Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
Vijay Pratap Singh, aged about 63 years, son of Jineshwar Singh, resident of
Matwari, P.O. Hazaribagh, P.S. Sadar, District- Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
… Petitioner
-VersusThe State of Jharkhand through A.C.B.
… Opposite Party
-----
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI
-----
For the Petitioner
For the A.C.B.
: Mr. Indrajit Sinha, Advocate
Mr. Mritunjay Chaudhary, Advocate
: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
Mr. Nillohit Choubey, Advocate
Ms. Shruti Shekhar, Advocate
Ms. Sanya Kumari, Advocate
-----
03/07.01.2026
Heard Mr. Indrajit Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
and Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel appearing for the ACB.
2.
The petitioner is seeking regular bail in connection with Hazaribagh
ACB P.S. Case No.09 of 2025, registered for the offence under Sections 409,
467, 468 (indicated as 469 in impugned order), 471, 420, 120B of the Indian
Penal Code Section 13(2) and 13(1)(c) and (d) of the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988, pending in the Court of the learned Additional Sessions Judge-II
cum Special Judge, Vigilance (A.C.B.) Hazaribag.
3.
Mr. Indrajit Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that the petitioner has been falsely implicated in the present case however
he has neither any dishonest intention nor any role in the alleged offence. He
further submits that the petitioner has been implicated only because he was
Power of Attorney holder of the land in question, which has been sold to
different persons. He then submits that by the registered deed dated
25.02.1941, Seth Ganpat Rai Sarogi dedicated the land in question
-1-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
admeasuring 2.75 acres in favour of deity Sri Sri Mahabir Ji and created a
scheme of management through appointed Sewayat. He next submits that by
a registered deed dated 29.10.1951, the settlor Sri Ganpat Rai Sarogi tried to
revoke and annul the earlier deed of dedication dated 25.02.1941, however,
the authority has not accepted the same. He submits that pursuant to that,
the land was leased out and subsequently the Sewayats have filed the
renewal petitions, which have been allowed and the Sewayats have given
Power of Attorney to the petitioner and, thereafter, the petitioner along with
Sudhir Kumar Singh has transferred the land. He also submits that the
petitioner is in custody since 05.10.2025 and the charge-sheet has been
submitted on 24.12.2025. He further submits that the petitioner was not
taken for interrogation by the ACB. He also submits that the allegations are
of the year 2009-10 and the case has been registered in the year 2025.
According to him, there is no money trail so far as the petitioner is concerned.
He then submits that the Government has granted permission and, thereafter,
the land has been sold by the petitioner. He next submits that one of the coaccused Binod Chandra Jha, who was the Khas Mahal Officer at relevant time,
has been granted regular bail by this Court. On these grounds, he submits
that in view of the fact that the petitioner is only Power of Attorney holder
and he is in custody and charge-sheet has been submitted, regular bail may
kindly be allowed to the petitioner.
4.
On the other hand, Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel appearing for
the ACB vehemently opposed the prayer and submits that the petitioner being
the Power of Attorney holder, has manipulated all the things and has assured
the purchasers that he is having high connection with the officers including
-2-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
with the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribag and he will facilitate
everything for transfer of the land in question. He further submits that these
facts are supported by the witnesses whose statements have come in the
case diary under Section 180 of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
He then submits that one witness, namely Sri Manish Narayan has stated that
the land has been sold to 23 persons and this petitioner along with Sudhir
Kumar Singh has approached Manish Narayan and stated that he will facilitate
everything as he is having high connection including the then Deputy
Commissioner, Hazaribag. He next submits that same facts have also been
deposed by the witnesses, namely, Smt. Priti Prasad and Smt. Nandrani Sinha
and their statements are part of the case diary. He also submits that the
investigating officer issued notices to the successor-in-interest and Sewayats,
namely, Basanti Kumari Sethi, Raj Kumar Sethi, Indrajit Sethi and Rajesh
Kumar Sethi, who are accused in the present case. He submits that the said
notices were issued under Section 35(3) of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 for participating in the investigation, but those persons have
not participated in investigation. He further submits that in the investigation,
it has been revealed that the said persons have given incorrect address of
their residence i.e. at Kolkata and at present they are not traceable. He then
submits that Sri Rajesh Sethi and Sri Indrajit Sethi have filed anticipatory bail
petitions before the learned Special Judge, ACB, Hazaribag, which were
rejected by the learned Court and in course of investigation, it has transpired
that the address mentioned in those anticipatory bail petitions are incorrect.
He next submits that so far as other two Sewayats, namely, Basanti Kumari
Sethi and Uma Sethi are concerned, Uma Sethi has filed anticipatory bail
-3-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
petition before the learned trial court giving incorrect address in the said
petition also and even the anticipatory bail petition filed by the aforesaid
Sewayats have been rejected by the learned trial court. He submits that
during investigation it has transpired that Basanti Kumari Sethi has passed
away 10 years back and the said fact is not confirmed because of noncooperation of other co-accused. He also submits that this petitioner is not
cooperating in revealing the correct address of two Sewayats. By way of
inviting attention of the Court to paragraph 35 of the counter-affidavit filed
by the ACB, he submits that in course of investigation, it has been revealed
that approximately 5000 acres of land in the district of Hazaribag have been
illegally transacted and the said lands in fact were belonging to and/or Forest
land, Gair Majaruwa Aam, Sarkari Khas Mahal, Kaiser-e-hind, Lakheraj, Trust
lands etc. He next submits that the entire land scams were done during the
tenure of the co-accused Vinay Kumar Choubey, then Deputy Commissioner,
Hazaribag in conspiracy with other persons including the petitioner and these
facts have come in paras 104 and 107 in case diary no.18. He also submits
that the prayer for regular bail of Vinay Kumar Choubey has been rejected by
this Court vide order dated 06.01.2026 in B.A. No.9602 of 2025. On these
grounds, he submits that the prayer for regular bail of the petitioner may
kindly be rejected.
5.
In view of the above submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and looking to the contents of the documents, which have been brought on
record and the documents which have been produced in course of argument
by the learned counsel appearing for the ACB, it transpires that one Sri Seth
Ganpat Rai Sarogi by a registered deed dated 25.02.1941 dedicated the land
-4-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
in question admeasuring 2.75 acres in favour of deity Sri Sri Mahavir Ji. Later
on, Sri Seth Ganpat Rai has tried to cancel the said donation by the deed of
the year 1951, however, that was not accepted by the authority and the
Commissioner of North Chhotanagpur Division, Hazaribag vide order dated
12.12.1988 has ordered for renewal of the said deed in the name of deity
only.
6.
Hira Lal Sethi and Panna Lal Sethi are sons of Seth Ganpat Rai Sarogi
and they have tried to transfer the land to third person, which was rejected
by the Commissioner of North Chotanagpur Division, Hazaribag vide order
dated 01.07.2000 and the said order was challenged by Basanti Kumari Sethi,
Raj Kumar Sethi, Indrajit Sethi and Rajesh Kumar Sethi by filing C.W.J.C.
No.4200 of 2000 and the High Court vide order dated 26.07.2005 has been
pleased to reject the said writ petition holding that the successor-in-interest
or any person who took the charge of Sewayat, had no right to transfer the
land in question in favour of any other person and, accordingly, it has been
held that the decision of Commissioner of North Chotanagpur Division
refusing the grant of permission for transfer of leasehold land is correct. It
transpires that even the order of the High Court has been ignored and the
petitioner being the Power of Attorney holder has sold the land in question.
7.
Three of the witnesses, namely, Sri Manish Narayan, Smt. Priti Prasad
and Smt. Nandrani Sinha, whose statements have been recorded under
Section 180 of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, which have been
produced by the learned counsel appearing for the ACB and they have
deposed that the petitioner along with Sudhir Kumar Singh approached the
purchasers to sell the land and the petitioner has also stated that he will
-5-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
facilitate everything as he is having high connection and good relationship
with the officers including the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribag. The
witnesses have also stated that the petitioner along with Sudhir Kumar Singh
were found visiting the office of the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribag
frequently. The petitioner is Power of Attorney holder of the Sewayats, namely,
Basanti Kumari Sethi, Raj Kumar Sethi, Indrajit Sethi and Rajesh Kumar Sethi.
It has been pointed out in course of the argument by the learned counsel
appearing for the ACB that those persons have even filed anticipatory bail
petitions before the learned Court and they have given incorrect address,
which has come in the investigation and the petitioner being the Power of
Attorney holder, is not providing correct address of those persons in spite of
the fact that he is in custody.
8.
In paragraph 46 of the counter-affidavit filed by the ACB, it has been
stated that the aforesaid witnesses in their statements, have stated that
during the period from 01.04.2010 to 09.07.2015, an amount of Rs.3.16
Crores was deposited in cash in the bank account of Brahmastra Education
Private Limited, in which, wife of Vinay Kumar Choubey, namely, Swapna
Sanchita and her brother, namely, Shipij Trivedi (brother-in-law of Vinay
Kumar Choubey) are the Directors in the said company. It has also been
stated in the counter-affidavit that money trail is also being investigated by
the ACB in view of the fact that has revealed in course of the investigation.
9.
There is no doubt that filing of the charge-sheet is a material
consideration while granting bail, however, the same is not the sole criterion
to be taken into consideration as it has to be coupled with the facts and
circumstances involved in the case. Here is a case, wherein, though the
-6-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
charge-sheet has already been filed, however, the witnesses in the case diary
have subsequently deposed the name of the petitioner and even attributed
his specific role. The allegation against the petitioner is there of having Power
of Attorney and sold the Government land to 23 persons in connivance with
the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribag.
10.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has raised the ground
of parity to the co-accused, namely, Binod Chandra Jha, who happened to
be the Khas Mahal Officer at relevant point of time and he has been
granted regular bail by this Court vide order dated 05.01.2026 in B.A. No.9487
of 2025.
11.
So far as parity is concerned, the law is well settled that the principle
of parity is to be applied if the case on fact is exactly similar then only the
principle of parity in the matter of passing order is to be passed but if there
is difference in between the facts then the principle of parity is not to be
applied. It is also well known that the Court cannot exercise its power in a
capricious manner and has to consider the totality of circumstances before
granting bail and only because another accused has been granted bail, the
present petitioner is also entitled for bail if the present facts are not similar.
So far as the case of Binod Chandra Jha is concerned, he has been granted
bail considering that he has passed only two orders and during his tenure the
land in question was not transferred. The land in question was transferred
later on by the successor of the said Binod Chandra Jha. Further, he was aged
about 70 years and retired in the year 2016 and he was having ailments. In
those backgrounds, the said Binod Chandra Jha was granted regular bail by
this Court.
-7-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
( 2026:JHHC:224 )
12.
What has been discussed herein above, prima facie it appears that the
petitioner is a prime accused being Power of Attorney holder and in
connivance with the then Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribag, he has
transferred the Government land. In view of these facts, the ground of parity
is not made so far as this petitioner is concerned and, as such, the argument
with regard to parity is, hereby, rejected.
13.
In the attending facts and circumstances of the case, I am not inclined
to grant bail to the petitioner at this stage and, hence, his prayer for regular
bail is, hereby, rejected.
14.
Accordingly, this application is dismissed.
(Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.)
Dated: 7th January, 2026
Ajay/
Uploaded on
8th January, 2026
-8-
B.A. No. 10414 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review