Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 19.08.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 14.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 14.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010552522025
+
W.P.(C) 11957/2025, CM APPL. 48790/2025 and CM APPL.
44034/2026
WELSPRING UNIVERSAL
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Kunal Sharma and Ms.
Rishika Goyal, Advs.
versus
ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL GST
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Brijesh Yadav, SPC with
Ms. Nikita, Mr. Sandeep
Yadav, Mr. Sawan Saini, Mr.
Anirudh Nagar, Mr. Atul Yadav
& Mr. Kunal Chaudhary, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
The issue which arises for consideration in the present Petition
is whether the demand confirmed against the Petitioner pursuant to the
Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 can be sustained,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
particularly when the grounds forming the basis of the said notice
were also the subject matter of the Department’s appeal against the
Refund Order dated 06.05.2019, and the Commissioner (Appeals)’s
order dated 16.12.2019, allowing the said appeal, was subsequently
set aside by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal
[‘CESTAT’] vide Final Order No.56215/2024 dated 01.08.2024,
whereby the Petitioner’s entitlement to refund of Rs.76,72,000/- under
Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 was upheld.
2.
Through the present Petition, the Petitioner seeks the following
reliefs:
a. Allow the present petition and issue a writ of certiorari or any other
appropriate writ as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit to quash the Show
Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 issued by the Joint Commissioner, Central
Goods and Service Tax, West, Delhi.
b. Allow the present petition and issue a writ of certiorari or any other
appropriate writ as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit to quash the Orderin-Original
dated
24.03.2025
having
no.
DL/GST/West/Adjn./ADC/138/Welspring/2019 whereby the learned
Adjudicating officer has confirmed the demand raised.
c. Pass a direction for the payment of interest on pre-deposit amounting to
Rs. 7,67,200/- made by the Petitioner in Excise Appeal No. 51000 of 2020
filed before the Hon’ble CESTAT; and
d. Pass such other orders as this Hon'ble court may deem fit and proper in
the facts and circumstances of the present case.
FACTUAL MATRIX
3.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present
Petition, the relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
4.
The Petitioner is a partnership firm engaged in the manufacture
of engineering products, with specialisation in the welding sector. It
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
was registered with the Central Excise Department as a 100% Export
Oriented Unit and was also registered as a private bonded warehouse
under Sections 58 and 65 of the Customs Act, 1962.
5.
During the period from 2006 to 2009, the Petitioner purchased
goods from its sister concern, namely, M/s Wellspring India Pvt. Ltd.,
Bahadurgarh, Haryana, which was also a 100% Export Oriented Unit.
The Petitioner paid duty on the goods so purchased and, on the basis
of the duty actually paid, availed CENVAT credit aggregating to
Rs.35,05,894/-.
6.
Subsequently,
Show
Cause
Notice
No.
CE-20/R-
25/WU/48/08/637 dated 26.09.2008 and Show Cause Notice No. CE20/R-25/WU/48/08/2141 dated 06.01.2009 were issued to the
Petitioner alleging that the CENVAT credit of Rs.33,70,340/- and
Rs.1,35,554/-, respectively, had been wrongly availed in respect of the
goods purchased from its sister concern. The said proceedings were
adjudicated vide Order-in-Original Nos. 5 & 6/09-10 dated
31.07.2009, whereby the aforesaid credit was disallowed.
7.
Aggrieved by the order dated 31.07.2009, the Petitioner
preferred appeals before the Commissioner (Appeals). The appeals
were allowed vide Order-in-Appeal No.141/CE/D-II/2010 dated
30.03.2010. The Department thereafter challenged the said order
before the CESTAT.
8.
The Department’s appeal was dismissed by the CESTAT vide
Final Order No. A/53564/2016-SM[BR] dated 19.09.2016. The
CESTAT noted, inter alia, that the Petitioner had claimed credit of the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
duty actually paid by it and not of any duty which was merely
payable. The CESTAT further observed that the officer who had
issued the Show Cause Notices did not have jurisdiction to reopen the
assessment of the sister concern and that the Petitioner was entitled to
avail the credit of the duty actually paid.
9.
The Department challenged the aforesaid order of the CESTAT
before this Court. The appeal filed by the Department was dismissed
by this Court vide order dated 13.12.2017 passed in CEAC
No.8/2017. This Court found no reason to interfere with the order
passed by the CESTAT, particularly in view of the admitted position
that the Petitioner had actually paid excise duty totalling
Rs.35,05,894/-.
10.
This Court further examined the applicability of Section
5A(1A) of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and observed that the
exemption relied upon by the Department was not absolute but was
subject to conditions and prescribed procedures. Consequently,
Section 5A(1A) was held to be inapplicable in the facts of the case.
The aforesaid order dated 13.12.2017 was accepted by the Competent
Authority (Reviewing) on 15.06.2018 and thus attained finality.
11.
The second limb of the controversy relates to the excise duty
paid by the Petitioner on goods exported by it. Between April 2007
and December 2007, the Petitioner exported goods out of India
through 36 consignments after paying excise duty amounting to
Rs.76,72,000/-.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
12.
The Petitioner initially filed rebate claims in respect of the
exported consignments under Rule 18 of the Central Excise Rules,
2002. Four rebate claims aggregating to Rs.7,88,553/- were sanctioned
by the jurisdictional officer. Subsequently, the jurisdictional officer
informed the Petitioner that the rebate claims had been wrongly
sanctioned on the ground that the Petitioner, being a 100% Export
Oriented Unit, was not required to pay duty on the exported goods.
The Petitioner was advised to deposit the amount already sanctioned
and was informed that the amount would thereafter be available to it
by way of refund.
13.
Acting upon the aforesaid advice, the Petitioner deposited
Rs.7,88,553/- and thereafter also deposited interest of Rs.1,964/-. The
Petitioner subsequently withdrew the pending rebate claims and
informed the Department that it would seek refund under Rule 5 of the
CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The Petitioner thereafter sought
permission from the Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise and
Customs, to take credit of the duty amounting to Rs.76,72,000/- paid
in respect of the 36 export consignments. The request was rejected
vide communication dated 17.04.2008 on the ground that the
Petitioner had wrongly paid duty on the goods exported and therefore
could not take credit thereof.
14.
The Petitioner sought issuance of a speaking order in respect of
the aforesaid decision. However, vide communication dated
21.05.2008, the Assistant Commissioner informed the Petitioner that
there was no requirement for issuance of a speaking or appealable
order. On 26.05.2008, the Petitioner submitted proof of export in
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
respect of all the consignments, took credit of the duty and intimated
the Department. The Assistant Commissioner subsequently reiterated,
vide communication dated 05.07.2008, that such credit was not
admissible. The Petitioner responded vide letter dated 24.07.2008,
setting out its reasons for taking the credit.
15.
A Show Cause Notice dated 03.02.2009 was thereafter issued to
the Petitioner proposing, inter alia, disallowance and recovery of
CENVAT credit of Rs.76,72,000/- already taken by the Petitioner
under Rule 14 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with the
applicable provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The Show
Cause Notice also proposed recovery in relation to the rebate amount
of Rs.7,88,553/- and imposition of penalty.
16.
The aforesaid Show Cause Notice dated 03.02.2009 was
adjudicated by the Commissioner, Central Excise, Delhi-II, vide
Order-in-Original No.19/2009-10 dated 26.02.2010. The rebate claim
of Rs.7,88,553/- was held to be inadmissible and the CENVAT credit
of Rs.76,72,000/- was disallowed. A penalty of Rs.1,53,000/- was also
imposed upon the Petitioner.
17.
The Petitioner challenged the aforesaid order before the
CESTAT. The appeal was allowed by way of remand vide Final Order
No.5066/2017 dated 07.02.2017. The CESTAT noticed that the earlier
Order-in-Original dated 26.02.2010 had proceeded without taking into
account the legal position arising from the earlier proceedings
concerning the admissibility of the CENVAT credit. It was observed
that the matter required a holistic consideration, including the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
correctness of the credit initially taken by the Petitioner on various
inputs and the benefit accruing to the Petitioner in terms of Rule 5 of
the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.
18.
Pursuant to the aforesaid remand, the Commissioner, Central
Excise, Delhi-II, adjudicated the Show Cause Notice dated 03.02.2009
vide Order-in-Original No.37/SS/CE/D-II/2-16-17 dated 21.03.2017.
By the said order, the proceedings initiated against the Petitioner were
dropped. The Commissioner, inter alia, recorded that the admissibility
of the credit initially taken by the Petitioner was not in dispute and
that the circumstances in which the credit had been taken were
required to be considered in their entirety. The Commissioner further
observed that, once the Department had taken the position that the
Petitioner had erroneously paid duty on the exported goods, the
appropriate course was to refund the duty so paid.
19.
The aforesaid Order-in-Original dated 21.03.2017 was accepted
by the Competent Authority (Reviewing) on 13.06.2017 and was not
challenged thereafter.
20.
Pursuant to the aforesaid proceedings, the Petitioner filed a
refund claim for Rs.76,72,000/-. The refund was sanctioned by the
Assistant Commissioner, CGST, Janakpuri vide Refund Order No.R02/19-20 dated 06.05.2019. The Assistant Commissioner, while
sanctioning the refund, took note of the inter-connected nature of the
earlier proceedings and held that the refund claim was within
limitation. It was also found that the Petitioner had furnished the
relevant documents evidencing export of the goods.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
21.
The Commissioner, CGST, West, however, reviewed the refund
order and, vide Review Order No.19 dated 09.08.2019, directed filing
of an appeal against the refund order. The grounds taken in review
included, inter alia, the alleged limitation of the refund claim, the
alleged requirement of transition of credit through TRAN-1 and the
Department's interpretation of the Order-in-Original dated 21.03.2017.
22.
In pursuance of the aforesaid review, the Department filed an
appeal against the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019 before the
Commissioner (Appeals). During the pendency of the said appeal, the
Joint Commissioner, Central Tax, GST, Delhi (West), issued the
Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019. The said Show
Cause Notice proceeded on the premise that the refund of
Rs.76,72,000/- sanctioned vide Refund Order dated 06.05.2019 was
erroneous and called upon the Petitioner to show cause as to why the
amount should not be demanded and recovered, along with applicable
interest.
23.
The Department’s appeal against the Refund Order dated
06.05.2019 was allowed by the Commissioner (Appeals) vide Orderin-Appeal dated 16.12.2019. The Commissioner (Appeals) took the
view, inter alia, that the Petitioner ought to have transitioned the
credit through TRAN-1 and that the refund in cash could not be
sustained.
24.
Aggrieved by the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019, the
Petitioner preferred Excise Appeal No.51000 of 2020 before the
CESTAT. The said appeal was allowed by the CESTAT vide Final
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
Order No.56215/2024 dated 01.08.2024, whereby the Order-in-Appeal
dated 16.12.2019 was set aside. The CESTAT examined the scheme
governing export of goods and the statutory mechanisms by which the
duty paid in respect of exported goods could be neutralised, including
the provisions relating to rebate under Rule 18 of the Central Excise
Rules, 2002, export under bond under Rule 19 thereof and refund of
CENVAT credit under Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.
25.
In the facts of the present case, the CESTAT recorded that the
Petitioner had initially exported the goods under a claim for rebate,
had paid the duty and had thereafter claimed rebate. Although the
rebate had initially been sanctioned, the Petitioner, acting upon the
advice of the Department, had repaid the rebate amount along with
interest. Thereafter, the Petitioner had continued to pay duty on the
exported goods by debiting its CENVAT account and had taken credit
of the duty so paid.
26.
The CESTAT ultimately held, in paragraph 22 of its Final
Order dated 01.08.2024, that the Petitioner was entitled to refund of
CENVAT credit of Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5 of the CENVAT
Credit Rules, 2004. The CESTAT further held that the substantive
benefit available to the Petitioner could not be denied merely because
the Petitioner had quoted the wrong rule while filing the refund claim
and the Assistant Commissioner had also sanctioned the refund by
referring to the wrong rule.
27.
Significantly, the question of limitation was also expressly
considered by the CESTAT. In paragraph 23 of its Final Order dated
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
01.08.2024, the CESTAT held that the refund claim was not hit by
limitation. The CESTAT took note of the fact that it was the Revenue
which had pursued the matter and carried the earlier proceedings to
this Court and that the Petitioner had waited for the judgment of this
Court dated 13.12.2017 before filing the refund claim on 08.01.2018.
28.
Thus, vide Final Order No.56215/2024 dated 01.08.2024, the
CESTAT set aside the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019, which had
interfered with the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019. The CESTAT also
expressly
upheld
the
Petitioner’s
entitlement
to
refund
of
Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 and
held that the claim was not barred by limitation.
29.
The Petitioner brought the aforesaid decision of the CESTAT to
the notice of the Department vide communication dated 24.02.2025
and enclosed a copy of the Final Order dated 01.08.2024. Despite the
same, the proceedings arising out of the Demand-cum-Show Cause
Notice dated 10.12.2019 were continued and further hearings were
held.
30.
Ultimately, the Additional Commissioner, CGST, Delhi (West),
passed the impugned Order-in-Original dated 24.03.2025 bearing
No.DL/GST/West/Adjn./ADC/138/Welspring/2019, confirming the
demand of Rs.76,72,000/- against the Petitioner.
31.
The reasoning in the Impugned Order, insofar as relevant for
the present controversy, proceeds, inter alia, on the following grounds:
i.
that the refund claims filed by the Petitioner under Rule 5 of the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 had earlier been rejected and the
said rejection had not been challenged;
ii.
that the subsequent applications for refund were new
applications and were consequently barred by limitation; and
iii.
that the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019 had already been set
aside by the Commissioner (Appeals) vide order dated
16.12.2019.
32.
It is the Petitioner’s grievance that the aforesaid findings have
been recorded without taking into consideration the subsequent Final
Order dated 01.08.2024 passed by the CESTAT, whereby the Orderin-Appeal dated 16.12.2019 had itself been set aside and the
Petitioner’s entitlement to refund had been upheld.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
33.
Contentions on behalf of the Petitioner
33.1. It was submitted that the Final Order dated 01.08.2024 passed
by the CESTAT was directly material to the adjudication of the
Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019. It was submitted
that the Department’s appeal against the Refund Order dated
06.05.2019 had resulted in the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019,
which was thereafter challenged by the Petitioner before the CESTAT.
The CESTAT, vide Final Order dated 01.08.2024, allowed the
Petitioner’s appeal, set aside the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019
and expressly held that the Petitioner was entitled to refund of
Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
CESTAT also held that the refund claim was not barred by limitation.
33.2. It was further submitted that once the Order-in-Appeal dated
16.12.2019 had been set aside, the Additional Commissioner could
not have relied upon the same order while passing the impugned
Order-in-Original dated 24.03.2025. It was submitted that the
impugned order effectively proceeds as though the Order-in-Appeal
dated 16.12.2019 continues to operate, notwithstanding that the same
had already been set aside by the appellate tribunal.
33.3. It was next submitted that the finding that an earlier refund
application had been rejected and that the Petitioner had not
challenged such rejection is factually and legally unsustainable in
view of the subsequent appellate proceedings. The Petitioner had
throughout been prosecuting its remedies and the CESTAT had finally
adjudicated the controversy in its favour.
33.4. It was also submitted that the question of limitation could not
have been reopened by the Additional Commissioner as the same
issue had already been expressly considered and decided by the
CESTAT in paragraph 23 of its Final Order dated 01.08.2024. It was
submitted that the impugned order has been passed without
considering the CESTAT's Final Order dated 01.08.2024, despite the
Petitioner having specifically informed the Department about the same
vide letter dated 24.02.2025. The impugned order, therefore, suffers
from a fundamental error inasmuch as it proceeds on a legal position
which had ceased to exist before the order itself was passed.
33.5. It was lastly submitted that the Petitioner had deposited an
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
amount of Rs.7,67,200/- as statutory pre-deposit while filing Excise
Appeal No.51000 of 2020 before the CESTAT. Since the appeal was
ultimately allowed, the Petitioner is entitled to refund of the said predeposit along with applicable interest.
34.
Contentions on behalf of the Respondent
34.1. Per contra, it was submitted that the present Petition is
misconceived and not maintainable, as the Petitioner has invoked the
extraordinary writ jurisdiction of this Court to challenge the statutory
Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 and the consequential Order-inOriginal dated 24.03.2025, despite an adequate and efficacious
statutory remedy being available against the impugned order. It was
submitted that the present Petition also involves disputed questions of
fact and law which ought to be examined within the statutory
appellate framework.
34.2. It was submitted that the pendency of the Department’s appeal
against the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019 did not constitute any
statutory bar to the issuance of the Show Cause Notice dated
10.12.2019. According to the Respondent, the proceedings arising
from the refund order and those initiated pursuant to the impugned
Show Cause Notice were distinct statutory proceedings. It was
submitted that the Show Cause Notice was independently issued upon
the Department forming a prima facie view that the refund had been
erroneously sanctioned, inter alia, to safeguard the interest of revenue
and prevent the matter from being defeated by limitation.
34.3. It was further submitted that the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
was an independent and self-contained statutory determination
concerning the eligibility, admissibility and quantification of the
refund and was consequently open to appellate scrutiny in accordance
with law. It was contended that the Petitioner could not claim that the
said order was merely consequential to the earlier proceedings and,
therefore, incapable of being independently examined or challenged.
The mere acceptance by the Reviewing Authority of an earlier order,
according to the Respondent, could not operate as an estoppel against
the Department from assailing a subsequent refund sanction order if
the latter was found to be erroneous or prejudicial to the interests of
revenue.
34.4. It was further submitted that the Final Order dated 01.08.2024
passed by the CESTAT did not render the Demand-cum-Show Cause
Notice dated 10.12.2019 non est, nor did it, according to the
Respondent, preclude adjudication of the proceedings initiated
pursuant to the said notice. It was submitted that the proceedings
arising from the Show Cause Notice were separate statutory
proceedings and were required to be adjudicated in accordance with
law.
34.5. It was also submitted that the Petitioner’s claim for refund of
Rs.76,72,000/- was barred by limitation. It was contended that the
earlier refund claims filed by the Petitioner under Rule 5 of the
CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, pertaining to the same period had
already been rejected and the Petitioner had failed to challenge such
rejection. The subsequent claim filed on 08.01.2018 was, therefore,
according to the Respondent, a fresh claim filed beyond the prescribed
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
period under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944, the relevant
date for limitation being the date of export. It was further contended
that the orders passed in the earlier adjudication proceedings did not
extend or revive the statutory period of limitation.
34.6. It was lastly submitted that the Petitioner had already availed
credit of Rs.76,72,000/- in respect of the subject export transactions
and could not seek a second benefit by way of cash refund for the
same transactions. It was further submitted that the impugned Orderin-Original dated 24.03.2025 had been passed after affording the
Petitioner sufficient and repeated opportunities of hearing. The
Respondent specifically relied upon the personal hearing attended by
the Petitioner through its counsel on 05.10.2023 and the subsequent
opportunities afforded on 22.11.2024, 25.02.2025 and 06.03.2025. It
was, therefore, contended that there was neither any violation of the
principles of natural justice nor any prejudice caused to the Petitioner
warranting interference by this Court.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
35.
This Court has carefully considered the submissions advanced
on behalf of the parties and perused the material on record.
36.
The controversy, in the view of this Court, does not require this
Court to once again examine the merits of the Petitioner’s entitlement
to refund of Rs.76,72,000/-. The said issue had already been
considered by the CESTAT in Final Order No.56215/2024 dated
01.08.2024. The said order has not been shown to have been set aside
or stayed in any subsequent proceedings
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
37.
The sequence of events assumes significance. The refund of
Rs.76,72,000/- was sanctioned by the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019.
The Department challenged the said order before the Commissioner
(Appeals), and during the pendency of that appeal, the Demand-cumShow Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 came to be issued. The
Commissioner (Appeals) thereafter allowed the Department’s appeal
vide Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019. The Petitioner challenged the
said Order-in-Appeal before the CESTAT, which ultimately allowed
the Petitioner’s appeal vide Final Order dated 01.08.2024 and set aside
the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019.
38.
The effect of the Final Order dated 01.08.2024 cannot be lost
sight of. The Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019, which had set aside
the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019, was itself subsequently set aside
by the CESTAT. Consequently, the Additional Commissioner could
not proceed on the premise that the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019
continued to operate as a valid determination against the Petitioner,
without considering the subsequent appellate adjudication by the
CESTAT.
39.
In this regard, the reasoning adopted in paragraph 23 of the
impugned Order-in-Original cannot be sustained. The Additional
Commissioner proceeded, inter alia, on the premise that the Refund
Order dated 06.05.2019 had been set aside by the Commissioner
(Appeals) vide Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019. However, the
impugned order was passed on 24.03.2025, by which date the said
Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019 had already been set aside by the
CESTAT vide Final Order dated 01.08.2024.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
40.
Once the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019 had been set aside
by the CESTAT, the same could not thereafter be treated as an
operative determination adverse to the Petitioner. The adjudicating
authority was, therefore, required to consider the effect of the Final
Order dated 01.08.2024 while adjudicating the proceedings pending
before it.
41.
The position becomes even clearer when the findings recorded
by the CESTAT are examined. In paragraph 22 of its Final Order
dated 01.08.2024, the CESTAT expressly held that the Petitioner was
entitled to refund of CENVAT credit of Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5
of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The CESTAT further held that
the substantive benefit available to the Petitioner could not be denied
merely because the Petitioner had quoted the wrong rule while filing
the refund claim.
42.
Thus, the CESTAT did not merely set aside the Order-in-
Appeal on a technical ground. It examined the substantive entitlement
of the Petitioner and concluded that the Petitioner was entitled to
refund of the CENVAT credit of Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5 of the
CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.
43.
Equally significant is the finding recorded by the CESTAT on
limitation. The Department had specifically raised the issue of
limitation before the CESTAT. The CESTAT considered the same in
paragraph 23 of its Final Order and held that the refund claim was not
hit by limitation.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
44.
Once the question of limitation had been specifically considered
and decided by the CESTAT in favour of the Petitioner, the
Additional Commissioner could not have proceeded to adjudicate the
issue by simply treating the refund claim as a fresh claim and arriving
at a conclusion contrary to the finding recorded by the CESTAT in its
Final Order dated 01.08.2024.
45.
The impugned order, insofar as it holds that the refund claim
was a fresh application and was barred by limitation, therefore, cannot
be sustained. The finding is directly contrary to the adjudication
already undertaken by the CESTAT in its Final Order dated
01.08.2024. The same infirmity permeates the finding of the
Additional Commissioner that the Petitioner had previously filed a
refund claim which had been rejected and that, since the said rejection
had not been challenged, the subsequent claim was not maintainable.
46.
The aforesaid finding fails to take into account the subsequent
appellate proceedings concerning the refund. The Refund Order dated
06.05.2019
was
challenged
by
the
Department
before
the
Commissioner (Appeals), and the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019
passed in those proceedings was thereafter challenged by the
Petitioner before the CESTAT. The CESTAT allowed the appeal on
01.08.2024 and set aside the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019.
47.
Therefore, the Additional Commissioner could not have treated
the proceedings as though the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019
continued to operate independently of the subsequent appellate
adjudication. Once the said Order-in-Appeal was set aside by the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
CESTAT, the Additional Commissioner was required to consider the
legal and factual consequences flowing from the Final Order dated
01.08.2024, including the CESTAT’s finding that the Petitioner was
entitled to refund of Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5 of the CENVAT
Credit Rules, 2004 and that the claim was not barred by limitation.
48.
It is also material that the Petitioner had specifically brought the
Final Order dated 01.08.2024 to the notice of the adjudicating
authority vide its communication dated 24.02.2025. Thus, the
CESTAT’s decision was not an order of which the adjudicating
authority could legitimately claim ignorance.
49.
Despite being apprised of the CESTAT's decision, the
Additional Commissioner proceeded to pass the impugned Order-inOriginal dated 24.03.2025 without dealing with the effect of the Final
Order dated 01.08.2024.
50.
An adjudicating authority exercising statutory powers is
necessarily required to take into account the operative orders of the
appellate
authorities
having
appellate
jurisdiction
over
the
adjudicating authority. The adjudicating authority cannot disregard a
subsequent appellate determination which directly bears upon the very
issue under adjudication.
51.
The present case is not one where the adjudicating authority
was required to consider an issue wholly unrelated to the proceedings
before the CESTAT. The findings recorded in the impugned order
concerning limitation and the Petitioner’s entitlement to refund have
to be considered in the context of the Final Order dated 01.08.2024.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
The CESTAT had expressly considered the question of limitation and
had also upheld the Petitioner’s substantive entitlement to refund
under Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. Further, the Orderin-Appeal dated 16.12.2019, upon which reliance has been placed in
the impugned order, had already been set aside by the CESTAT.
52.
The impugned Order-in-Original, therefore, proceeds on a legal
and factual premise which was no longer available to the Respondent
on 24.03.2025.
53.
This Court is also unable to sustain the finding that the
Petitioner’s claim stood defeated merely on the ground that an earlier
refund claim had been rejected and that such rejection had not been
challenged. The subsequent proceedings culminating in the Final
Order dated 01.08.2024 demonstrate that the entitlement to refund was
the subject matter of adjudication before the statutory appellate forum.
The CESTAT, while deciding Excise Appeal No.51000 of 2020,
examined the Petitioner’s entitlement to refund and ultimately allowed
the appeal.
54.
Once the CESTAT had set aside the Order-in-Appeal dated
16.12.2019 and had held that the Petitioner was entitled to refund of
Rs.76,72,000/- under Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, the
Additional Commissioner could not treat the said Order-in-Appeal as
continuing to operate against the Petitioner while adjudicating the
Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice.
55.
It is also relevant to notice that the earlier proceedings arising
out of the Show Cause Notice dated 03.02.2009 had culminated in the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
Order-in-Original dated 21.03.2017 dropping the proceedings. The
said order was accepted by the Competent Authority (Reviewing). The
subsequent refund proceedings thus arose in the backdrop of the
findings recorded in the earlier proceedings and, thereafter, the
appellate adjudication rendered by the CESTAT vide Final Order
dated 01.08.2024.
56.
The present proceedings cannot be viewed in isolation by
merely referring to the Refund Order dated 06.05.2019 and the Orderin-Appeal dated 16.12.2019. The latter order was not the last word on
the controversy. It was carried in appeal and was ultimately set aside.
57.
This Court therefore finds that the Additional Commissioner
committed a manifest error in confirming the demand of
Rs.76,72,000/- vide the impugned Order-in-Original dated 24.03.2025.
58.
In view of the aforesaid conclusion, it is not necessary for this
Court to examine the other grounds urged by the Petitioner. The
impugned order is unsustainable for the fundamental reason that it
fails to give effect to the subsequent Final Order dated 01.08.2024
passed by the CESTAT and proceeds on the basis of an Order-inAppeal dated 16.12.2019 which had already been set aside.
59.
The Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 was
issued while the Department’s appeal against the Refund Order dated
06.05.2019 was pending before the Commissioner (Appeals). The
subsequent Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019 passed in that appeal
was thereafter set aside by the CESTAT vide Final Order dated
01.08.2024. In these circumstances, the adjudication of the DemandSignature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
cum-Show Cause Notice could not have proceeded on the basis that
the Order-in-Appeal dated 16.12.2019 continued to operate against the
Petitioner, particularly when the CESTAT had expressly upheld the
Petitioner’s entitlement to refund and had held that the claim was not
barred by limitation.
60.
Accordingly, the Order-in-Original dated 24.03.2025 bearing
No.DL/GST/West/Adjn./ADC/138/Welspring/2019 and the Demandcum-Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 are set aside.
61.
The Petitioner had made a pre-deposit of Rs.7,67,200/- while
preferring Excise Appeal No.51000 of 2020 before the CESTAT.
Since the said appeal was allowed by the CESTAT vide Final Order
dated 01.08.2024, the Petitioner is entitled to refund of the said predeposit, together with applicable interest, in accordance with law.
CONCLUSION
62.
For the foregoing reasons, the present Writ Petition is allowed.
63.
The
Order-in-Original
dated
24.03.2025
bearing
No.DL/GST/West/Adjn./ADC/138/Welspring/2019 and the Demandcum-Show Cause Notice dated 10.12.2019 are hereby set aside.
64.
The Respondent is directed to refund to the Petitioner the
amount of Rs.7,67,200/- deposited by the Petitioner as pre-deposit
while filing Excise Appeal No.51000 of 2020 before the CESTAT,
together with applicable interest, in accordance with law.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
65.
The pending applications also stand disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
SHAIL JAIN, J.
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
sp/pal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
14:55:59
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review