Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~P-1 & 2
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 23.02.2026
Pronounced on: 19.03.2026
Uploaded on: 19.03.2026
+
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025
MANJAY KUMAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Aditya Aggarwal and Mr.
Naveen Panwar, Advocates.
versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI
Through:
+
.....Respondent
Mr. Tarang Srivastava, APP with
ASI Yashpal Singh.
BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
VIKAS KUMAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Aditya Aggarwal and Mr.
Naveen Panwar, Advocates.
versus
STATE GNCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Tarang Srivastava, APP with
ASI Yashpal Singh.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRATEEK JALAN
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioners seek regular bail in connection with FIR
No.133/2025 dated 05.03.2025, registered at Police Station Civil Lines,
District North, New Delhi, for offences punishable under Sections 20 and
29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 [“NDPS
Act”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
A.
PROSECUTION CASE
2.
The case of the prosecution is as follows:
a. Upon receipt of information, three persons, including the
petitioners herein and co-accused Kushindra Kumar, were
apprehended on 04.03.2025 at 06:40 PM. Notices under Section 50
of the NDPS Act were served upon them. They refused to undergo
personal search before the nearest Gazetted Officer or Magistrate.
b. During their personal search, a total of 1,955 grams of ganja was
recovered – 677.9 grams [inclusive of weight of a white opaque
polythene] was recovered from accused Manjay Kumar [petitioner
in BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025], and 1,277.1 grams [inclusive of
weight of a transparent polythene] was recovered from accused
Vikas Kumar [petitioner in BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025]. A seizure
memo dated 04.03.2025 was prepared.
c. During the course of further investigation, the accused persons
disclosed that a large quantity of ganja was kept at their rented
house in Andha Mughal, Pratap Nagar, Delhi. The petitioners
herein further revealed that two parcels containing ganja were
lying at Mark Express Courier Company, Jhandewalan, Delhi, and
that they had procured the recovered ganja from one Manoj
Pradhan, who is a resident of Odisha.
d. The search of House No. 62, Ground Floor, J-Block, Katra Khema
No. 4, Andha Mughal, Kishanganj, Delhi, was conducted at the
instance of the petitioners and co-accused Kushindra Kumar. Five
packets and one polythene containing a total of 12,882.8 grams of
ganja were recovered, and a seizure memo dated 04.03.2025 was
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
prepared. One Nokia mobile phone and five Aadhaar cards,
belonging to four different persons, were also recovered. Two of
the Aadhaar cards were in the name of Ankit Kumar Singh, but
contained photographs of different individuals, including one
photograph of accused Vikas Kumar.
e. Thereafter, a raid was conducted at Mark Express Private Limited,
2E/10, Jhandewalan Extension, Delhi, and two parcels, each
containing nine packets, with 18.700 kilograms and 18.450
kilograms of ganja respectively, were recovered in two separate
boxes, described as “Khaki Gatta Petis”. The slips on the parcels
bore the same mobile number as recovered from the rented
accommodation. They listed a fake name “Deepak Kumar”, used
by accused Manjay Kumar, as the consignee. A seizure memo
dated 05.03.2025 was prepared.
f. The mobile phones of the petitioners herein and co-accused
Kushindra Kumar were seized during investigation, and the Call
Detail Records of their mobile numbers were obtained. These
records showed that the locations of their mobile phones
corresponded to both the spot of the initial seizure, and the rented
accommodation.
g. It was further revealed that the petitioners were in regular contact
with one Manoj Pradhan. The bank statements of the petitioners,
co-accused Kushindra Kumar, and Manoj Pradhan were obtained,
which revealed that sums of Rs. 1,00,000/- from each of the
petitioners, were transferred on 24.11.2024 to the account of Manoj
Pradhan, and a further amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- was transferred
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
from the account of accused Vikas Kumar on 03.12.2024 to the
same account.
h. A raid was conducted at the house of co-accused Manoj Pradhan,
who was found absconding and failed to join the investigation,
despite service of notices under Section 67 of the NDPS Act.
Accordingly, non-bailable warrants have been issued against him.
i. On 18.03.2025, all the sealed parcels of the recovered contraband
were produced before the learned Magistrate’s Court for sampling
proceedings under Section 52A of the NDPS Act. Samples were
drawn from each packet/polythene, and were sent to the Forensic
Science Laboratory [“FSL”]. As per the FSL report dated
13.02.2026, which was handed up in Court during the hearing on
23.02.2026, all five exhibits tested positive for the presence of
ganja.
Mr. Tarang
Srivastava,
learned
Additional
Public
Prosecutor, stated that the FSL report will be filed before the
Special Court alongwith a supplementary chargesheet.
j. The original rent agreement/lease deed of the rented house in
which the petitioners were residing was taken into police custody,
and the owner of the house was examined. She informed that
accused Vikas Kumar and Manjay Kumar had introduced
themselves as Ankit Kumar Singh and Deepak Kumar,
respectively.
k. The chargesheet was filed before the Special Court on 18.08.2025,
but investigation regarding the source of the recovered contraband
is still ongoing.
l. The present case thus involves 51.937 kilograms of ganja, which
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
amounts to a commercial quantity.
3.
On this basis, it is contended that the petitioners were involved in
illicit drug trafficking. They were both arrested on 05.03.2025.
B.
SUBMISSIONS BY LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES
4.
I have heard Mr. Aditya Aggarwal, learned counsel for the
petitioners, and Mr. Tarang Srivastava, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor.
5.
Although several contentions have been raised in the bail
applications, Mr. Aggarwal pressed only two of them at this stage:
a. He submitted that the sampling procedure adopted by the
prosecution was not in consonance with the provisions of Section
52A of the NDPS Act, thereby rendering the recovery doubtful.
b. He submitted that the recovered substance does not constitute
ganja at all, in terms of the definition contained in Section 2(iii)(b)
of the NDPS Act.
6.
With regard to the first submission, Mr. Aggarwal submitted as
follows:
a. The present prosecution is based upon three distinct recoveries: [i]
spot recovery of 677 grams from accused Manjay Kumar, and
1,277 grams from accused Vikas Kumar; [ii] 12.882 kilograms in
six packets, recovered from the flat allegedly rented by the
petitioners; and [iii] 18.700 kilograms and 18.450 kilograms
allegedly recovered from nine packets each, contained in two
courier parcels.
b. The seizure memo in respect of the recovery from the flat rented by
the petitioners shows that the substance was in a blue-coloured bag
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
and five packets, all of which were packed in a khaki-coloured
pasting polythene. Each of the aforesaid bags/packets were
separately weighed, and then kept in a white-coloured plastic bag
marked as “Mark D”.
c. The seizure memo in respect of the recovery from the courier
similarly reveals that there were two cardboard boxes which,
alongwith their contents, weighed 20.40 kilograms and 20.70
kilograms respectively. The first box contained nine plastic
packets. The nine packets were kept together in a single container,
weighing 18.700 kilograms, and marked as “Mark P1”. Similarly,
nine packets were found in the second cardboard box, which were
collectively weighed at 18.450 kilograms. These packets were
thereafter placed in a single container, and marked as “Mark P2”.
d. The samples were drawn on 18.03.2025 in proceedings conducted
before the learned Magistrate.
e. As far as the recoveries from the flat and the courier parcels are
concerned, Rule 10 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances (Seizure, Storage, Sampling and Disposal) Rules, 2022
[“Sampling Rules”], required that, two samples of 100 grams each
be drawn from each of the packets/bags. In violation of this
requirement, samples of 200 grams each were, in fact, drawn
collectively from Marks D, P1, and P2.
f. Violation of the aforesaid Rule renders the sampling process
defective, and casts serious doubt upon the consequent testing of
the samples.
7.
In support of the second argument, Mr. Aggarwal submitted as
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
follows:
a. Section 2(iii)(b) of the NDPS Act, defines “ganja” as “the
flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant (excluding the
seeds and leaves when not accompanied by the tops)”.
b. In the present case, however, the FIR and the seizure memos
contain reference to the substances comprising of dried branches,
grass-like substances and leaves, but not to “flowering or fruiting
tops”, which is essential to satisfy the requirement of the definition
itself.
c. The identification of the seized substance as “ganja” is, therefore,
seriously disputed.
8.
As far as Mr. Aggarwal’s first argument is concerned, Mr.
Srivastava submitted that, under Rule 10(2) of the Sampling Rules,
drawing of one sample from multiple packages may be permissible in
certain factual circumstances. In any event, he argued that the question of
violation of Section 52A of the NDPS Act is not a relevant consideration
at the stage of grant of bail.
9.
Regarding the second aspect, Mr. Srivastava submitted that the
FSL report dated 13.02.2026, received during the pendency of the
captioned bail applications, a copy of which was handed up in Court
during the hearing on 23.02.2026, clearly referred to each packet as
containing “Dried brownish green colour vegetative material having
flowering and fruiting tops”.
10.
Learned counsel on both sides referred to several judgments of the
Supreme Court and this Court in support of their respective contentions,
to which I shall refer at the appropriate stage in this judgment.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
C.
ANALYSIS REGARDING SAMPLING PROCEDURE
11.
Rules 9 to 11 of the Sampling Rules, relied upon by Mr. Aggarwal,
are relevant for the purposes of the present judgment. They read as
follows:
“9. Samples to be drawn in the presence of Magistrate. – After
application to the Magistrate under sub-section (2) of section 52A of
the Act is made, the Investigating Officer shall ensure that samples of
the seized material are drawn in the presence of the Magistrate and the
same is certified by the magistrate in accordance with the provisions of
the said-sub-section.
10. Drawing the samples. – (1) One sample, in duplicate, shall be
drawn from each package and container seized.
(2)
When the packages and containers seized together are of
identical size and weight bearing identical marking and the contents
of each package give identical results on colour test by the drugs
identification kit, conclusively indicating that the packages are
identical in all respects, the packages and containers may carefully
be bunched in lots of not more than ten packages or containers, and
for each such lot of packages and containers, one sample, in
duplicate, shall be drawn:
Provided that in the case of ganja, poppy straw and hashish
(charas) it may be bunched in lots of not more than fourty packages or
containers.
(3)
In case of drawing sample from a particular lot, it shall be
ensured that representative sample in equal quantity is taken from
each package or container of that lot and mixed together to make a
composite whole from which the samples are drawn for that lot.
11. Quantity to be drawn for sampling. – (1) Except in cases of opium,
ganja and charas (hashish), where a quantity of not less than twentyfour grams shall be drawn for each sample, in all other cases not less
than five grams shall be drawn for each sample and the same quantity
shall be taken for the duplicate sample.
(2)
The seized substances in the packages or containers shall be
well mixed to make it homogeneous and representative before the
sample, in duplicate, is drawn.
(3)
In case where seized quantities is less than that required for
sampling, the whole of the seized quantity may be sent.”1
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
12.
The factual position, with regard to the recoveries and sampling in
the present case, is largely undisputed. Details regarding the number of
packets in each recovered parcel, and the manner in which sampling was
carried out, emerge from the seizure memos and the proceedings before
the learned Magistrate on 18.03.2025. Mr. Srivastava has also handed up
a tabular statement identifying the quantity of sample taken from each
packet, which is reproduced below:
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
13.
Mr. Aggarwal contended that Rules 10 and 11 of the Sampling
Rules, read together, require two samples to be drawn from “each
package and container seized”. The only exception provided under Rule
10(2) of the Sampling Rules arises when the packages and containers are
of identical size and weight, bearing identical marks, and the contents of
each package yield identical results on the colour test using the drug
identification kit. This factual position is admittedly not satisfied in the
present case.
14.
Proceeding on the basis of the tabular statement reproduced above,
which was handed up by the prosecution itself, it is clear that samples of
approximately 200 grams each were taken from Parcel A and Parcel B,
which where the spot recoveries from the two petitioners. No ground
under Section 52A has been raised in respect of these samples. It may be
noted, however, that these samples by themselves constitute far less than
20 kilograms, which is the commercial quantity of ganja under the NDPS
Act. Taken by themselves, therefore, these samples would not attract the
rigours of Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
15.
We, therefore, turn to the sampling in respect of parcels marked D,
P1, and P2, which were the recoveries from the petitioners’ flat and the
two courier parcels. Each of these contained multiple smaller parcels –
six in the case of Mark D, and nine each in the case of Marks P1 and P2.
The tabular statement shows that the total quantity drawn from each of
the three parcels was collectively in the region of 200 grams, which is
corroborated by the sampling order.
16.
The table also shows that, while drawing samples from each of the
constituent packets, the quantities drawn were fairly random. For
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
example, 4.9 grams was drawn from parcel D1, which weighed 5932.3
grams, whereas 49 grams was drawn from parcel D6, which weighed
only 512.2 grams. Similarly, although each of the packets in parcels P1
and P2 weighed approximately the same, the samples drawn ranged from
15.7 grams to 39.4 grams in parcel P1, and from 8.8 grams to 48.5 grams
in parcel P2.
17.
It prima facie appears that this method of sampling does not
conform to the requirements of the Sampling Rules. Samples were to be
drawn from each packet or container, but appear to have been drawn
collectively from several packets, which were recovered in a single larger
container or package.
18.
In several orders of this Court, relied upon by Mr. Aggarwal, bail
has been granted, despite the application of Section 37 of the NDPS Act,
on similar grounds. Reference has been made in those orders to Standing
Order No. 1/1988, which laid down the sampling procedure prior to
framing of the Sampling Rules. Some of the said orders are as follows:
a. In Gopal Das v. NCB2, mixing of contents of packets was held to
be contrary to the procedure, thereby entitling the accused to bail.
b. In Ahmad Hassan Muhammed v. The Customs3 also, a coordinate
Bench of this Court specifically held that mixing of packets for the
purposes of sampling is not permissible.
c. In Laxman Thakur v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)4, the Standing
Order was held to be a requirement of law, and it was held that
mixing of various packets into one, and drawing a sample from the
BAIL APPLN. 3491/2020, decided on 04.02.2021; paragraph 8.
BAIL APPLN. 3076/2020, decided on 11.02.2021.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
mixture, was not permissible.
d. In Sarvan v. State Govt. of NCT of Delhi5, samples were taken from
some of the packets in the parcel, but not from others, which was
held to constitute a violation of the sampling procedure.
e. In Sachin Kumar v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)6, samples were
taken from each “katta”, but not from each of the parcels therein.
f. In Aas Mohammad v. State Govt. of NCT of Delhi7 also, the
recovery consisted of 43 kattas containing 281 bundles. Samples
were not drawn from each bundle, but only from 43 kattas as a
whole.
19.
Mr. Srivastava sought to distinguish these judgments, on the basis
that the sampling in the present case, was conducted from separate
packets, and the contents of the packets were never mixed prior to
drawing the sample. This factual submission also aligns with the order of
the Magistrate and the fact that separate sample weights from each packet
have been identified. Nonetheless, I do not find any significant difference
between the aforesaid cases and the present case on this basis. The
requirement that samples be drawn from each packet is intended to ensure
that the packets containing the narcotics or contraband can be specifically
identified. By mixing the contents prior to sampling, this objective is
defeated. However, the case is no different if random samples are drawn
from each packet separately and mixed before testing, as has occurred in
the present case. Such a procedure also results in the prosecution’s
BAIL APPLN. 3233/2022, decided on 14.12.2022; paragraphs 8 to 11.
BAIL APPLN 2781/2022, decided on 18.01.2023.
BAIL APPLN. 557/2023, decided on 26.04.2023.
BAIL APPLN 2334/2023, decided on 20.03.2024.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
inability to quantify the contraband substance with precision. It may be
argued that some of the individual smaller packets contained the
contraband substance, while others did not, but the mixing of the samples
has led to the entire quantity being misidentified as ganja.
20.
In this factual background, learned counsel on both sides drew my
attention to certain recent judgments of the Supreme Court, which
consider the effect of non-compliance with Section 52A of the NDPS
Act.
21.
The judgments, cited in chronological order, are discussed below:
a. In Narcotics Control Bureau v. Kashif8, the Supreme Court held
that delay or non-compliance with Section 52A cannot be treated
as an illegality entitling the accused to be released on bail or claim
acquittal. Relying upon a purposive interpretation of the statute and
the provisions of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, the Court observed
that Section 52A was intended to ensure the early disposal of
seized contraband, drugs, and substances, but a lapse or delay in
compliance would constitute a procedural irregularity, rather than
vitiating the trial or entitling the accused to bail. The Court noted
that other circumstances and evidence would have to be considered
in order to determine the issue.
b. The judgment in Bharat Aambale v. State of Chhattisgarh9 also
involved the alleged mixing of the contents of various packets prior
to sampling, which led the accused to appeal against his
conviction. While upholding the conviction, the Supreme Court
(2024) 11 SCC 372, decided on 20.12.2024 [hereinafter, “Kashif”].
(2025) 8 SCC 452, decided on 06.01.2025 [hereinafter, “Bharat Aambale”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
considered several judgments, including Kashif, and observed as
follows:
“33. Thus, from above it is clear that the procedure prescribed
by the Standing Order(s)/Rules in terms of Section 52-A of the
NDPS Act is only intended to guide the officers and to ensure
that a fair procedure is adopted by the officer in charge of the
investigation, and as such what is required is substantial
compliance of the procedure laid therein.
33.1. We say so because, due to varying circumstances, there
may be situations wherein it may not always be possible to
forward the seized contraband immediately for the purpose of
sampling. This could be due to various factors, such as the sheer
volume of the contraband, the peculiar nature of the place of
seizure, or owing to the volatility of the substance so seized that
may warrant slow and safe handling. There could be situations
where such contraband after being sampled cannot be preserved
due to its hazardous nature and must be destroyed forthwith or
vice-versa where the nature of the case demands that they are
preserved and remain untouched. Due to such multitude of
possibilities or situations, neither can the police be realistically
expected to rigidly adhere to the procedure laid down in Section
52-A or its allied Rules/Orders, nor can a straitjacket formula be
applied for insisting compliance of each procedure in a specified
timeline to the letter, due to varying situations or requirements
of each case.
33.2. Thus, what is actually required is only a substantial
compliance of the procedure laid down under Section 52-A of
the NDPS Act and the Standing Order(s)/Rules framed
thereunder, and any discrepancy or deviation in the same may
lead the court to draw an adverse inference against the police
as per the facts of each and every case.
34. When it comes to the outcome of trial, it is only after taking a
cumulative view of the entire material on record including such
discrepancies, that the court should proceed either to convict or
acquit the accused. Non- compliance of the procedure envisaged
under Section 52-A may be fatal only in cases where such noncompliance goes to the heart or root of the matter.
34.1. In other words, the discrepancy should be such that it
renders the entire case of the prosecution doubtful, such as
instances where there are significant discrepancies in the
colour or description of the substance seized from that
indicated in the FSL report as was the case in Noor Aga [Noor
Aga v. State of Punjab, (2008) 16 SCC 417: (2010) 3 SCC (Cri)
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
748], or where the contraband was mixed in and stored with
some other commodity like vegetables and there is no credible
indication of whether the narcotic substance was separated and
then weighed as required under the Standing Order(s) or
Rules, thereby raising doubts over the actual quantity seized as
was the case in Mohd. Khalid [Mohd. Khalid v. State of
Telangana, (2024) 5 SCC 393: (2024) 2 SCC (Cri) 650], or
where the recovery itself is suspicious and uncorroborated by
any witnesses such as in Mangilal [Mangilal v. State of M.P.,
(2023) 19 SCC 364], or where the bulk material seized in
contravention of Section 52-A was not produced before the court
despite being directed to be preserved, etc.
34.2. These illustrations are only for the purposes of bringing
clarity on what may constitute as a significant discrepancy in a
given case, and by no means is either exhaustive in nature or
supposed to be applied mechanically in any proceeding under
the NDPS Act. It is for the courts to see what constitutes as a
significant discrepancy, keeping in mind the peculiar facts, the
materials on record and the evidence adduced.
34.3. At the same time, we may caution the courts, not to be
hypertechnical whilst looking into the discrepancies that may
exist, like slight differences in the weight, colour or numbering of
the sample, etc. The court may not discard the entire prosecution
case looking into such discrepancies as more often than not
ordinarily an officer in a public place would not be carrying a
good scale with him, as held in Noor Aga.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
37. Thus, the prosecution sans the compliance of the procedure
under Section 52-A of the NDPS Act will not render itself
helpless but can still prove the seizure or recovery of contraband
by leading cogent evidence in this regard such as by examining
the seizing officer, producing independent witnesses to the
recovery, or presenting the original quantity of seized substances
before the court. The evidentiary value of these materials is
ultimately to be assessed and looked into by the court. The court
should consider whether the evidence inspires confidence. The
court should look into the totality of circumstances and the
credibility of the witnesses, being mindful to be more cautious
in their scrutiny where such procedure has been flouted. The
cumulative effect of all evidence must be considered to
determine whether the prosecution has successfully established
the case beyond reasonable doubt as held in Noor Aga.
38. Even in cases where there is non-compliance with the
procedural requirements of Section 52-A, it does not necessarily
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
vitiate the trial or warrant an automatic acquittal. The courts
have consistently held that procedural lapses must be viewed in
the context of the overall evidence. If the prosecution can
otherwise establish the chain of custody, corroborate the seizure
with credible testimony, and prove its case beyond reasonable
doubt, the mere non-compliance with Section 52-A may not be
fatal. The emphasis must be on substantive justice rather than
procedural technicalities, and keeping in mind that the salutary
objective of the NDPS Act is to curb the menace of drug
trafficking.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
40. What this provision entails is that, where the seized
substance after being forwarded to the officer empowered is
inventoried, photographed and thereafter samples are drawn
therefrom as per the procedure prescribed under the said
provision and the Rules/Standing Order(s), and the same is
also duly certified by a Magistrate, then such certified
inventory, photographs and samples have to mandatorily be
treated as primary evidence. The use of the word “shall”
indicates that it would be mandatory for the court to treat the
same as primary evidence if twin conditions are fulfilled being:
(i) that the inventory, photographs and samples drawn are
certified by the Magistrate, AND (ii) that the court is satisfied
that the entire process was done in consonance and substantial
compliance with the procedure prescribed under the provision
and its Rules/Standing Order(s).
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
56. We summarise our final conclusion as under:
56.1. Although Section 52-A is primarily for the disposal and
destruction of seized contraband in a safe manner yet it extends
beyond the immediate context of drug disposal, as it serves a
broader purpose of also introducing procedural safeguards in
the treatment of narcotics substance after seizure inasmuch as it
provides for the preparation of inventories, taking of
photographs of the seized substances and drawing samples
therefrom in the presence and with the certification of a
Magistrate. Mere drawing of samples in the presence of a
gazetted officer would not constitute sufficient compliance of the
mandate under Section 52-A sub-section (2) of the NDPS Act.
56.2. Although, there is no mandate that the drawing of samples
from the seized substance must take place at the time of seizure
as held in Mohanlal [Union of India v. Mohanlal, (2016) 3 SCC
379: (2016) 1 SCC (Cri) 864], yet we are of the opinion that the
process of inventorying, photographing and drawing samples of
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
the seized substance shall as far as possible, take place in the
presence of the accused, though the same may not be done at the
very spot of seizure.
56.3. Any inventory, photographs or samples of seized
substance prepared in substantial compliance of the procedure
prescribed under Section 52-A of the NDPS Act and the
Rules/Standing Order(s) thereunder would have to be
mandatorily treated as primary evidence as per Section 52-A
sub-section (4) of the NDPS Act, irrespective of whether the
substance in original is actually produced before the court or
not.
56.4. The procedure prescribed by the Standing Order(s)/Rules
in terms of Section 52-A of the NDPS Act is only intended to
guide the officers and to see that a fair procedure is adopted by
the officer in charge of the investigation, and as such what is
required is substantial compliance of the procedure laid
therein.
56.5. Mere non-compliance of the procedure under Section 52A or the Standing Order(s)/Rules thereunder will not be fatal to
the trial unless there are discrepancies in the physical evidence
rendering the prosecution’s case doubtful, which may not have
been there had such compliance been done. Courts should take
a holistic and cumulative view of the discrepancies that may
exist in the evidence adduced by the prosecution and appreciate
the same more carefully keeping in mind the procedural lapses.
56.6. If the other material on record adduced by the prosecution,
oral or documentary inspires confidence and satisfies the court
as regards the recovery as well as conscious possession of the
contraband from the accused persons, then even in such cases,
the courts can without hesitation proceed to hold the accused
guilty notwithstanding any procedural defect in terms of Section
52-A of the NDPS Act.
56.7. Non-compliance or delayed compliance of the said
provision or rules thereunder may lead the court to drawing an
adverse inference against the prosecution, however no hardand-fast rule can be laid down as to when such inference may be
drawn, and it would all depend on the peculiar facts and
circumstances of each case.
56.8. Where there has been lapse on the part of the police in
either following the procedure laid down in Section 52-A of the
NDPS Act or the prosecution in proving the same, it will not be
appropriate for the court to resort to the statutory presumption
of commission of an offence from the possession of illicit
material under Section 54 of the NDPS Act, unless the court is
otherwise satisfied as regards the seizure or recovery of such
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
material from the accused persons from the other material on
record.
56.9. The initial burden will lie on the accused to first lay the
foundational facts to show that there was non-compliance of
Section 52-A, either by leading evidence of its own or by relying
upon the evidence of the prosecution, and the standard required
would only be preponderance of probabilities.
56.10. Once the foundational facts laid indicate noncompliance of Section 52-A of the NDPS Act, the onus would
thereafter be on the prosecution to prove by cogent evidence
that either: (i) there was substantial compliance with the
mandate of Section 52-A of the NDPS Act, OR (ii) satisfy the
court that such non-compliance does not affect its case against
the accused, and the standard of proof required would be
beyond a reasonable doubt.”10
c. Nadeem Ahamed v. The State of West Bengal11 was also a case of
appeal against conviction. Although the Supreme Court found that
Section 52A is not mandatory, it held that where samples were not
drawn in the presence of a Magistrate, the FSL Report lost all
significance, and the accused was acquitted.
d. In Jothi alias Nagajothi v. State, Rep. by the Inspector of Police 12,
the conviction was upheld on the finding that there was no
foundational material to suggest that the sampling process was
unreliable or that the integrity of the samples was compromised.
The Supreme Court relied upon a clear chain of custody to reject
an argument with regard to possible tampering, substitution, or
mishandling. It was held that, in these circumstances, a possible
violation of Section 52A would not go to the root of the matter.
e. The latest order of the Supreme Court cited before me was an order
Emphasis supplied.
2025 INSC 993, decided on 05.08.2025 [hereinafter, “Nadeem Ahamed”].
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2774, decided on 11.12.2025.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
dated 09.02.2026 in Wajid Ali @ Tinku v. State of Rajasthan13. The
Court reversed the view of the High Court, which had denied bail,
observing as follows:
“4.
The argument is that the petitioners were arrested on
28.03.2023 and that they have been in jail for more than two
years and ten months. The sample was sent to the Forensic
Science Laboratory(‘FSL’) after 21 days for which there is no
appropriate explanation.
5.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we
consider it proper to enlarge the petitioners on bail.”14
22.
The aforesaid judgments of the Supreme Court require a careful
examination of the facts and circumstances of each case in which noncompliance of Section 52A is alleged. The judgment in Kashif has been
specifically considered in Bharat Aambale, wherein the Supreme Court
has distilled the principles extracted above. It is evident from these
principles that prima facie non-compliance with Section 52A may lead to
an adverse inference against the prosecution. It is evident that even in
Nadeem Ahamed and Wajid Ali, which were subsequent to Kashif and
Bharat Aambale, the Supreme Court regarded a violation of Section 52A
as a significant ground for the grant of bail.
23.
Mr. Srivastava also drew my attention to the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Sumit Tomar v. the State of Punjab15, which rejected
the submission that sampling was required to be undertaken without
mixing the contents of two bags of alleged contraband. The Supreme
Court held, in an appeal against conviction, that no prejudice had been
caused to the accused.
SLP (CRL.) 7049/2025 [hereinafter, “Wajid Ali”].
Emphasis supplied.
Criminal Appeal Nos. 1690-1691 of 2012, decided on 19.10.2012.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
24.
Applying these principles to the facts of the present case, I have
observed above that the sampling procedure under Section 52A has prima
facie been violated. The mixing of samples drawn from various packets
and testing of the mixed samples is not a trivial irregularity, but affects
the question of substantial compliance. I am prima facie of the view that,
on such facts, it is possible that the petitioners could discharge the initial
factual burden with regard to non-compliance of Section 52A. It may or
may not ultimately vitiate the trial, having regard to other discrepancies
and physical evidence produced, but provides a basis upon which an
adverse inference against the prosecution is certainly plausible. As held in
Bharat Aambale, in such circumstances, the statutory presumption of
commission of an offence would also be discharged.
D.
ANALYSIS REGARDING IDENTIFICATION OF THE RECOVERED
SUBSTANCE AS “GANJA”
25. Mr. Aggarwal contended that, both in the FIR and the three seizure
memos, the description of the seized goods, does not correspond to the
statutory definition of “ganja”. Section 2(iii)(b) of the NDPS Act defines
“ganja” as follows:
“(b) ganja, that is, the flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant
(excluding the seeds and leaves when not accompanied by the tops), by
whatever name they may be known or designated;”
26.
In this connection, Mr. Aggarwal submitted that in the FIR, the
goods seized in the spot recovery from both petitioners was described as
“सूखी टहनिय ां, प्ቈे और घ सिुम पद र्थ जो दे खिे, सूांघिे और भौनिक गुणोां के आध र पर ग ांज लग रह है”,
which may be translated as ‘dried branches, leaves, and grass-like
materials which appear to be ganja on the basis of sight, smell, and
physical properties’. Similar phraseology has been used in three seizure
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
memos as well. The order of the learned Magistrate under Section 52A of
the NDPS Act also refers generally to a “greenish brown grassy
substance”. The definition, on the other hand, requires the presence of
flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant.
27.
Relying upon the judgment of this Court in Ravina Kumari v. The
State (NCT of Delhi)16, Mr. Aggarwal submitted that, in the absence of
any material whatsoever to show the presence of flowering or fruiting
tops of the plant, the presence of ganja is not even prima facie
established. Although the FSL report in that case confirmed that the
exhibits were ganja, the Court held that the weight of the seeds, stalks,
and stems should have been excluded while calculating the quantity of
the seized goods, and therefore granted bail on the following reasoning:
19. Thus, the intention of the Legislature appears to be clear that in
case of Ganja, if it is merely Category A i.e. a homogenous mixture of
flowering buds and fruiting tops, then the same would fall within the
meaning of “Cannabis”, however, if it is merely Category B i.e. a
homogenous mixture of seeds/leaves/stalks without the fruiting tops
and buds, then the same would not attract the provisions of the NDPS
Act.
20. Though the position with respect to homogenous mixtures i.e.
Category A & B is clear, there is often a conundrum surrounding the
quantification of Category C, i.e. the overlap between Category A and
Category B constituting the heterogenous mixtures which include both
the flowering tops and fruiting buds, along with the stems/ leaves and
seed.
21. From the framework of the entire NDPS Act and a reading of S.
2 (iii)(b), it emerges that if the material seized is a heterogenous
mixture/Category C, constituting of Category A mixed with Category
B, the placebo material such as stalks/leaves/stems (Category B)
would not constitute an actual part of the drug and only the actual
content and weight of the narcotic drug (Category A) would be
relevant for determining whether it would constitute small quantity
or commercial quantity.
22. Similar observations have been made in the cases of Kunal Dattu
BAIL APPLN. 1256/2024, decided on 20.09.2024 [hereinafter, “Ravina Kumari”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
Kadu (Supra) and Shri Sandip Ashok Raut (Supra) and it was held that
to ascertain whether the material seized was Ganja, it will have to be
ultimately ascertained whether the flowering and fruiting are
accompanied by the seeds and leaves as the weight of these
seeds/leaves/stems, has to be excluded.
23. Axiomatically, the weight of seeds/stalks and stems (Category B)
should be excluded while calculating the actual quantity (Only
Category A) recovered.
24. Evidently, the present case is of a recovery falling within Category
C. The Chargesheet records that when the Petitioner/Ravina was
apprehended, blue coloured plastic polythene bag was recovered from
her which contained grass-like flowery-leafy material along with its
stems, which appeared to be “Ganja” and was seized vide the seizure
memo. On weighing, the recovered Ganja on the electronic weighing
machine, the total weight of the quantity recovered, was about 24.145
Kg.
25. The FSL Report confirmed that on physical, Chemical.
Microscopic and TLC examination, exhibits 'SA-1' and 'SB-1' were
found to be “Ganja”.
26. Pertinently, the recovered quantity of about 24.145 Kg was just
4.145 kgs more than the commercial quantity. Since, the entire
substance including stems/stalks and dried leaves were weighed
together without quantifying the weight of the flowering or fruiting
tops, the quantity of 'Ganja' seized from the Applicant may be less
than commercial quantity so as to attract Section 20 of the NDPS
Act. The weight of actual Ganja recovered is a matter of trial.
27. It has been consistently held that if there is a prima facie
discrepancy in what was seized and what was analysed and weighed
and there are reasonable grounds to believe that the petitioner is not
guilty of offences dealing in commercial quantity. Consequently, the
rigors of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985 for grant of regular bail,
would not become applicable as has been held in the case of Ibrahim
Khwaja Miya Sayyed (Supra).
28. In the case of Suresh Kumar (Supra), the Coordinate Bench of this
Court gave benefit to the accused under Section 20 (b) (C) to 20
(b)(ii)(B) by observing that the weight of the contraband was not
precise and the actual quantity of Ganja seized could not be
determined because the FSL reflected that seeds, which do not come
within the definition of Ganja, were weighed along with the
flowering and fruiting tops. Thus, when there is a doubt on the actual
amount of recovery of contraband, then this unexplained discrepancy
would result in a benefit accruing in favour of the bail applicant.
29. Similar observations have been made in the case of Rajesh Sharma
(Supra), Bettanayaka (Supra), Ratanlal (Supra) and Ratnesh (Supra).
30. In light of the above discussion, it is settled that if there is the
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
discrepancy in weight, as in the present case, the same would be a
matter of trial.”17
28.
A similar analysis is also found in Govind v. State Govt. of NCT of
Delhi18 and Irshad Sheikh v. State Govt. of NCT of Delhi19. In Irshad
Sheikh, this Court held as follows:
“20. However, a perusal of the Seizure Memo describes the recovered
substance as containing “green grassy seeds type smelly leaves
substance”.
21. Section 2(iii)(b) of the NDPS Act defines Ganja as: “ganja, that is,
the flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant (excluding the
seeds and leaves when not accompanied by the tops), by whatever
name they may be known or designated”.
22. It is a settled legal position, affirmed by various High Courts
including the Bombay High Court in Mohammad Jakir Nawab Ali v.
The State of Maharashtra, decided on 20.09.2024 in Crl. Applic. (BA)
No. 602/2024 and the Delhi High Court in Basant Rai v. State, decided
on 02.07.2012 in Crl. Appeal No.909/2005, that if the seized substance
contains seeds and leaves mixed with flowering tops, the investigating
agency must segregate the non-prohibited parts i.e. seeds and leaves,
before weighing to determine the quantity of the “contraband”.”
29.
In the present case, the total seizure amounts to approximately 51
kilograms, whereas the commercial quantity of ganja is 20 kilograms and
above. The FSL report, which was handed up in Court, has analysed each
of the exhibits and described them as “Dried brownish green colour
vegetative material having flowering and fruiting tops weighing [XXXX]
(net weight without plastic box)”. The report concluded that the exhibits
“gave positive tests for the presence of Ganja”. It may also be noted that,
while no reference was made specifically to the flowering or fruiting tops
in the FIR and seizure memos, it was stated that the substance was found
Emphasis supplied.
BAIL APPLN. 1090/2024, decided on 23.09.2024.
BAIL APPLN. 3450/2025 and connected matter, decided on 21.11.2025 [hereinafter, “Irshad
Sheikh”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
to be ganja on the basis of size, smell, and physical properties. I am,
therefore, not inclined, at this stage, to accept the contention of the
petitioners that the material does not satisfy the definition of ganja at all.
30.
However, the question remains as to whether the weight of the
flowering and fruiting tops, exclusive of the branches, leaves, and grass,
was in excess of 20 kilograms, so as to fall within the range of
commercial quantity. As far as this aspect is concerned, the judgment in
Ravina Kumari, extracted above, clearly holds that only the actual content
and weight of the narcotic drug, exclusive of seeds, stalks, and stems, is
relevant for determining the weight of the drug. In the present case, it is
evident that the weight of the parcels was on the basis of the entire seized
goods. Although there is a considerable margin between the minimum
commercial quantity of 20 kilograms and the total weight of 51 kilograms
seized in the present case, it is not possible, without any material on
record, to speculate as to whether the weight of the flowering and fruiting
tops alone would cross the threshold of commercial quantity.
31.
On the basis of the aforesaid binding judgments of coordinate
Benches of this Court, I find that the quantity of contraband in the present
case, cannot be precisely determined at this stage, as the seized goods
were weighed alongwith dried branches, leaves, and grass-like
substances, which may not fall within the statutory definition of “ganja”.
E.
APPLICATION OF THESE FINDINGS
32.
The aforesaid findings must now be applied to a consideration of
the petitioners’ entitlement for bail. As noted above, there is some prima
facie uncertainty as to whether the quantity of contraband seized in the
present case exceeds 20 kilograms. That is a matter which would
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
ultimately be determined at trial, but raises a significant factor in favour
of the petitioners, as it casts a doubt on the applicability of the twin
conditions for bail, set out in Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
33.
Even assuming Section 37 of the NDPS Act is applicable, I am of
the view that the petitioners are entitled to bail in the facts of this case.
The observations of the Supreme Court in Mohd. Muslim v. State (NCT of
Delhi)20, make it clear that the requirements of Section 37 of the NDPS
Act are to be adjudged on the basis of a prima facie case, and not on a
literal reading which would require the Court, at the stage of bail, to be
satisfied beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused had not committed
the offence with which they are charged. Quite apart from the question of
mixing of dried branches, leaves, and grass-like substances, the
petitioners have also cast prima facie doubt on the sampling procedure.
While the judgment in Kashif mandates against the grant of bail or
acquittal merely on the finding of a procedural violation of Section 52A,
it has been clarified in Bharat Aambale, that significant discrepancies in
the procedure adopted are relevant. The failure to draw samples from
each packet separately is, in my view, a significant departure from the
procedure of Section 52A of the NDPS Act and the Sampling Rules. In
the absence of sampling in terms of the Sampling Rules, the value of the
FSL Report itself may require consideration. Although the prosecution
may ultimately be able to overcome this with other evidence at trial, in
my view, the benefit of doubt must be given to the accused at this stage.
34.
I reiterate that both these issues, with regard to the sampling
procedure, and the satisfaction of the statutory definition of “ganja”, are
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
ultimately matters for trial. However, a prima facie analysis, in line with
Md. Muslim, leads me to a determination in favour of the petitioners, that
they ought not to be deprived of liberty during the course of trial.
35.
It may also be noted that the petitioners have no prior criminal
antecedents, and that the matter is at the stage of filing of the
supplementary chargesheet with the FSL report. 31 witnesses have been
cited by the prosecution in the main chargesheet, which makes it clear
that there is likely to be a significant delay in completion of the trial.
F.
CONCLUSION
36.
For the aforesaid reasons, it is directed that the petitioners be
released on bail in connection with FIR No. 133/2025 dated 05.03.2025,
registered at Police Station Civil Lines, District North, New Delhi, for
offences punishable under Sections 20 and 29 of the NDPS Act, subject
to furnishing a bail bond in the sum of Rs. 50,000/- each, with one surety
each of the like amount, to the satisfaction of the concerned Trial
Court/Duty Magistrate, and further subject to the following conditions:
a. The petitioners shall appear before the learned Special Court on
each and every date of hearing.
b. If the petitioners have passports, they shall surrender the same to
the concerned Trial Court, and shall not leave the country without
the prior permission of the concerned Trial Court.
c. The petitioners shall ordinarily reside at the address as per prison
records, and shall not change the addresses without informing the
concerned IO/ Station House Officer [“SHO”].
(2023) 18 SCC 166 [hereinafter, “Md. Muslim”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
d. The petitioners shall furnish their mobile numbers to the concerned
IO/SHO, and shall ensure that the said mobile numbers remain
operational and switched on at all times. The mobile numbers shall
not be changed, nor shall the phones be switched off, without prior
intimation to the IO/SHO.
e. The petitioners shall not contact, nor visit, nor offer any
inducement, threat, or promise to any of the prosecution witnesses
or other persons acquainted with the facts of the case.
f. The petitioners shall not tamper with evidence nor otherwise
indulge in any act or omission that is unlawful or that would
prejudice the proceedings in the pending trial.
g. The petitioners shall not commit any offence during the pendency
of the proceedings.
37.
The applications stand disposed of in the above terms.
38.
It is clarified that the observations made herein are solely for the
purpose of adjudication of the present bail applications, and shall not be
construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case, nor shall
they prejudice the rights and contentions of the parties at any stage of the
proceedings.
39.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned Jail
Superintendent for information and necessary compliance.
PRATEEK JALAN, J
MARCH 19, 2026/‘SS/PV/Khushi’/
Signed By:BHUPENDER
21:18
BAIL APPLN. 4206/2025 & BAIL APPLN. 4207/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review