Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 05.05.2026
LPA 451/2013
YOGINDER SHARMA
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. H. K. Chaturvedi, Mrs. Anjali
Chaturvedi and Mr. Sagar Chaturvedi,
Advs.
versus
THE MANAGEMENT OF M/S ARAVALI LEASING LTD.
.....Respondent
Through: None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
1.
This intra Court appeal lays a challenge to the order dated 02.04.2013
passed by the learned Single Judge whereby the writ petition was dismissed.
The challenge in this appeal is primarily to an award made by the Labour
Court-01, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in ID No.489/1992, whereby the
Labour Court answered against the appellant with respect to his termination.
2.
The facts as noted are that the appellant was terminated on
27.09.1988, on the purported ground of misconduct. The case of the
appellant before the Labour Court was that the termination is in violation of
the principles of natural justice.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
3.
The learned Single Judge noted that the respondent/management
established the charge against the appellant before the Labour Court and the
witnesses produced by the respondent/management were cross-examined on
behalf of the appellant. The learned Single Judge also noted that the Labour
Court after analyzing the evidence concluded that the alleged misconduct
was that the appellant has not obeyed the directions given by the
respondent/management to collect the payment from customers of the
respondent, which was part of his duty. On the basis of the evidence, the
Labour Court concluded that the charge against the appellant is proved,
which resulted in an award whereby the Labour Court had answered in
favour of the respondent/management.
4.
In the writ petition various submissions were advanced including the
violation of principles of natural justice, the penalty being disproportionate
and that, even if the management had proved the charge before the Labour
Court, the appellant shall be entitled to the back wages from the date of
termination till the date of award.
5.
The learned Single Judge answered all the submissions made on
behalf of the appellant in the impugned order, in the following manner:“19. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, considered
the impugned award, the record, and the respective
submissions, I am of the view that there is no merit in this
petition and the same is liable to be dismissed. I have set out
hereinabove the submissions made by both counsel with regard
to the evidence brought on record by the parties, on the basis of
which the finding of guilt has been returned against the
petitioner by the Industrial Tribunal. The purpose of extracting
the relevant part of the evidence of the management and the
respective submissions of the parties is to demonstrate that the
present is not a case of “no evidence”. It is also not a case
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
where the finding of guilt can be said to be contrary to the
evidence brought on record. Though the management’s
witnesses may not have substantiated the allegations beyond
those which are contained in the termination order, so far as
the allegations contained in the termination order are
concerned, they stand substantiated and proved on the basis of
the evidence of the parties. I may set out herein below the
discussion in the impugned Award – analyzing the evidence led
by the parties, on the basis of which the learned Industrial
Adjudicator has arrived at the find of guilt against the
Petitioner. The same reads as follows:
“8. The main witness of the management Shri
H.P.Lakhotia deposed in support of the charges in his
affidavit Ex.MW2/A that on 27.09.88, the claimant
committed indiscipline by not complying with his
order/instructions as refused to collect the deposits from
Bahadurgarh which was a part of his duty being done in
routine within and outside Delhi i.e. collection of
deposits and other payments on behalf/account of the
company. The witness also proved the bills of the
expenses incurred by the claimant as Annexures A & B
and the payment vouchers made to the claimant vide
Annexures C & D for collection of deposits within and
outside Delhi.
9. This witness further deposed that claimant used
abusive language in indecent behaviour in the office.
Earlier also, the claimant had committed act of in
subordination and indiscipline and he was let off after
warning. The witness also deposed that during
conciliation proceedings, the claimant was offered to
join the company but he failed to do so. In support of the
deposition of Shri Lakhotia, another witness of the
management Shri D.K.Bhalla also deposed that
claimant used to use abusive language and caused
insubordination in the office who was working as
General Dealing Clerk and used to collect deposits on
behalf of the management within and outside Delhi. He
also corroborated that on 27.09.88, when he was asked
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
by Shri Lakhotia to collect deposits from Bahadurgarh,
the claimant refused and as such caused
insubordination leading to termination of his service.
Similarly, MW4 Shri Yogeshwar Datt Vats deposed in
corroboration of testimony of other witnesses. However,
there is substance in the submissions by Ld. A.R. for the
claimant and MW3 has not supported the case/charges
while MW4 added without corroboration that claimant
had also abused Shri D.K.Bhalla in his presence.
10. Regarding past conduct of the claimant, Shri
Lakhotia admitted during his cross-examination that
incident dated 27.09.88 was the first and last incident
with him when the workman refused to carry on his
instructions. Further he was not able to remember
whether prior to termination of services, the claimant
had committed any act of insubordination or
indiscipline.
11. In fact, the defence of the claimant as put to this
witness was that he had gone to collect the dues on the
day of incident as per the instructions and never
refused. The claimant in fact has taken contradictory
stand as it was not so suggested to MW1 Shri
D.K.Bhalla that claimant went to collect the dues and
never refused to obey the instructions. It is also not a
case of the claimant in his affidavit wherein the
claimant‟s case was that his services were terminated
on 27.09.88 on account of demand of enhancement in
the salary and false charge of indiscipline leveled vide
termination letter dated 27.9.88. The claimant admitted
that he was maintaining dispatch register and was also
going to bank to deposit cheques etc, however, he
denied during cross-examination that he was ever sent
to make collection of the dues.
12. On the face of contradictions and the submissions
made by the claimant that it was not part of his duty to
collect payment from the customers for the
company/management, the management is able to prove
the charges against the claimant as per evidence
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
adduced by the management on charge. The claimant
also admitted that he had refused to accept the cheque
dated 27.9.88 which was given to him along with letter
of even date i.e. Ex.WW1/M24 which contains the
charges against him.”
20. The purpose of setting out the respective submissions is also
to demonstrate that the endeavour of the petitioner is to require
this Court to reappreciate the evidence, as if this Court is
sitting in appeal over the impugned award. However, ld.
Counsel has not been able to point out any perversity, or
fundamental error of approach in the impugned Award. It is
well-settled that this Court-while exercising power of judicial
review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, in respect
of an order passed by a Tribunal, does not sit in appeal and it
is not for this Court to re-appreciate the evidence on merits.
Consequently, the finding of guilt returned by the Labour Court
does not call for interference by this Court in exercise of writ
jurisdiction.
21. Learned counsels have made substantial arguments on the
second plea of the petitioner, i.e., with regard to the date from
which the termination order should take effect. The submission
of the petitioner is that because the respondent management did
not hold any domestic inquiry whatsoever before issuing the
letter of termination dated 27.09.1988 and the inquiry was
conducted for the first time before the Labour Court and, on
that basis, the termination order has attained legality, the date
of termination should be taken as date of the award and the
petitioner should have been held as entitled to pay &
allowances up to the date of the award, i.e., 06.11.2003. The
petitioner has sought to place reliance on Gujarat Steel Tubes
Ltd. (supra) in support of this submission.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
28. Reliance placed by Mr. Chaturvedi on Prem Chand (supra)
is of no avail since this decision proceeds on the basis of
Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. (supra), which has been held to be per
incuriam, as aforesaid, and the decision in the later decision in
R. Thiruvirkolam (supra) was not brought to the notice of the
Division Bench when it rendered its decision in Prem Chand
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
(supra). The argument of Mr. Chaturvedi that Gujarat Steel
Tubes Ltd. (supra) being a decision of three Hon’ble Judges,
whereas the decision in R. Thiruvirkolam (supra) being a
decision of two Hon’ble Judges, the decision in Gujarat Steel
Tubes Ltd. (supra) should be followed by this Court, has no
merit. This is for the reason that the Supreme Court while
deciding R. Thiruvirkolam (supra) has examined all the
relevant decisions on the subject including Gujarat Steel Tubes
Ltd. (supra) in the light of the Constitution Bench judgment in
Kalyani (supra) and has concluded that Gujarat Steel Tubes
Ltd. (supra) is per incuriam. That being the position it is not for
this Court to disregard the later decision in R. Thiruvirkolam
(supra). Consequently, the decision in Devender Roy (supra)
has no application in the facts of the present case.
29. There is yet another aspect that needs to be taken note of.
The employer has two options while dealing with delinquent
workman. The employer may serve a charge-sheet on the
delinquent workman, hold a departmental inquiry and then take
disciplinary action against the workman. Alternatively, it may
take disciplinary action against the workman on the basis of the
misconduct which it may attribute to the workman. In the first
case, if an industrial dispute is raised and the punishment is
questioned, the Industrial Adjudicator would firstly determine
the issue with regard to the validity of the domestic inquiry. If
the domestic inquiry is found to be in compliance with the
principles of natural justice, and the applicable rules, the
Industrial Adjudicator would examine whether the findings
returned in the domestic inquiry are perverse, or not. The scope
of the examination undertaken by the Industrial Adjudicator in
relation to the domestic inquiryonce it is held to be in
compliance of the principles of natural justice and validly held,
is limited. The Industrial Adjudicator does not sit as a Court of
appeal. Therefore, unless the findings returned in the domestic
inquiry are perverse, the Industrial Adjudicator does not
interfere with the same. Even if the Industrial Adjudicator
would have come to a different conclusion on the appreciation
of the evidence on record, it is no ground for the Industrial
Adjudicator to interfere with the findings reached in the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
domestic enquiry, if the view taken by the Inquiry Officer is a
plausible view.
30. In the situation where the domestic inquiry is not held at
all, and the delinquent workman is punished by the
management without such an inquiry, but is later or
simultaneously made aware of the charges against him, the
management consciously takes the decision that in case the
workman raises an industrial dispute, it would have to establish
the charge before the Industrial Adjudicator by leading
evidence. Therefore, the management by straightaway taking
disciplinary action against the delinquent workman conveys its
willingness to establish the charge before the Industrial
Adjudicator. The scope of the inquiry before the Industrial
Adjudicator in this eventuality is much wider, since the
Industrial Adjudicator decides for itself whether, or not, the
charge is established by the management.
31. The second situation, i.e., where no prior inquiry is held
before the delinquent workman is punished, would be a
situation which places the delinquent workman in a more
advantageous position inasmuch, as, the inquiry is conducted
before an independent judicial officer and not in-house by the
employer-where the scope of interference by the Industrial
Adjudicator is somewhat limited. In my view, there is no reason
why a management-which is willing to prove the charge before
an Industrial Court, rather than resort to an in-house inquiry,
should be burdened with payment of wages up to the date of the
award even when the charge against the delinquent workman
stands proved before the Industrial Court.
32. Lastly, the submission of Mr. Chaturvedi that the
punishment of dismissal from service was not justified, even if
the charges are assumed to be proved, may be examined. The
order of dismissal makes allegations of indiscipline and
negligence on the part of the petitioner. Indiscipline has been
attributed on account of non-compliance of the instructions by
the petitioner of his senior Mr. H.P. Lakhotia, who had asked
the petitioner to collect deposit from Bahadurgarh on account
of the company. This charge stands duly proved. This charge,
by itself, is serious enough to warrant dismissal from service.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
Refusal by workman to obey the orders given to him which fall
within the scope of his duties clearly tantamounts to
insubordination. Such insubordination strikes at the very root
of the employer and employee relationship, as the employee is
duty bound to obey lawful and justified instructions of the
employer. If the employee does not obey orders of the
management which are legitimately given, and is still allowed
to continue in employment, the same would completely destroy
and vitiate the atmosphere in the industry. It would breed
indiscipline, insubordination and make it impossible for the
industry to thrive. Others would be encouraged to adopt such
conduct without fear of termination. It would adversely affect
the interest of the larger body of workmen who believe in
disciplined conduct, as the industry would suffer due to the
misconduct of a handful of indisciplined workmen. Such
indiscipline should certainly invite the punishment of dismissal
from service. The said punishment cannot be said to be
unjustified or disproportionate.”
6.
Mr. H. K. Chaturvedi, learned counsel for the appellant makes
identical submissions as were advanced before the learned Single Judge.
7.
Insofar as, the submission of Mr. Chaturvedi that the termination was
in violation of the principles of natural justice is concerned, the
respondent/management having examined the witnesses, and proved the
charge against the appellant before the Labour Court, the plea that the
termination was in violation of the principles of natural justice is clearly
unsustainable.
8.
This we say so for the reason that, even assuming that the initial
termination was contrary to the principles of natural justice, the management
has produced the witnesses and proved the charge against the appellant
through the process known to law in conformity with the principles of
natural justice before the Labour Court resulting in the termination. As such,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
the plea of Mr. Chaturvedi cannot be accepted.
9.
On the aspect of proportionality, the learned Single Judge clearly held
that, given the nature of charge alleged against the appellant, the penalty of
termination would be justified. We agree with the said conclusion drawn by
the learned Single Judge for the reason that part of the duty of the appellant
was to collect money from the clients of the company and the refusal of the
appellant to obey the orders given by the respondent/management, depicts
insubordination on the part of the appellant.
10.
Another submission of Mr. Chaturvedi is that the initial termination
having been found contrary to the principles of natural justice and the
respondent/management having proved the charge only before the Labour
Court, the appellant shall be entitled to the back wages from the day of the
termination till the award.
11.
The said submission does not appeal us for the simple reason that the
issue is covered by the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case R.
Thiruvirkolam v. Presiding Officer and Another, (1997) 1 Supreme Court
Cases 9, wherein the Supreme Court has in paragraph nos. 4 and 13, held as
under:“4. Reference may be made first to the decision in Kalyani
[(1964) 2 SCR 104 : AIR 1963 SC 1756 : (1963) 1 LLJ 679] .
This point arose directly before the Constitution Bench and
such a contention was rejected, making a distinction between a
case where no domestic inquiry had been held and another in
which the inquiry is defective for any reason and the Labour
Court on its own appraisal of evidence adduced before it
reaches the conclusion that the dismissal was justified. It was
held that in a case where the inquiry was found to be defective
by the Labour Court and it then came to the conclusion on its
own appraisal of evidence adduced before it that the dismissal
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
was justified, the order of dismissal made by the employer in a
defective inquiry would still relate to the date when that order
was made. In that decision it was stated thus: (SCR pp. 113-14)
“… If the inquiry is defective for any reason, the Labour
Court would also have to consider for itself on the
evidence adduced before it whether the dismissal was
justified. However, on coming to the conclusion on its
own appraisal of evidence adduced before it that the
dismissal was justified its approval of the order of
dismissal made by the employer in a defective inquiry
would still relate back to the date when the order was
made. … In the present case an inquiry has been held
which is said to be defective in one respect and
dismissal has been ordered. The respondent had
however to justify the order of dismissal before the
Labour Court in view of the defect in the inquiry. It has
succeeded in doing so and therefore the approval of the
Labour Court will relate back to the date on which the
respondent passed the order of dismissal. The
contention of the appellant therefore that dismissal in
this case should take effect from the date from which the
Labour Court's award came into operation must fail.”
In our opinion, the authoritative pronouncement by the
Constitution Bench in Kalyani [(1964) 2 SCR 104 : AIR 1963
SC 1756 : (1963) 1 LLJ 679] puts the matter beyond doubt.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
13. As a result of the aforesaid decision it must be held that the
only point involved for decision in the appeal is concluded
against the appellant by the Constitution Bench decision of this
Court in Kalyani [(1964) 2 SCR 104 : AIR 1963 SC 1756 :
(1963) 1 LLJ 679] and the observations to the contrary in
Gujarat Steel [(1980) 2 SCC 593 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 197 :
(1980) 2 SCR 146] are, therefore, per incuriam and not
binding. The order of punishment in the present case operated
from 18-11-1981 when it was made by the employer and not
from 11-12-1985, the date of Labour Court's award. The
appellant is, therefore, not entitled to any relief.”
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
12.
Suffice to state, the said judgment was also considered by the learned
Single Judge to hold that the appellant is not entitled to the back wages. In
view of the above, the submission made by Mr. Chaturvedi is unmerited.
13.
We are of the view that the learned Single Judge was justified in
dismissing the writ petition. Accordingly, this appeal being without any
merit is dismissed.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
MAY 05, 2026/rk
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:17:45
LPA 451/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review