Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
®
!
%
&
"
#
"$
#
"
' &
!"#$ %
"
!"#$ %
NIJAMUDDIN
JAMKHANDI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
&
"
!"#$ %
&$
!"#$ %
"
(
-2-
$
!"#$ %
$
&#
!"#$ %
&&
'
!"#$ %
#
$"
!"#$ %
(
$
#
!
!"#& &
)
*
+
,
-
$%
!"#$
-3-
"
!"#$ %
)
'
'
'
'
&
% "
% !%&!
% "
,
!
'
.
/01 23404056 01 70839 :; 4/3 234040563<1 133=06> 45
?@A1/
&
4/3
0B2@>639
% " 9A439 %
0D08 @9>3
%&
C5B2<5B013
93C<33
% " 2A1139 :; 4/3
<06C02A8
0EA;A2@<A
4 01 4/3 C564364056 57 83A<639 C5@6138 75< 4/3
234040563<1 4/A4 4/3 234040563<1 A69 <3125693641 A<3
C52A<C363<1 A69 4/3 1@04 1C/39@83 2<523<4; 01 A6 A6C314<A8
E5064 7AB08; 2<523<4; 57 4/3 234040563<1 A69 /@1:A69 57
<312569364
/3 6AB31 57 234040563<1 A69 <312569364
CAB3 45 :3 B@4A439 06 4/3 E5064 5F63<1/02 9A439
-4-
%
%
% "
4 01 4/3 7@<4/3< C564364056 57 83A<639 C5@6138
75< 4/3 234040563<1 4/A4 <312569364
06 C588@1056 F04/
<312569364
A883>398; 3643<39 0645 A6 A><33B364 57
1A83 9A439
$%
% " 06 <3123C4 57 &% >@64A1 57 8A69 A69
:; C588@906> F04/ 3AC/ 54/3<
/3<306 F/5 70839
06140>A439 4/3 <312569364
&
% " 75< 4/3 <38037 57
123C070C 23<75<BA6C3 57 A C564<AC4
/3 1@04 FA1 70839 56
%
% " A69 6540C3 FA1 >54 011@39 56
(%
A C5B2<5B013 23404056 CAB3 45 :3 70839 @693<
@83 & 57
A69 :;
593 57
0D08
<93< 9A439 %
<5C39@<3
%&
% " A69
<93< ,,
(%# 56 %$ %&
% " 4/3 83A<639
0D08
% "
@9>3
ACC32439 4/3 C5B2<5B013 23404056 A69 2A1139 A E@9>B364
A69 93C<33 56 4/3 :A101 57 4/3 1A09 C5B2<5B013 23404056
4 01 4/01 5<93< 57 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 4/A4 01 ?@31405639 :;
4/3 234040563<1 /3<306 /AD06> 654 :336 BA93 2A<4031 45
4/3 1A09 5<0>06A8 1@04 2<5C33906>1
&
4 01 4/3 C564364056 57 4/3 234040563<1 4/A4 4/3
1A09 C5B2<5B013 23404056 01 0883>A8 A<:04<A<; A69 7<A@9@8364
C<3A439 A69 3G3C@439 :3/069 4/3 :AC= 57 4/3
-5-
234040563<1 F/5 A<3 654 BA93 2A<4031 45 4/3 5<0>06A8 1@04
/3<375<3
F/36 4/3 2<523<4; 01 A6 A6C314<A8 2<523<4;
:3856>06> 45 4/3 234040563<1 A69 4/3 <3125693641 A69 4/3
B@4A4056 364<; 14A691 06 4/3 6AB3 57 4/3 234040563<1 A856>
F04/ 4/3 <312569364
4/3 ?@314056 57 4/3 <3125693641
654 BA=06> 4/3 234040563<1 2A<4031 45 4/3 1@04 2<5C33906>1
A69 /AD06> 5:4A0639 A 93C<33 7<A@9@83648; :3/069 4/3 :AC=
57 4/3 234040563<1 01 0883>A8 A69 A<:04<A<;
36C3 4/3 1AB3
<3?@0<31 45 :3 134 A1093 A69 4/3 234040563<1H 1A; <3?@0<31 45
:3 C561093<39
/01
5@<4 9531 654 7069 A 6339 5< 63C31104; 45
011@3 6540C3 45 4/3 <3125693641 A1 4/01
90<3C4 4/3
<0A8
5@<4 01 06C80639 45
5@<4 45 C561093< 4/3 A2280CA4056 5<
23404056 07 A6; 70839 :; 4/3 234040563<1
"
4 01 1336 4/A4 4/3 234040563<1 F3<3 654 BA93
2A<4031 45 4/3 5<0>06A8 1@04 2<5C33906>1 06
F/0C/ 36939 @2 06 A C5B2<5B013 93C<33
&
% "
34040563<1 /AD3
<A0139 13D3<A8 C5643640561 A69 @<>39 13D3<A8 ><5@691 45
134 A1093 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33
A1 4/3 1AB3 FA1
-6-
5:4A0639 7<A@9@83648; :3/069 4/3 :AC= 57 4/3 234040563<1
BA; 654 :3 2<523< 75< 4/01
5@<4 45 3643<4A06 4/01 23404056
A1 4/3 BA443< F088 /AD3 45 :3 <3D3<439 45 4/3 D3<; 1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/ 2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 45 <3C561093<
4/3 BA443< A7<31/ 56 4/3 234040563<1 70806> A6 A2280CA4056
5<
23404056
%
% " 06 10B08A< C0<C@B14A6C31 90125139 577 A
%
23404056 56 %
56.:83
%
23G
A69
/01
5@<4
5@<4 06 4/3 CA13 57
56.:83
23G
5@<4 /389 06 2A<A><A2/
A1 @693<
!
# %! %
# %! %
+
*
#
%
!
!
$
/0!
#
%
%
#
"
%
% "
% $ <38;06> @256 4/3 E@9>B364 57 4/3
F/3<306 4/3
&
"
!
#
$
&
##
#
!
#
'
%
#
(
&
"
) *
!! , $
"
!
$
%
&
"
& "
## ! $
%
.
*
!
(
) * +
%
1 #
1 "
" #
&
*
&
$
%
'
# 3# *
4)
&
&
"
5!
#
$ "
-7-
!
*
# %! %
#
$
%
*
##
# 3# *
!
#
#
#
$
0 %
$
,
"
#
!
"
"
# %! %
#
! , %
!! #
"
)
%%
)778
$
88 '
*
"
#
"
" (
: *+
% "
6 &,
, "
%
%
48*
(
) * +
#
#
"
!!
$
#
#
#
$
"
$
#
# %! %
%
& *
#
"
& "
"
$
#
#
; # *
,
% ,
&
$$
! ,
!!
#
#
#
# %! %
!
(
) *+
<
!
$
#
1 4
!
%
%%
!
!
=
!!
#
#
&
+ -
%
" (
%
$
#
!!
"
"
$
#
" #
"
:
!
$
"
%
#
#
=
$
&
"
%
#
&
<
#
=
$
)
&
$
$
! #"#
&
$
$
# %! %
# %! %
%
" +
(
#
# %! %
# %! %
#
+
&
#
"
"
"
>3
-8-
3#
&,
#
&
#
* &,
#
#
!
#
!!
#
!! #
!
+
"
!
$
!
(
*
,
,
#
%
#
,
&
#
!!
#
#
#
#
# %! %
%
#
%
" *
&
# %! %
'
*
#
#
#
# %! %
#
#
# %! %
& #
#
#
&
#
# &
!
! %!
" !!
"
#
, "
#
#
!
,
"
$
%
# %! %
#
%
$
#
)
*
4 F5@89 :3 <383DA64 75< 4/01
<93< ,,
@83 &!
"
$
,
5@<4 45 3G4<AC4
F/0C/ <3A91 A1 @693<
!
"
????
#$ %
#
#
!
" =
$
#
# %! %
" @
&
4 F5@89 :3 <383DA64 75< 4/01
5@<4 45 938D3 0645
4/3 BA443< 7@<4/3< 06 D03F 57 4/3<3 :306> 15B3 C56780C406>
D03F1
F04/
<3>A<9
F/34/3<
A
C/A8836>3
4/3
-9-
C5B2<5B013 93C<33 C5@89 :3 :375<3 4/3 1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/
2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 5< :; 70806> A 132A<A43 1@04
5< :; FA; 57 70806> A F<04 23404056
#
6 4/3 CA13 57 %
! %
$
% '!
% '!
<325<439 06 (
36C/ 57 4/01
&
&
)*+ ,
5@<4 A4 2A<A><A2/
- *. )/%+
0D01056
/389 A1
% A69
@693<
7 '
$
"
>
-
!
#
#
"
'
"
>3
!!
(
=
8 "
! ! ,
!
+ % !! 6
! *
!!
(
=
8 "
"
% #
%
!
!!
!
"
# %! %
&
$
*
&,
#
) *+
!
$&
A "
!!
#
!
>
#
!! #
B $ *
#
!
(
=
!
&,
E
"(
$
&,
C #
- #
"
#
&
"
'
#!
'
3!! #
"
: "
(
"
!!
, !
##
=
=
#
$ ,*
$ ,
"
:
% $
"
D8
- 10 -
!!
!
!
A "
! ,
# %! %
, $
'
"
%
*
!
"
!!
,
" #
!
# %! %
%
"
, 0 #
&,
"
>+ % !!
&,
%
&
$
!!
&
$
+
" + % !! 6
,
,
"
"
$ %
/
#
# %! %
#
!
#
"
"
# @
(
2 !
**
>+ % !!
"
6 4/3 CA13 57
30 !
0D01056
<325<439 06
36C/ 57 4/01
# ,$
5@<4 93A84 F04/ A BA443<
F/3<3 A>A06 A C5B2<5B013 93C<33 FA1 C/A8836>39
6 4/01
CA13 4/3 011@3 4/A4 FA1 93A84 F04/ FA1 4/3 C5B2<5B013
93C<33 06 A <32<31364A40D3 1@04 F/3<3 A
5@<4 /389 4/A4 A
23<156 F/5 01 3773C439 :; 1@C/ C5B2<5B013 :@4 654 A
2A<4; 45 04 BA; 7083 A 132A<A43 1@04 133=06> 2<523< <380371
<3>A<9
1@C/
C5B2<5B013
93C8A<A4056 5< 54/3<F013
E@9>B364 4/3
0D01056
93C<33
4 2A<A><A2/
:;
36C/ /A1 /389 A1 @693<
FA;
57 4/3 4/01
- 11 -
:
, !! ,
(
6 *
"
#
#
3 #
#
!
&
& 2
#
$ $
# %! %
#
#
#
#
!
, "
# %! %
&
#
#
!
##
#
+
3 &
%!
#
$
# %! %
!
& #
! ,
# %! %
#
$
# %! %
" *
&, " $
!! #
%
&, " $
!!
(
: +
#
%
&
,
!
3 !
! ,
*#
&
,"
!! #
*
!! *
#
$
# %! %
&
$
"
!
* "
#
!
!
% & "
#
$
& $
!
# %! % D $
%
*
,
"" # & # % !
&
%
&
! ,
$
# %! %
#
#
*
#
"
'
#
!
!
#
#
#
#
+
*
#
!
!
&
"
!! #
"
!!
(
: +
"
$
& $
!
9 $ !! !
% ,*
%
"" #
E
"
"+
# %!
*
!
$
#
# %! %
!
*
, !
"" #
&,
# # %! %
#
* &
! ,
% , "
!
9 $
!! !
"
$
# # %! %
#
* &,
, "
#
;
)
+
*
! #!
# #
- 12 -
% ,
"
# %! %
&
&,
!! @
%
"
!!
!
#
#
!
5!5<906A43
#!
36C/
" $
"
-
$
&
#
4/01
5@<4
/A9
4/3
5225<4@604; 45 93A8 F04/ 4/3 1AB3 011@3 06 4/3 CA13 57
!
2 4 56!
<325<439 06
,
<38;06> @256 4/3 E@9>B364 57
23G
5@<4 06 4/3 CA13 57 7
)/+
0D01056
!
/01
36C/ 57
!0
!
##
5@<4
56H:83
$
!
<325<439 06 $
((( BA93 A 901406C4056 A69 A<<0D39 A4 A
C56C8@1056 4/A4 A 23<156 F/5 01 6304/3< A 2A<4; 45 4/3 1@04
65< 45 C5B2<5B013 23404056 /A9 A6 06932369364 <0>/4 45
133= A6; 1/A<3 06 4/3 1@04 2<523<4;
@693<
@83 &
<93< ,,
/3<375<3 4/3 :A<
01 654 A228039 A1 /3 01
C8A0B06> 06932369364 <0>/4
/3
(
( .8
5!5<906A43
36C/ 57 4/01
# 06 4/3 CA13 57
5@<4 06
&
<38;06> @256 4/3 CA13 57 4/3 E@9>B364 06 4/3 CA13 57
%
!'
&
$
*1@2<A+ A69
- 13 -
DA<05@1 54/3< E@9>B3641 A4 2A<A><A2/
# /A1 /389 A1
@693<
'
#
!
#
!
""
&
$
! ,
( =
)D)7)
# %! %
#
"
# %! , $
+
"(
??''' "
"
#
!! #
!
""
!
&
# %! %
(
=
7 D)7)
$
$
" #
!
""
! ,
#
*
%
!! #
"
&,
"
=
@
6 4/3 CA13 57 &
$
' %
*
$
'94
,
( .*#
<325<439 06
0D01056
5@<4 93A84 F04/ 1AB3 104@A4056 0 3
901B011A8 57 C5B2<5B013 93C<33
36C/ 57 4/01
C/A8836>3 45 4/3
4 2A<A><A2/
/389 A1 @693<
; # *
#
!
!
""
"
(
=
4 D)7
#
$ $
# %! %
#
!
(
=
D
)
+ #
"
!
""* "
,*
&
##
#
(
??''' +
"
6 *
$ !
#
&
; # *
" %
" #
A $
A@
" 04
- 14 -
&
56H:83
23G
5@<4 93A84 F04/ 10B08A< 1@:E3C4
BA443< A69 /389 A1 @693< 06 4/3 75885F06> CA131
0D01056
36C/ 57
/
% 0
CA13 57 &!
56H:83
)
"(
=
#
#
#
=
"
$
$
&
#
" %
%%
%
$
&
$
%
"#
=
#
!
# %! %
# %! %
+
>3
!
"
#
&
#
#
*
#
<
$
! #"# &
(
)
,
%
:
&
"
"
$
"
!!
#
!
"
#
#
&,
* &,
+
%
&
$
# %! %
#
$
# %! %
% "+
(
.+ *
!!
#
#
% $
) #
&
!!
#
"
!0
<325<439 06 )
!
!
5@<4 06 4/3
+
*.. /A1 /389 A1 @693< 06 2A<A><A2/
23G
"
!
$
#
!
!! #
#
,
&
!
#
#
#
,
*
- 15 -
!!
#
# %! %
&
*
#
" #
#
%
#
% " *
# %! %
'
#
#
# %! %
#
# %! %
& #
#
#
$&
#
# &
!
! %!
" !!
"
#
, "
#
#
!
,
, "
$
%
# %! %
#
%
#
"
*
#
$
#
# %! %
#
" ,
"
!
"
!! #
"
$
#
#
) > >)77
&,
$ $
# %! %
##
#
$ "#
,*
"
"
#
$
#
#
.
&
"*
#
"
"
,
"
)4> >)77
"
!!
#
!
!! #
"
& "
#
#
!
#
#
#
!!
&,
#
"
%
& *
$
$
0!
&
#
#
"
"
0D01056
CA13 57 2
&
/
+
)
#
#
36C/ 57
56H:83
)
+
!0
!0
. 06 2A<A><A2/
23G
5@<4 06 4/3
2 &
<325<439 06 )
A1 /389 A1 @693<
(:+
- 16 -
4 '
#
*
9 ! $
+
>3 "
1 6 1 "
"
! "
"
#
&
#
(
)
"
6 #
*
"
$
#
"
& #
#
# !
&
" $ "
, !! *
#
!! , & #
#
!!
"
#
6 *
$
!
77 6
!
!
% 9 $
!
"
$
#
#
!
$
%
#
$
D !!
$
"
&,
*
#
0# !
&
$ "
#
$
" "
# %%
&
$
, #
!! !
#
*% ,
'
#
*
0 %
! $
"
!
$
!!
$
!
"
$
#9
#
%
!
*
! !
!! #
,
$
!!
!
"
%
"
!
!
!
"
,
&
#
*
%
,
;$
!!
"
" #
$
#
" "" # $
$
" # %! %
0 %
*
*
#
!
,
"
%
$ '
%
$
! #
$ "
&,
!
! #
#
# %!
*
#
>
;$
!!
0 %
"
!!
;$
#
#
- 17 -
7 '
"
" #
*
#
0 %
$
&,
$
!
!!
;$
##
"
0 %
"
#
!
!!
!
!
"
##
%! $
!
%
"
#
#
##
&,
,
"
#
$ "
;$
$
56H:83
%
#
"
%
&
" %
!
"
%
!
) > >)774
;$
"
&
$
%
$
%
#
@
6 4/3 CA13 57 7
23G
%
%
*1@2<A+ 4/3
A69
A1 /389 A1
5@<4 06 2A<A><A2/
,
$
, $ ! #!
* #
"
&
&
"
+
3 "(
@693<
4 .
"
"
# %! %
)
6 !
"
#
&
#
$ "
%
!
! #"# &
#
$
# %! %
#
#
&
"
# %
" (
) +
%
! # , "
$
! % !
%# &, # %
%
#
" *
$
, #
!
"
!
#
&
%
$
$
# %! %
"" #
"
,
#
%
&
! ,
%!
"
# %! %
!
- 18 -
$ !
!! #
)
,*
!
!
&
+
" (
& "
)) '
*
!!
#
, # %
$
!
#
%! , *
" $
%
&
%! ,
"
#
# %! %
#
C
,
& #
!!
! ,
# %! %
#
" #
"
!
#
*
&
"
!!
* % #
$
%
#
" #
, "
# %! %
#
!
&,
;$
&,
, "
&
& "
#
#
"
*
$
&
$
% 3
% $*
#
$
&
, "
# %! %
&,
!
!
*
,
;$
*
## !
# %! %
!
#
&
* #
0 %
%
!
+
" (
)
6 ' %
*
"
* "
& "
#
&,
!!
%
&
"
! #"# &
+
3 "(
)
%! $
- $%
@
0D01056
CA13 57
36C/ 57
!6!
56.:83
%
; 5
23G
5@<4 06 4/3
7 !
%
$
<325<439 06 )
06 2A<A><A2/
5 &( /A1 /389 A1 @693<
&
+ (*
. *
- 19 -
3 %
#
"
""
$
# %! %
"
*
# &
(
) +
>3
6 *
#
#
# %! %
#
!
! #
=
) "
8)) "
3!!
= 4 4 " )77 * 6
&
*
%
&
&
!
,
&,
9 =
$
$
&
(
) +
>3
!! # &
!
,
% ,
&
%
&
!!
#
% #
'
!
#
*
#
0 #
!
&
"
&
" %
; # *
"
&
& @
#
,
!
0D01056
CA13 57
36C/ 57
4!
9! !
<325<439 06
*
56H:83
23G
5@<4 06 4/3
0 )
*(
A4 2A<A><A2/
$
!0
+
A69
A1 /389 A1 @693<
)
,
"
%%
1 4
!
, $
#
!! #
$
+ !
!
!
"(
=
#
#
!!
$
%
# %!
#
$ * )778
"
"
% $
) #
&
%
$
%
&
" %
%%
$
! #"# &
!
<
%
!
<
#
#
"
- 20 -
=
#
#
!!
#
%
=
%
#
$
# %! %
"+
(
!
# %! %
#
%
+
>3
# %!
#
3#
#
#
(
&
"
$
"
"
$
"
#
#
!
&
!!
&,
* &,
+
)
"
*
,
#
%
#
!!
#
# %! %
&
*
#
" #
#
#
"
$
%
,
&
#
#
#
#
!
#
,
*
#
%
#
% " *
# %! %
'
#
#
# %! %
#
# %! %
#
#
$&
!
! %!
"
#
, "
!
,
, "
# %! %
#
& #
&
!!
#
%
#
*
"
!!
&
"
#
"
$
"
"
!
&
$
!
!! #
#
"
&
$
# %! %
"
:
#
%
## !
#
"
"
#
#
&,
"
!!
F $
"
# %! % *
#
!
#
*
"
, '
*
!!
"
#
!! #
& "
$
F
- 21 -
!
!!
F "
%
#
G C
#
*
#
,
'
"
"
7 )7)) !
)
3##
(
$ ,*
&
&,
*
%! $
;$
!!
%
@
6 4/3 2<31364 CA13 56 /A69 04 01 4/3 CA13 57
234040563<1 4/A4 4/3; F3<3 654 BA93 2A<4031 45 4/3 5<0>06A8
1@04 A69 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 /A1 :336 2A1139 :; 4/3
83A<639
<0A8 @9>3 06 4/30< A:136C3
4 01 A815 C56436939
4/A4 1@04 1C/39@83 2<523<4031 A<3 A6C314<A8 2<523<4031 57
234040563<1 A69 /@1:A69 57 <312569364
@4 :3/069
4/3 :AC= 57 4/3 234040563<1 A 9380:3<A43 A443B24 FA1 A69
7<A@9@8364 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 01 5:4A0639 F/0C/ 01 0883>A8
A69 A<:04<A<; A69 4/3 1AB3 /A1 45 :3 134 A1093
%
DA<05@1
7 !
3D3<A8 E@9>B3641 A<3 2A1139 :; 4/01
5@<41 A69 4/3
56.:83
23G
*1@2<A+ A69
5@<4 A69
5@<4 06 4/3 CA13 57
!6!
%
*1@2<A+ D3<; 123C070CA88; 93A84 F04/
- 22 -
C/A8836>3 :; A 14<A6>3< 45 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33
F/34/3< 45 :3 BA93 :; FA; 57 132A<A43 1@04 5< 06 4/3
1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/ 2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33
/3
?@314056 /A1 :336 <A0139 06 4/3 75885F06> BA663<! I /3
?@314056 A<0131 06 4/3 A223A8 75< 5@< C561093<A4056 01 A1 45
F/34/3< 56 A 93C<33 2A1139 06 A C5B2<5B013 23404056 CA6
:3 C/A8836>39 :; 4/3 14<A6>3< 45 4/3 2<5C33906>1 06 A
132A<A43 1@04JK A69 4/3 1AB3 /A1 :336 A61F3<39 06 4/3
63>A40D3
06 D03F 57 4/3 123C070C :A< @693<
<93< ,,
4/3
56H:83
593 57
23G
0D08
5@<4 06
<5C39@<3
@83 &
/3 1A09 5206056 57
% % 01 7@<4/3< 75<407039 :; 4/3
8A43< E@9>B364 93A806> F04/ 4/3 D3<; 1AB3 011@3 06 4/3
CA13 57
!6!
%
7 !
*1@2<A+ :;
/58906> I /3 8AF 56 4/01 25064 01 A8<3A9; 1344839 :; 4/01
5@<4 06 7
4/3 :A< @693<
<93< ,,
@83 &!
01 A2280CA:83 45 4/0<9 2A<4; A1 F388
/3 568;
<3B39; ADA08A:83 45 4/3B F5@89 :3 45 A22<5AC/ 4/3 D3<;
1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/ 9<3F C5B2<5B013 93C<33 K
- 23 -
6 4/3 CA13 57
$
*1@2<A+ 4/3
4!
56H:83
@2<3B3
5@<4 /A1 /389
4/A4 4/3 7<31/ 1@04 01 14088 654 DA809 <3B39; A>A0614
C5B2<5B013 93C<33
/3 568; <3B39; F5@89 :3 45 7083 A6
A2280CA4056 :375<3 4/3 1AB3
5@<4
F/0C/ 2A1139 4/3
C5B2<5B013 93C<33
6 D03F 57 4/3 13D3<A8 E@9>B3641 57 4/01
A69
56.:83
A4 :; 4/3
23G
56.:83
5@<4 A69 A 706A804; /AD06> :336 A<<0D39
23G
*1@2<A+
*1@2<A+
5@<4
5@<4 06 4/3 CA131 57 7
!6!
4!
%
7 !
$
*1@2<A+ 04 01 65 B5<3 <31 0643><A 4/A4 F/36 A 23<156 2A<4;
45 C5B2<5B013 4/3 93C<33 C/A8836>31 4/3 C5B2<5B013
93C<33 :375<3 A6;
5@<4 54/3< 4/A6 4/3 D3<; 1AB3
5@<4
F/0C/ 2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 1@C/ 23404056 F5@89
654 :3 BA064A06A:83
&
3C5698; 4/3 568; <3B39; 75< A 2A<4; 45 4/3
C5B2<5B013 93C<33 07 A>><03D39 56 4/3 <3A156 57 7<A@9 01
- 24 -
45 C/A8836>3 4/3 1AB3 :375<3 4/3 D3<; 1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/
2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33
7 A 23<156 F/5 01 654 2A<4; 45 4/3 C5B2<5B013
93C<33 C/A8836>39 4/3 1A09 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 :; FA; 57 A
132A<A43 1@04
4/3 1AB3 01 654 1@14A06A:83
123C070C :A< @693<
"
<93< ,,
06 D03F 57
@83 &!
6 4/3 2<31364 CA13 56 /A69 4/3 234040563<1 A<3
654 2A<4031 45 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 A69 4/3; /AD3 70839
2<31364 F<04 23404056 ?@31405606> 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33
/3 F<04 23404056 F5@89 654 :3 BA064A06A:83 A1 <3B39;
ADA08A:83 45 4/3 234040563<1 01 45 A22<5AC/ 4/3 D3<; 1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/ 2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 45 A>04A43 A69
@<>3 A88 250641 A69 C5643640561 4/A4 A<3 4A=36 06 4/01
23404056 :375<3 4/3 1A09
$
CC5<906>8;
5@<4
2A11 4/3 75885F06>
- 25 -
/01 23404056 01
34040563<1 A<3 2<5D0939 80:3<4; 45 A22<5AC/ 4/3
D3<; 1AB3
5@<4 F/0C/ 2A1139 4/3 C5B2<5B013 93C<33 :;
70806> A6 A2280CA4056 5< 23404056
@<>06> A88 ><5@691 A69
C5643640561 F/0C/ A<3 4A=36 @2 /3<3 :375<3 4/01
5@<4
70806> 1@C/ A2280CA4056 5< 23404056 4/3 83A<639
<0A8 @9>3
1/A88 C561093< 4/3 1AB3 A7<31/ 06 ACC5<9A6C3 F04/ 8AF A69
=33206> 06 B069 4/3 5:13<DA40561 57 4/3
56.:83
23G
5@<4 06 4/3 CA131 B36405639 /3<306A:5D3 A69 93C093 4/3
BA443< 3G23905@18;
)*
'
"
#
$
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review