Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:24836
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C. JAYACHANDRAN
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.MC NO. 7195 OF 2024
CRIME NO.815/2023 OF Peerumedu Police Station, Idukki
AGAINST CC NO.50 OF 2024 OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF FIRST
CLASS, PEERUMEDU
PETITIONER/ACCUSED:
VARGHESE JOHN
AGED 70 YEARS
S/O. V.J. VARGHESE, VANIYATH HOUSE, KARADIKUZHI PO,
PEERMADE, IDUKKI DISTRICT, PIN - 685531
BY ADVS.
BIJU .C. ABRAHAM
THOMAS C.ABRAHAM
BASIL MATHEW
RESPONDENTS/STATE AND DEFACTO COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682031
SHEELA
AGED 66 YEARS
W/O. MOHANAN, KANJIRATHINKAL, OTTAPPALAM P.O, PEERMADE
VILLAGE, IDUKKI DISTRICT, PIN - 685532
BY ADVS.
R.SHABANA – FOR R2
NAZEER HUZAIN.H(K/1166/2020)
SEENA C. - PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
24.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..2..
2025:KER:24836
O R D E R
Dated this the 24th day of March, 2025
Petitioner herein is the sole accused in Annexure-1 F.I.R.
bearing
No.815/2023
offence
under
Annexure-2
of
Section
charge
Peerumade
Police
alone
is
alleged
though
the
offences
sheet,
Station.
The
as
per
under
Sections 354 and 355 were canvassed in Annexure-1 F.I.R.
Annexure-2 final report is now pending before the Judicial
First
Class
Magistrate
Court-I,
Peerumade,
as
C.C.No.50/2024. The petitioner/ accused seeks quashment of
the entire proceedings in Annexure-1 Crime, as also, all
further proceedings therefrom.
2.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
learned counsel for the 2nd respondent/defacto complainant
and the learned Public Prosecutor. Perused the records.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that one
Noushad
had
trespassed
into
petitioner's
property
and
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..3..
2025:KER:24836
constructed some toilets therein. A complaint in this
regard
was
preferred
before
the
Health
Minister,
as
Annexure-4. Further complaints in the form of Annexure-3
to
were
preferred
before
various
authorities.
Ultimately, by virtue of Annexure-8, the patta in favour
of said Noushad was cancelled. Infuriated by the same, the
instant crime has been foisted against the petitioner by
the defacto complainant, who is an employee under the said
Noushad.
Noushad
is
running
a
hotel.
The
petitioner/
accused was summoned for a compromise talk by the said
Noushad and others. However, according to the learned
counsel, he was brutally manhandled and he was admitted in
the hospital. Nevertheless, no case was registered by the
Police
against
the
said
Noushad
and
others.
In
such
circumstances, he filed a complaint before the Judicial
First Class Magistrate Court-I, Peerumade. The same was
forwarded to the jurisdictional Police, and a crime was
registered, marked Annexure-10. The offences alleged in
Annexure-10 are under Sections 143, 144, 147, 294(b), 323,
324, 506 and 149 of the Penal Code. Final report has
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..4..
2025:KER:24836
already
been
filed
and
the
same
is
now
pending
as
C.C.No.166/2023 before the above-referred Judicial First
Class
against
Magistrate
the
Court-I,
petitioner
Peerumade,
herein,
as
where
an
the
accused,
case
namely
C.C.No.50/2024, is also pending. After the registration of
Annexure-10 crime, Annexure-1 crime was foisted, which was
also registered pursuant to a private complaint preferred
by the defacto complainant, the employee of the said
Noushad. Learned counsel would point out that the same was
registered after four months from the alleged date of
incident.
The
employees
of
witnesses
the
said
in
the
Noushad.
said
Learned
cases
are
counsel
all
would
invite this Court's attention to the statement of the
defacto complainant, which refers to the fact that the
petitioner/accused ran away from the place of occurrence,
which is an impossibility in itself. Similar statements
have been given by other witnesses to the effect that the
petitioner/accused
ran
away.
Inviting
this
Court's
attention to Annexure-9 medical report, learned counsel
would submit that the petitioner/accused had undergone a
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..5..
2025:KER:24836
Conversion Arthroplasty on 14.10.2020, by which procedure
his right hip was replaced. According to the learned
counsel, such a person cannot run, as the witnesses seek
to allege. Learned counsel then invited the attention of
this Court to the medical certificate, forming part of the
final report, whereby no external injury is noted at the
time
of
examination,
which
finding
of
the
doctor
is
contrary to the claim made by the defacto complainant in
the
F.I.S.
petitioner,
unnecessarily
According
who
is
dragged
to
the
learned
aged
more
than
into
this
counsel,
70,
has
litigation
the
been
as
a
counterblast to the crime registered vide Annexure-10. The
petitioner accordingly seeks quashment.
4.
This application was seriously opposed by the learned
counsel
for
the
2nd
respondent/defacto
complainant.
Learned counsel would submit that, in Annexure-10 private
complaint, the date of occurrence is 06.03.2023. However,
the wound certificate is dated 08.03.2023. According to
the learned counsel, the wound certificate is obtained,
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..6..
2025:KER:24836
upon
knowing
already
that
preferred
the
a
defacto
complaint
complainant
herein
against
petitioner/
the
had
accused in Annexure-1 crime. Learned counsel would also
point out that all the arguments raised by the learned
counsel for the petitioner are based on facts, which
require evidence to be adduced before the trial court; and
that the same cannot be considered, or for that matter, no
quashment can be based on such factual premise in exercise
of the powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. Learned counsel
relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
this regard in Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander [2012 (4) KLT
SN 109 (C.No.98) SC].
5.
This application was seriously opposed by the learned
Public Prosecutor, as well.
6.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the
respective parties, this Court finds little merit in the
instant Criminal Miscellaneous Case. As rightly canvassed
by the learned counsel for the 2nd respondent, all the
arguments advanced before this Court are based on factual
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..7..
2025:KER:24836
parameters. This Court may recall that the first point
canvassed is with respect to a delay of four months. It is
one thing to say that unexplained delay will seriously
impact the merits of a criminal case. However, it is for
the
trial
court
to
ascertain
whether
the
delay
is
explained or not. Needless to say that, an opportunity in
this
regard
has
to
be
given
to
the
defacto
complainant/prosecution. The second aspect canvassed is
that
there
complainant,
is
no
external
injury
to
the
defacto
contrary
to
claim
in
the
private
her
complaint. This, again, is a matter for evidence, to be
decided by the trial court. The question as to whether
this is a counterblast to Annexure-10 crime, is also a
matter for the trial court to decide. As it is well
settled,
quashment
under
Section
Cr.P.C.
is
an
extraordinary remedy, to be resorted to in cases where the
offences sought to be canvassed are not made out, even if
the entire prosecution version is presumed to be true, or
in a case where the court is fully convinced that the
criminal case launched is nothing, but shear abuse of
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..8..
2025:KER:24836
process. This Court cannot fit the instant facts to any of
the two propositions above-referred. Reliance has been
placed on Amit Kapoor (supra) rightly by the learned
counsel for the 2nd respondent. It was held by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court that the Court cannot examine the facts,
evidence, and materials on record to determine whether
there exists sufficient material, based upon which the
prosecution case will end up in a conviction. The court is
concerned primarily with an allegation, taken as a whole
in the matter, of constituting the offence alleged. It was
also
held
by
the
Supreme
Court
that
it
is
neither
necessary, nor called upon to hold an enquiry or to
appreciate the evidence collected by the investigating
agency, to find out whether it is a case of acquittal or
conviction. Such an enquiry is not contemplated at all in
exercise of the powers under Section 482, when a party to
a criminal case seeks quashment.
7.
Learned counsel would finally submit that the crime
was registered under Sections 354 and 355 along with
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..9..
2025:KER:24836
Section 323 of the Penal Code initially, as could be seen
from
Annexure-1
F.I.R.
However,
based
on
a
complaint
preferred by the petitioner before the District Police
Chief, the offences under Sections 354 and 355 has been
deleted as the same is not made out, and presently the
solitary offence is one under Section 323. From that fact
itself, it is clear that the case in question is nothing,
but one foisted falsely against the petitioner/accused, is
one final argument raised.
8.
that
This Court cannot express any opinion in respect of
and
the
possibility,
if
any,
of
the
factual
proposition canvassed by the petitioner is to be thrashed
out in evidence before the trial court, after eliciting
necessary answers in the cross-examination. This Court
cannot prejudge that, on account of the deletion of the
offence
under
Sections
and
355,
the
allegations
constituting the offence under Section 323 is also false
and fictitious.
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..10..
2025:KER:24836
9.
In view of the fact that the quashment is essentially
sought for based on attending facts and circumstances,
this Court finds little merit in the instant Crl.M.C. The
quashment sought for cannot be allowed. Accordingly, the
Criminal
Miscellaneous
Case
will
stand
dismissed.
The
matter will be decided by the trial court in accordance
with law, untramelled by any of the observations contained
in this Order.
The Criminal Miscellaneous Case is dismissed as above.
Sd/C. JAYACHANDRAN
JUDGE
TR
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..11..
2025:KER:24836
APPENDIX OF CRL.MC 7195/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure 1
THE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE FIR IN CRIME
NO. 815/2023 OF PEERMADE POLICE
STATION, DATED 21/09/2023
Annexure 2
THE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE CHARGE SHEET
IN C.C. NO. 50/2024 ON THE FILES OF
THE JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS MAGISTRATE
COURT I, PEERMADE IN CRIME NO.
815/2023 OF PEERMADE POLICE STATION
Annexure 3
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT DATED
09/05/2019 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Annexure 4
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT DATED
28/01/2020 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE HEALTH MINISTER, GOVERNMENT
OF KERALA
Annexure 5
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT DATED
28/01/2020 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE HON. CHIEF MINISTER OF
KERALA
Annexure 6
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT DATED
04/12/2023 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE HON. CHIEF MINISTER OF
KERALA
Annexure 7
TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOGRAPHS
EVIDENCING THE IIIEGAL CONSTRUCTION OF
TOILETS BY THE SAID NOUSHAD
Annexure 8
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS BEARING
NO. 4874/23 DATED 13/02/2024 ISSUED BY
THE TAHSILDAR, PEERMADE, CANCELLING
THE PATTA ASSIGNED AS PER LA NO. 60/95
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..12..
2025:KER:24836
AND LA NO. 47/92
Annexure 9
TRUE COPY OF THE MEDICAL REPORT ISSUED
BY ROTHMAN ORTHOPEADICS TO THE
PETITIONER DATED 10/03/2023
Annexure 10
TRUE COPY OF THE FIR IN CRIME NO.
386/2023 DATED 11/05/2023 OF PEERMADE
POLICE STATION
Annexure 11
TRUE COPY OF THE CHARGE SHEET IN CC
NO. 166/ 2023 DATED 02/06/2023 IN
CRIME NO. 386/2023 OF PEERMADE POLICE
STATION OF THE JFCM-I , PEERMADE
Annexure A13
A TRUE COPY OF THE X-RAY EVIDENCING
THE FACT THAT THE APPLICANT HAD
UNDERGONE HIP REPLACEMENT SURGERY
Annexure A14
A TRUE COPY OF THE MEDICAL REPORT
DATED 28/11/2023 ISSUED BY THE
JEFFERSON INTERNAL MEDICINE
SOUTHAMPTON, USA
Annexure A15
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT DATED
9/5/2019 SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT
ALONG WITH HIS WIFE, NAMELY, SUSAN
JOHN BEFORE THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF
POLICE
Annexure 16
TRUE COPY OF THE TREATMENT REPORT OF
THE APPLICANT DATED 28/11/2023 ISSUED
BY THE JEFFERSON HEALTH
Annexure 17
TRUE COPY OF THE UNLOCKED PROGRESS
NOTE DATED 28/11/2023
Annexure 18
TRUE COPY OF THE OP NOTE SIGNED BY
SCOT A. BROWN DATED 19/10/2020 ISSUED
JEFFERSON HEALTH
Annexure A19
TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY
DATED 4/3/2020 ISSUED BY THE CARITAS
Crl.M.C.No. 7195 of 2024
..13..
2025:KER:24836
HOSPITAL, KOTTAYAM
Annexure A20
TRUE COPY OF THE X-RAY OF THE
APPLICANT ISSUED FROM CARITAS
HOSPITAL, KOTTAYAM EVIDENCING THE
INJURY SUSTAINED BY THE APPLICANT IN
HIS RIGHT HIP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review