Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 33841
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE ANIL KUMAR JUKANTI
WRIT PETITION NO: 17773 OF 2016
Between:
Vemula Raji Reddy, S/o.Chandraiah, Age 43 years, Occ: Agriculturist, Rl/o.
Budharaopet Village, Khanapur Mandal, Warangal District.
...PETITIONER
AND
1.
The State of Telangana, Department of Revenue, Secretariat Buildings,
Hyderabad, Rep. by its Principal Secretary.
2. The Joint Collector, Warangal Warangal District.,
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Narsampet, Warangal District,
4. The Thasildar, Khanapur Mandal,Warangal District.,
5. Gottimukkala Pramila, Wo.Late Ram Reddy, Age 57 Years, R/o.Madhira
Village, Duggondi Mandal, Warangal District.
Gottimukkala Rajani, D/o.Late Ram Reddy, Age 29 Years, Fi/o.Madhira
Village, Duggondi Mandal, Warangal District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ or Direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of Certiorari
by calling for records pertaining to the Proceedings passed by the 2nd respondent
in his proceedings RC.No.E51364312014 dated 22.04.2016 and quash the same.
l.A. NO: I OF 2016( WPMP. NO:21299 OF 2016)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
dispense with filing of certified copy of order in RC No. E51364312014 dated
22.04.2016 on the file of the Joint Collector, Warangal.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2016(WPMP. NO: 21849 OF 2016)
Petition urrder Section 151 CPC praying that'in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filecl in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
Suspend the operation of the order passed by the 2nd respondent in his
proceedings RC.No.E5/364312O14 dated 22.04.2016 including consequential
proceedings if arry pending disposal of the above writ petition.
Counsel for the lretitioner: SRI B. SRIKANTH REPRESENTING FOR
SRIALLADI RAVINDER
Counsel for the llespondent No.1 to 4: ASST. cP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the llespondent No.S & 6: SRI SHASHANK GARIGE
The Court made the following: ORDER
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGAT{A
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR JUI(ANTI
WRIT PETITION N o.L7773 of 2o16
DATE OF ORDER :06.03.2026
Between:
Vemula Raji Reddy, S/o. Chandraiah,
Age: 43 years, Occ: Agriculturist,
R/o. Budharaopet Village, Khanapur Mandal,
Warangal District.
.. Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana,
Department of Revenue,
Secretariat Buildings, I'{yderabad,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary and 5 others
Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed seeking the following relief:
"...to issue a Writ or Direction more particularly one in
the nature of writ of Certiorari by calling for records
pertaining to the Proceedings passed by the 2'd
respondent in his proceedings RC.No.E5 /3643 l2Ol4
dated 22.04.201.6 and quash the same and pass such
other order or orders..."
2.
Heard Mr. R.Srikanth, learned counsel, representing
A.Ravinder, learned counsel for petitioner, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Revenue appearing for respondent
r-:
\:
\.
JAK, J
wP 17773 2016
Nos.1 to 4 and Mr. Shashank Garige, learned counsel for
responderrt Nos.5 and 6.
3.
It is the case of petitioner that a revision under Section 9
of Andhra Pradesh Rights in Lands and Pattedar Passbooks Act,
tg7l, (for short 'ROR ActJ was preferred before the office of
Joint Collector (respondent No.2) by respondent Nos.S and 6
herein in respect of entries in occupation column for land
admeasuring Acs.2.3O guntas in Sy.Nos.326l A, 327 I A, 328 I A,
330/A (E,<.Pl) situated in Inapalli Village, Khanapur Mandal.
That respondent No.2 vide order dated 22.04.2016 allowed the
revision, not considered the aspect of non-presence of petitioner
or his counsel. That a notice was served on petitioner on
08.O3.2O16 to appear for hearing on O5.O3.2O16, that the said
notice wasi served after the date of hearing of the revision.
4.
It is the case of petitioner that one Late Ramreddy was the
original o'wner and possessor of subject land, that after his
death in 1990, respondent Nos.S and 6, being the wife and
daughter, were issued pattedar passbooks. That respondent
No.S (wife) entrusted the management and cultivation of land to
her brother, petitioner herein. That petitioner got his name
entered in the possessor column in the year 2005-06.
,,
/
a
J
JAK, J
wP 17773 2016
5.
Learned counsel for petitioner submitted that Joint
Collector erred in holding that the entry of the name of
petitioner in revenue records was without any legal basis and
the direction to delete irregular entries from the year 2005-06
and to restore original position was bad in law. It is further
submitted that no notice was served on the petitioner at the
time of deciding the proceedings and that petitioner was not
granted an opportunity to present his case. That in the absence
of notice, the order of the Joint Collector is liable to be set aside
for violation of principles of natural justice.
6.
It is submitted that revision was filed by respondent Nos.S
and 6 herein after nine years and that no sufficient cause was
shown for the delay in filing the revision.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent Nos.S
and 6 submitted that petitioner is relying on a sada bainama,
said to have been executed in favour of Dongala Kattaiah by
respondent Nos.S and 6 on 10.05.1994, and that Dongala
Kattaiah executed a document in favour of petitioner on
28.06.1995 conferring the right and title in the subject land, as
petitioner is.the adopted son of Dongala Kattaiah. It is further
submitted that a suit bearing O.S.No.SS of 2O1O was filed before
JAK, J
wP 17773 2016
the senior civil Judge, Mahabubabad, by respondent Nos.S and
6 herei,, for decraration of ownership and consequential
injunction. It is submitted that the suit was dismissed for
default and that an interrocutory application is filed for
restorati<rn of the o.S. (to its lile on 23.12.20241 and, the said
application is pending consideration.
8.
Lee-rned counsel for respondent Nos.S and 6 invited the
attention of this court to the order of Joint collector and
submitte<l that revision petition was disposed of on nrerits and
that petit.ioner herein presented three documents, documents
on which petitioner was relying upon, before the office of Joint
collector and the Joint collector in his order has noted that all
the three documents were unregistered sale papers and no
original clocument was presented before the oflice of Joint
collector riuring the proceedings. It is also submitted that Joint
collector rightly held that a simplc sale deed/sada sale deed
cannot be considered to be evidence in the eve of law.
9.
It is submitted that Joint collector was right in holding
that entering the name of petitioner in the revenue records for
the year 2005-06 was without any basis and rightly directed
to
**:7
JAK, J
wP t7'173 20t6
delete the entry (of the name of the petitioner) in the revenue
records and to restore to earlier position.
10. Learned counsel for respondent Nos.S and 6 submitted
that at the time of execution of sada bainama in favour of
purchaser i.e., Dongala Kattaiah, respondent No.6 was aged 6
years. It is further submitted that it is highly improbable for
respondent No.6 to have been arrayed as a party in sada
bainama/private sale deed at the age of 6 years, that though the
said document has been relied upon by petitioner, a copy is not
placed on record. It is also submitted that an Advocate had filed
vakalat on behalf of petitioner herein before the Joint Collector
and that after {iling of vakalat and after a period of 15 months,
the order of Joint Collector came to be passed. It is lastly
submitted that there is no infirmity in the order of Joint
Collector and interference is not necessitated, as the order was
passed on merits.
11. Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Revenue
appearing for respondent Nos.l to 4 submitted that on the basis
of the record, that petitioner appeared on L6.12.2O14 before
respondent No.2 and on 27.L2.2OI4, petitioner engaged an
advocate named Mr. Shaik Rafi, that the advocate filed vakalat
-,-"*****q".
JAK, J
wP 17773 2016
and the revision case was adjourned to 16.04.2016 for final
hearing. That the said facts are reflected in paragraph No.4
of
the courrter affidavit.
L2. Heard learned counsers, perused the record and
considered the submissions.
13. Respondent Nos.s and 6 filed a revision under section 9
of the RoR Act before the Joint collector. Respondent Nos.S
and
6 are the: wife and daughter of one Late Ramreddy, who rvas the
owner a,d possessor of land admeasuring Acs.2.3o guntas
Sy.Nos.3 26/A, 322 /A,
in
Z2g/A, 330/4, situated in Inapalli
village, I'.hanapur Mandal. Ramreddy died in the year 1990 (as
per the rt:cord).
14- It is observed from the record that respondent No.5 (wife
of Ramrr:ddy) entrusted the management and cultivation of
subject leLnd to her brother, petitioner herein. petitioner,s name
was entered in the adangal pahani,s possessor column for
the
year 2005;-06. challenging the entry of the name of petitioner
revenue records, respondent Nos.S and 6 approached the
of Joint ccllector for deletion of the name of petitioner.
.\-b
/
in
office
-- 7i
JAK, J
wP 17773 2016
15. It is the case of petitioner that one Dongala Kattaiah was
the owner and possessor of the subject land, that Dongala
Kattaiah got the subject land by way of a simple sale deed dated
10.05. L994, claiming to be executed by respondent Nos.S and 6
and that the said Dongala Kattaiah executed a document dated
28.06.1995 conferring the right and title of subject land in
favour of the petitioner. It is further the case of petitioner that
petitioner is in possession of the subject land from the date of
purchase.
16. Both the documents dated 10.05.1994 and 28.06.1995
are simple sale deeds, they are not validated. A copy of the
revenue record i.e., adangal/pahani dated 28.O5.2016 is
annexed as document along with the writ affidavit. In all the
documents annexed to the writ affidavit i.e., page Nos.25, 27,
29 and 31, the name of the pattedar is of respondent No.5 and
in the column Anubavadar', the name of petitioner is reflected.
No other document is placed by petitioner before this Court.
17. It is trite law that simple sale deeds relied upon by
petitioner (as per the averments at paragraph No.3 in the writ
affidavit) cannot convey the title and ownership. In the absence
of any other documents, Joint Collector rightly held that simple
JAK, J
wP t7773 2016
sale deel documents cannot be considered as evidence in the
eye of la'w. The relevant portion of the order of Joint collector is
as follows:
"c) All (3) documents are unregistered sale papers and no
original document is submitted to this couit.-Hence they
cannot be taken as legar basis. More over they are de,ied
b5' the executants i.e., petitioner. Simple sale deeds cannot
be eviclence in eyes of law.
'fhis Court relied upon the following citation
2006(21 ALD (NOC 37)- A document undoubtedty
cnlates interest in immovable property which requires to
be sufficiently stamped and registered under section
17(1Xb) of Registration Act. Unless and until sufficientl.y
s&rmped and registered it cannot be admitted in evide,cc.
d) As per CCLA's Ref. No. ROM/RORL/42S|2OOT, dt.
15.08.07
'l'he PPBs/TDs should be issued after updating
the
RC)R record. As and when any entries are mad.e in the ROR
rer:ords, such entry should be carried into the village
rec:ords such Adangal/pahani with legal basis. Each entfo
me.de in ROR Record should be carried into pahani with
legal basis (u/s1o(A) of the Act). But in the instant case the
dor:uments are not validated under ROR act lg7l.
e) Vloreover in this instant case the petitioncr was issued
pal tedar passbooks and title deeds which were neither
qur:stioned nor cancelled.
This Court relied on the following citation of the
Ho:r'ble High Court
Writ Appeal No 63 of 2003 while observing .There was
notring rvrong of the revenue authorities in havinf restored the
position obtained prior there to when the un-authorized entry
canre to be recorded for first time."
f). I{ovi,ever, the Sub section (21 of section g of R.O.R Act
Rlo.vi-des that if any person is'aggrieved as to any rights oi
ryhjch he is in possession by an entry made in record of
rigtLts, he may institute a suit against any person denying
or interested to deny title to such right ioi declaration of
his right under chapter VI of the Specinc Relief Act, 1963
and the entry in the record of rights, shall be amended in
accordance with any such declarition.
/
.__r.
/
JAK, J
wP_17773 2016
In view of the aforesaid discussions it is held that the
entry of the name of the respondent No I in the revenue
records without any legal basis is illegal and liable to be
cancelled. Hence the Tahsildar, Khanapur is hereby
directed to delete the irregular entries in occupant's
column in favour of the respondent No 1 from the year
2005-06 and restore the original position as recorded
earlier up to 2005-06."
18. Sada bainama or simple sale deed has to be validated to
be considered as a document in evidence. In the absence of
such validation, there cannot be any claim for setting up the
defense of conveyance of title. If the contention of learned
counsel for petitioner is to be accepted, then every simple sale
deed or sada bainama will have to be considered, as though it
has conveyed the title, which is not acceptable in the eye of law.
19. The other issue raised by learned counsel for petitioner is
that no notice was served. on a perusal of the counter affidavit
filed by revenue authorities, it is observed from the contents of
paragraph No.4 that petitioner engaged an Advocate by name
Shaik Rafi and Mr. Shaik Rafi filed vakalat. This goes on to
demonstrate the fact that petitioner was aware of the
proceedings before the office of Joint collector. It is not the case
of petitioner that he was not represented by any counsel, once
an Advocate files a vakalat before an authorit5r, a quasi-judicial
l0
JAK, J
wP 17773 20t6
body, it is his duty to represent the matter. The following is the
relevant l)aragraph of the counter affidavit filed by RDO:
"lr: repl_y to the averments made in para no. 5 & 6 of the
affidavit filed by the petitioner, the same are not truly and
correctly stated, hence denied. The allegation of the
per-itioner is that the hearing notice was served on him
after the date of hearing of there vision filed by the
res;pondents No.5 and 6, and no further notice was issued
to him intimating the next date of hearing, as such he
corrld not able to engage a lawyer to represent him is not
truly and correctly stated, hence denied. In fact, it is
humbly submitted that upon the revision petition filed by
th€: respondent no.S & 6, the petitioner has appeared on
16t12l20 14 before the respondent no.2 and the case was
adjourned on 27 lL2/2O14 for the hearing, and on
27,tI212O14 the petitioner has engaged an advocate viz.,
Sh;rik Rafi, and the petitioner's advocate has filed
vaHatnama in the revision case filed by the respondent
no.5 & 6. The case was adjourned on 16/04 /2016 for final
hezLring, but for the final hearing neither the petitioner nor
his advocate appeared to defend the case of the petitioner.
It i:l humbly submitted that the petitioner has appeared at
first on 16lI2/2O14 before the respondent no.2, but till
the final hearing on 16/04/2016, about 15 months period,
the petitioner has failed to file his counter in support of his
resrective claim over the subject property. However, it is
hurnbly submitted that the respondent no.2 has disposed
of l.he revision petition basing on the merits of the case
onl;r."
20. It is observed from the contents of the counter affidavit
that having appeared on 16.12.2014, petitioner nor his counsel
appeared before the authorities till 16.04.2016 for a period of 15
months. These facts borne on record negate the contention that
petitionerwas not put on notice.
*-"v
JAK, J
wP t7773 20t6
21. As observed supra, petitioner failed to demonstrate even
before this Court by way of any document to support his case
that he is the owner and possessor of the subject propert5r.
22. It is submitted by learned counsel for respondent Nos.S
and 6 that o.S.No.SS of 2010 filed by respondent Nos.S and 6
herein for declaration of ownership and consequential
injunction and for recovery of possession is pending before the
Senior Civil Judge, Mahabubabad, to which, petitioner is a party
and that an interlocutory application for restoration of the suit
is pending consideration before the trial Court. Petitioner and
unofficial respond.ents are at liberty to avail remedies in
accordance with law before the appropriate Court, where the
suit is pending consideration.
23. For reasons aforesaid, this Court is not inclined to upset
the findings of the Joint Collector, as petitioner has not been
able to demonstrate with respect to the claim of the title of said
property. Joint Collector rightly held that simple sale deeds
cannot be evidences in the eye of law. Simple sale deeds cannot
convey title. Needless to state that any observations made in
this order shall not in any way influence the Court below, while
deciding the suit.
I
t
r
t2
JAK, J
wP 17773 2016
24. F.r reasons aforesaid, writ petition being devoid of merits
is liable to be dismissed and is accordingly dismissed.
No order
as to col;ts
M. scellaneous applications pending,
if any, shall stand
closed
SD/. P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC trr SRI ALLADI RAVINDER, Advocate [OPUC]
2. One CC to SRI SHASHANK GARIGE, Advocate [OPUC]
3. Two CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana
lourl
4. Two CD Oopies
\
BN
HIGH COUIRT
J
)
JAK,J
DATED:0610312026
Y
o
()
ORDER
WP.No.177'73 of 2016
R
'iH';- s
1 7 tl[R 70rf,
*
*
PATC
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITTON
WITHOUT I]OSTS
3 \a
\
c
b
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review