Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31849
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
FRIDAY, THE 11TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 21ST CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(CRL.) NO. 162 OF 2025
PETITIONER:
VILASINI RAMACHANDRAN
AGED 61 YEARS
W/O RAMACHANDRAN, KALLIDUMBIL HOUSE,
NEDUNGAPRA P.O, VENGOOR, ERNAKULAM - 683545
BY ADVS.
M.H.HANIS
T.N.LEKSHMI SHANKAR
NANCY MOL P.
ANANDHU P.C.
NEETHU.G.NADH
RIA ELIZABETH T.J.
SINISHA JOSHY
SAHAD M. HANIS
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO
GOVERNMENT, HOME AND VIGILANCE DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM- 695001
THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR & DISTRICT MAGISTRATE
CIVIL STATION, ERNAKULAM - 682030
THE DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF
REVENUE TOWER, ERNAKULAM - 682035
THE CHAIRMAN
ADVISORY BOARD, KAAPA, SREENIVAS, PADAM ROAD, VIVEKANANDA
NAGAR, ELAMAKKARA ERNAKULAM - 682026
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF JAIL
CENTRAL JAIL, VIYYUR, THRISSUR - 670004
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:2:
2025:KER:31849
BY ADVS.
ADVOCATE GENERAL OFFICE KERALA
ADDL.DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PROSECUTION(AG-11)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 10.04.2025, THE COURT ON 11.04.2025 DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:3:
2025:KER:31849
JUDGMENT
Jobin Sebastian, J.
This writ petition has been directed against an order of detention
dated 28.12.2024 passed against one Amal, S/o. Ramachandran, under
Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007
(‘KAA(P) Act’ for brevity). The petitioner herein is the mother of the
detenu. Upon considering the opinion of the Advisory Board, the
Government vide order dated 17.02.2025 has confirmed the order and the
son of the petitioner has been ordered to be detained for a period of one
year.
2.
The records reveal that a proposal was submitted by the
District Police Chief, Ernakulam, seeking initiation of proceedings under
Section 3(1) r/w 13(2)(i) of the KAA(P) Act before the jurisdictional
authority. For the purpose of initiation of the said proceedings, the detenu
was classified as a 'known rowdy' as defined under Section 2(p)(iii) of the
KAA(P) Act.
For passing the order of detention the authority reckoned
eight cases in which the detenu got involved. The case registered with
respect to the last prejudicial activity is Crime No.1114/2024 of
Kuruppampady Police Station alleging the commission of offences
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:4:
2025:KER:31849
punishable under Sections 127(2), 351 r/w 3(5) of Bharatiya Nyaya
Sanhita (for short “BNS”).
3.
We heard Sri.M.H.Hanis, the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and Sri. K.A. Anas, the learned Government Pleader.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the
impugned order was passed by the jurisdictional authority without proper
application of mind and without arriving at the requisite objective as well
as subjective satisfaction.
According to the counsel after passing the
impugned order of detention, the jurisdictional authority did not forward
the order to the Government forthwith and the said lapses itself will vitiate
the impugned order. The learned counsel further submitted that the above
action of the jurisdictional authority is violative of the provision contained
under Section 3(3) of the KAA(P) Act.
According to the counsel, the
sponsoring authority forwarded the proposal on the basis of a report
submitted by the SHO of Kuruppampady Police Station. But, as there were
some shortcomings in the said report, in order to undo the same, another
report was forwarded by the SHO.
However, the copy of the said
additional report was not served on the detenu.
The learned counsel
further submitted that, though on behalf of the detenu, he prepared a
representation for being forwarded to the Government and sent to the Jail
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:5:
2025:KER:31849
Superintendent concerned, the latter in turn sent back the said
representation to the counsel for the petitioner himself without sending
the same to the Government. According to the counsel, the said
malfeasance on the part of the Jail Superintendent will seriously affect the
constitutional as well as statutory right of the detenu and the impugned
order is liable to be set aside on the said sole ground.
5.
In response, the learned Government Pleader would submit that
the order of detention impugned by way of this writ petition was passed
by the jurisdictional authority after proper application of mind. According
to him the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
copy of the impugned order was not forthwith forwarded to the
Government is baseless. The learned Government Pleader submitted that
the failure to serve the detenu with a copy of the SHO’s additional report is
of minimal consequence, as the jurisdictional authority did not rely on that
report in issuing the impugned order, but instead based its decision on the
proposal submitted by the Superintendent of Police. The learned
Government Pleader fairly conceded that the representation prepared on
behalf of the detenu by his counsel and sent to the Jail Superintendent,
which was meant for forwarding to the Government, was sent back to the
counsel for the petitioner. But this was done at the detenu’s own request.
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:6:
2025:KER:31849
Moreover, another representation, which is the verbatim reproduction of
the representation sent to the Jail Superintendent, was duly forwarded to
the Advisory Board by the mother of the detenu who is the petitioner in
this writ petition.
Hence, as the matter was already seized of by the
Advisory Board if at all the representation was forwarded to the
Government, the latter could not act upon it and had to wait till the
opinion of the Advisory Board was obtained. According to the learned
Government Pleader, therefore no prejudice is caused to the detenu due to
the non-forwarding of the representation to the Government.
6.
The records reveal that the detenu was classified as a “known
rowdy”, considering his recurrent involvement in eight cases. The last case
registered against the detenu is Crime No.1114/2024 of Kuruppampady
Police Station, alleging the commission of the offences punishable under
Sections 127(2), 351 r/w 3(5) of BNS. The detenu, who is arrayed as the
1st accused in the said case was arrested on 19.10.2024. As all offences
alleged in the said case are bailable in nature, he was released on bail on
the same day itself. However, when he was arrested in connection with
the last prejudicial activity, his arrest was recorded in the last previous
crime registered against him as Crime No.1093/2024 and he was enlarged
on bail in the said case on 15.11.2024. It was on 04.12.2014, the
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:7:
2025:KER:31849
Superintendent of Police, Ernakulam forwarded the proposal for initiation
of proceedings under the KAA(P) Act against the detenu. Subsequently,
the detention order was passed on 28.12.2024 without any unreasonable
delay. The sequence of the events clearly demonstrates that there is no
delay either in mooting the proposal as well as in passing the impugned
order. Therefore, the detenu could not be heard to say that the live link
between the last prejudicial activity and the purpose of detention was
snapped.
7.
While coming to the various contentions pressed into service
from the side of the learned counsel for the petitioner, it can be seen that
one of the contentions is that, after passing the impugned order, the
jurisdictional authority failed to forward the copy of the detention order to
the Government undermining the provisions contained under Section 3(3)
of the KAA(P) Act. We do agree that it is a statutory obligation of the
jurisdictional authority to forward the detention order forthwith to the
Government for approval.
However, a bare perusal of the order itself
reveals that a copy of the impugned order is duly marked to the
Government. In the absence of any contra materials, it could not be found
that the order was not communicated to the Government forthwith.
Therefore, the only conclusion that can be arrived at is that the contention
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:8:
2025:KER:31849
of the detenu regarding the non-forwarding of the copy of the order
forthwith to the Government is baseless.
8.
According to the counsel, the sponsoring authority mooted the
proposal for the initiation of proceedings under the KAA(P) Act against the
detenu on the basis of a report submitted by the SHO of Kuruppampady
Police Station. But, as there were some shortcomings in the said report, in
order to remedy the same, an additional report was forwarded by the
SHO. However, the copy of the said additional report was not served on
the detenu. We are cognizant that it is incumbent upon the jurisdictional
authority to serve the copy of the detention order as well as the grounds
of detention to the detenu along with the documents relied upon by it in
passing the order. As evident from the records, it was after obtaining the
report of the SHO concerned, that the sponsoring authority i.e. the
Superintendent of Police Ernakulam, forwarded the proposal to the
jurisdictional authority to initiate proceedings under KAA(P) Act. Moreover,
it is gatherable that on verification of the initial report of the SHO, some
shortcomings were noted by the Superintendent of Police and accordingly,
an additional report was also submitted by the SHO to undo the flaws in
the earlier reports. It was after considering the said report, the
Superintendent of Police mooted the proposal. Anyhow, it was not on the
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:9:
2025:KER:31849
basis of the report of the SHO, the jurisdictional authority acted upon. On
the other hand, it was on the basis of the proposal submitted by the
Superintendent of Police, the jurisdictional authority ventured to pass the
impugned order of detention. Even the detenu is not having a case that
the copy of the proposal submitted by the Superintendent of Police was
not served on him. In short, it is liable to be held that the non-service of
the copy of the additional report of SHO is of little significance particularly
when the same is not a relied upon document.
9.
Another contention taken by the learned counsel for the detenu
is that, on behalf of the detenu he prepared a representation for being
forwarded to the Government and sent the said representation to the Jail
Superintendent concerned for forwarding the same after obtaining the
signature of the detenu. However, instead of forwarding the same to the
Government, the Jail Superintendent sent back the said representation to
the counsel for the detenu. According to the learned counsel, the said
malfeasance on the part of the Jail Superintendent will certainly affect the
constitutional as well as statutory right of the detenu. We do agree that it
is an indefeasible right of a detenu to file representations before the
Government as well as the Advisory Board challenging an order of
detention passed against him. Therefore, the Jail Superintendent ought to
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:10:
2025:KER:31849
have forwarded the representation sent to him by the counsel for the
detenu to the Government after obtaining the signature of the detenu.
The covering letter addressed to the Jail Superintendent and the postal
receipts produced by the learned counsel for the detenu reveal that a
representation was duly sent to the Jail Superintendent for forwarding the
same to the Government. Nevertheless, the said representation was sent
back by the Jail Superintendent to the counsel for the detenu after
obtaining the detenu’s signature, instead of sending the same to the
Government. The said fact is evident from the postal cover and the copy
of the representation which contains the signature of the detenu pressed
into
service
by
the
learned
afore-mentioned
postal
receipt,
counsel
for
covering
the
letter
petitioner.
as
well
The
as
the
representation bearing the signature of the accused, which is handed over
by the counsel for the petitioner at the time of hearing of this petition and
the genuineness of which is not disputed by the Government Pleader shall
form part of the record of this case.
10.
Now the crucial question to be considered is whether the said
lapses will infringe the constitutional right of the detenu.
While
considering the said question, it is to be noted that, a representation
which is the verbatim reproduction of the representation prepared by the
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:11:
2025:KER:31849
counsel for the accused for being forwarded to the Government, was sent
to the Advisory Board directly by the mother of the detenu who is the
petitioner in this writ petition. After considering the said representation
the Advisory Board formed an opinion. The said opinion was forwarded to
the Government with the representation addressed to the Advisory Board.
The Government in the matter of approving the detention considered the
representation forwarded by the Advisory Board as if it is one addressed to
the Government. Thereafter, the Government independently considered
the representation and the fate of the representation was communicated
to the detenu. Hence it cannot be said that the constitutional right of the
detenu is infringed in any manner.
More pertinently, even if the
representation was received by the Government, the Government could
not have considered it, as the matter was already seized by the Advisory
Board. Therefore, we are of the considered view that the detenu was in
no way prejudiced by the malfeasance on the part of the jail
Superintendent in sending back the representation to the counsel for the
detenu instead of forwarding the same to the Government.
11.
From a perusal of the records, we are satisfied that all the
necessary procedural requirements before passing an order under Section
3(1) of the KAA(P) Act have been scrupulously complied with in this case.
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:12:
2025:KER:31849
We are further satisfied that the competent authority passed the detention
order after thoroughly verifying all the materials placed by the sponsoring
authority and after arriving at the requisite objective and subjective
satisfaction. Therefore, it cannot be said that the order passed under
Section 3(1) of the KAA(P) Act is vitiated in any manner.
In view of the discussion above, we hold that the petitioner has not
made out any case for interference.
Hence, the writ petition stands
dismissed.
Sd/P.B. SURESH KUMAR
JUDGE
Sd/JOBIN SEBASTIAN
JUDGE
ANS
W.P.(Crl.) No. 162 of 2025
:13:
2025:KER:31849
APPENDIX OF WP(CRL.) 162/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.DCEKM/12936/2024/M7 DATED
28.12.2024 F THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 04.02.2025
SUBMITTED BY THE DETENU BEFORE THE 1ST RESPONDENT
Exhibit P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 04.02.2025
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P4
A TRUE COPY OF THE POSTAL RECEIPT EVIDENCING THE
ISSUANCE OF EXT P3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review