Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 26th February, 2026
Pronounced on: 5th June, 2026
+
RFA 361/2024
SANDEEP GOEL
S/o Late Satish Chand Goel
R/o House No.114, Site-1, Block-M,
New Rajinder Nagar,
New Delhi-110060.
Through:
....Appellant
Ms. Niharika Ahluwalia and Ms.
Sonakshi Chaturvedi, Advs.
versus
M/S ZAVENIR DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LIMITED
Through its Director Mr. Pratik Bhartia
Registered Office B-42, Second Floor,
Panchsheel Enclave,
New Delhi-110017.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Sonakshi Chaturvedi, Adv
+
RFA 718/2024
ZAVENIR DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LIMITED
B-42, Second Floor,
Panchsheel Enclave,
New Delhi-110017.
....Appellant
Through: Ms. Sonakshi Chaturvedi, Adv
versus
SANDEEIP GOEL
House No.114, Site-1, Block-M,
New Rajinder Nagar,
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
New Delhi-110060.
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Niharika Ahluwalia and Ms.
Sonakshi Chaturvedi, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The aforesaid two Appeals are being decided together, as they arise
from the same Judgment.
2.
The Defendant/Appellant Sandeep Goel has filed RFA No.361/2024
against the final Judgment dated 16.05.2023 and Decree dated 29.05.2023
whereby the Leave to Defend Application, has been dismissed and the Suit
of the Respondent/Plaintiff has been decreed in the sum of Rs.72,13,890/along with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of institution of the Suit
till the date of Decree.
3.
The RFA No.718/2024 has been filed by the Plaintiff Zavenir
Developers Private Limited against the same Judgment dated 16.05.2023,
whereby the rate of interest has been challenged on the ground that, despite
the parties having agreed to an interest rate of 15% per annum with quarterly
rests, the learned Trial Court reduced the pendent lite interest to 9% per
annum simple interest, with no future interest.
4.
The Plaintiff, Zavenir Developers Private Limited filed a Suit CS DJ
No.292/2021 under Order XXXVII read with Section 151 CPC, for recovery
of Rs.50 lakhs along with interest of Rs.22,13,890/- @ 15% per annum
quarterly compounded on the principal amount till 22.03.2021, and pendent
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
lite and future interest @ 15% per annum.
5.
The facts in brief, are that the Plaintiff duly incorporated Company
since 2010, was engaged in the business / trading of cosmetics raw materials
like heena powder, etc. The Defendant, Sandeeip Goel a Chartered
Accountant by profession, was known to the Directors of the Plaintiff since
early 2000 and had been acting as a Chartered Accountant/ Auditor of the
Plaintiff. The relations between the Plaintiff and Defendant were not only
professional, but more personal on account of their relationship, which
continued even after Defendant ceased to be the Auditor/ Chartered
Accountant of the Plaintiff.
6.
In September, 2018 the Defendant approached the Plaintiff for a
friendly loan of Rs,50,00,000/- as he required the money for his own
business/ work and was interested in buying/ investing in some real estate
project/ property and he was short of the money. He assured that he would
return the amount within a year and agreed to pay interest @ 15% per
annum
with
quarterly
compounding
of
interest.
Initially,
the
Plaintiff/Directors were hesitant, but considering the relationship between
them since last 18-19 years, the Plaintiff gave Rs.50,00,000/- loan to the
Defendant, the details of which are as under:
S.N.
Date
Payment Details
1.
24.09.2018
Cheque No.000347/RTGS/NEFT dated
24.09.2018 for Rs.30,00,000/- (Rupees
Thirty Lakh only)
2.
28.09.2018
NEFT
Reference
Number
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
N271180641755994 dated 28.09.2016
for Rs.20,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty
Lakh only).
3.
Total
Rs.50,00,000/-
(Rupees
Fifty
Lakh
only)
7.
On receipt of the said money, the Defendant confirmed the aforesaid
amount with agreed rate of interest in the Confirmation of Accounts dated
01.04.2019 (for the period 01st April 2018 to 31st March 2019). During this
one year since the Defendant was not even paying the agreed rate of interest,
the Plaintiff was constrained to seek an explanation, for non-payment of
interest. The Defendant, however, assured the Plaintiff that he was stuck in
couple of financial/ monetary disputes with regard to his investments and he
was expecting quick resolution of the same and requested the Plaintiff to
wait for a few months.
8.
In December, 2019 and in the beginning of the year 2020 the Plaintiff
gently reminded the Defendant, who again sought more time. He also
offered the Plaintiff to buy certain properties, which the Plaintiff declined.
However, since March, 2020 there was no clarity whatsoever, about the
refund of the aforesaid amount with interest. The Defendant every time was
evasive in the meetings or made lame excuses and gave empty assurances.
The Defendant despite expiry of more than two and a half years, chose not
to refund the loan amount. On 22.03.2021, the total outstanding amount i.e.
the principal amount along with the agreed interest worked out as follows:
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
Date
Particulars
24.09.2018 Payment
Debit
Credit
Balance
3000000
3000000
2000000
5000000
(RTGS/NEFT)
28.09.2018 Payment
(RTGS/NEFT)
30.09.2018 Interest (24.09.2018 to 9041
5009041
30.09.2018 @ 15%
p.a.)
31.12.2018 Interest (01.10.2018 to 189383
5198424
31.12.2018 @ 15%
p.a.)
31.03.2019 Interest 01.04.2019 to 192270
5390694
31.03.2019 @ 15%
p.a.)
30.06.2019 Interest (01.04.2019 to 201597
5592291
30.06.2019 @ 15%
p.a.)
30.09.2019 Interest (01.07.2019 to 211434
5803725
30.09.2019 @ 15%
p.a.)
31.12.2019 Interest (01.10.2019 to 219428
6023153
31.12.2019 @ 15%
p.a.)
31.03.2020 Interest (01.10.2020 to 225240
6248402
31.03.2020 @ 15%
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
p.a.)
30.06.2020 Interest (01.04.2020 to 233673
6482075
30.06.2020 @ 15%
p.a.)
30.09.2020 Interest (01.07.2020 to 245076
6727151
30.09.2020 @ 15%
p.a.)
31.12.2020 Interest (01.10.2020 to 254342
6981493
31.12.2020 @ 15%
p.a.)
24.02.2021 Interest (01.01.2021 to 157800
7139293
24.02.2021 @ 15%
p.a.)
22.03.2021 Interest (25.02.2021 to 74597
7213890
22.03.2021 @ 15%
p.a.)
22.03.2021 Balance payable as on
7213890
22.03.2021 (INR)
9.
The Plaintiff thus, sent a Legal Notice dated 25.02.2021 asking the
Defendant to pay the outstanding amount of Rs.71,39,293/-, within 15 days.
However, the Defendant chose not to respond to the Notice.
10.
The Plaintiff thus, filed the Suit under Order XXXVII CPC, on the
basis of Confirmation of Accounts, duly singed by the parties, for recovery
of Rs.72,13,890/- (Rs.50,00,000/- towards the principal amount and
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
Rs.22,13,890/- towards interest as on 22.03.2021) along with pendente lite
and future interest @ 15% per annum compounded quarterly.
11.
The Defendant/Appellant Sandeeip Goel on service of Summons for
Judgment, filed his Leave to Defend Application under Order 37 Rule 3(5)
read with Section 151 CPC.
12.
A preliminary objection was taken that the Plaintiff has approached
the Court with unclean hands. It was asserted that the averments made in
the Suit were ambiguous and material facts have been concealed.
13.
The Supreme Court in Krishna Lal Chawla & Ors. vs. State of U.P &
Anr. in Criminal Appeal No.283/2021 arising out of S.L.P (Crl.)
No.6432/2020 had held that the Court has inherent powers to prevent the
abuse of its processes.
14.
It was next contended that the Suit was barred by Limitation. Also,
the Plaint does not disclose any cause of action. It is a bogus suit alleging
the loan, when in fact there was no loan document ever signed or executed
between the parties. The Suit is not maintainable, as it is not based on any
written document, bills of exchange, hundies and promissory notes nor is it a
liquidated demand arising out of a written contract, enactment or guarantee.
Moreover, the Suit has been filed without necessary compliance of Order 37
CPC.
15.
On merits, the Defendant admitted that since the year 2000, he had
good relations with the Plaintiff; at certain times the Defendant helped the
Plaintiff by extending short term loans to the Plaintiff and its Directors and
also to their Group Company Zavenir Daubert India Limited. Hira Lal
Bhartia and Pratik Bhartia Directors of Plaintiff Company, who had good
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
relations with the Defendant, stated on 20.09.2018 that they were having an
urgent requirement of cash to be paid somewhere, for the purpose of the
Plaintiff Company and requested the Defendant to arrange for cash of
Rs.50,00,000/-.
On the same day, the Defendant through WhatsApp
message conveyed to the Plaintiff that he could arrange cash to the tune of
Rs.40-45 lakhs. Mr. Pratik Bhartia persuaded the Defendant to arrange a
sum of Rs.50 lakhs, as there was some equipment, for which the payment to
be made by the Plaintiff company.
16.
The Defendant with sheer hard work and goodwill, arranged cash of
Rs.50 lakhs for the Plaintiff Company, which he sent to Pratik Bhartia on
21.09.2018, at his residential address in Panchsheel Enclave and he duly
acknowledged the receipt of the same, through Whatsapp message.
17.
On 23.09.2018, Mr. Pratik Bhartia Director requested the Defendant
to send his copy of Aadhar Card and PAN Card and other Bank details, so
that he could transfer back the funds to the tune of Rs.50 lakhs, to his
account. Accordingly, Pratik Bhartia transferred a sum of Rs.30 lakhs to
Defendant, on 24.09.2018.
18.
The Defendant at the time of arranging the money had promised the
lender to return their money, on or before 24.09.2018. He thus, made a
request to Mr. Pratik Bhartia to immediately send the balance amount of
Rs.20 lakhs to him. The balance amount of Rs.20 lakhs was sent by Mr.
Pratik Bhartia, on 28.09.2018. On receipt of this total sum of Rs.50 lakhs
from Mr. Pratik Bhartia, the Defendant returned the amount to the person
from whom he had taken the money. The copy of WhatsApp chat along
with Certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act, were
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
annexed with the Leave to Defend Application.
19.
The Defendant claimed that Rs.50 lakhs was nothing, but refund of
the money advanced by the Defendant to Mr. Pratik Bhartia. He denied that
he ever approached the Plaintiff, for loan. He claimed that he has been with
mala fide intention, dragged into unwarranted litigation to harass and
humiliate him in the Court.
20.
The Defendant/Appellant thus, sought Leave to Defend the Suit on
the grounds that he had a strong prima facie case in his defence and was
entitled to unconditional leave. A fair, bona fide and triable issues had been
raised in his Leave to Defend Application. Hence, a prayer was made that
he should be granted unconditional Leave to Defend the Suit.
21.
The Plaintiff in the Reply, vehemently opposed the contentions made
in the Leave to Defend Application. It was denied that a cash of Rs.50 lakhs
had been arranged by the Defendant for the Directors of the Plaintiff or that
the amount transferred to the Account of the Defendant, was return of this
cash loan. It was denied that any amount of Rs.50 lakh, was ever received
by the Plaintiff.
It was reaffirmed that the Plaintiff had granted the
conventional help to the Defendant and the Plaintiff also filed the Certificate
issued by the Bank, to reflect that he had an FDR of Rs.60 lakhs in their
name on the date of alleged loan. It was claimed that the Defendant is only
relying upon WhatsApp chats, which are manipulated and fabricated and
cannot be relied.
22.
It was further claimed that the alleged loan of Rs.50 lakhs in cash as
claimed by the Defendant, was in complete contravention of Income Tax Act
and the Defendant and his, so called sources from whom he had arranged the
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
alleged loan, have acted in contravention of Section 269 SS, 269 SC, 269 T,
68 and 69A and are liable for punishment under Section 271 D, 271DA,
271E of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
23.
The learned District Judge, considered the defence as disclosed in
the Leave to Defend Application and observed that the defence taken by the
Defendant that in fact he had given money in cash and the bank transaction
of the Plaintiff were only for return of the said loan amount, appeared to be
total sham and moon shine. The WhatsApp chats on which the Defendant
had placed reliance to show that he had paid Rs.30 lakhs, was insufficient to
even draw an assumption of such cash loan having been advanced by the
Defendant to the Plaintiff. Even otherwise, such a transaction would be in
gross violation of Income Tax Act, 1961 which does not permit any
transaction in cash above Rs.20,000/-.
24.
The learned District Judge thus, found no grounds for granting of
Leave to Defend and the Suit of the Plaintiff was decreed in the sum of
Rs.72,13,890/- along with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of
institution of the Suit till the date of decree.
RFA No.361/2024: Challenge to the Dismissal of Leave to Defend
Application:
25.
The Defendant/Appellant, Sandeeip Goel aggrieved by the impugned
Judgment dated 16.05.2023 and Decree dated 25.09.2023, has preferred
RFA No.361/2024. The grounds of challenge are that a patent illegality has
been committed in the impugned Judgment and Decree, since the
Respondent had failed to produce any documents to show and demonstrate
that Appellant/ Defendant had ever requested for any loan of Rs.50 lakhs.
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
The WhatsApp chats have been completely ignored and discarded, even
though they were supported with Certificate under Section 65 B of the
Indian Evidence Act. These WhatsApp chats clearly prove that the alleged
sum of Rs.50 lakhs was nothing but the refund of cash facility, extended by
the Defendant in good faith, for 4-5 days.
26.
Furthermore, it has not been considered that the Respondent being a
big corporate entity, would never advance any loan of Rs.50,00,000/- to the
Defendant, without executing any Agreement or Contract or taking any
security for the alleged loan.
27.
The alleged Confirmation of Account Statement dated 01.04.2019,
was signed by the Appellant on the assurance and promise made by Mr.
Pratik Bhartia the Director and under duress of long standing relationship
with them. It has not been signed by the Appellant with his free will and
consent.
28.
Moreover, this Confirmation of Account Statement dated 01.04.2019,
cannot be construed as an Agreement or Contract between the parties.
Moreover, it is not tenable under various provisions of Indian Contract Act
and Indian Stamp Act and cannot be construed as an Agreement between the
parties.
29.
The learned District Judge has misled itself to the alleged Account
Confirmation Statement dated 01.04.2019. As per the Accounting norms
and practices, every Company registered under the Companies Act should
get the confirmation of its debt from its debtors, but in the present case the
Respondent Company except the alleged Account Confirmation Statement
dated 01.04.2019, did not produce any Account Confirmation Statement of
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
the subsequent Financial Years i.e. 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22.
30.
Moreover, this alleged Confirmation of Account Statement dated
01.04.2019, can neither be construed as Bill of Exchange, Hundies or
Promissory Notes nor it can be construed as a written Contract/ Agreement
for the loan.
31.
The Appellant has submitted that the learned District Judge has totally
ignored the principles laid down by the Apex Court and has given no reason
for declining the Leave to Defend Application.
32.
The Bombay High Court in the case of Jyotsna K. Valia vs. T.S.
Parekh and Co. 2007 (4) Mh.L.J. had noted that it is not possible to lay
down any precise test as to when a Summary Suit would be maintainable, on
an acknowledgement, writing or receipt. It would depend on the document
itself, the practice, usage and customs of the trade and also the facts of each
case.
The Trial Courts were advised to grant leave to defend to the
defendant, in the case on the basis of the principle/ test laid down in the case
of Machalec Engineering and Manufacturers vs. Basic Equipment
Corporation 1977 AIR 577 and Sunil Enterprises vs. S.B.I Commercial and
International Bank Ltd. AIR 1988 SUPREME COURT 2317.
33.
This Court in M/s Sakata INX (India) Ltd. vs. M/s Rexor India
Limited & Ors. 2015 SCC OnLine Del 13445 had observed that where the
supply of goods was through Invoices, they are itself a Contract/ Agreement,
and thus, demand on the basis of running Account, may be justified.
34.
However, in the present case, there is no written contract/ agreement
signed and executed between the parties. It is further asserted that the
alleged Demand Notice is false, frivolous, bogus, misconceived and a part of
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
ploy of the Plaintiff Company.
35.
Moreover, the Appellant asserted that he had good defence to contest
the Suit and, therefore, the impugned Judgment be set aside and the Leave to
Defend by granted and the Suit be decided on merits.
36.
The Respondent/Plaintiff Zavenir Developers Private Limited in the
Written Synopsis, had asserted that there is no merit in the Appeal preferred
by the Defendant, as there is no bona fide defence or triable issue disclosed
by him in the Leave to Defend Application. At the stage of considering the
Leave to Defend Application, the Court is only required to examine whether
the defence is plausible and raises triable issues and not to weigh the
evidentiary value or conduct mini trial.
37.
It was contended that the Suit under Order 37 IPC, was based on the
Confirmation of Account dated 01.04.2019 and, therefore, the Suit under
Order 37 CPC, was maintainable. Moreover, the loan transactions stood
fully confirmed in the Whatsapp conversations, which were duly supported
with the Certificate under Section 65 B of the Indian Evidence Act. It was,
therefore, submitted that the Leave to Defend has been rightly, dismissed
and the Suit of the Plaintiff decreed.
RFA 718/2024: Challenge by the Plaintiff to the pendente-lite Rate of
Interest and non-grant of Future Interest:
38.
The Plaintiff Zavenir Developers Private Limited have challenged the
impugned Judgment dated 16.05.2023 and Decree dated 25.04.2024 to the
extent of pendente lite interest at the agreed rate and the future interest, have
not been granted to the plaintiff.
39.
In the grounds of Appeal, it is asserted that denial of future interest to
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
the Plaintiff, has effectively given an undue benefit to the Defendant by
stopping the interest on the date of decree, thereby there being a substantial
time gap between the date of decree and actual realization of amount, which
would operate to the benefit of the Defendant. The rationale for awarding
the three sets of interest i.e. Pre-institution, Pendente lite and Future
Interest, is on the premise that a person is entitled to interest on his money
as he
remained deprived of the use of his money to which he was
legitimately entitled and he has a right to be compensated for the period of
such deprivation. The Plaintiff/Appellant had claimed interest @ 15% per
annum with quarterly rests, for pendente lite and future interest. However,
the learned District Judge has reduced the pendent lite interest from 15% per
annum with quarterly rest, to 9% Simple Interest and has failed to grant any
future interest.
40.
Section 34 CPC is the enabling Section under which the Courts have
been consistently granting all the three sets of interest. An illegality has
been committed in terms of Section 34 CPC by granting pendent lite Simple
Interest @ 9% Simple Interest and not granting any future interest.
41.
Reliance is placed on Central Bank of India vs. Ravindra & Ors.
(2002) 1 SCC 367, wherein the Supreme Court had held that the principal
sum so adjudged is such principal sum within the meaning of Section 34 on
which pendente lite and future interest i.e. post decree interest at such rate
and for such period for which the Court may deem fit, may be awarded by
the Court.
42.
Similarly, in the case of Space Enterprises vs. Srivivasa Enterprises
Ltd. 1998 (45) DRJ 375 it was held that in case the agreed rate of interest,
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
the court is only required to see that it is not exorbitant, unconscionable and
against the public policy of keeping the interest pegged at a reasonable rate
of interest, which may vary by one or two percent from the rate of interest at
which Banks advances monies for the purpose of commercial transactions.
In that case, the interest of 24% not being compoundable and being simple,
was held to be reasonable.
43.
The Plaintiff has claimed that denial of agreed rate of interest between
the parties, is contrary to the Judgment of the Division Bench of Supreme
Court in State of Rajasthan vs. Ferro Concrete Construction (P) Ltd. (2009)
12 SCC 1; South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. vs. State of M.P & Ors. (2003) 8
SCC 648; and Executive Engineer, Dhenkanal Minor Irrigation Division,
Orissa & Ors. vs. NC Budharaj (Deceased) by LRs and Ors. (2001) 2 SCC
721.
44.
It is contended that the impugned Judgment in limiting the interest,
has resulted in denial of justice to the Appellant. Hence, a prayer is made
that interest be granted as per the agreed rate between the parties.
45.
The Defendant Sandeeip Goel, however, contended that the
enhancement of pendent lite interest to 15% with quarterly rest and grant of
future interest till realization, is wholly mis-conceived and deserves outright
dismissal.
46.
At the outset, there was no written Loan Agreement and there was no
agreed rate of interest, as claimed by the Plaintiff. The entire claim of
contractual interest is based on unilateral interpretation of Confirmation of
Account, which by itself does not constitute a binding Loan Agreement
incorporating interest terms, in the absence of written contract specifying
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
the rate and compounding mechanism.
47.
Section 34 CPC squarely rests the jurisdiction to award reasonable
interest which has been granted by the learned District Judge after due
consideration to 9% Simple Interest. It is, therefore, submitted that the
interest has been granted appropriately and there is no merit in the Appeal.
Submissions heard and record perused.
RFA 361/2024:
48.
Admittedly, the Plaintiff Company and the Defendant had a
longstanding professional and personal relationship, since 2000. The
Appellant/Defendant was not only a Chartered Accountant/Auditor for the
Plaintiff Company, but had longstanding personal relationship.
49.
The simple case of the Plaintiff was that on the request of the
Defendant/Appellant for urgent need of Rs.50 lakhs, Rs.30 lakhs were
transferred through the bank on 24.09.2018 and Rs.20 lakhs on 28.09.2018
to the bank account of the Defendant/Appellant; a fact which is not denied
by the Defendant/Appellant.
50.
However, the first defence taken by the Appellant was that in fact he
had arranged cash of Rs.50 lakhs on 21.08.2018, on the request of the
Plaintiff. This cash money which had been given by the Defendant to the
Plaintiff, was also reflected in the WhatsApp conversations between the
Appellant and the Director of the Company. However, while the Appellant
has tried to explain an earlier transaction of Rs.50 lakhs, but the documents
placed on record, said a different story.
51.
As per the bank account of the Plaintiff Company, a NEFT transaction
for transfer of Rs.30 lakhs on 24.09.2018 and of Rs.20 lakhs on 28.09.2018.
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
The statement of the account clearly establishes the transfer of Rs.50 lakhs
through bank transaction to the Appellant. Not only this, the whole issue is
settled by a Confirmation of Accounts Letter dated 01.04.2019, for the
period from 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2019 written by the Plaintiff to the
Defendant.
52.
This Confirmation of Accounts Letter not only mentions about the
two Bank transfers of Rs.30 lakhs on 24.09.2018 and Rs.20 lakhs on
28.09.2018 through NEFT to the account of the Defendant, but it has also
indicated against the two bank transactions that it is a loan given interest @
15% p.a., with quarterly compounding interest repayable on loan.
53.
Further, this Statement reflects that interest @ 15 % p.a., was payable
on three occasions by the Defendant; first, in the sum of Rs.9041/- on
30.09.2018; next on 31.12.2018 for the period from 01.10.2018 to
31.12.2018 of Rs.1,89,383/-, and third on 31.03.2019 for the interest @15 %
p.a., from 01.01.2019 to 31.03.2019, in the sum of Rs.1,92,270/-. The total
balance of the amount due from the Defendant, was reflected as
Rs.53,90,694/-, in the Confirmation of Accounts Statement.
54.
This Letter is signed by the Plaintiff as well as by the Defendant, who
has written “we confirm the above”. This Confirmation Letter not only
amounts to the written Agreement/Contract wherein the terms of the loan
and the payment due have been reflected, but is also admitted and confirmed
by the Defendant.
55.
The only explanation given by the Appellant is that he had signed the
document, on the assurance of the Plaintiff that it would not be acted upon.
The Appellant himself being a Chartered Accountant, signing such a
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
document could not have come up with a more weak argument, which has
no legs to stand on.
56.
In Khan Bahadur Shapoor Freedom Mazda v. Durga Prosad
Chamaria (1962) 1 SCR 140, the term “acknowledgement” was explained to
mean an admission by a writer that there is a debt owing by him, either to
the receiver of the letter or some other person on whose behalf the Letter is
received. However, it is not enough that he refers to a debt as being due
from somebody in order to qualify as an acknowledgement, there must be
fair construction of the Letter read in the light of the surrounding
circumstances, to the admission that the writer owes the debt.
57.
It is therefore, evident that this Confirmation of Accounts Statement,
which is duly signed by the Appellant, amounts to a written contract as well
as an acknowledgement of the terms, stated therein. It is established that the
total loan amount of Rs.50 lakhs, was transferred in the account of the
Defendant.
58.
In the case of M/s Sakata INX (India) Ltd. (supra), a reference was
made to FCI v. Bal Kishan Garg (1982) 21 DLT 167, wherein it was
observed that the purpose of giving a written acknowledgment, implies that
it is absolute unqualified present liability of the obligation to repay it in
future, on the understanding that the creditor need not file a suit
immediately. The written acknowledgement surely falls under the term
“written contract” and the parties had consensus of mind that this written
acknowledgement was signed by one of the parties to the Petitioner’s firm.
There was a promise, there was a consideration, there was an acceptance, all
the elements essential for formulation of written contract was present.
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
Nothing more is required in this acknowledgement to make it a contract.
59.
The defence of Sandeep Goel, that he had arranged for a cash amount
of Rs.50 lakhs for a few days, through cash for the Plaintiff, is nothing but a
sham and moonshine. The Defendant has merely claimed that he had
arranged the money from some friend, but has failed to disclose the source
or to explain from where he had arranged the cash amount as alleged by
him.
60.
The defence raised by him, does not disclose any triable issue. The
learned District Judge rightly, dismissed the Leave to Defend Application
and decreed the Suit of the Plaintiff. There is no merit in the Appeal
preferred by the Appellant, Sandeep Goel, which is hereby, dismissed.
RFA 718/2024: In Respect of Interest:
61.
The second aspect for consideration is the Appeal filed by the
Plaintiff who had sought the enhancement of pendente lite interest @ 15% to
be compounded quarterly instead of 9% p.a. and also for future interest at
the same rate, which has not been granted to the Plaintiff.
62.
The short question is whether the Plaintiff was entitled to pendent lite
and future interest, at the agreed rate of 15% with quarterly rest.
63.
To appreciate the contention, it is relevant to refer to Order 37 Rule
2(3) of CPC which specifically provides that in case the Respondent fails to
enter an appearance and in default of his entering an appearance, the
allegations in the plaint shall be deemed to be admitted and the plaintiff shall
be entitled to a decree for any sum, not exceeding the sum mentioned in the
summons, together with interest at the rate specified, if any, up to the date
of the decree and such sum for costs as may be determined by the High
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
Court, from time to time, by rules made in that behalf and such decree may
be executed forthwith.
64.
It is therefore, evident that in a Summary Suit, the Plaintiff is entitled
to the agreed rate of interest, till the date of Decree. However, thereafter,
S.34 CPC, becomes applicable.
65.
In this regard, it would be pertinent to refer Section 34 CPC which
provides that in a money decree, in addition to any interest adjudged for
principal sum for any period prior to the institution of the Suit, the Court
may grant interest from the date of decree to the date of payment or such
earlier date, as the Court may deem fit.
66.
In the case of Space Enterprises (supra) while considering whether in
a Suit under Order 37 CPC, the court is entitled to grant pendente lite and
future interest, it was held that awarding of pendente lite and future interest
is a matter of discretion of the Court, but it should not reflect any
arbitrariness. In case the agreed rate of interest is held to be not exorbitant,
unconscionable and against public policy of keeping the interest pegged at a
reasonable rate of interest which may vary by one or two per cent from the
rate of interest at which banks lend and advance monies for the purpose of
commercial transactions, it may be granted.
67.
The Courts are thus, well within their right to grant the interest in the
money decree. The power to award pendente lite and future interest flows
from Section 34 of the CPC; it is based on the principle that a party deprived
of the use of money rightfully due to it, ought to be compensated for the
period during which such money remained withheld.
68.
In the case of Clariant International Limited and another. vs
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
Securities & Exchange Board of India 2004 (8) SCC 524 it was held that
interest can be awarded in terms of an Agreement or statutory provisions. It
can also be awarded by reason of usage or trade having the force of law or
on equitable considerations. Interest cannot be awarded by way of damages,
except in cases where money due, is wrongfully withheld and there are
equitable grounds thereof, for which a written demand is mandatory. In the
absence of any agreement or statutory provision or a mercantile usage,
interest payable can be only at the market rate. Such interest is payable
upon establishment of totality of circumstances, justifying the exercise of
such equitable jurisdiction.
This judgment was endorsed in Rampur
Fertiliser Limited vs. Vigyan Chemicals Industries (2009) 12 SCC 324.
69.
Similar observations were made in Thazhathe Thazhathe Purayil
Sarabi vs. Union of India (2009) 7 SCC 372, wherein it was held that when
there is no specific provision for grant of interest on any amount due, the
Court may award interest in their discretion, under the provisions of Section
3 of the Interest Act and Section 34 of the CPC.
70.
In M/s Tomorrowland Limited vs. Housing and Urban Development
Corporation Limited and Anr. 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 205 it was endorsed that
the award of interest, is a discretionary exercise steeped in equitable
considerations.
71.
The law has been succinctly discussed by the Constitution Bench in
Central Bank of India (supra), wherein it was held that award of interest
pendente lite or post-decree is discretionary and is essentially governed by
Section 34 of the CPC, de hors the contract between the parties. In a case, if
the Court finds that the principal sum adjudged on the date of Suit and the
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
component of interest, is disproportionate with the principal sum actually
advanced, the Court may exercise its discretion in awarding interest
pendente lite and post decree interest at a lower rate or may even decline to
award such interest. The discretion has to be exercised fairly, judiciously
and not for arbitrary or fanciful reasons.
As a general principle, in
commercial disputes, the award of interest pendente lite or post decree is
typically granted as a matter of discretion. This is because such interest
serves to compensate the aggrieved party for the time value of money that
was due, but was withheld during the legal process.
72.
In the present case, while dismissing the Leave to Defend Application
and finding the Plaintiff/Appellant Zavenir Developers Private Limited
entitled to recovery of Rs.50,00,000/-, had granted pre-Suit interest at the
agreed rate. The Court in its discretion, had granted not the agreed rate of
interest of 15% with quarterly rest, but has granted pendente lite Simple
Interest @ 9% per annum, in its discretion. There is nothing to show that
the discretion so exercised, is arbitrary or against the norms of custom usage
pertaining to commercial transactions.
73.
However, in so far as not granting of future interest is concerned,
there is no explanation stated therein. The Plaintiff is, therefore, in terms of
Section 34 of the CPC, justified to claim future interest, which is
accordingly awarded @ 9% simple interest per annum, from the date of
Decree till the date of payment.
74.
The Appeal of the Plaintiff is partly allowed and the impugned
Judgment dated 16.05.2023 is modified to the extent that the Defendant shall
also be liable to pay the future interest @ 9% simple interest per annum, till
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
the date of payment.
75.
Accordingly, Appeal along with pending Applications is, disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 5, 2026
Va/N
KUMAR BHATT
11:34:21
RFA 361/2024 & RFA 718/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review