Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on : 17.02.2026
Pronounced on : 24.02.2026
Uploaded on : 27.02.2026
APHC010549632025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3330]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
WRIT PETITION No. 28747/2025
BETWEEN:
1. VRED EXIM, REP., BY ITS PROPRIETOR K.VIVEK REDDY,
HAVING OFFICE D.No.35
D.No.35-3-69-371(C),
371(C), BHAGYANAGAR, 4TH
LANE, NEAR REVENUE WARD No.26, DHARAVARITHOTHA
DHARAVARITHOTHA,
ONGOLE, PRAKASAM DISTRICT, REP., BY ITS PROPRIETOR
P.VIVEK REDDY
2. P.VIVEK REDDY, S/o. P.VIJAYA ITUMAR REDDY, AGED
ABOUT 30 YEARS, OCC: PROPRIETOR, M/S.VRED EXIM,
HAVING OFFICE D.NO.35
D.NO.35-3-69-371(C),
371(C), BHAGYANAGAR, 4TH
LANE, NEAR REVENUE WARD NO.26, D
DHARAVARITHOTHA,
HARAVARITHOTHA,
ONGOLE, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP., BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT
OF
TRANSPORT,
SECRETARIAT BUILDINGS, VELAGAPUDI, AMARAVATI.
2. THE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER, THE STATE OF AND
ANDHRA
PRADESH, ARRIVAL BLOCK, PANDIT NEHRU BUS STATION,
VIJAYAWADA.
3. THE ADDITIONAL TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER THE STATE
OF ANDHRA PRADESH, ARRIVAL BLOCK, PANDIT NEHRU
BUS STATION, VIJAYAWADA.
4. VASI REDDY ACQA FARM, REP., BY ITS PROPRIETOR VASI
REDDY VANDANA, W/o. RAMAIAH, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
R/O.L24 VENKANAPALEM VILLAGE, MANUNOLU MANDAL
S.P.S.R NELLORE DISTRICT, ALSO HAVING OFFICE AT
D.NO.22, SRI SATYA ICE FACTORY, ORAGALLI CROSS
ROAD, CHILLAKUR, SPSR NELLORE DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that
in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High
Court may be pleased to issue an appropriate order or direction more
particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action
of the respondents No l to 3 in permitting the respondent No.4 to
establish the Automated Testing Station of Bapatla District
at
Sy.No.810, Yazali Village, Karlapalem Mandal, Bapatla District instead
of land in an extent of Ac.0.81 cents in Sy.No.658-6B3, Chandolu
Village, PittlavariPalem Mandal, Bapatla District as per Form-C Letter
of Undertaking for the Land contrary to the Request for Proposal
No.l7021/80/20 22/RSC,
dated 21.03.2025 for establishment of
Automated Testing Station of Bapatla
District, even though no
provision is provided for changing of the declared land for station by
the bidders as arbitrary, illegal, colourable exercise of power. contrary
to the terms and conditions of the tender, apart from being violative of
the fundamental rights guaranteed to me under Articles 14, 19 and 21
of the Constitution of India and consequently direct the respondents
No.l to 3 to cancel the Preliminary Registration Certificate granted in
favour of respondent No.4 to establish the Automated Testing Station
of Bapatla District at Sy.No.810, Yazali Village, Karlapalem Mandal,
Bapatla District and further direct the respondents No.l to 3 to follow
the Section 3(h) of the Request for Proposal NO.17021/80/2022/RSC,
dated 21.03.2025 for establishment of Automated Testing Station of
Bapatla District and pass such other order or orders.
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. B.ABHAY SIDDHANTH MOOTHA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR TRANSPORT
2. MULLA SOHAIL SHAREEF
The Court made the following:
ORDER:
The Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India for the following relief/s:
“to issue an appropriate order or direction more particularly one
in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the
respondents No.1 to 3 in permitting the respondent No.4 to
establish the Automated Testing Station of Baptla District at
Sy.No.810, Yazali Village, Karlapalem Mandal, Bapatla District
instead of land in an extent of Ac.0.81 cents in Sy.No.658-6B3,
Chandolu Village, Pittlavaripalem Mandal, Bapatla District as per
Form-C Letter of Undertaking for the Land contrary to the
Request for Proposal No.17021/80/2022/RSC, dated 21.03.2025
for establishment of Automated Testing Station of Bapatla
District, even though no provision is provided for changing of the
declared land for station by the bidders as arbitrary, illegal,
colourable exercise of power, contrary to the terms and
conditions of the tender, apart from being violative of the
fundamental rights guaranteed to me under Articles 14, 19 and
21 of the Constitution of India and consequently direct the
respondents No.1 to 3 to cancel the Preliminary Registration
Certificate granted in favour of respondent No.4 to establish the
Automated Testing Station of Baptka District at Sy.No.810,
Yazali Village, Karlapalem Mandal, Baptla District and further
direct the respondent No.1 to 3 to follow the Section 3(h) of the
Request for Proposal No.17021/80/2022/RSC, dated 21.03.2025
for establishment of Automated Testing Station of Baptla District
and pass such other order or orders…..
2.
Heard Sri B. Abhai Siddanth Mootha, learned counsel for the
petitioners and Sri Mulla Sohail Shareef, learned counsel for the 4th
respondent.
3.
The Transport Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh (for
short hereafter referred to as ‘organisation’) issued R.F.P. (Request for
Proposal)
No.17021/80/2022/RSC,
vide
tender
document
dated
21.03.2025 for establishment of Automated Testing Station at Bapatla
District, inviting tenders from the stakeholders. Unofficial respondent
No.4 stood as H1 bidder, vide preliminary PRC (Preliminary
Registration Certificate) dated 16.04.2025 and later, the organization
has issued revised PRC dated 04.07.2025. The present Writ Petition is
filed challenging the revised PRC dated 04.07.2025 issued in favour of
the 4th unofficial respondent.
4.
It is the contention of the writ petitioner that as per the tender
document, the organization cannot issue revised PRC as it is contrary
to sub-Section 5(e) and sub-Section 8(f) of Section 2 of the tender
document and also further contended that the issuance of revised PRC
dated 04.07.2025 is contrary to qualification conditions and also
contrary to sub-Section 13(c) and 18 (iv) of tender document. Hence,
prayed to direct the respondents to set aside the revised PRC issued in
favour of the 4th unofficial respondent as it is violation of tender
conditions.
5.
It is imperative to take review of the relevant provisions governing
the issue and the relevant provisions are hereby extracted:
Sub-section 5(e) of Section 2: the E-bids once submitted,
cannot be viewed, retrieved or corrected. The E-Bidder should
ensure the correctness of the E-Bed prior to uploading and take
printout of the system generated summary of submission to
confirm successful uploading of E-bid. The E-bids cannot be
opened even by the OIT/Opener before the due date and time of
opening.
Sub-section (8)(f) of Section 2:
The Technical Bid shall
comprise of the following documents which are to be scanned
and uploaded:
S.
No.
6.
Qualification Conditions
Documents to be uploaded
Ownership of the Premise/ Documentary Proof of Ownership
Land of ATS: Premise/
of Land/Proof of Lease to be
Land where ATS is to be
submitted.
established shall be either
Or
be owned or taken on
Consent letter from the Land
lease or hired by the
Owner for leasing the premises.
owner for a period not less
than 10 years. The Sole/ Undertaking in Form (C) of this
Lead Bidder shall submit
RFP
signed
by
authorized
undertaking
for
Land
signatory.
Ownership.
Copy of the document in case of
self owned property, shall be
submitted. In case of property
taken on Lease/Hire, the consent
letter from the land owner is
sufficient with the condition that,
the successful bidder shall enter in
to lease agreement within 30 days
from the award of the contract,
failing which the award gets
cancelled automatically.
Sub-section 13(c) of Section 2: No bidder shall carryout any
revision/correction/modification in his bid after the last date of
submission of Bids.
Sub-Section 18(iv) of Section 2 – Exclusion of Bids/
Disqualification: the
Bid
materially
departs
from
the
requirements specified in the Bid document or it contains false
information.
6.
The petitioner submits that the 4th unofficial respondent has
submitted tender application for Bapatla District to establish the
Automated Testing Station in an extent of 4046 Sq. meters in Survey
No.316/13 of West Bapatla village, Baptla Mandal and District.
Accordingly, the organization has issued preliminary PRC on
16.04.2025. The 4th unofficial respondent also submitted Form-C along
with an undertaking to establish the Automated Testing Station in
Bapatla. Later, he applied to the organization for permission to set up
the Automated Testing Station in Chandolu village, Pittalavari Palem
Mandal, Bapatla District, in an area of Ac.0.81 cents, Sy.No.658-6B3
and the said representation was considered by the respondents and
issued revised PRC on 04.07.2025 and it is contended that is contrary
to the Form-C and the provisions that referred supra and the
organization cannot revised or reviewed the Preliminary Registration
Certificate (PRC) as outlined in the tender document. Hence, prayed to
set aside the revised PRC dated 04.07.2025 issued to the unofficial
respondent and consequently prayed to declare the petitioner as H1
Bidder.
7.
The 4th unofficial respondent-H1 bidder filed counter affidavit
denying all the contentions raised by the Writ Petitioners stating that the
land owner of Yazali Village, Karlapalem Mandal, Bapatla District has
withdrew his consent subsequent to the confirmation of the Bid i.e.
preliminary PRC dated 16.04.2025, that is due to the plan engineered
by the 2nd petitioner which prevailed upon the land owner, resulting in
the lease not being granted by the land owner at Baptla. The
organisation has acknowledged the request made and accepted the
above contention allowing to establish the Automated Testing Station at
Chandolu village, Bapatla Mandal and the same was considered by the
organization and revised PRC dated 04.07.2025 was issued and which
does not constitute any revision or review, correction/ modification to
the Bid, as it was not submitted after the last date of the submission of
Bids as stipulated under sub-Section 13(c) of Section 2 of the Tender
Document. Petitioner’s counsel relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of M/s. N.G. Projects Limited v. M/s. Vinod
Kumar Jain1 for the proposition that if the Court finds that there is total
arbitrariness or that the tender application has been granted in a
malafied manner, still the Court should refrain from interfering in the
2022 (6) SCC 127
grant of tender but instead relegate the parties to seek damages for the
wrongful exclusion rather than to inject the execution of the contract.
The injunction or interference in the tender leads to additional costs on
the State and is also against public interest. Therefore, the State and
its citizens suffer twice, firstly by paying escalation costs and secondly,
by being deprived of the infrastructure for which the present day
Governments are expected to work.
8.
And the counsel for the 4th respondent also relied on the following
tow judgments of the Apex Court in B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd., v. Nair
Coal Services Ltd and others2 and also relied on the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa and
others3.
9.
In the case of M/s. Master Marine Services Pvt. Ltd v. Metcalfe
& Hodgkinson Pvt. Ltd. & another4, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that even when some defect is found in the decision making process,
the Court must exercise its discretionary powers under Article 226 with
great caution and should exercise it only in furtherance of public interest
and not merely on the making out of a legal point. The Court should
always keep the larger public interest in mind in order to decide whether
its intervention is called for or not. Only when, it comes to a conclusion
(2006) 11 SCC 548
(2007) 14 SCC 517
(2005) 6 SCC 138
that overwhelming public interest requires interference, the Court
should interfere. In the judgments of Jagdish Mandal (supra 3) and
in B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd., (supra 2), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that judicial review of administrative action is intended to prevent
arbitrariness, irrationality, unreasonableness, bias and malafides. Its
purpose is to check whether choice or decision is made ‘lawfully’ and
not to check whether choice or decision is ‘sound’. When the power of
judicial review is invoked in matters relating to tenders or award of
contracts, certain special features should be borne in mind. A contract
is a commercial transaction.
Evaluating tenders and awarding
contracts are essentially commercial functions. Principles of equity and
natural justice stay at a distance. If the decision relating to award of
contract is bonafide and is in public interest, Courts will not, in exercise
of power of judicial review, interfere even if a procedural aberration or
error in assessment or prejudice to a tender, is made out.
10.
The counsel appearing for the 2nd respondent vehemently
contended that the writ petitioners have not demonstrated any
arbitrariness, irrationality, or unreasonableness to the respondents.
Furthermore, the learned counsel for the 4th respondent stated or
asserted that the 2nd petitioner is mastermind who engineered a plan to
prevent the granting of a lease to the 4th unofficial respondent in
collusion with Bapatala land owner where the ATS is to be established.
In these circumstances, the 4th respondent prays to dismiss the Writ
petition.
11.
The organization i.e. the 2nd respondent has filed counter affidavit
and it is asserted that the 4th respondent having failed to commence
civil work in pursuance to preliminary PRC issued, has submitted a
representation on 14.05.2025 seeking extension of time for submission
of registered lease document of the land, where the Automated Testing
Station is to be established, stating the land owner was hospitalized.
Since, the 4th respondent in spite of extension of time not submitted
registered lease documents of the land, a show-cause notice was
issued vide letter R.No.18021/25/2024/RSC, dated 27.05.2025 to the
4th respondent and sought for explanation.
12.
In response to the show cause notice, the 4th respondent has
submitted explanation stating that “on his further investigation it was
discovered that the landowner has colluded with certain unsuccessful
bid participants from the earlier tendering process and it appears that
the land owner accepted payments from the parties to intentionally
cause the cancellation of PRC. This was purportedly done with the aim
of forcing the ATS project to be re-tendered, thereby allowing these
competitors to re-bid and potentially secure the tender and these
malafide actions have directly prevented them from completing the
lease deed registration as required.” And it is further stated that the
premises changed in the revised PRC is 15 Kms away from the District
Headquarters and the earlier is 20 Kms distance. The said revised
PRC was issued only after satisfying all the requisite conditions need to
be filed by the bidder and upon payment of penalty imposed on the 4th
respondent for delay in commencing civil work as per sub-Section 5(f)
of Section 4 of Request For Proposal (RFP).
Further a legal
contention
the
was
raised
stating
that
once
Preliminary
Registration Certificate was issued, technicalities could not be
raised by the writ petitioner.
13.
In the counter it is further stated that as per the clause 5(c) of the
Section 4 of Request For Proposal (RFP) suitability of land as follows:
(C) The suitability of the project site for ATS is defined as below:
(i) Project Site (Land) should be located with the concerned
District and at a place not beyond the radius of 30
kilometers from the District Magistrate Office.
(ii) Project site should not be next to the Power Station and
also it should not have any overhead High-tension line
passing over the project site.
(iii) Project site should be free from all encumbrances.
(iv) Project site should be either on national highways or State
Highways or District roads.
(v) The approach road to the Project Site should be minimum
07 meters wide so that it will not hinder the movement of
heavy vehicles coming for fitness test.
14.
It is further stated that as per the tender document that the
requirement that stipulated under the RFP with respect to land is that
the bidder shall furnish a valid proof of ownership or lease and ensure
that the proposed site satisfies the prescribed suitability criteria. Upon
issuance of the PRC, the process moves from the stage of evaluation to
that of implementation, and the RFP nowhere restricts administrative
modifications when warranted and when all mandatory conditions
continue to be fulfilled. And the present place of ATS enhances road
safety
and
ensure
effective
vehicle
testing
and
certification
mechanisms. Hence, prayed to dismiss the Writ Petition.
15.
Point for consideration:
The petitioners’ counsel advanced the arguments with a smirk.
The tenuous arguments presented by the petitioners’ counsel,
accompanied by inappropriate demeanour is that the organisation
cannot alter or change the rules once the process or game has
commenced and referenced the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited
v. Mandeepa Enterprises and others5. The purport of the judgment in
Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited case (supra 5)
is that the fundamental principle that no order can be passed by any
2025 INSC 1108
court in any judicial proceeding against any party without hearing and
without giving such party an opportunity of hearing. Wherein, the said
case, the L2 bidder has submitted an application subsequent to the
entire bidding process was over and the financial bids were opened and
the application was rejected by the organization therein. Assailing the
same, a Writ Petition came to be filed before the High Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India and a learned Single Judge has
dismissed the Writ Petition. Following this, the H2 bidder filed an intra
Court appeal before the division bench, which allowed the Writ Appeal.
The appellant before the Apex Court, who was the H1 bidder, then
challenged the Division Bench's order in the Supreme Court, which set
aside the Division Bench's finding on the grounds that no order can be
made against any party without providing them the opportunity to be
heard. Therefore, the facts therein and the facts herein are entirely
different and the said judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court is not
applicable to the present facts of the case.
16.
Learned counsel appearing for the 4th unofficial respondent would
submit that erstwhile land owner has not granted the lease due to the
plan engineered by the 2nd petitioner herein and he has not made any
application to revise or review the bid as per the conditions stipulated in
the tender document. And due to the act of the writ petitioners, the 4th
respondent has incurred huge loss and he is unable to establish the
same. And also stated that the writ petitioner is not attributed any
arbitrariness or irrationality and unreasonableness and bias on the part
of the official and unofficial respondents. And the judgments referred
by the respondents are clearly applicable to the present facts of the
case and the Court should refrain from entertaining under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, in awarding contract.
17.
In such a writ petition filed by an unsuccessful bidder, the limited
question to be considered by the Court is as to whether the process
adopted or decision made by the authority was malafide, arbitrary,
irrational or was intended to favour someone and whether public
interest was affected. If the answers are in the negative, there should
be no interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Permitting an unsuccessful bidder to raise grievance after opening of
the financial bid would set a bad precedent. If it is permitted, grievance
of all kinds and of all sorts would be forthcoming and the contracts
would never get executed and the tender is filed in conformity with
tender conditions and after confirming the tender if it was so entitled
and enabled, a post opening grievance wouldn’t give the writ
petitioner’s a cause of action.
18.
This Court vide order dated 17.10.2025, has suspended the
revised PRC dated 04.07.2024 granted in favour of the petitioner
herein.
On hearing learned counsel for the petitioners and learned
counsel for the respondents, and on perusal of the documents filed and
the law held by the Hon’ble Apex Court, this Court finds no
arbitrariness, irrationality in granting the contract to the 4th unofficial
respondent. The 4th respondent specifically pleaded in his counter that
at the behest and the plan engineered by the 2nd petitioner, the earlier
land owner did not granted a lease, this contention has not been denied
by the writ petitioners by way of reply. In absence of the denial, it shall
be deemed that the petitioners are accepted the said contention. The
2nd respondent has stated that the present site is more feasible rather
than the earlier site.
19.
In National High Speed Rail Corporation Ltd., Vs. Montecarlo
Ltd., and another6, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as follows :
"48. Even while entertaining the writ petition and/or granting the stay
which ultimately may delay the execution of the Mega projects, it
must be remembered that it may seriously impede the execution of
the projects of public importance and disables the State and/or its
agencies/instrumentalities from discharging the constitutional and
legal obligation towards the citizens. Therefore, the High Courts
should be extremely careful and circumspect in exercise of its
discretion while entertaining such petitions and/or while granting stay
in such matters. Even in a case where the High Court is of the prima
facie opinion that the decision is as such perverse and/or arbitrary
and/or suffers from mala fides and/or favouritism, while entertaining
such writ petition and/or pass any appropriate interim order, High
(2022) 6 SCC 401
Court may put to the writ petitioner's notice that in case the petitioner
loses and there is a delay in execution of the project due to such
proceedings initiated by him/it, he/they may be saddled with the
damages caused for delay in execution of such projects, which may
be due to such frivolous litigations initiated by him/it. With these
words of caution and advise, we rest the matter there and leave it to
the wisdom of the Court(s) concerned, which ultimately may look to
the larger public interest and the national interest involved."
20.
This writ petition has been filed with the aim to cancel the PRC
issued in favour the 4th unofficial respondent, who managed the
landowner interested in granting a lease to this respondent. The Court
finds that the petitioners filed this writ petition to harass the 4th unofficial
respondent and to delay the execution of ATS. Therefore, the Writ
Petition is dismissed with costs of Rs.25,000/- payable to the A.P. High
Court Employees Association. The said costs must be paid within a
period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order,
failing to do so it constitute a violation of the order and this Court will not
hesitate to exercise its power under contempt of Courts Act, for
realization of the said amount.
21.
Accordingly the writ petition stands dismissed.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications, if any, pending in this writ
petition shall stand closed.
Date: 24.02.2026
Harin
__________________________________
JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
W.P.No. 28747 OF 2025
Date: 24-02-2026
Harin
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review