Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 06.11.2025
Date of decision: 03.02.2026
Date of uploading: 05.02.2026
+
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
YANGTZE MEMORY TECHNOLOGIE
CO LTD
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Pradeep Koshti, Ms. Namitha
Prasad,Mr. P Adityan andMr. Anit
Kumar Singh (through vc)
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Kangan Roda, Adv.
%
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
W.P. (C)- IPD 10/2025
Factual Matrix
1.
The Petitioner on 9th May 2021, filed Indian Patent Application No.
202127020980
[‘Parent
Application’],
claiming
priority
from
PCT/CN2018/119908 dated 7th December 2018, along with a request for
examination under Section 11B of the Indian Patents Act, 1970 [‘the Patents
Act’], and corresponding rules of the Indian Patent Rules, 2003 [‘Patent
Rules’].
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
2.
The bibliographic details of the Parent Application are as follows:
3.
The Parent Application underwent examination, and Respondent
No.2/Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs [‘Controller’], through its
Mumbai office, issued a First Examination Report [‘FER’] on 23rd May
2022, where Controller has raised objection to the claims of the Parent
Application under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act as containing plurality of
inventions which are not linked by single inventive concept.The Petitioner
filed its response to FER on 19th September 2022. The Petitioner responded
to the objection by stating that the multiple independent claims are linked to
a single inventive concept.
4.
Following this, the Controller issued a hearing notice, maintaining
objections from the FER and scheduled the hearing for 7th June 2024.
5.
The Petitioner appeared at the hearing on 8th July 2024, and argued
that the claims complied with common inventive features, justifying their
allowance as multiple independent claims. Following the hearing, detailed
written submissions were filed on 22nd July 2024.
6.
In the written submissions, the Petitioner has mentioned its intention
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
to file a division application if the Controller is not satisfied with their
arguments under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act.
7.
Since the Controller was satisfied with the submissions made by the
Petitioner under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act, the Parent Application was
granted on 26th July 2024.
Aggrieved by the order allowing the Parent Application, which
consequently closed the window available to the Petitioner for filing a
divisional application, the present petition has been filed before thisCourt.
Submissions by the Petitioner
8.
Mr. Pradeep Koshti, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioner has made the following submissions:
8.1.
He states that the Petitioner had duly instructed its representatives to
prepare and file a divisional application before the grant of the Parent
Application, precisely, on 28th June, 2024.
8.2.
He states that the Petitioner had also sought an extended hearing to
file a divisional application covering both the disclosed inventions and the
claims not allowed by the Controller before deciding the grant of the Parent
Application.
8.3.
He states that the Petitioner clearly expressed the intent to file a
divisional application including claims identified as lacking common
inventive features as well as claims pertaining to the invention disclosed in
the specification, pursuant to the communication dated 28 th June 2024; the
Controller agreed, assured further hearings, and directed the Petitioner to file
written submissions.
8.4.
He states that the written submissions were filed on 22ndJuly 2024,
clearly recording the Petitioner’s intent to file a divisional application and
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
the Controller’s assurance of an extended hearing. The submissions
summarised the hearing discussions on the divisional application, noted the
reservation of decision on the allowability of multiple independent claims in
the Parent Application, and emphasised the inclusion of disallowed claims in
the divisional application. The Controller acknowledged the submissions,
granted the request for an extended hearing, accepted the justification of a
single inventive concept, waived objections on claim characterisation, and
noted that all formal requirements had been complied with.
8.5.
He states that, however, on 26th July 2024, the patent was granted
without prior notice or promised hearing, thereby affecting the Petitioner’s
right to file divisional applications. In this regard, reliance is being placed
upon the judgment by the Madras High Court in BASF SE v The Deputy
Controller of Patents and Designs1.
8.6.
He states that upon noticing the grant of the application, the Petitioner
immediately brought the matter to the notice of the concerned authorities
and attempted to file a divisional application and a petition under Rules
138/137, demonstrating bona fide intent and due diligence; however, the
official e-filing system did not permit such filing, as the relevant options
were disabled. Between 26thJuly 2024 and 23rd September 2024, the
Petitioner repeatedly communicated with the Controller regarding the grant
and sought acceptance of the divisional application.
8.7.
He states that the Petitioner yet again tried to file the divisional
application on the IT window of the Controller; however, the IT window did
not allow the same to be filed.
C.M.A.(PT) No.38 of 2024
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
8.8.
He states that on 1st August 2024, the Petitioner sent an email
explaining the circumstances and the powers vested in the Controller to
remedy the issue. Thereafter, on 2nd August 2024, the Petitioner made a
detailed representation seeking re-opening of the window for filing a
divisional application in respect of Parent Application, followed by reminder
communications dated 6th August 2024.
8.9.
He states that, however, on 6th August 2024, the Controller expressed
its inability to accept the divisional application due to insufficient
provisions, procedures, and IT infrastructure. It cited limitations of Section
16(1) and acknowledged a significant lacuna in the patent system, noting the
absence of established practices, guidelines, or rules regarding the timeline
for disposing of applications after written submissions.
8.10. He states that in a communication dated 20th September 2024, the
Controller, while deferring judgment to higher authorities, noted that there
were no objections in the FER regarding the unity of invention and
acknowledged that adherence to proper timelines was followed in issuing
the grant order. And that Section 16(1) of the Patents Act allows for
divisional applications to be filed before grant.
8.11. He states that on 20th September 2024, the Petitioner sought and was
granted leave by the Controller to make more elaborate submissions.
Pursuant thereto, the Petitioner informed that a detailed representation was
being prepared and subsequently filed the same on 23rd September 2024.
8.12. He states that the Petitioner took all precautionary actions and acted
diligently, without abandoning the right, with a clear intent to exercise the
right, and in good faith. In this regard, reliance is being placed upon the
judgment by a Co-ordinate Bench of the Court in European Union
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
Represented by the European Commission v. Union of India &Ors2. The
right to file a divisional application was adversely affected, with ‘no
opportunity of such hearing’ afforded to the Petitioner, thus violating the
principles of natural justice.
Submissions on behalf of the Respondents
9.
Ms. Kangan Roda, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondents, has made the following submissions:
9.1.
She states that the Parent Application is a National Phase Application
that arose out of the Petitioner’s PCT International Application. It is stated
that the address provided by the Petitioner for the purpose of the Parent
Application was not located in India. The address for service was in Indore,
Madhya Pradesh, while the appropriate office for the Petitioner’s application
was determined to be Mumbai.
9.2.
She states that the Controller’s office has a system of automatic
allotment of any patent application for examination and adjudication,
without any human intervention. Therefore, when the Petitioner filed a
request for examination on 9th May 2021 addressed to the Mumbai office,
the application was automatically assigned to the Assistant Controller at
Kolkata.
9.3.
She states that the FER dated 23rdMay 2022 was issued on behalf of
the Controller of Patents, Mumbai, directing that all communications be
addressed to the Mumbai office. The Petitioner accordingly addressed its
replies and subsequent correspondence, including the reply to the FER and
the Proof of Right, to the Controller of Patents at Mumbai. Although hearing
2022 SCC OnLine Del 1793
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
notices scheduling and adjourning the hearing were thereafter issued by the
Delhi office, the Petitioner continued to address its communications to the
Mumbai office, and even the written submissions filed on 22 ndJuly 2024 did
not specify any particular office of Respondent No.2. While the intimation
of grant dated 26thJuly 2024 mentions the Controller of Patents, Delhi, it is
stated that the said intimation was, in fact, issued by the Mumbai office.
However, this does not alter the fact that the Mumbai Office of the
Controller remained the appropriate office for all substantive proceedings, as
evident from the intimation of grant and the Petitioner’s own conduct.
Accordingly, the petition is not maintainable for lack of territorial
jurisdiction.
9.4.
She states that the Petitioner had filed the patent application on 9 th
May 2021, and the patent was granted to the Petitioner by the Controller
only in 2024. Thus, the Petitioner had ample opportunity to file the request
for division of the patent application prior to the grant of the patent as per
Section 16 of the Patents Act.
9.5.
She states that the Petitioner had never communicated its intent to file
for the division of the application prior to the grant of the patent. There was
no bar on the Petitioner to file for the division of the application suo moto
prior to the grant of the patent by the Controller.
9.6.
She states that the Petitioner has heavily relied on correspondence that
appears to be internal and doesn’t relate to the Controller.
9.7.
She
states
that
the
Petitioner
has
misinterpreted
various
communications exchanged with the Controller. The Petitioner’s reliance on
its written submissions to showcase its intention to file a divisional
application is incorrect and contrary to what has been stated in the said
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
submissions. On the contrary, the said submissions pray for an expeditious
grant of the patent. It stated that the Petitioner cannot be allowed to
approbate and reprobate, i.e., it cannot first seek expeditious grant of the
patent and then state it is aggrieved by the grant of said action. In fact, the
Petitioner had candidly acknowledged that in case the Controller believed
that the claims represent distinct inventions, the Petitioner would be willing
to remove one set and pursue the same in a divisional application, which
substantiates the fact that the Petitioner has no intention to file for the
divisional application on a suo moto basis.
She further states that the email dated 6th August 2024 has been
wrongly construed, as the Controller neither acknowledged any lacuna in the
patent system nor expressed inability to accept a divisional application;
rather, the Petitioner was informed that no intent to file a divisional
application had been communicated.
9.8.
She states that the Petitioner failed to raise any objection regarding
the unity of invention during the FER or the hearing notices. The Controller
has waived all pending objections prior to the grant of the patent
9.9.
She states that since the Controller had waived all pending objections
prior to the grant of the Parent Application, no division of the application
was required under Section 16 of the Patents Act. Had any such objection
existed, the patent would not have been granted. The Parent Application was
granted expeditiously on 26th July 2024, in line with the Petitioner’s written
submissions, and there was no obligation on the Controller to delay its
disposal.
9.10. She states that the Petitioner only expressed its intent to file the
divisional application on 31st July 2024, i.e., post-grant of the Parent
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
Application. The correspondences were only post-grant and don’t constitute
formal submissions during the prosecution phase. She states that the
Controller never assured the Petitioner of a definite further hearing as
alleged by it.
9.11. She states that once a patent has been granted, the same has attained
finality and cannot be subject to a division. Neither does the Patents Act
permit post-grant division of applications, nor does this petition call for any
exercise of discretionary power by the Controller.
ANALYSIS
10.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material on record.
11.
In the facts of this case, the patent was granted on 26 th July, 2024, and
the Petitioner admittedly sought to file a divisional application on 31st July,
2024, after the grant of the patent. The Petitioner is aggrieved by the nonacceptance of the divisional application by the Controller and seeks a
direction to the Controller to accept the divisional application.
12.
The issue arising before this Court for consideration in this matter is
whether it is permissible in law for the Petitioner to file a divisional
application after the Controller has already granted a patent for the Parent
Application.
Filing of Divisional Application
13.
For deciding this issue, this Court shall primarily examine the
requirements for filing a divisional patent application under Section 16 of
the Patents Act. The said section is reproduced below:
“16. Power of Controller to make orders respecting division
ofapplication.—(1) A person who has made an application for a patent
under this Act may, at any time before the grant of the patent, if he so
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
desires, or with a view to remedy the objection raised by the
Controller on the ground that the claims of the complete
specificationrelate to more than one invention, file a further
application in respectofan invention disclosed in the provisional or
complete specificationalready filed in respect of the first mentioned
application.
(2) The further application under sub-section (1) shall beaccompanied
by a complete specification, but such completespecification shall not
include any matter not in substance disclosed inthe
completespecification
filed
in
pursuance
of
the
first
mentionedapplication.
(3) The Controller may require such amendment of the
completespecification filed in pursuance of either the original or the
furtherapplication as may be necessary to ensure that neither of the
saidcomplete specifications includes a claim for any matter claimed in
theother.
[Explanation.—For the purposes of this Act, the further
applicationand the complete specification accompanying it shall be
deemed tohave been filed on the date on which the first mentioned
applicationhad been filed, and the further application shall be
proceeded with as asubstantive application and be examined when the
request forexamination is filed within the prescribed period.]”
[Emphasis Supplied]
14.
The requirements under Section 16 are as follows:
a) Sub-section 1 stipulates that the person filing the divisional
application should be the same person who filed the first-mentioned
application (i.e., the parent application).
b) Sub-section 1 stipulates that the divisional application should be filed
before the grant of a patent on the first-mentioned application (parent
application).
c) Sub-section 1 stipulates that a divisional application can be filed by
the patent applicant on his/her own volition or with a view to
remedying the objection raised by the controller on the ground that
the claims of the complete specification in the parent application
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
related to more than one [1] invention/inventive concept.
d) Sub-section 1 further stipulates that the divisional application is to be
filed in respect of an invention disclosed in the provisional or
complete specification, which is already filed in respect of the parent
application.
e) Sub-section 2 stipulates that the divisional application should be filed
with a complete specification, but such a complete specification shall
not include any matter not in substance disclosed in the complete
specification of the parent application.
f) Sub-section 3 stipulates that the controller may require amendment of
the complete specification filed in pursuance of either the parent
application or the divisional application, as may be necessary to
ensure that both the divisional and parent application(s) have a
distinct set of claims.
g) The explanation to Section 16 seeks to clarify that the divisional
application, even if filed later, will be deemed to have been filed on
the date on whichthe parent application was filed.
It further clarifies that the divisional application shall proceed
as a substantive application, i.e., a distinct application and be
examined when the request for examination is filed, within the
prescribed period.
15.
In the present case, it is the case of the Petitioner that it intended to
file a divisional application; and had orally3 intimated the same to the
Controller, who orally promised an extended hearing. The Petitioner is
post hearing dated 8th July 2024
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
aggrieved that however, the Controller thereafter without awaiting the
divisional application proceeded to grant the Parent Application on 26th July,
2024, thereby depriving the petitioner an opportunity to file the divisional
application. To substantiate this plea of oral request, the Petitioner relies
solely upon the written submissions dated 22nd July, 2024.
Burden of filing the Divisional application
16.
From Section 16(1) of the Patents Act, it is clear that an applicant can
file the divisional application themselves if they so desire, or to overcome
any objection raised by the Controller qua the Parent Application as regards
plurality of inventions in the claims of the complete specification; however,
prior to the grant of the patent.
17.
In the present case, the Petitioner was at liberty to file the divisional
application within the window between the date of filing of the Parent
Application, i.e., 09th May, 2021, and the date of grant of patent, i.e., 26th
July, 2024, which exceeds three [3] years. However, the Petitioner at no
stage prior to 26th July 2024 filed any divisional application and sought to
file the said application only on 31st July, 2024.
18.
Now this Court shall examine if the Controller had raised an objection
against the claims of the complete specification of the Parent Application,
which could give a cause to the Petitioner to consider an option to divide the
Parent Application and file a divisional application in order to overcome any
objection from the FER orhearing notice.
19.
Upon perusal of the FER and hearing notice, it is apparent that the
Controller has consistently raised an objection under Section 10(5) of the
Patents Act, alleging that the claims of the Parent Application
containsplurality of inventions which are not part of a single inventive
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
concept.
The objection raised by the Controller regarding the plurality of
inventions presented in the claims of the Parent Application as barred under
Section 10(5) of the Patents Act in the FER dated 23rd May 20224 is as
follows:
“The term “further comprising” in dependent claims tends to widen the
scope of the subject matter claimed from the preceding claims.
The plurality of independent claims as well as the dependency of
claims is such that the scope of protection sought is indefinite and do
not satisfy the requirements of sections 10(4)(c),10(5) respectively of
the Act. Claims shall be redrafted such that all independent claims
shall have a specific inventive embodiment different from all other
independent claims, besides the all essential common inventive feature
being present in each of them individually as required u/s
10(4)(c),10(5).
Drafting of claims is not proper because of which the nature & scope of
the alleged invention cannot be clearly ascertained. Multiple independent
claims claimed in the present set of claims do not relate to group of
inventions linked by a single inventive concept fairly based on the
matter disclosed in the specification as per Section 10(5) which is a
precondition for claiming multiple independent claims. Therefore
fresh set of claims should be drafted & all essential features of the
invention should be brought in claim 1 while subsidiary features of the
invention may be claimed in dependent claims to avoid any ambiguity
in the scope of protection.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
The objection raised by the Controller regarding the plurality of
inventionsin the claims of the Parent Application, as barred under
Section 10(5) of the Patents Act in the hearing notice dated 13th June
2024,is as follows:
“2. Multiple independent claims lack succinctness. Independent
claims should be suitably linked with principal claim to make them
clear, succinct and substantially definitive in accordance with the
requirements of section 10(5) of The Patents Act 1970 as amended.
The FER has been obtained from INPASS, the open access patent database of Indian Patent office
<https://iprsearch.ipindia.gov.in/PublicSearch/PublicationSearch/Search>
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
………
Scope
1. The plurality of independent claims as well as the dependency of
claims is such that the scope of protection sought is indefinite and do
not satisfy the requirements of sections 10(4)(c),10(5) respectively of
the Act. Claims shall be redrafted such that all independent claims
shall have a specific inventive embodiment different from all other
independent claims, besides the all essential common inventive
feature being present in each of them individually as required u/s
10(4)(c),10(5).
Drafting of claims is not proper because of which the nature & scope of
the alleged invention cannot be clearly ascertained. Multiple
independent claims claimed in the present set of claims do not relate
to group of inventions linked by a single inventive concept fairly
based on the matter disclosed in the specification as per Section 10(5)
which is a precondition for claiming multiple independent claims.
Therefore fresh set of claims should be drafted & all essential
features of the invention should be brought in claim 1 while
subsidiary features of the invention may be claimed in dependent
claims to avoid any ambiguity in the scope of protection”
[Emphasis Supplied]
20.
Upon examining both the FER dated 23rd May 2022 and the
hearing notice dated 13th June 2024, it is evident that the Controller
consistently raised the objection that the Parent Application contains
claims covering plurality of inventions that are not linked to a single
inventive concept, as barred under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act.
In these facts, no doubt the Petitioner could have, at the relevant
time, elected to file a divisional application to overcome the said
objection. However, the Petitioner consciously elected not to file a
divisional application and instead chose to file a response to the FER
and the hearing notice, disagreeing with the objections of the
Controller. In its response, the Petitioner did not assert any option to
file a divisional application.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
21.
As per the record, after being served with the FER, the
Petitioner elected to file amended claims on 19th September 2022 to
overcome the objections of plurality of inventions, but it elected not to
file a divisional application.
The response filed by the Petitioner to the FER overcoming the
objection under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act is as follows:
“The Applicant respectfully draws the attention of Honorable
Controller towards the MANUAL OF PATENT OFFICE PRACTICE
AND PROCEDURE version 3.0 published on 26-Nov-2019 (MPEP),
05.03.17 Structure of Claims item (s) on pp. 45, which clearly mentions
that “[t]here may be more than one independent claim in a single
application, if the claims fall under a single inventive concept”.
The Applicant respectfully submits, that Amended Claims 12 and 17 are
directed towards embodiments of methods of manufacturing of the
novel and inventive memory device, thus at least for this reason alone,
the subject matter involves a single inventive concept. The Applicant,
therefore, submits, that Amended Claims 12 and 17 both are
allowable.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
22.
Similarly, after being served with the hearing notice 13th June
2024, when the Petitioner elected to appear before the Controller on
8th July 2024, it elected to defend/stand by its amended claims and
even at this stage did not elect to file any divisional application.
The response in the written submissions dated 22nd July 2024,
filed by the Petitioner to the hearing notice for overcoming the
objection under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act is as follows:
“3. The Honorable Controller directed Counsel to submit written
arguments regarding the allowability of multiple independent claims
12 and 17. The Controller assured Counsel of a further hearing if any
issues remain unresolved
………
7. The Honorable Controller directed the filing of written submissions
and assured Counsel of a further hearing if any issues remain
unresolved.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
………
Objection: 2. Multiple independent claims lack succinctness. Independent
claims should be suitably linked with principal claim to make them clear,
succinct and substantially definitive in accordance with the requirements
of section 10(5) of The Patents Act 1970 as amended.
Reply: During the hearing, the Counsel the two independent method
claims (12 and 17). The Counsel submitted that both claims are allowable
in this application because they share a single inventive concept: 3DNAND technology.
Claim 12 lays the foundation by creating the memory itself, focusing on
the manufacturing process.
Claim 17 utilizes the memory for a specific function, focusing on data
manipulation (erasing).
The claim 12 and 17 of address different aspects of manufacturing
and data manipulation and that they are inherently linked by the
underlying 3D-NAND technology.
The Counsel respectfully points towards section 05.03.17 of the Patent
Office Practice and Procedure (MPEP) version 3.0 (published
November 26, 2019), which allows for multiple independent claims in
a single application as long as they share a single inventive concept.
However, if the Honorable Controller believes these claims represent
distinct inventions, the applicant is willing to remove one set and
pursue it in a divisional application under Section 16(3). The
Honorable Controller directed that written submissions regarding
claim allowability and assured of a further hearing if any issues
remain unresolved.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
23.
Upon perusal of the responses filed by the Petitioner to the FER
and hearing notice, it is clear that the Petitioner, before the patent
office, has clearly responded to the objection under Section 10(5) of
the Patents Actto assert that the independent claims clearly of the
Parent Application form part of a single inventive concept and had
pleaded for waiver of the said objection in light of their
arguments/submissions.
24.
In the order dated 26th July 2024 granting the patent, the
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
Controller has recorded the responses filed by the Petitioner in written
submissions dated 22nd July 2024, accepting all the arguments of
thePetitioner and waiving all the objections, including objection no. 2.
The relevant paragraphs from the impugned order are as follows:
“7. After hearing the arguments during hearing and reasoning provided by
the applicant in written submission, I agree that amended independent
claims 1, 12 and 17 have inventive step over cited documents.
Dependent claims 2-11, 13-16 and 18-20 also have inventive features over
the cited documents. During the hearing, I also discussed other issues of
claims 1-20 dated 19/09/2022. I also carefully read the written submission
about all other objections and found that all objections are fulfilled by the
applicant.
Since the applicant has also deleted/merged the claims and suitably
amended in view of under section 59 of the Indian Patents act 1970 (as
amended), thus claims 1-20 are allowable u/s 2(1)(j).
Order:
8. Hence, in view of the above, the requirements of objections raised
through the said hearing notice are met and in absence of any other
objection of substantive nature, claims 1-20 dated 19/09/2022 are found to
be novel, inventive, clear, definitive and in order, and thereby allowed.
9. Therefore, keeping in view the facts on record, the submissions of the
agents during hearing and subsequently through the written submissions, the
said patent application no. 202127020980 complies with the requirements of
The Patents Act, 1970 (as amended). I, therefore, hereby order the grant of
the said patent application 202127020980 u/s 43(1) of The Patents Act,
1970 (as amended) with claims 1-20 as uploaded on 19/09/2022 under the
document named “202127020980-AMMENDED DOCUMENTS [19-092022(online)].pdf”. There is no pre-grant opposition request filed u/s 25(1).
10. This is to be noted that the aforesaid observations, and decision thereof,
are based solely on the electronically uploaded documents to date.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
25.
The order dated 26th July, 2024, shows that the Controller accepted the
Petitioner’s reply to objection no. 2 raised in the hearing notice to the effect
that the amended set of claims filed on 19th September 2022, addressed the
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
objection of the Controller raised under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act. As
noted above, the Petitioner has relied upon its oral request for filing
divisional application to the Controller for alleging illegality. The oral
request is recorded in the post-hearing written submissions dated 22nd July
2024, filedwith the Patent Office, while responding to objection no. 2 of the
hearing notice. In this written submission, Petitioner refers to an intention to
file a divisional application and extended hearing by the Controller, if the
issues are unresolved.
26.
The willingness of the Petitioner to file a divisional application as
recorded at paragraph ‘5’ of the written submissions dated 22nd July 2024 of
the Petitioner was clearly an alternative reserved by the Petitioner in
response to objection no. 2 to be exercised by it in case of non-resolution of
the objection raised by the Controller under Section 10(5) of the Patents Act.
Thus, the Petitioner even as on 22nd July 2024, consciously did not proceed
to file a divisional application suo motu, but left the matter to the discretion
of the Controller, contingent upon the outcome of the Parent Application.
27.
However, the Controller waived all its objections, including the
objection no.2 that the claims of the complete specification of the subject
application does not fulfil Section 10(5) of the Patents Act, based on the
Petitioner’s written submissions dated 22nd July 2024 and hearing dated 8th
July 2024, and proceeded to grant the Parent Application on 26th July 2024.
Therefore, the reserving of right to file divisional application documented in
the written submissions dated 22nd July 2024 lost relevance and was not
triggered. Therefore, this Court finds no error in the decision of the
Controller; and is unable to appreciate the grievance of the Petitioner in this
writ petition.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
28.
The Petitioner has neither, during the course of arguments nor in the
writ petition, demonstrated any prejudice caused to it on account of the nonfiling of the divisional application.
29.
The onus/discretion to file a divisional application under Section 16(1)
of the Patent Act lies exclusively with the Applicant, i.e., the Petitioner
herein, which was consciously not exercised by it at any time prior to 26th
July 2024.
Section 16(1) of the Patents Act is very clear and it stipulates that the
divisional application is to be filed before the Parent Application has been
granted. The Petitioner however, sought to file the divisional application
only on 31st July 2024 which is beyond the stipulated period under Section
16(1) of the Patent Act and therefore, it has rightly not been accepted by the
Patent Office.
The Petitioner cannot be permitted to agitate and assert a right to file a
divisional application after the grant of the Parent Application, particularly
when no such step was taken at the relevant stage before the Controller, as
examined in the facts of this case. Therefore, the Petitioner’s submission
alleging a violation of the principles of natural justice is wholly devoid of
merit.
30.
Also, it is the argument of the Petitioner that the Parent Application
was granted abruptly without any notice to the Petitioner, which in effect
closed their window period to file a divisional application. The process for
granting a patent is as per Section 43 of the Patents Act. The said section is
as follows:
“43. Grant of patents.—(1) Where an application for a patent has
been found to be in order for grant of the patent and either—
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
(a) the application has not been refused by the Controller byvirtue of any
power vested in him by this Act; or
(b) the application has not been found to be in contravention ofany of the
provisions of this Act,the patent shall be granted as expeditiously as
possible to the applicant or, in the case of a joint application, to the
applicants jointly, with the seal of the patent office and the date on
which the patent is granted shall be entered in the register.
(2) On the grant of patent, the Controller shall publish the fact that the
patent has been granted and thereupon the application, specification and
other documents related thereto shall be open for public inspection.”
[Emphasis supplied]
31.
According to Section 43 of the Patents Act, a patent application found
to satisfy all the pending objections is to be proceeded to grant as
expeditiously as possible. There is no statutory provision under the Act
obligating the Controller to communicate a notice to the applicant indicating
the grant of a patent prior to the grant of the same.Hence, the Petitioner’s
contention of lack of notice prior to the grant of the Parent Application is
without any merit.
32.
The Petitioner has relied on BASF SE v The Deputy Controller of
Patents and Designs(supra), a recent judgment by the High Court of
Madras, for seeking a direction to the Controller to accept its divisional
application. In the facts of the said case, the High Court concluded that the
divisional application was filed by the applicant prior to acquiring
knowledge regarding the grant of the patent application and therefore held
the same to be maintainable. The said judgment is not applicable to the facts
of this case, as admittedly the Petitioner herein attempted to file a divisional
application on 31st July, 2024, much after the grant of the patent.
33.
Before closing the matter, it is noted that the Respondents, in their
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
counter-affidavit, have raised an objection regarding the lack of territorial
jurisdiction. However, the Respondents themselves have admitted that a part
of the cause of action arose in Delhi, inasmuch as two [2] hearing notices
dated 10thJune 2024 and 13thJune 2024 were issued by the Delhi Office of
the Controller. In addition, the Controller’s decision dated 26 th July 2024
was issued on the letterhead of the Controller of Patents, Patent Office,
Delhi. Therefore, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the present petition.
34.
On merits, however, this Court is unable to find any merit in this
petition; hence, the same is dismissed.
35.
The Registry is directed to supply a copy of the present order to the
office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs & Trade Marks of India
on the e-mail- llc-ipo@gov.in.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 03, 2026/aa/fv
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:05.02.2026 20:10
W.P.(C)-IPD 10/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review