Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of reserving: 18th May, 2026
Date of Decision: 18th September, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
CRL.A. 229/2005 & CRL.M.A. 2915/2005
VEER PAL
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Prang Newmai, Amicus Curiae.
versus
STATE
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Satinder Singh Bawa, APP for
the State.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIMAL KUMAR YADAV
JUDGMENT
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J.
1.
A back breaking hard day’s labour requires a sound peaceful sleep in
the night to rejuvenate the body in order to enable it to assume and discharge
next day’s assignments which invariably involves hard physical work. This
has become a regular and unending plight of the labourers in the country and
to add salt to the injury, this class is least paid, least cared and least
bothered. A very pathetic state of affairs where the society has failed to
value and respect the physical labour, contrary to the western world, where
the physical labour is adequately compensated and valued. It was another
such night on 17.03.2002 when the victim Rajinder Kumar after the usual
hard labour of the day, was about to sleep or was sleeping, at the verandah
of shop No. 69, Lajpat Rai Market, Chandni Chowk where he was employed
and possibly due to that he was allowed to sleep there. The nuisance and
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
ruckus created by the Appellant and some others disturbed the victim. The
request of the victim Rajinder Kumar to desist from such behaviour
infuriated the Appellant to the extent that he initially pushed the victim and
then attacked him with a sharp weapon. A Rapi (an instrument used by
cobblers to cut the leather) was used by the Appellant to cause injury to the
victim running from face / cheek to the chest. The rumpus and commotion
attracted the attention of a policeman on patrol i.e. Ct. Santosh Kumar. The
victim, however, fell unconscious after some time of the assault. Ct. Santosh
realizing the situation, spotted the Appellant running away from the scene,
chased and neutralized him. Reinforcement with the help of information
given by some public persons, came at the spot and the injured was removed
to Trauma Centre by Ct. Santosh Kumar while the Appellant was handed
over to SI Ranbir Singh and HC Jagdish. Injured Rajinder was unconscious
and underwent a surgery in the operation theatre. SI Ranbir Singh, was
assigned the matter, who recorded the statement of Ct. Santosh and based
upon the same a case was registered bearing FIR No. 180/2002 by the Police
Station Kotwali which ultimately culminated into a charge-sheet filed under
Section 307 Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
2.
Appellant Veerpal pleaded not guilty and claimed trial to the charge
framed under Section 307. The case of the prosecution traversing through
the statement of 17 witnesses, statement of accused recorded under Section
313 Cr.P.C. resulted into a judgement against the Appellant in which he was
held guilty and convicted under Section 307 IPC.
3.
The Appellant was, through an order on sentence dated 02.12.2004
condemned to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment (RI) for a period of 05 years
and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/- and in default of payment of fine he was to
further undergo RI of 03 months.
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
4.
Against the backdrop of aforesaid facts, the instant appeal has been
preferred whereby the learned counsel for the Appellant has come forward
with the plea that the requisite intention or knowledge for a conviction under
Section 307 IPC cannot be attributed to the Appellant inasmuch as even as
per the deposition of the injured Rajinder Kumar (PW-1) the incident
occurred in the spur of the moment where the Appellant was having some
altercation with some other persons which disturbed the sleep of the victim
and the intervention was not taken kindly by the Appellant who directed his
ire anger towards the victim. There was only a single blow given to the
victim which was an outcome of the uncalled for, unwanted and un-required
intervention from the side of the victim in the estimation of the Appellant.
The Appellant even according to the case of the prosecution, after giving a
single blow to the victim, tried to escape, but was chased and pinned down
by Ct. Santosh. This further indicates that the Appellant had no intention to
cause the death of the victim. Whatever had happened had happened in the
fraction of seconds without any pre-meditation or planning and for that
matter the victim was never even the target of the Appellant.
5.
It is asserted that the learned Trial Court has not appreciated these
facts and has recorded a finding against the Appellant by holding that he had
the requisite intention or knowledge as contemplated under Section 307 IPC.
In this context learned counsel for the Appellant has placed reliance on the
judgement titled as Surender Singh v. State (Union Territory of
Chandigarh) 2021 INSC 790, to draw a distinction that intention or
knowledge should have been put into action, irrespective of the outcome. If
it is found that the intention or knowledge was there as contemplated under
Section 307 IPC then only a person can be held responsible notwithstanding
the outcome of the intention or knowledge in the shape of the act which
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
followed thereafter. It is argued by the learned counsel for the Appellant that
in the absence of the requisite ingredients of Section 307 IPC, the acts of the
Appellant, at the most, can be brought under Section 326 IPC or any such
offence resulting into bodily injury.
6.
The learned APP on the other hand submitted that the intention is writ
large in the circumstances of the case where a dangerous weapon Rapi was
used by the Appellant to cause injury to the victim that too on very vital
parts of the body, starting from the neck and going down to the chest. The
body part targeted reflects the intention. It may or may not be true that the
incident took place in the spur of the moment but then the action does not
take place unless an intention is first generated in the mind of the person. So
the circumstances reflect that the Appellant’s intention was to cause harm
and then only he assaulted the victim. The question as to whether the
requisite intention or knowledge, as contemplated under Section 307 IPC,
was there or not can be inferred from various factors surrounding the
incident. It is asserted that the conclusion arrived at by the learned Trial
Court is based upon the material on record and is in consonance with the
facts and law on the subject therefore, no intervention is required qua the
impugned judgment.
7.
Having taken into consideration the contentions raised by the rival
sides and the material placed on record for consideration, what is of utmost
importance is to ascertain as to whether the Appellant had intention to
commit murder or not or that he had the knowledge that his act is going to
result into murder. This makes it imperative to ascertain the intention or
knowledge. These two things i.e. intention and knowledge are abstract,
intangible and invisible, therefore, how to ascertain, is the question.
8.
In Hari Singh v. Sukhbir Singh and Others, (1988) 4 SCC 551, the
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down as to what all is required to be
established in order bring home a case under Section 307 IPC, which is as
below:“7. ….Under Section 307 IPC what the court has to see is, whether
the act irrespective of its result, was done with the intention or
knowledge and under circumstances mentioned in that section. The
intention or knowledge of the accused must be such as is necessary to
constitute murder. Without this ingredient being established, there can
be no offence of “attempt to murder”. Under Section 307 the intention
precedes the act attributed to accused. Therefore, the intention is to
be gathered from all circumstances, and not merely from the
consequences that ensue. The nature of the weapon used, manner in
which it is used, motive for the crime, severity of the blow, the part of
the body where the injury is inflicted are some of the factors that may
be taken into consideration to determine the intention…...”
9.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Saleem
@ Chamaru, (2005) 5 SCC 554 and Prakash Chandra Yadav vs. State of
Bihar & Ors., (2007) 13 SCC 134 had emphasized that injury is neither
essential, nor determinative, rather it is the intention, which holds the centre
stage, in order to determine as to whether the acts of the accused fall into the
scope and ambit of Section 307 IPC. A bare reading of Section 307 IPC
itself indicates that injury is not sine-qua-non as in the event of causing
injury, the accused runs the risk of enhanced punishment. In this context, the
observations made in State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Saleem @ Chamaru
(supra) are worth noting, which is reproduced herein under:
'' 12. To justify a conviction under this Section, it is not essential
that bodily injury capable of causing death should have been
inflicted. Although the nature of injury actually caused may often
give considerable assistance in coming to a finding as to the
intention of the accused, such intention may also be deduced from
other circumstances, and may even, in some cases, be ascertained
without any reference at all to actual wounds. The Section makes a
distinction between an act of the accused and its result, if any. Such
an act may not be attended by any result so far as the person
assaulted is concerned, but still there may be cases in which the
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
culprit would be liable under this Section. It is not necessary that
the injury actually caused to the victim of the assault should be
sufficient under ordinary circumstances to cause the death of the
person assaulted. What the Court has to see is whether the act,
irrespective of its result, was done with the intention or knowledge
and under circumstances mentioned in the Section. An attempt in
order to be criminal need not be the penultimate act. It is sufficient
in law, if there is present an intent coupled with some overt act in
execution thereof.”
10.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Surinder Singh v. State (UT of
Chandigarh), (2021) 20 SCC 24 held as under:21. It is by now a lucid dictum that for the purpose of constituting an
offence under Section 307IPC, there are two ingredients that a court
must consider, first, whether there was any intention or knowledge on
the part of the accused to cause death of the victim, and, second, such
intent or knowledge was followed by some overt actus rea in execution
thereof, irrespective of the consequential result as to whether or not
any injury is inflicted upon the victim. The courts may deduce such
intent from the conduct of the accused and surrounding circumstances
of the offence, including the nature of weapon used or the nature of
injury, if any. The manner in which occurrence took place may
enlighten more than the prudential escape of a victim. It is thus not
necessary that a victim shall have to suffer an injury dangerous to his
life, for attracting Section 307IPC.
22. It would also be fruitful at this stage, to appraise whether the
requirement of “motive” is indispensable for proving the charge of
attempt to murder under Section 307IPC.
23. It is significant to note that “motive” is distinct from “object and
means” which innervates or provokes an action. Unlike “intention”,
“motive” is not the yardstick of a crime. A lawful act with an ill
motive would not constitute an offence but it may not be true when an
unlawful act is committed with best of the motive. Unearthing
“motive” is akin to an exercise of manual brain-mapping. At times, it
becomes Herculean task to ascertain the traces of a “motive”.
11.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Amit Rana v. State of Haryana,
(2024) 15 SCC 42 held as under:“9. Section 307 IPC makes it clear that to attract the said offence the
victim need not suffer any kind of bodily injury. The offence to commit
murder punishable under Section 307IPC is constituted by the
concurrence of mens rea followed by actus reus, to commit an attempt
to murder though its accomplishment or sufferance of any kind of
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
bodily injury to the victim is not a “sine qua non”. In other words, if a
man commits an act with such intention or knowledge and under such
circumstances that if death had been caused, the offence would have
amounted to murder or the act itself is of such a nature as would have
caused death in the usual course of an event, but something beyond
his control prevented that result, his act would constitute the offence
punishable as an attempt to murder under Section 307IPC.”
12.
Ultimately, the issue boils down to the aspect of the intention with
which a particular act has been done by the offender/assailant or the
requisite knowledge that the act is going to result in the death of a human
being, which may amount to murder. In the event of such knowledge or
intention, being found on record then it would be enough to hold the
assailant guilty for an offence under Section 307 IPC, injury or no injury. As
such, the entire episode, narrated by the witnesses has to be appreciated,
evaluated and determined on the aforesaid parameters. As noted earlier also,
intention or knowledge is something abstract, but intelligible provided the
overall act, the circumstances surrounding and attending it or having some
connection, are scrutinised meticulously. It may, then, help ascertain and
decipher the intention or the knowledge. It is this fact which holds the key to
open the lock of Section 307 IPC. How else otherwise, could something so
abstract as intention, thought or knowledge, be inferred or translated, so as
to place it in the definition or realm of Section 307 IPC.
13.
The culmination of an act, which could have resulted into the offence
of murder, essentially indicates some overt and violent act has to be there.
Thus, the act or actus reus becomes important as that would lead in a
backward reading, to mens rea, which otherwise, is the first and foremost
thing to be seen and ascertained in criminal law.
14.
Certain aspects, which may throw light on this mens rea or intention
include, though not exhaustive, the utterances accompanied by an act, the
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
act itself, the weapon, if any, used in that act, the body part targeted, number
of blows given, the circumstances and the conduct of assailant in those
peculiar circumstances, for instance, how the assailant behaved when the
victim became helpless and was not able to defend, protect or protests etc.
The conduct of the assailant when the victim was retreating or withdrawing
or running away from the scene, so on and so forth. These are some of the
tangible, visible and physical acts, which have its genesis and emerge out of
the intention and not otherwise. These sort of acts, individually or
collectively, would be the major and most likely the only source for anybody
to identify the intention of an assailant.
15.
In case titled as Parvinder @ Moti v. State, 2015 SCC OnLine Del
8849, Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that:
“33. “Intention”, as per Cross and Jones in Introduction to
Criminal Law (11th Ed.), is not defined in any statute and its
meaning must therefore be derived from judicial decisions. They
observe, “It is now clear from the House of Lords decisions
in Moloney ([1985] 1 All ER 1025 HL) and Hancock and
Shankland ([1986] 1 All ER 641 HL) that foresight of probability,
or even of certainty, is not intention in a legal sense nor the
equivalent of it.”
They then refer to Court of Appeals decision
in Nedrick ([1986] 3 All ER 1, CA), where it was stated
that “foresight of a consequence as “for all practical
purposes inevitable” could give rise to an irresistible
inference of intention (as opposed, in other words, to being
intention itself).” They conclude that “the irresistible
inference mentioned in Nedrick (supra) is likely to mean in
practice that foresight of inevitability, at least, will be
equated with intention in the minds of a jury”. They
however, cautioned “In some offences, the inference of
intention may not be drawn where the jury [or the Court]
are not satisfied that the prohibited consequence was the
accused’s aim or purpose.”
34. Decisions of the Indian Courts are more illustrative and
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
delineate the distinction between “intention” and “knowledge” in
significantly finite and articulate manner. The Supreme Court
in Kesar Singh versus State of Haryana, (2008) 15 SCC 753,
concluded to draw the distinction as, “30. It can thus be seen that
the “knowledge” as contrasted with “intention” signifies a state of
mental realisation with the bare state of conscious awareness of
certain facts in which human mind remains supine or inactive. On
the other hand, “intention” is a conscious state in which mental
faculties are aroused into activity and summoned into action for the
purpose of achieving a conceived end. It means shaping of one's
conduct so as to bring about a certain event. Therefore in the case
of “intention” mental faculties are projected in a set direction.
Intention need not necessarily involve premeditation. Whether there
is such an intention or not is a question of fact.”
The said judgment quotes the following portion from Kenny in
Outlines of Criminal Law (17th Edn. at P.31) as:“Intention: To intend is to have in mind a fixed purpose to
reach a desired objective; the noun 'intention' in the
present connection is used to denote the state of mind of a
man who not only foresees but also desires the possible
consequences of his conduct. Thus if one man throws
another from a high tower or cuts off his head it would
seem plain that he both foresees the victim's death and also
desires it: the desire and the foresight will also be the same
if a person knowingly leaves a helpless invalid or infant
without nourishment or other necessary support until death
supervenes. It will be noted that there cannot be intention
unless there is also foresight, since a man must decide to
his own satisfaction, and accordingly must foresee, that to
which his express purpose is directed. Again, a man cannot
intend to do a thing unless he desires to do it. It may well
be a thing that he dislikes doing, but he dislikes still more
the consequences of his not doing it. That is to say he
desires the lesser of two evils, and therefore has made up
his mind to bring about that one.”
Earlier in Jai Prakash vs. State (Delhi Admn.) (1991) 2 SCC 32, it
was elucidated that knowledge is bare awareness and not
something as intention, for the latter requires something more than
a mere foresight of the consequences namely, the purposeful doing
of a thing to achieve a particular end.”
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
16.
The aforesaid parameters are to be applied on the facts of the instant
case in order to infer and ascertain as to whether the act of the Appellant fall
into the realm and domain of Section 307 IPC or fall short of the same to be
bracketed in some other offence.
17.
The circumstances reflect that the Appellant and victim had no
connection with each other, they were not fighting or quarrelling with each
other. The Appellant and some other persons were involved in a quarrel. It
was the inconvenience caused to the victim by the ruckus created by the
quarrel in which the Appellant was involved, which prompted the victim to
the intervene and seek a peaceful sleep for him but the Appellant did not
take it kindly and suddenly attacked him with a Rapi causing injuries as
given below :“An incised wound (approx 14 inch X 1.5 inch) extending from
upper left cheek to sternal notch invloving left anterior aspect of
neck.”
18.
It is evident that the nature of injury cannot be treated as that of
grievous hurt, as defined in Section 320 IPC. Thus, it amounts to simple
injury. The weapon used indeed was a dangerous weapon and could have
been fatal but for the fact, that the way it was used. It was used in a vertical
manner and was not used to stab the victim. Had it been used for stabbing,
then in that situation there could have been a possibility of the injury
resulting into grievous hurt. In view of these facts, the Appellant cannot be
held responsible for the offence under Section 307 IPC inasmuch as, as
discussed herein before also, the requisite intention or knowledge as
contemplated and required under Section 307 IPC is amiss. Given the fact of
the injury in the medical terminology may be grievous, but then it is not so
in legal definition, therefore, the Appellant, at the most may be held
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
responsible for a simple injury by a sharp weapon and that brings the act of
the Appellant into the domain of Section 324 IPC. Accordingly the appeal is
partially allowed and the conviction is modified from 307 to 324 IPC.
19.
On the aspect of sentence nothing has much been argued,
nevertheless, the Court is duty bound to award a commensurate punishment
to the offender. The incident date backs to the year 2002. There is nothing
on record which may reflect that the antecedents of the Appellant are
questionable and no involvement has been reported after the instant case.
Therefore, considering the entire gamut of facts and circumstances, the
Appellant is sentenced undergo the incarceration for a period of 03 years.
The punishment with regard to the fine shall remain unaltered.
20.
With these observations the appeal stand(s) disposed. Application(s)
pending, if any, stand disposed of as well. Needless to say that the Appellant
shall be entitled to the benefit of set off under Section 428 Cr.P.C.
21.
Bail Bond(s), if any, stand discharged.
22.
Copy of the judgment be transmitted to the Trial Court and Prison
Authorities for information and necessary compliance.
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J
SEPTEMBER 18, 2026 /hk/ps/ij/ny
Signed By:PRIYA
12:52:45
CRL.A. 229/2005
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review