Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 27.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 27.03.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 28.03.2026
+
W.P.(CRL) 2829/2025, CRL.M.A. 30049/2025, CRL.M.A.
38732/2025 &CRL.M.A. 2042/2026
VARITA SONI
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr.
Sarthak
Advocate.
Maggon,
versus
+
STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Rahul Tyagi, ASC (Crl)
for State with Mr. Sangeet
Sibou, Advocate.
W.P.(CRL) 343/2026
VARITA SONI
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr.
Sarthak
Advocate.
Maggon,
versus
STATE ( NCT OF DELHI)
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Rahul Tyagi, ASC (Crl)
for State with Mr. Sangeet
Sibou, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
JUDGMENT
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
1.
By way of the captioned petitions – W.P. (Crl.) 2829/2025 and
W.P. (Crl.) 343/2026 – the petitioner seeks grant of the first spell of
furlough and grant of parole for a period of eight weeks, respectively,
primarily on the ground that the petitioner‟s presence is required for
the care and support of her children, as well as her aged mother, who
is presently facing health-related difficulties.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner is presently
lodged in Central Jail No. 6, Tihar, New Delhi, undergoing a
sentence of life imprisonment in connection with FIR No. 80/2007,
registered at Police Station Dabri, Delhi in respect of which she was
convicted for offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 [hereafter ‘IPC’] by the learned Trial Court. Her conviction was
upheld by this Court in CRL.A. 928/2011 vide judgment dated
15.01.2013, and the Special Leave Petition (SLP) preferred by her
was dismissed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court.
3.
The nominal roll of the petitioner has been received and, upon
perusal of the same, it is noted that the petitioner has remained in
judicial custody for a period of 17 years and 11 months.
4.
The case set out by the petitioner is that she is the mother of
two daughters. It is stated that the younger daughter was born in the
year 2018, while the petitioner was released on emergency parole.
The husband of the petitioner unfortunately, passed away on
25.04.2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic. At present, the
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
petitioner‟s elderly mother is looking after both daughters; however,
she is suffering from various ailments and is not in a position to
provide adequate care to them. The elder daughter has recently
secured admission in Punjab Engineering College and, owing to her
academic commitments, is also unable to take care of her younger
sister. Consequently, the younger daughter is presently in need of the
care, support, and companionship of her mother.
5.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner has undergone about 17 years and 11 months of actual
incarceration and over 20 years of imprisonment including remission,
and has never misused the liberty granted to her on earlier occasions.
It is contended that the competent authority erred in rejecting her
request for grant of first spell of furlough vide order dated 22.08.2025
on the ground of delayed surrender. It is submitted that the petitioner
was released on furlough from 04.03.2024 to 19.03.2024, and her
surrender was subsequently exempted by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
till 01.10.2024. On 01.10.2024, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
dismissed her petition, noting certain errors and concealments in a
batch of similar matters, and directed the petitioners, including the
present petitioner, to surrender forthwith. It is contended that the
order was uploaded on 05.10.2024 and communicated to the
petitioner only on 12.10.2024, and being a resident of Chandigarh,
she required reasonable time to arrange travel and engage counsel.
The learned counsel submits that the petitioner thereafter filed
W.P.(Crl.) 3255/2024, wherein this Court directed consideration of
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
her case for premature release on priority. It is further argued that, on
legal advice and in view of extensions granted to similarly placed
convicts, the petitioner believed that her exemption from surrender
was pending, and accordingly approached the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court by filing SLP (Crl.) No. 50463/2024. It is stated that the
Sentence Review Board considered her case on 10.12.2024.
Subsequently, on 15.04.2025, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court granted
her four weeks‟ time to surrender. The petitioner surrendered on
13.05.2025 within the stipulated time. It is further submitted that
upon the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observing on 23.05.2025 that the
appropriate remedy was to challenge the decision of the Sentence
Review Board before this Court, the petitioner withdrew the SLP and
filed W.P.(Crl.) 2446/2025. It is argued that no punishment has been
awarded to the petitioner for the alleged delay in surrender. It is also
submitted that the petitioner has a minor daughter aged about six
years, born during emergency parole in 2018, who requires her care,
and is presently being looked after by the petitioner‟s ailing mother,
while her elder daughter is unable to do so due to her recent
admission in Punjab Engineering College, Chandigarh.
6.
The learned ASC appearing for the State submits that the
petitioner was earlier released on parole by the competent authority
for the period from 04.03.2024 to 19.03.2024. It is stated that the
petitioner had approached the Hon‟ble Supreme Court by way of SLP
(Crl.) No. 3496/2024 seeking premature release, and vide order dated
07.03.2024, she was granted exemption from surrender. However,
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
subsequently, vide order dated 01.10.2024, the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court vacated the said interim protection and directed the petitioner
to surrender forthwith. It is contended that despite the aforesaid
direction, the petitioner failed to surrender. In the interregnum, the
petitioner filed another SLP before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court,
wherein vide order dated 15.04.2025, she was granted four weeks‟
time to surrender, along with a direction to place proof of surrender
on record. The learned ASC submits that the petitioner concealed the
material fact from the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that she had no
protection for the period from 01.10.2024 to 15.04.2025 and yet did
not surrender during the said period. It is further argued that in terms
of Rule 1224(III) of the Delhi Prison Rules, 2018, a prisoner who
absconds while on parole or furlough is not entitled to grant of
furlough. Reliance is also placed on Standing Order No. 01/2019
issued by the Office of the Director General of Prisons, which lays
down guidelines governing grant of parole and furlough. As per
Clause 26 thereof, the petitioner is stated to be ineligible for furlough
for a period of one year, as a punishment in the form of „warning‟
had been issued to her on account of delayed surrender. On these
grounds, it is prayed that the present application be dismissed.
7.
In rebuttal, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that the respondent seeks to deny furlough by invoking
Clause 26 of Standing Order No. 01/2019, which applies in cases
where a convict, while regularly availing furlough, commits a jail
offence and is issued a warning. It is contended that the said Standing
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
Order was issued pursuant to W.P.(Crl.) 2552/2018 (Sitaram v. State)
vide order dated 29.08.2018, at a time when the Delhi Prison Rules,
2018 had not yet come into force, and primarily concerns convicts
having pending appeals or SLPs against conviction. It is further
argued that, in any event, a Standing Order cannot override the
statutory provisions contained in the Delhi Prison Rules, 2018, and in
case of any inconsistency, the Rules, including Rule 1178 thereof,
would prevail.
8.
This Court has heard arguments addressed by the learned
counsel for the applicant and the learned ASC for the State, and has
perused the material on record.
9.
This Court notes that the petitioner had filed an application
seeking furlough before the competent authority, which came to be
rejected vide order dated 22.08.2025.
10.
The rejection was primarily on the ground that the petitioner
had earlier been released on furlough from 04.03.2024 to 19.03.2024.
Thereafter, the petitioner had filed SLP (Crl.) No. 3496/2024 seeking
premature release, and vide order dated 07.03.2024, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court had exempted her from surrendering. However,
subsequently, vide order dated 01.10.2024, while disposing of the
said SLP, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court directed the petitioner to
surrender. The petitioner failed to comply with the said direction
within the stipulated time and eventually surrendered on 13.05.2025.
The relevant portion of the order of the competent authority reads as
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
under:
“In this regard, I am directed to inform you that the Competent
Authority has considered the application for grant of furlough
and same has been declined for the following reason(s):–
1. She was released on furlough w.e.f. 04.03.2024 to
19.03.2024. Thereafter, she was exempted from surrendering
by Hon‟ble Apex Court till 01.10.2024. On 01.10.2024, the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court dismissed her petition and directed to
surrender immediately, but she did not surrender on time.
Later, she surrendered herself in jail on 13.05.2025.
2. Rule 1224(iii) of Delhi Prison Rules 2018 states that the
prisoner who absconded while released on parole or furlough
shall not be eligible to be released on furlough. Since, she had
violated the terms and conditions of furlough, her request of
furlough for current conviction year stands rejected.”
11.
It is the contention of the petitioner that she became aware of
the direction to surrender only on 12.10.2024. However, instead of
surrendering thereafter, she filed W.P. (Crl.) No. 3255/2024 before
this Court, contending that her case had not been considered even
once by the Sentence Review Board despite her being eligible for
such consideration. The petitioner has further submitted that she had
been advised by her counsel before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that
her application seeking exemption from surrender was still pending
consideration and that she was not required to surrender while
awaiting a decision of the Sentence Review Board. Subsequently, the
petitioner approached the Hon‟ble Supreme Court by way of SLP
(Crl.) No. 50463/2024. Vide order dated 15.04.2025, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court directed the petitioner to surrender within four weeks.
In compliance with the said direction, the petitioner surrendered on
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
13.05.2025.
12.
A perusal of the order dated 01.10.2024 passed in SLP (Crl.)
No. 3496/2024 makes it clear that the petition was withdrawn by the
petitioners and the interim relief granted earlier stood vacated. The
said order reads as under:
“ The learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners
seeks permission to withdraw these Petitions with liberty to
file substantive Petitions before the High Court.
The Petitions are, accordingly, disposed of as withdrawn
with liberty as prayed.
The interim relief granted by this Court in these Petitions
stands vacated.”
13.
The natural consequence of the above-noted order was that
the exemption from surrender, which had earlier been granted to the
petitioner, ceased to operate, and the petitioner was required to
surrender forthwith.
14.
It is also an admitted position that the order was uploaded on
the internet on 05.10.2024 and that the petitioner became aware of
the same on 12.10.2024. However, despite having knowledge of the
order, the petitioner did not surrender and instead proceeded on the
presumption that her application seeking exemption from surrender
was still pending consideration before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court,
which appears to be untenable.
15.
The record further reflects that wireless messages dated
10.10.2024, 23.10.2024, 15.11.2024 and 07.01.2025 were issued
noting that the petitioner had failed to surrender despite the direction
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
contained in the order dated 01.10.2024. However, even pursuant to
the said communications, the petitioner did not surrender before the
Jail Authorities, though she now disputes having received any such
messages.
16.
Nevertheless, the factum of the order dated 01.10.2024 was
concededly within the knowledge of the petitioner.
17.
The record further reveals that after surrendering on
13.05.2025, a warning was issued to the petitioner on 02.06.2025 by
the Jail Authorities, noting that she had failed to surrender within
time in terms of the order dated 01.10.2024 and that such conduct
could attract action under the Delhi Prison Rules, 2018.
18.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted a written apology
bearing her signatures, wherein she acknowledged that she was aware
of the order dated 01.10.2024 and yet did not surrender within the
stipulated time. In the said letter, she stated that her two daughters
were being looked after by her elderly mother and that, around the
relevant time, her mother had undergone an eye operation, which
prevented her from surrendering earlier; though she now disputes
having signed any such apology letter.
19.
As per Standing Order No. 01/2019 issued by the Office of the
Director General of Prisons, Clause 26 provides that where a convict,
who has been regularly availing furlough, commits a minor jail
offence and a warning is recorded against him or her, such convict
may be considered eligible for furlough only after the lapse of one
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
year from the date of the said offence. Thus, on this ground, the
petitioner would be ineligible for grant of furlough.
20.
The argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner that
Standing Order No. 01/2019 cannot override any provisions of the
Delhi Prison Rules is also without merit. Firstly, the petitioner has
not specifically challenged any clause of the said Standing Order
before this Court. Secondly, in this regard, this Court also notes that
the Division Bench of this Court in Deepak Srivastav v. State (NCT
of Delhi): 2025 SCC OnLine Del 8281 upheld the validity of Clause
F(3) of the same Standing Order and observed, inter alia, that the
Standing Order No. 01/2019 does not override the statutory rules but
rather supplements them by providing a mechanism to assess whether
a convict has continued to maintain good conduct. It was further held
that such administrative instructions, issued under the supervisory
powers of the Director General of Prisons, are valid so long as they
do not conflict with the provisions of the Act or the Rules. The
relevant portion of the decision is set out hereunder:
“31. The Delhi Prisons Rules, 2018, have been made by the
State Government in exercise of its power conferred on it under
Section 71 of the Act, 2000, which empowers the Government
to make rules generally to carry out the provisions of the Act,
2000. The particular subjects on which rules can be made under
Section 71, albeit without prejudice to the generality of subsection 1 of Section 71, have been mentioned in Section 71(2)
of the Act, 2000. Thus, the Rules, 2018, are statutory in nature
having been framed by the State Government under Section 71
of the Act, 2000.
32. The entire regime regulating grant of parole and furlough to
the prisoners is governed by Chapter XIX of the Rules, 2018.
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
The grant of furlough and procedure for disposal of
applications seeking furlough are governed by Rule 1220 to
Rule 1243 of the Rules, 2018. According to the statutory
Scheme for grant of furlough as available in Rule 1220 to
1243, in order to be eligible for furlough, the prisoner must
fulfill certain criterion which are, (1) he should be citizen of
India, (2) he should not be habitual offender and (3) he should
have exhibited good conduct in prison and should have earned
rewards in three AGCRs and he continues to maintain good
conduct. In the rules, certain categories of prisoners, such as
those convicted under sedition, terrorist activities and NDPS
are not eligible for release on furlough. Those prisoners whose
presence in the society may be considered dangerous or
prejudicial to public peace and order by the District Magistrate
are also not eligible to be released on furlough. Even the
convicted foreigners are also not eligible to seek furlough.
Certain other categories of prisoners in terms of the said rules
are also not eligible.
33. Rule 1226 provides that an application for grant of furlough
is to be submitted by the convict or his family members to the
Superintendent of Jail containing certain details given therein.
Such an application is to be forwarded to the police station
concerned and report from the police station and the
investigating agency are also required which should be based
on a fair inquiry. Thereafter, the application seeking furlough is
to be forwarded to the competent authority by the
Superintendent of Prisons and the competent authority
authorized to sanction furlough, may make order for release of
the prisoner, subject to certain conditions. One of the
considerations to determine the eligibility to obtain furlough as
given in Rule 1223 is that the prisoner should have earned
rewards in last three AGCRs and he continuous to maintain
good conduct. Thus, merely earning three AGCRs does not
suffice for making eligible a convict to seek furlough. In
addition to three AGCRs, for being eligible to seek furlough, a
convict should continue to maintain good conduct. Thus, the
impugned Clause F(3) of the Standing Order No. 01 of 2019
provides as to how determination of whether the convict
concerned had continued to maintain good conduct, can be
done. What we find, thus, is that Clause F(3) of the Standing
Order No. 01 of 2019 has been prescribed only to supplement
Rule 1223 (1) in the sense that Clause F(3) of the Standing
Order No. 01 of 2019 provides a mechanism to determine the
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
fact as to whether the convict seeking furlough, has continued
to maintain good conduct.
(Emphasis by the Court)
34. We are also of the opinion that to come to a conclusion that
the convict having earned three AGCRs has or has not
continued to maintain good conduct, a watch period of one year
has been prescribed therein which only supplements the
provisions contained in Rule 1223 (1) of the Rules, 2018. As a
matter of fact, the Standing Order No. 01 of 2019 is nothing
but a compilation of instructions, which have been issued in
order
to
appropriately
apply
the
rules
while
considering/processing any application/prayer for grant of
furlough. Thus, the impugned provision contained in Clause
F(3) of the Standing Order No. 01 of 2019 is supplemental to
the rules, which authority, in our opinion, can very well being
exercised by the Director General of Prisons under his general
administrative and supervisory power of control over the
affairs of the prisons.
35. Clause F(3) of the Standing Order No. 01 of 2019 which is
under challenge herein has, thus, been issued by the Director
General of Prisons exercising his general administrative powers
and since such a provision does not, in any manner, infringes
and contradicts any provision either of the Act, 2000 or of the
Rules, 2018, we are of the opinion that the same cannot be said
to be without jurisdiction or illegal being ultra vires.
36. Considering the other submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner that the impugned provision infringes the right of
liberty as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India, we may observe that right to seek furlough is not an
absolute right; it is rather a right governed by the statutory
prescriptions embodied in the Act, 2000 and the Rules made
thereunder, enacted by the competent legislature.
37. It is also to be noticed that a person seeking furlough is a
convict under law, who is incarcerated under a validly passed
order by a competent Court. In the instant case, order of
conviction of the petitioner has been upheld up to the Hon'ble
Supreme Court and therefore, if by operation of any statutory
rule or any statutory provision, furlough is being denied to the
petitioner, it cannot be said that it shall amount to denial of
right of liberty enjoyed by the petitioner. Right to liberty under
furlough or parole is regulated by the Act, 2000 and the rules
framed thereunder and therefore, any infringement of such a
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
right can only be attended to by the Courts, if the petitioner or
any other person is able to establish infraction of the provisions
of the Act, 2000 or rules framed thereunder…”
21.
This Court is also of the view that furlough is essentially
granted as an incentive for a prisoner‟s good conduct during
incarceration, and is intended to reward discipline and satisfactory
behaviour in prison, and the period spent by a prisoner outside the
prison while on furlough is counted towards the sentence. Parole, on
the other hand, refers to the temporary release of a prisoner for a
limited period, primarily to enable the prisoner to maintain social ties
with family and the community or to attend to specific personal
exigencies. However, the period spent by a prisoner outside the
prison while on parole is not counted towards the sentence. As held
by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in State of Gujarat v. Narayana:
2021 SCC OnLine SC 949, furlough is intended as an incentive for
maintaining good conduct while in custody and cannot be claimed by
a prisoner as an absolute or vested right.
22.
Even otherwise, though this Bench has granted the relief of
furlough to certain other convicts whose cases were akin to that of the
present petitioner, and whose petitions had been dismissed by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court on 01.10.2024 with the interim protection
from surrender having been vacated, the facts of those cases are
clearly distinguishable. In decisions such as Suresh v. State (NCT of
Delhi):
2025:DHC:588,
Raju
v.
State
(NCT
of
Delhi):
2025:DHC:586 and Md. Salauddin v. State (NCT of Delhi):
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
2025:DHC:331, the delay in surrender by the convict was only 5
days, 7 days and 10 days, respectively, and this Court, considering
such minor delays, had granted the relief of furlough. In the present
case, however, the delay in surrender is more than 07 months, and
therefore, this Court is not inclined to show any indulgence in favour
of the petitioner.
23.
The petitioner‟s prayer for grant of furlough is accordingly
rejected. This, however, shall not preclude the petitioner from
applying for furlough, as per rules, in the next conviction year.
24.
The petitioner herein has also filed W.P. (Crl.) 343/2026,
seeking grant of parole for a period of eight weeks on the ground that
her children and her ailing mother require her presence and maternal
support.
25.
It is noted by this Court that the petitioner has remained in
judicial custody for about 17 years and 11 months as on date,
excluding the remission. During the course of her incarceration, she
has been released on parole and furlough on about 31 occasions. The
record indicates that there has been only one instance of violation
attributed to her, when she failed to surrender on 01.10.2024 and
ultimately surrendered on 13.05.2025. In relation to the said lapse, a
warning was issued to her. But otherwise, her jail conduct is reported
as satisfactory.
26.
Therefore, insofar as the prayer for parole is concerned, this
Court is inclined to grant parole to the petitioner for a period of four
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
(04) weeks from the date of her release, on the following terms and
conditions:
i.
The petitioner shall furnish a personal bond in the sum
of Rs.10,000/- with one surety of the like amount, who shall be
a family member, to the satisfaction of the Jail Superintendent
concerned.
ii.
The petitioner shall report to the SHO concerned of the
local area once a week on every Sunday between 10:00 AM to
11:00 AM during the period of parole.
iii.
The petitioner shall furnish a telephone/mobile number
to the Jail Superintendent as well as SHO of local police
station, on which he can be contacted if required.
iv.
The petitioner shall reside at the address mentioned in
the present petition during the period of parole.
v.
The
petitioner
shall
surrender
before
the
Jail
Superintendent, immediately after the expiry of the period of
parole.
27.
Accordingly, W.P. (Crl.) 2829/2025 stands dismissed along
with pending applications, whereas W.P. (Crl.) 343/2026 is disposed
of in above terms.
28.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
MARCH 27, 2026/
TD/rb
W.P.(CRL.) 2829/2025 along with connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
17:45:58
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review