Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No.8 of 2026
Date of Decision: 12th May, 2026.
Vinod Kumar
.....Petitioner
Versus
Nimmo Devi
...Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Kush Sharma, Advocate.
For the Respondent:
Ms. Archana Dutt, Advocate, for the
respondent.
Romesh Verma, Judge (oral).
The present petition has been preferred against the
impugned judgment dated 01.11.2025, passed by the learned
Additional District Judge Chamba, District Chamba, H.P. in CMA
No. 13 of 2025, titled Vinod Kumar vs. Smt. Nimmo Devi,
whereby appeal filed by the present petitioner was dismissed and
order dated 08.07.2025 passed by learned Senior Civil Judge,
Chamba in CMA No. 363 of 2024 was affirmed, whereby application
filed by the plaintiff/ respondent under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC
for the grant of ad interim injunction was allowed.
2.
Brief
facts
of
the
present
case
are
that
the
plaintiff/respondent filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction
restraining the defendant, his agents, servants and workmen from
causing nuisance or raising any forcible and illegal construction
over the joint, undivided and un-partition suit land comprised in
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
Khata Khatuni No. 82/89, Khasra No. 527 measuring 00-08-00bighas, (00-02-00 Gair Mumkin panchayat Ghar) and (00-06-00
bighas Gair Mumkin Khandhar) situated at Mauza Kohlari, Hadust
No. 25, Pargna Udaipur, Patwar Circle Chamdoli, Kanungo Circle
Sach, Tehsil Chamba District Chamba H.P. Further prayer
for
Mandatory injunction was also made to the effect that if the
defendant succeeded in raising forcible and illegal construction over
the suit land, then he be directed to restore the suit property in its
original position.
3.
It is the case of the plaintiff that the suit land is in the joint
ownership and possession of the parties. In order to demonstrate
the same, the copy of Jamabandi for the year 2020-21 has been
attached with the plaint. It has been averred that in the last week of
May 2024, the defendant marked and developed the “GAIR
MUMKIN KHANDHAR” comprised in Khasra No. 527 of Mohal
Kohlari, Tehsil and District Chamba H.P. to raise the construction of
his house and while doing so, the plaintiff had raised the objection
and requested the defendant not to start the construction work of
his house without partition of the same.
4.
In this background, suit was filed for permanent prohibitory
injunction and mandatory injunction restraining the defendant from
changing the nature, and raising forcible construction over the suit
land.
5.
The suit was contested by the defendant/petitioner by filing
the written statement taking therein preliminary objections with
regard to maintainability, estoppel, cause of action, locus standi etc.
On merits, it was stated that though the suit land is joint amongst
the parties and other co-sharers as per revenue record, however,
as per the settled possession of the respective parties over the suit
land, the same is being utilized by the respective parties by virtue of
family settlement.
6.
In para 3 (a) of the written statement specific ground was
taken that the plaintiff/respondent has already raised construction of
her house and shop over the suit land by covering an area in
excess to her share in the suit land. Further it has been stated that
the plaintiff is owner to the extent of 00-02-13 Bigha while raising
construction the plaintiff has covered over and above the area qua
her share. It has further been stated that defendant has not raised
any new construction but he is renovating/ reconstructing his old
house, which is allotted to him, in family settlement and the same is
in his exclusive possession. After refuting all the averments, as
made in the plaint, the defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit.
7.
The plaintiff filed the replication and the defence of the
defendant, specially in para 3 of the written statement, was refuted
in the replication.
8.
Alongwith the suit, the plaintiff filed an application under
Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC read with Section 151 of CPC for the
issuance of the ad interim injunction.
9.
Reply to the application was filed filed by the present
petitioner/defendant, stating therein that respondent/ plaintiff had
already raised construction of her house and shop over the suit land
by covering the excess area.
10.
The learned trial Court while deciding the application under
Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC vide its order dated 8.7.2025 allowed
the application filed by the plaintiff and directed the parties to
maintain status quo qua the nature, possession and construction
over the suit land during the pendency of the main suit or till the
same is partitioned by metes and bounds.
11.
Feeling dissatisfied, the defendant/petitioner preferred an
appeal under Order 43 Rule 1 CPC in the Court of learned
Additional District Judge, Shimla, H.P. on 26.07.2025.
12.
The First Appellate Court vide its judgment dated
01.11.2025 dismissed the appeal as preferred by the defendant.
13.
Still feeling aggrieved the petitioner/defendant has invoked
the provisions of article 227 of the Constitution of India against the
impugned judgment and order as passed by the learned Courts
below.
14.
It is contended by Mr. Kush Sharma, Advocate, that the
Courts below have erred by passing the impugned judgment/order
by not taking into consideration the fact that the respondent/plaintiff
has herself raised the construction over the joint land. Therefore,
the principle of jointness will not be applicable in the present case.
He further submits that learned trial Court has dealt with this aspect,
however, the learned First Appellate Court has not assigned any
reasons, though specific ground were taken in the grounds of
appeal before the First Appellate Court.
15.
On the other hand, the judgment and order as passed by
the learned Courts below has been defended by the learned
counsel for the defendant. She submits that Courts below after
appreciating the material evidence on record, have rightly come to
the conclusion and directed the parties to maintain status quo qua
the nature, possession and construction over the suit land during
the pendency of the suit or till the time same is partitioned.
16.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone
through the case file.
17.
The main contention raised by the learned counsel for the
petitioner is that the learned First Appellate Court has neither
addressed nor assigned any reason with respect to the fact that the
respondent herself raised the construction over the suit land.
Therefore, the principle of jointness is not applicable in the present
case.
18.
He further submits that the respondent/plaintiff has not
approached the Court with clean hands, and a person seeking
injunction should approach the Court with clean hands. He further
submits that, since the grant of injunction is an equitable relief, the
said fact has been suppressed by the respondent/plaintiff in her
pleadings.
19.
On the other hand, it is contended by the learned counsel
for the respondent that the Courts below have taken into
consideration all the aspects raised by the respective parties, thus,
there is no error or infirmity in the impugned order and judgment as
passed by the learned Courts below.
20.
While perusing the judgment passed by the learned First
Appellate Court, prima facie, the grounds raised by the present
petitioner before the learned First Appellate Court have neither
been dealt with nor has any reason been assigned qua the said
contentions raised by the defendant before the learned First
Appellate Court.
21.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has repeatedly held that the
reasons are required to be assigned while passing the orders. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2010) 4 SCC 785, titled as Assistant
Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department,Works Contract &
Leasing, Kota vs. M/s Shukla & Brothers, decided on
15.04.2010, held as follows:
“24. Reason is the very life of law. When the reason of a
law once ceases, the law itself generally ceases
(Wharton's Law Lexicon). Such is the significance of
reasoning in any rule of law. Giving reasons furthers the
cause of justice as well as avoids uncertainty. As a matter
of fact it helps in the observance of law of precedent.
Absence of reasons on the contrary essentially introduces
an element of uncertainty, dis- satisfaction and give
entirely different dimensions to the questions of law raised
before the higher/appellate courts. In our view, the court
should provide its own grounds and reasons for rejecting
claim/prayer of a party whether at the very threshold i.e. at
admission stage or after regular hearing, howsoever
precise they may be.
30. In light of the judgments referred to and relied upon
by the parties including the judgment of this Court, it is
true that requirement of stating reasons for judicial orders
necessarily does not mean a very detailed or lengthy
order, but there should be some reasoning recorded by
the Court for declining or granting relief to the petitioner.
The purpose, as already noticed, is to make the litigant
aware of the reasons for which the relief is declined as
well as to help the higher Court in assessing the
correctness of the view taken by the High Court while
disposing off a matter. May be, while dealing with the
matter at the admission stage even recording of short
listening dealing with the merit of the contentions raised
before the High Court may suffice, in contrast, a detailed
judgment while matter is being disposed off after final
hearing, but in both events, in our view, it is imperative for
the High Court to record its own reasoning however short
it might be.”
22.
Similarly, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2010) 9 SCC 486
titled as M/s. Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. vs. Sh. Masood
Ahmed Khan & Others, decided on 08.09.2010, held as follows:
“22. In Woolcombers of India Ltd. vs. Workers Union
and another, AIR 1973 SC 2758, this Court while
considering an award under Section 11 of the Industrial
Disputes Act insisted on the need of giving reasons in
support of conclusions in the Award. The Court held that
the very requirement of giving reason is to prevent
unfairness or arbitrariness in reaching conclusions. The
second principle is based on the jurisprudential doctrine
that justice should not only be done, it should also appear
to be done as well. The learned Judges said that a just
but unreasoned conclusion does not appear to be just to
those who read the same. Reasoned and just conclusion
on the other hand will also have the appearance of
justice. The third ground is that such awards are subject
to Article 136 jurisdiction of this Court and in the absence
of reasons, it is difficult for this Court to ascertain whether
the decision is right or wrong.
28. In Gurdial Singh Fijji vs. State of Punjab and
Ors., (1979) 2 SCC 368, this Court, dealing with a
service matter, relying on the ratio in Union of India
vs. Mohan lal Capoor, (1973) 2 SCC 836, held that
"rubber-stamp reason" is not enough and virtually
quoted the observation in Capoor (supra) to the extent
that:
28...Reasons are the links between the materials on
which certain conclusions are based and the actual
conclusions."
23.
In the present case, no reasons have been assigned by the
learned First Appellate Court to the stand taken by the defendant in
the written statement as well as in the grounds of appeal.
24.
Consequently, without touching upon the merits of the
case, this Court is of the considered opinion that, after setting aside
the impugned judgment passed by the learned First Appellate
Court, the case is remitted back to the Court of the learned
Additional District Judge, Chamba, with a direction to decide the
appeal under Order 43 Rule 1 CPC afresh by affording an
opportunity to the respective parties to argue their case and to take
the appeal to its logical end strictly in accordance with law.
25.
Parties are directed to appear before the learned First
Appellate Court on 15.06.2026.
26.
It is made clear that the learned First Appellate Court shall
not issue fresh notices for the service of the parties, and the learned
counsel for the parties undertake that the parties, through their
counsel, shall remain present before the learned First Appellate
Court on 15.06.2026.
27.
Accordingly, the petition stands disposed of, and the
pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
12th May, 2026
(Nisha)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review