Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:213
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S). No. 5739 of 2019
---------Vinod Kumar, son of late Panna Singh, resident of Flat No. 2/A,
Jeevandeep Enclave, Bank Colony, Kokar, P.O. Kokar, P.S. Sadar,
District Ranchi, Jharkhand.
………. Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand.
2. Principal Secretary, Road Construction Department, Government of
Jharkhand, Project Building, P.O. and P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi,
Jharkhand.
3. Deputy Secretary, Road Construction Department, Government of
Jharkhand, Project Building, P.O. and P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi,
Jharkhand.
4. The Appellate Authority through Joint Secretary, Road Construction
Department, Government of Jharkhand, Project Building, P.O. and
P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi, Jharkhand.
……….
Respondents
--------CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
----------For the Petitioner
:
Mr. A. Allam, Sr. Advocate
M/s. Faisal Allam, Sushmita Kumari,
Shalini Singh, Asfia Sultana, Advocates
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Priyadarshi, GP-VI
Mr. Ayush Deb, AC to GP-VI
---------06/ 06.01.2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
In this writ application the petitioner prays for the following
reliefs:
a. For issuance of an appropriate writ/writs,
order/orders, direction/directions or writ in the nature
of certiorari for quashing the notification bearing No.
119(S), dated 06.01.2011 [ANNEXURE-4], issued by
the Road Construction Department, Government of
Jharkhand, Ranchi through its Deputy Secretary,
whereby petitioner has been awarded following
punishments:
(i) Stoppage of four annual increments with
cumulative effect;
(ii) No payment for suspension period except
subsistence allowances during the period of
suspension;
2026:JHHC:213
(iii) No promotion on higher post for next five
years, as contained in ANNEXURE -4 to the writ
petition.
b.
For issuance of an appropriate writ/writs,
order/orders, direction/directions or writ in the nature
of certiorari for quashing the Appellate Order as
contained in Memo No. 2061 (S), dated 11.04.2019,
issued by the Government and communicated through
the Joint Secretary, Department of Road Construction
whereby and whereunder the punishment order dated
06.01.2011, has been confirmed without mentioning
any reason and which was passed only on the ground
that in another departmental proceeding some
punishment has been inflicted. So, the order of
punishment dated 06.01.2011 is confirmed without any
basis.
3.
Petitioner was appointed to the post of Assistant Engineer and
he joined his post on 21.07.1981 under the respondents and
subsequently, he was promoted to the post of Executive Engineer
in the year 2002. Thereafter, he was transferred to the Road
Division, Jamshedpur through a Notification dated 29.12.2006,
where he took charge of his post on 30.12.2006. It is further case
of the petitioner that while he was posted as Executive Engineer,
Rural Works Department, Government of Jharkhand, he was
served with a Notification bearing No. 21(S), dated 04.01.2009,
whereby he was suspended with immediate effect. Thereafter, by a
Resolution no. 1199(S)WE, dated 06.03.2009, issued by the Road
Construction Department, Government of Jharkhand, a decision
was taken to initiate departmental proceeding against the petitioner
and consequently, the departmental proceeding was initiated. After
conclusion of the enquiry proceeding, the Enquiry Officer
submitted his report holding the petitioner guilty of the charges.
Thereafter, the Disciplinary Authority vide Notification issued
under Memo No. 119(S), dated 06.01.2011, imposed punishment
of stoppage of four annual increments with cumulative effect, no
payment for the suspension period except the subsistence
2026:JHHC:213
allowance and stoppage of promotion on the higher post for the
next five years. It is further case of the petitioner that in para-6 of
the supplementary counter affidavit, names of the officers have
been mentioned who were responsible for monitoring the
construction of the said road, however, petitioner's name was not in
that list. Against the order of punishment, petitioner filed an
Appeal before the Governor of Jharkhand through proper channel
vide his Memo of Appeal dated 21.12.2017.
4.
After receiving Memo of Appeal, the Appellate Authority has
not gone into the grounds of appeal nor considered any aspects
under which the enquiry officer had dealt with the charges. There
were several defects in the departmental enquiry, for example,
neither any witnesses were examined; nor any documentary
evidences were produced by the Presenting Officer. Ultimately, the
appellate authority not at all considered all these grounds and
confirmed the punishment order vide Memo No. 2061(S), dated
11.04.2019.
The petitioner has thrown challenge to the aforesaid orders in
the instant writ application.
5.
Learned Sr. Counsel has made following submissions:
i)
The impugned order of punishment dated 06.01.2011 is a
non-reasoned and non-speaking order, inasmuch as, none of the
grounds which has been taken by the petitioner in reply to the
2nd show-cause has been taken into account.
ii)
Even the Appellate Authority did not pass a reasoned
order, instead, the Appellate Authority has taken into
consideration one another case in which punishment has been
imposed. The same is beyond jurisdiction.
iii)
In the entire enquiry proceeding, none of the documents
has been proved by oral evidence.
2026:JHHC:213
6.
Learned Sr. Counsel for the petitioner has further argued the
case on merit that the petitioner was posted only for couple of
months and the entire work was over much prior to his posting to
the concerned place; as such, even otherwise, the impugned order
of punishment as well as the appellate order should be quashed and
set aside.
7.
Learned counsel for the respondent-State justifying the
impugned orders submits that an inspection report of construction
of work of Adityapur Kandra road was submitted by the Chief
Engineer (Communication), Road Construction Department,
Ranchi vide letter No. 1961 dated 18.11.2008, wherein it was
reported that the road was damaged within a year of its
construction. The department after reviewing the report, served a
show-cause notice to the petitioner vide letter No. 7438 dated
25.11.2008, to which the petitioner submitted his reply vide letter
No. 2277 dated 01.12.2008. Thereafter, being not satisfied with the
reply of the petitioner, the Department after approval from the
competent authority suspended the petitioner vide notification
contained in memo No. 21 (S) dated 04.01.2009 and initiated a
departmental proceeding vide resolution dated 06.03.2009 in
which three charges were levelled against the petitioner. The
Enquiry Officer reported that charge Nos. 1 and 2 are proved. After
reviewing the enquiry report, the petitioner was served 2 nd showcause notice vide letter dated 10.11.2019 and the petitioner
submitted his reply vide letter dated 23.11.2010. The disciplinary
authority after reviewing the reply of 2nd show-cause and after
approval from the competent authority revoked the suspension of
the petitioner and punishment was imposed upon the petitioner
vide notification contained in memo No. 119(S) dated 06.01.2011.
The petitioner preferred appeal and the appellate authority vide
order dated 11.04.2019 also confirmed the order of punishment.
2026:JHHC:213
Learned counsel further submits that petitioner has been
8.
punished in another matter vide notification dated 27.03.2015
wherein following punishment have been imposed upon the
petitioner:
i)
Reduction to the lowest scale of the pay.
ii)
Proportionate recovery of loss of government revenue which
amounts to Rs.69,40,098.67.
He further submits that the retiral benefits of the petitioner is
being pending due to the aforesaid reason, for which a writ petition
being W.P.(S). No. 5388 of 2019 has been filed by the petitioner.
9.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after going
through the impugned order of punishment dated 06.01.2011, it is
evident that the same is passed without considering any of the
contention of the petitioner. As a matter of fact, the concerned
authority has only stated that a proceeding was initiated and
thereafter, 2nd show-cause was issued and after getting the reply,
the same was not found satisfactory. However, why reply to the 2 nd
show-cause was not found satisfactory, has not been mentioned
even in a single sentence. In crux, the punishment has been
awarded without giving any reason; as such, on this score alone the
impugned order of punishment needs to be quashed and set aside.
10.
After going through the memorandum of appeal filed by the
petitioner and the appellate order, it appears that two reasons have
been assigned in rejecting the appeal. Firstly, the petitioner has
taken same grounds what he has taken in reply to the 2 nd showcause and secondly, the petitioner has also been punished in a
separate case, for which petitioner has also filed a writ petition.
However, the appellate authority failed to deliberate with any of
the contentions/ grounds raised in the memo of appeal.
11.
After going through the appellate order, this Court is having no
hesitation in holding that the same is not a reasoned order and the
reason of another case is inconsistent and unheard in the service
2026:JHHC:213
jurisprudence for the sole reason that the appellate authority was
supposed to pass the order after going through the grounds taken
by the petitioner which is absent in the instant case.
12.
From the entire counter-affidavit, it has not been stated that any
oral evidence has been adduced in order to prove the documents,
which is also against the settled principle of enquiry proceeding.
13.
Having regard to the aforesaid facts and discussion, the
impugned orders dated 06.01.2011 and 11.04.2019 are hereby
quashed and set aside.
14.
Accordingly, the instant writ application stands allowed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
6th January, 2026
Kunal/-
Uploaded 20.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review