Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:11364
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
WEDNESDAY, THE 12TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 23RD MAGHA,
CRL.A NO. 809 OF 2017
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 05.11.2016 IN SC NO.1691
OF 2010 ON THE FILES OF THE COURT OF THE ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT COURT & SESSIONS COURT - IV, KOLLAM
APPELLANT/ACCUSED:
YOHANNAN
S/O.FRANCIS, H.NO:155, KADAPPURAM PURAMPOKU,
ANUGRAHA NAGAR, NEAR KENNADY LIBRARY,
PALLITHOTTAM WARD, PALLITHOTTAM VILLAGE,
KOLLAM DISTRICT.
ADV.GAJENDRA SINGH RAJPUROHIT
RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT:
STATE REPRESENTED BY THE DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT
OF POLICE, CRIME DEPARTMENT, KOLLAM, THROUGH
THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
ERNAKULAM.
BY ADV.ALEX.M.THOMBRA SR.PP
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
05.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
12.02.2025
DELIVERED
THE
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 2 :-
2025:KER:11364
P.B.SURESH KUMAR & JOBIN SEBASTIAN, JJ.
----------------------------------------------Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
----------------------------------------------Dated this the 12th day of February, 2025
JUDGMENT
P.B.Suresh Kumar, J.
The sole accused in S.C.No.1691 of 2010 on the
files of the Court of the Additional District and Sessions JudgeIV, Kollam, is the appellant in the appeal. He stands convicted
and sentenced for the offences punishable under Sections 302,
333, 353 and 341 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
2.
The appellant,
a
person
with
a
physical
disability requiring the use of crutches, lived with his parents .
On 26.04.2008 at 11.30 a.m., two linemen and an overseer of
the Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) who were deputed for
disconnecting the power supply of defaulters visited the house
of the sister of the appellant , who resides adjacent to the
house of the appellant, and since she expressed inability to
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 3 :-
2025:KER:11364
clear
the
dues
the
power
supply
to
her
house
was
disconnected as directed by the said officials of KSEB. After
sometime, the officials of KSEB visited the house of the
appellant also and when they attempted to disconnect the
power supply therein, there occurred an altercation between
the KSEB officials and the mother of the appellant. In the
course of the said altercation, one of the linemen, namely
Kuriakose sustained stab injuries. Kuriakose was initially taken
to the District Hospital, Kollam and from there to the Medical
College Hospital, Thiruvananthapuram and he succumbed to
the injuries on 07.05.2008 while undergoing treatment in the
latter hospital.
3.
occurrence
A case was registered in connection with the
by
Pallithottam
Police
on
the
basis
of
the
information furnished by Studymon, the other lineman at 12.30
p.m. on 26.04.2008 itself and the investigation conducted in
the said case revealed that it was the appellant who stabbed
Kuriakose. By the time the investigation in the case concluded,
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 4 :-
2025:KER:11364
Studymon
who
lodged
the
First
Information
Statement,
subsequently died in an accident. A final report was filed
thereupon against the appellant under Sections 333, 353, 341
and 302 of IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act.
4.
The accusation against the appellant in the
final report is that the appellant who was present on
26.04.2008 in the house of his sister when the officials of KSEB
disconnected the power supply, proceeded to his house in
anticipation that the officials would come to his house as well
to disconnect the power supply, as he was also in default and
thereby waited for them. It is alleged that when the officials
reached his house at about 11.30 a.m. and attempted to
disconnect the power supply, the mother of the appellant
prevented
them
from
doing
so
and
there
occurred
consequently, a verbal altercation between the officials and
the mother of the appellant. It is also alleged that in the course
of the said altercation, the appellant who came to the scene
using a crutch under his left arm, hit on the back of Kuriakose
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 5 :-
2025:KER:11364
with his right hand, after which Kuriakose threatened the
appellant and his mother that if the dues are not cleared on
the same day, there will not be any power supply on the
following day. It is also alleged that the appellant, after
dropping the crutch onto the floor, caught hold of Kuriakose
with his left hand and while Kuriakose was attempting to
wriggle out of his hold, the appellant took out a knife from the
right pocket of his pants and stabbed Kuriakose repeatedly on
his abdomen as also left chest. Kuriakose succumbed to the
said injuries on 07.05.2008.
5.
On the appellant being committed to trial, the
Court of Session framed charges against him to which he
pleaded not guilty. The evidence in the case consists of the oral
evidence of PWs 1 to 15 and Exts.P1 to P39 proved through
them. Exts.D1 and D2 are the portions of the case diary
statements of the witnesses examined as PWs 1 and 2. MOs 1
to 5 are the material objects identified by the witnesses.
Thereupon, after complying with the procedure prescribed, the
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 6 :-
2025:KER:11364
Court of Session found the appellant guilty of the offence
punishable under Sections 333, 353, 341 and 302 IPC,
convicted him and sentenced him to undergo among others,
imprisonment for life. The appellant was however acquitted of
the charge framed under Section 27(2) of the Arms Act. The
appellant is deeply aggrieved by his conviction and sentence in
the case, hence this appeal.
6.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant as
also the learned Public Prosecutor.
7.
The
point
that
falls
for
consideration
is
whether the conviction of the appellant and the sentence
passed against him, are sustainable in law.
8.
It is seen that it is based on the oral evidence
tendered by the witnesses examined on the side of the
prosecution as PWs 1 to 3 that the appellant is convicted. The
essence of the elaborate arguments advanced by the learned
counsel for the appellant is that there are inherent infirmities in
the evidence of the said witnesses and that, therefore, their
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 7 :-
2025:KER:11364
evidence cannot be the basis of a conviction. The learned
counsel has pointed out various reasons in support of the said
argument, and we are not referring to the same here as we
propose to deal with the same elaborately in the latter part of
this judgment. Per contra, the learned Public Prosecutor
supported the impugned judgment pointing out that there is
absolutely no reason to reject the evidence tendered by the
eyewitnesses examined as PWs 1 to 3, and that apart, their
evidence is corroborated by the evidence tendered by other
witnesses examined in the case.
9.
Let us now consider the evidence. PW1 is the
overseer of KSEB who accompanied the linemen namely,
Kuriakose and Studymon on the relevant day to disconnect the
power supply of defaulters. PW1 deposed that on the relevant
day, he along with Kuriakose and Studymon went to the house
of the sister of the appellant at about 11.00 a.m. and required
her to pay the dues and as she sought time to pay the same,
the power supply to her house was disconnected. It was
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 8 :-
2025:KER:11364
deposed by PW1 that in the meanwhile, he received a
complaint from another consumer concerning a street light and
that he proceeded to examine the said complaint after
directing
Kuriakose
and
Studymon
to
continue
the
disconnection procedure. It was deposed by PW1 that he heard
a commotion after sometime and that when he proceeded to
that place, he saw the appellant hitting on the back of
Kuriakose after voicing a threat. According to PW1, even
though he instructed Kuriakose and Studymon to leave the
place, Kuriakose voiced a threat to the appellant that if he does
not clear the dues on the same day, the power supply to his
house would be disconnected. It was deposed by PW1 that the
appellant then caught hold of Kuriakose with his left hand and
stabbed on his abdomen and chest with the knife which he
took out with his right hand from the pocket of his pants and
that the appellant thereafter went back to his house with the
crutches. It was deposed by PW1 that Kuriakose was taken by
him and others to the District Hospital, Kollam in an
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 9 :-
2025:KER:11364
autorickshaw and from there to the Medical College Hospital,
Thiruvananthapuram. PW1 identified the appellant in the dock
and also identified MO1 as the knife that was used by him to
stab Kuriakose. PW1 also affirmed that he was a witness to the
inquest. In cross-examination, it was clarified by PW1 that the
police took his statements on a few occasions.
10.
PW2 was a neighbour of the appellant. The
version of PW2 as regards the occurrence was that at about
11.30 a.m. on the date of occurrence, while he was watching
television in the house of his son, he heard a commotion from
the house of the appellant and when he proceeded there, he
saw a few persons in the midst of an altercation and that two
among them were found to be wearing khakhi. It was deposed
by PW2 that in the course of the altercation, the appellant hit
on the back of Kuriakose and thereupon gave a blow on his
head with the crutch and that after holding the neck of
Kuriakose with his left hand, the appellant stabbed on his
abdomen and chest with a knife which he took out from the
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 10 :-
2025:KER:11364
pocket of his pants. PW2 also identified MO1 as the weapon
used by the appellant to stab Kuriakose. In cross-examination,
it was admitted by PW2 that he only has limited vision for the
past
three
to
four
years
and
that
he
has
severe
shortsightedness. It was also admitted by PW2 in crossexamination that there was a case between the appellant and
the son of PW2 namely, Nixon. It was stated by PW2 in his
cross-examination that the appellant used to inch before he
started using a crutch and that he cannot walk without a
crutch. In re-examination, it was clarified by PW2 that the case
between his son Nixon and the appellant was closed on a
compromise.
11.
PW3 was the driver of the auto-rickshaw in
which Kuriakose was taken to the hospital for treatment. The
version of PW3 as regards the occurrence was that on the
relevant day, he came near the scene of occurrence to drop
two ladies who engaged his auto and while he was about to
leave, he heard a commotion in which two persons were
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 11 :-
2025:KER:11364
wearing khakhi and that he saw then another person
proceeding to that place with a crutch and stabbing one of the
said two persons with a knife by holding him with his left hand.
According to PW3, the said person with the crutch was uttering
something at that time and the same was not clear to him. It
was deposed by PW3 that while he was about to leave that
place, one of the persons who was wearing khakhi called him
from behind and when he stopped the auto-rickshaw, the said
person came to the vehicle with the injured person and that
PW3 took them to the District Hospital, Kollam. PW3 identified
the appellant as the person who came with the crutch and
stabbed the person who was wearing khakhi. PW3 is a witness
whose statement was recorded under Section 164 of the Code.
In cross-examination, PW3 however admitted that he had not
stated in his
statement recorded under Section 164 of the
Code that he saw the appellant stabbing anyone with a knife.
12.
PW4 was a Medical Officer attached to the
District Hospital, Kollam during 2008. PW4 deposed that at
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 12 :-
2025:KER:11364
12.01 p.m. on 26.04.2008, he examined Kuriakose who was
brought to the casualty with the alleged history of assault
while on duty. Ext.P2 is the wound certificate prepared by PW4.
The following are the injuries noted by PW4 on the body of
Kuriakose:
“1. Incised wound 1½ cm long 0.3 cm broad left part of
the chest. Depth of the wound not explored
2. Incised wound 1 ½ cm long 0.3 cm broad left part
of the abdomen. Depth of the wound not explored.”
It was deposed by PW4 that after examination and surgical
consultation, the patient was referred to the surgical casualty
of the Medical College Hospital, Thiruvananthapuram. It was
deposed by PW4 that the injuries noted by him can be caused
with MO1 knife. In cross-examination, it was clarified by PW4
that what was recorded by him in the wound certificate is that
the injured was brought to the hospital by the subordinates of
the latter. PW8 was one of the doctors who treated Kuriakose
at the Medical College Hospital, Thiruvananthapuram. Ext.P8 is
the treatment certificate issued by PW8. It was deposed by
PW8 that the injuries noted on the body of Kuriakose are
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 13 :-
2025:KER:11364
injuries that could be caused by using a sharp edged weapon
like MO1.
13.
PW9 was the doctor who conducted the
postmortem examination on the body of the deceased and
issued Ext.P9 postmortem certificate. The ante-mortem injuries
noticed on the body of the deceased at the time of
postmortem
examination
as
deposed
by
PW9,
are
the
following:
“1. Sutured pale scar 1.5cm long on the left side of chest,
vertical, upper end 16.5cm below armpit. Incised wound
2.5cm long involving the 8th inter costal space. Left dome of
diaphragm seen sutured for a length of 1.5cm underneath.
Spleen seen surgically removed. Two sutured wounds 1cm
long each, 1cm apart, involving whole thickness of front wall
of jejunum, the former 26cm distal to the fixed loop. The
wound was directed downwards, forwards and to the right for
a depth of 12cm. Mesentery contained reddish brown blood
clots. Jejunum, was gangrenous for a length of 60cm, 42cm
distal to the fixed loop. Peritoneal cavity contained 150ml of
blood stained fluid.
2. Sutured pale scar 2cm long, 0.5cm deep, oblique on the
abdomen, its upper inner end 4cm outer to midline and 14cm
below costal margin.
3. Sutured pale laparotomy scar, 24 cm long, vertical on the
abdomen, its upper end 19 cm below top of breast bone.
4. Surgical drainage wound 1.5cm long on the left side of
abdomen 29.5cm below armpit.
5. Sutured intercosal drainage wound on the left side of chest,
1.5cm long, 8.5cm outer to midline and 19cm below
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 14 :-
2025:KER:11364
collarbone, with yellowish slough at the edges.
6. Abrasion 0.5x0.2cm, on the right side of back of trunk 2cm
outer to and 5.5cm below root of neck.
7. Abrasion 2x0.2cm, oblique on the right side of back of
trunk, its inner extent in midline and 20.5cm below top of
shoulder.
8. Abrasion 2.5x0.2cm on the right side of back of trunk,
vertical, its upper extent, 7cm outer to midline and 17.5cm
below top of shoulder.
9. Abrasion 1.5x0.5cm, on the right side of back of trunk 4cm
outer to and 4.5cm below root of neck.
10. Abrasion 2x0.3cm on the left side of back of trunk 2cm
outer to midline and 17.5cm below top of shoulder.
11. Abrasion 2x0.2cm on the left side of back of trunk 2cm
outer to midline and 37cm below top of shoulder.”
It was opined by PW9 in her evidence that the cause of death
was due to injury 1 involving chest and abdomen and that the
same could be caused by using a sharp edged weapon. It was
clarified by PW9 in her evidence that injuries 6 to 11 could be
caused in a backward fall.
14.
PW7 was the Assistant Engineer attached to
the electrical section within whose jurisdiction, the house of
the appellant falls. PW7 deposed that the deceased, Studymon
and PW1 were the staff in his office and that they were on
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 15 :-
2025:KER:11364
disconnection duty on 26.04.2008. PW13 was the Station
House Officer attached to Pallithottam Police Station from
17.01.2008. PW13 deposed that it was he who recorded
Ext.P15 First Information Statement of Studymon. It was
deposed by PW13 that Studymon left the signature column
blank in the First Information Statement. It was deposed by
PW13 that he conducted a search on the same day in the
house of the appellant and seized MO1 knife which was found
kept on the top of an almirah. PW14 was the police officer who
conducted the substantial part of the investigation in the case.
It was deposed by PW14 that he arrested the appellant on
17.05.2008 and seized a pair of pants and a shirt from the
house of the appellant as per Ext.P12 mahazar. PW15 was
another police officer who took over the investigation in the
case from PW14 and submitted the final report. It was PW15
who tendered formal proof of the report of the Forensic Science
Laboratory which is marked in the proceedings as Ext.P35.
15.
It is based on the evidence discussed above
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 16 :-
2025:KER:11364
that the Court of Session came to the conclusion that the
prosecution has established the charges against the accused
beyond reasonable doubt. As noted, it is a case where the
prosecution has relied on the oral evidence of PWs 1 to 3 to
prove the guilt of the accused. The remaining witnesses were
cited and examined only for corroborating the evidence of PWs
1 to 3. As noted, the main contention of the appellant is that
the evidence tendered by the ocular witnesses is not reliable
and trustworthy. Let us, therefore, consider the sustainability of
the said contention.
16.
Although PW3, the auto-rickshaw driver gave
evidence more or less on similar lines as the evidence
tendered by PWs 1 and 2, in cross-examination, PW3 admitted
that he had not disclosed in the statement given to the
Magistrate under Section 164 of the Code that he saw the
appellant stabbing anyone with the knife. The relevant portion
of the deposition of PW3 reads thus:
“Magistrate-ന മ ഴ മ
ടകമ
ൾ
ഞ ൻ പറഞ ട ല. അത ഓർ കറവ മ
ണ
ത മ
ക .”
ണ പത ആമ മ ങ ല കത ത
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 17 :-
2025:KER:11364
The omission of PW3 in the statement recorded under Section
164 of the Code that he saw the appellant inflicting any stab
injury
on
the
deceased
would
amount
to
a
material
contradiction and in the light of the said contradiction, we do
not find it safe to place reliance on that part of the evidence
tendered by PW3.
17.
The evidence tendered by PW7, the Assistant
Engineer of KSEB within whose jurisdiction the house of the
appellant falls, reveals that, PW1 was the overseer who
accompanied the deceased and Studymon on the relevant day
to disconnect the power supply of defaulters. In the light of the
evidence tendered by PW1, he was not present at the scene of
occurrence at the time when the altercation took place. But,
going by the evidence of PW7, the presence of PW1
somewhere in the vicinity of the house of the appellant, cannot
be doubted. The version of PW1 was that after disconnecting
power supply to the house of the sister of the appellant, he left
the company of Studymon and the deceased to attend to the
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 18 :-
2025:KER:11364
maintenance work of a street light and that he went to the
scene of occurrence only on hearing a commotion and it was at
that point of time that he saw the occurrence. The question,
therefore, is whether PW1 could see the occurrence.
18.
One of the arguments
advanced by the
learned counsel for the appellant is that the evidence of PW1
that he had previous acquaintance with the appellant cannot
be believed in the light of the previous statement given by
PW1 to the police which is marked as Ext.D1 contradiction and
that therefore the rest of his evidence also cannot be believed.
True, PW1 deposed in court that he had previous acquaintance
with the appellant, and in Ext.D1, what was stated by him was
that he came to know of the name of the appellant from those
who gathered at the scene at the time of occurrence. Merely
for the reason that PW1 came to know of the name of the
appellant only from those who gathered at the scene at the
time of occurrence, it cannot be said that he had no previous
acquaintance with the appellant. As such, the argument that in
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 19 :-
2025:KER:11364
the light of Ext.D1 contradiction, the entire evidence tendered
by PW1 has to be rejected, cannot be accepted.
19.
It is seen that PW1 has stated in cross-
examination that it was PW15 who recorded his previous
statement for the first time and that it was about three to four
months after the occurrence. The relevant portion of the
deposition reads thus:
"അമന&ഷണ ഉമ*+ ഗസന CW26 മ.വ+ർ എന വമ . ഭവത ന 3, 4 . ഴ ഞ
അമ2ഹത മ4 office ൽ വച ണ
ണത. അമ2ഹ ണ എമ4 മ ഴ ആ*+
മ ഖമ8ടത ത .”
Placing reliance on the said evidence, it was vehemently
argued by the learned counsel for the appellant that inasmuch
as the previous statement of PW1 was recorded several
months after the occurrence, it is not safe to place reliance on
the evidence tendered by PW1. We do not find any merit in this
argument, as the materials on record reveal that the previous
statement of PW1 was recorded on 27.04.2008 itself, the day
following the date of the occurrence and Ext.D1 contradiction
is the portion of the said statement. Needless to say, what was
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 20 :-
2025:KER:11364
deposed by PW1 as extracted above is a mistake on his part.
20.
Another argument advanced by the learned
counsel for the appellant is that the deposition of PW1 that it
was he who took the deceased to the hospital, is false. The
said argument is advanced since what is recorded in Ext.P2
wound certificate is that it was the subordinates of the victim
who took him to the hospital and if PW1 were to be the person
who took the deceased to the hospital being a superior officer,
Ext.P2 would not have contained an endorsement that it was
the subordinates who took the victim to the hospital. We do not
find any merit in this argument also. Merely for the reason that
there is an endorsement in Ext.P2 that it was the subordinates
of the deceased who took him to the hospital, it cannot be said
that PW1 was not present with the deceased when he was
taken to the hospital. When an unexpected and untoward
incident of the present nature takes place, it is only natural
that
several
persons
working
with
the
injured
would
accompany him to the hospital and the doctor who examines
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 21 :-
2025:KER:11364
the injured is not expected to record the names of all who
accompanied the injured, as his priority at that point of time is
to save the life of the injured.
21.
Another argument advanced by the learned
counsel for the appellant is that PW1 was a person who was
present at the time of inquest and had he seen the occurrence
as claimed by him, his statement would have certainly been
recorded by the officer who held the inquest, and inasmuch as
the statement of PW1 has not been recorded by the officer who
held the inquest, it has to be taken that PW1 had not witnessed
the occurrence. Ext.P1 is the inquest report. PW1 is a witness
to Ext.P1 inquest report. The statement of PW1 is not seen
recorded at the time of holding the inquest. Instead, the
statement of some others, including the brother of the
deceased were seen recorded then. Merely for the reason that
the statement of PW1 was not recorded at the time of holding
the inquest, it cannot be inferred straightaway that PW1 had
not seen the occurrence. Needless to say, we do not find any
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 22 :-
2025:KER:11364
reason at all to disbelieve the evidence tendered by PW1.
22.
Let us now deal with the evidence of PW2. The
facts that PW2 is a person residing in the neighbourhood of the
appellant
and
that he
is
a
person
who
had
previous
acquaintance with the appellant, are not seen disputed. The
arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant
as regards the evidence tendered by PW2 are that he is a
person who is partially blind and that he was also a person who
maintained a strained relationship with the appellant on
account of a case between the appellant and the son of PW2
namely, Nixon. According to the learned counsel, no reliance
can, therefore, be placed on the evidence of PW2. We do not
find any merit in this contention. It has come out in evidence
that the occurrence took place almost seven years before the
date on which PW2 gave evidence in the case. What was
stated by PW2 in cross-examination is that he has only limited
vision for the past three to four years and that he has severe
short-sightedness. There is nothing on record to indicate that
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 23 :-
2025:KER:11364
PW2 was suffering from any vision impairment at the time of
occurrence. Similarly, it has come out in evidence that the case
between his son Nixon and the appellant was closed on a
compromise. In the circumstances, we do not find any
impediment in placing reliance on the evidence of PW2. Of
course, there is a minor inconsistency in the evidence tendered
by PW2 as regards the occurrence that before inflicting the
stab injuries, the appellant had also beat the deceased with
the crutch. PW1 does not have such a case. Having regard to
the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, we are
of the view that the said inconsistency in the evidence of PW2
is not sufficient to disbelieve him in toto.
23.
As noted, it was deposed by PW2 in his
evidence that the appellant is a person who cannot stand
without a crutch. Another argument advanced by the learned
counsel for the appellant is that it is, therefore, not possible for
the appellant to attack the deceased in the manner alleged by
the prosecution. We do not agree. The appellant has produced
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 24 :-
2025:KER:11364
a photograph in the appeal in support of an application
preferred by him to suspend the execution of the sentence
against him. Having regard to the photograph, we cannot
accept the argument that it is impossible for the appellant to
attack a person as alleged by the prosecution in the case.
24.
Ext.P35
report
of
the
Forensic
Science
Laboratory, Thiruvananthapuram reveals that blood was not
found on MO1 knife. The argument raised in this context is that
MO1 cannot, therefore, be regarded as the weapon that was
used to inflict stab injuries on the deceased. According to the
learned counsel, the case of the prosecution has to fail on that
sole ground. We are unable to agree. Merely for the reason that
the Forensic Science Laboratory could not find blood on MO1, it
cannot be inferred straightaway that MO1 was not the weapon
used, especially when the weapon was not one seized from the
scene of occurrence, but seized hours after the occurrence
from a place inside the house of the appellant. We do not find
any merit in the argument aforesaid also for the reason that it
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 25 :-
2025:KER:11364
is now trite that recovery of the weapon used in the
commission of the offence is not a sine qua non to convict the
accused [See Rakesh v. State of U.P., (2021) 7 SCC 188].
25.
In short, we find that the evidence tendered by
PW1 and PW2 is reliable and trustworthy. True, Studymon left
the signature column blank in the First Information Statement.
It is
of
no consequence whether
the First Information
Statement contains the signature of the informant [See
Surendra Pal v. State of U.P., (2010) 9 SCC 399]. The evidence
tendered by PWs 1 and 2 is corroborated by Ext.P15 First
Information Statement. That apart, the oral evidence of the
said witnesses has been corroborated by the medical evidence
tendered by PWs 4, 8 and 9 also.
26.
The appellant has no case that the evidence
tendered by PWs 1 and 2 do not make out the offences
charged. In other words, the finding rendered by the Court of
Session
that
the
prosecution
has
established
beyond
reasonable doubt, the guilt of the appellant for the offences
Crl.Appeal No.809 of 2017
-: 26 :-
2025:KER:11364
punishable under Sections 302, 333, 353 and 341 IPC, is in
order.
The appeal, in the circumstances, is devoid of
merits and the same is accordingly dismissed.
Sd/P.B.SURESH KUMAR, JUDGE.
Sd/JOBIN SEBASTIAN, JUDGE.
ds 05.02.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review