Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:196
Judgement Delivered on: 06.01.2026
Judgement Reserved on: 09.12.2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
WRIT PETITION (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024
Vishal Agarwal
......Petitioner
Versus
Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others
…..Respondents
Presence:
Mr. Ramji Srivastava, learned counsel for the Petitioner.
Mr. V. K. Kaparuwan, learned counsel for the Respondents.
Hon’ble Ashish Naithani, J.
The present writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India has been instituted by the Petitioner assailing the
order dated 13.02.2024 passed by the learned Additional District Judge,
Rishikesh in Civil Revision No. 128 of 2022, whereby the revisional court
affirmed the order dated 22.09.2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge
(Junior Division), Rishikesh in Original Suit No. 16 of 2021, rejecting the
Petitioner’s amendment application filed under Order 6 Rule 17 of the
Code of Civil Procedure
2.
The dispute relates to a property situated at Nehru Marg,
Rishikesh, bearing old Municipal No. 26/2/11A and present Municipal No.
222/26, recorded over Khasra No. 74/9, admeasuring approximately
376.245 square meters. The Petitioner claims title through his mother, late
Savitri Devi, who is stated to have acquired the said property by a
registered sale deed dated 13.07.1988 and thereafter remained in
possession until her death.
3.
It is the case of the Petitioner that during her lifetime, Savitri
Devi executed a Will in his favour, pursuant to which, upon her demise on
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:196
02.06.2021, the Petitioner claims to have succeeded to the property and
continued in possession thereof. House tax and other municipal dues are
stated to have been paid continuously, both during the lifetime of the
Petitioner’s mother and thereafter by the Petitioner.
4.
The Petitioner asserts that in the year 2005, a sale deed was
executed in favour of one Virendra Aawal, not as an absolute transfer, but
as a security arrangement in respect of a loan transaction. According to the
Petitioner, the loan amount was subsequently repaid over a period of time,
and disputes arising from the said transaction led to the institution of
Original Suit No. 25 of 2020 against Virendra Aawal, which is stated to be
pending adjudication before the competent civil court.
5.
In the year 2021, proceedings were initiated before the Municipal
Corporation, Rishikesh, at the instance of the present Respondents, who
claimed rights over the same property on the basis of an alleged sale deed
of the year 1967 executed in favour of their predecessor in interest, Shanti
Devi. The Petitioner disputes the genuineness and validity of the said sale
deed and asserts that it pertains to a different property and chain of title.
6.
In the backdrop of the municipal proceedings and rival claims set
up by the Respondents, the Petitioner instituted Original Suit No. 16 of
2021 before the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Rishikesh, seeking
declaratory and consequential reliefs in respect of the aforesaid property.
7.
Upon service of summons, the Respondents filed their respective
written statements. In their pleadings, the Respondents set up a defence
founded inter alia on the transactions involving Virendra Aawal and
subsequent purchasers, including alleged transfers in favour of third
parties and an entity described as Anandpur Trust, thereby asserting that
the property claimed by the Petitioner stood alienated through a distinct
chain of title.
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:196
8.
Before commencement of evidence, the Petitioner moved an
application dated 27.07.2022, registered as Application No. 42-A, under
Order 6 Rule 17 CPC, seeking amendment of the plaint. By the proposed
amendment, the Petitioner sought to clarify the rival chains of title, to
explain the distinction between the property claimed by him and the
property relied upon by the Respondents, and to implead certain
subsequent transferees so as to avoid ambiguity and multiplicity of
proceedings.
9.
The learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), by order dated
22.09.2022, rejected the amendment application, primarily holding that the
facts sought to be introduced were already in issue in another suit against
Virendra Aawal and that the amendment was a mala fide attempt to delay
the proceedings.
10.
Aggrieved, the Petitioner preferred a civil revision, which came
to be dismissed by the learned Additional District Judge, Rishikesh, by
order dated 13.02.2024, affirming the reasoning of the trial court and
holding that no interference was warranted.
11.
Challenging the aforesaid concurrent orders, the Petitioner has
approached this Court contending that the courts below have misapplied
the principles governing amendment of pleadings and have failed to
exercise jurisdiction vested in them in accordance with law.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.
13.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the courts
below have committed a manifest error in applying the proviso to Order 6
Rule 17 CPC, even though the amendment application was filed before
commencement of evidence and at a stage when only issues had been
framed.
13.
It was contended that the proposed amendment was purely
explanatory in nature and did not introduce a new cause of action, alter the
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:196
basic structure of the suit, or withdraw any admission made earlier.
Learned Counsel argued that the amendment was necessitated by the
defence set up by the Respondents in their written statements and was
essential for proper adjudication of the real controversy between the
parties.
14.
Learned Counsel further submitted that the reliance placed by the
courts below on Section 10 CPC was wholly misconceived, as the suit
against Virendra Aawal was founded on a distinct cause of action,
involved different parties, and pertained to a separate chain of
transactions. According to learned Counsel, the pendency of the said suit
could not operate as a bar either to the institution of the present suit or to
the amendment of pleadings therein.
15.
It was also urged that the finding of mala fides recorded by the
trial court was unsupported by any material on record and was based on a
presumption rather than a reasoned analysis. Learned Counsel submitted
that seeking comprehensive adjudication and avoidance of multiplicity of
proceedings could not, by any stretch, be characterised as mala fide.
16.
Per contra, learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents
supported the impugned orders and submitted that the amendment
application was filed after framing of issues and, therefore, squarely
attracted the rigour of the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. It was
contended that the Petitioner had failed to demonstrate due diligence as
required under the proviso.
17.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents further argued that the
Petitioner was seeking, under the guise of amendment, to indirectly reopen
issues already raised in the earlier suit against Virendra Aawal and to
unnecessarily expand the scope of the present proceedings. According to
learned Counsel, permitting such an amendment would cause prejudice to
the Respondents and unduly delay the trial.
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:196
18.
It was also submitted that the concurrent findings recorded by the
trial court and the revisional court were discretionary in nature and did not
warrant interference in the exercise of the supervisory jurisdiction of this
Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
19.
This Court has considered the rival submissions advanced by
learned Counsel for the parties and has perused the pleadings, the
amendment application, the objections thereto, and the impugned orders
passed by the courts below.
20.
At the outset, it is necessary to delineate the scope of interference
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The supervisory jurisdiction
of this Court is not intended to function as a court of appeal. However,
where a subordinate court applies an incorrect legal test, ignores settled
principles governing the exercise of jurisdiction, or declines to exercise
jurisdiction vested in it by law, supervisory correction is not only
permissible but warranted.
21.
The core issue in the present case is whether the courts below
were justified in rejecting the amendment application filed by the
Petitioner under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC, and in doing so, whether they
applied the correct legal parameters.
22.
The record clearly demonstrates that although issues had been
framed in the suit, the trial had not commenced, and no evidence had been
led at the time when the amendment application was moved. The
distinction between “framing of issues” and “commencement of trial” is
well recognised. The proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC is attracted only
after the trial has commenced, which, in the context of civil proceedings,
is understood as the stage when the court begins recording evidence.
23.
The courts below have proceeded on the erroneous premise that
framing of issues, by itself, attracts the rigour of the proviso to Order 6
Rule 17 CPC. This approach reflects a misapplication of the statutory
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:196
provision and a conflation of two distinct procedural stages. Such an error
goes to the root of the exercise of jurisdiction.
24.
Equally significant is the nature of the amendment sought. A
careful reading of the amendment application reveals that the Petitioner
did not seek to introduce a new cause of action, alter the fundamental
character of the suit, or withdraw any admission previously made. The
proposed amendment was intended to explain and clarify the rival chains
of title asserted by the parties, particularly in light of the defence taken by
the Respondents in their written statements.
25.
It is well settled that an amendment which is explanatory or
clarificatory in nature, and which assists the court in effectively
adjudicating the real controversy between the parties, ought ordinarily to
be permitted, especially when no irretrievable prejudice is caused to the
opposite party. The courts below have failed to examine the amendment
application from this perspective.
26.
The reliance placed by the courts below on Section 10 CPC is
also misplaced. The bar of res sub judice operates only where the matter in
issue in the subsequent suit is directly and substantially the same as that in
the previously instituted suit, between the same parties or parties claiming
under them, and where the reliefs are identical. The suit instituted by the
Petitioner against Virendra Aawal arises out of a distinct transaction and
involves a different set of parties and causes of action. The pendency of
that suit could not, therefore, be a valid ground to non-suit the Petitioner
or to deny amendment in the present proceedings.
27.
The finding recorded by the trial court, and affirmed in revision,
that the amendment was mala fide is not borne out from the record. Mere
overlap of background facts or reference to related transactions does not
constitute mala fides. On the contrary, the amendment appears to have
been prompted by the defence set up by the Respondents themselves, who
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:196
sought to rely upon multiple transactions and alleged transfers to contest
the Petitioner’s claim.
28.
The courts below have also overlooked the principle that
procedural law is a handmaid of justice and that rules of procedure are
meant to advance, not obstruct, the cause of substantive adjudication. The
refusal to permit amendment in the present case is likely to result in
multiplicity of proceedings and fragmented adjudication, an outcome
which the procedural law seeks to avoid.
29.
The revisional court, while affirming the order of the trial court,
has failed to independently examine whether the discretion exercised by
the trial court was in consonance with settled legal principles. The
revisional jurisdiction was thus exercised in a mechanical manner, without
addressing the jurisdictional infirmities apparent on the face of the record.
30.
This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that the
impugned orders suffer from a manifest error of law and a failure to
exercise jurisdiction in accordance with the parameters governing
amendment of pleadings. The present case falls within the narrow but
well-defined contours where supervisory interference under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India is justified.
ORDER
For the reasons recorded hereinabove, the writ petition is
allowed.
The order dated 22.09.2022 passed by the Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Rishikesh, in Original Suit No. 16 of 2021, as well as the order
dated 13.02.2024 passed by the learned Additional District Judge,
Rishikesh, in Civil Revision No. 128 of 2022, are set aside.
Ashish Naithani, J.
SB
SHIKSHA
BINJOLA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF
UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=3410ef86ae41ec9fbabcd5dba6b3a2c24b5aa08b09c12f21822fbd40bf639
b1c, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=FD80A2D028949381C52796A542D7FF0A9BED00E67B5283D205F1
8FE29BDF5DD9, cn=SHIKSHA BINJOLA
Date: 2026.01.06 16:32:13 +05'30'
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1120 of 2024, “Vishal Agarwal Vs. Rakesh Kumar Varshney and others”
Ashish Naithani J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review