The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
09. 10.2017 and the same is the date of institution of suit also. [11] Be that as it may, Mr. RK Birla, learned counsel on record for CRP petitioner made one short point and that short point is, when an application for setting aside the ex-parte decree (obviously under Order IX Rule 13 of CPC) filed along with CoD application seeking condonation of 302 days delay is pending, said Execution Court has made the impugned order and if the impugned order is carried to its logical end, an irreversible situation can arise. [12] Responding to the aforesaid short point on which learned counsel for CRP petitioner predicated his campaign against the impugned order, Mr. N. Suresh, learned counsel on record for R1 & R2 submitted that CRP petitioner should have filed an application in said Execution Court under Order XXI Rule 26 and sought stay of execution but without doing that, revision petitioner has rushed to this Court, filed captioned CRP and obtained interim order dated 19.12.2025 which has brought all the proceedings to a grinding halt. [13] This Court carefully considered the afore-referred rival submissions. [14] A bare perusal of said ex-parte judgement makes it clear that said trial court has proceeded against both defendants ex-parte on and from
18. 03.2024. Therefore, it is well open to the defendants to make an application to set aside the ex-parte decree which they have done vide an application dated 17.11.2025 albeit along with another application of even date (17.11.2025) with a CoD prayer qua 302 days delay in filing the set aside application being Judl. Misc. Case. No.293 of 2025. Condonation of delay application has to be decided on merits and subject to the outcome of the CoD application, the application to set aside the ex-parte decree has to be decided on its own merits and in accordance with law. For the sake of specificity and abundant clarity, this Court deems it appropriate to write that considering the application for setting aside ex-parte decree on its own merits and in accordance with law will arise only if CoD prayer is acceded to and if CoD prayer is not acceded to, that will be end of the road for the CRP petitioner atleast in as far as the said trial court is concerned. [15] As regards said Execution Court, as rightly pointed out by Mr. N. Suresh, the remedy for the revision petitioner who is JD2 is to file an application under Order XXI Rule 26 of CPC. In this regard, Mr. RK Birla, learned counsel on record for revision petitioner very fairly submitted that he will file an application in said Execution Court under Order XXI Rule 26 of CPC on or before 05.10.2026. If the revision petitioner files an …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MNHC:202
REPORTABLE
Item Nos. 7-9
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP(C.R.P. Art. 227) No. 58 of 2025
Wahengbam Inaocha Meetei aged about 50 years s/o W. Maipak
Singh of Lamboi – Khul, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Lamlai, Imphal East
District, Manipur.
…Petitioner/Judgment Debtor/Defendant No. 2
- Versus 1. Irengbam Ongbi Lairenlakpam Ningol Sandhyarani Devi,
aged about 56 years D/O late Lairenlakpam Kullapati Devi
and late Lairenlakpam Ibotombi Singh of Kongpal Kongkham
Leikai P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
2. Thounaojam Ongbi Lairenlakpam Ningol Kamala Devi, aged
about 53 years D/O late Lairenlakpam Kullapati Devi and late
Lairenlakpam Ibotombi Singh of Top Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…Respondents/Decree Holders/Plaintiffs
3. Ngasam Ningol Nirmala Devi aged about
years, d/o N.
Indrani Devi of Kongpal Kongkham Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…Respondents/Judgment Debtor No. 1/Defendant No. 1
WITH
MC(CRP(CRP Art. 227)) No. 104 of 2025
Wahengbam Inaocha Meetei aged about 50 years s/o W. Maipak
Singh of Lamboi – Khul, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Lamlai, Imphal East
District, Manipur.
…Applicant
- Versus 1. Irengbam Ongbi Lairenlakpam Ningol Sandhyarani Devi,
aged about 56 years D/O late Lairenlakpam Kullapati Devi
and late Lairenlakpam Ibotombi Singh of Kongpal Kongkham
Leikai P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
2. Thounaojam Ongbi Lairenlakpam Ningol Kamala Devi, aged
about 53 years D/O late Lairenlakpam Kullapati Devi and late
Lairenlakpam Ibotombi Singh of Top Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
3. Ngasam Ningol Nirmala Devi aged about
years, d/o N.
Indrani Devi of Kongpal Kongkham Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…Respondents
WITH
MC(CRP(CRP Art. 227)) No. 35 of 2026
Wahengbam Inaocha Meetei aged about 50 years s/o W. Maipak
Singh of Lamboi – Khul, PO Lamlong, PS Lamlai, Imphal East
District, Manipur.
…Applicant
- Versus 1. Irengbam Ongbi Lairenlakpam Ningol Sandhyarani Devi,
aged about 56 years D/O late Lairenlakpam Kullapati Devi
and late Lairenlakpam Ibotombi Singh of Kongpal Kongkham
Leikai PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
2. Thounaojam Ongbi Lairenlakpam Ningol Kamala Devi, aged
about 53 years D/O (L) Lairenlakpam Kullapati Devi and (L)
Lairenlakpam Ibotombi Singh of Top Leikai, PO & PS.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…Respondents
B EF O R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
For the petitioner/applicant
: Mr. R.K. Birla, Advocate
For the respondents
: Mr. N. Suresh, Advocate for
R1 & R2
Date of order
: 10-09-2026
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(Oral)
[1]
The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in this
order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity):
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Form/other short
references
Full Form/Expansion
1.
CRP
Civil Revision Petition
2.
MC
Miscellaneous Case
3.
MCs
Miscellaneous Cases
4.
said trial court
Court of Civil Judge (Junior
Division)
Imphal
East
at
Lamphelpat, Manipur
5.
said suit
Original Suit No. 28 of 2017 on
the file of said trial court
6.
D1
1st defendant
7.
D2
2nd defendant
8.
JD1
Judgment Debtor No. 1
9.
JD2
Judgment Debtor No. 2
10.
said ex parte judgment
Judgment dated 21-12-2024
made by said trial court in said
suit
11.
said Execution Court
Court of Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Imphal East (to be
noted, said trial court and said
Execution Court are one and the
same)
12.
CoD
Condonation of Delay
13.
CPC
The Court of Civil Procedure,
1908 (V of 1908)
14.
impugned order
Order dated 27.11.2025 made in
Title Execution Case No. 4 of
2025 by said Execution Court
15.
said execution case
Title Execution Case No.4 of
2025 on the file of said Execution
Court
[2]
Sole revision petitioner in captioned CRP is D2 in said suit in
said trial court and he is also JD2 in said execution case in said Execution
Court.
[3]
R1 and R2 in captioned CRP are 1st and 2nd plaintiffs
respectively in said suit in said trial court. To be noted, they are also decree
holders 1 and 2 respectively in said execution case in said Execution Court.
[4]
Parties to the captioned CRP and captioned MCs thereat will
also be referred to by their respective ranks in said suit in said trial court as
well as in the said execution case in the said Execution Court wherever
necessary for the sake of convenience and clarity.
[5]
Plaintiffs 1 and 2 along with one Ms. Yumnam Ningol Laishram
Ongbi Bino Devi filed said suit in said trial court with prayers for declaration
of title qua suit property, declaration that D1 has no title qua suit property
and another declaration for cancellation of a ‘Sale Deed dated 14.12.2016
bearing registration No. 1191 of 2016 on the file of Sub-Registrar,
Sawombung executed by D1 in favored of D2’ (‘said Sale Deed’ for the sake
of convenience) as null and void, perpetual injunction and eviction. In this
suit, there are two defendants and as already alluded to supra, D2 is the sole
petitioner in the captioned CRP. As per the District and Sessions Court ecourts website, said suit has been filed on 09.10.2017 and institution of suit
date (described as ‘registration date’) has also been shown as 09.10.2017.
In the said suit, after service of suit summons, D1 and D2 filed separate
written statements, completed pleadings and issues were framed but
thereafter, it is clear that the said trial court proceeded ex-parte against both
defendants inter-alia as determination application was filed by counsel. This
is evident from proceedings of said trial court dated 18.03.2024 and a
scanned reproduction of the same is as follows:
[6]
Proceedings ex-parte, said trial court decreed said suit vide a
detailed judgement dated 21.12.2024 (said ex-parte judgment).
[7]
Case of the revision petitioner (D2/JD2) is that he was not
aware of the said ex-parte judgment and he came to know about the same
only on 25.10.2025 on receipt of summons from said Execution Court in said
execution case. This Court refrains from expressing any view or opinion on
this stand of the revision petitioner as the matter will now stand relegated to
the Execution Court and the said trial court, the details of which would be set
out elsewhere infra in instant order. To be noted, said execution case was
launched by 1st and 2nd plaintiffs/decree holders 1 & 2 for executing said exparte judgment and decree, more particularly decree drawn on the basis of
said ex-parte judgment. Thereafter, the revision petitioner filed Judl. Misc.
Case. No.293 of 2025 dated 17.11.2025 with a CoD prayer qua condonation
of 302 days delay in filing an application for setting aside said ex-parte
judgment and decree. In this CoD Judl. M.C, notice was ordered by said trial
court, plaintiffs 1 & 2/respondents thereat have filed affidavit-in-opposition,
pleadings are complete and it is next scheduled to be heard on 22.09.2026.
[8]
In the interregnum, said Execution Court made the impugned
order inter-alia directing the jurisdictional Sub-Registrar namely, SubRegistrar
Sawombung,
Imphal
qua
compliance
of
said
ex-parte
judgement/decree drawn up on the same, further directions to jurisdictional
revenue
authorities
for
mutation
on the
basis of
said
ex-parte
judgement/decree have also been given vide impugned order.
[9]
Assailing the impugned order, CRP petitioner filed captioned
CRP in this Court on 18.12.2025 and a Hon’ble Single Judge of this Court
has granted an interim order on 19.12.2025 inter-alia putting on hold the
execution proceedings and this interim order is now operating.
[10]
It has become necessary to record that in the said ex-parte
judgement (in paragraph 4), a tabulation capturing the chronology of events
have been set out and in that tabulation, 04.09.2017 has been shown as the
date on which said suit was registered but as already alluded to supra,
elsewhere in instant order, the date of filing as per e-courts website is
09.10.2017 and the same is the date of institution of suit also.
[11]
Be that as it may, Mr. RK Birla, learned counsel on record for
CRP petitioner made one short point and that short point is, when an
application for setting aside the ex-parte decree (obviously under Order IX
Rule 13 of CPC) filed along with CoD application seeking condonation of 302
days delay is pending, said Execution Court has made the impugned order
and if the impugned order is carried to its logical end, an irreversible situation
can arise.
[12]
Responding to the aforesaid short point on which learned
counsel for CRP petitioner predicated his campaign against the impugned
order, Mr. N. Suresh, learned counsel on record for R1 & R2 submitted that
CRP petitioner should have filed an application in said Execution Court
under Order XXI Rule 26 and sought stay of execution but without doing that,
revision petitioner has rushed to this Court, filed captioned CRP and
obtained interim order dated 19.12.2025 which has brought all the
proceedings to a grinding halt.
[13]
This Court carefully considered the afore-referred rival
submissions.
[14]
A bare perusal of said ex-parte judgement makes it clear that
said trial court has proceeded against both defendants ex-parte on and from
18.03.2024. Therefore, it is well open to the defendants to make an
application to set aside the ex-parte decree which they have done vide an
application dated 17.11.2025 albeit along with another application of even
date (17.11.2025) with a CoD prayer qua 302 days delay in filing the set
aside application being Judl. Misc. Case. No.293 of 2025. Condonation of
delay application has to be decided on merits and subject to the outcome of
the CoD application, the application to set aside the ex-parte decree has to
be decided on its own merits and in accordance with law. For the sake of
specificity and abundant clarity, this Court deems it appropriate to write that
considering the application for setting aside ex-parte decree on its own
merits and in accordance with law will arise only if CoD prayer is acceded to
and if CoD prayer is not acceded to, that will be end of the road for the CRP
petitioner atleast in as far as the said trial court is concerned.
[15]
As regards said Execution Court, as rightly pointed out by Mr.
N. Suresh, the remedy for the revision petitioner who is JD2 is to file an
application under Order XXI Rule 26 of CPC. In this regard, Mr. RK Birla,
learned counsel on record for revision petitioner very fairly submitted that he
will file an application in said Execution Court under Order XXI Rule 26 of
CPC on or before 05.10.2026. If the revision petitioner files an application
under Order XXI Rule 26 of CPC in the said Execution Court, said Execution
Court shall consider the same on its own merits and in accordance with law
untrammeled by instant order and dispose of the same within 6(six) weeks
from the date of filing Order XXI Rule 26 application.
[16]
As regards captioned MCs, as the matter is relegated to said
trial court as well as said Execution Court, MC(CRP(CRP Art.227)No.104 of
2025 will now stand disposed of as closed albeit keeping the execution
proceedings in abeyance till 16.11.2026 within which period, the said
Execution Court will decide Order XXI Rule 26 application. A closure in this
manner is thus given to MC(CRP(CRP Art.227)No.104 of 2025.
[17]
As regards MC(CRP(CRP Art.227)No.35 of 2026, the same
has been taken out to carry out amendments in captioned CRP as revision
petitioner has erroneously sought a writ of certiorari though captioned CRP
is one under Article 227 of Constitution. The prayer sought in this MC is
innocuous, nonetheless as closure is being given to the main CRP vide
instant order this Court, without either allowing the amendment MC or
dismissing the same makes it clear that captioned CRP prayers shall be
treated as one under Article 227 assailing the impugned order. Captioned
MC(CRP(CRP Art.227)No.35 of 2026 is disposed of as closed in this
manner.
[18]
In the light of the narration, discussion and dispositive
reasoning set out thus far, the following order is made:
a) It is open to CRP petitioner to file an application under
Order XXI Rule 26 of CPC in the said Execution Court
qua Title Execution Case No. 4 of 2025 (said execution
case) on or before 05-10-2026;
b) If the CRP petitioner files an application under Order
XXI Rule 26 of CPC in the aforesaid manner within the
afore-referred time frame, the same shall be decided on
its own merits and in accordance with law untrammeled
by observations made in instant order by said Execution
Court;
c) If the CRP petitioner does not file an application under
Order XXI Rule 26 of CPC on or before 05-10-2026, it
will be open to said Execution Court to proceed further
with the matter i.e., proceed further with Title Execution
Case No. 4 of 2025 (said execution case) on its own
merits and in accordance with law;
d) If the CRP petitioner files an application under Order
XXI Rule 26 of CPC within the afore-referred time frame
in said Execution Court, said Execution Court shall
decide the same on its own merits and in accordance
with law untrammeled by observations made in instant
order within 6(six) weeks and in any event on or before
16-11-2026;
e) As regards said trial Court, Judl. Misc. Case. No.293 of
2025 filed with a CoD prayer shall be decided on its own
merits and in accordance with law untrammeled by any
observations made in instant order;
f) Subject to the outcome of the CoD application, if it
became necessary, said trial court shall take up the
Judl. Misc. Case dated 17.11.2025 filed with a prayer to
set aside said ex-parte judgement and decide the same
also on its own merits and in accordance with law
untrammeled by any observations made in instant
order.
[19]
Though obvious, all the rights and contentions of all the parties
in said trial court as well as said Execution Court will stand preserved for the
legal drills that are to ensue.
[20]
The interim order already granted by this Court on 19.12.2025
will continue to operate until the said Execution Court decides the Order XXI
Rule 26 application but in any event not beyond 16.11.2026.
[21]
Captioned CRP and 2(two) captioned MCs thereat are
disposed of in the aforesaid manner with aforesaid directions, observations
and preservations of rights. There shall be no order as to costs.
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John KomVictoria
P.S. I :
P.S. II :
Upload forthwith
All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded in
High Court website inter alia as the same is QR coded.
signed
Ningom Digitally
by Ningombam
Victoria
bam
Date:
Victoria 2026.09.14
10:27:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review