Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved On: 24.12.2025
Delivered On:07.01.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Criminal Appeal No. 454 of 2019
Deepak Singh Rawat
State of Uttarakhand
Present:
.... Appellant
Vs.
....Respondent
Mr. Piyush Garg, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Pankaj Joshi, A.G.A. for the State.
with
Criminal Appeal No. 665 of 2019
Jony Sharma
State of Uttarakhand
Present:
.... Appellant
Vs.
....Respondent
Mr. Navneet Kaushik, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Pankaj Joshi, A.G.A. for the State.
With
Criminal Appeal No. 666 of 2019
Vishal @ Jolly
State of Uttarakhand
Present:
.... Appellant
Vs.
....Respondent
Mr. Navneet Kaushik, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Pankaj Joshi, A.G.A. for the State.
And
Criminal Appeal No. 576 of 2019
Surendra Singh alias Suri
.... Appellant
State of Uttarakhand
Present:
Vs.
....Respondent
Mr. Navneet Kaushik, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Pankaj Joshi, A.G.A. for the State.
JUDGMENT
Coram: Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J.
Hon’ble Alok Mahra, J.
Per: Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J.
Since, all these appeals arise from common judgment and
order, they are heard together and decided by this common judgment.
2.
All these appeals are preferred against the judgment and
order dated 31.08.2019/03.09.2019, passed in Sessions Trial No. 21
of 2015, State of Uttarakhand Vs. Deepak Rawat and others, by the
court of Additional Sessions Judge, Kotdwar, Pauri Garhwal. By it, the
appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma have been convicted under
Section 302 IPC and sentenced to imprisonment for life with a fine of
Rs. 1 lakh each and in default of payment of fine, to undergo
imprisonment for a further period of one year. The appellants Deepak
Rawat and Surendra Singh @ Suri were convicted under Section 302
read with 34 IPC and sentenced to imprisonment for line with a fine of
Rs. 1 lakh each and in default of payment of fine, to undergo
imprisonment for a further period of one year.
3.
The appellant Surendra Singh @ Suri, died during the
pendency of the appeal, therefore, appeal against him stands abated.
4.
Briefly stated, according to the prosecution case, on
22.03.2015, at about 05:45 in the evening, 2-3 motorcycle borne
assailants waylaid the deceased Sumit Patwal at Beladaat Crossing in
Kotdwar, shot him dead from close range and ran away. The incident
was witnessed by many nearby shopkeepers and others. The deceased
was into the property dealing; therefore, he had enmity with certain
persons. His mother PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Patwal lodged an FIR
Ex.A1 at 12:30 midnight at Police Station Kotdwar, District Pauri
Garhwal, based on which, Case Crime No. 29 of 2015, under Section
302 IPC was lodged at Police Station Kotdwar. PW1 Smt. Sateshwari
Patwal also gave a text dated 04.02.2015, purportedly written by the
deceased to the Station House Officer, Police Station Kotdwar,
wherein, it was stated that the appellants Deepak Singh Rawat,
Surendra Singh @ Suri and others had once waylaid him on
02.02.2014 and demanded money from him and threatened him to
life. This text is Ex.A2. PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi also gave a
communication to the Police, which is Ex. A3, which records that the
shooters were seen alongwith the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat on a
motorcycle Yamaha Fazer bearing Registration No. UK008P4959. The
inquest of the deceased Sumit Patwal was conducted on 23.03.2015.
the inquest report is Ex. A15. The post mortem was done on
23.03.2015. According to the post mortem report, the cause of death is
due to brain injury as a result of firearm injuries. The doctor
conducting post mortem had also taken out two bullets from the
person of the deceased. They were handed over to the police. The
statements of PW2 Ashish Rana and PW3 Ravindra Singh Negi were
recorded under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(“the Code”). They are Ex. A5 and Ex. A6, respectively. According to
the Police, after killing the deceased, the assailants came at roadways
bus stand, parked their motorcycle there and from there, they ran
away on the motorcycle of the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat. The
police took the CCTV footage into custody from the roadways bus
stand Kotdwar. They got identification of the assailants done during
investigation and prepared its memos, which are Ex. A4 and Ex. A39.
The motorcycle which was parked by the assailants near roadways
bus stand was also taken into custody.
5.
It has also been the prosecution case that, in fact, the real
shooters are appellants Jony Sharma and Vishal @ Jolly, who had
stayed a few days before in one Paramount Hotel. They were shown
the deceased by the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat. The police took
into custody the visitors register from the Paramount Hotel.
6.
According to the prosecution, on 27.03.2015, upon an
information having been received, the appellant Surendra Singh @
Suri alongwith the appellants Jony Sharma and Vishal @ Jolly
were apprehended. They confessed their guilt and the appellant
Jony Sharma stated that after killing the deceased, he had kept
the pistol in his rented room in Subhash Nagar. He had hid the
weapon. According to the prosecution, the appellant Vishal @ Jolly
had kept the country-made pistol in some bushes in Kotdwar. At
the instance of the appellant Jony Sharma, a pistol was recovered
from a rented accommodation of the appellant Jony Sharma in
Subhash Nagar from the building of Sewa Ram. A recovery memo
of
arrest
Next
day,
and
at
recovery
the
of
pistol,
instance
of
Ex.
A25
was
the
appellant
prepared.
Vishal
@
Jolly, a country-made pistol was recovered from an open place in
Kotdwar. Recovery memo of it, Ex. A27 was
also prepared. Those
recovered
firearms
were
sent
for
forensic
examination.
The
Investigating Officer prepared site plan. He also received Forensic
Science Laboratory report. The result of examination is a follows:“Result of Examination:
i)
“OPINION”
The 7.65mm pistol cartridge marked ‘L/1’ was successfully
test fired through the non-standard pistol marked ‘A/1’. On
test firing the non-standard pistol marked ‘A/1’ was found in
working order and the 7.65mm pistol cartridge marked ‘A/1’
was found to be live.
ii)
Two .315”/8,, rifle cartridges from the stock of the laboratory
were successfully test fired through the countrymade pistol
marked ‘A/2’ was found in working order.
iii)
On thorough examination and comparison of individual
characteristics marks present on crime and test fired cartridge
cases under the comparison microscope, I came to the
conclusion that the .315”/8mm rifle cartridge case marked
‘C/1’ and the 7.65mm pistol cartridge case marked ‘C/2’ had
been fired through the countrymade pistol marked ‘A/2’ and
non-standard pistol marked ‘A/1’ respectively and they could
have not been fired through any other firearm because every
firearm has its own individual characteristics marks.
iv)
On thorough examination and comparison of individual
characteristics marks present on crime and test fired bullets
under the comparison microscope, I came to the conclusion
that the 7.65mm pistol bullet marked ‘B/2’ had been fired
through the non standard pistol marked ‘A/1’ and it could
have not been fired through any other firearm because every
firearm has its own individual characteristic marks.
v)
It could not be possible to form any definite opinion regarding
linkage of .315”/8mm rifle bullet marked ‘B/1’ with respect to
the countrymade pistol marked ‘A/2’ due to lack of sufficient
individual characteristic marks present on it.”
7.
After investigation, charge sheet was submitted against
the appellants. On 16.12.2015, charge under Section 302 read with
34, 120B IPC were framed against the appellants and Surendra Singh
@ Suri, to which, they denied and claimed trial.
8.
It may be reiterated that since the appeal against the
appellant Surendra Singh @ Suri has been abated, therefore, the
evidence shall not be scrutinized qua Surendra Singh @ Suri.
9.
In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined forty
one witnesses.
10.
After prosecution evidence, the appellants were examined
under Section 313 of the Code. According to them, they have been
falsely implicated. They did not commit any offence.
11.
After hearing the parties, by the impugned judgment and
order, the appellants have been convicted and sentenced, as stated
hereinbefore. Aggrieved, the appellants have preferred these appeals.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
13.
Learned counsel for the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat
submits that there is no evidence against the appellant; merely based
on some CCTV footage, the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat has been
convicted. But, he would submit that there is no certificate under
Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (“the Evidence Act”) qua
the electronic evidence and in view of the judgment in the case of
Arjun Panditrao Khotkar Vs. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and others,
(2020) 7 SCC 1, without certification under Section 65B of the
Evidence Act, such electronic evidence may not be read into evidence.
Learned counsel also submits that the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat
has been acquitted under Section 120B IPC, whereas, he has been
convicted under Section 302 read with 34 IPC, which is not legally
permissible. In support of his contention, learned counsel has placed
reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of
Vasant alias Girish Akbarasab Sanavale and another Vs. State of
Karnataka, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 337.
14.
In paras 51 and 53 of the judgment, in the case of Vasant
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the scope of Section
120B IPC and Section 34 IPC, as follows:“51. Participation of the individual offender in the criminal act
in some form or the other which is the leading feature of
Section 34, IPC differentiates it not only from Section 149, IPC, but
also from other affiliated offences like criminal conspiracy and
abetment. A bare agreement between two or more persons to do or
cause to be done an illegal act might make a person liable for the
offence of criminal conspiracy as defined in Section 120, IPC. If the
said agreement is to commit offence, then such an agreement is by
itself enough to make a man guilty and no overt act apart from the
agreement would be necessary.
53. On the other hand, under Section 34, IPC, a mere
agreement, although it might be a sufficient proof of the common
intention, would be wholly insufficient to sustain a conviction with the
application of Section 34, IPC, unless some criminal act is done in
furtherance of the said common intention and the accused himself
has in some way or the other participated in the commission of the
said act.”
15.
Learned counsel for the appellants Jony Sharma and
Vishal @ Jolly submits that from the possession of the appellant Jony
Sharma, according to the prosecution case, pistol was recovered. But,
he submits that the recovery is beyond the disclosure statement and
how the pistol is connected with the prosecution case, is not
established by the prosecution. Recoveries from both, the appellants
Jony Sharma and Vishal @ Jolly were made from an open place.
Merely based on the recovery, conviction cannot be held. In support of
his contention, learned counsel has placed reliance in the case of
Govind Vs. State of Haryana, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2456 and Raja
Khan Vs. State of Chattisgarh, (2025) 3SCC 314.
16.
In the case of Govind (supra), it was argued that merely
based on the recovery of pistol and the live cartridges, supported by
FSL Report, the conviction is not justified. On this argument, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:-
“17. In the present case, the alleged recovery was made from a
place accessible to other family members, hence, the extent to which
such recovery can be relied upon to establish the appellant's guilt
requires careful scrutiny in light of judicial precedents. In this regard,
we can profitably refer the judgment of this Court in the case
of Jaikam Khan v. State of U.P.11, wherein the conviction was based
on recovery of knives from the accused, one from room and two from
an open field, which were later found not relevant to connect the
accused in commission of offence when such recoveries were from a
place accessible to others and also from place of public use. The
relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced as under:
58. As already discussed hereinabove, since no public
witness has been examined to support the said memo, the
statement made therein will have to be scrutinised with
greater caution and circumspection. All the statements made
therein with regard to the confession of committing the crime
would not be admissible in evidence. Only such information,
which distinctly relates to the discovery of facts will be
admissible
under
Section 27 of
the Evidence
Act,
1872 (hereinafter referred to as “the Evidence Act”). The
evidence of PW 9 Brahmesh Kumar Yadav (IO) would reveal
that immediately after the FIR was lodged, he had come to the
spot of incident for further investigation. According to him,
Accused 1, 3 and 4 were arrested at around 2.00 a.m. on 241-2014. Even according to him, the police party was very
much there at the spot. One of the alleged recoveries is from
the room where deceased Asgari used to sleep. The other
two recoveries are from open field, just behind the house of
deceased Shaukeen Khan i.e. the place of incident. It could
thus be seen that the recoveries were made from the places,
11- (2021) 13 SCC 716
which were accessible to one and all and as such, no reliance
could be placed on such recoveries.
18. In Manjunath v. State of Karnataka (supra), this Court
while dealing with the recovery from the place accessible to public or
areas accessible to others observed that such recovery alone is not
sufficient and it becomes suspicious. In the said case, eucalyptus
sticks found from eucalyptus plantation and iron chains recovered
from houses shared with other occupants were not found sufficient to
prove the guilt and to bring home the charge of murder. The court in
para 28 held as thus:
“28. As reflected from record, and in particular the
testimony of PW-15 it is clear that the discoveries (stick as
shown by A10, for instance) was a eucalyptus stick, found
from the eucalyptus plantation, which indisputably, is a public
place and was found a week later. A second and third stick
purportedly found half kilometre away on that day itself, was
found by a bush, once again, a place of public access. Two
further sticks recovered at the instance A6 and A7, were also
from public places. An iron chain produced from the house of
A1 and A2, is not free from the possibility that any of the other
occupants of their house were not responsible for it. We,
further cannot lose sight of the fact that sticks, whether
bamboo or otherwise, are commonplace objects in village life,
and therefore, such objects, being hardly out of the ordinary,
and that too discovered in places of public access, cannot be
used to place the gauntlet of guilt on the accused persons.”
19. Similarly, in Nikhil Chandra Mondal v. State of West
Bengal12,
the appellant was accused of murdering his wife with
a bhojali (knife) which was found from an open place accessible to
others. The Trial Court acquitted the accused though the High Court
reversed the findings. While confirming the order of the Trial Court,
this Court observed as under:
“20. The trial court disbelieved the recovery of clothes
and weapon on two grounds. Firstly, that there was no
memorandum statement as required under section 27 of
the Evidence Act, 1872 and secondly, the recovery of the knife
was from an open place accessible to one and all. We find that
the approach adopted by the trial court was in accordance
with law……”
12- (2023) 6 SCC 605
17.
Further in para 23 of the judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court observed that “though the FSL report indicates that the
pistol and cartridges recovered correlate with the bullets found in
the body of the deceased, such evidence by itself is not sufficient
to establish the appellant's guilt in the absence of any proof that
the recovered pistol was indeed used in the commission of the
offence.”
18.
In the case of Raja Khan (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court discussed the evidence pertaining to the recovery and observed
that “the courts below were not justified in disregarding the
glaring inconsistencies with respect to the recoveries.” Further it
was observed that “the manner of recovery and preparation of
seizure memos raises grave doubts about the version of disclosure
and recovery put forth by the prosecution.”
19.
Before the arguments are appreciated, it would be apt to
examine as to what the witnesses have stated.
20.
PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi is the informant. She is mother
of the deceased. According to her, on 22.03.2015, she was in Delhi,
wherein, she got an information that her son Sumit Patwal has been
shot dead. Thereafter, she reached Kotdwar and lodged a report, Ex.
A1. According to her, in her house, she found a letter written by the
deceased to the police, before his death, on 04.02.2014. She gave this
letter, Ex. A2 to the police and on the same day, she also gave another
communication to the police, Ex. A3, which records that the shooter
was seen with the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat on a motorcycle.
According to her, the deceased was in the property dealing, therefore,
the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat was inimical to him and he, with
the help of other appellants killed the deceased.
21.
PW2 Ashish Rana, PW3 Ravindra Singh Negi, PW5
Pradeep Chamoli, PW6 Pradeep Lakhera, PW8 Prakash Chand, PW9
Mohan Khantwal, PW11 Yudhveer Singh, PW12 Suraj Kumar, PW13
Budhi Prakash, PW 14 Gaurav Bothiyal, PW17 Sanjay Gaur, PW18
Manwar Singh Chauhan, PW20 Ram Prakash, PW31 Satish Prasad,
PW33 Jagmohan Singh, PW34 Sonu Kumar, PW37 Smt. Usha Dimri
and PW39 Narendra Singh Rawat have not supported the prosecution
case. They have been declared hostile and cross examined by the
prosecution, although, these witnesses have identified their signatures
on certain documents.
22.
PW2 Ashish Rana has identified his signatures on Ex. A4.
It is a memo written on 27.03.2015. According to which, PW2 Ashish
Rana and PW3 Ravindra Singh Negi did identify the appellant Deepak
Singh Rawat in the CCTV footage. But, PW2 Ashish Rana has said
that he had declined to sign on it, but he was forced by Inspector
Pramod Shah to sign on it. With regard to his statement recorded
under Section 164 of the Code, this witness tells that police had asked
him to give such statement. In his cross examination by the defence,
PW2 Ashish Rana states that he had seen CCTV footage, but he did
not identify anyone in it.
23.
This is settled law that the statement of hostile witness
can also be taken into consideration while reading the prosecution
case. But, PW2 Ashish Rana, in no manner, supports or proves the
prosecution case.
24.
PW3 Ravindra Singh Rana is another witness of Ex. A4,
the identification memo of the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat in CCTV
footage. According to him, he was asked to sign on Ex. A4 without
reading and he was forced to sign on it. With regard to his statement
recorded under Section 164 of the Code, this witness tells that the
police had asked him to speak before the Magistrate and accordingly,
he had given his statement. He, in his cross examination by the
defence, clearly speaks that under the threat of police, he deposed
before the Magistrate. He denies having identified the appellant
Deepak Singh Rawat in any CCTV footage. The statement of this
witness also does not support the prosecution case.
25.
PW4
Vijendra
Chaudhary
has
totally
denied
the
prosecution case. He was cross examined by the prosecution.
26.
Similarly, PW5 Pradeep Chamoli, PW6 Pradeep Lakhera,
PW8 Prakash Chand have also not supported the prosecution case.
PW8 Prakash Chand has though proved his signatures on the recovery
memo Exs. A9, A10 and A11, which are recovery memo of taking into
custody plain and blood stained soil, recovery memo of cartridge case
and recovery memo of two mobile phones from the place of incident,
but, according to him, the cartridge case and mobile phones were not
recovered in his presence.
27.
PW9 Mohan Khantwal, PW11 Yudhveer Singh, PW12
Suraj Kumar, PW 13 Budhi Prakash, PW14 Gaurav Bothiyal, PW17
Sanjay Gaur, PW18 Manwar Singh Chauhan have also not supported
the prosecution case. They have been cross examined by the
prosecution. There statements also, in no manner, support the
prosecution case. PW18 Manwar Singh Chauhan has identified his
signatures on Ex. A12, which is recovery memo of the CCTV footage.
In
fact,
PW18
Manwar
Singh
Chauhan
was
working
in
the
Uttarakhand Transport Corporation, Kotdwar Office, at the relevant
time. According to him, once police had visited their office. Beyond it,
this witness has not stated anything about the prosecution case. He
simply says that when he signed Ex. A12, it was a blank paper. His
statement also does not support the prosecution case.
28.
PW20
Ram
Prakash,
PW31
Satish
Prasad,
PW33
Jagmohan Singh, PW34 Sonu Kumar, PW37 Smt. Usha Dimri and
PW39 Narendra Singh Rawat have not supported the prosecution case
to any extent.
29.
PW7 Head Constable, Devi Lal has proved the chik FIR Ex.
A7 and an extract of GD, by which the case was registered, Ex. A8.
According to him, the FIR was lodged at 12:30 in the midnight. He
denied the suggestion that PW1 Sateshwari Devi did reach at the
police station in the morning.
30.
PW10 Sanjeev Singh was working in the Uttarakhand
Transport Corporation. According to him, on 24.03.2015, police had
visited their office and had seen the CCTV footage of 22.03.2015
saying that some murder was committed, which is under investigation.
According to this witness, he telephoned his senior officers and he
alongwith PW18 Manwar Singh Chauhan, his colleague shown the
CCTV footage to the police and the police prepared recovery memo of
it, which is Ex. A12. It may be noted that according to PW18 Manwar
Singh Chauhan, he signed Ex. A12, when it was blank, whereas,
according to PW10 Sanjeev Singh, police had prepared recovery memo
Ex. A12.
31.
PW15 Vivek Rathi was the Police Officer at the relevant
time. According to him, PW11 Yudhveer Singh and PW12 Suraj Kumar
had told him that near their shop, a motorcycle bearing Registration
No. UK008P4959 was parked. Thereafter, this witness took the
motorcycle into custody and prepared recovery memo Ex. A13. It may
be noted that PW11 Yudhveer Singh and PW12 Suraj Kumar, both
have identified their signatures on Ex. A13, but according to both of
them, when they signed it, it was blank. According to PW15 Vivek
Rathi, he also took into custody the CCTV footage from the roadways
bus stand on 24.03.2015, of which recovery memo Ex. A12 was
prepared by him. It may be noted that PW10 Sanjeev Singh has also
stated that police had taken the CCTV footage into custody. But, as
stated, PW18 Manwar Singh Chauhan has said that he had signed on
a blank sheet, which was Ex. A12 signed by him. PW15 Vivek Rathi
also tells that PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi had identified the appellant
Deepak Singh Rawat in the CCTV footage. It may be noted that PW1
Smt. Sateshwari Devi has not stated about any identification of any
CCTV footage.
32.
PW16 Anup Barthwal runs a hotel in Kotdwar. He has
stated about the visitors register maintained in the hotel, but he has
not made any entry in that register.
33.
PW19 Harish Chandra has stated about some land, which
according to him, one Chandi Prasad wanted to sell to the deceased
and Surender Singh @ Suri.
34.
PW21 Dipendra Kala has identified his signatures on the
inquest report Ex. A15.
35.
PW22 Dr. Guman Singh Rana had conducted the post
mortem of the deceased and had found two entry wounds as follows:“(1)
Entry wound measuring 2x1.5cm x brain deep right
side of face 06 cm laterally from the lateral angle of right eye with
inverted margin the subcutaneous tissues round the wound of
entrance are lacerated surrounding skin is scourched, blackened the
adjacent hair are signed.
(2)
Entry wound 2.5 x 2cm x chest cavity deep on the right
side of chest 20 cm laterally from the right nipple and 18 cm below
the right shoulder joint with inverted margin round the wound the
wound of entrance are lacerated. Surrounding skin is scorched and
blackened and the adjacent hair are signed.”
According to the Doctor, the cause of death was firearm
injury on the brain.
36.
PW23 Sub Inspector, Neeraj had recorded inquest Ex. A15
and had prepared documents for post mortem. According to him, on
24.03.2015, upon information having been received, they intercepted
the appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma alongwith Surendra
Singh @ Suri at 02:50 p.m., when they confessed that they had killed
the deceased Sumit Patwal and the pistol was kept by Jony Sharma in
his rented accommodation in Subhash Nagar, which was recovered on
the same day. He has proved the recovery memo Ex. A25 and also
proved the pistol Ex.2 and cartridges Exs. 4 and 5 alongwith magazine
Ex. 3.
37.
PW24 Sunil Kumar has stated about a mobile number
and according to him mobile number was taken by the deceased
Surendra Singh @ Suri by using his ID.
38.
PW25 Ashwini Kumar has stated that Surendra Singh S/o
Ganpat Singh had taken a sim from him on the ID of Sunil S/o
Jagpal.
39.
PW27 Narendra Singh Bisht and PW28 Girish Chandra
Sharma are also police officers. They have corroborated the statement
of PW23 Sub Inspector, Neeraj with regard to recovery made on
27.03.2015 and arrest of appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma.
40.
PW26 Wasim has stated about some photographs, which
are on record.
41.
PW29 Sub Inspector Vijay Singh has corroborated the
statement of PW23 Sub Inspector Neeraj with regard to the arrest of
appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma on 27.03.2015 and
recovery of the pistol. He has also stated that on 28.03.2015, at the
instance of appellant Vishal @ Jolly, a country-made pistol was
recovered from a vacant plot of Harendra Rawat. He proved its
recovery memo Ex.A 27.
42.
PW30 Sunil Singh Rawat has stated about the mobile
number, which the appellant was holding and with the help of call
details report, he has stated that the appellants were in touch, before
and after the incident of killing.
43.
PW32 Raj Darshan Singh is a witness of recovery memos
Ex. A9, A10 and A11. He has stated about other recoveries made by
the police. He is also a witness of recovery of a country-made pistol
made on 28.03.2015, at the instance of the appellant Vishal @ Jolly.
44.
PW35 Surjeet Singh is the witness of identification of
appellant Deepak Singh Rawat in the CCTV footage, which is Ex. A4. It
may be noted that PW2 Ashish Rana and PW3 Ravindra Singh Negi
have denied of having any identification made on that date. This
witness PW35 Surjeet Singh tells that PW2 Ashish Rana and PW3
Ravindra Singh Negi had identified the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat
in the CCTV footage.
45.
PW36 Mohit Kumar tells that the motorcycle bearing
Registration No. DL13HH0285 was a stolen motorcycle, of which an
FIR was lodged.
46.
PW38 Anil Kumar was owner of the motorcycle bearing
Registration No. DL13HH0285. According to him, it was stolen and he
had lodged an FIR.
47.
PW40 Pramod Kumar Shah is the Investigating Officer.
According to him, he had taken blood stained and plain soil and
prepared recovery memo, Ex. A9. He had also taken into custody the
cartridge case and prepared its recovery memo, Ex. A10. According to
him, two mobile phones, which were left at the place of incident were
taken into custody by Police Constable Sandeep Rathi and this witness
took them into custody and prepared recovery memo, Ex. A11. He also
states about Ex. A2, a letter purportedly written by the deceased to the
police officer on 04.02.2014, of which photocopy was given to this
witness by PW1 Sateshwari Devi. He also tells that Ex. A3, another
communication of PW1 Sateshwari Devi was given to him by PW1
Sateshwari Devi, in which it was recorded that shooters were seen
with the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat, in the vicinity, on motorcycle
bearing Registration No. UK008P4959. This witness also took into
custody the CCTV footages and got their photographs prepared. He
also proved various articles and documents. According to him, after
investigation, he submitted charge sheet.
48.
PW41 B.P. Singh, Senior Scientific Officer has proved the
Forensic Science Laboratory report, Ex. A48. Its conclusion has
already been stated hereinbefore.
49.
In fact, according to the prosecution, witnesses had seen
the appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma shooting the deceased
and then moving from the place of incident on a motorcycle, which
they parked near roadways bus stand, Kotdwar and from there, the
appellant Deepak Singh Rawat took them on his motorcycle. The
prosecution tried to produce eyewitnesses of the incident, but no
witness has supported the prosecution case.
50.
Second set of evidence, which the prosecution tried to
adduce, is that, near the roadway bus stand Kotdwar, the appellants
Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma came on a motorcycle. They parked
their motorcycle and from there, they drove away on the motorcycle
driven by the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat. According to the
prosecution, the CCTV footage was taken into custody from the
roadways bus stand and the appellants were identified. One of the
identification memo of it, is Ex. A4. But, PW2 Ashish Rana and PW3
Ravindra Singh Negi have categorically stated that they did not
identify the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat in the CCTV footage.
According to them, they were forced to sign on Ex. A4. They did not
read it even.
51.
There is another CCTV identification memo, which is Ex.
A39. According to it, PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi had identified the
appellant Deepak Singh Rawat on a motorcycle Yamaha Fazer bearing
Registration No. UK008P4959. But, PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi has not
stated anything about Ex. A39.
52.
With regard to the CCTV footages, admittedly, there is no
certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act. In the impugned
judgment, in paragraph 102 onwards, it is recorded that, in fact, the
electronic evidence may be proved by secondary evidence and
certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act is not required. But,
fact remains, the law has further been clarified by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in the case of Arjun Panditrao Khotkar (supra), and
in paras 33, 36 and 37 of it, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as
follows:“33. The non obstante clause in sub-section (1) makes it clear
that when it comes to information contained in an electronic record,
admissibility and proof thereof must follow the drill of Section 65-B,
which is a special provision in this behalf — Sections 62 to 65 being
irrelevant
for
this
purpose.
However,
Section
65-B(1)
clearly
differentiates between the “original” document — which would be the
original “electronic record” contained in the “computer” in which the
original information is first stored — and the computer output
containing such information, which then may be treated as evidence
of the contents of the “original” document. All this necessarily shows
that Section 65-B differentiates between the original information
contained in the “computer” itself and copies made therefrom — the
former being primary evidence, and the latter being secondary
evidence.
36. Despite
the
law
so
declared
in Anvar
P.V. [Anvar
P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473 : (2015) 1 SCC (Civ) 27 :
(2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 24 : (2015) 1 SCC (L&S) 108] , wherein this Court
made it clear that the special provisions of Sections 65-A and 65-B of
the Evidence Act are a complete code in themselves when it comes to
admissibility of evidence of information contained in electronic
records, and also that a written certificate under Section 65-B(4) is a
sine qua non for admissibility of such evidence, a discordant note was
soon struck in Tomaso Bruno [Tomaso Bruno v. State of U.P., (2015)
7 SCC 178 : (2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 54] . In this judgment, another threeJudge Bench dealt with the admissibility of evidence in a criminal
case in which CCTV footage was sought to be relied upon in evidence.
The Court held : (Tomaso Bruno case [Tomaso Bruno v. State of U.P.,
(2015) 7 SCC 178 : (2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 54] , SCC pp. 191-92, paras 2425)
“24. With the advancement of information technology,
scientific temper in the individual and at the institutional level
is to pervade the methods of investigation. With the increasing
impact of technology in everyday life and as a result, the
production of electronic evidence in cases has become relevant
to establish the guilt of the accused or the liability of the
defendant. Electronic documents stricto sensu are admitted as
material evidence. With the amendment to the Evidence Act in
2000, Sections 65-A and 65-B were introduced into Chapter V
relating to documentary evidence. Section 65-A provides that
contents of electronic records may be admitted as evidence if
the criteria provided in Section 65-B is complied with. The
computer generated electronic records in evidence are
admissible at a trial if proved in the manner specified by
Section 65-B of the Evidence Act. Sub-section (1) of Section
65-B makes admissible as a document, paper printout of
electronic records stored in optical or magnetic media
produced by a computer, subject to the fulfilment of the
conditions specified in sub-section (2) of Section 65-B.
Secondary evidence of contents of document can also be led
under Section 65 of the Evidence Act. PW 13 stated that he
saw the full video recording of the fateful night in the CCTV
camera, but he has not recorded the same in the case diary as
nothing substantial to be adduced as evidence was present in
it.
25. The production of scientific and electronic evidence
in court as contemplated under Section 65-B of the Evidence
Act is of great help to the investigating agency and also to the
prosecution. The relevance of electronic evidence is also
evident in the light of Mohd. Ajmal Amir Kasab v. State of
Maharashtra [Mohd.
Ajmal
Amir
Kasab v. State
of
Maharashtra, (2012) 9 SCC 1 : (2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 481] ,
wherein production of transcripts of internet transactions
helped the prosecution case a great deal in proving the guilt of
the accused. Similarly, in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot
Sandhu [State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, (2005) 11 SCC
600 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1715] , the links between the slain
terrorists and the masterminds of the attack were established
only through phone call transcripts obtained from the mobile
service providers.”
37. What is clear from this judgment is that the judgment
of Anvar P.V. [Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473 : (2015)
1 SCC (Civ) 27 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 24 : (2015) 1 SCC (L&S) 108] was
not referred to at all. In fact, the judgment in State (NCT of
Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu [State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, (2005)
11 SCC 600 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1715] was adverted to, which was a
judgment specifically overruled by Anvar P.V. [Anvar P.V. v. P.K.
Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473 : (2015) 1 SCC (Civ) 27 : (2015) 1 SCC
(Cri) 24 : (2015) 1 SCC (L&S) 108] It may also be stated that Section
65-B(4) was also not at all adverted to by this judgment. Hence, the
declaration of law in Tomaso Bruno [Tomaso Bruno v. State of U.P.,
(2015) 7 SCC 178 : (2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 54] following Navjot
Sandhu [State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, (2005) 11 SCC 600 :
2005 SCC (Cri) 1715] that secondary evidence of the contents of a
document can also be led under Section 65 of the Evidence Act to
make CCTV footage admissible would be in the teeth of Anvar
P.V. [Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473 : (2015) 1 SCC
(Civ) 27 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 24 : (2015) 1 SCC (L&S) 108] and cannot
be said to be a correct statement of the law. The said view is
accordingly overruled.
53.
And, finally, in para 46, the law laid down in the case of
Shafhi Mohammad Vs. State of Haryana, (2018) 5 SCC 311 has been
overruled as such. The Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:“46. Resultantly, the judgment dated 3-4-2018 of a Division
Bench of this Court reported as Shafhi Mohd. v. State of H.P. [Shafhi
Mohd. v. State of H.P., (2018) 5 SCC 311 : (2018) 2 SCC (Cri) 704] , in
following the law incorrectly laid down in Shafhi Mohammad [Shafhi
Mohammad v. State of H.P., (2018) 2 SCC 801 : (2018) 2 SCC 807 :
(2018) 2 SCC (Civ) 346 : (2018) 2 SCC (Civ) 351 : (2018) 1 SCC (Cri)
860 : (2018) 1 SCC (Cri) 865] , must also be, and is hereby,
overruled.”
54.
Admittedly, in the instant case, certificate under Section
65B of the Evidence Act has not been prepared or proved by the
prosecution. In absence of that certificate, the secondary evidence of
any electronic evidence, like CCTV footage cannot be read into
evidence. Therefore, the CCTV footages, which have been tried to be
proved by the prosecution cannot be read into evidence. In fact, as
stated, in the CCTV footages, the appellants were seen, even it has not
been established. PW2 Ashish Rana and PW3 Ravindra Singh Negi,
who allegedly identified the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat on the
motorcycle, as recorded in the recovery memo Ex. A4, have denied
having identified the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat. Similarly, in Ex.
A39, it is recorded that PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi did identify the
appellant Deepak Singh Rawat. But, Smt. Sateshwari Devi has not
stated about it in her statement.
55.
Moreover, the CCTV footages that have been tried to be
proved by the prosecution are not of the actual incident. According to
the prosecution, it only shows that two persons came on the
motorcycle and parked it at the roadways bus stand and from there,
they ran away on a motorcycle driven by the appellant Deepak Singh
Rawat. Without any connecting evidence, even if, such evidence is
read at all, it does not help the prosecution case. As stated, there is no
eyewitness of the incident. There is no evidence suggesting that it is
the appellant Vishal @ Jolly or Jony Sharma, who fired at the
deceased. Therefore, this Court concludes that CCTV footage evidence
is not admissible. Even otherwise, it does not help the prosecution at
all.
56.
In order to prove enmity between the deceased and the
appellants Deepak Singh Rawat and Surendra Singh @ Suri, the
prosecution has relied on Ex.A2, which has been proved by PW1 Smt.
Sateshwari Devi, the informant. According to PW1 Smt. Sateshwari
Devi, after lodging of the FIR, when she came to her house, she found
a photocopy of the communication signed by the deceased Sumit
Patwal addressed to the Station House Officer, Police Station Kotdwar,
which she proved as Ex.A2. In page 4, top paragraph of her statement,
PW1 Smt. Sateshwari Devi has stated that Ex.A2 is a photocopy. It is
not in the handwriting of the deceased Sumit Patwal, but it is signed
by him.
57.
The question is, can it be read to establish enmity, as held
in the impugned judgment in para 86? Mere proving of signature does
not prove the contents of the document. Mere signature of the
deceased on the photocopieddocument cannot prove its contents.
Contents are otherwise to be proved. In the instant case, the contents,
Ex. A-2 are not proved. It is a photocopy document. Though, it records
that the appellant Deepak Singh Rawat and others did threaten the
deceased on 02.02.2014. But, mere identification of signature on this
document, as stated, does not prove its contents. Therefore, based on
Ex. A2, it cannot be said that there was any enmity between the
deceased and the appellants or any of them.
58.
The
prosecution
witnesses
have
stated
that
on
27.03.2015, the appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma were
apprehended and at the instance of the appellant Jony Sharma, a
pistol was recovered from the roof top of the house of Sewa Ram.
59.
Arguments have been made that alleged recovery is
beyond the scope of Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
60.
PW23 Sub Inspector Neeraj has stated about the arrest of
the appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma on 27.03.2015 and at
their instance, recovery of pistol from the building owned by Sewa
Ram. He has proved the recovery memo Ex. A25. The disclosure
statement, which is recorded in it, reveals that on interrogation, the
appellant Jony Sharma had stated that the pistol by which he shot the
deceased has been concealed by him in a rented room in Subhash
Nagar. But, fact remains that when the police proceeded to recover,
they record that they visited the rented room of the appellant Jony
Sharma at Gali No.8, in the building of Sewa Ram and from the roof
top of double storey house, from below bricks a pistol and cartridges
were recovered. Definitely, the recovery is beyond what was disclosed.
According to the recovery memo Ex. A25, on interrogation, the
appellant Jony Sharma had revealed that he had concealed the pistol
in his rented room in Subhash Nagar. He had not stated that he had
kept the pistol on the roof top of his rented house in Gali No. 8,
Subhash Nagar owned by Sewa Ram. How these further details were
recorded in the recovery memo Ex.A25? It is not clear. Witnesses have
not explained it. Admittedly, the house owner Sewa Ram is not the
witness and there is no other independent witness of the locality. The
recovery was made from an open place.
61.
There is another recovery with regard to recovery of a
country-made pistol from an open plot at the instance of the appellant
Vishal @ Jolly, as stated by PW29 Vijay Singh. This is also a recovery
from an open place. There is no evidence to suggest that the appellant
Vishal @ Jolly or Jony Sharma had any actual control of the place
from where the weapons were allegedly recovered.
62.
It is the prosecution case that from the dead body of the
deceased two bullets were recovered and they were handed over to the
police. The post mortem report, Ex. A19, records two entry wounds
and at page 2, it records that from entry wound no.1 a bullet about
1.5 cm was obtained. It did not disclose as to from where another
bullet was obtained. But then, two bullets were handed over to the
police. From where two bullets were recovered? PW22 Dr. Guman
Singh Rana has not stated about two bullets handed over by him to
the police.
63.
The Forensic Science Laboratory report has been proved
by PW41. According to it, Constable Omveer Singh Bisht took those
articles for forensic examination, which had the seal of CJM, Pauri
Garhwal. The question is as to where the bullets were kept after they
were handed over by the doctor to the police? When were those bullets
produced before the Magistrate? When they were forwarded to the
Forensic Science Laboratory and who forwarded it? Whether the
recovered bullets were forwarded to the Magistrate for forensic
examination or not? The carrier of those articles to Forensic Science
Laboratory Constable Omveer Singh Bisht has not been examined. No
GD entry has been proved to reveal the complete chain of safe custody
of the bullets after their extraction from the dead body till they were
produced before the Magistrate. Therefore, the forensic report does not
help the prosecution.
64.
The recovery of firearms was made from an open place.
The allegedly recovered weapons are not connected with the offence.
The CCTV footages cannot be read into evidence. Even identification of
the appellants has not been done. There is no evidence of actual
shooting, whatsoever, in terms of eyewitness or any other manner.
65.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
view that the chain of events, in this case is not complete. Prosecution
has not been able to prove the charge leveled against the appellants
Vishal @ Jolly, Jony Sharma and Deepak Singh Rawat and these
appellants ought to have been acquitted of the charges. Learned court
below committed an error in convicting and sentencing them.
Therefore, the appeals deserve to be allowed.
66.
The appeals are allowed.
67.
The judgment and order dated 31.08.2019/03.09.2019,
passed in Sessions Trial No. 21 of 2015, State of Uttarakhand Vs.
Deepak Rawat and others, by the court of Additional Sessions Judge,
Kotdwar, Pauri Garhwal, is set aside.
68.
The appellants Vishal @ Jolly and Jony Sharma are
acquitted of the charge under Section 302 IPC and the appellant
Deepak Singh Rawat is acquitted of the charge under Section 302 read
with 34 IPC.
69.
Appellants are in jail. Let they be released forthwith, if not
wanted in any other case, subject to their furnishing personal bonds
and two sureties each of the like amount to the satisfaction of the
court concerned under Section 437 A of the Code.
70.
Let a copy of this judgment be sent to learned court below
along with the original records.
(Alok Mahra, J.)
Jitendra
07.01.2026
(Ravindra Maithani, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review