The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In view of the same, this Court is of the view that not only the writ petitions are not maintainable, but also having regard the nature of the duties discharged by the petitioners, the petitioners are not entitle to the claim of enhancement of age of superannuation.
12. Accordingly, the writ petitions are dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, all pending miscellaneous applications shall stand closed. THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA WRIT PETITION Nos.32434, 12855 & 17193 of 2023 and 10202, 10284, 10298, 10611 & 14491 of 2024
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010621042023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3458]
WEDNESDAY,THE FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA
WRIT PETITION NO: 32434/2023
Between:
...PETITIONER
Venkata Rama Rao
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SCHOOL EDUCATION (AP)
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 12855/2023
Between:
...PETITIONER
Palli Hymavathi
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES II
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 17193/2023
Between:
...RESPONDENT(S)
Pentakota Rama Satyam and Others
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State Of Ap and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. ANIL KUMAR DASARI
2. GP FOR SERVICES II
3. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 10202/2024
Between:
...PETITIONER(S)
GorliShoury Sukumar and Others
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State Of Ap and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES II
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 10284/2024
Between:
...PETITIONER
Palli Hymavathi
AND
The State Of Ap and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES II
...RESPONDENT(S)
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 10298/2024
Between:
...PETITIONER
Madani Maria
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State Of Ap and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES II
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 10611/2024
Between:
...PETITIONER(S)
Piridi Prakasha Rao and Others
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State Of Ap and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SCHOOL EDUCATION
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 14491/2024
Between:
...PETITIONER(S)
T. Anuradha and Others
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
...RESPONDENT(S)
1. GP FOR SERVICES II
2. V SUBRAHMANYAM
The Court made the following:
COMMON ORDER:
Heard Sri A.K.Kishore Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioners
and Sri V.Subrahmanyam, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
2nd respondent.
2.
The prayer sought in the writ petition is for a direction to the
respondents to enhance the age of superannuation of the petitioners from 60
to 62 years, on the basis of G.O.Ms.No.15, Finance (HR.IV-FR & LR)
Department, dated 31.01.2022, amending the provisions of Section 3 of The
Andhra Pradesh Public Employment (Regulation of Age of Superannuation)
Act, 1984, (for short, “the Act, 1984”).
3.
The 2nd respondent is a Central Public Sector Undertaking,
Government of India. It is contended that pursuant to a Memorandum of
Understanding between Rastriya Ispath Nigam Limited (RINL) - the
2nd respondent and the 3rd respondent - Society, the 4th respondent school was
established to impart education to the children of RINL employees. The
infrastructural facilities for running the educational institution are being
provided by the 2nd respondent at nominal charges. In pursuance thereof, the
4th respondent school was established. Contending that the provisions of the
Act, 1984, and the provisions of Section 78A of Andhra Pradesh Education
Act, 1982, as regards the age of superannuation, would apply to the case of
the petitioners, the petitioners have earlier approached this Court, seeking the
same benefit of enhanced age of superannuation as that of the teaching staff
of the Government Schools from 58 to 60 years.
4.
The petitioners, who are working in the said school, had claimed
for enhancement of superannuation from 58 to 60 years on par with the
regular teachers working in the Government schools in terms of the
amendment made. The petitioners were not given the said benefit. Seeking
redressal of the said grievance, the petitioners have earlier filed W.P.No.1432
of 2019.
The same was dismissed vide order dated 05.08.2019.
Being
aggrieved by the same, a writ appeal was filed in W.A.No.267 of 2019. The
said writ appeal was partly allowed on 27.11.2019, directing the respondents
to enhance the age of superannuation from 58 to 60 years. Against the said
order, the 2nd and 4th respondents filed appeals before the Hon’ble Apex
Court. The said SLP’s were dismissed. In the meanwhile, the 1st respondent
issued G.O.Ms.No.15, Finance (HR.IV-FR & LR) Department, dated
31.01.2022, pursuant to the Andhra Pradesh Public Employment (Regulation
of Age of Superannuation) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2022 (A.P. Ordinance
No.1 of 2022), enhancing the age of superannuation in the employees of the
State Government from 60 to 62 years. In furtherance of the said G.O., the
petitioners have made a representation to the respondents to allow them to
work till completion of 62 years. The same was not considered. Hence the
instant writ petition.
5.
The respondents filed counter affidavit stating that the petitioners
are not entitled for the benefits of the amendment made to the provisions of
the Act,1984, and that the writ petition is not maintainable.
The State
Government Service Conditions would not apply to the petitioners. Unless the
2nd respondent falls within the list of corporations/companies/societies or other
institutions listed under Schedule IX and X of the Andhra Pradesh
Reorganization Act, 2014, the amended provision would not apply to the
petitioners. It is further contended that since the 4th respondent school was
established by the 3rd respondent society, their pay and allowances have been
discharged by the 2nd respondent in terms of the Memorandum of Agreement
and the State Education Department did not provide any aid or assistance to
the 4th respondent school. In other words, it is stated that the subject school is
a private school, therefore, not entitled to the benefit of Section 78A of Andhra
Pradesh Education Act, 1982. It is further contended that the 4th respondent
school is not under the administrative control of the State Government. It is
argued that the Act 4 of 1984 has been enacted to regulate the age of
superannuation of the persons appointed to public services and in connection
with the affairs of State of Andhra Pradesh. In view of the same, amendments
made under the said Act would not apply to the 4th respondent school.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner Sri A.K.Kishore Reddy, argues
that in the MOA between the 2nd respondent and the 3rd respondent, it was
agreed that the scales of pay and other allowances of the teaching and
non-teaching staff of the school would be governed by the Rules and
Regulations of the Andhra Pradesh Education Act, 1982. Placing reliance on
the judgment of the Division Bench in W.A.No.267 of 2019, it is contended that
the petitioners' age of superannuation should be enhanced to 62 years.
7.
Sri V.Subrahmanyam, learned Standing Counsel appearing for
the 2nd respondent, placing reliance on the Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Dileep Kumar Pandey and another Vs. Union of India
& Others, contends that the writ petition is not maintainable.
He further
relying on the Judgments of this Court and Hon’ble Apex Court in
W.P.Nos.1033 of 2022 & batch and in the case of Armu Welfare Education
Society, New Delhi Vs. Sunil Kumar Sharma & Others, contends that the
4th respondent is a private entity and the relationship between the 2nd and 3rd
respondents is in the private domain thus the petitioners are also employees
of the 3rd respondent Society andthey cannot have any right to invoke the
jurisdiction under Article 226 for enhancement of age of superannuation. With
regard to the contention of the petitioners that the order of the Division Bench
in W.A.No.267 of 2019 has become final, the learned Standing Counsel,
Sri V.Subrahmanyam, placing reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Shivappa Etc.Vs The Chief Engineer and Others in
Civil Appeal Nos.2694-2700 of 2023, contends that mere dismissal of the SLP
would not amount to affirmation of the view taken by the High Court, unless
the Judgment of the High Court is affirmed at least with short reasoning and
the same would not amount to binding precedent.
8.
Considered the rival submissions.
9.
Perusal of the record would indicate that as per Clauses 7(a) and
8 of MOA dated - January, 2015, it is the responsibility of the 2nd respondent
Company to meet the expenditure of the school relating to recurring and nonrecurring heads of expenditure.
As per Clause 11 of the said MOA, the
teaching and non-teaching staff of the 4th respondent – school are entitled to
the same scales of pay and other allowances as would be paid by State
Government. The provisions of Section 78A of Andhra Pradesh Education Act,
1982, would not apply to the facts of the present case, since the
4th respondent school is not an aided institution. Mere obligation under the
MOA on the part of the 2nd respondent company to pay salaries of the
teaching staff would not entitle the petitioners to claim enhancement of age of
superannuation as that of the State Government employees. The obligation
on the part of the 2nd respondent in payment of salaries is referrable to the
contract between the Company and the Society, and the same would not
make the petitioners as employees of the 2nd respondent Company.
10.
Further, with regard to the contention of the respondents as to the
maintainability of the writ petition, a reference to the decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of St. Mary's Education Society and Another Vs.
Rajendra Prasad Bhargava and Others1, is required to be made in the said
regard, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as follows:
“75.We may sum up our final conclusions as under:—
(a) An application under Article 226 of the Constitution is maintainable
against a person or a body discharging public duties or public functions.
The public duty cast may be either statutory or otherwise and where it is
otherwise, the body or the person must be shown to owe that duty or
obligation to the public involving the public law element. Similarly, for
ascertaining the discharge of public function, it must be established that
the body or the person was seeking to achieve the same for the collective
benefit of the public or a section of it and the authority to do so must be
accepted by the public.
(b) Even if it be assumed that an educational institution is imparting public
duty, the act complained of must have a direct nexus with the discharge
of public duty. It is indisputably a public law action which confers a right
upon the aggrieved to invoke the extraordinary writ jurisdiction under
Article 226 for a prerogative writ. Individual wrongs or breach of mutual
contracts without having any public element as its integral part cannot be
rectified through a writ petition under Article 226. Wherever Courts have
intervened in their exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226, either the
service conditions were regulated by the statutory provisions or the
employer had the status of “State” within the expansive definition under
Article 12 or it was found that the action complained of has public law
element.
(c) It must be consequently held that while a body may be discharging a
public function or performing a public duty and thus its actions becoming
amenable to judicial review by a Constitutional Court, its employees
would not have the right to invoke the powers of the High Court conferred
by Article 226 in respect of matter relating to service where they are not
governed or controlled by the statutory provisions. An educational
(2023) 4 SCC 498
institution may perform myriad functions touching various facets of public
life and in the societal sphere. While such of those functions as would fall
within the domain of a “public function” or “public duty” be undisputedly
open to challenge and scrutiny under Article 226 of the Constitution, the
actions or decisions taken solely within the confines of an ordinary
contract of service, having no statutory force or backing, cannot be
recognised as being amenable to challenge under Article 226 of the
Constitution. In the absence of the service conditions being controlled or
governed by statutory provisions, the matter would remain in the realm of
an ordinary contract of service.
(d) Even if it be perceived that imparting education by private unaided the
school is a public duty within the expanded expression of the term, an
employee of a non-teaching staff engaged by the school for the purpose
of its administration or internal management is only an agency created by
it. It is immaterial whether “A” or “B” is employed by school to discharge
that duty. In any case, the terms of employment of contract between a
school and non-teaching staff cannot and should not be construed to be
an inseparable part of the obligation to impart education. This is
particularly in respect to the disciplinary proceedings that may be initiated
against a particular employee. It is only where the removal of an
employee of non-teaching staff is regulated by some statutory provisions,
its violation by the employer in contravention of law may be interfered by
the court. But such interference will be on the ground of breach of law and
not on the basis of interference in discharge of public duty.
(e) From the pleadings in the original writ petition, it is apparent that no
element of any public law is agitated or otherwise made out. In other
words, the action challenged has no public element and writ of
mandamus cannot be issued as the action was essentially of a private
character.”
11.
In view of the same, this Court is of the view that not only the writ
petitions are not maintainable, but also having regard the nature of the duties
discharged by the petitioners, the petitioners are not entitle to the claim of
enhancement of age of superannuation.
12.
Accordingly, the writ petitions are dismissed. There shall be no
order as to costs.
As a sequel, all pending miscellaneous applications shall stand closed.
_______________________________
JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA
Date: 04.02.2026
ANI
THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA
WRIT PETITION Nos.32434, 12855 & 17193 of 2023 and 10202,
10284, 10298, 10611 & 14491 of 2024
Date:04.02.2026
ANI
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review