Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VENKATESH NAIK T
WRIT PETITION NO.35870 OF 2025 (GM-FOR)
BETWEEN:
VEDANTA IRON & STEEL LIMITED
(DEMERGED IRON ORE ENTITY OF VEDANTA
LIMITED)
(A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER
THE COMPANIES ACT, 2013)
REGISTERED OFFICE AT C-103
Digitally
ATUL PROJECTS, CORPORATE AVENUE NEW LINK
signed by
CHAKALA, MIDC
RAKSHA
MUMBAI - 400 093
Location:
REP. BY ITS POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER,
High Court
of Karnataka MR. NARAYANA M.P.
HEAD - CORPORATE AFFAIRS - IRON ORE
KARNATAKA
(AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT VIDE COURT ORDER
DATED 05.06.2026)
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. K.N.PAHNINDRA, SENIOR COUNSEL A/W
SRI. VIKRAM H. BHATT AND
SRI. ARYAN RAO, ADVS. FOR
SMT. VAISHALI HEGDE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF
SECRETARY, FOREST, ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT
DEPARTMENT M.S. BUILDING, 4TH FLOOR
DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDI
BENGALURU 560 001
2.
THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
ARANYA BHAVAN
18TH CROSS, MALLESWARAM
BENGALURU 560 003.
3.
THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
KARWAR DIVISION, KARWAR DIVISION
M.G. ROAD, KAJUBAG, KARWAR 581 301
4.
ASSISTANT CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
ANKOLA SUB-DIVISION
M.G. ROAD, KAJUBAG, KARWAR 581 301.
5.
RANGE FOREST OFFICER
ANKOLA RANGE
M.G. ROAD, KAJUBAG, KARWAR 581 301
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. PRATHIMA HONNAPUR, AAG A/W
SRI. KHAMROZ KHAN, AGA FOR R1 TO R5)
THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING
TO
DIRECT THE
RESPONDENTS TO CONSIDER THE REPRESENTATIONS DATED
25.10.2024,
20.11.2024,
07.04.2025,
27.05.2025
AND
09.10.2025 VIDE ANNEXURES 'A' TO A4 IN TERMS OF THE
ORDERS PASSED BY THIS COURT IN CRL. PTN. NO.7827/2018
AND CRL. PTN. NO.100029/2023 AND RELEASE THE IRON ORE
LYING IN STOCK NO.MC-12 AT BELEKERI PORT TO THE CUSTODY
OF THE PETITIONER.
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
HAVING
BEEN
HEARD
AND
RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 31.07.2026 AND COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, ANU SIVARAMAN
J., PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VENKATESH NAIK T
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN)
This writ petition is filed seeking a writ of mandamus
directing the respondents to consider the representations
dated 25.10.2024, 20.11.2024, 07.04.2025, 27.05.2025 and
09.10.2025, produced as Annexures 'A' to 'A4', in terms of
the orders passed by this Court in Criminal Petitions
No.7827/2018 and 100029/2023 and to release the iron ore
lying in Stock No.MC-12 at Belekeri Port to the custody of
the writ petitioner. The writ petitioner also seeks a writ of
certiorari to quash the letter dated 08.12.2025, issued by
respondent No.5, produced as Annexure 'J'.
2.
We have heard Shri. K.N. Phanindra, learned
senior counsel as instructed by Shri. Vikram H. Bhatt,
learned counsel and Smt. Vaishali Hegde, learned counsel
appearing
for
the
writ
petitioner
and
Smt.
Prathima
Honnapur, learned Additional Advocate General along with
Shri.
Khamroz
Khan,
learned
Additional
Government
Advocate appearing for respondents No.1 to 5.
3.
A quantity of 34,544.61 MT of iron ore claimed by
the writ petitioner formed part of the stock seized at
Belekeri Port in connection with FIR No.17/2009-10. The
application filed by the writ petitioner seeking release of the
said iron ore was rejected by the CBI Court, Bengaluru by
order dated 03.09.2018 in Spl.C.C.No.268/2013. The writ
petitioner challenged the said order in Criminal Petition
No.7827/2018. By order dated 25.09.2023, this Court set
aside the order dated 03.09.2018 passed by the CBI Court
and directed the competent Forest authorities to determine
the available quantity and value of the iron ore and
thereafter release it to the writ petitioner upon furnishing
one surety and executing an indemnity bond for the value
determined.
4.
The State Government challenged the order dated
25.09.2023 before the Apex Court in SLP (Crl.) Diary
No.18017/2024. The Special Leave Petition was dismissed
by
order
dated
17.05.2024.
The
State
Government
thereafter filed a “Memo for Being Spoken To” in Criminal
Petition No.7827/2018 seeking inclusion of a condition
requiring surety for a like sum. The memo was rejected by
this Court on 26.06.2024. Thereafter, in the proceedings
instituted
before
the
Apex
Court,
the
State
sought
permission to withdraw the said memo. By order dated
28.03.2025, the Apex Court permitted its withdrawal and set
aside the order dated 26.06.2024 as a consequence thereof,
while clarifying that it had not adjudicated upon the
correctness of the factual observations contained therein.
5.
Pursuant to the order dated 25.09.2023, the
Senior Geologist submitted a report dated 02.08.2024
determining the available quantity of the iron ore at
20,083.95
MT
and
its
value
at
Rs.7,71,42,452/-.
By
communication dated 23.08.2024, the Assistant Conservator
of Forests directed the writ petitioner to approach the Range
Forest Officer for release of the iron ore after submitting the
requisite bonds. The writ petitioner thereafter executed an
indemnity bond dated 17.09.2024 and furnished a surety
bond dated 23.09.2024 in compliance with the order dated
25.09.2023. By order dated 02.06.2025 passed in Criminal
Petition No.100029/2023, this Court permitted the State
Government to take custody of and auction the available
iron ore. By a subsequent order dated 02.09.2025 passed on
the interlocutory applications filed by the affected parties,
this Court clarified that the order dated 02.06.2025 was
subject to the earlier orders passed in Criminal Petition
No.7827/2018.
6.
The writ petitioner submitted representations
dated 25.10.2024, 20.11.2024, 07.04.2025, 27.05.2025 and
09.10.2025 seeking release of the iron ore. During the
pendency of the writ petition, respondent No.5 issued the
communication dated 08.12.2025 stating that the writ
petitioner’s request for release would be considered after the
conclusion of the proceedings pending before the Apex
Court.
7.
The learned senior counsel appearing for the writ
petitioner contends that despite the order dated 25.09.2023
passed in Criminal Petition No.7827/2018 directing release
of the iron ore and the subsequent clarification dated
02.09.2025 passed in Criminal Petition No.100029/2023,
respondent No.5 has failed to release the iron ore lying in
Stock No.MC-12 at Belekeri Port. It is submitted that the
writ petitioner has complied with all the conditions imposed
by executing the requisite indemnity bond and furnishing
surety for the value determined by the Senior Geologist.
8.
It is contended that the State Government’s
challenge to the order dated 25.09.2023 was dismissed by
the Apex Court and that no order staying its operation is
presently in force. The pendency of proceedings before the
Apex Court, in the absence of an order of stay, cannot
justify postponement of its implementation. The impugned
communication dated 08.12.2025 is, therefore, contrary to
the binding directions issued by this Court.
9.
It is further submitted that the order dated
02.09.2025 expressly clarified that the permission granted
to the State Government to take custody of and auction the
available iron ore was subject to the earlier orders passed in
Criminal Petition No.7827/2018. The respondents cannot
rely upon the order dated 02.06.2025 to defeat the writ
petitioner’s entitlement under the order dated 25.09.2023.
10.
It is further submitted that no criminal case was
registered against the writ petitioner in relation to the seized
iron ore. The SIT, upon investigation, filed a ‘B’ Report,
which was accepted by the competent Court and was not
challenged. The objections now raised regarding ownership,
the scope of the CBI and SIT investigations and the
pendency of other criminal proceedings are stated to
constitute an impermissible attempt to reopen matters
concluded by the order dated 25.09.2023.
11.
It is further submitted that, despite the writ
petitioner having complied with the conditions imposed by
the order dated 25.09.2023, the respondents have failed to
release the iron ore. Out of the 34,544.61 MT of iron ore
seized in the year 2010, only 20,083.95 MT is presently
stated to be available, the balance allegedly having been
depleted owing to prolonged exposure to rain and wind. Any
further delay, according to the writ petitioner, would result
in continued depletion of the remaining stock and cause
irreparable financial loss.
12.
The
learned
Additional
Advocate
General
appearing for respondents No.1 to 5 contends that the writ
petition, though framed as one seeking consideration of the
representations, is in substance an attempt to secure
release of seized property by converting the writ Court into
an executing Court for enforcement of the order dated
25.09.2023 passed in Criminal Petition No.7827/2018. It is
submitted that the iron ore continues to be seized property
in FIR No.17/2009-10 and remains subject to the custody
and jurisdiction of the JMFC, Ankola.
13.
It is contended that the writ petitioner has failed
to disclose the order dated 23.09.2023 passed by the JMFC,
Ankola, rejecting its application under Sections 451 and 457
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, on the ground that
it had failed to establish ownership over the seized iron ore.
Neither the acceptance of the ‘B’ Report filed by the SIT nor
the dismissal of the Special Leave Petition challenging the
order
dated
25.09.2023
is
stated
to
constitute
an
adjudication establishing the writ petitioner’s ownership over
the seized iron ore.
14.
It is further submitted that the order dated
25.09.2023 proceeded on an erroneous understanding of the
distinct investigations entrusted to the CBI and the SIT
pursuant to the orders of the Apex Court in Samaj
Parivartana
Karnataka
Samudaya
and
others.
and
others
While
the
v.
CBI
State
of
investigation
concerned the iron ore seized in FIR No.17/2009-10, the SIT
investigation
in
Crime
No.2/2014
concerned
iron
ore
allegedly exported from Belekeri Port. The ‘B’ Report filed by
the SIT, therefore, had no bearing on the writ petitioner’s
ownership over or entitlement to release of the seized iron
ore.
15.
It is also submitted that C.C.No.312/2012 arising
out of Crime No.189/2010, concerning the alleged theft of
the seized iron ore, remains pending against the writ
petitioner. The failure of the CBI to investigate the writ
petitioner’s
claim
of
ownership
cannot
be
treated
as
establishing such ownership or entitling it to release of the
seized iron ore.
16.
It is contended that the condition requiring surety
was intended to safeguard public revenue and secure
recovery of the value of the mineral under Section 21(5) of
the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act,
1957, if the iron ore is ultimately found to have been
illegally extracted. In these circumstances, and in view of
the proceedings pending before the Apex Court, the decision
to defer the writ petitioner’s request for release is stated to
be justified. It is further contended that the dismissal of the
Special Leave Petition against the order dated 25.09.2023
does not amount to an affirmation of the findings contained
therein on merits or an adjudication of the writ petitioner’s
ownership over the seized iron ore.
17.
We have considered the contentions advanced on
either side and perused the material placed on record. The
question that
arises for
consideration is whether the
respondents are justified in withholding release of the iron
ore despite the order dated 25.09.2023 passed in Criminal
Petition No.7827/2018 and the subsequent clarification
dated
02.09.2025
passed
in
Criminal
Petition
No.100029/2023.
18.
We notice that the Apex Court had directed the
CBI to investigate all aspects of illegality relating to iron ore
seized
at
Belekeri
Port.
However,
by
Order
dated
16.09.2013, the Apex Court permitted the CBI to refer cases
involving exports of less than 50,000 metric tonnes of iron
ore to the State Government. The relevant portion of the
order dated 16.09.2013 reads as under:"x x x x x
(a) The CBI is permitted to register criminal case
against those exporters who were enquired into in the
preliminary enquiry and who had exported iron ore of
more than 50,000 MT without valid permits and as
recommended by the Central Empowered Committee in
its report dated 5th September, 2012.
(b) The CBI is permitted to refer the matter with
respect to the exporters who had exported less than
50,000 MT and were not enquired into in the preliminary
enquiry, to the Government of Karnataka for taking
further necessary action under the relevant laws, as
recommended by the Central Empowered Committee in
its Report dated 5th September, 2012.
(c)
We
also
permit
the
Central
Bureau
of
Investigation to refer to the Government of Karnataka
for taking further action under relevant laws with regard
to those exporters who were enquired into in the
preliminary enquiry and who had exported less than
50,000
MT
of
iron
ore
without
valid
permits
as
recommended by the Central Empowered Committee in
its Report dated 5th September, 2012.
(d) We direct the State of Karnataka to take
further necessary action under the relevant laws as
recommended by the CEC in its Report dated 5th
September, 2012 with regard to those exporters who
have
exported
less
than
50,000
MT
and
report
compliance within a period of four weeks from the date
of receipt of communication of this order.
x x x x x"
19.
The quantity claimed by the writ petitioner was
34,544.61 MT and was, therefore, below the threshold of
50,000 MT. Pursuant to the liberty granted by the Apex
Court, the matter was investigated by the State authorities.
The investigation culminated in the filing of a ‘B’ Report,
which was accepted by the competent Court. The order
accepting the ‘B’ Report has not been challenged. The
respondents cannot, therefore, contend that an investigation
by the CBI is necessarily required merely because the iron
ore had originally formed part of the stock seized at Belekeri
Port.
20.
The respondents contend that the ‘B’ Report filed
by the SIT in Crime No.2/2014 did not concern the
ownership of the iron ore seized in FIR No.17/2009-10. The
writ petitioner’s claim for release of the very same iron ore
was specifically considered by this Court in Criminal Petition
No.7827/2018. By order dated 25.09.2023, this Court set
aside the order dated 03.09.2018 passed by the CBI Court
and directed the competent Forest authorities to determine
the available quantity and value of the iron ore and
thereafter release it to the writ petitioner upon furnishing
one surety and executing an indemnity bond for the value so
determined. The direction to release the iron ore is explicit
and admits of no ambiguity.
21.
The State Government challenged the said order
before the Apex Court. The Special Leave Petition was
dismissed on 17.05.2024. The State thereafter filed a
“Memo for Being Spoken To”, seeking inclusion of a
condition requiring surety for a like sum. The memo was
rejected by this Court and was subsequently withdrawn by
the State in the proceedings before the Apex Court.
Consequently,
the
order
dated
25.09.2023
remains
unmodified and operative. The respondents have also relied
upon the order dated 23.09.2023 passed by the JMFC,
Ankola, rejecting the writ petitioner’s application under
Sections 451 and 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
The said order preceded the order dated 25.09.2023 passed
by this Court. The subsequent order of this Court contains a
specific direction to the competent Forest authorities to
release the iron ore subject to the conditions stipulated
therein.
22.
The objections now raised regarding ownership,
the distinction between the CBI and SIT investigations, the
pendency of other criminal proceedings and the nature and
extent of the surety cannot be made the basis for refusing to
comply with the order dated 25.09.2023. Such objections
cannot now be relied upon to reopen matters concluded by
the order dated 25.09.2023 or to render the direction
contained therein ineffective.
23.
dated
The respondents also cannot rely upon the order
02.06.2025
passed
in
Criminal
Petition
No.100029/2023, permitting the State Government to take
custody of and auction the available iron ore. By the
subsequent order dated 02.09.2025, this Court expressly
clarified that the order dated 02.06.2025 was subject to the
earlier orders passed in Criminal Petition No.7827/2018. The
direction
for
release
contained
in
the
order
dated
25.09.2023 was thus expressly preserved.
24.
Pursuant to the order dated 25.09.2023, the
Senior Geologist determined the available quantity of iron
ore at 20,083.95 MT and its value at Rs.7,71,42,452/-. The
writ petitioner thereafter executed the indemnity bond and
furnished the surety contemplated by the said order. The
execution
of
these
documents
is
not
disputed.
The
conditions imposed upon the writ petitioner having been
complied with, nothing further remained to be performed by
it for securing release of the iron ore.
25.
The impugned communication dated 08.12.2025
postpones the release of iron ore until the conclusion of the
proceedings pending before the Apex Court. The pendency
of a review petition or any other proceeding before the Apex
Court does not, in the absence of an order of stay, suspend
the operation of the order dated 25.09.2023. The Apex
Court in Collector of Customs, Bombay v. Krishna Sales
(P) Ltd, reported in 1994 Supp (3) SCC 73, held that the
mere filing of an appeal does not operate as a stay or
suspension of the order appealed against and that, if the
authorities
considered
it
necessary
to
withhold
implementation of the order pending the appeal, the proper
course was to obtain an order of stay or other appropriate
direction from the competent Court and without such an
order, the authorities could not refuse to implement the
order under appeal. Similarly, in State of Haryana v. State
of Punjab reported in (2004) 12 SCC 673, the Apex Court
held that while dealing with successive proceedings assailing
an operative decree, including proceedings before the
Supreme Court, in the absence of any order of stay, the
mere filing of proceedings does not operate as a stay.
26.
We are, therefore, of the opinion that the
objections raised by the respondents do not furnish any
legally sustainable ground for withholding release of the iron
ore. The direction contained in the order dated 25.09.2023
remains operative, the subsequent order dated 02.09.2025
expressly preserves it and the writ petitioner has complied
with the conditions imposed therein. The communication
dated 08.12.2025 is, therefore, unsustainable.
27.
In the result,
(i)
The writ petition is allowed.
(ii)
The
communication
dated
08.12.2025
issued by respondent No.5, produced as
Annexure ‘J’, is set aside.
(iii) Respondents No.1 to 5 are directed to
release the available quantity of 20,083.95
MT of iron ore lying in Stock No.MC-12 at
Belekeri Port to the writ petitioner, in terms
of the order dated 25.09.2023 passed in
Criminal Petition No.7827/2018.
(iv) The release of iron ore shall be completed
within a period of two weeks from the date
of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
All
pending
interlocutory
applications
shall
disposed of.
Sd/(ANU SIVARAMAN)
JUDGE
Sd/(VENKATESH NAIK T)
JUDGE
cp*
stand
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review