Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 16579/2026
Decided on: 24.09.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Vishal Kumar
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and Ors.
.....Respondents
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes.
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Onkar Jairath, Sr. Advocate with Mr.
Anshul Jairath, Advocate.
For the Respondents:
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with
Mr. Y.P.S. Dhaulta, Additional Advocate
General, for respondents No.1 & 2.
Mr. Vishwajeet Singh, advocate,
respondent No.3.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
for
On 03.03.2026 respondent No.4 gave a timeline to
certain identified candidates including respondent No.3 for
removing
specified
defects
in
their
documents/information
supplied while applying for the advertised posts terming them as
‘curable defects’. Feeling aggrieved against this action, petitioner
instituted this writ petition on 21.09.2026.
2.
The case.
2(i)
Respondent No. 3-Himachal Pradesh Rajya Chayan
Ayog issued an advertisement on 04.03.2024 (Annexure P-2),
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
inviting applications for 12 posts of Group Instructor to be filled up
on contract basis. Out of these 12 posts, 2 were meant for
candidates belonging to the Other Backward Classes (OBC)
Unreserved (UR) categories. The closing date for submission of
online recruitment applications was 26.03.2024. The minimum
essential qualifications, as per the applicable Recruitment and
Promotion Rules, laid down in the advertisement were as under: “…2.
Minimum Essential Qualifications as per R&P Rules.
i)
10th Class pass from a recognized Board of School
Education.
Provided that the candidate must have passed Middle
and Matriculation from any Institution situated within
Himachal Pradesh, duly recognized by Central/HP
Government.
ii)
Degree in Technology/Engineering from a recognized
University
with
three
years
post
qualification
practical
experience in a reputed industrial concern or in a training
institute. OR
i)
Diploma in Technology/Engineering from a recognized
University/Board with five years post qualification practical
experience in a reputed industrial concern or in a training
institute OR
ii)
ITI (National Trade Certificate/National Apprenticeship
Certificate) with eight years post practical experience in a
reputed industrial concern or in a training institute.”
In order to be eligible, a candidate was also required
to have post-qualification practical experience for varying years
(as per above provision) in a reputed industrial concern/training
institute.
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
Clause 16 of the advertisement provided the checklist
as under:
“16. CHECK LIST:
VERIFY
THE FOLLOWING BEFORE
ONLINE
RECRUITMENT
SUBMITING
APPLICATION
THE
OR
DOCUMENTS/CERTIFICATES:
a.
That no column is wrongly filled or kept blank, as the
information furnished therein would be used to determine the
eligibility of candidates.
b. That copies of only following documents/certificates are to be
provided in support of claims made/information given in the
Online
Recruitment
Application(ORA)
at
the
time
of
documentation:i) Matriculation certificate for age proof.
ii) Degree/Diploma/ITI certificates along with Marks
Sheets
of
all
Qualifications
years
as
in
support
prescribed
of
Educational
under
Essential
Qualification column of R&P Rules. The provisional
certificate(s)
along
with
marks
sheets
of
all
semesters/years.
iii) Experience certificate(s) wherever required, the post
practical experience shall be considered only if the
same is attained after acquiring qualification i.e. Degree
Diploma/ITI and should be duly verified counter signed
by the concerned Government Authority Departmental
Officer.
iv )
Caste certificates, if applicable.
v)
BPL certificates, if applicable.
vi)
All
other
certificates,
if
any
required
for
determining, eligibility etc. as mentioned in mode of
selection criteria which so ever applicable to the
applicants.”
As
per
Checklist-b(iii),
‘Experience
Certificate,
wherever required, the post “practical experience shall be
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
considered only if the same is attained after acquiring the
qualification, i.e., Degree/Diploma/ITI, and should be duly
verified/countersigned
by
the
concerned
Government
Authority/Departmental Officer.’
2(ii)
The petitioner, respondent No. 4 and others applied
for the post in question. The petitioner and respondent No. 4 had
applied for the post meant for OBC (UR) category.
2(iii)
On 03.03.2026 (Annexure P-4), respondent No. 3
issued a public notice informing all concerned that during the
document verification conducted on 05.02.2026 for the posts in
question, certain shortcomings/discrepancies had been noticed,
which were pointed out in the notice against the respective names
and roll numbers of the candidates. The candidates were directed
to
rectify
the
shortcomings
and
submit
the
requisite
certificates/information/documents within one week, but not later
than 12.03.2026. It was further stipulated that failure to submit the
requisite documents within the stipulated time would result in
rejection of the candidature without entertaining any further
request or representation in that regard.
Name of respondent No. 4 figured in the aforesaid
notice at serial No. 13. The shortcoming pointed out against his
name was that the experience certificate supplied by him had not
been verified/countersigned by the concerned authority. The
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
relevant portion of the notice dated 03.03.2026 is reproduced
hereunder:
“NOTICE'
It is hereby informed to all concerned that during the
Document Verification (DV) conducted on 05.02.2026 for Post Code24001 (Group Instructor), certain candidates, were observed. With the
due approval of the Hon'ble Aayog, the candidates listed below are
hereby directed to rectify the said shortcomings and submit the
requisite certificate(s)/information/documents in person within one
week, but not later than 12.03.2026. Failure to submit the required
documents within the stipulated time shall result in rejection of
candidature on account of non-fulfillment of essential qualifications.
No further request representation in this regard shall be entertained
thereafter…..
Sr.No
Name
of
Roll No
Candidate
13.
Pradeep
24001001171
Description
of
Action required
Shorcomings
in
by
the
documents etc.
candidates
Post qualification practical
experience of 03 years
(being Degree) as Data
Analyst
in
ASICS
Technoligies MMS Divya
Diamond Junction Kaveri
Hills, Hyderabad w.e.f.
24.08.2015 to 02.04.2019
and as Supervisor w.e.f.
May 2012 to May 2015 at
United Engineering Corpn
Jaladhar
is
not
verified/countersigned by
the
concerned
Government
Authority/Departmental
Officer
Certificates
of
experience
required to be
verified
countersigned
by
the
concerned
Labour
Officer/Labour
Inspector.
It appears that respondent No.4 availed the above
opportunity and removed the pointed deficiency.
2(iv)
Respondent No. 3 declared the result on 25.03.2026.
Names of the petitioner and Respondent No. 4 did not figure in the
list of successful candidates. Their names, however, figured in the
waiting panel. Respondent No. 4, with score of 71.50, is at Serial
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
No. 1, and name of petitioner, with an identical score appears at
Serial No. 2 in the waiting list for the OBC (UR) category.
3.
In the instant writ petition, instituted on 19.09.2026,
petitioner’s contention is that respondent No. 3 could not have
given an opportunity to Respondent No. 4 to rectify the
shortcomings in his experience certificate and could not have
permitted respondent No. 4 to furnish a countersigned experience
certificate by 12.03.2026, when the closing date for submission of
the online recruitment applications was 26.03.2024. Substantive
relief prayed for by the petitioner reads as under:
“That issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus, or any other
appropriate writ, order or direction, directing the Respondents
to reject the candidature of the Private Respondent and the
Petitioner may be considered for appointment to the post of
Group Instructor against the post earmarked for the OBC (UR)
Category and the Respondents may further be directed to offer
the appointment to the Petitioner on the post of Group
Instructor with all consequential benefits like arrears, seniority
etc.”
Pursuant to the notice issued in this writ petition on
22.09.2026, confined to respondents No. 1 to 3, instructions have
come forth from respondent No. 3 as also from respondents No. 1
and 2. Instructions dated 24.09.2026 from respondent No. 3 and
dated 23.09.2026 from respondents No. 1 and 2 have been
placed on record.
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
Learned Counsel for respondent No. 3, on the basis
of the aforesaid instructions dated 24.09.2026, has submitted that
the amended R&P Rules dated 05.12.2022, governing the post in
question, do not prescribe any requirement that the experience
certificate must be countersigned or verified by any authority.
Such stipulation existed in the old and unamended R&P Rules
dated 04.07.2017, under which the experience was required to be
acquired in a reputed industrial concern registered with the
concerned
department
of
the
respective
State
or
in
a
Government/Semi-Government training/teaching institute. This
stipulation was done away with by the amendment dated
05.12.2022. The recruitment in question was processed on the
basis of the amended R&P Rules dated 05.12.2022. That Clause
16(iii) of the advertisement was general in nature. The expression
‘concerned Government Authority/Departmental Officer’ was
neither specifically identified in the advertisement nor do the
applicable
Recruitment
&
Promotion
Rules
prescribe
any
particular authority such as Labour Officer/Labour Inspector as the
authority competent to countersign the certificate.
4.
Heard & considered the case file. Clause 2 of the
advertisement
laid
down
minimum
essential
qualifications
including the requirement of post qualification practical experience
certificate for requisite period. Clause 16 is with the heading
‘Check List’.
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
In terms of Clause 16 of the advertisement, the
experience certificate, wherever required, was to be considered
only if the practical experience was acquired after obtaining the
requisite qualification. Another stipulation therein was that the
same "should be duly verified/countersigned by the concerned
Government Authority/Departmental Officer." I am inclined to
agree with the submissions made by learned counsel for
respondent No. 3, as also by the learned Advocate General, that
such stipulation was general in nature.
Judicial pronouncements have differentiated and
distinguished
the
appointments
suffering
from
procedural
deviations with illegal appointments. Appointment made without
following every procedural formality may be irregular but it does
not become illegal unless it violates statutory provisions or is
made without the existence of post [ Re: Pawan Kumar Tiwary &
Ors. Vs. Jharkhand State Electricity Board (Now Jharkhand
Urja Vikas Nigam Limited) and Others.2
Admittedly, requirement of countersigning of the
experience certificate was not prescribed in the amended R&P
Rules. This was a procedural requirement laid down in the
advertisement under ‘the Check List’. The essential criteria was
that candidates should be in possession of the requisite
2025 SCC Online SC 1751
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
experience certificate. Countersigning of such an experience
certificate was merely a procedural requirement. In a scenario
where the post-degree/diploma experience certificate of a
candidate was not countersigned, respondent No. 3 did not
commit any error by allowing a defined timeline to such candidate
for rectifying this discrepancy as such omission only amounted to
a curable discrepancy. It is not that such candidate lacked the
essential qualification or failed to satisfy the parameters of
essential qualification laid down in clause 2 of the advertisement.
Granting a fixed timeline for removal of discrepancies in an
already existing certificate was justiciable action of respondent No.
3 in larger interest of the applicants and did not vitiate the
selection process.
In this regard, reference can also be made to Sunita
Devi v. Himachal Pradesh Staff Selection Commission and
Others3, where the certificates of wards of ex-servicemen
furnished by the candidates were not in the prescribed format,
and, for this reason, the candidature of the petitioners had been
rejected for the grant of reservation. The writ petitions were
allowed by the Hon’ble Division Bench, holding that although the
petitioners had no fundamental right to selection, they possessed
a fundamental right to be considered for selection. If any
CWP No. 3035 of 2019, decided along with connected matters on 25-11-2019
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
application or certificate was not in the proper format or contained
a technical error, it was to be treated as a curable defect that
could be cured at any time. Rejection of the candidature was held
to be a violation of fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India. Relevant paras from the judgment read
as under: “2.
Pursuant to the requisition received from Director
Ayurveda, Himachal Pradesh for filling up of 66 posts of
Ayurvedic Pharmacists (on contract basis), which have been
reserved for the Wards of Ex-servicemen i.e. General
(W.Exsm); OBC (W.Exsm); SC (W.Exsm) and ST (W.Exsm),
petitioners have submitted their applications, as per the
Notification issued by the respondentSelection Commission.
The petitioners claimed for consideration of their candidature
under different categories of Ex.Servicemen and they have
submitted the certificates of Ward of Ex-servicemen on the
Format, which is prescribed for the said purpose issued by the
Competent Authority, namely, Deputy Director, Zila Sanik
Welfare Officer and they were required to submit their
certificates as per Annexure-A, duly issued by Patwari/Pradhan
Gram Panchayat/President of NAC/ Executive Officer of MC
etc. with the further counter-signature of Tehsildar/SDO (Civil)
of the area supported by Annexure-B in affidavits made by the
deponentpetitioners while submitting their applications. The
respondentSelection
Commission
has
processed
their
applications, allowed them to appear in the written test and
interview. However, at the time of evaluation, the candidature of
the petitioners have been rejected vide impugned Notice(s) on
the ground that certificate of Ward of Exserviceman was not
issued in a prescribed Format for fulfilling the requirement for
grant of reservation to the ward of Ex-serviceman. Therefore, a
prayer has been made in these writ petitions to quash the
Notice(s), whereby candidatures of the petitioners have been
rejected and further a direction has been sought to the
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
respondents to consider their cases for the selection to the
posts for which they have applied.
9. Though the petitioners have no fundamental right of selection
but have a fundamental right for consideration to the selection
and while dealing with fundamental rights respondents have to
take all possible steps for considering the applications, until and
unless it is hopelessly barred by non-compliance. If any of the
applications/certificate was not in the proper format and if there
is a technical error, it is to be treated as curative defect which
can be curated at any time. At this stage, we find the rejection
of the candidature of the petitioners nothing but violation of
fundamental right for the purpose of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
10. The Selection Commission in order to ensure whether the
petitioners are really and genuinely the Wards of Exservicemen or not could do it before issuance of appointments
order by sending the said certificates to the officers, who have
issued thesame, for cross verification, till then no persons could
have been held entitled for selection. We are satisfied that the
Format which was though prescribed along with the application
could not be exactly the same but in letter and spirit it is the
same in compliance claiming their candidature for consideration
under the Ward of Ex-servicemen. Also the cases of candidates
belonging to SC,ST and OBC categories have also to be
verified
by the
competent
authority.
Therefore,
in our
considered view the certificates issued in favour of the
petitioners are required to be sent to the Competent Authority
for cross-verification and on verification, if found suitable, the
cases of the petitioners are required to be considered for
selection and appointment to the aforesaid posts.
In view of above, all writ petitions are allowed and
impugned Notice(s) rejecting the candidature of the petitioners
is quashed and set aside. Respondent-State is directed to redraw the merit after evaluating the candidature of the
petitioners within three months after re-verification of their
certificates. Pending applications if any also stand disposed of.
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
At this stage, it will also be relevant to note Vashist
Narayan Kumar Vs. The State of Bihar and Ors4. The question
that arose for consideration before the Hon’ble Apex Court was,
whether the error committed in the application form, which was
uploaded, is a material or a trivial error and whether the State was
justified in declaring the appellant as having failed on account of
the same. In the aforesaid case, the appellant had submitted his
online application through the assistance of Cyber Café,
mentioning his incorrect date of birth. The Hon’ble Apex Court
held that the error was not so grave so as to constitute wrong or
misleading information. Whenever any material discrepancy is
noticed in the application form and/or when any suppression and/
or misrepresentation is detected, the candidature might be
cancelled even after the application has been processed and the
candidate has been allowed to participate in the selection process.
However, after a candidate has participated in the selection
process and cleared all the stages successfully, his candidature
can only be cancelled, after careful scrutiny of the gravity of the
lapse, and not for trivial omissions or errors. Law does not
concern itself with trifles.
In
the
present
case,
one
of
the
essential
qualifications required under the advertisement was post-
4 (2024) 11 SCC 785
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
qualification practical experience certificate. The countersigning of
such certificate was a requirement but as part of the checklist
issued under the advertisement. In case the experience certificate
admittedly supplied by the candidate within the timeline prescribed
in the advertisement, was not countersigned by the concerned
authority, it was merely a procedural defect that was curable.
Respondent No. 3 giving a specific timeline not only to respondent
No. 4, but to all similarly situated candidates, for curing different
remediable defects in their applications, including the defect of
experience certificate having not been countersigned, cannot be
held to be an unjusticiable action. It is not that requirement of post
qualification practical experience as on date of applying for the
post had been dispensed with by respondent No.3. Rather
candidates were considered on the basis of such certificates
supplied by them as on date of applying but certain curable
procedural defects as per check list were noticed by respondent
No.3. For removal of these discrepancies, time was granted, in
larger interest of the applicants. Countersigning the certificate
would not confer eligibility upon a candidate. It is just a
circumstance of the recruitment process insisted by respondent
No.3 under the check list.
For the above reasons, this writ petition is dismissed.
Needless to clarify that while passing this judgement validity of
experience certificate furnished by respondent No.4 has not been
( 2026:HHC:40946 )
gone into. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also to
stand disposed of.
24th September, 2026
rohit
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review