Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment Reserved on: 15.01.2026
Judgment delivered on: 12.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per Digital Signature~
W.P.(C) 13179/2025
VISION DIAGNOSTIC INDIA
PRIVATE LIMITED
.....Petitioner
versus
ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL
SCIENCES & ANR
.....Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Petitioner
:
Mr Ankit Jain, Senior Advocate with Mr.
Abhishek Kumar, Mr. Devesh Pratap Singh,
Mr. Imtiyaz, Ms. Ankita Pandey and Ms.Aditi
Kushwaha, Advocates.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Anand Verma, Mr. Apoorva Pandey and
Mr. Ayush Gupta, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J.
CM APPL. 54020/2025 (for taking on record additional documents)
1.
For the reasons stated in the application, the same is allowed. The
additional documents are taken on record.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
2.
The application stands disposed of.
W.P.(C) 13179/2025 and CM APPL. 64121/2025
3.
This petition has been filed with the following prayers:
“a) Issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate
writ, order, or direction, calling for records & to
quash/set aside/strike off the impugned Notice Inviting
Tender (NIT) bearing Tender Enquiry No. NCI47/DTM/2024-25 dated 25.07.2025 issued by
Respondents Annexed as Annexure P – 2.
b) To quash the impugned Notice Inviting Tender (NIT)
dated 25.07.2025 as it imposes the disqualification
condition requiring that “the bidder should submit an
undertaking that no FIR/criminal proceedings are
pending against them,” and declare the said condition as
arbitrary,
unconstitutional,
unreasonable
and
disproportionate being violative of Article 14, 19(1)(g) &
21 of the Constitution of India, being repugnant to the
fundamental principle of presumption of innocence
ingrained in Indian criminal jurisprudence.
c) Issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate
writ, order, or direction, directing the Respondents to
process the Petitioner’s already scrutinised and
negotiated L1 bid in Tender Enquiry No. NCI47/DTM/2024-25 dated 06.12.2024, and issue the
purchase order in accordance with law.
d) Direct the Respondents to refrain from taking any
coercive or adverse action against the Petitioner,
including but not limited to blacklisting, termination, or
discontinuation of business relations, solely on account
of the pendency of CBI-FIR No. RC0062024A0019 dated
23.07.2024, in which the Petitioner has neither been
implicated as a prime accused nor has any adverse
finding been made against it.
e) Grant any other relief( s) that this Hon'ble Court may
deem just and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
4.
The primary challenge in this petition is to a Notice Inviting Tender
(NIT) bearing Tender Enquiry No. NCI-47/DTM/2024-25 dated 25.07.2025
issued by the respondents - All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS).
The petitioner is seeking a direction to the respondents to process the
already scrutinized, negotiated and concluded L1 bid in Tender Enquiry
No.NCI-47/DTM/2024-25 dated 06.12.2024.
5.
The case of the petitioner is that it is a leading private limited
company engaged in specialised fields such as Cancer Diagnostics, Life
Sciences, Transplant Diagnostics, Reproductive Health, Proteomics, and
Genomics. Over the last two decades, it has established itself as a key
supplier and service provider of advanced diagnostic and research solutions
to premier institutions across India, with its products widely used in fertility
clinics, ART centres, hospitals, universities, and research institutes. The
respondent No.1 is AIIMS, New Delhi, a premier medical institution of
national importance, established under the All-India Institutes of Medical
Sciences Act, 1956. The respondent No.2 is the National Cancer Institute
(NCI), which functions as an integral part of the respondent No.1.
6.
At the outset, we may narrate the facts leading to the present
controversy as seen from the petition. The respondents invited a Tender
through the Central Public Procurement (CPP) Portal for the procurement of
Digital PCR Systems through NIT vide Tender Enquiry No. NCI47/DTM/2024-25, dated 25.07.2025 (second Tender), suppressing the
previously floated Tender NCI-47/DTM/2024-25 dated 06.12.2024(first
Tender) wherein the petitioner had already been declared L1 for
procurement of the same product with identical specifications and terms,
except for one material change i.e. the insertion of a new and additional
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
condition in Clause 5 of Section VIII, “Qualification Criteria” requiring that
“Bidder should submit an undertaking that no pending criminal proceedings
/ FIRs are pending against them.” and “…AIIMS reserve the right to reject a
bid on account of any pending criminal proceeding(s)/FIR(s) against the
bidders…” and in Section VII stating that thereby indirectly barring the
petitioner from participating in the Tender process, which the respondents
could not have done legally merely on the basis of any pending
FIR/Criminal proceedings against the petitioner. The details of both the
previous and the impugned identical Tenders are as follows:
7.
The petitioner had submitted its bid for the previously floated Tender
NCI-47/DTM/2024-25
dated
06.12.2024
wherein
multiple
bidders
participated in the Tender process. Upon due technical evaluation by the
competent authority, three bidders, including the petitioner, were shortlisted
as technically qualified. Thereafter, the financial bids of the shortlisted
bidders were opened in accordance with the terms of the Tender, the General
Financial Rules, 2017, and the Purchase Manual of the respondent No.1
wherein the petitioner emerged as the lowest (L1) bidder. Pursuant to the
same, a price negotiation meeting was convened, with the petitioner being
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
the sole L1 bidder, and subsequently, the petitioner submitted a proforma
invoice at the revised/negotiated rates as asked by the respondents for the
purposes of a purchase order, thereby fully complying with all Tender
requirements.
8.
The respondents instead of following the Procurement Rules and the
terms and conditions of the Tender, which require the issuance of a purchase
order to the petitioner being the L1 bidder, vide email dated 03.01.2025,
informed
the
petitioner
that
an
FIR
bearing
CBI/ACB
FIR
No.RC0062024A0019 dated 23.07.2024 had been registered against the
petitioner, and directed the petitioner to provide classification with regard to
the same within three days. Thereafter, on 16.01.2025, the petitioner
received another email from the respondents with the subject "Reminder-I",
reiterating the contents of the previous communication dated 03.01.2025
regarding the alleged registration of FIR dated 23.07.2024 and requesting
the petitioner to investigate the matter and inform the Store Research
Section.
9.
On 21.01.2025, the petitioner responded to the respondents’ emails,
clarifying its position regarding the CBI, ACB FIR No. RC0062024A0019
dated 23.07.2024. The petitioner highlighted its longstanding reputation as a
trusted vendor for various institutions across India, operating transparently
and providing quality services for over two decades. It was specifically
pointed out that while the FIR pertains to alleged anti-corruption activities,
no adverse findings have been made against the petitioner in the CBI
preliminary inquiry or the High-Level Committee report of the Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). Moreover, the petitioner
conveyed that it is not the prime accused in the FIR, and its inclusion is
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
solely based on a WhatsApp exchange regarding a standard business inquiry
between its Area Sales Manager and a CSIR employee, Mr. Avinash Tambe.
The petitioner further emphasized that its name appears in the FIR as a
matter of procedure and precaution, similar to other entities engaged in
business dealings with CSIR during Mr. Tambe’s tenure.
10.
However, on 25.07.2025, the respondents issued a fresh and identical
Tender bearing the same Tender Enquiry No.NCI- 47/DTM/2024-25, for the
same item, with the same specifications without cancelling the earlier
Tender. The only material change in the second Tender was the insertion of
a new qualification criteria requiring an undertaking that no FIR/criminal
proceedings were pending against the bidder, and granting AIIMS the right
to reject bids on that basis.
11.
The petitioner firmly asserted that mere allegations, without
substantive evidence or conviction by a competent authority cannot justify
prejudicial actions against it. Referring to settled legal principles, including
the judgment of the Supreme Court in Basayya Prabhayya Hallur v. State
of Karnataka [(2009) 17 SCC 55], the petitioner stressed that an FIR is
merely an initial investigatory step and does not establish guilt. The
presumption of innocence, a fundamental principle of Indian criminal
jurisprudence must be upheld, as reiterated by the Supreme Court in
Narendra Singh & Anr. v. State of M.P. (2004)Criminal Appeal
No.298/1997 . Any adverse action against the petitioner solely on the basis
of an FIR would be premature, unjustified, and legally untenable. The
petitioner also assured its full cooperation with the investigation, expressing
its willingness to provide any clarifications required by the authorities in the
appropriate legal forum.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
12.
On 27.01.2025, an affidavit was executed by the Director of the
petitioner wherein it was solemnly undertaken and declared that the CBI
FIR, under which the Lucknow branch of the petitioner has been arraigned,
has no connection or legal implication on the functioning of its Delhi
branch. It was further clarified that the FIR concerning the Lucknow branch
would have no bearing on any order of supply issued via the Delhi branch.
The affidavit also stated that in the event of any irregularity in connection
with any order of supply, the petitioner is fully prepared to face any legal
consequences. As per the petitioner, the affidavit establishes beyond doubt
that the allegations in the FIR are confined solely to the Lucknow branch
and do not affect the operations, contractual obligations, or Tender
participation of the Delhi branch.
13.
Despite the detailed and well-reasoned representation submitted by
the petitioner via email on 21.01.2025, the respondents, without any due
consideration of the submissions made, sent yet another email on
11.02.2025, insisting that the petitioner submit a closure report of the FIR,
failing which "necessary action" would be taken.
14.
While the Tender (wherein the petitioner had already been declared
L1) was still live on the CPP Portal, the respondents issued the fresh
impugned NIT vide Tender Enquiry No. NCI-47/DTM/2024-25, dated
25.07.2025, for procurement of the same product with identical
specifications and terms having same Tender Enquiry Number as that of the
first Tender, except for one material change i.e. the insertion of a newly
introduced “Qualification Criteria” under Clause 5 of Section VIII of the
Tender Document, requiring that “Bidder should submit an undertaking that
no pending criminal proceedings/FIRs are pending against them.” And a
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
condition under Section VII that “…AIIMS reserve the right to reject a bid
on account of any pending criminal proceeding(s)/FIR(s) against the
bidders…”.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
15.
It is the case of the petitioner that the new additional clause, coupled
with the issuance of the second Tender overlapping the first Tender is
arbitrary, mala fide, and designed solely to disqualify the petitioner, despite
it being the successful L1 bidder for the identical Tender. The respondents
have issued the second Tender with the same Tender Number as that of the
first Tender to keep the issuance of the purchase order on hold. This act of
the respondents not only defeats the sanctity of the concluded Tender
process but also confers an undue advantage upon the petitioner’s
competitors, who had otherwise failed in the earlier Tender process wherein
the petitioner turned out to be the L1 bidder.
16.
Mr. Ankit Jain, learned senior counsel for the petitioner would submit
that the respondents, with the sole intent to debar the petitioner, have added
the following conditions:
i.
A new Qualification Clause (as part of Section VIII –
Qualification Criteria) requiring an undertaking that no
FIR/criminal proceedings were pending against the bidder.
ii.
Grant of unfettered discretion to AIIMS (as part of Section VIITechnical Specification) the right to reject bids on account of
any pending criminal proceeding(s)/FIR(s) against the bidder.
17.
He stated that the first Tender was never shown as cancelled on the
Government e-Procurement / GeM Portal, and its status continued to reflect
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
“Opening in Progress”. He has placed on record a screenshot taken on
29.08.2025 at 12:45 PM, of the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) Portal, eProcurement System, Government of India.
18.
He submitted that the respondents were fully aware of FIR No.
RC0062024A0019 dated 23.07.2024 well before the technical evaluation,
financial bid opening, price negotiation, and declaration of the petitioner as
L1 in the Tender dated 06.12.2024. Having proceeded with the process
despite prior knowledge, shortlisted the petitioner as technically qualified,
declared L1 status, further conducted negotiations and having accepted the
proforma invoice, the respondents are estopped from withholding the
purchase order or re-tendering on the ground of the FIR, rendering the action
biased, arbitrary, mala fide, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India. The respondents should have refrained from moving ahead with the
Tender process after writing the e-mail dated 03.01.2025 to the petitioner
and the action to cancel the Tender after further price negotiation and
exposing the minimum possible rate of the petitioner, shows that the action
is biased, arbitrary and mala fide. If the respondents were not satisfied with
the response filed by the petitioner, they should have cancelled the Tender
process without opening the Financial Bids. The bias and arbitrary action of
the respondents is evident from the fact that they further entered into price
negotiations with the petitioner and after having the best price offer from the
petitioner, they floated a new Tender without cancelling the earlier one.
19.
Mr. Jain has submitted that registration of an FIR under Section 154
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is merely the recording of
information relating to a cognizable offence and does not involve any
adjudication on the merits or determination of guilt. Reliance on the mere
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
pendency of an FIR to disqualify a bidder is legally untenable and can be
misused as a tool to arbitrarily eliminate competitors from the procurement
process.
20.
In fact, The FIR primarily implicates one Mr. Avinash Tambe, a CSIR
employee, of corrupt practices involving non-official vendors at CSIR-IITR,
Lucknow. It highlights a nexus between Mr. Tambe and suppliers, M/s
Shipra Scientific and M/s N.D. Enterprises, through the manipulation of
purchase orders and the receipt of monetary favors in exchange for unfair
practices. The only reason as to why the petitioner has been arraigned in the
FIR is because of the existence of a WhatsApp exchange regarding a
standard business inquiry about product pricing between Mr. Gaurav, Area
Sales Manager of the petitioner, and Mr. Tambe. This cannot reasonably
form the basis for an accusation of corrupt practices. Hence, business
entities holding any sort of business with CSIR during the course of
employment of Mr. Tambe has been arraigned in the FIR as a matter of
procedure and precaution. This cannot by any stretch of imagination, be
construed as evidence of corruption or collusion.
21.
He stated that the respondents never formally cancelled, withdrew, or
annulled the first Tender wherein the petitioner had already been declared
L1. Further upon cancelling the Tender, the security deposit was not
refunded to the petitioner. The respondents have never issued any formal
order or communication cancelling the first Tender in which the petitioner
was declared L1. He also stated that the respondents’ reliance on the internal
file notings to say the competent authority approved the cancellation is
wholly misconceived, as such notings are merely intra-departmental
opinions and do not constitute any binding decision, order, or communicated
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
policy. It is settled law that internal notings, unless crystallized into a formal
and reasoned order, confer no legal rights and cannot be relied upon to
justify arbitrary cancellation or exclusion of a successful bidder. Reliance in
this regard is placed on Sethi Auto Service Station and Anr. v. Delhi
Development Authority & Ors., (2009) SCC 180.
22.
He has also submitted that as per Clause 5.29 of the AIIMS Purchase
Manual, 2018 read with Rule 151 of the General Financial Rules, 2017,
debarment from bidding can be resorted to only upon conviction for an
offence and not merely on the basis of allegations or pendency of an FIR, as
sought to be incorporated by the respondents. Any exclusion of a bidder
without a finding of guilt by a competent Court is, therefore, arbitrary,
illegal, and contrary to the governing procurement framework. The
respondents later amended this clause again, pursuant to the observations of
this Court during the hearing, to restrict the ineligibility to: i) Conviction for
serious offences, or ii) FIRs under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
These successive changes demonstrate thata) The qualification criteria were not based on procurement
requirements;
b) They were reactive, not principled; and
c) They were tailored to suit the respondents’ objective of excluding
the petitioner from participating in the Tender process by any means.
23.
From the official website of the Government, the petitioner has
verified the Tenders floated by AIIMS after the Tender dated 25.07.2025
and the conditions relating to FIR is not uniform in all the Tenders. This
shows the bias and arbitrary action of the respondents. Mr. Jain has attached
a list of Tenders where these conditions have been incorporated and also
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
excluded. He has filed details of equipments qua which the services are
being provided by the petitioner to AIIMS, which according to him, shows
that the act of the respondents in introducing the further condition is
deliberate and smacks of malice and bias against the petitioner.
24.
Further, it is stated that Clause 10.1.3 of the AIIMS Purchase Manual,
2018 provides that all the bids are to be evaluated strictly on the basis of the
terms and conditions incorporated in the Bidding Document. No new bid
condition should be brought in while evaluating the bids. As such, after
having further negotiated the price with the petitioner pursuant to the L1
declaration, the respondents’ act of cancelling the Tender only shows their
bias and mala fide intent.
25.
That apart, Rule 173(xii) (Transparency, Competition, Fairness and
Elimination of Arbitrariness in the Procurement Process) of the General
Financial Rules, 2017 read with Clause 1.4.6 (xii), Clause 30.1 and Clause
10.1.3 of the AIIMS Purchase Manual, 2018 mandate that no new condition
will be brought in while scrutinising and evaluating the bids. The imposition
of an additional requirement, one that was never contemplated in the terms
of the Tender, amounts to an illegal and unilateral modification of the
contractual framework, which is impermissible in law. The respondents
cannot introduce conditions to justify an unjustified and extrajudicial action,
especially when such an imposition violates the fundamental principles of
fair play, transparency, and adherence to contractual terms. This act not only
undermines the sanctity of the Tender process but also amounts to mala fide
interference in a legally binding contractual relationship, warranting judicial
intervention. He stated that the insertion of the new condition, without any
authority under the original Tender terms, and without adherence to the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
provisions of the AIIMS Purchase Manual, 2018, the General Financial
Rules, 2017, and the governing Tender conditions, amounts to a colourable
exercise of power. The respondents, instead of complying with the settled
norms of procurement and ensuring fairness and transparency in public
contracting, have acted in a manner designed to defeat the petitioner’s
legitimate expectation of receiving the award of contract as an L1 bidder,
thereby rendering their conduct arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of
Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.
26.
He has also contended that the introduction of such 'Qualification
Criteria' requiring an undertaking related to pending FIRs unfairly restricts
the petitioner and other bidders from participating in the Tender process,
which is an attempt by the respondents to indirectly debar or blacklist the
petitioner and similarly situated bidders. This amounts to achieving
indirectly what they cannot do directly, thereby violating the doctrine of
colourable legislation. He has placed reliance on the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Erusian Equipment & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of West
Bengal, AIR 1975 SC 266 wherein it was held that blacklisting a party is a
serious matter that adversely affects the party’s reputation and business
prospects. The Court emphasised that such an action cannot be taken
without adhering to the principles of natural justice, which mandate that the
affected party must be given a fair opportunity to be heard. Moreover, the
Court observed that pending investigations or mere allegations are
insufficient grounds for blacklisting; concrete evidence and due process are
necessary before implementing such punitive measures. It is the contention
of Mr. Jain that therefore, non-consideration of the representation of the
petitioner by the respondents amounts to a blatant violation of the principles
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
of natural justice, fairness, and due process. The arbitrary refusal to
acknowledge or deliberate upon the petitioner’s submissions reflects a
premeditated intent to impose punitive consequences without any legal
basis. Such an approach is not only unjust but also vitiates the entire
decision-making process, rendering it perverse and unsustainable in the eyes
of law. Any adverse action, including restricting business dealings with the
petitioner based solely on unproven allegations and without following due
process, would be premature and legally untenable.
27.
He has sought the prayers as made in the petition.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
28.
Per contra, Mr. Anand Verma, learned counsel for the respondent
AIIMS, would submit that it is a matter of record that the Tender dated
06.12.2024 has been cancelled by the respondents on 05.06.2025 which was
followed by the issuance of the Tender dated 25.07.2025. As such, the
petitioner cannot agitate any alleged rights flowing from the same. It is a
settled position of law that even the highest/lowest bidder cannot claim any
vested right to do business with the government, until the contract or Letter
of Intent has been issued in its favour.
29.
He stated that as per Clause 40 of the Tender, the purchaser (AIIMS)
reserved the right to accept in part or full, any bid or reject any or more
bid(s) without assigning any reason or to cancel the Tender process and
reject all bids at any time prior to the award of the contract. Clause 40 reads
as under:
“40. Purchaser’s Right to accept any bid and to reject any
or all bids. 40.1. The purchaser reserves the right to accept
in part or in full any bid or reject any or more bid(s)
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
without assigning any reason or to cancel the Tender
process and reject all bids at any time prior to the award of
the contract, without incurring any liability, whatsoever to
the affected bidder(s).”
30.
Pertinently, while submitting a bid, prospective bidders have to
submit a Tender Acceptance Form as provided under Section IX of the
Tender dated 06.12.2024. In the said Form, the bidders expressly
acknowledge the following:
“We further understand that you are not bound to accept
the lowest or any bid you may receive against your abovereferred advertised tender enquiry. …
We confirm that we fully agree to the terms and conditions
specified in above mentioned Tender document, including
amendment/ corrigendum if any. …”
31.
In view of the above clear stipulations in the Tender dated
06.12.2024 and the undertaking given by all prospective bidders, it is
evident that the respondents are not under any obligation to accept any bid,
even the lowest / L1 bid, and that the said Tender can be cancelled at any
time. Reference in this regard is made to the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Indore Vikas Praadhikaran (IDA) v. Shri Humud Jain Samaj Trust,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3511.
32.
Mr. Verma submitted that on 25.03.2025, the Technical Specification
and Evaluation Committee (TESC) of the respondents held a meeting
wherein it was decided that the competent authority shall finally decide
whether the Tender dated 06.12.2024 should be cancelled and re-tendered.
As such, the matter was submitted to the competent authority which
conferred its approval for cancellation of the said Tender on 05.06.2025 and
for floating a new / fresh Tender for procuring a single unit of Digital PCR.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
Consequently, with the due approval of the competent authority i.e., Dr.
Alok Thakar, the then Head of respondent No. 2-NCI, AIIMS floated the
second Tender dated 25.07.2025 after cancelling the Tender dated
06.12.2024. In the second Tender Clause 5 under Section VIII (Qualification
Criteria) the following condition was added:
“5. Bidder should submit the undertaking that that no
pending criminal proceedings(s)/FIR(s) against
bidder(s)”
33.
The end date of submission of bids for the Tender dated 25.07.2025
was extended on two occasions by AIIMS to 30.09.2025 and 15.10.2025. It
is submitted that due to inadvertence, the status of the Tender dated
06.12.2024 as being cancelled was not updated on the portal. However, the
same is not in any manner indicative of the said Tender being active /
pending / being kept in abeyance.
34.
As the Tender dated 06.12.2024 was duly cancelled with the approval
of the competent authority, it is entirely incorrect and flawed for the
petitioner to claim that the respondents have kept the said Tender in
abeyance. The inadvertence in updating the (cancelled) status of the Tender
on the website cannot be relied upon by the petitioner for substantiating any
alleged arbitrariness /mala fide / unreasonableness on the part of the
respondents.
35.
Further, he submitted that AIIMS being an instrumentality of the
State and an institute of national importance, took a conscious decision to
float a fresh/new Tender, keeping in view the nature of contract as its main
consideration. The subject matter of both Tenders involves not just provision
of a single unit of Digital PCR but also further services (warranty and
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
comprehensive Annual Maintenance Contract) over a period of 10 years
from the date of installation of the Digital PCR. Considering the nature of
the Tender and the services required, AIIMS took a considered decision that
it will require a long-term contractual arrangement from all prospective
bidders and any pending criminal proceedings/FIRs may impact the same.
Notwithstanding this, AIIMS also considered it appropriate as a matter of
precaution to not engage in contracts with any entities against whom any
criminal proceedings/FIRs are pending. The same is not borne out of any
alleged arbitrariness / mala fide or other extraneous consideration to favour
another bidder. To support his stand, he has referred to the judgments of this
Court in Deepak and Co. v. IRCTC, WP(C) No. 6460/2024 dated
22.04.2025 and Sahakar Global Ltd. v. MCD, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 2273.
36.
While the petitioner has not been convicted under the FIR dated
23.07.2024, the respondents are entitled to adopt a precautionary eligibility
qualification whereby they do not enter into a long-term contract with
entities against whom any criminal proceedings/FIRs are pending.
Moreover, the condition for the subject Tender is general in application and
not directed against any particular bidder, including the petitioner, and
cannot amount to blacklisting/debarment by AIIMS.
37.
He has referred to a Full Bench decision of the High Court of Orissa
in Nanda Infra Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Orissa & Ors., WP(C)
No. 5790 & 5535 of 2024 wherein the law laid down by the Supreme Court
in this regard has been summarised as under:
“43. In view of the above discussion and the decisions of the
Supreme Court referred to above , we answer the questions
referred to the Full Bench as under:- …
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
(ii) Before cancellation of a tender notice, there is no
requirement of giving an opportunity of hearing or prior
notice to the highest / lowest bidder, as such bidder does not
acquire any vested right to have the auction confirmed in
his / her / its favour on that basis alone.”
38.
That apart, he has submitted that the Tender condition being a
commercial decision does not require interference of the Court. He has
contested the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
now amended Clause 5 of Section VIII of the Tender dated 25.07.2025 is in
violation of the General Financial Rules, 2017 and the AIIMS Purchase
Manual, 2018, by stating that the AIIMS Purchase Manual, 2018 itself states
that it is meant as a “guide” and not a mandatory rule/regulation in the
preface that “Since, all situations cannot be foreseen and laid down in the
Purchase Manual; the persons involved in the procurement process are
expected to take decisions exercising normal commercial prudence taking
into consideration the canons of financial propriety and move forward.”
39.
His contention is that once the respondents’ Technical Specification
and Evaluation Committee has, after application of mind and as a measure
of precaution, recommended to introduce a clause for disqualifying bidders
having FIR(s)/criminal proceedings against them (Clause 5 under Section
VIII), and the same ought not to be interfered with.
40.
He has referred to the judgment of the High Court of Judicature at
Allahabad in Jain Video On Wheels v. State of U.P. & Ors., 2014 SCC
OnLine All 17866 wherein the Court has upheld disqualification of bidders
on account of pending criminal proceedings. Relevant part of the judgment
reads as under:
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
“12. Since these issues are interrelated, it would be
appropriate for the convenience of the exposition to deal
with them seriatim. The first issue pertains to the rejection
of the bid submitted by the petitioner. Clause 2.3.6.2 of the
RFP document specifically provides that an entity, which
has been punished for any offence or if the
Director/President/Chairperson/Trustee of that entity is
convicted, or against whom any criminal case is pending
before the competent Court, shall not be eligible to submit a
proposal. Essentially, clause 2.3.6.2 is in three parts. The
first part pertains to a situation where a bidding entity has
been punished for an offence. The second part refers to a
situation where one or more of the named personnel of the
bidding entity are convicted of any offence. The third refers
to the pendency of a criminal case. Now, in the present case,
it is not in dispute that a First Information Report was
lodged on 5 March 2012 under Section 120- B read with
Sections 409 and 420 of the Penal Code, 1860, both against
the Company and Atul Prakash Nigam, who is described as
the Vice President of the Company.
xxxx
26. In the present case, the challenge to clause 2.3.6.2
cannot be considered in the abstract, but regard must be
had to the nature of the allegations in the charge sheet
which has been filed against the This Procurement Manual
will provide the essential information and will serve as stepby-step guide for procurement of goods and services. The
earlier version has been modified and new processes I
chapters have been added and explained taking into account
technical complexity of procurement activities. Procurement
is a complex process and it is unique for different categories
of items. Since, all situations cannot be foreseen and laid
down in the Purchase Manual; the persons involved in the
procurement process are expected to take decisions
exercising normal commercial prudence taking into
consideration the canons of financial propriety and move
forward petitioner and its CEO. It must be noted that the
charge sheet which has been filed relates specifically to
allegations of wrong doing in regard to the operation of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
mobile and medical units in the course of the programmes
of the National Rural Health Mission itself. Undoubtedly, at
this stage, the allegations have to be proved in the Court of
competent criminal jurisdiction. However, the issue before
the Court is as to whether a party against whom a criminal
case is pending before the competent Court on an allegation
pertaining to commission of offences under the Penal code
in collusion with officers of the State against whom, in
addition, there are charges under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, should be regarded as eligible,
notwithstanding the pendency of the criminal case. In our
view, the State is entitled to prescribe such a norm of
eligibility so as to ensure that the bidding process is not
tainted. There is nothing arbitrary or improper in the action
of the State in excluding such a bidder from the fray of
contesting parties.
xxxx
In the circumstances, we dispose of the petition in terms of
the following conclusions: (i) The rejection of the bid
submitted by the petitioner for the reasons, as
communicated on 15 January 2014, is held to be valid and
proper”
41.
A challenge preferred to the said judgment has been rejected by the
Supreme Court in SLP(Crl) No. 3750/2014.
42.
He has submitted that the petitioner has sought to downplay the
allegations in the FIR dated 23.07.2024, where it has been arrayed as an
accused and its role has been clearly made out. The said FIR has been
registered due to a complaint dated 05.07.2024 by the CSIR, is he has drawn
our attention to the following:
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
43.
In fact, the recommendations of the committee constituted for
vigilance in CSIR specifically recorded that “(ii) the matter may be referred
to an appropriate authority for further investigation”.
44.
Mr. Verma has drawn our attention to a judgment of the Allahabad
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Rajan Construction v. State of UP
& Anr., Writ-C No.34248/2024, wherein it has been held as under:
“24. This Court is of the view that the impugned conditions
are tailormade and incorporated with a specific motive for
public interest and no material has been placed on record to
show as to how the petitioner has been targeted for their
exclusion in the tender process. There is no material to
show that the impugned condition is designed to favour a
particular bidder. For want of necessary particulars, we are
not inclined to accept the submissions of the learned
counsel for the petitioner.
xxxx
26. The tender condition is also in consonance with the
policy of the Government. The purpose of incorporating
such conditions can be clearly understood from the policy
framed by the Government, followed by the advisory issued
in this regard. The respondent, in its counter affidavit, has
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
also averred that the purpose behind incorporating such
stringent clause as a pre-qualifying condition of the tender
is the distressing environmental condition in the NCR
region. This indicates that the raison d'être of imposition of
a stringent condition, that is, allowing only the existing
pellet manufacturers having their plant location in NCR
region or within 100 km from the truck gate of the power
station to participate in the tender process is to reduce
stubble burning by farmers which is the persistent and root
cause for air pollution in the NCR region.
27. Ergo, the restrictive condition in the tender cannot be
considered to be arbitrary and discriminatory. It is within
the wisdom and discretion of the employer to determine the
conditions/clauses that are best suited for the work to be
performed in the public interest.
28. In the present case, respondent no.3 floated a tender
dated July 10, 2024 for supply of biomass pellets at
Harduaganj Thermal Power Station. Clause 3(i) of the
tender imposes restrictions on participants to keep a tight
rein on persistent obnoxious air condition in the NCR
region. This clause is also at consensus with the revised
Model Contract dated January 6, 2023 issued by the
Ministry of Power, Government of India. It is the
prerogative of the respondents to frame the terms and
conditions of the tender in accordance with policy
decisions. We, therefore, do not find any substance in the
arguments raised on behalf of the petitioner.
29. The power of judicial review will not be permitted to be
invoked to protect private interest at the cost of public
interest. It is a well settled principle that judicial review in
contractual matters is limited, particularly when the
decision of the tendering authority is bona fide and taken in
the public interest.”
45.
He stated that as is clear from the above, AIIMS as the Tendering
Authority is entitled to prescribe Tender conditions, as a commercial
decision, it deems fit and necessary to ensure the sanctity of the Tender
process and in public interest, and such commercial decision may not
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
require interference in the absence of arbitrariness, mala fides and
unreasonableness. In short, his contention is that Courts should not interfere
with commercial transactions. To buttress this, he has relied upon the
judgments of the Supreme Court in Tata Cellular v. Union of India, (1994)
6 SCC 651; Air India Ltd. v. Cochin International Airport Ltd., (2000) 2
SCC, 617; Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa, (2007) 14 SCC 517;
Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka, (2012) 8 SCC 216
and N.G. Projects Ltd. v. Vinod Kumar Jain, (2022) 6 SCC 127.
46.
Mr. Verma has also submitted that the inclusion of Clause 5 in the
Tender dated 25.07.2025 cannot be treated as an amendment to the previous
Tender dated 06.12.2024, when the latter already stands cancelled and
cannot be acted upon. The petitioner’s allegations regarding the insertion
thereof amounting to a colourful exercise of power are consequently,
misconceived and without any basis in fact and in law.
47.
He also submitted that the petitioner’s reliance upon the General
Finance Rules, 2017 and AIIMS Purchase Manual, 2018 is irrelevant as the
previous Tender already stands cancelled, and as such no issue of
amendment to the said Tender conditions can arise. Any alleged
arbitrariness in a Tender process which has since been cancelled is irrelevant
vis-a-vis the qualification criteria in a fresh / new Tender since the alleged
cause of action for both the Tenders are entirely distinct and separate.
48.
It is also submitted that the petitioner does not have any fundamental
right
to
conduct
business
with
the
respondents/Government.
Notwithstanding this, the said clause has been amended vide Corrigendum
IX dated 12.01.2026 by which AIIMS has relaxed Clause 5 to allow bidders
having FIR(s) of minor offences to participate in the Tender, in accordance
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
with the observations of this Court during the hearings held on 15.12.2025
and 16.12.2025. He submitted that the same ought not to be interfered with,
especially considering that the condition for disqualifying bidders who have
FIR(s) registered against them is a condition adopted by several government
organisations in the Tenders issued by them.
49.
He stated that there is no inconsistency with Clause 23 under Section
VII and Clause 5 under Section VIII of the Tender dated 25.07.2025. Clause
23 merely provides AIIMS with the power to reject a bidder on account of
any pending criminal proceedings/FIRs against them. The same does not
operate as a disqualification. Whereas, the amended Clause 5 under Section
VIII allows bidders without any conviction under offences for imprisonment
for more than 3 years and with FIRs other than under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988 to participate in the Tender. A harmonious reading of
the said clauses clearly shows that AIIMS is empowered to reject a bidder
who has any pending criminal proceeding(s)/FIRs against them whereas,
bidders who have been (i) convicted under any offence and imprisoned for a
period of more than 3 years and (ii) those who are being investigated / under
trial arising out of an FIR involving allegations of Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 are disqualified from the subject Tender. Clause 5 of Section VIII
operates as an objective curtailment of the discretion to be exercised by the
respondents under Clause 23 of Section VII, and there is no conflict between
the two clauses. As such, the respondents will have to exercise their
discretion to reject bids/bidders against whom there are FIRs other than
under the provisions the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, as opposed to
an overarching/wide discretion.
50.
It is also his case that the inclusion of the impugned Clause 5 in the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
subject Tender does not operate as a bar to the petitioner specifically. It is a
general clause in the subject Tender meant to safeguard public interest.
There is no arbitrariness or unreasonableness in the said stipulation which
entails interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
51.
He seeks dismissal of the petition.
52.
At this juncture, it is necessary to state that Mr. Jain for the petitioner
has contested the reliance placed by Mr. Verma on the judgments above to
justify the impugned re-tendering and withholding of the purchase order.
According to Mr. Jain, these judgments are distinguishable on facts and in
law, and in several instances, actually reinforce the petitioner’s case that
arbitrary actions in Tender processes, without due process or rational basis,
warrant judicial intervention under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
He has provided a concise refutation of the judgments, reproduced as below:
a. Jain Video On Wheels (supra): This case involved the cancellation of
a Tender for ambulance services under NRHM due to serious
irregularities, including cartel formation and manipulation by the bidder,
leading to a fresh Tender after proper inquiry. The Court upheld the
State's discretion to cancel Tenders in public interest where malpractices
were evident. There was specific clause 2.3.6.2 in the contract which
provided as under:
“2.3.6.2 Any Entity which has been punished for any offence
or the Director/President/Chairperson/Trustee of the that
entity is convicted for any offence or against whom any
criminal cases is/are pending before competent court, shall
not be eligible to submit the proposal. The Bidder or each
member of Consortium (if Consortium is Bidder), as the
case may be, shall have to submit an affidavit to this effect
as per Format 4 as part of the Qualification Proposal.”
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
As is clear from this, here there was a specific provision relating to
punishment and conviction, or pendency of case before the competent
Court. In the present case, only an FIR has been registered and even the
charge sheet has not been filed against the petitioner. The said judgment
is distinguishable on the facts of the present case. Further, there is no
inquiry or finding of irregularity against the petitioner, and no refund of
security deposit has been made, apart from non-communication of
cancellation of Tender process. The re-Tendering was not in “public
interest” but mala fide to exclude the petitioner based on a mere FIR
(with no adverse findings in the CSIR High-Level Committee Report or
the CBI preliminary inquiry). Far from supporting the respondents, this
judgment underscores that Tender cancellations must be reasoned and
non-arbitrary, which is not the case here, as evidenced by the portal
status showing the first Tender as “Opening in Progress” even post retendering.
b. Jain Video On Wheels, SLP(Crl) No. 3750/2014 (supra): The
Supreme Court order dismissed the special leave petition challenging the
High Court's refusal to quash criminal proceedings linked to Tender
irregularities in the above case. It emphasizes that criminal probes into
Tender frauds should not be interfered with prematurely. This is wholly
distinguishable, as the petitioner here faces no conviction or even
charge-sheet but only a peripheral mention in an FIR arising from
routine business communication. The respondents’ reliance misconstrues
it to justify disqualification on mere FIR pendency, which violates
General Financial Rule 151 and AIIMS Manual Clause 5.29. This order
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
actually bolsters the petitioner’s stance that presumptive guilt from an
FIR cannot override Tender finality without due process.
c. Deepak and Co. v. IRCTC, dated 22.04.2025 in WP(C) No.
6460/2024: The Court here upheld IRCTC's decision to reject a bid due
to noncompliance with essential conditions and emphasised limited
judicial interference in Tenders unless arbitrariness is proven. It is
inapposite, as the petitioner fully complied with the original Tender, and
the impugned re-tender introduced a post-facto disqualification clause
absent in the first. The successive corrigenda and further amendment on
12.01.2026 (restricting to convictions or PC Act FIRs) reveal reactive
tailoring to exclude the petitioner, evidencing arbitrariness warranting
interference contrary to the respondents' claim.
d.
Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa, (2007) 14 SCC 517: This
seminal Supreme Court judgment limits judicial review of Tenders to
cases of arbitrariness, bias, or mala fides, stressing that administrative
decisions should not be substituted unless they are Wednesbury
unreasonable. The judgment supports the case of the petitioner, as the
respondents’ actions of re-tendering without cancelling the first,
Tenderer withholding PO despite its L1 status, and inserting the FIRbased disqualification mid-process are patently arbitrary and mala fide
(no public interest rationale in file notings).
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION
53.
The issue that arises for consideration is whether, when the bidding
process is complete and a bidder is successfully declared as the lowest
bidder (L1), the same can be cancelled and a fresh Tender can be issued by
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
the Tender Inviting Authority for the same subject matter, with revised
eligibility/qualification criteria that no criminal proceedings/FIRs should be
pending against potential bidders.
54.
The respondents issued the first Tender on 06.12.2024 and the second
Tender on 25.07.2025, for the same product with the same Tender number.
The petitioner was declared as L1, however, no purchase order or letter of
intent was issued pursuant to the same. It is the case of the respondents that
the first Tender has been cancelled by the competent authority, which
resulted in the issuance of the second Tender. It is also averred that the
respondents had cancelled the Tender without issuing any letter of intent or
purchase order. They have endeavored to justify the same by stating that
Clause 40 of the Tender Conditions states that the purchaser has the right to
accept in part or in full any bid, and reject any bid without assigning any
reason, and to cancel the Tender process and reject all bids at any time.
Though the case of the petitioner is that the cancellation of the first Tender
was not communicated to it.
55.
We note that the first Tender did not have any stipulation of
ineligibility owing to pendency of criminal proceedings/FIR. Though no
reason has been recorded by the respondents for cancelling the first Tender,
it is a settled law that the Tender Inviting Authority is within its rights to
cancel/reject the Tender at any stage. Even the lowest bidder (L1) does not
have any vested enforceable right to have their Tender accepted. We may
refer to the judgment of this Court in PKF Sridhar and Santhanam v.
Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India, WP(C) 12385/2021 in
this regard.
56.
So it follows that this Court shall only examine the vires of the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
qualification criteria as amended by the respondent, which we have already
reproduced above.
57.
There is no doubt that the respondent – AIIMS has been established
under the All-India Institutes of Medical Sciences Act, 1956, and is an
instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12, Part-III of the
Constitution of India. Suffice it to state, any decision taken by the
respondents therefore, needs to be free from arbitrariness, unreasonableness,
malafide and discrimination. We shall examine the impugned prescription of
qualification criteria in terms of the above.
58.
Now the question is whether the respondents are justified in
prescribing the qualification criteria that no criminal proceedings/FIRs
should be pending against the bidders. Suffice it to state, the Tender Inviting
Authority is entitled to prescribe Tender conditions it deems fit and
necessary to ensure sanctity of the Tendering process. The court only
examines the decision making process, and does not sit in appeal to review
the merits of such decision. However, when the process or the decision is
vitiated by arbitrariness, unfairness, illegality, irrationality or the principle of
Wednesbury unreasonableness, the same can be subjected to judicial review.
The law in this regard is well-settled by the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Tata Cellular (supra) wherein it has been observed as under:
“94. The principles deducible from the above are :
(1) The modern trend points to judicial restraint in
administrative action.
(2) The court does not sit as a court of appeal but merely
reviews the manner in which the decision was made. (3) The
court does not have the expertise to correct the
administrative decision. If a review of the administrative
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
decision is permitted it will be substituting its own decision,
without the necessary expertise which itself may be fallible.
(4) The terms of the invitation to tender cannot be open to
judicial scrutiny because the invitation to tender is in the
realm of contract.
Normally speaking, the decision to accept the tender or
award the contract is reached by process of negotiations
through several tiers. More often than not, such decisions
are made qualitatively by experts.
(5) The Government must have freedom of contract. In other
words, a fair play in the joints is a necessary concomitant
for an administrative body functioning in an administrative
sphere or quasi-administrative sphere. However, the
decision must not only be tested by the application of
Wednesbury principle of reasonableness (including its
other facts pointed out above) but must be free from
arbitrariness not affected by bias or actuated by mala
fides.
(6) Quashing decisions may impose heavy administrative
burden on the administration and lead to increased and
unbudgeted expenditure.”
(emphasis supplied)
59.
Further, in the judgment titled Erusian Equipment & Chemicals
Limited (supra), the Supreme Court has held that the activities of the
government, having a public element, should be undertaken with great
fairness and equality. It observed that the State need not enter into any
contract with anyone, but if it does, it must do so in a fair manner without
any discrimination.
60.
In view of the law which has enunciated by the Supreme Court on the
scope and limitations of the judicial review of administrative action of the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
State in the matters of Tender, we need to examine the consequences of the
qualification criteria prescribed by the respondents.
61.
It may be stated here that during the pendency of the petition,
pursuant to the observations of this Court, the respondents amended the
eligibility/qualification criteria by way of a Corrigendum in the following
manner:-
62.
Further, in Section-VII of the Tender dated 25.07.2025 under the head
‘Technical Specifications’, it has been stated that “AIIMS reserve the right
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
to reject a bid on account of any pending criminal proceeding(s)/FIR(s)
against bidder(s)”.
63.
The above reveals that a bidder shall not be eligible to participate in
the Tender in two eventualities –
(i)
when it has been convicted for any offence and sentenced to
imprisonment for a period of three years or more; and
(ii)
when it is being investigated and / or pending trial arising out
of an FIR involving allegations under the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988.
64.
Though the prayer sought for by the petitioner with regard to the
qualification criteria prescribed in the second Tender, was later amended
during the pendency of this writ petition, as the parties proceeded to argue
the case even on the amended conditions, we heard them extensively. In so
far as prayer (c) of the petition is concerned, it is the eventuality (ii) as
described above, that would arise.
65.
Now, the issue that needs to be decided is whether the qualification
criteria with regard to eventuality (ii) above, is justified or not. It is a
conceded case that it is the pendency of a CBI FIR dated 23.07.2024 in
relation to the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 which is being read
against the petitioner. The contention of the petitioner is that under Section
154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, an FIR is merely the
recording of information relating to a cognizable offense and does not
involve any adjudication of merits or determination of guilt. As such,
reliance on the mere pendency of an FIR to disqualify is unfair, and could
potentially be used as a tool to arbitrarily eliminate competitors from the
procurement process. Further it has been contended that the petitioner is not
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
the prime accused in the said FIR, rather it is registered against one Mr.
Avinash Tambe, an employee of CSIR, suspected of corrupt practices. The
petitioner has been mentioned as an accused in the FIR only as a
precautionary measure on the basis of the certain WhatsApp chats with Mr.
Avinash Tambe.
66.
The stand of the learned counsel for the respondents is that the
petitioner is downplaying the allegations in the FIR and that its role has been
clearly made out. In fact, the High Level Committee Report of CSIR has
recommended further investigation into the petitioner with respect to the
complaint that lead to the filing of the FIR. He stated that the respondents
have taken an informed decision with approval of the competent authority to
alter Clause 5 under Section VII of the Tender to exclude bidders who are
being investigated/ under trial in relation to FIRs involving the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988, to safeguard the sanctity of the Tender and public
interest.
67.
We are in agreement with the learned counsel for the petitioner that a
mere registration of the FIR cannot be construed to be a conclusive evidence
of guilt. No doubt, the allegations in the FIR, under the provisions of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 are serious in nature; however, it is
settled law that an FIR is not an encyclopedia disclosing all facts and details
relating to the offence. It is neither meant to be a chronicle of all intricate
and minute details, nor is it considered to be a substantive piece of evidence
and can be only used to corroborate or contradict the informant’s evidence
in the court. (Ref: Dharma Rama Bhagare v. State of Maharashtra, (1973)
1 SCC 537). It is merely a starting point for investigation and does not by
itself constitute the formal institution of criminal proceedings.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
68.
Criminal prosecution in law, for most purposes, begins when the
police investigates the allegations in the FIR, files the final report / charge
sheet and the Court takes cognizance of it. The principle that criminal
proceedings begin only when the court takes cognizance of the offences can
be found laid down by the Supreme Court in R.R. Chari v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, AIR 1951 SC 207 and Hardeep Singh v. State Of Punjab & Ors.,
AIR 2014 SC 1400. It is also a known presumption in law that every person
is innocent until proven guilty, and even when a statute or provision
presumes guilt, it must do so while meeting the standards of reasonableness
enshrined in the Constitution of India.
69.
As on the date of Tender, the allegations read against the petitioner
arises only from the FIR dated 23.07.2024. Investigation into such
allegations with regard to the petitioner is yet to be completed, and offenses
are yet to be made out for the FIR to culminate in a charge sheet to be laid
before a court of law. Any final adjudication on the same would presumably
take several years to culminate either in a conviction or an acquittal. The
effect of the impugned qualification criteria is that till such time there is a
final adjudication on the allegations contained in the FIR, the petitioner shall
be barred from participating in the selection process. Practically, the
consequence of the impugned qualification criteria is that the petitioner
would be ousted from the scope of the current and potentially future Tenders
issued by the respondents as long as the FIR persists, thereby debarring
and/or blacklisting it for an indefinite amount of time, without saying as
much.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
70.
The Supreme Court in Erusian Equipment and Chemicals Ltd.
(supra) has discussed the concept of blacklisting and its consequences as
under:
“12. Under Article 298 of the Constitution the Executive power of the
Union and the State shall extend to the carrying on of any trade and
to the acquisition, holding and disposal of property and the making of
contracts for any purpose. The State can carry on executive function
by making a law or without making a law. The exercise of such
powers and functions in trade by the State is subject to Part III of the
Constitution. Article 14 speaks of equality before the law and equal
protection of the laws. Equality of opportunity should apply to matters
of public contracts. The State has the right to trade. The State has
there the duty to observe equality. An ordinary individual can choose
not to deal with any person. The Government cannot choose to
exclude persons by discrimination. The order of black-listing has the
effect of depriving a person of equality of opportunity in the matter of
public contract. A person who is on the approved list is unable to
enter into advantageous relations with the Government because of the
order of black-listing. A person who has been dealing with the
Government in the matter of sale and purchase of materials has a
legitimate interest or expectation. When the State acts to the prejudice
of a person it has to be supported by legality.
….
14. The State can enter into contract with any person it chooses. No
person has a fundamental right to insist that the Government must
enter into a contract with him. A citizen has a right to earn livelihood
and to pursue any trade. A citizen has a right to claim equal treatment
to enter into a contract which may be proper, necessary and essential
to his lawful calling.
15. The blacklisting order does not pertain to any particular contract.
The blacklisting order involves civil consequences. It casts a slur. It
creates; a barrier between the persons blacklisted and the
Government in the matter of transactions. The blacklists are
"instruments of coercion".
16. In passing an order of blacklisting the Government department
acts under what is described as a standardised Code. This is a Code
for internal instruction. The Government departments make regular
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
purchases. They maintain list of approved suppliers after taking into
account the financial standard of the firm, their capacity and their
past performance. The removal from the list is made for various
reasons. The grounds on which blacklisting may be ordered are if the
proprietor of the firm is convicted by court of law or security
considerations so warrant or if there is strong justification for
believing that the proprietor or employee of the firm, has been guilty
of malpractices such as bribery, corruption, fraud, or if the firm
continuously refuses to return Government dues or if the firm employs
a Government servant, dismissed or removed on account of
corruption in a position where he could corrupt Government servant.
The petitioner was blacklisted on the ground of justification for
believing that the firm has been guilty of malpractices such as
bribery, corruption, fraud. The petitioners were blacklisted on the
ground that there were proceedings pending against the petitioners
for alleged violation of provisions under the Foreign Exchange
Regulations Act.
17. The Government is a government of laws and not of men. It is true
that neither the petitioner nor the respondent has any right to enter
into a contract but they are entitled to equal treatment with others
who offer tender or quotations for the purchase of the goods. This
privilege arises because it is the Government which is trading with
the public and the democratic form of Government demands equality
and absence of arbitrariness and discrimination in such transactions.
Hohfeld treats privileges as a form of liberty as opposed to a duty.
The activities of the Government have a public element and, therefore,
there should be fairness and equality. The State need not enter into
any contract with any one but if it does so, it must do as fairly without
discrimination and without unfair procedure. Reputation is a part of
person's character and personality. Blacklisting tarnishes one's
reputation.
18. Exclusion of a member of the public from dealing with a State in
sales transactions has the effect of preventing him from purchasing
and doing a lawful trade in the goods by discriminating against him
in favour of other people. The State can impose reasonable conditions
regarding rejection and acceptance of bids or qualifications of
bidders. Just as exclusion of the lowest tender will be arbitrary.
similarly exclusion of a person who offers the highest price from
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
participating at a public auction would also have the same aspect of
arbitrariness.
19. Where the State is dealing with individuals in transactions of sales
and purchase of goods, the two important factors are that an
individual is entitled to trade with the Government and an individual
is entitled to a fair and equal treatment with others. A duty to act
fairly can be interpreted as meaning a duty to observe certain aspects
of rules of natural justice A body may be under a duty to give fair
consideration to the facts and to consider the representations but not
to disclose to those persons details of information in its possession.
Sometimes duty to act fairly can also be sustained without providing
opportunity for an oral hearing. It will depend upon the nature of the
interest to be affected, the circumstances in which a power is
exercised and the nature of sanctions involved therein.
20. Blacklisting has the effect of preventing a person from the
privilege and advantage of entering into lawful relationship with the
Government for. purposes of gains. The fact that a disability is
created by the order of blacklisting indicates that the relevant
authority is to have an objective satisfaction. Fundamentals of fair
play require that the person concerned should be given an
opportunity to represent his case before he is put on the blacklist.”
71.
Further, the Supreme Court, in the judgment titled Gorkha Security
Services v. Government (NCT of Delhi) and Ors., (2014) 9 SCC 105,
described blacklisting as “civil death” of a person who is foisted with such
an action and observed that that several evil consequences follow
blacklisting.
72.
We find that the effect of disqualifying/barring an entity from bidding
for a Tender on the basis of an FIR is akin to blacklisting, whereby the
bidder is precluded from participating in the tendering process.
73.
At this juncture it is also necessary to reproduce Rule 151 of the
General Financial Rules, 2017 and Clause 5.29 of the AIIMS Purchase
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
Manual, 2018, both pari materia, which contemplate debarment of a bidder
as under:
“Debarment from bidding
(i) A bidder shall be debarred if he has been convicted of
an offence—
(a) under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; or
(b) the Indian Penal Code or any other law for the time
being in force, for causing any loss of life or property or
causing a threat to public health as part of execution of a
public procurement contract.
(ii) A bidder debarred under sub-section (i) or any
successor of the bidder shall not be eligible to participate
in a procurement process of any procuring entity for a
period not exceeding three years commencing from the
date of debarment. Department of Commerce (DGS&D)
will maintain such list which will also be displayed on the
website of DGS&D as well as Central Public Procurement
Portal.
(iii) AIIMS may debar a bidder or any of its successors,
from participating in any procurement process undertaken
by it, for a period not exceeding two years, if it determines
that the bidder has breached the code of integrity. AIIMS
will maintain such list which will be circulated and also
displayed on AIIMS website.
(iv) The bidder shall not be debarred unless such bidder has
been given a reasonable opportunity to represent against
such debarment.”
(emphasis supplied)
74.
The above provision provides for debarment of a bidder only in the
eventuality that it is convicted of an offence under the Indian Penal Code,
1860, or the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. It further states that a
bidder shall not be debarred unless it has been given a reasonable
opportunity to represent itself against such debarment. Pertinently, it does
not contemplate debarment based on an FIR or pending criminal
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
proceedings. The qualification criteria in the present case has the effect of
ousting those who have FIRs or criminal proceedings pending against them,
practically debarring them from participating in the present and future
Tender proceedings, without following the above stipulations. By cancelling
the first Tender dated 06.12.2024 in which the petitioner was declared L1,
and floating the second Tender dated 25.07.2025 with the new qualification
criteria, the respondents have all but barred the petitioner from participating
in the same, doing indirectly what they could not do directly. Such a
colourable exercise of power cannot be permitted, more so on part of the
State who must be held to a higher standard, and are expected to act in a fair
and reasonable manner. The salutary principle laid down in Nazeer Ahmad
v. King Emperor, AIR 1936 PC 253 that where a power is given to do a
certain thing in a certain way, it must be done that way or not at all and other
methods of performance are necessarily forbidden, would apply here on all
fours.
75.
That apart, the above Rule 151 of the General Financial Rules, 2017
and Clause 5.29 of the AIIMS Purchase Manual, 2018 explicitly state that
debarment from bidding shall only for a period not exceeding three years.
The impugned qualification criteria is in direct contradiction with these
provisions, inasmuch as it practically debars such people against whom FIRs
have been lodged under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 for an
indefinite amount of time. If the contentions of Mr. Verma on behalf of the
respondents are to be accepted, it would mean that a person/entity against
whom an FIR has been filed would be worse off than a person/entity who
has been found guilty under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
Condemning the petitioner for an indefinite period time, only based on an
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
FIR, when even a conviction would only bring about debarment of three
years, is ex facie arbitrary and discriminative. Such a scenario would strike
at the very root of Article 14 of the Constitution of India, and does not stand
the test of Wednesbury reasonableness.
76.
Mr. Verma has endeavored to draw a distinction between the
qualification criteria prescribed under Clause 5 of Section VIII and the
condition added in Clause 23 of Section VIII under the title ‘Technical
Specification’, by stating that the latter shall not act as a deterrent for the
petitioner from participating in the Tender process, as it only states that the
respondents reserve a right to reject any bid on account of any pending
FIR/criminal proceedings against the bidders. However, we are not
persuaded by the submission of Mr. Verma, as this condition also fails to
meet the test of reasonableness and arbitrariness, for the reasons enunciated
by us above.
77.
He has referred to a catena of judgments to buttress his submission
that this Court shall not interfere in the matter, as the same is essentially a
commercial decision. There cannot be any cavil with the law laid down in
those judgments. However, in view of the facts of this case, as we have
found that the actions of the respondents are arbitrary, discriminative and
unreasonable, they warrant interference.
78.
As such, we are of the view that the impugned qualification
criteria/conditions prescribed by the respondents in the NIT dated
25.07.2025 are unreasonable and discriminatory, and are ultra vires the
Constitution of India. The same need to be struck down.
79.
We state that our observations above shall not preclude the
respondents from prescribing any conditions of Tender as they deem fit in
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
the future. However, such conditions must necessarily be within the
contours of the above enunciated principles.
80.
Accordingly, we set aside the impugned eligibility/ qualification
criteria (as amended) prescribed in Clause 5, Section-VIII under the title
‘Qualification Criteria’ and also the condition mentioned in Section VII
under the title ‘Technical Specification’, of the Tender bearing Tender
Enquiry No. NVI-47/DTM/2024-25 dated 25.07.2025, to the extent that they
oust those who have FIRs pending against them under the provisions of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 from the bidding/ Tender process.
81.
The petition is disposed of on the above terms. The pending
application is disposed of as infructuous.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
FEBRUARY 12, 2026
PS
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:18:07
WP(C) No.13179/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review