Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
CP No.426 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 03rd DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE P SREE SUDHA
CIVIL PETITION NO.426 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
WACOM COMPANY LIMITED,
510-1 TOYONODAI 2-CHOME,
OTONE-MACHI
KITA SAITAMA DISTRICT,
SAITAMA 349-1148, JAPAN
EMAIL: chintan@spectrumlegal.in
dhruv@anandandanand.com
Tel:+91 96864 55514
REPRESENTED BY
PDA HOLDER MR. NRIPENDRA KASHYAP
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. CHINTAN CHINNAPPA .M, ADVOCATE)
AND:
CIREL SYSTEMS PRIVATE LIMITED
303, FIRST FLOOR, A BLOCK,
60 FEET ROAD, AECS LAYOUT,
KUNDALAHALLI, BENGALURU,
KARNATAKA-560 037, INDIA
TEL: +91 80 4052 6200
+91-8040526200
Email: ic@cirelsystems.com
bizserv@cirelsystems.com
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. ANIND THOMAS., ADVOCATE)
THIS CP IS FILED UNDER ORDER XXVI RULES 19 TO 22
READ WITH SECTION 78 OF THE CPC, 1908 PRAYING TO PASS
AN ORDER APPOINTING A LD. LOCAL COMMISSIONER,
PREFERABLY A SENIOR PERSON HAVING GOOD KNOWLEDGE
-2-
CP No.426 of 2025
IN THE FIELDS OF TECHNOLOGY AND CIRCUITRY SUCH AS A
RETIRED PROFESSIONAL OR A DISTRICT JUDGE FOR
COLLECTION OF EVIDENCE, DOCUMENTS (AS MENTIONED IN
CLAUSE 11 OF THE LETTERS ROGATORY) AS WELL AS FOR
OBTAINING
AND
RECORDING
THE
TESTIMONY
(AS
MENTIONED IN CLAUSE 10 OF THE LETTERS ROGATORY) FROM
THE RESPONDENT AND ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVES
WHOSE DETAILS ARE GIVEN IN CLAUSE 9 OF THE LETTERS
ROGATORY AND ETC.
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
30.01.2026 COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS
THIS DAY, P SREE SUDHA J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE P SREE SUDHA
CAV ORDER
This petition is filed by Wacom Company Limited, Japan,
Represented by power of attorney holder Mr. Nripendra
Kashyap against Cirel Systems Private Limited situated at
Kundalahalli, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India under Order XXVI
Rules 19 to 22 R/w Section 78 of CPC, 1908, seeking relief as
directed
in
Civil
Action
No.2:24-CV-00702-JRG
(between
Wacom Co. Ltd. Vs. Shenzhen Qianfenyi Intelligent Technology
Co. Ltd.) by the Hon'ble United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Texas.
2.
It is stated that the Petitioner is a corporation
incorporated under the laws of Tokyo, Japan, having its
registered in Japan. It is a global technology firm specializing in
-3-
CP No.426 of 2025
interactive pen tablets, pen displays, digital styli, and signature
solutions. Mr. Nripendra Kashyap is the authorised signatory of
the Petitioner vide a Power of Attorney dated 24.09.2025
issued by the Petitioner.
3. That the Respondent-*Shenzen Qianfenyi Intelligent
Technology
Company
Limited
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
"Maxeye"). The Plaintiff alleged before the Hon'ble US District
Court that Maxeye makes, offers to sell and sells branded and
non-branded infringing stylus products, including at least under
the names Maxeye, Penoval, and Metapen, for use, sale,
distribution, and exportation to and importation into the United
States. The Plaintiff's claim is that the production, sale, and
distribution of these impugned products infringe on their rights
in the Patents-in-Suit. The Plaintiff asserts the details under
para 4(i) to 4(vi) in the petition.
4. Maxeye asserted before the Hon'ble US District Court
that they are not liable due to non-infringement, invalidity of
the Patents-in-suit, that the Plaintiff's damages are statutorily
limited, that such claims are barred by prosecution history
estoppel, disclaimer, ensnarement, principles of equity, license,
*Corrected vide Court order dated 12.02.2026.
-4-
CP No.426 of 2025
exhaustion, lack of damages, or the stature of limitations.
There is no basis for injunctive relief.
5. The Plaintiff represents that the US case include
components
comprising
hardware
and
software
that
are
provided by the Respondent in the present petition to Maxeye.
It is submitted that Maxeye has purchased Active Stylus
Integrated Circuits including Cirel CSAA2001 and CSAA2002
from the Respondent Cirel for use in the impugned stylus
products. The Petitioners believe that the Respondent Company
and its employees possess information and documents relating
to Maxeye's impugned product that are relevant to proving
infringement of the Patents-in-suit before the Hon'ble US
District Court. The Petitioners filed a request for International
Judicial Assistance
Convention of
(Letters Rogatory) as per the Hague
18.3.1970 on the Taking of Evidence Abroad
in Civil or Commercial Matters (hereinafter referred to as
"Hague Evidence Convention, 1970").
6. For the purpose of obtaining documents or evidence
from entities or individuals situated beyond the territorial
jurisdiction of a particular Court, litigants customarily seek the
issuance of Letters Rogatory, also referred to as Letters of
-5-
CP No.426 of 2025
Request for Judicial Assistance. These instruments constitute
formal judicial communications transmitted from a court within
one nation to a court of another nation, the taking of evidence,
production of documents, or the service of judicial process upon
persons or entities located abroad.
7.
Both India and the United States of America are
signatories Hague to Evidence Convention, 1970. In the present
matter, the Petitioner seeks to obtain evidence from the
Respondent, who is situated within the territorial jurisdiction of
this Hon'ble Court, for the purpose of its use in civil
proceedings presently pending before the Hon'ble U.S. District
Court.
8. The Hon'ble U.S. District Court approved the Letters
Rogatory vide order dated 10.06.2025 after hearing both
parties, and issued the Letters Rogatory dated 12.08.2025
requesting this Court for obtaining the deposition of and
documents from the Respondent under Annexure-B.
9. As per the Article 3 of the Hague Evidence Convention,
1970, the questions that are sought to be put before the
Respondent are mentioned in Clause 10 of the Letters Rogatory
dated 12.08.2025 and the documents and other property to be
-6-
CP No.426 of 2025
inspected/produced by the Respondent are detailed in Clause
11 of the said document.
The Letters Rogatory dated
12.08.2025 accompanied by the 'Protective Order' appended as
Attachment A to the Letters Rogatory is as stipulated in Clause
7(d) of the Letters Rogatory. It was issued to protect the
proprietary or confidential trade secrets or technical, business,
financial, source code or personal information disclosed by the
Petitioners or Respondent or any third party. Thus, no prejudice
will be caused to them.
10.
Article 9 of the Hague Evidence Convention, 1970
empowers the judicial authority executing a Letter of Request
to do so in accordance with its own procedural and municipal
laws. In India, it is conferred under Order XXVI, Rules 19 to 22,
read with Section 78 of CPC. It is also requested this Court to
set up a 'Confidentiality Club' with the persons mentioned in
paragraph 17 of the petition on the following lines mention in
paragraph 18 of the petition.
11. The Letters Rogatory requests the appointment of a
commissioner,
preferably
a
senior
person
having
good
knowledge in the field of technology and circuitry, such as a
retired professional or a retired District Judge. The Petitioners
-7-
CP No.426 of 2025
are willing to reimburse and meet all costs for conducting the
commission proceedings. The Petitioner's main case is of
infringement, pending before the US Court, in which the
Respondent is not impleaded as a Defendant. The purpose of
the Petitioners, is only to discover certain, documents through
the Respondent.
12. The only relief that the Petitioner is claiming against
the Respondent is to produce the evidence as mentioned in the
Letters Rogatory, that are critical for the US District Court
matter to reach its logical conclusion, and the Petitioner is not
seeking any other relief (injunctive or damages or costs)
against
the
Respondent.
The
evidence
sought
from
the
Respondent is subject to a confidentiality club arrangement.
The Respondent is carrying on business and/or working for gain
within the ordinary jurisdiction of this Court.
13.
The Petitioner is engaged in patent infringement
proceedings before the Hon'ble US District Court, wherein
certain entities located in India, with whom the Respondent
maintains an ongoing contractual and commercial relationship,
are directly. connected to the subject matter of the dispute.
The documents and information sought from the Respondent
-8-
CP No.426 of 2025
are
material
and
necessary
for
the
just
and
effective
adjudication of the said proceedings. Despite the Petitioner's
bona fide efforts, the relevant documents are not accessible
within the jurisdiction of the United States of America, as they
are in the possession, custody, and control of the Respondent
situated within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.
14.
The cause of action for the present petition first
arose when the Hon'ble US District Court for East Texas issued
the said Letters Rogatory on 12.08.2025, and thus, he
requested for :
(i)
appointing preferably learned Local Commissioner
as detailed in the above paragraphs for collection of
evidence, documents and obtaining and recording
the testimony as mentioned in clause 10 of the
Letters Rogatory from the Respondent and its
authorized representatives whose details are given
in Clause 9 of the Letters Rogatory;
(ii)
Conferring
commissioner
special
powers
including
power
on
the
local
to summon the
person or persons including corporations and their
representations to produce documents and for other
-9-
CP No.426 of 2025
aspects which are detailed in clause 2 of the prayer
portion;
(iii) Setting up Confidentiality Club as stated in paragraph
14 and on the lines as stated in paragraph 15 of the
petition;
(iv) Conducting further proceedings before this Court as
well as by the local commissioner in camera with
only members of confidentiality club being present;
(v) Directing the officials of the registry and also local
commissioner to keep all the documents collected in
a sealed cover and allow access to the documents
only to the members of the club;
(vi) Directing the local commissioner to send evidence
and documents collected and testimony recorded to
the United States District Court in a sealed cover.
15.
In the
statement of objections filed by
the
Respondent, it is stated that nothing in the petition shall be
deemed to be admitted for want of specific traverse.
It is also
stated that the Respondent is a semiconductor company that
develops a wide range of integrated circuits, predominantly for
- 10 -
CP No.426 of 2025
active capacitive styli and he/it is a licensee of the Universal
Stylus Initiative (“USI”) and the Microsoft Pen Protocol (“MPP”),
and has by virtue of several years of effort and significant time
and cost developed several integrated circuits, including the
Cirel CSAA2001 and the Cirel CSAA2002, in compliance with
USI and MPP standards. His/Its products are well regarded in
the stylus market and the Respondents have been included in
Google’s approved vendor list.
16.
In the preliminary submissions, the Respondent
stated that he is neither aware of, nor a party to the Texas
Proceedings, and is no way involved in the Texas Proceedings.
He is not a Defendant in the Texas Proceedings and that no
claim of infringement or costs is being made against him. He is
non-party to the Texas Proceedings and completely unaware of
the dispute between the parties to the Texas Proceedings and
he cannot be compelled to part with sensitive and confidential
documents of the nature sought in proceedings. Order dated
12.08.2025 passed by the Texas Court approving the Letter of
Request does not examine whether such a letter can be issued,
or provide the reasons for issuing it, but merely notes that it
unopposed by Shenzhen.
- 11 -
CP No.426 of 2025
17.
The
Letter
of
Request
does
not
merit
consideration by this Court:
(a) it admittedly seeks to conduct a pre-trial
discovery despite the fact that the Government of India
has, by notification, expressly refused to execute such
Letters of Request under Article 23 of the Hague
Convention;
(b) the requests made are in violation of Article 3 of
the Hague Convention, being vague, omnibus, and in the
nature of a fishing and roving enquiry;
(c) the Respondent, as a non-party to the dispute,
is legally entitled to protect as privileged and confidential,
its valuable trade secrets in terms of Article 11 of the
Hague Convention;
(d) Article 9 of the Hague Convention provides that
a Letter of Request will be executed in accordance with
Indian Law. Indian law does not provide for pre-trial
discovery in the nature sought for.
(e) the requests made, if allowed, would severely
prejudice
the
Respondent
by
giving
access
to
the
any
- 12 -
CP No.426 of 2025
Respondent’s confidential and sensitive information to the
Petitioner, who is in a competing supply chain; and
(f)
enforcing
the
same
would
prejudice
the
sovereignty of India.
18.
It is submitted that the Letter of Request is
admittedly in the nature of pre-trial discovery of documents,
which is in violation of Article 23 of the Hague Convention as it
was issued for the purpose of obtaining pre-trial discovery of
documents.
As per paragraphs 8(b) and 11 of Petition, that
trial is yet to commence in the Texas Proceedings, and the
documents sought are to be used during trial or prior to trial for
the purpose of obtaining a summary Judgment. The purpose of
the instant Petition as per para 22 is to “discover certain
documents through the Respondent”. The Letter of Request
being in the nature of pre-trial discovery ought not to be
executed in India. Hence, the Petition is to be dismissed.
19.
The Letter of Request was issued in a complete
abuse of process of law. It is trite law that such a declaration
by the Government of India mandates Courts to exercise
careful scrutiny of Letters Rogatory received for execution, and
- 13 -
CP No.426 of 2025
orders cannot be passed as a matter of routine.
Respondent
has the right to refuse to give evidence as enshrined in Articles
11 and 12 of the Hague Convention.
The Petitioner seeks to
conduct a fishing and roving enquiry, as it is bereft of specific
details regarding what documents are sought, and their
relevance to the Texas Proceedings. The documentary requests
made in clause 11 of the Letter of Request are omnibus, vague
and do not contain specific details. Petitioner is not aware of
what documents are in the Respondents possession, and he is
not aware of their relevance to the Texas Proceedings.
20. The Letter of Request fails to meet the requirements
under Article 3 of the Hague Convention, which mandates that
it has to specify which documents / property are sought to be
inspected or received. The Letter of Request contains a list of
documentary requests not limited to the alleged infringing
products that form subject matter of the Texas Proceedings,
but in relation to “all/any USI Protocol based Active Stylus
Integrated Circuits” provided by the Respondent to Shenzhen,
not just those used in the two products. This broad and openended request includes internal documents in the nature of
functional
specifications,
register-level
specifications,
data
- 14 -
CP No.426 of 2025
sheets, roadmap presentations, compliance and certification
documents, developer manuals etc., for products provided by
the Respondent to Shenzhen.
The Letter of Request seeks to
cast a wide net for production of a vast, all-encompassing
range of documents with no explanation for their relevance or
necessity.
21. The Petitioner is seeking to obtain information from a
non-party to the proceedings as a pre-trail discovery. Indian
Law does not provide for such pre-trial discovery from a nonparty to the proceedings, and hence, under Article 9 of the
Hague Convention, a Letter of Request cannot be executed.
The Letter of Request also covers confidential and sensitive
documents such as the Chip Schematics, Printed Circuit Board
Layouts, VHSIC Hardware Description Language descriptions
and source codes for software and hardware in the products
supplied by the Respondent and it includes the Respondent’s
proprietary intellectual property, which is a product of several
years of dedicated research and development.
Respondent
would be severely prejudiced if the Petitioner is permitted to
access such documents, as the Petitioner is in a competing
supply chain of the Respondent. This intellectual property does
- 15 -
CP No.426 of 2025
not belong to either party to the Texas Proceedings, but solely
to the Respondent. The Respondent a licensee of USI and MPP,
invested over
man-months
towards developing high
performance integrated circuits to which he has a propriety
right. If the Petitioner is permitted to access a wide array of
documents as sought in the Letters Rogatory, the Respondent’s
right
to
protect
its
intellectual
property,
stands
to
be
jeopardized.
22.
It is submitted that the Petitioner has not claimed
violation by the Respondent of any of the Petitioner’s patents.
The Petitioner does not claim to have patents over the alleged
infringed products in India. In the absence of any patent rights
that are enforceable against the Respondent or even allegations
as to violation of the Petitioner’s intellectual property rights, he
is not entitled to the Respondent’s documents or information.
As such, the Respondent has refused to provide its sensitive
and confidential intellectual property and trade secrets for pretrial discovery in proceedings that it is a complete stranger to
by availing the protection available to it under Article 11 of the
Hague Convention.
It is submitted that the Respondent is a
renowned manufacturer of integrated circuits, operating for
- 16 -
CP No.426 of 2025
over a decade in the industry, whose products are utilized
across the world by several companies. The Respondent’s
products are in terms with the Universal Stylus Initiative, Inc.’s
policies. The Respondent cannot be compelled to part with
confidential and sensitive documents at the instance of the
Texas Court, before whom the Respondent is not a party, the
proceedings are at a nascent stage, trial is yet to commence
and where the Respondent has been conducting its operations
in compliance with all applicable laws.
23.
The Petitioner’s request for international judicial
assistance should have emanated out of legal necessity, only
after exhausting the available remedies before the Texas Court
for seeking production of documents from Shenzhen.
The
Petitioner does not possess valid patents in India, for all the
items protected by its purported United States patents. Patents
being inherently jurisdictional and territorial, and he cannot
seek to enforce any related rights in India.
24.
It is further stated that the decision of the Single
Judge of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in Pfizer Inc. and Ors.
v. Softgel Healthcare Private Limited has been set aside by a
Division Bench of the Hon’ble Madras High Court as it does not
- 17 -
CP No.426 of 2025
consider the India’s declaration under Article 23 of the Hague
Convention. The enforcement of the Letter of Request ex-facie
be prejudicial to Indian Sovereignty.
Confidentiality club
partially mitigates the prejudice that is caused by the disclosure
of
confidential
prejudice.
information
and
does
not
eliminate
such
The Power of Attorney issued by the Petitioner is
neither validly executed nor stamped. The Power of Attorney is
dated
24.08.2025,
10.10.2025.
and
the
Notarial
Certificate
is
date
As such, this petition is not filed with valid
authority.
25.
The Petitioner has also failed to indicate the
relevance of the all-encompassing array of documents sought
from the Respondent.
As such, a blanket protective order
would not sufficiently prevent the Respondent’s rights being
prejudiced. The Petitioner lacks any cause of action to enforce
the Letter of Request as against the Respondent, and the same
is barred by law and in the teeth of the declaration of the
Government of India under Article 23 of the Hague Convention
and other legal protection available to trade secrets.
- 18 -
CP No.426 of 2025
26. Learned Counsel for the Respondent has relied upon
Article 23 of the Hague Convention, which reads as follows:
“A. contracting State may at the time
of signature, ratification or accession,
declare that it will not execute letters
of Request issued for the purpose of
obtaining
pre-trial
discovery
of
documents as known in common Law
countries.”
27. The Respondent has mainly contended that Letter of
Request issued in Texas proceedings is against the said Article
and cannot be executed.
He further stated that Petitioner has
not made any best efforts to get the relevant documents and
information from the defendant before Texas Court and simply
obtained Letters Rogatory against him, though he is no way
related to the defendant before the U.S. Court. Petitioner does
not possess valid patents in India and there is no infringement
of his patents. Under the guise of Letters Rogatory, he cannot
get all the sensitive and confidential information from them.
Even the Confidentiality Club cannot protect the prejudice
caused to it and he has a right to refuse to give evidence as per
Articles 11 and 12 of the Hague Convention.
- 19 -
CP No.426 of 2025
28.
Admittedly, Petitioner herein filed a case against
Shenzhen QIANFENY Intelligence Technology Company Ltd.
before the District Court of Texas, And Respondent herein is
not at all party to the proceedings. Even the said fact was
already mentioned by the Petitioner in this petition. The
Petitioner is represented by Mr. Nripendra Kashyap, as per the
power of attorney dated 24.09.2025 issued in this regard. The
learned counsel for the Respondent objected the authenticity of
the same on the ground that date of power of attorney and the
notary attestation is not one and the same date.
Letters
Rogatory was granted on 12.08.2025 after hearing both sides.
29. The Petitioner requested the U.S. Court for issuance
of assistance from the authorities in India to obtain documents
and testimony from Respondent herein as it is relevant to the
plaintiff's claim of patent infringement in the litigation.
30.
Perusal of letter of request issued on *12.08.2025
clearly shows the purpose of evidence of judicial act sought
under clause 8B,
and in clause 11, it was mentioned that
requesting authority is aware of declaration of the Republic of
India made under Article 23 of the Hague Convention and they
stated that documents requested by them in the Letter of
* Corrected vide Court order dt. 12.02.2026.
- 20 -
CP No.426 of 2025
Request are likely to be in the possession and custody and
power of Respondent herein for the reasons stated in the clause
11. They also mentioned the details of the documents in the
same clause under 1 to 9 and thus, Petitioner sought for the
specific documents from the Respondent as detailed in clause
11 from 1 to 9. It was also specifically mentioned in the said
document.
31. In clause 8, it was mentioned as follows:
8a. XXX
b.
Purpose of the XXX
evidence
or
Under US patent practice, because
judicial
act
the claims of patents are construed
sought.
by the court as a matter of law
rather than by the jury, a claim
construction hearing typically occurs
prior to trial). Defendant Shenzhen
Qianfenyi Intelligent Technology
Co., Ltd. Purchased Active Stylus
Integrated Circuits including Cirel
CSAA2001 and CSAA2002 from Cirel
Systems Pvt. Ltd. For incusion in its
stylus products. These integrated
circuits perform a portion of the
functionality of Defendants’ accused
stylus products including aspects
which
relate
to
Plaintiff’s
infringement allegations.
- 21 -
CP No.426 of 2025
32.
In clause 9, they sought for information of the
documents and evidence from any other office or location
where Respondent has stored the details of the questions to be
put to the Respondent are also mentioned. The main objection
of the Respondent is that Petitioner has not made any efforts to
get information from the defendant before Texas court and he
simply sought for information from the Respondent, and the
said Letters Rogatory was issued in favour of Petitioner merely
because the Shenzon company has not opposed the same. But,
the perusal of the same clearly reveals that it was issued after
hearing both the sides and also considering Article 23 of the
Hague convention and it was specifically mentioned in clause
8B that the said information is sought for pre-trial Purpose.
Therefore, the objections raised by the Respondent cannot be
considered.
33. The learned counsel of the Petitioner also relied upon
the judgments of the Madras High Court, Bombay High Court,
Andhra Pradesh High Court and also of this Court and perused
the same.
- 22 -
CP No.426 of 2025
34.
This Court in the case of United States Federal
Trade Commission Vs. Nil (in W.P. No.13264/2020 dated
23.11.2020)) has held as follows :
"19. Cases in which High Court may issue
commission to examine Witness.-(1) If a
High Court is satisfied.(a) that a foreign Court situated in a
foreign country wishes to obtain the
evidence of a witness in any
proceeding before it;
(b) that the proceeding is of a civil
nature; and
(c) that the witness is residing within
the limits of the High Court's
appellate jurisdiction,
it may, subject to the provisions of Rule 20,
issue a commission for the examination of
such witness.
(2) Evidence may be given of the matters
specified in clauses (a), (b) and (c) of subrule (1).(a) by a certificate signed by the consular
officer of the foreign country of the highest
rank in India and transmitted to the High
Court through the Central Government; or
(b) by a letter of request issued by the
foreign Court and transmitted to the High
Court through the Central Government; or
- 23 -
CP No.426 of 2025
(c) by a letter of request issued by the
foreign Court and produced before the High
Court by a party to the proceeding."
There is no need for any interpretation of
these provisions which are as clear as
Gangetic waters.
(C) The aforementioned provisions of the
Code which were originally enacted by Act
10 of 1932 have been re-framed in the
1976 amendment, for giving effect to the
Directive
Principles
of
State
Policy
enshrined in Article 51 of the Constitution
of India; the said Article is phrased as
under:
"Article 51. The State shall endeavour to.(a) promote International peace and
security;
(b) maintain just and honourable
relations between nations;
(c) foster respect for international
law and treaty obligations in the
dealings of organised peoples with
one another; and
(d)
encourage
settlement
of
international disputes by arbitration."
The text of the aforesaid provisions of the
Code are presumably enacted for giving
effect inter alia to the intent of The Hague
Convention to which both India and United
States of America are parties; the Apex
Court in Safal Karamchari Andolan v. Union
of India MANU/SC/0233/2014: III (2014)
SLT 695 : 2014(4) Scale 165 has ruled that
the International Covenants which have
been ratified by India are binding to the
- 24 -
CP No.426 of 2025
extent they are not inconsistent with the
provisions of the domestic law.”
35. The Respondent has not submitted any iota papers
to show that production of documents by the Respondent will
be detrimental to the national security interest of India.
36.
In a judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of
Judicature at Madras in the case of Pfizer Inc and others Vs.
Softgel Healthcare Private Limited (in O.P. (PT). Nos.5 and
6 of 2024 decided on 28.01.2025), it was held as follows:
“The only objection raised by India
as a signatory to the Hague Evidence
Convention under Article 23 of the
said convention is that they will not
execute Letter or Request issued in
pursuance of Article 23 of the
Convention for the purpose of
obtaining pre-trial discovery of
documents, only in cases where the
documents are not specified. In the
case on hand, documents have been
specified in the Letters Rogatory
issued by the United State District
Court at Delaware”
- 25 -
CP No.426 of 2025
37.
Even in this case, the documents required by
Petitioner from the Respondent are mentioned in detail in
clause 11 from 1 to 9.
Therefore, the objection of the
Respondent that the purpose of obtaining them for pre-trial of
documents
with
the
Respondents
cannot
be
accepted.
Therefore, this Court finds it just and reasonable to allow this
petition and appoint Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal, Advocate.
38. In the result, the following order is passed:
(a)
The petition is allowed.
(b)
Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal, Advocate, is appointed
as a Local Commissioner for collecting evidence, including
documentary evidence as mentioned in Schedule A to the
Letters Rogatory, and also for obtaining and recording the
testimony and depositions from the person(s) designated by
the Respondent as mentioned in Schedule B to the Letters
Rogatory. Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal required to adhere to the
terms of the protective order dated *14.02.2025:
c)
Mr.
Vikram
Unni
Rajagopal,
the
appointed
Commissioner is conferred with "Special Powers' including the
power to -
* Corrected vide Court order dt. 12.02.2026.
- 26 -
CP No.426 of 2025
i. Summon a person to produce documents and
things as per Schedule A to the Letters Rogatory,
which shall be done as per the schedule set by the
appointed Commissioner and should be at least three
weeks prior to the commencement of the testimony;
ii. Accept copies of the said documents and things,
and provide the same to the members of the
confidentiality club from the Petitioner's side;
iii. Set the schedule for the collection of the
testimony of the Respondent's witness on a day-today basis;
iv. Decide to collect evidence based on the digitized
files of the court record and as collected from the
Court;
v. Summon a person, to administer oath to her/him
and to record his her evidence;
vi. Allow the Petitioners' and Respondent's respective
Indian counsel the opportunity to examine or crossexamine the aforesaid person;
- 27 -
CP No.426 of 2025
vii. To record the objections, if any, of the parties
and conclude, without delay, the testimony of the
witness nominated by the Respondent. To not stall
the testimony of the witness, once started, for
technical grounds and reasons. It is clarified, that the
questions, as asked should be recorded along with
the answers given;
viii.
Permit
the
Petitioners'
and
Respondent's
respective foreign representatives to attend and
observe the examination of the said person;
ix. Video record the testimony of the said person;
x. Have the said recording transcribed verbatim;
xi. Provide both the documents and recording and
the transcript to the Petitioners and Respondents
respective representatives and their Indian Counsels;
d) A 'Confidentiality Club' is set-up by this Court
consisting of the persons stated in Paragraph *17 and 18 of the
Petition
* Corrected vide Court order dt. 12.02.2026.
- 28 -
CP No.426 of 2025
e) All proceedings before Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal will
be in camera with only the members of the 'Confidentiality
Club' being present; and
f) The Registrar General of this Court is directed to keep
all documents and records pertaining to these petitions or the
matters arising therefrom, including the evidence collected by
Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal under seal. They shall allow access
to those documents only to the members of the Confidentiality
Club;
g) The venue of collecting evidence and recording
testimony of the Respondent shall be at *Prestige Trade Tower
situated at No.45/1, Palace Road, High Grounds, Sampangiram
nagar, Bengaluru-560001, Karnataka.
h) Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal to conduct proceedings as
per the above terms and send the evidence/ documents
collected and the testimony recorded to the Registrar General
of this Court who would then forward to the Hon’ble United
States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas in a
sealed cover.
* Corrected vide Court order dt. 12.02.2026.
- 29 -
CP No.426 of 2025
i) Mr. Vikram Unni Rajagopal, Advocate, shall be paid
remuneration of Rs.3,00,000/- by the Petitioner from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order. The Commissioner is also
permitted to seek additional remuneration once the work is
completed.
Sd/(P SREE SUDHA)
JUDGE
CS
CT:NR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review