendered in the case of T S G
International Marketing Private Limited v. Income Tax Officer, Ward
25(3), Delhi in W.P.(C) 9715/2025 and thus, this petition needs to be
entertained.
4.
Learned Junior Standing Counsel controverted this contention by
submitting that the order dated 14.07.2025
in the case of T S G
International Marketing Private Limited (Supra) is only an interim order,
whereas the judgment dated 11.09.2025 is a final order passed in petitioner’s
own case.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
6.
Indisputably, in petitioner’s own case for preceding assessment year
(2019-20), this Court has refused to interfere and rejected petitioner’s writ
petition by observing thus:
“…8. Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and
perused the record, we must at the outset refer to the notice
dated 24.03.2025 issued under Section 148A(1) of the Act on
the ground that the income subject to tax has escaped
assessment within the meaning of Section 147 of the Act as per
“information in accordance with the risk management strategy
formulated in this regard”. Further, as per the impugned
notice the respondent has mentioned that a search and seizure
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
under Section 132 of the Act on Middle Layer Business Entities
(„MLBE‟, henceforth) of the insurance sector was conducted on
30.11.2022 to verify the claim of services against which these
entities had received payments from the insurance companies.
According to the notice, these MLBEs were neither authorized
to receive commission nor registered under Insurance
Regulatory and Development Authority of India („IRDAI‟,
hereinafter) and have acted as pass-through entities for the
insurance companies. These payments were masked under
various heads such as online media expenses, advertisement
services, online marketing, marketing activities, brand
promotion expense, etc., and that these were finally paid to the
insurance agents or insurance intermediaries or their
nominees. Such search and seizure has covered 37 MLBEs and
32 insurance companies were part of post search verification.
9.
According to the impugned notice, the respondents
have stated that the insurance companies have signed several
service agreements with several MLBEs to facilitate transfer of
such payments. The notice states that the analysis of this
financial data was carried out and has indicated that these
MLBEs do not have the capacity to render such services and
the funds which have been received from the insurance
companies were simply passed on without rendering any
relevant services. The amount of Rs. 82,25,822/- from IFTGI
was found to be one such transaction of the assessee company.
10.
The relevant paragraphs of the impugned order dated
23.06.2025 reads as under:
“2.1 On perusal of the information uploaded on the insight
portal, it is noticed that a Search and seizure u/s 132 on Middle
Layer Business Entities (MLBEs) of Insurance Sector was
conducted on 30.11.2022 by Investigation Unit -1 and Unit-5,
Mumbai under names Wings Brand Group and Ajay Mehta
group respectively to verify the claim of services against which
these entities have received huge payments from the insurance
companies. These MLBEs were not authorized to receive the
commission since they are not registered with the IRDAI and
they acted as pass-through entities for Insurance Companies.
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
These payments were masked as various heads of expenses
such as online media and advertisement services, online
marketing, marketing activities, brand promotion expense etc.
These were finally paid either to Insurance agents/insurance
intermediaries/MPHs or to their nominees. 37 Entities
(MLBEs) were covered during search operation and 32
insurance companies were covered as part of post search
verification.
2.2 The search action revealed that these MLBEs have acted
merely as pass-through entities and transferred the additional
commission (also called as Overriding commission-ORC), over
and above the IRDAI limit, to Insurance intermediaries/agents,
Master Policy holders or their nominees. The evidences
gathered from different premises clearly established the nexus
between Insurance Companies and the end beneficiaries who
are either the Insurance agents/intermediaries Master Policy
holders, or their nominees. The Middle Layer Business Entities
have shown the payments received from Insurance Companies
under the head business promotion, marketing expenses,
advertisement expense etc. and have further debited expenses
under different heads to transfer the commission over and
above the IRDAI limit to the end beneficiaries. These middle
layer entities acted as payment facilitator and passed on the
amount received from insurance companies to nominees of
insurance intermediaries and agents.
2.3 The Insurance companies have signed service agreements
with several middle layer business entities (MLBEs) for
transferring huge payments under the head marketing and
business promotion to various entities. Analysis of financial
data and enquiries of these entities were carried out by the
Investigation Wing which indicated that these entities are not
having the capacity to render such services. They have
received the fund from the Insurance companies and simply
passed on the funds to other individuals and other business
entities without receiving any services.
2.4 From the investigation report it is gathered that the
assessee company also found to be involved in bogus
transaction amounting to Rs. 82,25,822/- with IFFCO-TOKIO
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
General Insurance Company Ltd.
3. Considering the above referred credible information and
analysis, subsequent to the information, proceedings u/s 148A
of the Income-tax Act, 1961 was initiated. In view of the above
facts and circumstances of the case, a show cause notice u/s
148A(1) was issued to the assessee on 31/03/2025 requesting
the assessee company to respond by 17/04/2025, as it appeared
that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for the
transaction mentioned above amounting to Rs. 82,25,822/during the year under consideration. In response of the notice
the assessee has submitted its submission on 17-04-2025.
Relevant portion of the reply is reproduced as under:“………..In the matter under consideration the assessee has
taken a written email confirmation from ITGI stating that the
amount of INR 82,25,822/- as shown in the insight portal is a
genuine transaction and it pertains to the brokerage income
against the premium placed by the assessee to ITGI on behalf
of their various client's insurance policies. In the email
confirmation received from ITGI dated 14/04/2025, the
officials of ITGI shared a reconciliation summary of Form
26AS versus the amount reported on income tax insight portal.
In the reconciliation received over the mail, the difference is on
account of credit memos which are not reported in Form 26AS
but reported on insight portal. The assesee hereby further
states that they have reported a taxable income of Rs.
83,28,333/- as brokerage (basis on the monthly statements
received from the ITGI) in their Audited Financials of AY 1920. A reconciliation of reported income versus the amount
reported in the Insight portal is as below:
It can be verified from the above reconciliation that during the
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
Financial Year 2018-19 (AY 2019-20), the assessee has
reported a taxable income of Rs. 83,28,333/-which is higher
than the amount of Rs. 82,25,822/- as reported on Insight
portal of the Income Tax department.
2. This is a legitimate income within IRDAI rules and
regulations and the same has also been declared in our profit
and loss account.
3. Please find attached here with a list of invoices along with
copies of invoices (backed up by insurer statements) that were
raised on Iffco-Tokio General Insurance Company Ltd during
the period from 1st of April 2018 to 31st of March 2019, (AY
2019-20). The total of all these invoices is INR. 83,28,333/and the same amount has been appropriated as income in the
profit and loss account for the FY 2018-19 (AY 2019- 20).
4. So, all the relevant documents have been reconciled and are
matching with each other confirming that an amount of Rs.
83,28,333/- is the only amount received from ITGI against the
premium placed by us to them through the policies of our
various clients. And this amount has already been accounting
in our profit and loss statement and due tax has already been
paid on the same. Also, it would not be out of place to mention
that throughout the life span of our existence, we as company
have remained profitable, deposited our taxes diligently and
have contributed significantly to the cause of the country. Last
5years data is selfexplanatory and have been reproduced
below for your kind perusal: -
Further kindly note below points also:
a) Any income/payment which we have received from ITGI
have been booked in our profit and loss account and tax has
been paid on the same. (Annexure 4a to 4c Invoice copies with
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
ITGI statements)
b) We have no relationship whatsoever with Wings Brand
Group and Ajay Mehta group herein referred as MLBES.
c) We have not received any income/payment directly or
indirectly through any of these MLBES.
d) As per our limited knowledge the practice of additional
commissions over and above IRDAI prescribed norms were
prevalent in retail insurance business and not in corporate or
group insurance business.
e) We are a IRDAI broker whose more than 99% of business is
group business and not retail business. f) We categorically
deny our involvement in any bogus transaction and all the
above submissions are evident of the same. In view of above
stated facts, we pray that your Honor shall accept our
submission as our true and correct submission. The notice
under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 should not be
issued as there is no suppression of income and that we have
earned only the legitimate brokerage as per prescribed IRDA
guidelines which has been fully disclosed in the return of
income filed with the Income Tax Authorities for the AY 201920. We assure you of our full cooperation in this matter and
are committed toproviding all necessary information and
documentation……”
Alongwith the above reply, documents in support of assessee‟s
claim was also furnished
4. The entire submissions of the assessee have been considered
and carefully gone through and it is found that the reply of the
assessee is vague and inconclusive. ITGI‟s email confirmation
(14/04/2025) is a self-serving document without third-party
verification which can not be relied upon. Similarly, the
invoices furnished alone does not prove the genuineness of
transactions.
4.1 The core issue as mentioned in the showcause notice has
not at all been addressed as no comment has been made with
regard to percentage of commission received from IFFCO
Tokyo General Insurance Company Ltd(ITGI) and has given
very vague reply stating: “ as per our limited knowledge the
practice of additional commissions over and above IRDAI
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
prescribed norms were prevalent in retail insurance business
and not in corporate or group insurance business”. No
working of commission in terms of % of premium receipts has
been given. Mere denial of the issues involved is insufficient to
accept the plea of the assessee. In light of the same, the reply of
the assessee is considered evasive and devoid of substantial
documentary evidence and therefore can not be accepted.
5. In this case income likely to escape is more than Rs.50 lakhs
and the same is represented in the form of transaction or
entries as mentioned above which shows the income
chargeable to tax, which has escaped assessment, amounts to
more than fifty lakhs rupees. Thus, the assessee‟s case is
covered under provision of section 149 (1)(b) of the Income
Tax Act, 1961. Accordingly, it is concluded that it is a fit case
for issuing notice u/s 148 of the Act for A.Y. 2019-20.
6. Accordingly, after considering the facts of the case, as
mentioned above, it is concluded that this case is a fit case for
issuing notice u/s 148 of the I.T. Act.”
xxxxx
13.
It is seen from the above that the contention of the
petitioner in respect of the sum of Rs. 82,25,822/- being an
amount which has been declared in books and return of income
tax and as such the impugned notice which alleges that such an
amount has escaped the assessment is clearly untenable, is
concerned the issue need to be seen in facts for which it is
imperative that the notice is issued to elicit a reply and to
check whether the sum of Rs. 82,25,822/- is a result of a
spurious transaction, resulting in the income escaping
assessment/Tax. Such an exercise shall be undertaken by the
Assessing Officer, and surely not by this Court.
14. Suffice to state that the reliance placed by Mr. Gupta on
the judgment in the case of Jindal Saw Limited (supra) can be
distinguished on facts in as much as the notice under Section
148A(b) was issued on account of undeclared/unexplained
income whereas, the assessee in that case had sufficiently
explained the amount and the impugned order in that case was
seen to be at variance with the allegations made in the
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
impugned notice in the said case. Needless to state, the
reliance placed by Mr. Gupta on this judgment is misplaced.
15. In view of the above, we find no merit in this petition and
the same is dismissed along with the accompanying application
for stay…”
7.
Except for the assessment year (which in the present case is 2020-21),
the facts are identical.
8.
Being guided by the judicial discipline, we cannot take a view other
than what the Coordinate Bench had taken in petitioner’s own case.
9.
The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.
10.
The pending applications are also disposed of accordingly.
(DINESH MEHTA)
JUDGE
ADITI CHOUDHARY
(JUDGE)
OCTOBER 1, 2026/nk
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
20:00:05
W.P.(C) 13064/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review