Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 6th May, 2026
Pronounced on: 01st July, 2026.
Uploaded on: 01st July, 2026.
+
W.P.(C) 15601/2024 & CM APPLs. 65495/2024, 65497/2024,
5696/2025, 27449/2025
VIJAY BISHNOI
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Gautam Narayan, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Sanjiv Kr. Saxena,
Mr. Ramneek Mishra, Mr. Mukesh
Kumar Tiwari and Ms. Asmita Singh,
Advocates.
versus
COMPETITION COMMISSION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vinay Kumar Garg, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Ankur Chhibber,
Mr. Shlok Chandra, Mr. Parikshit
Singh Bhati, Mr. K.S. Rekhi and Ms.
Lolita Crasta for CCI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J.:
1.
The Petitioner, an officer of the Competition Commission of India1,
challenges the memorandum of charge dated 3rd October, 2023 issued under
Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. The charge arises from allegations that he
tampered with statements recorded during search and seizure proceedings
conducted by the office of the Director General, CCI.
2.
At this stage, the Court is not concerned with the correctness of the
allegations or the merits of the disciplinary proceedings. The controversy is
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
confined to the validity of the charge memorandum and the manner in which
it came to be issued.
3.
It is not in dispute that CCI is the competent Disciplinary Authority in
relation to the Petitioner. The record discloses that CCI approved initiation
of major penalty proceedings against the Petitioner on 27 th June, 2023, and
thereafter approved a draft charge-sheet on 4th August, 2023. The matter was
subsequently referred to the Central Vigilance Commission,2 which rendered
its first-stage advice on 25th September, 2023, following which the charge
memorandum was issued on 3rd October, 2023.
4.
The principal issue is therefore narrow but determinative: after receipt
of CVC’s first-stage advice, was the matter required to be placed before CCI
again for fresh approval before the charge memorandum could issue? The
answer determines the validity of the impugned disciplinary proceedings.
Factual background
5.
The Petitioner was working as Deputy Director (Law) in the
Competition Commission of India. The disciplinary proceedings arise from
allegations concerning tampering of statements recorded during search and
seizure proceedings conducted by the office of the Director General, CCI, in
Case No. 35/2020. In April, 2023, complaints and internal communications
were received alleging that statements recorded during the said search and
seizure had been tampered with. A preliminary enquiry was thereafter
conducted. The Petitioner was placed under suspension by order dated 19 th
May, 2023.
6.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
The matter was placed before the Commission in its special meeting
“CCI”
“CVC”
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
held on 27th June, 2023. The meeting was attended by the Chairperson and
two Members. Agenda Item No. 6 concerned departmental proceedings in a
case relating to tampering of statements recorded during search and seizure.
The Commission decided that major penalty proceedings under Rule 14 of
the CCS (CCA) Rules be initiated against the Petitioner. The Commission
also directed that the draft charge-sheet in the matter be placed before it. It
further directed that explanation be sought from certain other officers
regarding their respective conduct in handling the case.
7.
The draft charge-sheet was thereafter placed before the Commission
in its special meeting held on 4th August, 2023. This meeting was also
attended by the Chairperson and two Members. Agenda Item No. 1
concerned departmental proceedings against the Petitioner in the same
matter. The minutes record the decision of the Commission in the following
terms:
“The Commission approved the draft charge sheet for instituting major
penalty proceedings under Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 against Shri
Vijay Bishnoi, Deputy Director (Law) for tampering the statements,
recorded during search & seizure.”
8.
The Commission also directed that necessary action be taken for
constituting the Review Committee for reviewing the suspension of the
Petitioner.
9.
After approval of the draft charge-sheet by the Commission, the
matter was referred to CVC for first-stage advice. By office memorandum
dated 25th September, 2023, CVC recorded that it had examined the case
and, in agreement with the recommendation of the CVO and DA, CCI,
advised initiation of major penalty proceedings against the Petitioner under
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. CVC also advised digitisation of
documents relating to search and seizure and indicated timelines for
appointment of the Inquiry Officer and Presenting Officer and completion of
the inquiry.
10.
Upon receipt of the CVC advice, the matter was processed internally
on 29th September, 2023. The noting recorded that the Commission, being
the Disciplinary Authority, had approved institution of major penalty
proceedings against the Petitioner in its meeting held on 27th June, 2023 and
that the draft charge-sheet had also been approved by the Commission in its
meeting held on 4th August, 2023. The noting further recorded the advice
tendered by CVC on 25th September, 2023. The file was then placed before
the Chairperson.
11.
On 3rd October, 2023, the Chairperson recorded as follows:
“Draft Chargesheet as approved by the Commission and CVC may be
issued. It may be ensured that every page of the chargesheet is duly signed.”
12.
The Chairperson also directed that digitisation of documents
pertaining to the case be undertaken. The memorandum of charge was
thereafter issued to the Petitioner on 3rd October, 2023.
13.
During the course of the proceedings, the Petitioner sought copies of
the file, file notings, agenda papers and minutes of meetings culminating in
the memorandum of charge dated 3rd October, 2023. He thereafter instituted
W.P.(C) 1097/2024 challenging, inter alia, the appointment of the Inquiry
Officer and seeking appointment of an independent officer to conduct the
inquiry. The said petition was disposed of as withdrawn by order dated 25 th
January, 2024, with liberty to raise all contentions at the relevant stage of the
inquiry proceedings.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
14.
The Petitioner again sought the aforesaid records under the Right to
Information Act, 2005. Pursuant thereto, he was supplied, on 7 th June, 2024,
the agenda papers and minutes relating to the meetings of the Commission
held on 4th August, 2023 and 3rd November, 2023. The Petitioner thereafter
instituted W.P.(C) 10135/2024, assailing, inter alia, the memorandum of
charge dated 3rd October, 2023, the order dated 14th June, 2024 whereby his
defence was closed, and the order rejecting his objection to the Inquiry
Officer.
15.
W.P.(C) 10135/2024 was disposed of as withdrawn by order dated
26th July, 2024, with liberty to the Petitioner to raise his objections and
contentions at the appropriate stage of the inquiry proceedings. The
Petitioner, thereafter, submitted a representation dated 13th August, 2024
before the Disciplinary Authority, contending, inter alia, that the
memorandum of charge had not been approved by the competent
Disciplinary Authority in accordance with Rule 14(3) of the CCS (CCA)
Rules. The representation was rejected by CCI by order dated 30 th
September, 2024. Aggrieved, the present writ petition has been filed
challenging the memorandum of charge dated 3rd October, 2023, the order
dated 30th September, 2024, and consequential disciplinary proceedings.
Submissions on behalf of the Petitioner
16.
Mr. Gautam Narayan, Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, assails the
validity of the memorandum of charge dated 3rd October, 2023 on several
grounds, which may be summarised as follows:
16.1. The Petitioner does not invite the Court, at this stage, to examine
whether the allegation of tampering is true or false. The challenge is to the
jurisdictional validity. The submission is that the charge memo was issued
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
without approval of the competent Disciplinary Authority and is therefore
non est.
16.2. The Petitioner was appointed by CCI. On a conjoint reading of
Section 17 of the Competition Act, 2002 and Rule 12 of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, the Commission is the Disciplinary Authority. Once the Commission
is the Disciplinary Authority, the requirement under Rule 14(3) that the
Disciplinary Authority shall “draw up or cause to be drawn up” the articles
of charge cannot be satisfied by approval of the Chairperson acting alone.
16.3. The distinction between approval for initiation of disciplinary
proceedings and approval of the charge memo is now firmly settled. Rule
14(3) of the CCS (CCA) Rules embodies a jurisdictional safeguard requiring
approval of the charge memorandum by the competent Disciplinary
Authority. A charge memorandum issued without such approval is legally
unsustainable and cannot be cured by subsequent conduct or participation in
the inquiry proceedings. In this regard, reliance is placed on Union of India
v. B.V. Gopinath,3 State of Tamil Nadu v. Promod Kumar,4 Sunny
Abraham v. Union of India,5 Union of India v. R.K. Nim,6 Union of India
v. S.K. Jasra,7 and Dr. Sahadeva Singh v. Union of India.8
16.4. Developing
this
submission,
Mr.
Narayan
argues
that
the
Commission’s decision dated 27th June, 2023 was confined to initiation of
major penalty proceedings. The minutes themselves directed that the draft
charge-sheet be placed before the Commission. This shows that the
(2014) 1 SCC 351.
(2018) 17 SCC 677.
(2021) 20 SCC 12.
2024 SCC OnLine Del 7712.
2025:DHC:8985.
2016:DHC:4918-DB.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
Commission was conscious that initiation and approval of the charge-sheet
were separate stages. The subsequent decision dated 4th August, 2023,
cannot be treated as the final approval contemplated by Rule 14(3), because
the matter was yet to be placed before CVC for first-stage advice. The
disciplinary process had therefore not reached its final point for issuance of
the charge memo.
16.5. Reliance is placed on the DoPT office memorandum dated 29 th
November, 2012 and A.M. Kulshrestha v. Union Bank of India & Ors.9 to
contend that, upon receipt of CVC’s first-stage advice, the matter was
required to be placed before the Disciplinary Authority for an independent
decision. This requirement ensures that the Disciplinary Authority applies its
own mind to the CVC advice and does not act mechanically upon it. In the
present case, while CVC rendered its advice on 25th September, 2023, the
matter was placed only before the Chairperson and not before the
Commission acting as the Disciplinary Authority. The charge memorandum,
therefore, was issued without the approval required in law.
16.6. The CVC advice dated 25th September, 2023 cannot cure this defect.
CVC is not the Disciplinary Authority. Its advice, whether called first-stage
advice or otherwise, is only advisory. The final decision must remain with
the Disciplinary Authority. CVC’s concurrence with the proposal, therefore,
cannot be treated as a substitute for approval by the Commission.
16.7. Further, Section 13 of the Competition Act, 2002, which confers
powers of general superintendence, direction and control over administrative
matters on the Chairperson, cannot be read to transfer the disciplinary power
of the Commission to the Chairperson. Administrative superintendence
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
cannot override the statutory and service-rule requirement that the
Disciplinary Authority must approve the charge memo.
16.8. Further reliance is placed on Dr. Sahadeva Singh to submit that even
where a department contends that draft charges were before the competent
authority at the stage of initiation, the Court must examine the file to see
whether the charge memo was actually approved by the Disciplinary
Authority. It is urged that the internal noting dated 29 th September, 2023,
which placed the draft charge-sheet for “approval” of the Chairperson, itself
shows that the authorities did not treat the earlier Commission decision as
final approval of the charge memo. If the Commission had already approved
the charge memo for issuance, there was no occasion to seek approval from
the Chairperson.
16.9. On maintainability, it is argued that the writ petition cannot be
rejected as premature. Union of India & Anr. V. Kunisetty Satyanarayana10
itself recognises that a writ court may interfere with a charge-sheet where it
is wholly without jurisdiction or otherwise wholly illegal. The present
challenge, falls within that exception. Nor is the petition barred by res
judicata or constructive res judicata. The earlier writ petitions were not
decided on merits on the present issue and the Petitioner was granted liberty
to raise available contentions at the appropriate stage. Reliance is placed on
V.D. Barot v. State of Gujarat,11 Mathura Prasad Bajoo Jaiswal v.
Dossibai N.B. Jeejeebhoy,12 and Srihari Hanumandas Totala v. Hemant
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1177.
(2006) 12 SCC 28.
(2002) 10 SCC 668.
(1970) 1 SCC 613.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
Vithal Kamat.13
16.10. The Petitioner further contends that the disciplinary proceedings have
been conducted in violation of principles of natural justice. Despite repeated
requests, several documents necessary for his defence have not been
supplied. Although the Inquiry Officer directed supply of certain documents
sought by the Petitioner, only a fraction thereof was furnished, while others
were withheld on varying grounds including confidentiality, non-availability
and non-existence. The non-supply of these documents has caused serious
prejudice to his ability to effectively defend himself in the inquiry.
Submissions on behalf of the Respondents
17.
Mr. V.K. Garg, senior counsel for the Respondents, submits that the
Petitioner’s challenge rests on an incorrect reading of the record and is not
sustainable on the following grounds:
17.1. It is not disputed that the Commission is the Disciplinary Authority. It
is also not disputed that approval of the charge memo by the Disciplinary
Authority is required where Rule 14(3) applies. The Respondents’ case is
that such approval was in fact granted.
17.2. The Commission first considered the matter in its meeting held on
27th June, 2023. In that meeting, the Commission approved initiation of
major penalty proceedings against the Petitioner and directed that the draft
charge-sheet be placed before it. Pursuant to that direction, the draft chargesheet was placed before the Commission in its special meeting held on 4 th
August, 2023. The minutes of that meeting expressly record that the
Commission approved the draft charge-sheet for instituting major penalty
proceedings under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules against the Petitioner.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
(2021) 9 SCC 99.
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
This shows direct and sufficient compliance with Rule 14(3).
17.3. The charge-sheet approved by the Commission on 4th August, 2023
was thereafter forwarded to CVC for first-stage advice along with the
relevant documents. CVC examined the matter and, by office memorandum
dated 25th September, 2023, agreed with the recommendation of CVO and
DA, CCI, and advised initiation of major penalty proceedings. CVC
suggested no change in the draft charge-sheet. The Respondents emphasise
that the charge memo ultimately issued to the Petitioner on 3rd October,
2023 was the same as the draft charge-sheet approved by the Commission
on 4th August, 2023.
17.4. On this basis, it is submitted that there was no occasion to place the
very same draft charge-sheet before the Commission again after receipt of
CVC advice. The Disciplinary Authority had already applied its mind and
approved the draft charge-sheet. CVC made no alteration. The later step was
therefore only issuance of the approved charge memo, not fresh approval of
the charge memo.
17.5. The Chairperson’s noting dated 3rd October, 2023 has to be read in
this context. The Chairperson did not purport to approve the charge memo as
Disciplinary Authority. The noting states that the “Draft Chargesheet as
approved by the Commission and CVC may be issued.” This recognises the
prior approval of the Commission and merely directs administrative
issuance. Section 13 of the Competition Act, 2002 empowers the
Chairperson to exercise general superintendence, direction and control in
respect of administrative matters of the Commission. Issuance of a charge
memo already approved by the Commission falls within that administrative
domain.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
17.6. The Petitioner’s reliance on B.V. Gopinath and the decisions
following it is misplaced on facts. Those cases involved absence of approval
of the charge memo by the competent Disciplinary Authority. In the present
case, the Commission specifically approved the draft charge-sheet on 4th
August, 2023. B.V. Gopinath supports the requirement of approval, but does
not assist the Petitioner once the record shows that approval was granted.
17.7. Reliance is also placed on State of Jharkhand v. Rukma Kesh
Mishra,14 to submit that B.V. Gopinath does not lay down an inflexible rule
and must be applied in the context of the governing statutory framework and
the factual record of each case. Once the draft charge-sheet had been
expressly approved by the Commission in its meeting dated 4 th August,
2023, the charge memorandum cannot be invalidated on a technical
objection regarding approval.
17.8. The Respondents also rely on The Chairman, Central Board of
Trustees v. M. Vijayaraj15 to submit that CVC advice is advisory and not a
prior approval. The requirement of CVC consultation cannot be conflated
with the jurisdictional requirement of approval by the Disciplinary
Authority. The Respondents submit that the DoPT office memorandum
dated 29th November, 2012 does not create a second mandatory approval
stage where the Disciplinary Authority has already approved the draft
charge-sheet and CVC has suggested no modification.
17.9. The present writ petition is barred by principles analogous to res
judicata and constructive res judicata. The Petitioner had earlier challenged
various aspects of the disciplinary proceedings in W.P.(C) 1097/2024 and
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
2025 SCC OnLine SC 676.
2011:DHC:5642-DB.
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
W.P.(C) 10135/2024 and, having withdrawn those proceedings, cannot be
permitted to re-agitate the same issues in the present petition. In any event,
writ interference at the stage of a charge-sheet is exceptional. The
Petitioner’s grievances relating to supply of documents, appreciation of
evidence, examination of witnesses and conduct of the inquiry are matters to
be urged before the Inquiry Officer or the Disciplinary Authority and do not
furnish a ground to quash the charge memorandum at the threshold.
Points for determination
18.
On the basis of the pleadings and submissions advanced, the
following points arise for determination:
(i)
whether the present writ petition is barred by res judicata,
constructive res judicata, or by reason of the earlier withdrawal of writ
proceedings.
(ii)
whether the memorandum of charge dated 3rd October, 2023 is void
for want of approval by the Commission as the Disciplinary Authority under
Rule 14(3) of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
(iii)
whether, after receipt of CVC’s first-stage advice dated 25th
September, 2023, the matter was required to be placed again before the
Commission before issuance of the charge memo.
(iv)
whether the Chairperson’s direction dated 3rd October, 2023 amounted
to an impermissible exercise of disciplinary power vested in the
Commission, or was merely an administrative direction for issuance of a
charge memo already approved by the Commission.
(v)
what relief, if any, should follow.
Analysis and findings
Maintainability and scope of interference
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
19.
The judicial principles relating to scope of interference, at the initial
stage of disciplinary proceedings are well settled. A memorandum of charge
does not, by itself, warrant interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution.16 A charge-sheet marks the commencement, not the
culmination, of disciplinary proceedings. At that stage, neither has any
finding of guilt been recorded nor any penalty imposed, and the proceedings
may yet be dropped. Kunisetty Satyanarayana states this restraint in clear
terms. At the same time, the decision recognises a limited exception where
the challenge goes to jurisdiction or alleges that the charge-sheet is wholly
without authority of law.
20.
The Petitioner’s objection falls within that limited category. His case
is not that the charge is factually unsustainable, but that the memorandum of
charge is non est because it was issued without approval of the competent
Disciplinary Authority. Whether that objection is ultimately made out must
be tested on the record. The petition cannot, therefore, be dismissed at the
threshold merely because it assails a charge memo.
21.
The plea of res judicata or constructive res judicata also does not
commend acceptance. The earlier writ petitions were not adjudicated on
merits on the issue now raised; they were withdrawn with liberty to urge
available contentions at the appropriate stage. The Petitioner thereafter
submitted a representation dated 13th August, 2024, which the Commission
rejected on 30th September, 2024. The present petition, therefore, does not
seek to re-agitate an issue previously decided between the parties. The Court
accordingly proceeds to examine the jurisdictional objection on merits.
Executive Engineer, Bihar State Housing Board v. Ramesh Kumar Singh (1996) 1 SCC 327; Special
Director v. Mohd. Ghulam Ghouse (2004) 3 SCC 440.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
Rule 14(3) and the authorities cited
22.
Rule 14(3) of the CCS (CCA) Rules provides that where it is
proposed to hold an inquiry against a government servant, the Disciplinary
Authority “shall draw up, or cause to be drawn up,” the substance of the
imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour into definite and distinct articles
of charge, together with a statement of imputations in support of each
article. Rule 14(4) then contemplates delivery to the charged officer of the
articles of charge, the statement of imputations, the list of documents and the
list of witnesses by which the charges are proposed to be proved.
23.
In B.V. Gopinath, the Supreme Court held that approval for initiation
of disciplinary proceedings is not the same as approval of the charge memo.
In that case, though initiation of major penalty proceedings had been
approved by the Finance Minister, the charge memo had not been placed
before him for approval. The Supreme Court rejected the contention that
approval for initiation would, by itself, include approval of the charge
memo.
24.
Promod Kumar and Sunny Abraham proceed on the same principle.
Where the governing rule requires the Disciplinary Authority to “draw up or
cause to be drawn up the articles of charge,” the requirement is not an empty
formality. Sunny Abraham further holds that a charge memo invalid at
inception for want of approval cannot be revived by post-facto approval.
25.
This Court has applied the same principle in R.K. Nim, and S.K.
Jasra. In R.K. Nim, the draft charge-sheet was not placed before the
competent authority for approval. In S.K. Jasra, the Court found absence of
approval of the charge memo by the Disciplinary Authority. Both decisions
turned on a factual defect going to the root of Rule 14(3).
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
26.
The Petitioner has also placed substantial reliance on Dr. Sahadeva
Singh. In that case, the department contended that the Minister’s approval
for initiation of disciplinary proceedings should also be treated as approval
of the draft charge-sheet. The Division Bench rejected that submission. It
found that a subsequent file note had expressly sought approval of the “draft
memo”, but the file was never thereafter placed before the Minister. That
circumstance, in the Court’s view, showed that approval of the charge
memorandum was still pending. On that basis, the charge memorandum was
quashed.
27.
The Respondents, on the other hand, rely on Rukma Kesh Mishra. In
that case, the Supreme Court cautioned against mechanical application of
B.V. Gopinath and Promod Kumar as precedents, emphasising that the
governing rules and factual matrix must be examined in each case. It held
that where the draft charge-sheet formed part of the proposal placed before
the competent authority, approval to initiate disciplinary proceedings could,
on the facts of that case, be read as approval of the draft charge-sheet as
well. The Court further observed that the expression “cause to be drawn up”
permits the Disciplinary Authority to have the charge-sheet prepared by
another authority and that, where such authority is superior to the charged
officer, courts ought ordinarily to exercise restraint.
28.
The authorities discussed above indicate that the question cannot be
answered merely by asking whether approval for initiation of disciplinary
proceedings was granted. Equally, it cannot be resolved by mechanically
applying B.V. Gopinath or Promod Kumar. The Court must examine the
governing rules, the material placed before the Disciplinary Authority, the
nature and scope of the approval granted, and whether the charge
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
memorandum ultimately issued can fairly be said to have received such
approval.
Application to the present record
29.
On the record placed before this Court, the Petitioner’s jurisdictional
objection cannot be accepted.
30.
The Commission, in its meeting dated 27th June, 2023, approved
initiation of major penalty proceedings against the Petitioner and directed
that the draft charge-sheet be placed before it. Had the matter rested there,
the Petitioner’s reliance on B.V. Gopinath and the line of authorities
following it would have required closer consideration, because approval of
initiation of proceedings, by itself, does not satisfy the requirement of Rule
14(3).
31.
The record, however, discloses a further and significant step. Pursuant
to the Commission’s direction, the draft charge-sheet was placed before it in
the special meeting held on 4th August, 2023. The minutes record that the
Commission “approved the draft charge sheet for instituting major penalty
proceedings under Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965” against the
Petitioner. The approval was thus directed not merely to the initiation of
proceedings but to the draft charge-sheet itself.
32.
This feature of the record distinguishes the present case from B.V.
Gopinath, Promod Kumar and the other decisions relied upon by the
Petitioner. In those cases, the defect lay in the absence of approval of the
charge memorandum by the competent Disciplinary Authority. Here, the
Commission not only approved initiation of proceedings; it also considered
and approved the draft charge-sheet placed before it on 4th August, 2023.
33.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
The Petitioner nevertheless submits that the Commission’s approval
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
dated 4th August, 2023 did not bring the approval process to a close. The
Petitioner argues that once CVC tendered its first-stage advice on 25th
September, 2023, the matter had to return to the Commission for a fresh and
independent decision before the charge memorandum could be issued. For
this proposition, reliance is placed on the DoPT Office Memorandum dated
29th November, 2012 and the decision of the Supreme Court in A.M.
Kulshrestha.
34.
The submission is not persuasive on the present record. The
requirement that the Disciplinary Authority must apply its own mind is a
substantive safeguard and not a mere formality of repeatedly endorsing the
same view. Where, after the Disciplinary Authority has approved a draft
charge-sheet, CVC’s first-stage advice introduces a material change, such as
modification of the articles of charge, alteration of the statement of
imputations, addition or deletion of relied-upon documents or witnesses, or
any other matter requiring reconsideration of the proposed disciplinary
action, the matter would ordinarily have to return to the Disciplinary
Authority. However, where CVC merely concurs with the proposal and the
charge memorandum ultimately issued is the same draft already approved by
the competent Disciplinary Authority, the legal requirement is satisfied.
Here, CVC’s advice dated 25th September, 2023 neither altered nor qualified
the draft charge-sheet approved by the Commission on 4th August, 2023.
35.
This conclusion is also consistent with the limited proposition for
which the Respondents rely upon M. Vijayaraj. Although that decision was
not concerned with the approval requirement under Rule 14(3) of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, its relevance lies in recognising the advisory character of
CVC’s first-stage advice and distinguishing such advice from a requirement
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
of approval. The decision-making authority continues to be the Disciplinary
Authority. CVC’s advice is an input in that process; it is not the source of
authority to issue the charge memorandum.
36.
Viewed in this light, the DoPT Office Memorandum dated 29th
November, 2012 cannot be read as mandating fresh approval of an
unchanged charge-sheet merely because CVC advice was received in the
intervening period. Its object is to ensure that the Disciplinary Authority
does not act mechanically on CVC’s advice, but independently retains
control over the decision to proceed departmentally. That safeguard is
satisfied where the Disciplinary Authority has already applied its mind to,
and approved, the draft charge-sheet, and the subsequent CVC advice
neither alters nor calls into question that draft.
37.
On the present record, the Commission approved the draft charge-
sheet on 4th August, 2023. The CVC advice dated 25th September, 2023 left
that draft undisturbed, without any alteration to the articles of charge, the
statement of imputations, the list of documents or the list of witnesses. The
charge memorandum thereafter issued on 3rd October, 2023 was, in
substance, the very same document. No fresh approval of the Commission
was therefore required before its issuance.
38.
The decision in A.M. Kulshrestha also does not advance the
Petitioner’s case. That case turned on a materially different circumstance:
the employer had represented before the High Court that the charge-sheet
would issue only after receipt of CVC advice, yet served it before that
consultative step was completed. The Supreme Court disapproved that
course because the employer acted contrary to its own stand and prematurely
issued the charge-sheet. The present case is different. CVC’s first-stage
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
advice was received before issuance; it did not alter the approved draft; and
the charge memorandum served was, in substance, the same draft approved
by the Commission on 4th August, 2023. A.M. Kulshrestha, properly
understood, therefore does not apply.
39.
The internal noting dated 29th September, 2023 requires separate
consideration, since the Petitioner places considerable emphasis on it. The
noting proposed that the charge-sheet be placed before the Chairperson for
“consideration and approval”. If read in isolation, that expression may
appear to support the Petitioner’s submission that approval of the competent
Disciplinary Authority was still awaited. The file, however, cannot be read
in fragments. A stray expression in an internal noting cannot be treated as
the operative decision, nor can it be divorced from the earlier approvals
recorded by the Commission and the final order made on the file. The same
noting expressly records that the Commission, as the Disciplinary Authority,
had approved initiation of major penalty proceedings on 27 th June, 2023 and
had thereafter approved the draft charge-sheet on 4th August, 2023. The
Chairperson’s order dated 3rd October, 2023 is consistent with that position.
It does not purport to approve the charge-sheet as the Disciplinary
Authority. On the contrary, it directs that the “Draft Chargesheet as
approved by the Commission and CVC may be issued.” The Chairperson
thus proceeded on the footing that the draft charge-sheet already stood
approved by the Commission, and confined himself to directing issuance of
that approved charge memorandum.
40.
Section 13 of the Competition Act, 2002 must be read in that setting.
The Chairperson’s power of general superintendence, direction and control
over administrative matters cannot prevail where the Commission is
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
required to act as the Disciplinary Authority. But once the Commission had
approved the draft charge-sheet, the direction to issue that approved chargesheet was administrative in character. It did not amount to the Chairperson
exercising, or assuming, the disciplinary jurisdiction vested in the
Commission.
41.
The decision in Dr. Sahadeva Singh turned on a materially different
record, where the subsequent movement of the file indicated that approval of
the draft memo was still being sought from the disciplinary authority. No
such inference arises on the present record, which shows that the
Commission had already approved the draft charge-sheet on 4th August,
2023.
42.
The memorandum of charge dated 3rd October, 2023 is therefore not
void for want of approval under Rule 14(3) of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
43.
One further aspect urged during the hearing may be noticed. Mr.
Narayan submitted that the minutes recording approval of the draft chargesheet in the Commission’s meeting dated 4th August, 2023 bear the signature
of the Chief Vigilance Officer, and not of all Members of the Commission.
On that basis, he contended that the minutes do not conclusively establish
that the Commission had, in fact, granted the approval recorded therein. The
submission cannot be accepted. Minutes are the formal institutional record
of the business transacted and decisions taken by a statutory body. Unless
the governing statute, rules, regulations or binding procedure require every
member to authenticate them by signature, the absence of individual
signatures does not, by itself, undermine the decision recorded. To hold
otherwise would elevate form over substance, particularly where there is no
challenge to the meeting, quorum, agenda or decision itself. Mr. Garg, on
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
instructions, has also clarified that where decisions of the Commission are
unanimous, separate signatures of all Members are not obtained. This
statement is taken on record.
44.
More importantly, there is no material before the Court to suggest that
the meeting dated 4th August, 2023 was not convened, the requisite
Members were not present, the draft charge-sheet did not form part of the
agenda, or the minutes incorrectly recorded the decision taken. The
presumption of regularity attaches to official acts and official records. Its
purpose is not to place such records beyond judicial scrutiny, but to ensure
that institutional decisions are not treated as doubtful on conjecture alone.
That presumption may undoubtedly be displaced by cogent material
showing that the record is inaccurate, fabricated, or contrary to the decision
actually taken. No such material has been placed in the present case. In these
circumstances, the Court finds no reason to doubt the record of approval
reflected in the minutes dated 4th August, 2023.
Other grievances
45.
The Petitioner has also raised grievances concerning supply of
documents, refusal of additional documents, closure of defence and related
procedural orders passed during the inquiry. These grievances are distinct
from the jurisdictional objection founded on Rule 14(3). They do not bear
upon the competence of the Commission to approve the charge memo. They
concern the fairness of the inquiry and the opportunity afforded to the
Petitioner to defend himself.
46.
The legal position is settled in principle. A charged officer must have
access to the relied-upon material and must receive a reasonable opportunity
to defend himself. Denial of material documents may vitiate disciplinary
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
proceedings where prejudice is shown. At the same time, the charged officer
has no unqualified right to demand every document referred to in the wider
administrative or preliminary enquiry record.17 Under the scheme of Rule 14
as well, requests for additional documents are to be examined for relevance
and necessity to the defence.
47.
In the present case, the Petitioner’s request for additional documents
was considered during the inquiry. The record indicates that the request was
not rejected entirely. Certain documents were permitted; some were stated to
have been supplied or made available for inspection; and others were
declined on grounds such as relevance, confidentiality, or their connection
with the preliminary enquiry or disciplinary record. The Petitioner disputes
this approach and maintains that denial of those documents has caused
serious prejudice to his defence. The grievance, therefore, is not that the
inquiry proceeded in complete disregard of his request, but that the request
was not adequately considered, thereby prejudicing his defence.
48.
This Court is not inclined, at this stage, to undertake a document-by-
document review of every request made by the Petitioner. That exercise
would require an assessment of each document’s relevance to the articles of
charge, its necessity for the defence, the evidence led, the reasons for
withholding or refusing it, and the stage at which the request was made.
Those questions are fact-sensitive and must be evaluated against the inquiry
record as a whole. A document described in isolation may add little once the
admitted facts, evidence and cross-examination are considered; conversely,
refusal of a document may become material if it bears directly on a charge
or the credibility of the evidence relied upon. The issue is therefore better
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
Chandrama Tewari v. UOI (Through General Manager, Eastern Railways) 1987 SCC OnLine SC 742.
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
examined, in the first instance, by the Disciplinary Authority while
considering the inquiry record, the Petitioner’s objections, and whether any
actual prejudice has been caused. To interfere at this stage would risk
turning every disputed request for documents into a threshold challenge to
the inquiry, before the competent authority has had occasion to assess its
bearing on prejudice, fairness, and the overall validity of the disciplinary
proceedings.
49.
At the same time, the Petitioner’s procedural grievances cannot be
treated as irrelevant or foreclosed. If such objections have already been
placed on record, or are specifically urged before the Disciplinary Authority,
they shall be considered before any final order is passed in the disciplinary
proceedings. The Disciplinary Authority shall examine whether the
documents or opportunities allegedly denied were relevant and necessary for
an effective defence, and whether their denial has caused actual prejudice in
the conduct of the inquiry. The Court expresses no opinion on the merits of
these objections. They are left open for consideration by the Disciplinary
Authority in accordance with law.
Conclusion
50.
The points for determination are answered as follows:
(i)
The writ petition is not liable to be rejected on the ground of res
judicata, constructive res judicata, or by reason of the earlier withdrawal of
writ proceedings.
(ii)
The Commission is the Disciplinary Authority for the Petitioner.
(iii)
The Commission approved initiation of major penalty proceedings on
27th June, 2023 and thereafter expressly approved the draft charge-sheet on
4th August, 2023.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
(iv)
Since the draft charge-sheet approved by the Commission was the
same charge-sheet later issued to the Petitioner, and since CVC suggested no
alteration in the draft, no fresh approval of the Commission was required
after receipt of CVC’s first-stage advice.
(v)
The Chairperson’s direction dated 3rd October, 2023 was an
administrative direction to issue the charge-sheet already approved by the
Commission. It was not an assumption of the disciplinary power vested in
the Commission.
(vi)
The challenge to the procedural orders concerning supply of
documents, refusal of additional documents and closure of defence is not
accepted as a ground to quash the charge memo or interdict the inquiry at
this stage. The Petitioner is, however, at liberty to raise those objections
before the Disciplinary Authority, which shall be considered in the manner
indicated above, before passing any final order.
51.
The challenge to the memorandum of charge dated 3 rd October, 2023
on the ground of want of approval by the Disciplinary Authority is
accordingly rejected.
52.
The writ petition is disposed of in the above terms. All contentions of
the Petitioner on the merits of the charge, appreciation of evidence,
procedural prejudice and proportionality of any eventual penalty are left
open to be urged in accordance with law at the appropriate stage. Pending
applications, if any, stand disposed of.
53.
Interim order dated 9th December, 2024, stands vacated.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JULY 01, 2026/nk
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
17:09:49
W.P.(C) 15601/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review