The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. The perfunctory order impugned herein is set aside. Ordinarily, since the writ petition was not considered at all, the matter ought to have been remanded for a fresh consideration. However, that would have resulted in more suffering for the appellants and the judicial system is better served with less remand-or-referral judges.
19. The order impugned dated April 9, 2021 is set aside and the writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above. The costs as directed should be paid individually within six weeks from date and the second respondent (Staff Selection Commission) will be responsible therefor. It is hoped that the award of costs would act as a catalyst to ensure both integrity and accountability.
20. WA No.14 of 2021 is allowed as above. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.14/2021
Date of Order: 21.04.2022
Vijay Manjhi & anr
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv
For the Respondents
: Dr. N. Mozika, ASG with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This appeal brings out the importance of institutional integrity
and how apparently trivial anomalies which are sought to be justified or
attempted to be passed off as mistakes may not be as innocent and,
indeed, may only be the proverbial tip of the iceberg of malaise that has
the potential to contaminate the entire sea.
2.
But one must begin with the mistake committed by the joint
appellants before referring to the other acts of omission and commission.
3.
The two appellants were independent candidates who had
applied to be recruited as constables in 2018 recruitment process for the
Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF). Both the appellants failed at the
detailed medical examination stage, though for different causes. As such,
the appellants ought to have filed individual petitions since there was no
commonality in their dissimilar causes apart from the fact that they had
applied for the same post and were found to be medically unfit.
4.
This is not a hyper-technical point. This has also nothing to do
with the nominal additional court-fees that should have been paid on the
second petition. Disparate matters cannot be dealt with together and, to
such extent, the adjudication in this case calls for consideration of the
individual cases independently. The appeal has been so assessed.
5.
The writ court dismissed the petition upon a rather cursory
look thereat and in three terse paragraphs. Here was a case of two young
citizens aspiring to obtain coveted government jobs and who perceived
that they had been unfairly treated and deliberately denied the positions
that they deserved. In such a scenario, the citizens may have expected
some more respect and to be informed why their causes were found
unworthy in somewhat better terms than evident from the order assailed
in appeal. Even the overwhelming burden of pending matters or the lack
of adequate resources can be no excuse to belie the minimum
expectation of every litigant of due consideration of his cause. Hours
need not be expended and tomes need not be wasted on apparently trite
matters; but the gamut of the grievance must be noticed unless there is a
legal impediment to the consideration thereof or a bar to the grant of the
relief sought.
6.
There is no doubt that when the candidates have been found to
be medically unfit, the writ court would ordinarily not issue a mandamus
for such persons to be recruited. However, the writ court is obliged to
look into the circumstances and grounds if an irregularity in the process
is complained of. It does not appear that the writ court turned the pages
of the writ petition to even ascertain the nature of the grievance.
7.
In this case, the first appellant was found unfit in the detailed
medical examination on the ground of a perforation in his tympanic
membrane in the right ear. Upon availing of the review medical
examination in terms of the rules applicable to the recruitment process,
the first appellant was referred to a specialist. He was examined at the
North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health and Medical
Sciences (NEIGRIHMS) and the opinion of such institution was that the
right tympanic membrane was intact and the right ear audiometry test
was normal. Upon the first appellant, armed with favourable report of
NEIGRIHMS approaching the respondent authorities, he was found to
have a problem in the left ear on the basis of an audiometry report that
had not been called for and it is the admitted position that audiometry
tests are not conducted on the candidates.
8.
If the writ court had taken the time to look into the papers, it
would have discovered that when the first appellant’s right ear was
found to be normal, the respondent authorities rejected him because of
his left ear and, on the basis of a test that other candidates are not
subjected to. Such a scenario would not be acceptable to any judicial
conscience and there appears to have been more to the rejection than
meets the eye. If normal citizens seeking public employment cannot
approach the appointing authority with the confidence that they will be
tested on the basis of their ability and not on extraneous considerations
or recommendations, there is bound to be resentment that may lead to
anarchy. And if Constitutional courts tasked with the duty to protect
rights abdicate their authority to step in when necessary by giving due
consideration to the complaining citizen’s grievance, it is a slur on the
institution.
9.
If it was the right ear of the first appellant that was defective,
then the review process should have been confined to the right ear and
the authorities had no business to look into the condition of the left ear,
since that had already been passed in accordance with the previous
detailed medical examination. It was as if the respondents wanted the
first appellant not to qualify that they picked out some form of an excuse
to rule him medically unfit.
10.
As far as the second appellant is concerned, he was found to
suffer from hypertension in course of the detailed medical examination.
Upon applying for a review medical examination in accordance with the
prescribed procedure, the second appellant was tested again. This time
the report indicated that he was found to suffer from hypertension upon
three readings being taken over a period of seven hours. However, the
measurements or readings are not indicated in the report. It may be
noticed that in course of the initial detailed medical examination, the
second appellant was found to have blood pressure measuring 134/96 (in
terms of millimeters of mercury) which was said to be the average of
three readings.
11.
There is no doubt that the rules for recruitment indicated that
the accepted parameters of blood pressure would be between 140 and 90
mmHg. In other words, persons with diastolic pressure greater than 90
mmHg or systolic pressure greater than 140 mmHg would be
disqualified.
12.
Even though judges qualify in law examinations and may not
possess any medical expertise, when it comes to the rudimentary medical
feature as blood pressure, most educated persons have a rough idea. It is
no rocket science to know that the level of blood pressure can vary to a
considerable extent in course of the day or because of the weather
conditions or other influences. In particular, when a recruitment process
is conducted and the candidates are required to queue up and undergo a
long period of wait before they are called in, the anxiety and tiredness
may result in the usual fluctuation and an experienced medical
practitioner would disregard the same, unless it is the brief of the
examiner to find the tiniest bit of fault to make out an excuse to
eliminate a candidate.
13.
In course of the detailed medical examination, it was
exemplary that the appropriate authorities conducting such examination
had the patience to take three readings over a period of seven hours, but
such readings should have been reflected for, at least, an objective
satisfaction that the prescribed parameters had not been met.
14.
The manner in which the ultimate medical examinations were
conducted in both cases left a lot to be desired and there may be some
basis to the general perception that these recruitment processes are not
conducted in the most fair manner or with the degree of indifference or
impartiality that every not-so-influential candidate lacking a godfather or
the requisite purse strings would expect.
15.
The unfair prejudice suffered in either case cries out to be
corrected.
16.
These two candidates had applied for the 2018 recruitment
process and it is possible that the recruitment process of 2018 has not
been completed since the detailed medical examination was conducted
towards the end of October, 2020. In the light of the unfair manner in
which both the appellants were treated, they deserve to be examined
only for the specific grounds on which their candidatures were rejected
earlier and, if found fit on the relevant ground alone, their candidatures
should be processed in accordance with law. In the event the recruitment
process of 2018 has already been completed, the same tests pertaining to
the deficiencies found in the appellants would be conducted in the usual
course by the respondent authorities and if the appellants are found fit,
their candidatures should be processed in accordance with law for the
next subsequent year for which the recruitment process remains open
and, irrespective of any age-bar, they should be recruited if they meet
the other non-medical parameters.
16.
In addition, the appellants will be paid Rs.75,000/- each
irrespective of whether they are, or either of them is, successful in the
further medical examination to be conducted in accordance with this
order and confined to the area of perceived deficiency discovered earlier.
17.
Every citizen deserves to be treated fairly, particularly when it
comes to recruitment or employment. Government positions are
advertised for the candidates in the relevant categories to be recruited on
sound and objective criteria where the element of subjectivity has to be
kept at the minimum to ensure that nepotism and favouritism do not
come into play. Unfortunately, the shoddy manner in which these
appellants were dealt with does not instill any confidence in the system.
18.
The perfunctory order impugned herein is set aside. Ordinarily,
since the writ petition was not considered at all, the matter ought to have
been remanded for a fresh consideration. However, that would have
resulted in more suffering for the appellants and the judicial system is
better served with less remand-or-referral judges.
19.
The order impugned dated April 9, 2021 is set aside and the
writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above. The costs as
directed should be paid individually within six weeks from date and the
second respondent (Staff Selection Commission) will be responsible
therefor. It is hoped that the award of costs would act as a catalyst to
ensure both integrity and accountability.
20.
WA No.14 of 2021 is allowed as above.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
21.04.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review