Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:31619
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.15595 of 2025
Reserved on:09.07.2026
Decided on: 30.07.2026
Uploaded on: 30.07.2026
… Petitioner
Vidhan Sharma
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
… Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1Yes
____________________________________________________
For the petitioner:
Mr. Surender Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents:
_
Mr. Pushpinder Jaswal, Additional Advocate
General.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
By way of this petition, the petitioner has, inter alia,
prayed for the following reliefs:“(i)
That
the
impugned
Annexure-P8
order
dated
18.06.2025, passed by respondent No.2, may kindly be
quashed and set aside;
(ii) That respondents No.1 and 2 may kindly be directed
to
regularize
the
services
of
the
petitioner
w.e.f.
01.01.2011 with all consequential benefits, such as
arrears of salary, seniority and promotion etc.;
(iii) That the respondents may kindly be directed grant
and release the arrears of salary to the petitioner
alongwith interest @ 12% per annum w.e.f. 01.01.2011 till
the date of its disbursement.”
2.
The case of the petitioner is that in terms of Annexure P-
1, a communication was sent by the Secretary (Education) to the
Government of Himachal Pradesh to the Principal, SCERT, Rabon,
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:31619
District Solan, H.P. that Chairman, Finance Committee had
conveyed the approval to engage Caretaker, Attendant and Sweeper
on daily wages, subject to the condition that ex-post-facto approval of
the Finance Committee will have to be obtained in the matter. It was
also mentioned in this communication that wages of these daily
wagers will have to be borne by the Society out of its own funds.
Thereafter, in terms of Annexure P-2, the present petitioner was
engaged as a Hostel Caretaker (Storekeeper) on daily wage basis
w.e.f. 11.11.2002. The appointment letter of the petitioner is signed
by respondent No.3. As per the petitioner, he is serving against the
post in issue till date. The petitioner filed an Original Application
before the erstwhile learned Himachal Pradesh Administrative
Tribunal, praying for regularization of his services w.e.f. 01.01.2011,
with all consequential benefits, which Original Application after the
abolition of the learned Tribunal was transferred to this Court and
registered as CWPOA No.4978 of 2019. Said petition was disposed of
by this Court in terms of judgment dated 24.04.2025, which
judgment is being quoted hereinbelow in totality, as it lays down the
complete factual matrix of this case:“The instant petition has been filed for the following
substantive relief(s):“That the respondents may be directed to regularize
the services of the applicant with effect from
01.01.2011 with all consequential benefits.”
2. The case as set-up by the petitioner is that he was
appointed as Hostel Care Taker (Store Keeper) in State
Council for Education, Research and Training ( for short
“SCERT”), on daily wages w.e.f. 11.11.2002, in terms of
office order dated 06.11.2002, Annexure A-1. Petitioner
2026:HHC:31619
is continuing in the same position and on the same terms
till date.
3.
It is averred that on 05.11.2002, the Secretary
(Education) to the Government of H.P., vide
communication of the same date, had conveyed to the
Principal, SCERT, Solan, the approval of Chairman
Finance Committee to engage Care Taker/Attendant and
Sweeper on daily wage basis, subject to the condition
that the ex-post facto approval of Finance Committee
would be obtained in the matter. The wages of these
daily wage employees were directed to be borne by the
SCERT from its own funds. It was in pursuance to the
aforesaid communication that the office order dated
06.11.2002, appointing petitioner as Hostel Care Taker
(Store Keeper) in SCERT, was issued.
4. Petitioner has also placed reliance on the ‘Minutes of
Meeting’ of the Finance Committee of SCERT, dated
31.10.2003, in which vide item No. 3, it was resolved as
under:Item No. 3
As far as Item No. 3 is concerned the members of
the committee accorded their sanction to fill up the
post of care taker and sweeper of the Hostel on
year to year contract basis on a fixed salary of Rs.
5,000/- and 3,000/- per month respectively. It was
decided that out of the present sanctioned posts of
SCERT Society two posts i.e. one class III (Lab
Attendant) and one class IV be surrendered and
conversion of the same may be sought from the
finance Department to Hostel of SCERT Society, so
that their fixed salary could be drawn against the
regular sanctioned/converted posts and not from
the income of the Hostel. The procedure for filling up
of these posts may strictly be followed in
accordance with the norms already approved by the
Govt. and conveyed to the field from time to time.”
5. In sequel to aforesaid resolution, Principal-cumMember Secretary, SCERT, had sought necessary
sanction from the Principal Secretary (Education) with
respect to conversion of posts of Laboratory Attendant
and Class-IV into Care Taker and Sweeper in SCERT,
Hostel Solan, H.P.
6. Petitioner had also submitted his individual
representation to the authorities seeking regularization of
his services on completion of the requisite period as per
the regularization policy of the State Government. In
response, the Director of Higher Education, vide
communication dated 07.12.2011, addressed to the
2026:HHC:31619
Principal, SCERT, had sought pointwise comments.
7. The grievance of the petitioner is that the
respondents/authorities did not take any decision which
forced him to file the instant petition in the year 2015.
8. Respondents have filed their reply. The factual
position as averred in the petition has not been denied.
Their defence is that without there being substantive post
of Care Taker in the SCERT Hostel, the services of
petitioner could not be regularized. It is also contended
that respondent No. 2, vide letter dated 16.12.2004, had
directed respondent No. 3 to take action as per the norms
of SCERT and because in SCERT norms there was no
provision for regularization of employees engaged in
society mode, the request of the petitioner could not be
acceded to.
9. Respondents have also taken objection of petition
being time barred.
10. Petitioner filed the rejoinder and has refuted the
averments made in the reply. It has been submitted that
the SCERT, Solan, imparts training and conduct
orientation programmes for the teachers i.e. PGTs, Head
Masters, Principals, College Lecturers and Deputy
Directors etc. working with the State Government. The
Government of Himachal Pradesh, exercises deep and
pervasive control over the affairs of respondent No. 3.
The Director Education, Joint Director Education and
Under Secretary Finance are the members of third
respondent, which by no means can be said to be a
private society. It for all intents and purposes is
discharging public functions, hence, it cannot be allowed
to absolve itself by saying that the government rules
were not applicable to its employees. Petitioner has also
placed on record a communication dated 20.07.2011,
issued by Principal Secretary (Personnel) to the
Government of H.P. to all the Principal Secretaries and
Head of Departments in the State providing details of the
terms and conditions of the regularization policy of the
State Government.
11. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have
also gone through the record of the case carefully.
12. At the outset, it is noticed that the plea raised by
respondents to the effect that second respondent had
issued directions to the third respondent to take action as
per society norms, vide letter dated 16.12.2004 is not
substantiated. No such document has been placed on
record. The said plea rather becomes doubtful as the
communication dated 14.01.2005, Annexure A-4, on
record from respondent No. 3 to the Principal Secretary
2026:HHC:31619
(Education) clearly reveals that the third respondent had
sought necessary sanction for conversion of posts of Lab
Attendant and Class-IV into posts of Care Taker and
Sweeper for SCERT Hostel, Solan, H.P. In this
correspondence, there was no reference to the alleged
communication
dated
16.12.2004,
issued
by
respondent No. 2 to respondent No. 3. The said
contention is further belied from the contents of
document i.e. communication dated 07.12.2011, from
respondent No. 2 to respondent No. 3, placed on record
as Annexure A-5, whereby such respondent had sought
comments on the representation of the petitioner, by
way of which the petitioner had sought regularization of
his services on completion of ten years.
13. Thus, it is clearly evident that the respondents have
failed to take any final decision in the matter of
petitioner.
14. It is sufficiently shown on record that there was
genuine need and requirement for the post of Hostel
Care Taker in SCERT, Solan. The Secretary (Education)
had conveyed approval of Chairman Finance Committee
to engage Care Taker on daily wage basis vide
communication dated 05.11.2002, Annexure A-2. It
was subject to only one condition that ex post facto
approval of Finance Committee was to be taken. The
Finance Committee, admittedly, had accorded the
sanction to the posts of Care Taker and Sweeper in the
Hostel. A decision was taken by the Finance Committee
to this effect in its meeting held on 31.10.2003. It was
further decided that out of the sanctioned post of SCERT,
two posts i.e. one Class-III (Lab Attendant) and one
Class-IV be surrendered and permission for conversion of
the same be sought from the Finance Department, in
order to enable the SCERT to draw the fixed salary of
Care Taker and Sweeper against the regular
sanctioned/converted post and not from the income of
the hostel. It was after the aforesaid decision of the
Finance Committee that the third respondent had sought
the permission from the Principal Secretary (Education),
vide Annexure A-4, as noticed above.
15. However, evidently no final decision has been taken
by the competent authority till date. Petitioner is now
working for last about twenty-three years.
16. There cannot be any doubt with respect to the entity
of SCERT being an instrumentality of State Government.
It discharges public functions. The SCERT is nothing but
an extended wing of Government. Under the garb of
being a society, it cannot use exploitative policies against
2026:HHC:31619
its employees. In other words, the SCERT cannot be
allowed to be used by the State for said exploitative
policies.
17. Once, the petitioner was appointed in SCERT after
the grant of sanction by the Chairman Finance
Committee and subsequently, ratified by the Finance
Committee, to say that petitioner will not be entitled for
the benefits of regularization at par with similarly
situated employees of State will be unjustified and
antithetic to the Constitutional Principle laid down in
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
18. In the given circumstances, the petition is disposed of
with the directions to the respondents to consider and
take a final decision in the case of petitioner within a
period of six weeks from the date of the passing of this
order, strictly in terms of the observations made
hereinabove.
19. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall
also stand disposed of.
20. List for compliance on 19.06.2025.”
3.
In compliance to this judgment, the Authority has
passed impugned order dated 18.06.2025, which reads as under:“ORDER
Whereas, the petitioner Sh. Vidhan Sharma filed CWPOA
4978/2019
for
regularisation
of
the
services.
The
operative part of Judgment/Order dated 24-04-2025
which has been received in this Directorate on 12-06-25
passed by the Hon'ble High of H.P. Court is as under:"18. In the given circumstances, the petition is disposed of
with the directions to the respondents to consider and
take a final decision in the case of petitioner within a
period of six weeks from the date of the passing of this
order,
strictly
in
terms
of
the
observations
made
hereinabove."
And Whereas, on the perusal of record produced by the
officials of SCERT Solan, the petitioner was initially
engaged by SCERT Society Solan as Hostel Care Taker
(Store Keeper) to look after the Hostel for 89 days vide
2026:HHC:31619
Office Order dated 6-11-2002 with the condition that no
claim for regularization of services can be entertained and
his service can be dispensed with without any notice. He
joined as such on 11-11-2002. No post was created /
sanctioned in Ure said hostel and his wages were drawn
from the income of SCERT hostel. The said society has
been registered Under the Societies Registration Act 1860
vide registration No. 297/97 dated 2-6-1997.
And Whereas, on the proposal dated 08-10-2002 of
Principal SCERT Solan, the approval of Chairman,
Finance Committee SCERT Society Solan vide letter dated
5-11-2002 was conveyed to engage Caretaker, attendant
and sweeper subject to the condition that the ex-post-facto
approval of Finance Committee will be obtained in the
matter. Wages of these employee will be borne by the
Society out of own funds.
And Whereas, vide the proceedings of the meeting of
finance committee of SCERT Society, which was held on
31-10-03 under the chairmanship of Chairman SCERT
Society Solan, the following decision on item No.3 was
taken:"As far as Item No. 3 is concerned the members of the
committee accorded their sanction to fill up the post of
care taker and sweeper of the Hostel on year to year
contract basis on a fixed salary of Rs. 5,000/- and
3,000/- per month respectively. It was decided that out of
the present sanctioned posts of SCERT Society two posts
i.e. one class III (Lab Attendant) and one class IV be
surrendered and conversion of the same may be sought
from the finance Department to Hostel of SCERT Society,
so that their fixed salary could be drawn against the
regular sanctioned/converted posts and not from the
2026:HHC:31619
income of the Hostel. The procedure for filling up of these
posts may strictly be followed in accordance with the
norms already approved by the Govt. and conveyed to the
field from time to time."
And Whereas, this matter was taken up by the Principal
cum-member response to letter dated 16-10-2004 it was
replied by the Director of Education vide letter dated 1612-2004 to take action as per society norms and
constitution of SCERT as there was no provision for
regularisation of employees engaged in society mode.
And Whereas, the matter of regularization as caretaker in
SCERT Hostel was taken up with the Govt. who vide letter
dated 5-2-2013 conveyed that matter was taken up with
the Finance Department who has observed that the
SCERT is Society and staff of the Societies belongs to the
Society only, which are a separate legal entity. Therefore,
FD expenses its inability to concur in the proposal.
Now therefore, after going through the record produced by
the SCERT Solan and in view of facts and circumstances
enumerated as above, the petitioner was engaged by the
Society only which is a separate legal entity and there is
no provision for regularisation of society hostel staff. There
is no merit in the representation of petitioner and
accordingly rejected.”
4.
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner has approached this
Court.
5.
I heard learned Counsel for the petitioner as also
learned Additional Advocate General and have also carefully gone
through the pleadings as well as all the documents appended
herewith.
2026:HHC:31619
6.
The issue before this Court is as to whether the decision
of the respondents of not regularizing the services of the petitioner
on the ground that SCERT is a Society and staff of the said Society
belongs to the Society only, which is a separate legal entity and
therefore, the Finance Department expresses its inability to concur
with the proposal of regularization of the services is sustainable in
the law or not.
7.
At this stage, it is relevant to refer to the judgment
earlier passed by this Court in the case of the petitioner. A perusal of
said judgment demonstrates that it was categorically held by this
Court in the said judgment that it was sufficiently demonstrated on
record that there was genuine need and requirement for the post of
Hostel Caretaker in SCERT, Solan and Secretary (Education), to the
Government
of
Himachal
Pradesh
had conveyed
approval of
Chairman, Finance Committee to engage Caretaker on daily wage
basis vide communication dated 05.11.2002. The same was subject
to only one condition that ex-post-facto approval of the Finance
Committee was to be obtained. The Finance Committee admittedly
accorded its sanction to the post of Caretaker and Sweeper in the
Hostel and decision was taken by the Finance Committee to this
effect in its meeting held on 31.10.2003. It is also evident from the
said judgment that it was further decided that out of the sanctioned
post of SCERT, two posts, i.e. one of Class-III Lab Attendant and one
of Class-IV be surrendered and permission for conversion of the
2026:HHC:31619
same be sought from the Finance Department in order to enable
SCERT to draw the fixed salary of Caretaker and Sweeper against
regularly sanctioned/converted post and not from the income of the
Hostel.
8.
This Court had also held in its earlier judgment that
SCERT being an instrumentality of the State Government is
discharging public functions and that SCERT is nothing, but an
extended wing of the Government. This Court also observed that
under the garb of being a Society, it cannot use exploitative
employment policies against its employees, so as to say that SCERT
cannot be allowed to be used by the State for said exploitative
policies. This Court also held that once the petitioner was appointed
in SCERT after the grant of sanction by Chairman, Finance
Committee, which appointment was subsequently ratified by the
Finance Committee, then the respondents cannot be allowed to say
that he will not be entitled for the benefit of regularization at par
with similarly situated employees of the State, which act of the
respondents was unjustified and antipathetic to the Constitutional
Principles laid down in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India.
9.
In the backdrop of the observations made by this Court
in its earlier judgment, now the rejection of the case of the petitioner
on the same bogie that he was an employee of the Society and,
therefore, his services could not be regularized, is not sustainable in
2026:HHC:31619
the eyes of law.
10.
At this stage itself, this Court would like to refer to
certain recent judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India on
the issue of regularization of daily wagers as well as contract
employees.
11.
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Jaggo Versus Union of
India & Ors., 2024 SCC Online SC 3826, has been pleased to hold as
under:“………...10. Having given careful consideration to the
submissions advanced and the material on record, we
find that the appellants’ long and uninterrupted service,
for periods extending well beyond ten years, cannot be
brushed
aside
merely
by
labelling
their
initial
appointments as part-time or contractual. The essence of
their employment must be considered in the light of their
sustained contribution, the integral nature of their work,
and the fact that no evidence suggests their entry was
through any illegal or surreptitious route.
11. The appellants, throughout their tenure, were
engaged in performing essential duties that were
indispensable to the day-to-day functioning of the offices
of the Central Water Commission (CWC). Applicant Nos.
1, 2, and 3, as Safaiwalis, were responsible for
maintaining hygiene, cleanliness, and
a conducive
working environment within the office premises. Their
duties involved sweeping, dusting, and cleaning of floors,
workstations,
and
common
areas—a
set
of
responsibilities that directly contributed to the basic
operational functionality of the CWC. Applicant No. 5, in
2026:HHC:31619
the role of a Khallasi (with additional functions akin to
those of a Mali), was entrusted with critical maintenance
tasks, including gardening, upkeep of outdoor premises,
and ensuring orderly surroundings.
12. Despite being labelled as “part-time workers,” the
appellants performed these essential tasks on a daily
and continuous basis over extensive periods, ranging
from over a decade to nearly two decades. Their
engagement was not sporadic or temporary in nature;
instead, it was recurrent, regular, and akin to the
responsibilities typically associated with sanctioned
posts. Moreover, the respondents did not engage any
other personnel for these tasks during the appellants’
tenure, underscoring the indispensable nature of their
work.
13. The claim by the respondents that these were not
regular posts lacks merit, as the nature of the work
performed
by
the
appellants
was
perennial
and
fundamental to the functioning of the offices. The
recurring nature of these duties necessitates their
classification as regular posts, irrespective of how their
initial engagements were labelled. It is also noteworthy
that subsequent outsourcing of these same tasks to
private
agencies
after
the
appellants’
termination
demonstrates the inherent need for these services. This
act of outsourcing, which effectively replaced one set of
workers with another, further underscores that the work
in question was neither temporary nor occasional.
17.
As
for
the
argument
relating
to
educational
qualifications, we find it untenable in the present context.
The nature of duties the appellants performed—cleaning,
sweeping, dusting, and gardening—does not inherently
2026:HHC:31619
mandate formal educational prerequisites. It would be
unjust to rely on educational criteria that were never
central to their engagement or the performance of their
duties
for
decades.
Moreover,
the
respondents
themselves have, by their conduct, shown that such
criteria were not strictly enforced in other cases of
regularization. The appellants’ long-standing satisfactory
performance itself attests to their capability to discharge
these functions, making rigid insistence on formal
educational requirements an unreasonable hurdle.”
In this judgment, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that
it is
imperative for Government Departments to lead by example in
providing
fair and stable employment. Engaging workers on
temporary basis for extended periods, especially when their roles are
integral to the organization's functioning, not only contravenes
international labour standards but also exposes the organization to
legal challenges and undermines employee’s morale. By ensuring fair
employment practices, Government institutions can reduce the
burden of unnecessary litigation, promote job security, and uphold
the principles of justice and fairness that they are meant to embody.
This approach aligns with international standards and sets a
positive
precedent
for
the
private
sector
to
follow,
thereby
contributing to the overall betterment of labour practices in the
country. Hon’ble Supreme Court also held that the pervasive misuse
of temporary employment contracts reflects a broader systemic issue
that adversely affects workers' rights and job security. In the private
sector, the rise of the gig economy has led to an increase in
2026:HHC:31619
precarious employment arrangements, often characterized by lack of
benefits, job security, and fair treatment. Such practices have been
criticized for exploiting workers and undermining labour standards.
12.
In Dharam Singh & Ors. Versus State of H.P. & Anr.,
2025 SCC Online SC 1735 (2025 INSC 998), Hon’ble Supreme Court
has been pleased to hold as under:“……...17. Before concluding, we think it necessary to
recall that the State (here referring to both the Union and
the State governments) is not a mere market participant
but a constitutional employer. It cannot balance budgets
on the backs of those who perform the most basic and
recurring public functions. Where work recurs day after
day and year after year, establishment must reflect that
reality in its sanctioned strength and engagement
practices. The long-term extraction of regular labour under
temporary
labels
administration
and
corrodes
confidence
in
public
offends
the
of
equal
promise
protection. Financial stringency certainly has a place in
public policy, but it is not a talisman that overrides
fairness, reason and the duty to organise work on lawful
lines.
18. Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that "adhocism" thrives where administration is opaque. The
State Departments must keep and produce accurate
establishment registers, muster rolls and outsourcing
arrangements, and they must explain, with evidence,
why they prefer precarious engagement over sanctioned
posts where the work is perennial. If "constraint" is
invoked, the record should show what alternatives were
considered, why similarly placed workers were treated
2026:HHC:31619
differently, and how the chosen course aligns with
Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
Sensitivity to the human consequences of prolonged
insecurity is not sentimentality. It is a constitutional
discipline that should inform every decision affecting
those who keep public offices running.”
13.
In Bhola Nath Versus the State of Jharkhand & Ors.,
2026 SCC Online SC 129 (2026 INSC 99), Hon’ble Supreme Court
has been pleased to hold as under:“13. Another facet requiring consideration in the case of
contractual employees, such as the present appellants, is
the doctrine of legitimate expectation. Where employees
have continued to discharge their duties on contractual
posts for a considerable length of time, as in the present
case, it is but natural that a legitimate expectation arises
that the State would, at some stage, recognize their long
and continuous service. It is in this belief, bolstered by
repeated extensions granted by the Executive, that such
employees continue in service and refrain from seeking
alternative employment, notwithstanding the contractual
nature of their engagement. At this juncture, it is thus
apposite to advert to the principles governing the doctrine
of legitimate expectation as enunciated by this Court in
Army Welfare Education Society v. Sunil Kumar Sharma,
(2024) 16 SCC 598 wherein it was held as follows: "63. A reading of the aforesaid decisions brings forth
the following features regarding the doctrine of
legitimate expectation:
63.1. First, legitimate expectation must be based on a
right as opposed to a mere hope, wish or anticipation:
2026:HHC:31619
63.2. Secondly, legitimate expectation must arise
either from an express or implied promise; or a
consistent past practice or custom followed by an
authority in its dealings;
…
63.5. Fifthly, legitimate expectation operates in the
realm of public law, that is. a plea of legitimate action
can be taken only when a public authority breaches a
promise or deviates from a consistent past practice,
without any reasonable basis.
64. The aforesaid features, although not exhaustive in
nature, are sufficient to help us in deciding the
applicability of the doctrine of legitimate expectation to
the facts of the case at hand. It is clear that legitimate
expectation. jurisprudentially, was a device created in
order to maintain a check on arbitrariness in State
action. It does not extend to and cannot govern the
operation of contracts between private parties, wherein
the doctrine of promissory estoppel holds the field."
It is, therefore, not difficult to comprehend the
expectation with which such contractual employees
continue in the service of the State. The repeated
conduct of the employer-State in expressing confidence
in
their
performance
and
consistently
granting
monetary upgrades & tenure extensions reasonably
nurtures an expectation that their long and continuous
service would receive further recognition.
13.1.
Another
Constitution
Bench
in
State
of
Karnataka v. Umadevi, (2006) 4 SCC 1 cautioned that
the doctrine of legitimate expectation cannot ordinarily
be extended to persons whose appointments are
2026:HHC:31619
temporary, casual or contractual in nature. The
relevant extract of the judgment reads as follows: "47. When a person enters a temporary employment or
gets engagement as a contractual or casual worker
and the engagement is not based on a proper selection
as recognised by the reievant rules or procedure, he is
aware of the consequences of the appointment being
temporary, casual or contractual in nature. Such a
person
cannot
invoke
the
theory
of
legitimate
expectation for being confirmed in the post when an
appointment to the post could be made only by
following a proper procedure for selection and in cases
concerned, in consultation with the Public Service
Commission.
Therefore,
the
theory
of
legitimate
expectation cannot be successfully advanced by
temporary. contractual or casual employees. It cannot
also be held that the State has held out any promise
while engaging these persons either to continue them
where they are or to make them permanent. The State
cannot constitutionally make such a promise. It is also
obvious that the theory cannot be invoked to seek a
positive relief of being made permanent in the post."
However, this Court in Umadevi (supra) clarified that the
bar against invocation of the doctrine of legitimate
expectation applies only to those temporary, contractual
or
casual
employees
whose
engagement
was
not
preceded by a proper selection process in accordance
with
the
extant
rules.
Consequently,
where
such
engagement is made after following a due and lawful
selection procedure, there is no absolute bar in law
preventing such employees from invoking the doctrine of
legitimate expectation.
2026:HHC:31619
Limits on Perpetual Contractual Engagements:
13.2. In the present case, the respondent-State had
engaged the services of the appellants on sanctioned
posts since the year 2012. It was only towards the end of
the year 2022 that the respondents communicated that
no further extension of the appellants' engagement was
likely to be granted.
13.3. In our considered opinion, the aforesaid action is
not only vitiated by arbitrariness but is also in clear
derogation of the equality principles enshrined in Article
14 of the Constitution. The respondent-State initially
engaged the appellants in their youth to discharge public
duties
and
functions.
Having
rendered
long
and
dedicated service, the appellants cannot now be left to
fend for themselves, particularly when the employment
opportunities that may have been available to them a
decade ago are no longer accessible owing to age
constraints.
13.4. We are unable to discern any rational basis for the
respondent-State's decision to discontinue the appellants
after nearly ten years of continuous service. We are
conscious that the symbiotic-relationship between the
appellants
and
the
respondent-State was
mutually
beneficial, the State derived the advantage of the
appellants' experience and institutional familiarity, while
the appellants remained in public service. In such
circumstances, any departure from a long-standing
practice of renewal, particularly one that frustrates the
legitimate expectation of the employees, ought to be
supported by cogent reasons recorded in a speaking
order.
2026:HHC:31619
13.5. Such a decision must necessarily be a conscious
and reasoned one. An employee who has satisfactorily
discharged his duties over several years and has been
granted repeated extensions cannot, overnight, be treated
as surplus or undesirable. We are unable to accept the
justification
advanced
by
the
respondents
as
the
obligation of the State, as a model employer, extends to
fair treatment of its employees irrespective of whether
their engagement is contractual or regular.
13.6. This Court has, on several occasions, deprecated
the practice adopted by States of engaging employees
under the nominal labels of "part-time", "contractual" or
"temporary" in perpetuity and thereby exploiting them by
not regularizing their positions. In Jaggo v. Union of India,
2024 SCC Online SC 3826 this Court underscored that
government departments must lead by example in
ensuring fair and stable employment, and evolved the
test of examining whether the duties performed by such
temporary employees are integral to the day-to-day
functioning of the organization.
13.7. In Shripal v. Nagar Nigam, 2025 SCC Online SC 221
and Vinod Kumar v. Union of India, (2024) 9 SCC 327 this
Court cautioned against a mechanical and blind reliance
on Umadevi (supra) to deny regularization to temporary
employees in the absence of statutory rules. It was held
that Umadevi (supra) cannot be employed as a for years
without undertaking regular recruitment. The Court
further clarified that Umadevi itself draws a distinction
between appointments that are "illegal" and those that
are merely "irregular", the latter being amenable to
regularization
conditions.
upon
fulfilment
of
the
prescribed
2026:HHC:31619
13.8. In Dharam Singh v. State of U.P. 2025 SCC Online
SC 1735, this Court strongly deprecated the culture of
"ad-hocism" adopted by States in their capacity as
employers. The Court criticised the practice of outsourcing
or informalizing recruitment as a means to evade regular
employment obligations, observing that such measures
perpetuate
precarious
working
conditions
while
circumventing fair and lawful engagement practices.
13.9. The State must remain conscious that part-time
employees, such as the appellants, constitute an integral
part of the edifice upon which the machinery of the State
continues to function. They are not merely ancillary to the
system, but form essential components thereof. The
equality mandate of our Constitution, therefore, requires
that their service be reciprocated in a manner free from
arbitrariness, ensuring that
decisions of the State
affecting the careers and livelihood of such part-time and
contractual employees are guided by fairness and
reason.
13.10. In the aforesaid backdrop, we are unable to
persuade ourselves to accept the respondent-State's
contention that the mere contractual nomenclature of
the
appellants'
engagement
denudes
them
of
constitutional protection. The State, having availed of
the appellants' services on sanctioned posts for over a
decade pursuant to a due process of selection and
having
consistently
acknowledged
their
satisfactory
performance, cannot, in the absence of cogent reasons
or a speaking decision, bruptly discontinue such
engagement by taking refuge behind formal contractual
lauses. Such action is manifestly arbitrary, inconsistent
with the obligation of the ate to act as a model employer,
2026:HHC:31619
and fails to withstand scrutiny under Article 14 of me
Constitution.
14.
Recently, this Court by placing reliance upon the above
mentioned judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in CWP
No.5784 of 2023, titled Manju Devi Versus State of H.P. and others,
has held as under:“19.
In light of the fact that the petitioner is
performing his duties as a Class-IV daily wager with
respondent No.3-Society since 09.01.2015, the same
demonstrates that there is permanency attached with the
nature of work which is being extracted from the petitioner
by the said Society. That being so, obviously it cannot be
the case of the respondents that as there is no permanent
work available with the Society, the services of the
petitioner cannot be regularized. In fact, this Court cannot
ignore that before the services of the petitioner were
converted on daily wage basis, he was serving the same
Society on part time basis since the year 2005, meaning
thereby
that
the
respondent-Society
petitioner
has
been
serving
the
firstly
part
time
basis
and
on
thereafter, on daily wage basis for almost 21 years.
20.
Under
these
circumstances,
this
Court
disagrees with the respondents that because the
petitioner is serving respondent No.3, which is a
Society, she does not has a right of regularization in
terms of the Policies circulated by the State Government
from time to time on the regularization of daily wage
workers. It is not in dispute that various Corporations
and Societies owned and controlled by the State which
per se are not Government Departments, are also
regularizing the services of the daily wage staff
2026:HHC:31619
engaged
by
them
by
following
the
Policies
of
regularization of the State.
21.
In the present case, respondent No.3, as
observed hereinabove, came into existence after the
Deputy Commissioner concerned was called upon to
constitute
a
Society
by
Director,
Small
Savings,
Himachal Pradesh. Thus, it is the Governmental action
which resulted in the formation of the Society. Further,
in terms of Annexure P-10, which has been referred by
me hereinabove, Principal Secretary (Finance), to the
Government
of
Himachal
Pradesh
wrote
to
all
concerned that whereas new Societies shall not engage
staff including temporary/ daily wage without the
approval of the Government, the existing Societies were
also instructed to carry out necessary amendments in
the Memorandum of Association/ Articles of Association
of the said Societies. This further demonstrates the
deep and pervasive control of the State Government
over these Societies. Their members are all Government
officers, ex-officers.
22.
Simply
because
the
Small
Savings
Department itself was not interested to do the work
which is being carried out through the Societies, this
does not mean that said Societies are not a limb of the
Government per se.
23.
Therefore, the daily wage staff engaged
therein cannot be discriminated vis-a-vis the other staff
engaged in various other Departments of the State. The
daily wage staff serving with such Societies also has a
legitimate expectation of regularization in terms of the
Policies of regularization circulated by the State
Government from time to time and whether or not such
2026:HHC:31619
staff has to be regularized, cannot depend upon the
whims and fancies of the Authorities.
24.
The Society is an extended arm of the
Department working under the Chairman, who is the
Deputy Commissioner of the District. In these facts, the
act of the respondents of not regularizing the services of
the petitioner on the pretext that he happens to be an
employee of respondent No.3-Society, which is not a
Government Department, is held to be bad in law. It is
held that as respondent No.3 is just an extended limb of
the Small Savings Department of the State of Himachal
Pradesh, though it is registered and functioning as a
Society, the same is also bound by the Policies of
regularization of the State Government relating to daily
wage employees.
25.
Accordingly, this petition is allowed. Said
Society and Government cannot be permitted to continue
to engage staff on daily wage services for eternity without
any assurance of regularization and with an uncertain
future. This is not acceptable more so in the light of the
latest judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court, referred
hereinabove. The respondents are directed to regularize
the services of the petitioner upon completion of five years
of daily wage service with 240 days in each calendar
year as calculated w.e.f. 09.01.2015, in terms of
regularization Policy of the State Government, dated
22.04.2020. Regularization
be conferred upon the
petitioner w.e.f. 22.04.2020, i.e. the date when relevant
regularization
Policy
was
circulated
by
the
State
Government. In case there is any requirement of a
creation of regular post to regularize the services of the
petitioner, then needful shall be done by all the
2026:HHC:31619
respondents. The regularization of the petitioner shall be
notional as from 22.04.2020, upto the date of passing of
this judgment and thereafter, regular benefits shall be
conferred upon the petitioner. The benefit of regularization
w.e.f. 22.04.2020 shall be inclusive of all consequential
benefits/though notional upto to the passing of the
judgment, including seniority. The Court places on record
its appreciation for the assistance rendered by learned
Counsel for the petitioner in the adjudication of the case.”
15.
The findings returned by this Court in Manju Devi’s case
are applicable to the facts of this case also. Herein also, the only
ground as to why regularization is being denied to the petitioner is
that he is an employee of a Society. This Court reiterates the
observations made by it in its earlier judgment in the case of the
present petitioner that regularization cannot be denied to the
petitioner on the ground that he happens to be an employee of the
Society, because the said Society is not an independent Society, but
is a Society which is owned and controlled by the Government. This
Society is nothing but an extended arm of the Government and is
performing the duties which otherwise have to be performed by the
Government. It discharges public functions. Besides this, herein
also, the very fact that the petitioner is serving with the respondentSociety
though
on
daily
wage
basis
since
the
year
2002,
demonstrates that there is permanancy attached to the work of the
petitioner, otherwise his services would not have been retained by
the Society for almost two decades now. The petitioner at the time of
2026:HHC:31619
filing of the petition was 54 years old, meaning thereby that at this
age, he otherwise cannot leave the job and seek employment in any
other Department. After having given two decades of his life to the
respondent-Society which is a Government owned Society, the least
he expects and deserves is the regularization of his services, that too
from due date, so that there is an element of certainty as far as the
remaining service career of the petitioner is concerned.
16.
Accordingly, in light of discussion made hereinabove,
this writ petition is allowed. Impugned order dated 18.06.2025
(Annexure-P-8), passed by respondent No.2 is quashed and set aside.
The act of the respondents of not regularizing the services of the
petitioner on the pretext that the petitioner is an employee of the
Society is held to be bad in law. The respondents are directed to
regularize the services of the petitioner from the date of filng of
O.A.No.586 of 2015, with all consequential benefits, both monetary
as well as seniority-wise.
17.
With these observations, the petition stands disposed of,
so also, pending miscellaneous application(s), if any.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
July 30, 2026
(Rishi)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review