Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision : 15.01.2026
W.P.(C) 6833/2013
VIJAY KUMAR BAHL
....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Ujala Vishnoi and Mr. Randeep
Singh, Advs.
+
versus
DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Shobhana Takiar, SC
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JASMEET SINGH
:
JASMEET SINGH, J (ORAL)
1.
This is a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, seeking the following prayers:
“(a) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari and mandamus
or any other appropriate writ order or direction thereby
directing the Respondent to produce the records pertaining
to the Petitioner before this Hon'ble Court;
(b) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari and mandamus or
any other appropriate writ order or direction thereby
quashing the letter dated 10.6.2013 issued by the
Respondent and to revive the registration of the Petitioner
to its original number.
(c) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari and mandamus or
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
any other appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
directing the Respondent to include the name of the
Petitioner in a draw of lots and to allot a MIG Flat in the
same locality as allotted in the draw of lots held on 9.7.1994
to the Petitioner upon payment of demand by the
Petitioner.”
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner registered himself
under the New Pattern Registration Scheme-1979 floated by the respondent.
The aforesaid housing scheme offered public to get themselves registered
therein and own flats to be constructed by the respondent authority. The
policy formulated three categories of registrants namely MIG, LIG and Janta
depending on the income range of the registrants. The petitioner on
10.09.1979 registered himself under the MIG category, by paying the
requisite fee of Rs. 4,500/- as the registration amount. The respondent
thereafter issued a deposit receipt and a Certificate of Registration.
3.
Under the said Registration Form, there were two columns for address
i.e. one for residential address and another was for occupational address.
The petitioner in the column for residential address filled up his address as
“H.No.35/C, MIG Flats, Ph-III, Pkt.-C, Ashok Vihar, New Delhi- 110052”
and in the occupational address column gave his business address as “1/27,
Nicholson Road, Kashmere Gate, Delhi-6”. The deposit receipt dated
10.09.1979 provided by the respondent mentioned the occupational address
of the petitioner and the Certificate of Registration bearing registration No.
6853, dated 28.03.1980 mentioned the residential address of the petitioner.
Thereafter, in 1980, the respondent authority issued a letter to the petitioner,
addressed at his occupational address, instructing him to collect the
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
documents.
4.
In pursuance of the draw of lots conducted, the petitioner was issued a
demand letter dated 09.07.1994 at his residential address, which was
returned as undelivered because the petitioner had vacated the said
residential property. In 1997, for the first time vide letter dated 15.07.1997
the petitioner informed the respondent regarding the change of his
residential address from “H.No 35/C MIG Flats, Phase 3 Pocket-C-Ashok
Vihar, Delhi- 52” to “ED-43-C, MIG Flats, Pkt.C, Ashok Vihar, Pitampura,
Delhi”. Thereafter, the petitioner raised multiple representations before
several authorities for change of residential address but to no avail. Though
the letter dated 06.03.2000 mentioned the letter dated 15.07.1997, however,
the letter of 15.07.1997 is not on record. Hence the first letter informing the
respondent about the petitioner’s change of address filed before the Court is
dated 06.03.2000. The letter dated 06.03.2000 reads as under:
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
5.
The petitioner was informed by the respondent, subsequently, to make
representation to the respondent for cancellation of his allotment. After
several representations being made before several authorities, on
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
30.08.2012, the respondent instructed the petitioner to deposit ownership
proof of his residential and the occupational properties. The required
documents were duly furnished by the petitioner.
6.
Ultimately, the respondent vide letter dated 10.6.2013 informed the
petitioner that N.P.R.S., 1979 has been closed in November, 2012 and
hence, his request for allotment of flat has been rejected by the competent
authority.
7.
Hence, the present petition has been filed before this court.
8.
Ms. Vishnoi, learned counsel for the petitioner, states that in the
present case, no show cause or cancellation notice or no opportunity of
personal hearing was afforded by the respondent. Moreover, the show cause
and cancellation notice also were not issued at both the addresses of the
petitioner, which were available with the respondent on their official file and
hence, the petition needs to be allowed.
9.
Mr. Singh, learned counsel for the respondent, raises the objection the
case of the petitioner is barred by delay and latches. The petitioner was
aware of the allotment in the year 1994 and despite being fully aware and
despite making a representation in the year 2004, the petitioner has only
approached the court in the year 2013.
10.
He further draws my attention to a letter dated 07.10.2005 and states
that the letter clearly shows that the respondent had accordingly informed
the petitioner to apply for return of the registration money. Hence, by
implication as well, the allotment had been cancelled. The said letter was
addressed at “1/27, Nicholson Road, Kashmere Gate, Delhi-6”, which is the
occupational address of the petitioner which reads as under:
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
11.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties and perused the material
on record.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
12.
The observations of the Division Bench of this Court in D.D.A. vs.
Mahinder Pal Sikri passed in LPA No.743/2013 are relevant and read as
under:
“17. The DDA admits that the occupational address of all
the writ petitioners was available on its file (with two
exceptions, i.e. LPA 346/2013 and 369/2013). This being the
case, it is clear that an obligation lay on the DDA to attempt
to inform the writ petitioners’ at all available addresses,
rather than substitute this obligation for a press notice.
Indeed, neither the decisions of the Supreme Court in Wazir
Chand (supra) and Banda Development Authority, Banda
(supra) nor the various judgments of this Court relied upon
by the DDA displace this principle, on which the learned
Single Judge rightly based his decision. Indeed, as regards
the two appeals mentioned above wherein there was only
one address, it is admitted by the DDA that the letters were
sent to the wrong addresses through mistakes of the DDA's
clerks, and crucially, for no fault of the writ petitioners.
After those letters came back undelivered, the DDA did not,
at any point, try to go into the matter to determine whether
indeed the letters were sent to the wrong addresses. In such
a case, it does not lie in the DDA's mouth to claim that the
writ petitioners’ are liable to suffer, and their allotments be
cancelled, on account of a mistake committed by the DDA
itself.”
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
13.
A perusal of the aforesaid paragraphs shows that the respondent is
under the obligation to issue notices to all the addresses available on the
record file of the respondent.
14.
In the present case, the registration receipt dated 10.09.1979 and the
registration certificate dated 28.03.1980 clear shows that both occupational
and residential addresses of the petitioner, i.e., “1/27, Nicholson Road,
Kashmere Gate, Delhi-6” and “H.No.35/C, MIG Flats, Ph-lll, Pkt.-C, Ashok
Vihar, New Delhi- 110052” respectively, were available with the
respondent.
15.
The notice dated 01.03.1996, handed over in court today, clearly
shows that the same was only addressed to the residential address and not
the occupational address. The same is reproduced below:
“DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
NO. Mo 41 (773) 94/DW/NP
FROM ASST DIRECTOR (Н)
D.D.A.
New Delhi
To
:
Sh. Vijay Kumar Bahl
H.No 35/C MIG Flats, Phase 3
Pocket-C-Ashok Vihar, Delhi- 52
NOTICE
1. Whereas you have been allotted a MIG flat bearing No.
373 in Sector 19 Pkt. 3 Phase I at Second floor in Dwarka
(Scheme) Delhi/New Delhi against Registration No. 6853
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
under Registration Scheme for New Pattern, 1979 under the
Delhi Development Authority (Management & Disposal of
Housing Estates) Regulations, 1968, through draw of lots
held on 21-3-94.
2. And whereas it was mandatory on your part to pay the
demanded amount and to furnish the required documents by
7-10-94 in accordance with the terms & conditions as
stipulated in the Demand-cum- Allotment letter dt. 5-7-94-97-94.
3. And whereas you have not deposited the said amounts
and failed to furnish the required documents mentioned at S.
No.____ of the Demand-cum-allotment letter within the
stipulated period and thus, committed a breach of terms &
conditions of the aforesaid demand-cum-allotment letter.
4. Now, therefore, I Padam Singh, Asst. Director (H), DDA
hereby call upon you to show cause, within 15 days from the
date of issuance of this letter as to why the allotment of the
aforesaid flat be not cancelled for breach of terms &
conditions of allotment. If no reply is received within the
above period, the allotment of flat shall be cancelled
without any further reference to you and the amount of
regn. after deducting ____ will be refunded to you in terms
of clause of the terms/condition of the allotment letter dt. 57-94-9-7-94 (Pl. strike whichever is in applicable).
Аsst. Director (H)”
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
16.
Similarly, the cancellation letter dated 16.05.1996 is also not
addressed to the occupational address of the respondent. The same reads as
under:
“DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
HOUSING/MIG
F 41 (773) 94/DW/NP)
Dated: 16.05.96
Sh.
Vijay Kumar Behl
H.No 35/C MIG Flats, Phase 3
Pocket-C-Ashok Vihar, Delhi- 52
Sub : Cancellation of flat No. 373 Pocket 3 Dwarka, (MIG),
Sector ______ in Residential Scheme.
Sir/Madam,
Kindly refer to your letter dated _____ vide which
you have requested for cancellation of above said flat and
further requested for registration kept alive for further
allotment.
In this connection, I am directed to inform you that due to
non
payment/non
submission
of
documents
registration/allotment have since been cancelled as per your
request. As far as your request to keep registration kept
alive for further allotment, it is to inform you that same
cannot be acceded to per policy.
You are therefore advised to kindly surrender your all the
original documents, i.e., F.D.R. in original duly discharged
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
by affixing 1.00 Revenue Stamp, registration card in
original and 4th copy of challan so that your case for refund
of earnest money can be processed.
Yours faithfully
Asstt. Director (MIG)
N.P. (H)”
17.
The representation of the petitioner dated 29.04.2004 is reproduced
below and reads as under:
“The Vice Chancellor,
1496-C
Delhi Development Authority,
29.04
Vikas Sadan,
Delhi
Subject: “For registration scheme of New pattern (1979)
(HUDDCO) Reg. No. 6853 dt. 10.09.79 receipt No. 135350
of Rs. 4550 SNRT No. 17997
File No. 41/773/94/Dwarka
Sir,
Once again I have come with a request to go through my
case which is still outstanding even after gone for a number
of transactions with the concerned dept.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
The brief summary of the case is once again given below for
ready reference please:Acknowledgment receipt of Rs. 4500/- and the information
to collect the registration from DDA was received by us on
29.02.80 at our postal address (correspondence address)
1/27., Nicholson Road, Kashmiri Gate. Certificate of
registration was received with our old residential address
on 29.03.80. But the correspondence address was same as
mentioned above, as we are living in a rental house. Draw
was held on 09.07.1994. I was unaware of it as I was out of
station at the time due to my professional tour.
Any letter of allotment might have been sent on our old
residential address instead of our postal address which was
never received by us because we have changed our
residence and shifted to Pritampura by that time. It came to
my notice in June,1997, when next draw of DDA was held
since then I am in contact with DDA. A lot of oral
conversation had gone with the concerned dept. And I
submitted a reminder and a change of residential address to
the concerned department as advised by dept. people.
Since that day, a game of hide and seek is being going on
with me. Every time I was given the assurance of solving the
case by concerned person of the dept. After 3 years, again I
have a written note to them but in vain. No reply was
received by me. Once again I gave a request to kindly
reconsider my case in the upcoming scheme of adults in
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
Dwarka itself just to transfer our priority to any other draw.
Once again a draw of DDA flats of (1979) came to my
notice in the newspaper. On 19th March, 2004, again I came
to DDA office to make one more request. Here I came in
contact with public officer who was ...... a good favour and
suggested me to meet your excellence. Sir, on Wednesday
and once again I am here with a new hope and positive
response from your side.
Thanking you.
Sincerely Yours
Vijay Kumar Bahl
Usha Bahl (Wife)”
18.
A perusal of the aforesaid representation clearly shows that the same
is only seeking an audience from the respondent and does not indicate that
the petitioner was aware of the cancellation made by the respondent.
Additionally, the respondents have time and again called the petitioner for
personal appearance with all the documents. If the allotment already stood
cancelled there was no requirement to call the petitioner as late as on
25.04.2012 with the documents showing his address.
19.
The documents on record do not seem to suggest that the respondent
indicated or that the petitioner knew that the allotment of the petitioner had
been cancelled. Even the letter dated 07.10.2005 shows that the petitioner
was to requested to apply for refund of the registration money and there was
no mention of the cancellation letter.
20.
It was only on 10.06.2013 that the petitioner was informed that his
request of allotment of flat has been rejected by the authority on account of
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
closure of the said scheme. Thereafter, the petitioner has approached this
court through the present petition. In view of the above, it is evident that the
petitioner approached the court immediately on becoming aware of the
cancellation and the petition is not barred by delay and laches.
21.
Further, the alleged cancellation notice dated 16.05.1996 issued by the
respondent has not been sent to both the addresses, i.e. residential and
occupational, as provided by the petitioner. As held in, Mahinder Pal Sikri
(supra), the respondent while issuing a cancellation notice is under an
obligation to send the same to all the address available with the respondent.
It is an admitted fact that the occupational address of “1/27, Nicholson Road,
Kashmere Gate, Delhi-6” was available with the respondent and also that
the show cause notice and cancellation notice was not sent on this address.
22.
For the said reasons, the petition is allowed and the respondent is,
hereby, directed to allot an alternate flat to the petitioner in accordance with
law.
23.
It is directed that a similar flat in terms of his entitlement be allotted
to the petitioner. The payment for flat allotted shall be made as per the
applicable rate on the date of filing the writ petition, i.e., 30.10.2013 as held
in paragraph No. 18 of the judgment of Mahinder Pal Sikri (supra), which
reads as under:
“18. Equally, the holdings in the various decisions on the
appeal present that that the payment for the plot will be made
as per the price on the date of filing the writ, and not as per
the Circular dated 13.10.2011, cannot be faulted, given the
established principle to the effect that the clock in terms of the
price to be paid stops at the time of approaching the Court for
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
the appropriate remedy, and the matter at that point rests with
the Court and not in the hands of the writ petitioners.”
24.
The calculation shall be given within 4 weeks from today and the
petitioner shall make the payment and submit documents for verification
within 4 weeks thereafter. The allotment shall be made as per the policy of
the DDA.
25.
The petition is disposed of with pending applications, if any.
JASMEET SINGH, J
JANUARY 15, 2026/AS
(corrected and released on 22.01.2026)
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
20:56:50
W.P. (C) 6833/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review