Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 8737/2016 & CM APPLs. 35840/2016, 11793/2017,
26783/2024
Y. NOORUDDIN
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Manpreet Kaur, Advocate with
Petitioner (in-Person).
versus
INDIRA GANDHI NATIONAL OPERN UNIVERSITY (IGNOU) &
ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Pratima N. Lakra and Mr.
Shailendra Kumar Mishra, Mr.
Abhishek Sharma and Ms. Upanita
Soumyadarshini, Advocates for R-2.
Mr. Varun Jain, Advocate for R-1
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
20.02.2026
%
1.
The Petitioner joined Respondent No. 1 as Assistant Engineer (Civil)
on 31st March, 1999. On completion of 8 years of service, he was placed in
the Pay Band of Rs. 15,600-39,100 + GP Rs. 6,600.
2.
On 30th March, 2009, he requested Respondent No.1 to consider him
for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil). A Departmental
Promotion Committee met on 9th November, 2010 and, according to the
Petitioner, recommended his promotion to the post of Executive Engineer
(Civil).
3.
While the process of promotion was underway, Respondent No. 1
issued Office Order No. 1100 dated 28th December, 2010, entrusting him
with the charge of the post of Executive Engineer (Civil) under FR 49(1), in
addition to his routine duties, purely on a temporary basis and until further
orders. The same reads as follows:
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
“MAIDAN GARHI, NEW DELHI 110 068
(ADMINISTRATION DIVISION)
F.No.AD/2/NA/3336/99/391
Dated: 28, December, 2010
OFFICE ORDER No.1100
Shri.Y. Nooruddin, Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil), CMD has been
entrusted with the charge of the post of Executive Engineer (Civil) in
addition to his routine duties purely on temporary basis till further orders
under the provisions of FR-49(1) with immediate effect. This issue with the
approval of the Competent Authority
-SD(R. THYAGARAJAN)
Dy. REGISTRAR (Estt)”
4.
Thereafter, the Board of Management, in its 109th meeting held on
27th August, 2011, approved the Petitioner’s promotion as Executive
Engineer (Civil) in the Pay Band of Rs. 15,600-39,100 with Grade Pay of
Rs. 7,600, on a temporary basis against a project post stated to be coterminus with the project period.
5.
Pursuant to the above, Office Order No. 127 dated 5 th October, 2011
was issued. It records that, on the recommendation of the DPC held on 9 th
November, 2010 and approval of the Board of Management on 27 th August,
2011, the Petitioner was promoted to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil)
in Pay Band-3 (Rs. 15,600-39,100) with Grade Pay of Rs. 7,600 on a
temporary basis against a project post created for a period of five years. The
order further states that the promotion would take effect from the date he
assumed charge of the post on promotion. The same reads as follows:
“INDIRA GANDHI NATIONAL OPEN UNIVERSITY
MAIDAN GARHI, NEW DELHI
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
F.No.1-48(B)NA/E-1/Vol.III/1750
Dated : 5th October, 2011
OFFICE ORDER No.127
On the recommendation of the Departmental Promotion Committee
made in its meeting held on 09.11.2010 and with the approval of the
Board of Management in its 109th meeting held on 27.08.2011, Shri. Y.
Nooruddin, Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil) is promoted to the
post of Executive Engineer (Civil) in the Pay Band -3 i.e., Rs.1560039100 with a Grade Pay of Rs.7600/- On temporary basis against the
project post created for a period for 05 years.
The date of effect of promotion shall be the date of assumption of the
charge of the said post on promotion.
If Sh. Y. Nooruddin refuses the promotion, he will not be considered for
promotion for a period of one year and in such a situation, her will
lose his seniority and will rank junior to the last official promoted
during this period. He has the option to get his pay fixed in the
promoted post from the date of drawal of increment in the lower grade,
if applicable, for which the option should be exercised within a month
of the date of assumption of the charge under the provisions of FR 22
1(a) (i), if applicable.
Acceptance/Refusal of the promotion must be communicated within one
month from the date of issue of this order.
-SD(U.S. TOLIA)
Registrar (Admn)”
6.
On 24th January, 2014, Office Order No. 1024 was issued on the
recommendations of the Establishment Committee in its 71 st meeting held
on 21st November, 2013. By this order, officers promoted were declared to
have completed the prescribed period of probation satisfactorily from the
dates specified. In the Petitioner’s case, probation was lifted with effect from
4th October, 2012.
7.
In the above backdrop, the Petitioner’s grievance arises from
impugned Office Order No. 214 dated 22nd August, 2016. By this order,
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
officials who were “earlier promoted/entrusted the charge of Executive
Engineer (C/E) on temporary basis under the provisions of FR 49 against the
Project Post” were reverted to their substantive posts with effect from the
date of completion of the maximum period of five years of the relevant
project. The same reads as follows:
“INDIRA GANDHI NATIONAL OPEN UNIVERSITY
MAIDAN GARHI, NEW DELHI 110068
ADMINISTRATION DIVISION (ESTT)
F.No:AD/2/NA/904
Dated 22nd August, 2016
OFFICE ORDER No.214
With the approval of the Competent Authority, the following officials
who were earlier promoted/entrusted the charge of Executive Engineer
(C/E) on temporary basis under the provisions of FR 49 against the
Project Post are hereby reverted back to their substantive posts with
effect from the date of completion of maximum period of five year of the
Project indicated against each:
Accordingly, the revised pay fixation orders in respect of above said
officials will be issued separately.
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
-SD(A.K. SIROHI)
Deputy Registrar (Estt)”
Petitioner’s submissions
8.
The Petitioner submits that under the Recruitment and Promotion
Rules, 2003, an Assistant Executive Engineer completing ten years of
regular service becomes eligible for promotion as Executive Engineer
(Civil). It is urged that he was duly considered by the Departmental
Promotion Committee and was recommended for promotion, which was
thereafter approved by the Board of Management. Pursuant thereto, he was
promoted to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil), and his probation was
subsequently declared to have been satisfactorily completed. On that basis, it
is contended that he stood confirmed in the promoted post and could not
thereafter be reverted as though he were merely holding a temporary charge.
9.
The Petitioner contends that the impugned order proceeds on a flawed
premise because it treats him as a mere FR 49 charge holder. The FR 49
arrangement ended once the promotion order dated 5th October, 2011 was
issued. Thereafter, he held the post of Executive Engineer by promotion
[with pay fixation under FR 22(1)(a)(i)], his probation was lifted, and he
could not be reverted by treating the position as only an FR 49 entrustment.
The Petitioner submits that the impugned reversion is illegal, arbitrary and
without authority because it was not approved by the appointing authority
for Group-A officers, namely the Board of Management. He alleges that it
was issued only with the approval of the Vice-Chancellor (in-charge),
which, according to him, was insufficient.
10.
The Petitioner disputes the respondent’s stand that the project had
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
ended by 18th June, 2015 and relies on certain documents showing
continuation of construction activities.
11.
The Petitioner also submits that the reversion could not have even
been implemented because there was no vacant substantive post available.
The Petitioner went on deputation to IIT Delhi on 16 th November, 2009.
During this period, in the DPC meeting dated 9 th April, 2010, one Shri R.P.
Meena was promoted on a temporary basis to the Petitioner’s post, with a
specific stipulation that he would have no right to the post and would be
reverted upon the Petitioner’s repatriation. The Petitioner was relieved from
IIT Delhi to return to the parent department (IGNOU) by memorandum
dated 8th November, 2010. He points out that Shri R.P. Meena was not
reverted back and was later regularised by Office Order dated 12 th April,
2023. He further claims that although six sanctioned posts exist for Assistant
Executive Engineer, seven persons were shown as working against them,
based on information received under RTI.
12.
The Petitioner further submits that recovery is impermissible. He
asserts that he continued to discharge duties of Executive Engineer and that
a status quo order dated 28th September, 2016 protected him. He also points
to the respondent’s later order dated 23rd November, 2016 cancelling the
recovery of the “excess” amount, to contend that the recovery itself was
unsustainable. He further submits that, having been placed in Grade Pay Rs.
7,600 since 28th December, 2010, he became entitled to an upward
movement/time scale to Grade Pay Rs. 8,700 with effect from 27 th
December, 2015, and that similarly placed officers had been granted such
benefit. He claims that his request was declined only because the
respondents treated his promotion as withdrawn. On these grounds, the
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
Petitioner seeks quashing of Office Order dated 22nd August, 2016,
restoration of his status and pay as Executive Engineer (Civil), protection
against recovery, and consequential benefits.
Respondent’s submissions
13.
The respondents controvert the Petitioner’s case and submit that the
promotion as Executive Engineer (Civil) was never to a regular cadre
vacancy, but was a time-bound arrangement against a project post, with a
maximum outer limit of five years. They submit that this position flows
from the very terms of the DPC recommendation and the promotion order,
which expressly tie the appointment to the project post and its duration.
14.
It is further urged that the project itself was conceived as a limited-
period arrangement, and the Works Committee deliberations show that
while construction activity and allied contracts continued to be reviewed, the
manpower and delegations for the Construction and Maintenance Division
were treated as contingent arrangements, with regular recruitment being
deferred until appointment of a regular Vice-Chancellor. On that basis, the
respondents defend the reversion as a consequence of the project tenure
having run its course, and contend that the Petitioner could not claim a
vested right to continue as Executive Engineer beyond the sanctioned
project period.
Analysis
15.
The controversy turns on the legal character of the Petitioner’s
promotion. The record does not show a regular promotion against a cadre
vacancy. The DPC minutes dated 9th November, 2010 record, in terms, that
“one Executive Engineer (Civil) has been created for project for period not
exceeding for 05 years” and, on that footing, recommended that the
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
Petitioner “may be promoted … on temporary basis against the post created
for the project period”. The promotion order dated 5 th October, 2011 follows
the same line. It promotes the Petitioner “on temporary basis against the
project post created for a period of 05 years”. The foundation, therefore, is a
time-bound project post.
16.
A project post created for a fixed period carries an inherent limit. It
does not belong to the regular cadre strength. It is not a “vacancy” in the
sense in which service rules contemplate a substantive promotion. When a
person accepts such a placement, the right acquired is to hold the post on the
terms of the creation and the order granting such a right. Once the sanction
period expires, there is no continuing right to remain in that post merely
because the individual has worked on it for a length of time, or because
some construction activity continues on the ground. Continuance thereafter
would require a fresh and valid administrative decision extending the post
and the tenure, with the requisite financial sanction and approval by the
authority competent to create or extend Group ‘A’ posts.
17.
The Petitioner places emphasis on two events: (i) entrustment of
charge under FR 49(1) by Office Order No. 1100 dated 28 th December,
2010, and (ii) lifting of probation by Office Order dated 24 th January, 2014
with effect from 4th October, 2012. Neither carries the case further. FR 49(1)
is an arrangement of additional charge “till further orders”. It is not a source
of substantive appointment. It cannot override the subsequent promotion
order which itself describes the promotion as temporary and tied to the
project post. As regards “probation”, the expression, in service usage, only
reflects that the incumbent’s work was assessed satisfactory for the post held
at that time. It cannot transform a time-bound project post into a permanent
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
cadre post. Confirmation, even when stated, cannot operate beyond the life
of the post itself.
18.
The argument that the project was “alive” and therefore the post could
not lapse has an attractive factual appeal but fails in law. The material relied
upon by the Petitioner, including the Works Committee minutes and
correspondence showing extension of RITES’ PMC engagement, or
municipal approvals, indicates that construction activity and contract
management continued. However, that does not, by itself, establish that the
University extended the sanctioned project posts beyond the maximum
period for which they were created. Extension of a consultancy contract, or
extension of a construction timeline, is not the same thing as extension of
sanctioned manpower posts. Each has its own approval and financial
discipline. Significantly, the Petitioner’s own documents disclose that, in
May 2016, a proposal was placed seeking extension of the technical and
non-technical posts. The very fact that such extension was proposed
demonstrates that no prior decision extending the life of the project posts
had been taken. A proposal or internal noting cannot substitute for a
completed and approved decision of the competent authority. In the absence
of any material showing that the sanctioned posts themselves were extended,
the reversion cannot be invalidated merely because construction activity
continued.
19.
The contention that the impugned reversion order is without
jurisdiction because, at the relevant time, there was no regular ViceChancellor and the office was being looked after by an acting ViceChancellor also does not merit acceptance. The Petitioner relies upon the
circular dated 7th August, 2014, referring to Rule 12(2) of the CCS (CCA)
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
Rules, 1965, to contend that an officer performing the current duties of an
appointment cannot exercise statutory powers. However, the said circular
itself recognises that such officer may exercise administrative and financial
powers vested in the incumbent of the post. The reversion of the Petitioner
on completion of the five-year project period was in implementation of the
earlier decision of the Board of Management creating the project post for a
limited duration and the terms of the promotion order itself, which expressly
tied the appointment to the project period. The Petitioner has not
demonstrated that such consequential reversion amounts to exercise of any
independent statutory power under the IGNOU Act requiring the approval of
a regular Vice-Chancellor or exclusively of the Board of Management. In
the absence of any statutory prohibition, the mere fact that the ViceChancellor was holding charge in an acting capacity does not render the
order invalid.
20.
The submission that there was no substantive vacancy to which the
Petitioner could be reverted, because another officer (Sh. R.P. Meena)
allegedly continued as AEE, is a service management issue. It cannot
operate as a lever to confer a right to continue as Executive Engineer beyond
the life of the project post. At best, it may raise an implementation concern
for the employer to rectify by appropriate postings within the cadre. It does
not invalidate the legal basis of reversion from the project post.
21.
Prayer (c), seeking regular promotion “with effect from 30.03.2009
against the existing vacancy”, cannot be granted in these proceedings.
Promotion is not a matter of right. The right is to be considered in
accordance with rules, subject to vacancy position, eligibility and
comparative assessment. As already noticed, the Petitioner was promoted
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
only against a project post, which itself suggests that a regular cadre vacancy
was not being filled through that DPC recommendation. A writ of
mandamus for a retrospective regular promotion from 2009 would require a
clear foundation of (i) existence of a regular vacancy in the cadre, (ii)
entitlement under the applicable R&P Rules, and (iii) illegality in denial of
consideration in that regular channel at the relevant time. That factual
foundation is absent on the present record.
22.
On recovery, the approach in service law is settled. Recovery of pay
already drawn is not automatic merely because an administrative decision is
revisited later. Courts weigh whether the employee contributed to the
alleged overpayment and whether recovery would be harsh or inequitable. In
Chandi Prasad Uniyal v. State of Uttarakhand,1 the Supreme Court held
that any amount paid without authority of law can ordinarily be recovered,
and absence of fraud or misrepresentation on the part of the employee does
not, by itself, create a bar against recovery. Relief against recovery is not a
matter of right, but rests in equity, to be exercised in appropriate cases.
Subsequently, in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer),2 the
Court identified certain categories where recovery would ordinarily be
impermissible on grounds of fairness, such as recovery from Class III and
IV employees, retired employees, or where excess payment has continued
for a long period and recovery would be iniquitous.
23.
In the present case, the respondents’ pleadings disclose that the
proposed recovery was cancelled by order dated 23 rd November, 2016, and
no recovery has in fact been effected. In that view, the grievance as regards
(2012) 8 SCC 417
(2015) 4 SCC 334
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
recovery does not survive. Needless to add, if any recovery is sought to be
initiated or revived in future, it would have to be tested on the touchstone of
the principles laid down in the aforesaid decisions, including whether the
case falls within the categories recognised in Rafiq Masih or whether
recovery would be iniquitous in the facts of the case.
Conclusion:
24.
The petition, therefore, does not make out a legal basis to quash the
reversion order on the footing that the Petitioner acquired a substantive right
to remain as Executive Engineer beyond the sanctioned project-post period.
The Petitioner’s service on the post, even if satisfactory, cannot enlarge the
tenure fixed by the creation of the post and the promotion order. The remedy
of the Court cannot be to convert a time-bound project promotion into a
regular cadre promotion by judicial command.
25.
That said, the Petitioner’s grievance on regular promotional avenues
can be addressed only to the limited extent permitted by law. If the
Petitioner is eligible under the applicable R&P Rules for consideration to a
regular Executive Engineer (Civil) vacancy, and such vacancy exists, the
respondents shall consider the Petitioner for promotion in the regular
channel in accordance with the governing rules, along with other eligible
officers, within a reasonable time.
26.
In view of the above, the petition is disposed of along with pending
application(s), if any.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 20, 2026/as
W.P.(C) 8737/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/02/2026 at 12:35:34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review