Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
---A.B.A. No. 5781 of 2025
---1.Vijay Pratap Singh, aged about 60 years, son of Jineshwar Singh,
resident of Matwari, P.O. Hazaribagh, P.S. Sadar, District- Hazaribagh,
Jharkhand -
[Vide Order No.3, Dated 16.10.2025, dismissed as not
pressed against the petitioner no.1.]
2.Sudhir Kumar Singh, aged about 56 years, son of Late Viresh
Chandra Sinha, resident of Hurhuru, PO Hazaribagh, PS Sadar and
District -Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
… Petitioner(s)
-VersusThe State of Jharkhand, through A.C.B.
… Opposite Party
-----
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI
----For the Petitioner
: Mr. Indrajit Sinha, Advocate
Mr. Mritunjay Chaudhary, Advocate
For the A.C.B.
: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
Mr. Nillohit Choubey, Advocate
Ms. Shruti Shekhar, Advocate
-----
06/20.01.2026
Heard Mr. Indrajit Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
respondent Anti-Corruption Bureau (A.C.B.).
2.
The petitioner is apprehending his arrest in connection with
Hazaribagh ACB P.S. Case No.09 of 2025, registered for the offence under
Sections 409, 467, 468 (inadvertently indicated u/s 469 in impugned order),
-1-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
471, 420, 120B of the Indian Penal Code and Section 13(2) and 13(1)(c) and
(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, pending in the Court of the
learned Additional Sessions Judge-II cum Special Judge, Vigilance (A.C.B.)
Hazaribag.
3.
By order dated 16.10.2025, this anticipatory bail application is
restricted to Sudhir Kumar Singh, who is petitioner no.2, as Vijay Pratap
Singh, who is the petitioner no.1, was already arrested.
4.
Mr. Indrajit Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that case is arising out of the complaint made to the Vigilance (A.C.B.)
alleging that the petitioner is Power of Attorney holder of the recorded
settlees has facilitated transfer of Khas Mahal Land situated in Hazaribagh in
favour of several purchasers and that was done in contravention of the Order
dated 26.07.2005 passed by High Court of Jharkhand passed in C.W.J.C.
No.4200 of 2000. He further submits that the petitioner is innocent and has
been falsely implicated in this case. He next submits that by the registered
deed dated 25.02.1941, the said Ganpat Rai Sarogi dedicated the land in
question admeasuring 2.75 acres in favour of Deity Shri Shri Mahabir Ji and
created a scheme of management through appointed Sewayat. He next
submits that by a registered deed dated 29.10.1951, cancellation was sought
to be done by said Ganpat Rai Sarogi and it was cancelled in its entirety and,
accordingly, 1941 arrangement made by the deed was also terminated and
from 1951 onwards, the land seized to be treated as indoor property. He next
submits that the said Khas Mahal land was settled in favour of the heirs of
the said settlors and renewal of the lease was granted from time to time
including the renewal in the year 1977 and 1986 and ultimately an application
-2-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
was filed before the Deputy Commissioner and thereafter the State
Government has sanctioned renewal of lease for 30 years which was
approved by Department of Revenue and Land Reforms. He next submits that
only on sanction, the petitioner, being the power of attorney holder, has
transferred the said land, and apart from that, there is no allegation against
the petitioner.
5.
On the other hand, Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel
appearing for the ACB opposed the application for anticipatory bail of the
petitioner and he then submits that the regular bail of the co-accused, who
was also the power of attorney holder along with this petitioner, has already
been rejected by this Court in B.A. No.10414 of 2025 by the Order dated
07.01.2026. He next submits that in course of investigation, the statement of
one Investigating Officer namely Santosh Kumar has also been recorded
under section 180 of B.N.S.S., 2023 and who is investigating the A.C.B. Ranchi
P.S. Case No.9 of 2025 which was registered under sections 120B, 420, 467,
468,409, 107, 109 of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 7(13) and
13(1)(c) and 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, in which
Vinay Kumar Choubey who is a named accused, an I.O. of the present case
especially examined Investigating Officer of A.C.B. Ranchi P.S. Case No.9 of
2025 for the purposes of seeking assistance for recovery of money trail in the
present case also and it has been revealed that that during the period from
01.04.2010 to 09.07.2015, an amount of Rs.3.16 Crores was deposited in
cash in the bank account of Brahmastra Education Private Limited, in which,
wife of Vinay Kumar Choubey, namely, Swapna Sanchita and her brother,
namely, Shitij Trivedi (brother-in-law of Vinay Kumar Choubey) are the
-3-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
Directors in the said company. The statement of the informant, Arvind Kumar
Agarwal in Korra P.S. Case No.1 of 2024 dated 01.01.2024 registered for the
offence under sections 406 and 420 I.P.C was recoded telephonically and the
said person has stated that Vijay Pratap Singh along with this petitioner
Sudhir Kumar Singh was taken Rs.25 lakhs as consideration amount towards
sale of the present Khas Mahal Land in his favour which is the subject matter
of the present F.I.R and the said person has also stated that neither the
aforementioned two persons returned the money nor they transferred the
land in his favour. He also submits that the aforesaid Government Khas Mahal
Land was initially granted in favour of one Ganpat Rai Sarogi in the year 1941
i.e on 26.02.1941 and the said Ganpat Rai Sarogi intended to settle the land
in favour of the Deity Shri Shri Mahavir Ji and in the said deed of settlement,
the said Ganpat Rai Sarogi declared himself as Sevayat and it was clearly
provided inter-alia that the property is absolutely dedicated to the Deity Shri
Shri Mahavir Ji and no Sevayats, at any point of time, be entitle to give the
property as his or her own property and at no point of time, the said property
be alienated or sold, partitioned or mortgaged. He submits that in light of
Clause 10 of the Sale Deed specifically provided inter-alia that if any alienation
or transfer is made one or any of the Sevayat(s) of the property in question,
the same will be treated as null and void. He also submits that admittedly the
Government Khas Mahal Land given for settling the said land in favour of Shri
Shri Mahavir Jee, the Deity, by Ganpat Rai Sarogi, a permission of the Deputy
Commissioner is required and accordingly the said permission was accorded
in the year 1948 which was granted in favour of Shri Shri Mahavir Ji through
the Sevayat Ganpat Rai Sarogi and the said deed was valid for a period of 30
-4-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
years, that is, up to the year 1978. He further submits that the said Ganpat
Rai Sarogi died leaving behind two sons, namely, Panna Lal Sethi and Hira Lal
Sethi who assumed the role of Sevayat and an application was filed by the
said Panna Lal Sethi for renewal of lease which was expired in 1978. In the
investigation, it has been revealed according to the learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondent A.C.B., that an attempt was made to get the
lease renewed/ transferred in favour of the individual names of Sevayats, that
is, Panna Lal Sethi and Hira Lal Sethi instead of renewal of the lease in the
name of Deity, Shri Shri Mahavir Ji, and the said management was sought to
be made in favour of Panna Lal Sethi and Hira Lal Sethi and brought deed of
cancellation of lease in the year 1951. He next submits that in connivance of
this petitioner, along with Vijay Pratap Singh, whose regular bail was rejected
by this Court, one Transfer (Partition) Case No.1 of 2009-2010 was registered
and in connivance with the then Deputy Commissioner the file was forwarded
for permission of transfer. He also submits that the A.C.B. has issued notice
under section 35(3) of BNS, 2023 for participating in the investigation but the
petitioner has not come forward and is not cooperating in the investigation.
He also submits that in paragraph no.119 of the case diary, and in paragraph
no.8 of the supplementary case diary, it has come that the petitioner in
collusion with other co-accused persons attempting to create the evidences
to exonerate himself as well as to implicate the innocent persons and the
petitioner was trying to sale out the immovable and movable property and it
is a great likelihood that if the privilege of anticipatory bail is granted to the
petitioner, he would sell out his movable and immovable properties and that
come in paragraph no.119 of the case diary and paragraph no.8 of
-5-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
supplementary case diary. He next submits that the petitioner is having power
of attorney holder and has manipulated all the things and has assured the
purchasers that he is having high connection with the officers including the
then Deputy Commissioner Hazaribagh and he will facilitate everything for
transfer of land and these facts are supported by the witnesses whose
statement has come in the case diary under section 180 of B.N.S.S. (Bhartiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita), 2023. He also submits that one of the witnesses,
namely, Manish Narayan has stated that the land is sold to 23 persons by this
petitioner along with Vijay Pratap Singh and approached Manish Narayan and
stated that he will facilitate every thing as he is having high connection with
the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribagh and he has also stated that the
land was purchased in the name of his mother and the same fact has also
been deposed by the Smt. Priti Prasad and Smt. Nandrani Sinha and their
statements are part of the case diary. He also submits that successor-ininterest and Sewayats, namely, Basanti Kumari Sethi, Raj Kumar Sethi,
Indrajit Sethi and Rajesh Kumar Sethi, who are accused in the present case,
are not cooperating in the investigation and even they have filed anticipatory
bail application before the learned Sessoins Judge on the forged address as
the address provided in the anticipatory bail petition and when the A.C.B has
gone there, that address was found to be forged. He also submits that in the
district of Hazaribagh, approximately 5000 acres of land have been illegally
transacted and the said lands in fact were belonging to and/or Forest land,
Gair Majaruwa Aam, Sarkari Khas Mahal, Kaiser-e-hind, Lakheraj, Trust lands
etc. He also submits that the entire land scams were done during the tenure
of the co-accused Vinay Kumar Choubey, then Deputy Commissioner,
-6-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
Hazaribag in conspiracy with other persons including the petitioner and these
facts have come in paras 104 and 107 in case diary. He next submits that the
prayer for regular bail of the coaccused Vijay Pratap Singh who is also the
power of attorney holder, his such prayer has been rejected by this Court in
B.A. No.10414 of 2025 by order dated 7.1.2026 and the bail application of
Vinay Kumar Choubey, the then Deputy Commissioner was rejected by order
6.1.2026 in B.A. No.9604 of 2025. In this background, he submits that the
petitioner is not deserving anticipatory bail by this Court. He further submits
that the transaction has been done in contravention of the order of this Court
passed in CWJC No.4200 of 2000 by order dated 26.7.2005.
6.
In view of above submission of the learned counsels appearing
for the parties and looking to the contents of the FIR and the documents
which have been brought on record and the documents which has been
produced in course of the argument of the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondent A.C.B, it transpires that one Shri Ganpat Rai Sarogi
by registered deed dated 25.2.1941 has dedicated the land in question
admeasuring 2.75 acres in favour of the Deity, Shri Shri Mahavir Ji and later
on the said Ganpat Rai Sarogi has tried to cancel the same by the deed of the
year 1951, however, it was not accepted by the authority and the
Commissioner, North Chhotanagpur Region, Hazaribagh, by the order dated
12.12.1988 has ordered for renewal of the said deed in the name of the Deity
only. Hira Lal Sethi and Panna Lal Sethi both sons of Ganpat Rai Sarogi have
tried to transfer the said land to the third person which was rejected by
Commissioner, North Chhotanagpur Division, Hazaribagh by order dated
1.7.2000 and the said order was challenged by Basanti Kumari Sethi, Raj
-7-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
Kumar Sethi, Indrajit Sethi and Rajesh Kumar Sethi by filing C.W.J.C. No.4200
of 2000 and the High Court vide order dated 26.07.2005 has been pleased to
reject the said writ petition holding that the successor-in-interest or any
person who took the charge of Sewayat, had no right to transfer the land in
question in favour of any other person and, accordingly, it has been held that
the decision of Commissioner of North Chotanagpur Division refusing the
grant of permission for transfer of leasehold land is correct. It transpires that
even the order of the High Court has not been taken care of in illegally
transferring of the land.
7.
Three witnesses, as noted in the argument of the learned
counsel for the A.C.B, namely, Shri Manish Narayan, Smt. Priti Prasad and
Smt. Nand Rani Sinha have deposed that the petitioner along with Vijay
Pratap Singh has approached the purchaser to sell the land and the petitioner
has also stated that he will facilitate everything as he is having high
connection and good relation with the officers including the then Deputy
Commissioner, Hazaribagh. They have also stated that the petitioner along
with Vijay Pratap Singh were found visiting the Office of the Deputy
Commissioner, Hazaribagh frequently. The petitioner along with Vijay Pratap
Singh are power of attorney holder of Sevayat namely, Basanti Kumari Sethi,
Raj Kumar Sethi, Indrajit Sethi and Rajesh Kumar Sethi, who are not
cooperating in the investigation and they have even tried to cheat the Court
by way of filing anticipatory bail application by providing forged address.
8.
Here is the case, wherein the witnesses in the case diary have
deposed the name of the petitioner and even attributed his specific role and
it has to be considered coupled with the facts and circumstances involved in
-8-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:1435)
the case.
9.
The investigation against the petitioner is still going on as he is
not cooperating.
10.
In view of above, it transpires that the petitioner is the prime
accused being the power of attorney holder and the regular bail application
of Vijay Pratap Singh who is the accomplice of this petitioner has already been
rejected by order dated 7.1.2026 passed in B.A. No.10414 of 2025, and in the
attending facts and circumstances of the instant case, I am not inclined to
grant anticipatory bail to the petitioner, and as such, this anticipatory bail
application, being A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025 is, hereby, rejected.
(Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.)
Dated: 20th January, 2026
SI/
Uploaded on
29.01.2026
-9-
A.B.A. No.5781 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review