Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
B. A. No. 9602 of 2025
Vinay Kumar Choubey, aged about 49 years, son of Devendra Choubey,
resident of 4, Kanke Road, P.O. and P.S. Kanke, District-Ranchi
...... … Petitioner
Versus
The State of Jharkhand through ACB, (Vigilance) .…. …
Opposite Party
-------CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI
For the Petitioner
:Mr. R.S. Mazumdar, Senior Advocate
Mr. Nishant Kumar Roy, Advocate
For the ACB
: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
: Mr. Ritesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
: Ms. Shruti Shekhar, Advocate
Mr. Nillohit Choubey, Advocate
04/ 06.01.2026: Heard Mr. R.S. Mazumdar, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel for the A.C.B.
2.
The petitioner has been made an accused in connection with
Hazaribagh A.C.B. P.S. Case No. 09 of 2025 registered under sections 409,
467, 468, 471, 420, 120B of the Indian Penal Code and under section 13(2)
and 13(1) (c) & (d) of the Prevention of Corruption (Amendment) Act, 1988,
pending in the Court of
learned
Additional District Judge-II-cum-Special
Judge, Vigilance (ACB), Hazaribagh and by way of this petition the petitioner
is seeking regular bail.
3.
Mr. R.S. Mazumdar, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submits that
petitioner is innocent and he has committed no offence as
alleged in the F.I.R. He further submits that the petitioner has been falsely
implicated in this case. He next submits that petitioner was not named as
an accused in the F.I.R. but subsequently he has been made accused in the
instant case and he has been taken into custody by the prosecuting agency.
He next submits that the petitioner has been made an accused in the instant
case only on account of the fact that the petitioner was the then Deputy
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
Commissioner, Hazaribag and petitioner had joined the office as Deputy
Commissioner, Hazaribagh on 26.05.2008 and he remained there till
05.10.2010.
He next submits that
the present
case is outcome of
preliminary enquiry being 24 of 2015 which was conducted by A.C.B on the
complaint made by one Tripurari Singh 10 years ago who happens to be a
journalist and the said enquiry was conducted with respect to the orders
which were not passed by the petitioner
passed 17 years
and even the said orders were
back when the petitioner was posted as Deputy
Commissioner, Hazaribagh. He then submits that any order with respect to
land relating to the khas mahal land are being passed under the Khas Mahal
Estate Manual and on the directions of the Government. He further submits
that only on the approval of the State Government said land has been
transferred. He next submits that lessee has made an application for renewal
of the lease which was registered as Lease Renewal Case No. 85/2007-08
and they have also made a prayer with respect to removing the word
“Sevayat” and petitioner being the Deputy Commissioner has passed an order
to delete the word “Sevayat” from Register-II and further recommended for
renewal of the
Commissioner.
lease to the State Government through Divisional
He further submits that this allegation is false in the F.I.R
against the petitioner and petitioner has not passed any order to remove the
word ‘sevayat’
and only forwarded the proposal put up by the Additional
Collector in lease renewal case record no. 85/2007-08 to Divisional
Commissioner for the State Government to take a decision in the matter and
further action was taken after the approval of the State Government was
obtained vide Memo No. 1502 dated 18.06.2009 thereafter the land in
question has been transferred. He then submits that the petitioner has only
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
forwarded the same and noting of the other officers
have been placed
before the petitioner and in view of that the petitioner has been falsely
implicated in the instant case. He next submits that allegation of not taking
care of the order dated 26.07.2005 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 4200 of 2000 of
the High Court is not against the petitioner. He submits that the petitioner
has not passed any order and only the Government has passed the order of
transfer of land in question. He next submits that the said order is of the
year, 2005 whereas the
petitioner has joined in the year, 2008 and the
period of the said order the petitioner was not posted at Hazaribagh and it
was not within the knowledge of the petitioner.
submits that the petitioner may kindly be
On these
grounds, he
granted regular bail. He next
submits that the petitioner is in custody since 13.08.2025. He further submits
that in para 41 to 43 of the counter affidavit, the Anti Corruption Bureau
has stated about the other criminal cases lodged against the petitioner. He
further submits that the word “approval for transfer
of the land by the
petitioner has been mentioned in the para 26 of the counter-affidavit, is not
correct.
On these grounds, he submits that the petitioner may kindly be
granted regular bail.
4.
Per contra, Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel for the Anti
Corruption Bureau vehemently opposes the prayer for grant of regular bail of
the petitioner. He draws the attention of the Court to Annexure-D of the
counter-affidavit which is order passed by the
Chhotanagpur, Division, Hazaribagh
Commissioner, North
and submits that
the lease was
renewed in favour of deity Sri Sri Mahavir Ji from 01.04.1978 to 31.03.2008.
He submits that by way of Annexure-E renewal was granted in favour of
individual “sevayat” in place of deity Sri Sri Mahavir Ji ignoring all earlier
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
records of the case. He further submits that by order dated 08.12.2008 the
approval was granted for substitution of the name of the Sevayat by the
approval of the petitioner. He next submits that in the light of order dated
08.12.2008, the petitioner has recommended the renewal in favour of the
four ‘sevayat’ and forwarded the same for recommendation to the
Government. He further submits that the petitioner has approved
the
renewal of lease to the power of attorney holder namely, Vijay Pratap Singh
and Sudhir Kumar Singh. He next submits that transfer case has been
initiated being Transfer Case No. 01/2009-10 contained in Annexure-F which
was instituted by Smt.Basanti Kumari Sethi and others. He then submits that
by order dated 04.09.2009 the petitioner has recommended for approval of
the transfer of the land to the Government in respect of 23 persons. He
next submits that the petitioner is deeply involved in transaction of Khas
Mahal land. He further submits that Investigating Officer has also examined
the witness and two persons out of 23 persons in whose favour subsequent
transfer of khas mahal land has taken place, have given the specific
statement that through the power of attorney holders, namely, Vijay Pratap
Singh and Sudhir Pratap Singh, the aforesaid persons met the petitioner, who
was the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribagh and the petitioner has
personally assured them that lease can easily be transferred in their names
and accordingly, the said persons have stated that they had agreed to get
the land transferred in their names. He draws the attention of the Court to
para 86 of case diary and submits that this fact has been stated by three of
the purchasers namely, Manish Narayan, Smt. Priti Prasad and Nand Rani
Sinha. He further submits that in course of investigation it has been revealed
that that approximately 5000 acres of land in the district of Hazaribagh have
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
been illegally transacted and the said lands in fact were belonging to and/or
Forest land, Gair Majaruwa Aam, Sarkari Khas Mahal, Kesher-e-hind,
Lakheraj, Trust lands etc. He then submits that entire land scams were done
during the tenure of the petitioner, the then Deputy Commissioner,
Hazaribagh. He further submits that there is huge possibility of surfacing of
transaction of huge amount of illicit money being involved and that fact has
come in para 104-107 of the case diary. He next submits that the petitioner
being a senior IAS officer and custodian of government land records,
exercised enormous administrative control and authority over subordinate
officials of the district administration, revenue and registration departments.
He then submits that
ACB has very genuine apprehension
that if the
petitioner be granted regular bail he will influence the witnesses and tamper
with the documentary evidence and to buttress this argument he draws the
attention of the Court
to supplementary affidavit
filed by the petitioner
particularly annexure-1 series and submits that even the orders which were
in custody of the ACB have been annexed and that orders are not certified
copy of the said orders. He next submits that petitioner being in custody, he
has been able to procure those documents and annexed the same with the
supplementary affidavit which cannot be ruled out that petitioner will not
tamper with the documentary evidences. He next submits that the petitioner
is also involved in another three cases relating to land scam
and
disproportionate assets etc.
5.
Mr. Gadodia further draws the attention of the Court to para 54 of
the Case Diary and submits that Rupees 3.16 crores in cash has been
deposited in the account of Brahmastra Education Private Limited of which
Swapna Sanchita who is wife of the petitioner and
her brother namely,
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
Shipij Trivedi (brother-in-law of Vinay Kumar Choubey) are the directors. On
these grounds, he submits that regular bail of the petitioner may kindly be
rejected.
6.
In view of above submissions of the learned counsel for the
petitioner and learned counsel for the Anti Corruption Bureau, the Court has
gone through the documents brought on record by way of annexing with
this bail application as well as with the counter affidavit and in course of
argument, case diary was also produced before the Court.
7.
The land in question is khas mahal land which settled in favour
of Ganpat Rai Sarawgi and the said Ganpat Rai Sarawgi as settled the same
in the name of deity Sri Sri Mahavir Ji. The said settlement was sought to be
cancelled by the deed of cancellation dated 29.10.1951 which has been
rejected later on by the competent authority
i.e Commissioner, North
Chhotanagpur Division, Hazaribagh. Thereafter, again the renewal application
was filed by Sevayat Pannalal Sethi and again it was renewed in favour of
deity upto 31.03.2008. Thereafter ancestors-in-interest Sevayats have filed
another renewal
application being Renewal
thereafter, it has been renewed in favour of
Case No. 85/2007-08 and
four Sevayats.
The four
sevayats have given the power of attorney to Vijay Pratap Singh and Sudhir
Kumar Singh and through this power of attorney holder all the land was
transferred to 23 persons. Various documents annexed with the petition
which has been noted in the argument of the learned counsel for the Anti
Corruption clearly suggests that the petitioner was instrumental in moving
the file and recommending to the Government for approval of transfer.
8.
The statement of the purchasers under section 180 of BNSS has
been produced before the
Court which is part of the case diary wherein
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
Manish Narayan, Smt. Priti Prasad and Smt. Nandrani Sinha have stated that
Vijay Pratap Singh and Sudhir Kumar Singh have sold the land to twenty
three persons and the purchasers were not having the knowledge of fraud
being done by the power of attorney holder. They have stated that both
power of attorney holders
have stated that they are having the high
connection with the higher officials and they will facilitate everything. They
have also stated that Vijay Pratap Singh and Sudhir Kumar Singh used to
visit the office of the Deputy Commissioner when the petitioner was posted
as Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribagh.
9.
Thus, there are sufficient materials
against the petitioner to
suggest that the petitioner was involved in all these transactions through
different persons.
10.
An IAS officer serves as the District Collector District Magistrate
(DM)/Deputy Commissioner and acts as the government representative for
the district. The officer will coordinate all services and direct the district's
administration.
The District Magistrate/ Deputy Commissioner do focus on the
field and his role includes three major, related functions. First, the officer
serves as the Revenue Head of the district, in charge of all records of land,
revenue, and taxes within the district, including land acquisition.
The second function is of the DM/ Deputy Commissioner to act as
the Executive Magistrate, serving as a direct partner with the police
department in Law & Order and maintaining public peace.
Finally, the DM/ Deputy Commissioner
serves as the district's
Development Leader, organizing all government welfare and infrastructure
projects related to roads, hospitals, and schools to effectively advance
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
development for all citizens.
11.
The petitioner was heading the post of Deputy Commissioner
at the relevant time and
all these transactions have taken place. At this
stage it can be noted that interpreting the provisions of bail contained under
sections 438 & 439 of the Cr.P.C., the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its various
judgments has laid down various considerations for grant or refusal of bail to
an accused in a non-bailable offence like, (i) Whether there is any prima facie
or reasonable ground to believe that the accused had committed the offence;
(ii) Nature of accusation and evidence therefor, (iii) Gravity of the offence and
punishment which the conviction will entail, (iv) Reasonable possibility of
securing presence of the accused at trial and danger of his absconding or
fleeing if released on bail, (v) Character and behavior of the accused, (vi)
Means, position and standing of the accused in the Society, (vii) Likelihood of
the offence being repeated, (viii) Reasonable apprehension of the witnesses
being tampered with, (ix) Danger, of course, of justice being thwarted by
grant of bail, (x) Balance between the rights of the accused and the larger
interest of the Society/State, (xi) Any other factor relevant and peculiar to
the accused. (xii) While a vague allegation that the accused may tamper with
the evidence or witnesses may not be a ground to refuse bail, but if the
accused is of such character that his mere presence at large would intimidate
the witnesses or if there is material to show that he will use his liberty to
subvert justice or tamper with the evidence, then bail will be refused.
12.
Furthermore, in the landmark judgment of Gurucharan Singh
and others v. State, reported in (1978) 1 SCC 118, it was held that
there is no hard and fast rule and no inflexible principle governing the
exercise of such discretion by the courts. It was further held that there
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
cannot be any inexorable formula in the matter of granting ball. In the facts
and circumstances of each case will govern the exercise of judicial discretion
in granting or refusing bail. It was further held that such question depends
upon a variety of circumstances, cumulative effect of which must enter into
the judicial verdict. Such judgment itself mentioned the nature and
seriousness of nature, and circumstances in which offences are committed
apart from character of evidence as some of the relevant factors in deciding
whether to grant bail or not.
13.
In the case of Mallampati Gandhi S/O. Naga Raju vs The
State of Telangana, reported in 2018 SCC Online HYd. 42, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that, "Bail law on economic and white collar offences is
well delineated-and-no-more-res integra. Echoing the concern for economic
offences, which are more dangerous and having far reaching impact on
society than bodily offences, Honble Apex Court and several High Courts
have held that in dealing with such bail applications, Courts are required to
analyze and evaluate certain relevant factors cautiously."
14.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Nimmagadda Prasad
vs. Central Bureau of Investigation, reported in (2013) 7 SCC 466),
has held as under;
"23.Unfortunately, in the last few years, the country has been
seeing an alarming rise in white-collar crimes, which has affected the
fibre of the country's economic structure. Incontrovertibly, economic
offences have serious repercussions on the development of the
country as a whole. In State of Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji
Porwal this Court, while considering a request of the prosecution for
adducing additional evidence, inter alia, observed as under: (SCC
p.371, para 5) #5.....The entire community is aggrieved if the
economic offenders who ruin the economy of the State are not
brought to book. A murder may be committed in the heat of moment
upon passions being aroused. An economic offence is committed with
cool calculation and deliberate design with an eye on personal profit
regardless of the consequence to the community. A disregard for the
interest of the community can be manifested only at the cost of
forfeiting the trust and faith of the community in the system to
administer justice in an even-handed manner without fear of criticism
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
from the quarters which view white-collar crimes with a permissive
eye unmindful of the damage done to the national economy and
national interest.
25. Economic offences constitute a class apart and need to be
visited with a different approach in the matter of bail. The economic
offence having deep rooted conspiracies and involving huge loss of
public funds needs to be viewed seriously and considered as a grave
offence affecting the economy of the country as a whole and thereby
posing serious threat to the financial health of the country.”
15.
Further looking into para 54 of the Case Diary it transpires that
Rupees 3.16 crores in cash has been deposited in the account of Brahmastra
Education Private Limited
of which Swapna Sanchita who is wife of the
petitioner and her brother Shipij
Trivedi
(brother-in-law of Vinay Kumar
Choubey) are the directors.
16.
So far the argument of the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
with regard to ignoring the order of the High Court passed in C.W.J.C No.
4200 of 2000 is concerned, that cannot be accepted in view of the fact that
the petitioner being head of the administration
particularly
of revenue
record was not able to see the order of the High Court, the said submission
appears to be misconceived.
17.
In the light of above discussions noted hereinabove and coming to
the facts of the present case it transpires that the petitioner while working
as
Deputy Commissioner and has done various irregularities by allotting
various government lands to the interested persons. The petitioner has
shown undue favour
to the
persons in whose favour the land was
transferred. The petitioner has abused the power of his post and position.
18.
The supplementary affidavit has been filed by the petitioner
wherein annexure-1 series are the
orders passed relating to the said
transfer. The said orders are not certified copy. The petitioner is in custody
and inspite of that those orders have been annexed with the supplementary
( 2026:JHHC:99 )
affidavit which clearly suggests that petitioner can tamper with the evidence
and this fact itself fortifies the apprehension of the Anti Corruption Bureau
that petitioner can tamper with the evidence being senior IAS officer of the
State of Jharkhand.
19.
Thus, considering the overall materials on record and the role
attributed to this petitioner, the gravity and seriousness of the offence
committed by the petitioner as he is sitting over the highest post of the
Government, he can tamper with the evidence if he is granted regular bail.
Further in course of argument
it has been pointed out by the learned
counsel for the Anti Corruption Bureau that Sevayats are not cooperating in
the investigation being done by the ACB and investigating against Sevayats is
pending.
20.
It has been noticed that in recent times there was increase in
socio-economic offences in the country. These are the offences which are
solely committed for personal gains. These crimes are affecting every part of
the country’s economic structure and wrecking the people’s faith in the
system.
21.
In the following circumstances, if the person is very influential
and there is every chance to mislead the case, in such cases bail should not
be granted.
22.
In view of what has been discussed hereinabove, the present
bail application fails and is hereby rejected at this stage. Pending I.A, if any,
stands dismissed.
( Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.)
Dt.06.01.2026
Satyarthi/-A.F.R.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review