Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non-reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
RSA No. 5 of 2016 with
MC(RSA) No. 1 of 2025
Shri Yumnam Chandra Singh, aged about 77 years, S/o
late Y. Gouro Singh, resident of Kakwa Laishram
SelungbaLeikai, P.S. Singjamei, Imphal died by Lrs: 1. Yumnam Ongbi Radhamani Devi, aged about 70
years, wife of late Y. Chandra Singh, resident of
Kakwa Laishram SelungbaLeikai, P.O. & P.S.Singjamei, District- Imphal East, Manipur
2. Yumnam Ranachandra Singh, aged about 44
years, son of late Y. Chandra Singh, resident of
Kakwa Laishram SelungbaLeikai, P.O. & P.S.Singjamei, District- Imphal West, Manipur
3. Nongthombam Ongbi YumnamDevrani Devi, aged
about 51 years, daughter of late Y. Chandra Singh
and wife of N. Bimolchand Singh, resident of
KongbaUchekon, P.O.- Singjamei & P.S.- Irilbung,
District- Imphal East, Manipur
4. Richa Yumnam, aged about 48 years, daughter of
late Y. Chandra Singh, resident of Kakwa Laishram
SelungbaLeikai, P.O. & P.S.- Singjamei, DistrictImphal West, Manipur
5. Leishangthem Ongbi Yumnam Marina Devi, aged
about 42 years, daughter of late Y. Chandra Singh
and wife of L. Binoy Singh, resident of Yumnam
Leikai, P.O. & P.S.- Singjamei, District- Imphal
West, Manipur
6. Yumnam Rezia Chanu, aged about 41 years,
daughter of late Y. Chandra Singh, resident of
Kakwa Laishram Selungba Leikai, P.O. & P.S.Singjamei, District- Imphal West, Manipur
….. Appellant/s
Versus
1.
Shri Yumnam Tomba Singh, aged about 67 years,
S/o late Y. Gouro Singh, resident of Kakwa
Lamdaibung (Laishram Selungba Leikai), P.S.
Singjamei, Imphal died on 3/8/2016 by his LRs
i.
Yumnam Mema Devi, aged about 66 years,
wife of late Y. Tomba Singh, resident of
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 1
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
Kakwa
Leiphrakpam
Leikai
PO&PS
Singjamei, Imphal West, Manipur
Yumnam Kanta Mangang, aged about 47
years, son of late Y. Tomba Singh, resident
of Kakwa Leiphrakpam Leikai PO&PS
Singjamei, Imphal West, Manipur
Yumnam Basanta Mangang, aged about 44
years, son of late Y. Tomba Singh, resident
of Kakwa Leiphrakpam Leikai PO&PS
Singjamei, Imphal West, Manipur
Yumnam Basanti Chanu, aged about 41
years, daughter of late Y. Tomba Singh,
resident of Kakwa Leiphrakpam Leikai
PO&PS Singjamei, Imphal West, Manipur
Yumnam Ningol Wangkhem Ongbi Surjabala
Devi, aged about 38 years, wife of W.
Arunkumar and daughter of late Y. Tomba
Singh, resident of Kakwa Lamdaibung
PO&PS Singjamei, Imphal West, Manipur
Yumnam Ningol Hanjabam Tejbala Devi
aged about 35 years, wife of H. Mohon
Sharma and daughter of late Y. Tomba
Singh,
presently
residing
at
Kakwa
Leiphrakpam Leikai PO&PS Singjamei,
Imphal West, Manipur
Yumnam Ningol Konthoujam Ongbi Sunanda
Devi aged about 32 years, wife of
Konthoujam Sanjoy Singh and daughter of
late Y. Tomba Singh, resident of Moirang
Tera Khongsangbi, PO & PS: Moirang,
District- Bishnupur, Manipur
………Principal Respondent
1.
Shri Wangkhem Chaoba Singh, aged about 70
years, S/o Late W. Tampha Singh of Kakwa
Laiphrakpam Leikai, P.S. Singjamei, Imphal died
on 03/09/2006 (LRs were exempted from
bringing).
2.
Shri Wangkhem Sangai Singh, aged about 66
years, S/o Late W. Tampha Singh of Kakwa
Laiphrakpam Leikai/ Laishram Selungba Leikai,
P.S. Singjamei, Imphal died on 12/01/2001 and
represented by his legal representatives : i.
Smt. Wangkhem Ongbi Madhuri Devi, W/o
Late
W.
Sangai
Singh
of
Kakwa
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 2
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
3.
Laiphrakpam
Leikai,
P.O.
and
P.S.
Singjamei (died by LRs already on record)
Shri Wangkhem Manglem Singh, S/o Late
W. Sangai Singh of Kakwa Laiphrakpam
Leikai, P.O. and P.S. Singjamei
Shri Wangkhem Ramesh Singh, S/o Late W.
Sangai Singh of Kakwa Laiphrakpam Leikai,
P.O. and P.S. Singjamei (died on 20/8/2014)
by his LRs.
a) Wangkhem ongbi Ranjita Devi @
Innu, aged about 24 years, w/o Late
W. Ramesh Singh of Kakwa
Laiphrakpam Leikai, P.O. and P.S.
Singjamei .
b) Wangkhem
Malemnganbi
Devi,
aged about 3 years, d/o late W.
Ramesh Singh represented by her
natural mother, Wangkhem Ongbi
Ranjita Devi of Kakwa Laiphrakpam
Leikai, P.O. and P.S. Singjamei
Wangkhem Bimola Devi, D/o Late W. Sangai
Singh and wife of Wahengbam Samananda
Singh of Uripok Polem Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur.
Wangkhem Shantibala Devi, D/o Late W.
Sangai Singh and wife of R.K. Sanajaoba
Singh of Haobam Marak Keisham Leikai,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
Wangkhem Binapani Devi, D/o Late W.
Sangai Singh and wife of Ningthoujam
Jayadev Singh of Yaishkul Jamastan,
Imphal West District, Manipur
Wangkhem Memi Devi, D/o Late W. Sangai
Singh and wife of Konthoujam Somorendro
Singh of Singjamei Thongam Leikai, Imphal
West District, Manipur.
Wangkhem Modhubala Devi, D/o Late W.
Sangai Singh and wife of late Heisnam Lalit
of Haobam Marak, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
Wangkhem Radhapriyari Devi, D/o Late W.
Sangai Singh and wife of Shiv Sankar, now
residing at Quarter No. 362 -C, Railway
Officer Enclave, Gandhi Nagar, Bangalore,
Pin No. 560023, Karnataka.
Shri Yumnam Gouro Singh, aged about 81 years,
S/o Late Netra Singh of Kakwa Laishram
Selungba Leikai, P.S. Singjamei, Imphal, died on
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 3
26/01/2014. (LRS were exempted from bringing
by the order of the trial court).
……Pro-forma Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
Compromised Order
05.08.2025
On 04.02.2025, Mr. Th. Henba, learned counsel along with
[1]
Mr. Y. Ranachandra Singh and Mrs. Richa Yumnam, LRs of the deceased
appellants and Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel along with Mr. E. Dayali,
learned counsel and Mr. Yumnam Basanta Mangang, one of the LRs of
the deceased respondent No. 1 appeared before this Court in chamber
for mutual settlement of the pending second appeal in terms of the joint
application being MC(RSA) No. 1 of 2025 filed under the provisions of the
Order 23 Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
The parties filed an application being MC(RSA) No. 1 of
[2]
2025 in RSA No. 5 of 2016 under the provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC,
1908 for amicable settlement of the second appeal pending before this
Court on mutual understanding that both parties will share 50% each of
the suit land.
[3]
The application is signed by the LRs of the contesting
parties before this Court i.e. plaintiff and defendant No. 1. Plaintiff namely
Yumnam Chandra Singh and defendant No. 1 namely Yumnam Tomba
Singh are the sons of Y. Gouro Singh who is original owner of the suit
land. The homestead land having an area of .27 acre (0.1099 hactre)
under C.S. Dag No. 112 of patta No. 63/42(old)/11(new)/WT(II) recorded
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 4
in the name of Yumnam Chandra Singh (plaintiff) which is now
erroneously/falsely shown to be comprised of Dag No. 137/161 of patta
No. 63/11(old-part)/83/131 (new)/WT in the name of Yumnam Tomba
Singh (Principal Defendant) which is situated at Laiphrakpam Leikai,
Imphal West and found as follows:North:- Homestead land of Wangthem Sangai Singh;
South:- Homestead land of Thounaojam Nipamacha Singh;
East:- Burma (Myanmar) Road;
West:- Agricultural-cum-homestead land of Leimapokpam
Shyamjai Singh.
[4]
The plaintiff filed a suit being O.S. No. 15 of 1997 before the
then Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division No. 1), Manipur East, Imphal (now
Senior Judge), Imphal West inter-alia praying that the suit land was gifted
to him by his father i.e. defendant No. 4 by a registered deed and for
cancellation of the 4 (four) sale deeds dated 10.10.1996. Defendant No.
1 also filed a counter claim praying that he purchased the suit land from
his father i.e. defendant No. 4 by a registered sale deed and for cancelling
the gift deed of the plaintiff.
[5]
Vide judgment and decree dated 23.09.2014 passed by the
then Civil Judge (Sr. Division No. 1), Imphal East, both the suit and the
counter claim were dismissed. Against the said order, only plaintiff
preferred the first appeal being RFA No. 14 of 2014/7 of 2015 before the
Court of District Judge, Imphal West and vide judgment and decree dated
19.01.2016, the appeal preferred by the plaintiff was also dismissed.
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 5
[6]
It may be noted that the defendant No. 1 did not file any
appeal against the dismissal of the counter claim. Being aggrieved by the
dismissal of the first appeal, the original plaintiff preferred the regular
second appeal being RSA No. 5 of 2016 before this Court and the same
is pending for adjudication.
[7]
The defendant No. 4 had seven children including the
plaintiff and defendant No. 1. However, vide order dated 29.08.2014
passed by the Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Division No. 1), Manipur East, Judl.
Misc. Case No. 386 of 2024 [Ref: O.S. No. 15 of 1997] filed under Order
22 Rule 4 (iv) read with Section 151 CPC for exemption for filing LRs of
defendant No. 4 was allowed as deceased defendant No.4 failed to
appear and contest the case by filing written statement.
[8]
Since the order dated 29.08.2014, Ld. Civil Judge (Sr.
Division No. 1), Manipur East allowing the application filed by plaintiff for
exempting from bringing on record the remaining children of the deceased
defendant No. 4 on record, this order attained finality and hence, the other
children of defendant No. 4 were not brought on record before the first
appellate court and also before this court.
[9]
On 02.04.2024, during the course of hearing, the learned
counsel for the parties made a request to find out an amicable settlement
and accordingly, on 13.04.2024, 30.04.2024, 13.06.2024, 23.07.2024 &
27.08.2024, the parties appeared in person before this Court for an
amicable settlement.
[10]
On 24.09.2024, learned counsel appearing for the parties
submitted that the parties are on the verge of bringing an amicable
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 6
settlement and in the circumstances. On 04.02.2025, the parties
appeared before this Court in chamber with an application being
MC(RSA) No. 1 of 2025 containing the terms and conditions of settlement
has been filed which is reproduced below:
“(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
That the plaintiff hereinafter shall mean the legal
heirs late Yumnam Chandra Singh only and the
defendant No. 1 hereinafter shall mean the legal
heirs late Yumnam Tomba Singh only and as a
portion of 0.045 (Zero point zero four five) acre out of
the suit land admeasuring an area 0.27 acre under
CS Dag No. 112 under patta No. 42 (old)/11(new) of
Revenue village No. 63-Laiphrakpam Leikai, Imphal
West had been acquired by the State government for
widening the National High Way the area of suit land
has been reduced to 0.225 (zero point two two five)
acre shall hereinafter be meant and referred as the
present suit land and the said area of 0.27 (zero point
two seen) acre shall hereinafter be meant and
referred as the former suit land.
That the defendant No. 1 shall get (Rs. 1,16,910/- +
Rs. 36,769/-) = Rs. 1,53,679/- (Rupees one lakh fifty
three thousand six hundred seventy nine) only and
the plaintiff shall get Rs. 36,769/- (Rupees thirty six
thousand seven hundred sixty nine) only out of the
award of Rs. 1,90,448/- (Rupees one lakh ninety
thousand four hundred forty eight) only issued in the
name of the Y. Chandra Singh for the acquisition of
an area of 0.045 (Zero point zero four five) acre by
the State Government, out of the said former suit land
admeasuring an area 1.27 acre under CS Dag No.
112 under patta No. 42 (Old)/11 (new) of Revenue
Village No. 63- Laiphrakpam Leikai, Imphal West.”
That the defendant No. 1 shall own and possess the
northern half i.e. the area of 0.1125 (zero point one
one two five) acre of the present suit land and plaintiff
shall own and possess the remaining southern half
portion i.e. the area of 0.1125 (zero point one one two
five) acre of the present suit land. The plaintiff and
defendant No. 1 shall voluntarily do handing over and
taking over of possession of their respective share of
land by demolishing any structure found encroaching
upon the share of one another.
That if the plaintiff desires to sell whole or any portion
out of his share, the defendant No. 1 shall have first
option of right to purchase and therefore prior
notice/information shall be given. Similarly if the
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 7
(v)
(vi)
[11]
defendant No. 1 desires to sell whole or any portion
out of his share the plaintiff shall have first option of
right
to
purchase
and
therefore
prior
notice/information shall be given. However there
shall not be such right of first option to purchase
when the transfer is within their respective family
members.
That the plaintiff and defendant No. 1 shall give cooperation to one another for doing the needful for
proper demarcation and preparation of separate
jamabandi in their names.
That the plaintiff and defendant No. 1 shall bear their
respecting own costs of the litigation.”
During the course of hearing, the representatives of the
original plaintiff and original defendant No. 1 inform this Court that they
are authorized by the other LRs and confirm the genuineness of the terms
of settlement and stated that the second appeal may be disposed of in
terms of the agreement.
[12]
This Court has perused the application including the terms
of agreement and after interaction with the representatives of the parties
satisfied that the settlement is genuine and is in the interest of the parties.
Accordingly, the second appeal is disposed of in terms of the above
conditions mentioned in Para 10.
[13]
It is stated that the possession of the suit land is with the
LRs of the original defendant No. 1 and in case upon the division of the
suit land in two halves, the existing structures of the LRs of defendant No.
1 will be affected and require demolition/modification/reallocation and the
same will require a considerable time.
[14]
Accordingly, parties have agreed that the LRs of defendant
No. 1 shall handover the vacant position, half share of the suit land to the
LRs of the plaintiff on or before 31.03.2026. The parties also further agree
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 8
that the existing old structure constructed by defendant No. 4 which is
existing in the middle of the suit land covering shares of both the parties
be preserved as it is.
[15]
The decree of the original court as well as the first appellate
court are modified in terms of the above settlement.
[16]
Registry is directed to prepare the second appellate decree.
[17]
Send a copy of the judgment/decree to the Deputy
Commissioner, Imphal West for entering names of the LRs of plaintiff and
defendant No. 1 in the land record in their respective shares and issue
separate patta in terms of Rule 90 of the MLR & LR Rules, 1961.
JUDGE
Kh. Joshua Maring
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2025.08.05
14:08:27 +05'30'
RSA NO. 5 OF 2016 & MC(RSA) NO. 1 OF 2025
Page 9
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review