The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. Prima-facie, it appears that cases of the petitioners are covered by Inder Singh Thakur (supra), however, factual aspects are required to be examined by the competent authority. Hence, the present writ petition is allowed. Impugned office order dated
09. 12.2025 (Annexure P-7) is quashed and set aside qua the petitioners. This shall be subject to costs of Rs.10,000/- to be deposited with the “Indira Gandhi Hospital, Shimla, Poor Patient Treatment Fund Account.” A/C Name Poor Patient Treatment Fund, A/C No. 34256228603, IFSC Code SBIN0004054 at SBI IGMC, Shimla.
9. Respondent No.3/Competent Authority is directed to consider and decide the respective cases of the petitioners for grant of benefits under the Revised Pay Scale Rules, 2022, strictly in consonance with Inder Singh Thakur (supra) and in accordance with law, within a period of four weeks from today. The order so passed, be also communicated to the petitioners. The writ petition stands disposed of in the above terms, so also the pending miscellaneous application(s), if any January 08 , 2026 (sunil) (Sandeep Sharma), Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.499 of 2026
Date of Decision: 08.01.2026
_____________________________________________________________________
Yogesh Kumar & Ors.
……...Petitioners
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
…....Respondents
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Kush Sharma & Mr. Abhishek Thakur,
Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar,
Additional Advocates General with Mr. Ravi
Chauhan & Mr. Anish Banshtu, Deputy
Advocates General.
___________________________________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, J. (Oral)
Notice. Mr. Rajan Kahol, learned Additional Advocate
General, appears and waives service of notice on behalf of the
respondents.
2.
Taking into consideration the order impugned herein,
decision rendered in CWP No.4830 of 2023, titled as Inder Singh
Thakur & Ors Vs. State of H.P. & Ors. along with connected
matters, decided on 07.04.2025, submissions made by learned
counsel for the parties and the order being passed hereinafter, reply to
this writ petition is not required to be called from the respondents.
With consent of learned counsel for the parties, matter is heard at this
stage.
3.
Petitioners had instituted CWP No.14948 of 2025, titled as
Yogesh Kumar and others Vs. State of H.P. and others, seeking
applicability of Inder Singh Thakur
(supra). The writ petition was
disposed of on 16.09.2025 with directions to the respondents to
consider the representations of the petitioners in light of Inder Singh
Thakur (supra) by passing appropriate orders in accordance with law
within a time frame.
Pursuant to the directions issued in Yogesh Kumar
4.
(supra), respondents passed consideration order on 09.12.2025
(Annexure P-7), rejecting the cases of the petitioners. According to the
respondents, petitioners had completed two years of regular service on
01.04.2020, respectively. They were granted revised Pay Band + Grade
Pay in compliance to the H.P. Civil Services (Category/Postwise
Revised Pay) Rules, 2012, therefore, petitioners were not held entitled
to the benefits flowing from Revised Pay Scale, 2022 notified on
06.09.2022.
5.
The aforesaid reasoning has already been turned down in
Inder Singh Thakur
(supra). Paras from Inder Singh Thakur
(supra), relevant in the context of reasoning given by the respondents
for rejecting the cases of the petitioners, are as under:4(iv). The notification dated 03.01.2022 promulgating the
Revised Pay Rules, 2022 w.e.f. 01.01.2016, does not stipulate that
those who were appointed on regular basis prior to 03.01.2022, are to
be excluded from the purview of the said notification. In fact, Rule 7 of
the Revised Pay Rules, 2022, notified on 03.01.2022 provides the
mechanism for fixation of pay in the revised pay structure. Rule 7(I)
provides
for
fixation
of
pay
of
Government
employees
recruited/appointed before 01.01.2016, whereas Rule 7(II) of the
notification dated 03.01.2022 provides for fixation of pay of regular
Government employees recruited/appointed on or after 01.01.2016 till
the date of issuance of the notification. Rule 7 of notification dated
03.01.2022 promulgating Revised Pay Rules, 2022, being relevant is
extracted hereinafter….XXXXXXXXXXXXX
Services of petitioners having been regularized during the year 2019 &
2020 fall within the ambit of Revised Pay Rules, 2022.
In view of clear provisions of Revised Pay Rules, 2022, notified on
03.01.2022, as amended on 06.09.2022, the stand of the respondents
that notification dated 03.01.2022 and more specifically its amendment
under notification dated 06.09.2022 will not be applicable to those
employees who were in regular service prior to 03.01.2022, cannot be
countenanced. Mechanism for fixing the revised pay of the regular
Government employees recruited/appointed before 01.01.2016 has
been provided under Rule 7(1), whereas fixation of pay of regular
Government employees recruited/appointed on or after 01.01.2016 is to
be carried out as per Rule 7(II) of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022 notified
on 03.01.2022 as amended on 06.09.2022. It cannot be construed from
the notifications that Revised Pay Rules, 2022 (as amended) will not be
applicable to those who were appointed and whose services were
regularized prior to the date of issuance of notification dated
03.01.2022 as amended on 06.09.2022.
4(v). The other contention of learned Deputy Advocate General that
since the petitioners’ pay had undergone revision in the year 2012
under a notification issued on 27.09.2012, they are not entitled for the
benefit of higher pay under the notifications dated 03.01.2022 and
06.09.2022, also lacks merit.
Under the notification dated 03.01.2022 while determining the revised
pay of the regular Government employees recruited/appointed before
01.01.2016, due regard has been given to the Re-Revision of pay-scale
carried out in the year 2012. Rule 7, more particularly Rules 7(1)(b) and
7(II)(b) of the Revised Pay Rules 2022 notified on 03.01.2022 cater to
these situations and offset the impact of Re-Revision while assessing
the corresponding revised pay-scales under the Revised Pay Rules,
2022. The Revised Pay Rules, 2022 do not bar the applicability of these
Rules in case of those employees, who have been granted benefit of pay
revision of the year 2012 under notification dated 27.09.2012. Rather,
the Revised Pay Rules, 2022 take into account the impact of the revision
of scales in 2012 and then determine the mechanism for coming over to
the corresponding revised scale under Revised Pay Rules, 2022.
Petitioners, therefore, cannot be deprived from the applicability of
Revised Pay Rules, 2022, only on count of their pay having undergone
revision in terms of 2012 revision of pay-scales.
4(vi). Respondents’ contention that notification dated 06.09.2022
amending the Revised Pay Rules, 2022, is not applicable to the
petitioners, is without substance. The notification dated 06.09.2022
granting higher stages of pay to certain categories of posts is an
amendment carried out by the respondents to the Revised Pay Rules,
2022 notified on 03.01.2022. Rule 2 of the amendment notification
dated 06.09.2022 inserted following Rule 7(A) in the Revised Pay Rules,
2022:-
“2.
Insertion of
Rules 7(A).-
In the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services
(Revised Pay) Rules, 2022, after Rule 7,
the following shall be inserted, namely:7(A). Fixation
categories.-
of
pay
of
certain
(1)
This rule shall apply to the
employees, who are appointed
before 3rd January, 2022.
(2)
The pay of employee of
those categories/posts included in
Schedule-II shall be fixed at
higher pay stage in the concerned
level
of
pay
matrix
after
completion of two years regular
service as given in Schedule-II.”
7(A). Fixation of pay of certain categories:(1) This rule shall apply to the employees, who are
appointed before 3rd January, 2022.
(2) The pay of employee of those categories/posts
included in Schedule-II shall be fixed at higher pay stage
in the concerned level of pay matrix after completion of
two years regular service as given in Schedule-II.”
By virtue of following Rule 1(2) of the notification dated
06.09.2022, the above rule is to be deemed to have into force on
03.01.2022:-
“1
Short title and
Commencement
(1)
(2)
These rules may be called
the Himachal Pradesh Civil
Services (Revised Pay) First
Amendment Rules, 2022
They shall be deemed to have
come into force on 3rd
January, 2022.”
The newly added Rule 7(A) fixed the pay of certain categories of
posts at higher stages as per the Schedule appended with the
notification. At Serial No.31 of the Schedule is the category of
School Lecturers/PGT to which the petitioners belong. As per the
Schedule,
an
incumbent
upon
appointment
as
School
Lecturers/PGT is to be given Rs.43,000/- and Rs.47,000/- on
completion of two years of regular service. Rule 7(A) is
applicable to those employees, who were appointed before
03.01.2022. The Schedule reads as under:-
It is not understandable as to how the respondents are denying the
applicability of notification dated 06.09.2022 to the petitioners only on
the ground that their services were regularized prior to issuance of
notification dated 03.01.2022.
4(vii). Rule 7(A) inserted by amendment in the Revised Pay Rules, 2022,
under the amendment notification dated 06.09.2022 has become part &
parcel of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022, notified on 03.01.2022.
Therefore, when the main Rules do not discriminate employees upon
their acquiring regular status and are applicable to all regular
employees subject to their respective & individual dates of attaining the
eligibility for the benefits flowing from Revised Pay Rules, 2022, then
the benefits of Rule 7(A) are also to be similarly accorded to the regular
employees. There cannot be situations in given facts where incumbents
belonging to one category are to receive different pay scales. The
employees, who have become regular after 03.01.2022 are also to get
benefits of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022, including Rule 7(A) upon their
fulfilling the stipulated conditions. Thus, the petitioners on completing
two years of regular service are to be released revised pay scale as per
Rule 7(A) of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022.
Even if Rule 7(A) of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022, is to be read
independently of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022, which seems to be the
misplaced contention of the State, then also the petitioners are entitled
to the benefit of Rule 7(A). As in such situation also, it has to be held
that Rule 7(A) does not place any embargo upon flow of benefits under
it to the regular employees. The words used in Rule 7(A) pertaining to its
applicability are “employees who are appointed before 03.01.2022,”
without making any distinction between date of completion of two years
of regular service. Revised Pay Rules, 2022, therefore, become
applicable and higher stage of pay provided under Rule 7(A) is to be
released upon completing requisite number of years of regular service.
5. In view of above discussion, notification dated 03.01.2022
promulgating the H.P. Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2022 and
notification dated 06.09.2022 amending the Revised Pay Rules, 2022,
are held applicable to the petitioners. This writ petition is allowed.
Respondents are directed to extend the benefit of notifications dated
03.01.2022 and 06.09.2022 to the petitioners. Their pay be accordingly
re-fixed from due dates and consequential benefits be granted in favour
of the petitioners in accordance with law and aforesaid notifications.
This exercise be carried out within four weeks from today.”
6.
Inder Singh Thakur (supra) has already held that
notification dated 03.01.2022 promulgating the revised pay Rules,
2022, w.e.f. 01.01.2016, does not stipulate that those who were
appointed on regular basis prior to 03.01.2022 are to be excluded
from the purview of the said notification. That Rule 7 of the Revised
Pay Rules, notified on 03.01.2022, provides the mechanism for
fixation of pay in the revised pay structure for fixing pay of the
Government employee recruited/appointed before 01.01.2016 as also
on or after 01.01.2016 till the issuance of the notification.
7.
The respondents’ stand that revised pay Rules 2022, (as
amended) will not been applicable to those who were appointed and
whose services were regularized prior to the date of issuance of
notification dated 03.01.2022, as amended on 06.09.2022, was
rejected.
8.
Prima-facie, it appears that cases of the petitioners are
covered by Inder Singh Thakur (supra), however, factual aspects are
required to be examined by the competent authority. Hence, the
present writ petition is allowed. Impugned office order dated
09.12.2025 (Annexure P-7) is quashed and set aside qua the
petitioners. This shall be subject to costs of Rs.10,000/- to be
deposited with the “Indira Gandhi Hospital, Shimla, Poor Patient
Treatment Fund Account.”
A/C Name Poor Patient Treatment Fund,
A/C No. 34256228603,
IFSC Code SBIN0004054 at SBI IGMC, Shimla.
9.
Respondent No.3/Competent Authority is directed to
consider and decide the respective cases of the petitioners for grant of
benefits under the Revised Pay Scale Rules, 2022, strictly in
consonance with Inder Singh Thakur (supra) and in accordance with
law, within a period of four weeks from today. The order so passed, be
also communicated to the petitioners.
The writ petition stands disposed of in the above terms, so
also the pending miscellaneous application(s), if any
January 08 , 2026
(sunil)
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review