Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgement delivered on: 28.01.2026
+
ARB.P. 1479/2025
WINFRA BUILD TECH PRIVATE LIMITED
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Atul Verma, Advocate.
versus
NKG INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Manish Gupta, Mr. Mehul
Jain, Ms. Payal Singh, Ms.
Riya, Mr. Nikhil Malik, Ms.
Shipra Bhardwaj, Mr. Vivek
Chandrasekhar,
Mr.
Yash
Tiwari, Ms. Manaswee Gupta,
Mr. Ravi and Ms. Sowmya
China, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGEMENT (ORAL)
1.
The present petition has been filed under Section 11(6) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 19961, seeking the appointment of
a Sole Arbitrator for adjudication of the disputes alleged to have arisen
between the parties out of the Work Order/Purchase Order dated
08.02.2024.
2.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner places reliance upon Clause
29 of the Purchase Order dated 08.02.20242, which has been
Act
Purchase Order
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
annexed as ‘Document No. D1’ to the present petition. The said clause
reads as under: “29. Dispute Resolution:
1. All dispute and claims will be mutually discussed and agreed
upon at site level. in case of any difference of opinion, the decision
of “Contracts Head” of NKG Infrastructure shall be final and
binding.
2. Arbitrators, if needed shall be appointed by NKG Infrastructure
Ltd in Delhi only.
3. Any further dispute shall be settled in courts of jurisdiction of
Delhi.”
3.
It is the case of the Petitioner that disputes subsequently arose
between the parties, pursuant to which arbitration was invoked by way
of a legal notice dated 22.07.2025. It is contended that despite the
invocation of arbitration, no Arbitrator was appointed by the
Respondent, compelling the Petitioner to approach this Court by filing
the present petition.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the Respondent, however,
submits that there exists no valid or enforceable arbitration agreement
between the parties. It is urged that Clause 29 of the Purchase Order,
as relied upon by the Petitioner, is vague, ambiguous, and does not
unequivocally provide for arbitration as the agreed and definitive
mechanism for the resolution of disputes between the parties.
5.
Learned counsel for the Respondent further submits that the
clause merely reflects a tentative or optional possibility of arbitration,
evident from the use of the expression “Arbitrators, if needed”. It is
argued that such language demonstrates the absence of a firm and
binding consensus ad idem between the parties to mandatorily refer
disputes to arbitration. Reliance is placed upon the judgments of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court, stating that an arbitration agreement must
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
reflect a clear, unambiguous, and definitive intention of the parties to
submit disputes to arbitration, without requiring any further consent at
a later stage. In the absence of such clarity, the disputes cannot be
referred to arbitration.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that
Clause 29 constitutes an arbitration clause and that the appointment of
the Arbitrator ought to be made in terms thereof.
7.
Learned counsel for the parties have been heard at length, and
with their able assistance, this Court has carefully perused the paper
book and other materials placed on record.
8.
There is a consistent and settled line of precedent laid down by
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court to the effect that the intention of the
parties to enter into an arbitration agreement must be gathered from
the terms of the agreement as a whole. Where the terms clearly
indicate an intention to refer disputes to a tribunal for adjudication and
a willingness to be bound by its decision, such clause would constitute
an arbitration agreement.
9.
It is equally well settled that where there is a clear and specific
expression of intent to resolve disputes through arbitration, it is not
necessary for the clause to expressly incorporate all the attributes of an
arbitration agreement. However, where the dispute resolution clause
contains language that either excludes essential attributes of
arbitration, or contemplates a future or fresh consent of the parties for
reference to arbitration, or otherwise detracts from the binding nature
of arbitration, such a clause cannot be construed as an arbitration
agreement. Mere use of the words “arbitration” or “arbitrator” is not
determinative, particularly where the clause is couched in tentative or
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
conditional terms. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court, in BGM & M-RPLJMCT (JV) v. Eastern Coalfields Ltd.3, made various pertinent
observations, which read as under:
“20. Before we proceed to consider whether Clause 13 would
constitute an arbitration agreement, it would be useful to examine
the law as to when an arbitration agreement comes into existence.
An arbitration agreement is the foundation of arbitration as it
records the consent of the parties to submit their disputes to
arbitration. Section 2(b) of the 1996 Act defines an arbitration
agreement to mean an agreement referred to in Section 78. In Bihar
State Mineral Development Corporation v. Encon Builders9, this
Court culled out the essential ingredients of an arbitration
agreement as follows : (a) there must be a present or future
difference in connection with some contemplated affair; (b) the
parties must intend to settle such difference by a private tribunal;
(c) the parties must agree in writing to be bound by the decision of
such tribunal; and (d) the parties must be ad idem.
21. In Cox and Kings Limited v. SAP India Private Limited10, a
Constitution Bench of this Court held:
“61. An arbitration agreement is a contractual undertaking
by two or more parties to resolve their disputes by the
process of arbitration, even if the disputes themselves are
not based on contractual obligations. An arbitration
agreement is a conclusive proof that the parties have
consented to submit their dispute to an arbitral tribunal to
the exclusion of domestic courts. The basis for an
arbitration agreement is generally traced to the contractual
freedom of parties to codify their intention to consensually
submit their disputes to an alternative dispute resolution
process.”
22. The principles regarding what constitutes an arbitration
agreement were summarized by this Court in Jagdish
Chander (supra) in the following terms:—
“8. …..this Court held that a clause in a contract can be
construed as an „arbitration agreement‟ only if an
agreement to refer disputes or differences to arbitration is
expressly or impliedly spelt out from the clause. We may
at this juncture set out the well settled principles in regard
to what constitutes an arbitration agreement:
(i) The intention of the parties to enter into an arbitration
agreement shall have to be gathered from the terms of the
agreement. If the terms of the agreement clearly indicate
an intention on the part of the parties to the agreement to
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1471 made
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
refer their disputes to a private tribunal for adjudication
and a willingness to be bound by the decision of such
tribunal on such disputes, it is arbitration agreement.
While there is no specific form of an arbitration
agreement, the words used should disclose a determination
and obligation to go to arbitration and not merely
contemplate the possibility of going for arbitration. Where
there is merely a possibility of the parties agreeing to
arbitration in future, as contrasted from an obligation to
refer disputes to arbitration, there is no valid and binding
arbitration agreement.
(ii) Even if the words „arbitration‟ and „arbitral tribunal (or
arbitrator)‟ are not used with reference to the process of
settlement or with reference to the private tribunal which
has to adjudicate upon the disputes, in a clause relating to
settlement of disputes, it does not detract from the clause
being an arbitration agreement if it has the attributes or
elements of an arbitration agreement. They are : (a) The
agreement should be in writing. (b) The parties should
have agreed to refer any disputes (present or future)
between them to the decision of a private tribunal. (c) The
private tribunal should be empowered to adjudicate upon
the disputes in an impartial manner, giving due
opportunity to the parties to put forth their case before it.
(d) The parties should have agreed that the decision of the
private tribunal in respect of the disputes will be binding
on them.
(iii) Where the clause provides that in the event of disputes
arising between the parties, the disputes shall be referred
to arbitration, it is an arbitration agreement. Where there is
a specific and direct expression of intent to have the
disputes settled by arbitration, it is not necessary to set out
the attributes of an arbitration agreement to make it an
arbitration agreement. But where the clause relating to
settlement of disputes, contains words which specifically
excludes any of the attributes of an arbitration agreement
or contains anything that detracts from an arbitration
agreement, it will not be an arbitration agreement. For
example, where an agreement requires or permits an
authority to decide a claim or dispute without hearing, or
requires the authority to act in the interests of only one of
the parties, or provides that the decision of the Authority
will not be final and binding on the parties, or that if either
party is not satisfied with the decision of the Authority, he
may file a civil suit seeking relief, it cannot be termed as
an arbitration agreement.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
(iv) But mere use of the word „arbitration‟ or „arbitrator‟
in a clause will not make it an arbitration agreement, if it
requires or contemplates a further or fresh consent of the
parties for reference to arbitration. For example, use of
words such as “parties can, if they so desire, refer their
disputes to arbitration” or “in the event of any dispute, the
parties may also agree to refer the same to arbitration” or
“if any disputes arise between the parties, they should
consider settlement by arbitration” in a clause relating to
settlement of disputes, indicate that the clause is not
intended to be an arbitration agreement. Similarly, a clause
which states that “if the parties so decide, the disputes
shall be referred to arbitration” or “any disputes between
parties, if they so agree, shall be referred to arbitration” is
not an arbitration agreement. Such clauses merely indicate
a desire or hope to have the disputes settled by arbitration,
or a tentative arrangement to explore arbitration as a mode
of settlement if and when a dispute arises. Such clauses
require the parties to arrive at a further agreement to go to
arbitration, as and when the disputes arise. Any agreement
or clause in an agreement requiring or contemplating a
further consent or consensus before a reference to
arbitration, is not an arbitration agreement, but an
agreement to enter into an arbitration agreement in
future.”
(Emphasis supplied)
23. In Jagdish Chander (supra), the issue that arose for
consideration was whether paragraph 16 in the partnership
agreement constituted an arbitration agreement. Clause 16 under
consideration there, is extracted below:
“16) If during the continuance of the partnership or at any
time afterwards any dispute touching the partnership arises
between the partners, the same shall be mutually decided
by the partners or shall be referred for arbitration if the
parties so determine.”
While holding that clause 16 did not constitute an arbitration
agreement, this Court observed:
“9. Para 16 of the Partnership deed provides that if there is
any dispute touching the partnership arising between the
partners, the same shall be mutually decided by the parties
or shall be referred to arbitration if the parties so
determine. If the clause had merely said that in the event
of disputes arising between the parties, they “shall be
referred to arbitration”, it would have been an arbitration
agreement. But the use of the words “shall be referred for
arbitration if the parties so determine” completely changes
the complexion of the provision. The expression
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
“determine” indicates that the parties are required to reach
a decision by application of mind. Therefore, when clause
16 uses the words “the dispute shall be referred for
arbitration if the parties so determine”, it means that it is
not an arbitration agreement but a provision which enables
arbitration only if the parties mutually decide after due
consideration as to whether the disputes should be referred
to arbitration or not. In effect, the clause requires the
consent of parties before the disputes can be referred to
arbitration. The main attribute of an arbitration agreement,
namely, consensus ad idem to refer the disputes to
arbitration is missing in clause 16 relating to settlement of
disputes. Therefore, it is not an arbitration agreement, as
defined under section 7 of the Act. In the absence of an
arbitration agreement, the question of exercising power
under section 11 of the Act to appoint an Arbitrator does
not arise.”
(Emphasis supplied)
24. In Mahanadi Coalfields (supra), this court was required to
consider whether clause 15 constituted an arbitration agreement.
Clause 15 under consideration there, is extracted below:
“15. Settlement of Disputes/Arbitration:
15.1 It is incumbent upon the contractor to avoid litigation
and disputes during the course of execution. However, if
such disputes take place between the contractor and the
department, effort shall be made first to settle the disputes
at the company level. The contractor should make request
in writing to the Engineer-in-Charge for settlement of such
disputes/claims within 30 (thirty) days of arising of the
case of dispute/claim failing which no disputes/claims of
the contractor shall be entertained by the company.
15.2 If differences still persist, the settlement of the
dispute with Govt. Agencies shall be dealt with as per the
Guidelines issued by the Ministry of Finance, Govt. of
India in this regard. In case of parties other than Govt.
Agencies, the redressal of the disputes may be sought in
the Court of Law.”
25. Following the decision in Jagdish Chander (supra), this Court,
in Mahanadi Coalfields (supra), held that Clause 15 of the Contract
Agreement though is titled “Settlement of Disputes/Arbitration”,
the substantive part of it makes it abundantly clear that there is no
arbitration agreement between the parties to refer either present or
future dispute to arbitration.
26. What is clear from the judgment in Mahanadi
Coalfields (supra) is that mere use of the word “arbitration” or
“arbitrator” in a clause will not make it an arbitration agreement, if
it requires or contemplates a further or fresh consent of the parties
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
for reference to arbitration. In Jagdish Chander (supra), use of
words such as “parties can, if they so desire, refer their disputes to
arbitration”, or “in the event of any dispute, the parties may also
agree to refer the same to arbitration”, or “if any disputes arise
between the parties, they should consider settlement by
arbitration”, in a clause relating to settlement of disputes, were
found not indicative of an arbitration agreement. Similarly, a clause
which states that “if the parties so decide, the disputes shall be
referred to arbitration” or “any disputes between parties, if they so
agree, shall be referred to arbitration” would not constitute an
arbitration agreement. Because such clauses merely indicate a
desire or hope to have the disputes settled by arbitration, or a
tentative arrangement to explore arbitration as a mode of settlement
if and when a dispute arises. This is so, because such clauses
require the parties to arrive at a further agreement to go to
arbitration, as and when disputes arise. Therefore, any agreement,
or clause in an agreement, requiring or contemplating a further
consent or consensus before a reference to arbitration, is not an
arbitration agreement.”
10.
In view of the aforesaid settled legal position, and upon a
careful consideration of Clause 29 of the Purchase Order, this Court
finds that the clause fails to fulfill the attributes of a valid arbitration
agreement. The clause first provides for the resolution of disputes
through mutual discussion at the site level, followed by a mechanism
wherein the decision of the “Contracts Head” of the Respondent is
stated to be final and binding.
11.
The subsequent use of the expression “Arbitrators, if needed”
renders the purported arbitration mechanism uncertain, conditional,
and non-mandatory. The clause does not unequivocally demonstrate a
binding obligation upon the parties to refer disputes to arbitration.
Rather, it contemplates arbitration only as a contingent possibility,
dependent upon a further determination of necessity. Such language
introduces ambiguity and makes it impossible to discern, without
doubt, that the parties had agreed to arbitration as the exclusive or
mandatory mode of dispute resolution.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
12.
Consequently, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
objection raised by the Respondent is well-founded. Clause 29 of the
Purchase Order, as it stands, is clearly ambiguous and does not
constitute a valid and enforceable arbitration agreement under the Act.
There is no positive or unequivocal mandate for resorting to
arbitration as a means of adjudication of disputes between the parties.
13.
In view of the above, the reliefs sought in the present petition
cannot be granted. The petition is accordingly dismissed.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J
JANUARY 28, 2026/nd/sm
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:47:02
ARB.P. 1479/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review