The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. From the perusal of the judgment of this Court in the case of Pradeep Kumari (supra), it is clear that the limitation for moving the application under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act will begin to run only from the date of the award on the basis of which redetermination of the compensation is sought. The appellants are seeking redetermination of the compensation on the basis of the judgment and order of the High Court in First Appeal No. 429 of 2023 dated 2nd May 2016. It is not disputed that the application of the appellants under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act is within a period of three months from 2nd May 2016." Further the decision made in the case of Banwari and others (supra) has also been followed by the Division Bench of this Court in case of “Union of India and another vs. The Special Land Acquisition Collector-cum-Sub -Divisional Magistrate, Pathankot and others, 2025(3) RCR (Civil) 786”. [10]. As such, once the application preferred under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act, filed at the instance of the petitioners/landowners was pending adjudication with respondent No.2 and during such period this Court made the assessment of market value @ Rs.1754/- per marla vide its decision dated 16.03.2017 passed in the case of Durgi Devi and others' (supra) which even was upheld by the Hon'ble Apex Court while 2026.03.19 09:36 I agree to specified portions of this document CWP-38661-2025…
16. 03.2017 and on the said date the said application preferred at the instance of the petitioners/landowners was pending adjudication with respondent No.2. In fact, keeping in mind the principle of the landowners being entitled for just, fair and equal compensation against compulsory acquisition of their land, respondent No.2 was required to adopt a pragmatic approach so as to further the object, purpose and intent of the statutory provision enacted by the Legislature in the form of Section 28-A of the 1894 Act, rather than taking a hyper-technical approach, thereby causing prejudice to the rights of the petitioners-landowners. [11]. In view of aforesaid discussion, the present writ petition is allowed and the impugned dated 24.08.2021 passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate-cum-Land Acquisition Collector, and Shahpurkandi Dam Project, Shahpurkandi Township is hereby set aside, The petitioners/landowners are held entitled for award of similar benefit of market value @ Rs. 1754/- per marla besides award of all other statutory benefits and interest as provided under the provisions of the 1894 Act (amended upto date). The due amount be released in favour of 2026.03.19 09:36 I agree to specified portions of this document CWP-38661-2025 petitioners/landowners within two months from today or else respondent No.2 shall be liable to pay cost of Rs.1 lakh to the petitioners for causing del…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-38661-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-38661-2025
Date of Decision: March 16, 2026
VIJAY KUMAR @ VIJAY
VIJA SHARMA AND ORS.
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS
...Petitioners
.....Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARKESH MANUJA
Present:
Mr. R.S. Manhas, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. Gunjan Mehta, Addl. A.G. Punjab.
HARKESH MANUJA,
MANUJA J. (ORAL)
****
By way of present writ petition, challenge has been laid to the
order dated 24.08.2021 passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate
Magistrate-cum-Land Acquisition Collector, RSD and Shahpurkandi Dam Project,
Shahpurkandi Township, whereby Reference preferred at the instance of
the petitioners/landowners having invoked Section 28
28-A
A of the Land
Acquisition
quisition Act, 1894 (for short "the 1894 Act') was dismissed.
[2].
Briefly stating, in the present case, some land owned by the
petitioners/landowners situated within the revenue estate of village Kot
Tikka Majra, Tehsil Dhar Kalan, Distt. Gurdaspur, came to be acquired
vide Notifications dated 16.06.1994 and 28.10.1994 issued under
Sections 4 & 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 respectively for the
public purpose namely for construction of Shahpurkandi Dam Project.
The Award under Section 11 of the 1894 Act was passed by the Land
Acquisition Collector (for short 'the LAC") on 04.12.1996.
[3].
Being aggrieved thereof, some of the other landowners
pertaining to this very acquisition sought reference under Section 18 of
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.03.19 09:36
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-38661-2025
the 1894 Act which came to be decided on 02.05.2018 and the market
value was assessed @ Rs.1600/- per marla along with all the statutory
benefits under the 1894 Act.
[4].
Based on the aforesaid Award, the petitioners/landowners
preferred reference under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act before the LAC
on 22.12.2008. The said application was kept pending. In the meanwhile,
the other landowners being aggrieved of the Award dated 02.05.2008,
approached this Court having filed Regular First Appeal, which were
disposed of on different dates; one such RFA No.1233 of 2017 titled
Durgi Devi and others vs. Punjab State and others' decided on
16.03.2017 vide which the market value was enhanced to Rs. 1754/- per
malra for the acquired land pertaining to the village Kot Tikka Majra.
Further the appeals preferred at the instance of the respondents were
dismissed by the Hon'ble Apex Court vide judgment dated 20.09.2017.
[5].
value
On the basis of the aforesaid final determination of the market
qua
the
present
acquisition
proceedings,
the
petitioners/landowners moved an application dated 28.12.2017 before
respondent No.2 for Award of similar compensation being identically
placed landowners of the same acquisition proceedings. The said prayer
came to be dismissed by respondent No.2 vide order dated 24.08.2021
while holding that the application filed by the petitioners, under Section
28-A of the 1894 Act was barred by limitation.
[6].
Impugning the aforesaid order, learned counsel for the
petitioners submits that once during pendency of the application
preferred under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act before respondent No.2,
the final determination qua the market value stood adjudicated upon by
this Court to the tune of Rs.1754/- per marla; in view of decision made by
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.03.19 09:36
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-38661-2025
the Hon'ble Apex Court in case of “Banwari and others VS. Haryana
State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited
(HSIIDC) and another” reported as "2025(1) RCR (Civil) 232", the
petitioners/landowners should have been awarded the same market
value and as such the impugned order passed by respondent No.2 was
liable to be set aside.
[7]
On the other hand, learned State counsel submits that once
the application dated 22.12.2008 preferred under Section 28-A of the
1984 Act at the instance of the petitioners/landowners was beyond 90
days of the learned Reference Court Award dated 02.05.2008, the same
was rightly declined being barred by limitation and as such the impugned
order calls for no interference.
[8].
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
paper book. I find substance in the submissions made on behalf of the
petitioners/landowners.
[9].
In the given facts, the application preferred under Section 28-
A of the 1894 Act at the instance of the petitioners/landowners was filed
on 22.12.2008 based on one Reference Court Award dated 02.05.2008.
Though the same was beyond 90 days, however it was kept pending by
respondent No.2 and in the meanwhile this Court vide its decision dated
16.03.2017 passed in the case of Durgi Devi and others' (supra)
assessed the market value @ Rs.1754/- per marla for the land pertaining
to the same revenue estate and relating to the same acquisition
proceedings. The final determination made by this Court gave fresh
cause to the petitioners/landowners in terms of law laid down by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Banwari and others' (supra). Relevant
paragraph Nos.15 & 16 thereof are extracted hereunder:-
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.03.19 09:36
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-38661-2025
"15.
In the present case, it is not in dispute that the First Appeal
which was allowed by the High Court vide judgment and order dated 2nd
May 2016 was in respect of the land which was covered by the same
notification under which notification the appellants' land is also covered.
It is also not in dispute that the amount awarded by the High Court in the
said First Appeal is in excess of the amount awarded by the Collector
under Section 11 of the 1894 Act in the case of the land of the
appellants. It is also not in dispute that the appellants had not made an
application to the Collector under Section 18 of the 1894 Act. It is also
not in dispute that the application made by the appellants under Section
28-A of the 1894 Act to the Collector was within a period of three months
from the date of the judgment and order of the High court
16.
From the perusal of the judgment of this Court in the case of
Pradeep Kumari (supra), it is clear that the limitation for moving the
application under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act will begin to run only from
the date of the award on the basis of which redetermination of the
compensation is sought. The appellants are seeking redetermination of
the compensation on the basis of the judgment and order of the High
Court in First Appeal No. 429 of 2023 dated 2nd May 2016. It is not
disputed that the application of the appellants under Section 28-A of the
1894 Act is within a period of three months from 2nd May 2016."
Further the decision made in the case of Banwari and
others (supra) has also been followed by the Division Bench of this
Court in case of “Union of India and another vs. The Special Land
Acquisition Collector-cum-Sub -Divisional Magistrate, Pathankot
and others, 2025(3) RCR (Civil) 786”.
[10].
As such, once the application preferred under Section 28-A of
the 1894 Act, filed at the instance of the petitioners/landowners was
pending adjudication with respondent No.2 and during such period this
Court made the assessment of market value @ Rs.1754/- per marla vide
its decision dated 16.03.2017 passed in the case of Durgi Devi and
others' (supra) which even was upheld by the Hon'ble Apex Court while
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.03.19 09:36
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-38661-2025
dismissing the appeal preferred by the respondents/State vide its order
dated 20.09.2017, the application preferred under Section 28-A of the
1894 Act at the instance of the petitioners/landowners was required to be
adjudicated upon based on the final determination qua the amount of
compensation, rather than making them prefer fresh application based on
the determination made by this Court for which they were entitled in view
of decision rendered in case of Banwari and others (supra). Thus, the
pending application filed under Section 28-A of the 1894 Act could not
have been rejected by any means, being barred by limitation as the final
determination was made by this Court @ Rs.1754/- per marla on
16.03.2017 and on the said date the said application preferred at the
instance of the petitioners/landowners was pending adjudication with
respondent No.2. In fact, keeping in mind the principle of the landowners
being entitled for just, fair and equal compensation against compulsory
acquisition of their land, respondent No.2 was required to adopt a
pragmatic approach so as to further the object, purpose and intent of the
statutory provision enacted by the Legislature in the form of Section 28-A
of the 1894 Act, rather than taking a hyper-technical approach, thereby
causing prejudice to the rights of the petitioners-landowners.
[11].
In view of aforesaid discussion, the present writ petition is
allowed and the impugned dated 24.08.2021 passed by the Sub
Divisional
Magistrate-cum-Land
Acquisition
Collector,
RSD
and
Shahpurkandi Dam Project, Shahpurkandi Township is hereby set aside,
The petitioners/landowners are held entitled for award of similar benefit
of market value @ Rs. 1754/- per marla besides award of all other
statutory benefits and interest as provided under the provisions of the
1894 Act (amended upto date). The due amount be released in favour of
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.03.19 09:36
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-38661-2025
petitioners/landowners within two months from today or else respondent
No.2 shall be liable to pay cost of Rs.1 lakh to the petitioners for causing
delay. The cost shall be borne by respondent No.2 from his/her own
pocket and be not treated as burden upon the State Exchequer.
[12]
16.03.2026
Tejwinder
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.03.19 09:36
I agree to specified portions
of this document
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(HARKESH MANUJA)
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned
Yes/No
Whether reportable
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review