Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 29898 OF 2025
Between:
1. Vibha Kakade, D/o.RavinderKakade, Aged 40 years, Currently residing at Flat
No. 506, 7 Block, Silicon Ridge Apartments, Rajpushpa Apartments,
RajendraNagar, Attapur, Hyderabad - 500048.
2. tVlanjula Kakade, W/o.RavinderKakade Aged 66 years, Currently residing at.
Flat No. 506, 7th Block, Silicon Ridge Apartments, Rajpushpa Apartments,
RajendraNagar, Attapur, Hyderabad - 500048.
3. Ravinder Kakade, S/o.[\tlahadevRaoKakade Aged 72
years,
Currentlyresidingat. Flat No. 506, 7th Block, Silicon Ridge Apartments,
Rajpushpa Apartments, RajendraNagar, Attapur, Hyderabad -500048.
.....PETITIONERS
AND
1. Reserve Bank of lndia, Fourth Floor, Amar Building, SirPttI Road, f\Iumbai400001.
2. Banking Ombudsman, Reserye Bank of lndia, Banking Ombudsman Office, 61
-56, Secretariat Road, Saifabad, Hyderabad-500004.
3. Dealing Officer, Reserve Bank of lndia, Banking Ombudsman Office-ll, Fort
Glacis, Chennai, Tamil Nadu- 600001.
4. Banking Ombudsman, lClCl Bank Limited,34l,Arihant Apartment, Railway
Colony, Ward 1 24, Gand hid ham, G uj arat-37 0201
.
5. Bank lVlanager, ICICI Bank Limited Head Office, lclcl Bank towers, BandraKurla Complex Mumbai - 400 051.
6. Bank.Manager, lClCl Bank Limited, Rajendranagar, 4-3-1431A. BPR Towers,
Attapur, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500048
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or a direction more so in the nature of Writ of
o
Mandamus (i) declaring the action of the Respondents in not releasing the no dues
certificate for Home Loan bearing A/c No. LBANJ00OO5760999 and tifle deeds of
the property bearing Flat No. 506, Silicon Ridge, Attapur Village, Rajendra Nagar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Sy. No. 44o, Part 441 AA 47oAAa4Jl, Hyderabad500048 which was mortgaged with lClCl Bank for a Home Loan bearing A/c No.
L84I1J00005760999, even though the Petitioners have cleared all dues in
connection with the Home Loan bearing Alc No. LBANJ00005Z60ggg on
24.06.2024 as illegal, arbitrary and violation of fundamental rights of the petitioner
more particularly Article 21 of the Constitution of lndia and other Iegal rights of the
Petitioner and Consequently direct the Respondents No.6 bank to release the no
dues certificate for Home Loan bearing A/c No. LBANJ0O00S760999 and tile
deeds of the property bearing Flat No. 506, Silicon Ridge, Attapur Village,
Rajendra Nagar [vandal, Ranga Reddy District, Sy. No. 440, parl441 AA 47oAAa
471, Hyderabad-500048 which was mortgaged with lClCl Bank. (ii) To set aside
the Response dated 26.08.2024- and Reply dated 24.10.2024-by Reserve Bank of
lndia as being unconstitutional, arbitrary and against the well settled principles of
law. (i) Direct the Respondents to pay an amount of Rs. Rs. 22,2s,000 (Rupees
Twenty Two Lakhs Twenty Five Thousand Only) for 455 d Responsible Lending
conduct- Release of Movable/lmmovable property Documents on
Repayment/Settlement of Personal Loans.
!;A.NO:1 OF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
Respondents No. 6 bank to release the no dues certificate for Home Loan bearing
A/c No. L8ANJ00005760999 and title deeds of the property bearing Flat No. 506,
Silicon Ridge, Attapur Village, Rajendra Nagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Sy.
No. 440, Part 441 AA 4704 Ae 471, Hydeiabad : 500048 which was -mortgaged
with lClCl Bank for a Home Loan bearing A/c No. LBANJ000OS760999 within a
period of 15 days.
a
!.A.NO:2 OF 2025
Petition UnderSection 15'l CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent Nos.3, 4 to 6 to consider the representations of 28.10.2024,
. 28402924 and U1'.2O24 within a period of 10 days pending disposal of the writ
petition.
|.A.NO:3 OF 2025
Between:
1. Vibha Kakade, D/o.RavinderKakade, Aged 40 years, Currently residing at
Flat No. 506, 7 Block, Silicon Ridge Apartments, Raipushpa Apartments,
RajendraNagar, Attapur, Hyderabad - 500048.
2. Manjula Kakade, Wo.RavinderKakade Aged 66 years, Cunently residing
at. Flat No. 506, 7th Block, Silicon Ridge Apartments, Rajpushpa
Apartments, RajendraNagar, Attapur, Hyderabad - 500048.
years,
3. Ravinder Kakade, S/o.MahadevRaoKakade Aged
Ridge
Apartments,
Currentlyresidingat. Flat No. 506, 7th Block, Silicon
Rajpushpa Apartments, RajendraNagar, Attapur, Hyderabad -500048.
.....PETITIONERS
AND
1. Reserve Bank of lndia, Fourth Floor, Amar Building, SirPM Road,
Mumbai- 400001 .
2. Banking Ombudsman, Reserve Bank of lndia, Banking Ombudsman
Office, 6-1 -56, Secretariat Road, Saifabad, Hyderabad-500004.
3. Dealing Officer, Reserve Bank of lndia, Banking Ombudsman Office-ll,
Fort Glacis, Chennai, Tamil Nadu- 600001.
4. Banking Ombudsman, lClCl Bank Limited,34l,Arihant Apartment,
Railway Colony, Ward 12A, Gandhidham,Gujarat-37O2O1 .
5. Bank Manager, lClCl Bank Limited Head Office, lClCl Bank towers,
Bandra-Kurla Complbx Mumbai - 400'051.
6. Bank Manager, lClCl Bank Limited, Rajendranagar, 4-3-143iA, BPR
Towers, Attapur, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500048.
.....RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
7. Mr. Vimal Suhag, S/o.Azad Singh, aged 41 years, C-1104, Nilgiri
Apartments, Off Military Road, Bamandayapada, Marol, Andheri East
Mumbai, Maharastrar - 400072.
a
.....PROPOSED RESPONDENT No.7/RESPONDENT
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
implead Respondent No. 7 herein as Respondent No. 7 in WP No. 29898 of 2025.
Gounsel for the Petitioners : M/s VALA SRIHITHA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 4 : SRI G.KALYAN CHAKRAVARTHY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.S & 6 : -The Court made the following ORDER
a
e-"r'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI{A
trIRIT PETITION No. 29A9A OF 2o25
07.01.20/26
Between:
Vibha Kakade & two others
Petitioners
And
Reserve Bank of India & five others
..... Respondents
ORDER:
Petitioner No.1 (co-applicant) with her ex-husband
Mr. Vimar Suhag (principal borrower) had availed home loan of
Rs.27.5O lacs with ICICI Bank, Gandhidham Branch, Gujarat
for which petitioners 2 and 3, parents of petitioner No.l stood
as guarantors and also mortgaged the propert5r bearing Flat No.
506, Silicon. Ridge, Attapur Village, Rajendernagar Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District. It is stated, since April, 2022, both
petitioner No.1 and her husband started living separately and
from then, principal borrower defaulted in payment of home
loan.
1.1.
It is stated, petitioner No.l filed O.S.No. 643 of
2023 before the Principal Junior Civil Judge-cum-Additional
Metropolitan Magistrate's Court at Rajendernagar against Vimal
Suhah seeking a direction for monthly payment of EMI dues. [n
the meanwhile, loan account was declared as a 'Non Performing
Asset'. While so, accepting the OTS proposal of petitioner No.1
for an amount of Rs.25.5O lacs, tJ:e bank issued a settlement
offer letter dated 21.06.2024 ar:d accordingly, petitioner No. 1 on
29.06.2024 transferred the entire sum to the bank and
requested Respondent No.6 to return all the documents related
to the subject propert5r. The ICICI Bank, Gandhidham Branch
acknowledged payment and sent confirmation letter dated
29.04.2024 and they also sent letter dated O5.O7.2O25 to
petitioner No.1 to collect documents from Respondent No.6 by
19.07.2024. However, Respondent No.6 refused to hand over all
the documents citing pendency of suit. Petitioner No.l
therefore, is stated to have addressed representation dated
g1.O7.2O25 to Respondent No.6 and also raised a complaint
regarding imposition of conditions with Reserve Bank of India
a
on 26.08.2024 which was closed as being ah-judice.
It is stated, Petitioner No.l aggriev"d by the RBI
1.2.
reply dated 24.10.2024, addressed another representation dated
28.10.2024 to RBI Ombudsman stating that injunction suit has
no bearing on the bank and imposing conditions is in violation
/
J
of Section 171 of the Contracts Act, L976, however, petitioner
No.1 has not received any response. Hence, the Writ Petition.
2-
Learned counsel for petitioners Ms. Vala Srihitha
submits that as the home loan account is settled by petitioner
No.l, no prejudice would be caused to the bank due to
pendency of suit and after satisfaction of Home loan, the bank
cannot refuse to release the title documents. She relied on the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sgndicate Bank a.
Vtiag Kumart and that of Orissa High Court in Sujit Kumor
3.
Respondents No.1 to 3 filed counter stating that
petitioner No.l filed complaint dated 26.08.2024 through
Complaint Management System (CMS) portal before the Reserve
Bank of India against ICICI Bank; it was observed that
complainant had selected the following option in CMS portal
'the complaint is sub-judice I und.er arbitration / already dealt
with on merits by a Court / Tribunal / Arbitrator / Authority';
therefore, the complaint was auto closed by the system as non-
maintainable under Clause 16(1)(a) 10(2xb[ii) and accordingly,
closure letter dated 26.08.2024 was issued to complainant and
ICICI Bank. It is also stated, thereafter, petitioner No.1
' 1tssz1 2 scc 330
'zoz4 SCC Online Ori2632
submitted representation dated 27.08.2024, based on which
complaint was registered in CMS portal against ICICI Bank and
the same was forwarded to the bank. On 05.O9.2024, the bank
replied that matter is under consideration in OS.No. 643 of
2023 and the same be withdrawn for releasing the propert5r and
borrower needs to take steps for withdrawl. since the case is
pending, complaint was closed on 16.O3 .2025. The Ombudsman
followed the principles of natural justice and issued reasoned
orders after examining every aspect of the matter.
4.
Respondent No.6 filed counter stating that
petitioner No.1 and her husband Sri vimal Suhag were granted
home loan and instalments were recovered from the savings
account of Mr. Vimal Suhag but he was not arrayed as part5r
respondent to this writ Petition. Though petitioner No. 1 made
OTS payment on 29.06.2024, she did not comply with the
agreed mandatory conditions of withdrawl of pending litigation
against the bank. The said conditions were condition precedent
a
and were not introduced by bank after accepting the OTS
amount. It is stated, due to pendency of the said proceedings,
the bank acted with legal prudence and placed the matter on
hold to ensure that their rights were not prejudiced by parallel
litigation affecting the same loan account. It is therefore, lawful
/
arff prudent for the bank to await either formal withdrawl of
-
suit or to get an appropriate clarification or final order from the
civil Court.
5.
Heard Sri G. Kalyan Chakravarthy, learned
Standing Counsel for Respondents 1 to 4.
6.
Since Respondent No.6 had taken a ground that
husband of petitioner No.1 i.e. principal borrower was not made
part5i, on 10.12.2025, this Court directed learned counsel for
petitioner to implead him as party respondent to this Writ
Petition. Accordingly, learned counsel had taken out I.A.No. 3 of
2025. The said Application was ordered and notice was directed
to be served on the impleaded respondent. Accordingly, though
notice was served on15.12.2o25, Respondent No.7 did not
appear before this Court.
7.
Admittedly, petitioner No.1 settled and paid the
entire home loan amount and ICICI Bank, Gandhidham Branch
sent conlirmation letter dated 29.04.2024 stating that home
loan account would be closed in five days and all the related
documents such as no due certificate, title documents would be
released and transferred to Respondent No.6 branch and
directed petitioner No.1 uide letter dated O5.O7 -2025 to collect
the property documents from them by I9-O7-2O24- The
grievance of petitioner No.1 is that though there is such a
direction, Respondent No.6 is not releasing the documents
t
citing pendency of civil suit filed against her husband and bank.
At the same time, it is the case of respondent No.6 bank that
though amount was cleared under OTS, petitioner No.1 has not
complied with the mandatory condition of withdrawing pending
litigation filed against them and this condition is to ensure that
bank's rights were not prejudiced by parallel litigation affecting
the same loan account.
8.
Be that as it may, since the entire loan amount was
cleared under OTS and to that effect, ICICI Bank also issued
confirmation letter dated 29.04.2024, no prejudice would be
caused to defend5nt No.Z bank in the suit, if documents are
released in favour of petitioner No.1 pending litigation. Further,
it is also to be seen, as per the directions of this Court,
petitioner No.1 got impleaded her husband as Respondent No.7
and though notice was served, he did not make his appearance
before this Court. In these circumstances, relying on the
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Syndi cate Bank o.
Gijag Kumar (supra), which held that banker's lien under
Section 17 L of the Contract Act, 1972 can only be exercised
when there is an existing relationship between the banker and
the customer; when the loan amount is settled, the relationship
between the banker and customer ceases and the bankers lien
comes to an end, this Court deems it appropriate to direct
r
i
l
I
.
respondent bank to release the documents of the mortgaged
propert5r in favour of petitioner No. 1.
9.
In the result, the Writ Petition is disposed of
directing Respondent ICICI Bank to release the documents in
respect of the mortgaged property i.e. Flat No. 506, Silicon
Ridge, Attapur Village, Rajender Nagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District in favour of petitioner No.1 forthwith. No costs.
10.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
/
I
SD/-P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
To
SECTION OFFICER
1. The Reserve Bank of lndia, Fourth Floor, Amar Building, SirPM Road,
Mumbai- 400001.
2. The Banking Ombudsman, Reserve Bank of lndia, Banking Ombudsman
Office, 6-1 -56, Secretariat Road, Sai labad,Hyderabad-500004.
3. The Dealing Officer, Reserve Bank of lndia, Banking Ombudsman Office-ll,
Fort Glacis, Chennai, Tamil Nadu- 600001.
4. The Banking Ombudsman, lclCl Bank Limited,34l,Arihant Apartment,
Railway Colony, Ward 1 2A, Gand h idham, G ujarat-37 O2O1 .
5. The Bank fVlanager, lclcl Bank Limited Headoffice, lclcl Bank towers,
Bandra-Kurla Complex Mumbai - 400 051.
6. The Bank Manager, lclcl Bank Limited, Rajendranagar, 4-3-143lA, BPR
Towers, Attapur, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500048.
7. One CC to M/s VALA SRIHITHA, Advocate [OPUC]
8. One CC to SRI G.KALYAN CHAKRAVARTHY, Advocate IOPUC]
9. Two CD Copies
SA
W
.
HIGH COURT
DATED:07/0112020
t
t
(
(J
Ii1tr O
1 6 J;l:i 7l'!1s
*
1...,
l
ORDER
WP.No.29898 of 2025
DISPOSING OF THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review