Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 10.11.2025
Judgment delivered on: 16.01.2026
W.P.(C) 17385/2024, CM APPL. 74029/2024 & CM APPL.
65260/2025
WORKING NEWS CAMERAMEN’S ASSOCIATION .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Aseem Mehrotra and Ms.
Deeksha Mehrotra, Advs.
versus
PRESS COUNCIL OF INDIA & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, ASG with
Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu Gulati,
Ms. Yamini Singh, Mr. Abhijit
Chakravarty, Ms. Anum Hussain, Ms.
R. Kaur, Ms. Akansha, Mr. S. Kumar,
Mr. T. Srivastava, Mr. P. Rawat, Mr.
Vedant Sood, Advs. for PCI
Ms. Shiva Lakshmi, CGSC with Mr.
Amit Acharya, GP and Mr. Madhav
Bajaj, Adv. for UOI
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TUSHAR RAO GEDELA
JUDGMENT
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, C.J.
CHALLENGE
1.
The instant writ petition filed by an Association of Working News
Cameramen challenges the notice dated 09.06.2024 issued by the Press
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
Council of India (hereinafter referred to as the “Council”) inviting claims
for being notified as an eligible “association of persons” for nomination of
Members of the 15th term of the Council under Rule 3 of the Press Council
(Procedure for Notification of associations of persons) Rules, 2021
(hereinafter referred to as the “Rules, 2021”). The petitioner also challenges
the report dated 10.09.2024 submitted by the Scrutiny Committee whereby a
recommendation has been made to reject the claim of the petitioner/
association as an eligible “association of persons” under the category of
members to be nominated to the Council in terms of Section 5(3)(a) of the
Press Council of India Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”).
2.
The petitioner also challenges the letter of the Council, dated
12.11.2024, whereby it was communicated to the petitioner that the Council
on deliberations on the recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee has
approved the recommendation, enclosing therewith the detailed findings
whereby the claim of the petitioner was rejected.
3.
A further prayer has also been made by the petitioner seeking a
direction to the Council to include its name in the list of eligible
“associations of persons” under Section 5(3)(a) of the Act in the category of
Working Journalists other than Editors for nomination as members to 15th
term of the Council.
FACTS
4.
Press Council of India is a statutory body incorporated under Section
4 of the Act, 1978 and is a body corporate having perpetual succession and a
common seal.
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
5.
Section 5 of the Act, 1978 provides for composition of the Council
which consists of a Chairman and twenty eight other Members. Out of
twenty eight other Members of the Council, thirteen are nominated from
amongst the working Journalists of whom six are Editors of newspapers and
seven are working Journalists other than Editors. Six persons are to be
nominated from amongst persons who own or carry on business of
management of newspapers. One Member is nominated amongst persons
who manage news agencies and three persons are those who have special
knowledge or practical experience in education, science, law and literature
and culture, of whom one is nominated by University Grants Commission,
one by the Bar Council of India and one by the Sahitya Academy. Rest five
Members are Members of Parliament of whom three are nominated by the
Speaker from amongst the Members of the Lok Sabha and two are
nominated by the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha from amongst its Members.
For the purposes of nomination of thirteen Members from amongst working
Journalists and also for nominating six persons from amongst persons who
own or carrying on business of management of newspapers and also for
nominating one Member from persons who manage news agencies, the
retiring Chairperson of the previous Council has to invite panels of names
comprising twice the number of Members to be nominated, from
“associations of persons” of the working Journalists, those who own or carry
on the business of management of newspapers and also those who manage
news agencies. All persons are nominated as Members of the Council by the
Council except in the case of the First Council and on nomination of persons
as Members, the Central Government notifies names of persons nominated
by the Council. So far as the present case is concerned, we are concerned
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
with nominations of working Journalists in terms of Section 5(3)(a) of the
Act, 1978.
6.
Section 5 of the Act, 1978 is extracted herein below:
“5. Composition of the Council.—(1) The Council shall consist of a Chairman
and twenty-eight other members.
(2) The Chairman shall be a person nominated by a Committee consisting of the
Chairman of the Council of States (Rajya Sabha), the Speaker of the House of the
People (Lok Sabha) and a person elected by the members of the Council under
sub-section (6) and the nomination so made shall take effect from the date on
which it is notified by the Central Government in the Official Gazette.
(3) Of the other members—
(a) thirteen shall be nominated in accordance with such procedure as
may be prescribed from among the working journalists, of whom six
shall be editors of newspapers and the remaining seven shall be working
journalists other than editors; so, however, that the number of such
editors and working journalists other than editors in relation to
newspapers published in Indian languages shall be not less than three
and four respectively;
(b) six shall be nominated in accordance with such procedure as may be
prescribed from among persons who own or carry on the business of
management of newspapers, so, however, that there shall be two
representatives from each of the categories of big newspapers, medium
newspapers and small newspapers;
(c) one shall be nominated in accordance with such procedure as may be
prescribed from among persons who manage news agencies;
(d) three shall be persons having special knowledge or practical
experience in respect of education and science, law, and literature and
culture of whom respectively one shall be nominated by the University
Grants Commission, one by the Bar Council of India and one by the
Sahitya Academy;
(e) five shall be members of Parliament of whom three shall be
nominated by the Speaker from among the members of the House of the
People (Lok Sabha) and two shall be nominated by the Chairman of the
Council of States (Rajya Sabha) from among its members:
Provided that no working journalist who owns, or carries on the business of
management of, any newspaper shall be eligible for nomination under clause (a):
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
Provided further that the nominations under clause (a) and clause (b) shall be so
made that among the persons nominated there is not more than one person
interested in any newspaper or group of newspapers under the same control or
management.
[Explanation.—For the purposes of clause (b), a “newspaper” shall be deemed
to be categorised as big, medium or small newspaper on the basis of its
circulation per issue, as the Central Government may, by notification in the
Official Gazette, notify from time to time.]
(4) Before making any nomination under clause (a), clause (b) or clause (c) of
sub-section (3), the Central Government in the case of the first Council and the
retiring Chairman of the previous Council in the case of any subsequent Council
shall, in the prescribed manner, invite panels of names comprising twice the
number of members to be nominated from such associations of persons of the
categories referred to in the said clause (a), clause (b) or clause (c) as may be
notified in this behalf by the Central Government in the case of the first Council
and by the Council itself in the case of subsequent Councils:
Provided that where there is no association of persons of the category referred to
in the said clause (c), the panels of names shall be invited from such news
agencies as may be notified as aforesaid.
(5) The Central Government shall notify the names of persons nominated as
members under sub-section (3) in the Official Gazette and every such nomination
shall take effect from the date on which it is notified.
(6) The members of the Council notified under sub-section (5) shall elect from
among themselves in accordance with such procedure as may be prescribed, a
person to be a member of the Committee referred to in sub-section (2) and a
meeting of the members of the Council for the purpose of such election shall be
presided over by a person chosen from among themselves.”
7.
Prescribing the procedure for notification of “associations of persons”
for the purposes of constitution of the Council, the Central Government has
framed Rules, 2021 in exercise of its powers conferred on it under Section
25 read with Section 5(4) of the Act, 1978. As per Rule 3, in case of a
Council subsequent to the First Council, the retiring Chairman has to invite
filing of claims from eligible “associations of persons” by giving wide
publicity.
Rule 4 of the Rules, 2021 provides for the eligibility of
“association of persons” for being eligible to file claims. According to Rule
4, to be eligible, an “association of persons” must have been registered
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
under the relevant law for at least six years prior to last date of filing of the
claims and must be conducting its business continuously thereafter. Rule 4
also requires the “associations of persons” seeking its nomination to submit
documents duly certified by the competent authority under the relevant law
under which the association is registered.
8.
Rule 5 provides for scrutiny of such claims of “associations of
persons” by a Scrutiny Committee comprising of three persons to be
nominated by the Chairperson from amongst the Members of the Council
and such Scrutiny Committee is required to submit its report to the Council.
Sub Rule 2 of Rule 5 provides that the Council on consideration of the
report submitted by the Scrutiny Committee shall take appropriate decision
and notify the “associations of persons” in terms of the requirement of
Section 5(4)
of the Act, 1978. The Rules, 2021 are extracted herein
below:
“In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 25
read with sub-section (4) of Section 5 of the Press Council Act, 1978 (37 of
1978), the Central Government hereby makes the following rules, namely—
1. Short title and commencement.—(1) These rules may be called the Press
Council (Procedure for Notification of associations of persons) Rules, 2021.
(2) They shall come into force on the date of their publication in the Official
Gazette.
2. Definitions.—In these rules—
(a) “Act” means the Press Council Act, 1978 (37 of 1978);
(b) associations of persons means associations of persons of the
categories referred to in clause (a), clause (b) and clause (c) of subsection (3) of Section 5;
(c) “Committee” means the Scrutiny Committee constituted by the
Chairman under Rule 5 in exercise of powers under Section 8;
(d) “section” means a section of the Act;
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
(e) words and expressions used but not defined herein shall have the
meanings assigned to them in the Act.
3. associations of persons to be notified.—The Central Government in the case
of first Council and the retiring Chairman of the previous Council in the case of
any subsequent Council shall, for the purpose of notifying associations of
persons under sub-section (4) of Section 5, invite filing of claims from eligible
associations of persons by giving wide publicity in at least two widely circulated
national daily newspapers.
4. Eligibility of association of persons.—For being eligible to file claims under
Rule 3, an association of persons must have been registered under the relevant
laws for the time being in force for at least six years prior to last date of filing of
the claims and must be conducting its business continuously thereafter, and shall
submit documents in proof thereof, duly certified by the competent authority
under such relevant laws:
Provided that the memorandum of association of such association of persons
shall not restrict its membership to any particular religion, race, caste or
language.
5. Scrutiny of Claims.—(1) The claims filed by associations of persons under
Rule 3 shall be scrutinized by a Scrutiny Committee consisting of three persons
to be nominated by the Chairman from amongst members of the Council who are
not associated in any manner with any of such claimant associations and shall
submit its report to the Council.
(2) The Council shall, after considering the report submitted by the
Scrutiny Committee, take appropriate decision and notify the
associations of persons as required under sub-section (4) of Section 5:
Provided that where the decision of the Council is at variance with the
recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee, such decision shall be taken by not
less than three-fourth majority of members, other than members of the Scrutiny
Committee, present and voting, and in case of equality of votes, the Chairman
shall have the casting vote.”
9.
The term of the 14th Press Council of India expired on 05.10.2024.
Before the expiry of its term, the Council issued a notice on 09.06.2024
inviting filing of claims for notification of “associations of persons” for
constituting 15th Press Council of India under Rule 3 of the Rules, 2021.
The notice dated 09.06.2024 mentions eligibility of “association of persons”
which is extracted herein below:
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
“Eligibility of association of persons:
association of persons must have following:
a) It must have been registered under the relevant laws for the time being in
force for at least six years prior to last date of filing of the claims;
b) It must be conducting its business continuously thereafter, and shall submit
documents in proof thereof, duly certified by the competent authority under
such relevant laws;
c) The Memorandum of Association (MoA) of such association of persons shall
not restrict its membership to any particular religion, race, caste or
language.
The claims shall be filed in a sealed envelope superscribed “Claims with the name of the
Association” on the letter head of the association carrying the registered address for
correspondence, email i.d., contact numbers with the CHAIRPERSON PRESS COUNCIL
OF INDIA, SOOCHNA BHAWAN, 8, CGO COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD, NEW DELHI110003, so as to reach on or before 5:00 PM of 24thJuly, 2024.”
10.
The said notice also mentioned the supportive documents to be filed
which are as under:
“SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED
The claims should be accompanied by supportive documents showing that
the associations eligible in terms of the Act and the Rules made thereunder
to represent anyone of the categories set out above and also to establish
that it is qualified to represent the category under which it is staking its
claim.
Following documents authenticated by Notary Public need to be filed:
(a)
A copy of the MoA/Constitution/MoU of the Association;
(b)
Copy of the Registration Certificate of the claimant body,
with up to date renewal certificate wherever applicable;
(c)
Minutes of the General Body meetings for the last six years
preceding the issuance of advertisement filed before the
appropriate authority i.e. Registrar of Societies or such authorities
under relevant laws under which the associations of persons is
registered to show their existence for at least six years prior to last
date of filing of the claims;
(d)
Certificate of the Competent Authority under relevant law
in the following format:
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
Dated:
Certificate
I ________________ (Full Name) do hereby certify
________________ (Name of the Association) has been
registered/incorporated under (Name of the Act) on_________
(Date, Month & Year) and conducting its business continuously
thereafter.
(Signature and Seal of the Competent Authority)
(e) An upto date detailed list of its members representing the
category under which the claim is being filed with complete
particulars as set out below, in hardcopy as well as soft copy in
Pen Drive:
(1) SURNAME, FIRST NAME
(2) RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS OF THE MEMBER(S)
(3) TITLE OF THE NEWSPAPER BEING REPRESENTED ALONGWITH
REGISTRATION NUMBER
(4) LANGUAGE IN WHICH THE NEWSPAPER IS PUBLISHED
(5) NEWSPAPER PUBLICATION ADDRESS ALONG WITH STATE
NAME
(6) OFFICE ADDRESS WITH NAME OF THE STATE AT WHICH THE
MEMBER IS CURRENTLY POSTED
(7) DESIGNATION IN THE NEWSPAPER i.e. EDITOR, WORKING
JOURNALIST OTHER THAN EDITORS, OWNER/PUBLISHER
ORMANAGER
(8) CIRCULATION OF THE NEWSPAPER OWNED OR MANAGED BY
THE MEMBER [INFORMATION REGARDING THIS POINT TO BE
PROVIDED BY ASSOCIATIONS FILING CLAIM UNDER SECTION
5(3)(b)]
(9) WHETHER MEMBER OF ANY OTHER PARALLEL ASSOCIATION
(10)YEAR OF JOINING THE ASSOCIATION AND
(11)MEMBERSHIP FEE UPTO DATE OR OUTSTANDING
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
THE ASSOCIATION SHALL SPECIFY THE CATEGORY UNDER
WHICH THEYARE STAKING THEIR CLAIM.
The President/Secretary/authorized signatory to the association shall
make and subscribe to a declaration to be sworn before the Notary Public,
verifying that he/she has been duly authorized by the association of
persons to file the claim and the facts stated in the claim application and
the particulars attached thereto are true to the best of his/her knowledge
and belief and information.
The claimant association shall also subscribe to a declaration establishing
that the claim of the said body is valid and free from all
encumbrances/disputes/litigation. The Press Council may at its discretion
reject any claim if any such encumbrances are brought to its notice.
No claim made by any person other than a person duly authorized under
the Constitution of the association shall be entertained.
Any claim not in conformity with the above is liable to be rejected.
The Press Council of India will be within its right to call for such
additional information or verify such information as might be considered
necessary.
The associations notified for the present term of the Press Council (20212024) may also take note of this Notice and file fresh claim applications.
The list of the claimant's Associations shall be published on the website of
the Council on or before 25thJuly, 2024. Any person can file objection
questioning the eligibility of claimant’s Associations by 1stAugust, 2024.
The claims shall be decided by the Scrutiny Committee thereafter.
No claim made after 5:00 PM of 24thJuly, 2024 will be entertained.”
11.
The notice dated 09.06.2024 also required the claimant association to
subscribe a declaration establishing that claim of the concerned association
is valid and free from all encumbrances/disputes/litigations. It also provided
that the Council may at its discretion reject any claim if any such
encumbrances are bought to its notice. According to the said notice, no
claim made by a person other than a person duly authorized under the
constitution of the association shall be entertained and any claim which is
found not in conformity with such requirements is liable to be rejected. It
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
was further provided therein that the Press Council of India will be within its
right to call for such additional information or verify such additional
information as might be considered necessary.
12.
Pursuant to the impugned notice dated 09.06.2024, the petitioner
submitted its application which was considered along with other applications
for the claim of nomination as eligible “association of persons” by the
Scrutiny Committee which submitted its report/ recommendation on
10.09.2024. In respect of the application of the petitioner, recommendation
made by the Scrutiny Committee in its report dated 10.09.2024 was to reject
the said application for reasons stated in the said recommendations. The
recommendation made in respect of the petitioner by the Scrutiny
Committee is as follows:
“
17.
13.
Working News
1. Copy of Constitution bears the stamp of
notary but signature of authentication
Cameramen's Association
missing.
filed by Shri notary Sandeep
Shankar, General Secretary 2. The stamp paper of declarations by claimant
does not bear the signature of notary.
3. Not submitted Minutes of General Body
meeting for three financial years.
4. List of Members not notarized
5. No proof whether minutes of all the financial
years were submitted before the appropriate
authority
”
The Press Council of India vide impugned notification dated
28.10.2024 notified the “associations of persons” pertaining to different
categories, including the category with which we are concerned with in this
matter, namely, the category as contemplated in Section 5(3)(a) of the Act,
1978, however, accepting the recommendation made by the Scrutiny
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
Committee dated 10.09.2024, name of the petitioner was not included in the
List of “associations of persons” as notified by the Council on 28.10.2024.
14.
It may also be noted that the recommendation made by the Scrutiny
Committee dated 10.09.2024 was considered by the Council in its meeting
held on 27.09.2024 whereby, all the recommendations made by the Scrutiny
Committee were accepted, including the recommendation of rejection in
respect of the petitioner. The relevant extract of the Minutes of the Meeting
of the Press Council of India held on 27.09.2024 is quotes hereunder:
“Rule 5. Scrutiny of Claims.- ( 1) The claims filed by associations of
persons under rule 3 shall be scrutinized by a Scrutiny Committee consisting
of three persons to be nominated by the Chairman from amongst members or
(he Council who are not associated in any manner with any of such claimant
associations and shall submit its report to the Council.
(2) The Council shall, after considering the report submitted by the Scrutiny
Committee ,take appropriate decision and notify the associations of persons
as required under subsection (4) of section 5.
Provided that where the decision of the Council is at variance with the
recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee, such decision shall be taken by
not less than three fourth majority of members, other than members of the
Scrutiny Committee, present and voting, and in case of equality of votes, the
Chairman shall have the casting vote.
The Council proceeded to consider the report of the Scrutiny
Committee. All the claims in the Scrutiny Committee report (attached as
annexure A) and recommendations thereupon were read out before the full
Council and disapprovals, if any, on each decision were sought. Not a single
decision could muster three fourth (3/4th) of total members present (1
member through video conferencing) and voting (17). Accordingly, the
Council adopted the Scrutiny Committee report in its entirety by majority.
However, eight votes were against the recommendations in case of Claim
No. 27 i.e. Mumbai Press Club filed under the Category Working Journalists
other than Editors.”
15.
After notifying the eligible “associations of persons”, the Council vide
notification dated 13.11.2024 invited panels of names comprising twice the
requisite number of working journalists from the “associations of persons”
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
notified vide notification dated 28.10.2024 for nomination to the Council as
its members in terms of Section 5(4) of the Act, 1978.
16.
The petitioner initially chose not to challenge either the notification
dated 28.10.2024 issued by the Press Council of India, nor the report of the
Scrutiny Committee dated 10.09.2024. The instant petition was filed only on
16.12.2024, that too when W.P.(C) 16202/2024 filed by the Press Club,
Mumbai in respect of the recommendation made for rejection of its claim
was allowed by a learned Single Judge of this Court by means of the
judgment and order dated 22.11.2024.
17.
It is noticed that before the petitioner instituted the instant writ
petition, the notification dated 28.10.2024 was already acted upon in the
sense that pursuant to the said notification, the Council issued another
notification dated 13.11.2024, inviting panels of names for the purpose of
nomination to the Council as its Members in terms of Section 5(4) of the
Act. The petitioner also did not challenge the notice dated 09.06.2024
before filing of the instant writ petition and, in fact, yielded to the said
notice and submitted its application pursuant thereto. It is this notice dated
09.06.2024 and the report of the Scrutiny Committee dated 10.09.2024
which have now been challenged by the petitioner by instituting the present
writ petition only on 16.12.2024. The petitioner, as already stated above,
has also challenged the rejection of its representation vide letter dated
12.11.2024, without making any challenge to the notification dated
28.10.2024 issued by the Council whereby the recommendation made by the
impugned report of the Scrutiny Committee dated 10.09.2024 were accepted
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
including the recommendation made in respect of the petitioner for rejection
of its claim.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
18.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the impugned
notice dated 09.06.2024 prescribes certain eligibilities for an “association of
persons” to be eligible for nomination which are beyond the Rules, 2021. In
this regard, it has further been argued that the requirement of submission of
notarized documents as prescribed by the impugned notice dated 09.06.2024
is inconsistent with the provisions of the Notaries Act, 1952 (hereinafter
referred to as the “Notaries Act”) inasmuch as that Section 8 of the Notaries
Act while prescribing the functions of notaries provides that notaries may
discharge certain functions by virtue of their office, including verification,
authentication, certification or attestation of execution of any instrument,
however, as per Section 2(b) of the Notaries Act, the documents required to
be submitted by the petitioner/ association as per the impugned notice dated
09.06.2024 cannot be termed to be an instrument for the reason that such
instrument, in terms of the said definition, include documents by which any
right or liability is or purported to be created, transferred, modified, limited,
extended, suspended, extinguished or recorded. It is his submission that
only such instruments as described in Section 2(b) of the Notaries Act can
be notarized as one of the functions ascribed to a Notary Public in terms of
Section 8(1)(a) of the Notaries Act.
19.
On behalf of the petitioner, it has thus been submitted that such
requirement in the notice dated 09.06.2024 for determination of the
eligibility of the petitioner/ association to be nominated as an eligible
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
“association of persons” being contrary to Section 8(1)(a) read with Section
2(b) of the Notaries Act vitiates the impugned notice dated 09.06.2024.
20.
Certain judgments have been cited on behalf of the petitioner to assert
that if an advertisement is inconsistent with the statutory rules, the same
cannot be acted upon as the same would be beyond the scope of the Rules.
Reliance in this regard has been placed by learned counsel for the petitioner
on the following judgments:
i.
Malik Mazhar Sultan and Another v. U.P. Public Service Commission
and Others, (2006) 9 SCC 507
ii.
Raminder Singh v. State of Punjab and Another, (2016) 16 SCC 95
iii.
Ashish Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others, (2018) 3 SCC 55
21.
It has also been contended by learned counsel for the petitioner
impeaching the impugned action on the part of the respondents, that before
rejecting the claim of the petitioner, no opportunity of hearing was provided.
As such the impugned action is vitiated for want of observance of principles
of natural justice.
22.
The petitioner also seeks parity with the judgment rendered by the
learned Single Judge on 22.11.2024 in W.P.(C.) No. 16202/2024, subject
matter of which pertained to notification of eligible “association of persons”
for the purposes of constitution of the 15th term of the Council.
23.
In respect of the objections, on the basis of which the claim of the
petitioner was recommended to be rejected by the Scrutiny Committee by
the impugned report dated 10.09.2024, learned counsel for the petitioner has
stated that the reasons given for rejection of the claim of the petitioner are
not tenable.
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
24.
Regarding the first objection/reason given by the Scrutiny Committee
to the effect that copy of the constitution of the petitioner though bears the
stamp of Notary, however, the signature of Notary for authentication is
missing, it has been argued that such a reason is contrary to the record. He
has stated that the Notary Public’s seal is available on all the five pages of
the constitution and it also contains his signature with the seal and date of
attestation. Our attention was drawn in this regard to the said document,
which is available at page 54 of the paper book.
25.
As regards the second objection/reason for rejection of the claim of
the petitioner by the Scrutiny Committee to the effect that stamp paper of
declaration submitted by the petitioner does not bear the signature of the
Notary, it has been stated by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
said objection is also contrary to record inasmuch as that seal of the Public
Notary is available on both pages with his signature on the second page of
the declaration. We have been taken through the said document by the
learned counsel for the petitioner which is at pages 71-72 of the paper book.
26.
In respect of the third objection/reason taken by the Scrutiny
Committee for recommending the claim of the petitioner as rejected, namely
non-submission of minutes of General Body Meeting for three financial
years, it has been argued on behalf of the petitioner that as per Section 4 of
the Societies Registration Act, once in every year, on or before the
fourteenth day succeeding the day on which, according to the rules of the
society, the annual general meeting of the society is held, or, if the rules do
not provide for an annual general meeting, in the month of January, a list
shall be filed with the Registrar containing the names, addresses and
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
occupation of the Members of the Governing Body who are entrusted with
the management of the affairs of the society.
27.
He has further stated that so far as the constitution/rules of the
petitioner-society are concerned, the same do not provide for holding
meeting of the General Body on annual basis rather, as per its constitution,
the meeting of the General Body of the petitioner is to be held once in every
three years and, accordingly, requirement of submission of the minutes of
General Body Meeting for three financial years was an impossibility in case
of the petitioner – association. In this view, the submission is that insistence
on the part of the Scrutiny Committee or even by the Council on fulfillment
of requirement of submission of minutes of General Body Meeting for three
financial years is non-workable so far as the petitioner is concerned and,
therefore, on the basis of such a reasoning, the petitioner could not have
been held ineligible.
28.
As regards the reason given by the Scrutiny Committee in respect of
the claim of the petitioner for being notified as an eligible “association of
persons” to the effect that the list of Members was not notarized, it has been
argued on behalf of the petitioner that the list of members with full details
was submitted and that non-notarization of list of Members cannot lead to
rejection of the claim of the petitioner as there is no requirement of
notarization under the scheme of the Act or the Rules.
29.
In respect of the objection taken by the Scrutiny Committee to the
eligibility of the petitioner to the effect that no proof was submitted by the
petitioner of submission of minutes to the appropriate authority (the
Registrar of Societies) pertaining to all the financial years, it has been
submitted on behalf of the petitioner that such an objection merits rejection
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
for the reason that the petitioner has been complying with the provisions of
the Societies Registration Act and it has also been submitting the list of
elected office bearers every year and further, that the list so submitted bears
the signatures of the District Magistrate.
30.
On the aforesaid counts, it has been argued by learned counsel for the
petitioner that the objections taken and the reasons given by the Scrutiny
Committee for recommending the claim of the petitioner to be rejected are
untenable.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NO.1
31.
Vehemently opposing the writ petition, Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee,
learned ASG representing the respondent No.1 – Council, has argued that in
absence of any challenge to the notice dated 09.06.2024, before filing of the
proceedings of this writ petition, which is now being challenged, bars any
such challenge once the petitioner had acted upon the said notice by
submitting its claim application thereunder without any protest. In this
regard, reliance has been placed by Mr. Banerjee on Tarun Kataria v.
Union of India and Others, 2024 SCC OnLine Del 935 and Union of India
v. C. Girija and Others, (2019) 15 SCC 633.
32.
Mr. Banerjee has also argued that the instant writ petition suffers from
the vice of inordinate delay. In this regard, it has been stated that the
Scrutiny Committee made its recommendation on 10.09.2024 which was
considered by the Council in its meeting held on 27.09.2024 and thereafter,
the eligible “associations of persons” were notified vide notification dated
28.10.2024, however, the petitioner approached this Court only on
16.12.2024 after considerable delay, that too only on learning about the
judgment of this Court in W.P.(C.) No. 16202/2024.
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
33.
According to Mr. Banerjee, such delay in filing the instant writ
petition disentitles the petitioner to claim any relief for the reason that the
entire process is for constitution of the Council whose term had expired way
back on 05.10.2024.
34.
It has also been argued on behalf of respondent No.1 that the
explanation sought to be given by the petitioner to the objection/reasons
given by the Scrutiny Committee while making recommendation for
rejection of the claim of the petitioner are incorrect and legally untenable.
35.
He has argued that the notice dated 09.06.2024 required the claimant
associations to submit notarized documents for the reason that the
documents required are self generated by the claimant associations and for
authentication of such documents, notarization was required.
36.
Drawing our attention to the document at page No.71 of the paper
book which is the declaration submitted by the petitioner, it has been stated
on behalf of the respondent No.1 that the said document does not bear the
signature of the Public Notary at page No.1 and, therefore, the explanation
offered by the petitioner in this respect is factually incorrect.
37.
Similarly, in respect of non-notarization of list of members submitted
by the petitioner, it has been stated that it was a mandatory requirement in
terms of the notice dated 09.06.2024 and in absence of any challenge to the
said notice dated 09.06.2024 prior to institution of the instant writ petition,
any challenge by the petitioner to the said notice now will be barred keeping
in view the fact that the petitioner acted upon the said notice and made its
application for consideration of its claim without any demur or protest.
38.
It has been vehemently argued by Mr. Banerjee that the application
submitted by the petitioner for being declared as an eligible “association of
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
persons” did not contain the requisite documents and, therefore, the Scrutiny
Committee has rightly rejected its claim.
39.
On the aforesaid counts, it has been urged by Mr. Banerjee that the
writ petition be dismissed.
ANALYSIS
40.
The foremost question which needs our consideration in this case is as
to whether the writ petition suffers from the vice of inordinate delay and
laches which disentitles the petitioner to seek any relief as has been prayed
for, keeping in view the nature of exercise undertaken by the Council which
is for the purposes of constitution of the 15th Council as the term of the 14th
Council had expired on 05.10.2024.
41.
It is to be noted that without making any challenge to the notice dated
09.06.2024, which is now being challenged in the instant writ petition, the
petitioner acting upon the said notice submitted its application and thereafter
the recommendation by the Scrutiny Committee for rejecting the claim of
the petitioner was made on 10.09.2024.
On the basis of the said
recommendation, the notification dated 28.10.2024 was issued by the
Council which contained a list of the eligible “associations of persons”,
wherein the name of the petitioner association was not mentioned, which is
based on the recommendation made by the Scrutiny Committee in its report
dated 10.09.2024.
42.
The petitioner also did not challenge either the report of the Scrutiny
Committee dated 10.09.2024 or the notification dated 28.10.2024 before
filing the instant writ petition. We may also note that the recommendation
made by the Scrutiny Committee was approved by the Council on
28.10.2024, pursuant to which a further notice was issued by the Council on
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
13.11.2024, inviting panel of names comprising twice the requisite number
of Working Journalists from the eligible “associations of persons” notified
vide notification dated 28.10.2024 for nomination to the Council as its
Members in terms of Section 5(4) of the Act.
43.
Thus, the notification dated 28.10.2024 was acted upon by the
Council by issuing the notification dated 13.11.2024. It is only thereafter
that the petitioner instituted the proceedings of this writ petition on
16.12.2024.
44.
We are of the considered opinion that delay in filing the instant writ
petition is fatal to the prayers made herein for the reason that the
recommendation of the Scrutiny Committee, dated 10.09.2024 and the
notification issued by the Council, dated 28.10.2024 are in the process of
constitution of the 15th term of the Council and, therefore, not taking prompt
steps to challenge the impugned notice dated 09.06.2024 and to the report of
the Scrutiny Committee is deleterious, as the process of constitution of the
Council needs to be continued, in our view, without any unwanted
interruption.
45.
The Council, as already observed above, is a body corporate which
discharges certain essential and important statutory functions and hence its
continuance is essential. Therefore, for this reason alone the petitioner was
expected to act promptly if it intended to challenge the notice dated
09.06.2024 or the recommendation of the Scrutiny Committee made on
10.09.2024, which have now been challenged by the petitioner by instituting
the instant writ petition with inordinate delay.
46.
For the aforesaid reasons, we hold that the petitioner, by not acting
with requisite promptness to challenge the impugned notice dated
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
09.06.2024 and the recommendation of the Scrutiny Committee made on
10.09.2024 is disentitled to invoke the discretionary jurisdiction of this
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and seek any relief.
47.
As already observed above, the petitioner is now challenging the
notice dated 09.06.2024, though pursuant to the said notice, the petitioner
participated in the process and submitted its claim for being notified as an
eligible “association of persons”.
Once the petitioner submitted its
application pursuant to the notice dated 09.06.2024 without protest, in our
opinion, it cannot be permitted now to challenge the same; rather, such a
challenge is barred for the reason that the petitioner had submitted its claim
without any protest or demur.
48.
The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner
in the instant writ petition is entitled to parity with the judgment dated
22.11.2024 passed by this Court in W.P.(C.) No. 16202/2024 is also not
tenable for the reason that the said writ petition has been decided on its own
merit and on the basis of the facts pleaded in the said writ petition. It is to
be noticed that the said writ petition was filed within reasonable time and
hence on this count also the petitioner is not entitled to seek any parity with
the petitioner of the said writ petition.
49.
Since we are not exercising our discretion under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India to entertain this writ petition on the ground of
inordinate and fatal delay in institution of this writ petition and also for the
reason that challenge to the notice dated 09.06.2024 is not available to the
petitioner at this stage as the petitioner had acted upon the said notice by
submitting its claim for being declared as an eligible “association of
persons”, we need not go into the merits of the factual aspects of the matter.
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
50.
We are, therefore, not inclined to interfere in this writ petition which
is hereby dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
(DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA)
CHIEF JUSTICE
(TUSHAR RAO GEDELA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 16, 2026
N.Khanna
W.P.(C) 17385/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review