Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KABORAMBA Digitally
KABORAMBAM
M SANDEEP SANDEEP SINGH
Date: 2024.11.20
SINGH
11:31:40 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Vasochan Ragui, aged about 30 years, D/o Benjamin
Ragui, a resident of Hamleikhong, P.O. & P.S. Ukhrul,
District – Ukhrul, Manipur.
Petitioner
-Versus1. The Union of India represented by the Secretary
Forest
and
Wildlife
Division,
Ministry
of
Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Indira
Paryavaran Bhavan, Jorbagh Road, New Delhi –
110 003.
2. The State of Manipur represented by the Principal
Chief Conservator of Forest & Head of Forest
Force, Government of Manipur, Sanjenthong,
Imphal – 795001.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU KABUI
For the petitioner
::
Mr. Sarosh Damania, Advocate
Mr. Zinranso Shatshang, Advocate
For respondent No. 1
::
Mr. W. Darakeshwar, Sr. PCCG
For respondent No. 2
::
Mr. H. Debendra, Dy. Advocate General
assisted by Mr. I. Amri, Advocate
Date of reserving
judgment & Order
::
21.10.2024
Date of Judgment &
Order
::
20.11.2024
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 1
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Justice Siddharth Mridul, C J:
[1]
The present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India has been instituted by a practicing advocate of this Court, statedly in the
public interest, and on the basis of articles in the public domain. The petitioner
candidly admits that no representation has so far been addressed to the
authorities in relation to the omnibus reliefs prayed for in the instant petition.
[2]
The petitioner seeks directions for the enforcement and
implementation of the provisions in Chapter V-B of the amended Wild Life
(Protection) Act, 1972, (hereinafter referred to as the Act), which became
effective on 1st April, 2023.
[3]
It is submitted on behalf of the petitioner that Exotic animals were
hitherto not covered by the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972, till the amendment
to the said Act took effect as above stated on 1st April, 2023. The petitioner
would urge that meanwhile, international transfer of Exotic animals was
governed by the Treaty known as the Convention on International Trade in
Endangered Species (CITIES) of Wild Fauna and Flora, which has been ratified
by India.
[4]
The amendment to the said Act, it is asserted aims to implement
the provisions of the convention and to regulate issues in relation to ownership,
possession and domestic transfers of Exotic animals. It is urged that the animals
covered by the amendment are listed in Schedule IV of the Act, as amended,
and correspond to those enumerated in the Appendices of the Convention.
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 2
[5]
Before the amendment of 1st April, 2023, a time–limited Voluntary
Disclosure Scheme was introduced on 11th June, 2020, by the Union of India,
respondent No. 1 herein, inviting the public to declare their personal inventory
of Exotic animals. This Scheme, it is asserted, was the subject matter of various
petitions, including one before the Supreme Court, which has consistently held
that the Scheme constitutes an amnesty providing immunity from coercive
action for applicants who declare their inventory thereunder.
[6]
Subsequently, the aforementioned amendment to the Act
introduced Section 49-M, which stipulates that all owners of animals listed in
the new Schedule IV must register them in accordance with the prescribed
Rules. The Living Animals Species (Reporting and Registration) Rules, 2024,
came into force in February, 2024, and Rule 3(3); which is central to the
petitioner’s argument; requires that applicants for the registration of animals
acquired prior to the amendment must submit ‘proof of acquisition’ of the
animals.
[7]
The petitioner would urge that the requisite proof must consist of
a legitimate, verifiable document evidencing the lawful acquisition of the
animal; in the absence of which, the animal is subject to seizure and
repatriation to its country of origin or placement in state run rescue facilities.
[8]
The petitioner has invited our attention to a judgment dated
11.09.2024 rendered by the Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in the
matter of Bhupesh Charan Vs. Union of India and another (D.B. Civil
writ Petition No. 14968 of 2024). Additionally, the petitioner has
referenced an interim order dated 29.08.2024 passed by the Kerala High Court
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 3
in Aviculture Association Bhaskaram and others Vs. Union of India
and others (W.P. (C) No. 30031 of 2024)
[9]
Nevertheless, the petitioner would urge that the ruling of
Rajasthan High Court in Bhupesh Charan (supra) and the interim order
passed by the Kerala High Court in Aviculture Association Bhaskaram
(supra) should not impede our independent interpretation of Rule 3(3). The
petitioner has vigorously asserted that the Rajasthan High Court’s decision in
Bhupesh Charan (supra) is flawed, inasmuch as, it fails to consider the Rules
in their appropriate context and neglects the fundamental principles of
interpretation. In other words, it is argued that the above judgment is not a
binding authority on this Court.
[10]
In our opinion, the central issue for deliberation is whether
registration can be granted under the aforementioned Rules for cases governed
by Rule 3(3) solely based on a declaration submitted under the Scheme.
[11]
In this behalf, it is pertinent to observe, that the Scheme in
question has been recognized by decisions of various High Courts, as well as a
Supreme Court decision, as an Amnesty Scheme. The Scheme indicates that
following the submission of a declaration, an online certificate of possession is
to be issued to the declarant. Consequently, it is our view that this Amnesty
Scheme confers upon the declarant the benefit of retaining possession of the
declared animal. Given that this benefit has been established by a Scheme upon
which the general public has relied, it cannot be rescinded by subsequent
legislation. Furthermore, we do not perceive Rule 3 as having abrogated this
benefit.
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 4
[12]
We are bolstered in our opinion by the ruling of the Rajasthan
High Court in Bhupesh Charan (supra); with which we express our respectful
agreement. We find no merit whatsoever in the petitioner’s assertion that the
Rajasthan High Court’s decision is flawed. The Court, in our considered view,
has accurately interpreted the Rules within the context of the Scheme and its
ramifications
[13]
We find ourselves unable to be persuaded by the argument that,
we should entirely disregard or overlook the Rajasthan High Court’s ruling. It is
important to observe that a decision from another High Court, rendered in
relation to an all India Act or Rules, carries persuasive authority and typically
promotes uniformity and certainty when adhered to. As such, we discern no
error in that decision, so as to warrant our disagreement with the findings
arrived at. Consequently, we find ourselves in concurrence with the Rajasthan
High Court’s ruling.
[14]
The Rajasthan High Court in paragraph 10 of the report, clearly
and unequivocally holds that, benefits already conferred under the Advisory,
namely, the Scheme, cannot be revoked to the detriment of the beneficiaries.
We find ourselves in agreement with the view that the declaration made under
the Advisory, i.e., the Scheme itself, should be regarded as sufficient evidence
of acquisition and an individual should not be compelled to provide additional
‘so called’ tangible or verifiable proof. Furthermore, we find ourselves in
complete agreement with the perspective articulated in paragraph 11 of the
said report, which posits that when a declaration is timely made, but a
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 5
certification of possession is not issued, a legal presumption arises, that such a
certificate is deemed to have been granted.
[15]
The interim ruling of the Kerala High Court in Aviculture
Association Bhaskaram (supra), in our view, is in an entirely different
context and given its nature as an interim direction, we find it unnecessary to
refer to it any further.
[16]
The relief sought for in the instant petition, calls for a direction to
the respondents to conduct seizures of Exotic animals held by private citizens,
which admittedly were declared under the Scheme and sought to be registered
only on the basis of a declaration. It is our view that a declaration under the
Scheme constitutes sufficient evidence of acquisition in accordance with Rule 3
of the aforementioned Rules.
[17]
We find ourselves completely unable to countenance the absurd
clarification prayed for on behalf of the petitioner, to the effect that, the
decision of the Rajasthan High Court and the interim order of Kerala High Court
ought not to come in the way of the respondent authorities from taking action
as per the orders to be passed by this Court in the present proceeding. It is
axiomatic that we are not and cannot sit in appeal over a judgment and order
passed by a Division Bench of another High Court.
[18]
In view of the foregoing, in our considered opinion, the petitioner
has failed to make out any cogent case for the broad and omnibus directions
that she seeks in the present public interest petition. Even otherwise, as
observed hereinabove, the petitioner has not approached the competent
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 6
authorities by way of a representation on the issues raised in the present
proceedings before approaching this High Court seeking sweeping directions in
the nature of a writ of mandamus.
[19]
The present public interest litigation, being devoid of merit, is
accordingly dismissed.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sandeep
PIL No. 13 of 2024
Page 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review