Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:121
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
VANSHIDHAR ELECTRIC PRIVATE LIMITED (a company registered
under the Companies Act, 1956/2013), having its registered office at House
No. 26, Dr. P.N. Mukerjee Street, LP-65/9 Chatra, Hoogly, P.O. and P.S.
Hoogly, District Hoogly (West Bengal), PIN 712204, through its Authorized
Signatory, Sanjay Dutta Gupta, aged about 49 years, son of Gouranga Dutta
Gupta, resident of Bhattanagar, Bally Municipality, P.O. and P.S. Bhattanagar,
District Howrah, West Bengal, PIN 711203.
….........Petitioner(s)
Vrs.
1. State of Jharkhand, through Principal Secretary, Road Construction
Department, having its office at Jharkhand Mantralaya (Project Building),
P.O. Dhurwa, P.S. Jagannathpur, District Ranchi, PIN 834004.
2. Engineer-in-Chief, Road Construction Department, having its office at
Jharkhand Mantralaya (Project Building), P.O. Dhurwa, P.S. Jagannathpur,
District Ranchi, PIN 834004.
3. Chief Engineer (Communication), Road Construction Department, having
its office at Jharkhand Mantralaya (Project Building), P.O. Dhurwa, P.S.
Jagannathpur, District Ranchi, PIN 834004.
4. Executive Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division,
Saraikela, P.O. and P.S. Saraikela, District Saraikela-Kharsawan (Jharkhand).
.......... Respondents
…....
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
Mrs. Shilpi Sandil Gadodia, Advocate
Mr. Anish Lal, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Mohan Kumar Dubey, AC to AG
06/06.01.2026
The present writ petition has been filed for the following
relief(s):
(i)
For issuance of an appropriate writ/order/direction,
including Writ of Mandamus, directing Respondentauthorities to pay admitted due and payable amount in
respect of Agreement No. 01 RFP of 2023-24 dated 15th
September, 2023 (Annexure-3) entered by and between
Petitioner
and
Respondents,
after
taking
into
consideration Force Majeure claim of Petitioner in terms
of Clause 25 of the Agreement.
(ii)
For issuance of further appropriate writ/order/direction,
including Writ of Declaration, declaring that action of
Respondent on one hand in not making payment of
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
admitted due amount and on the other hand unilaterally
extending the tenure of the Agreement is void ab initio;
and status of Petitioner after expiry of the tenure of the
Agreement is only that of an Agent of Respondentauthority.
2.
Arguments of the petitioner on the factual matrix reads as
under:
“1. Respondent-Executive Engineer, Road Division, Saraikela
published a Notice Inviting Tender dated 03.01.2023 for
appointment of User Fee Collection Agency in respect of
Adityapur-Kandra Road Section (0.000 to 15,100),
2. Petitioner was declared as the highest bidder and vide Letter
No. 798 dated 07.08.2023, it was appointed as User Fee
Collection Agency for Kandra Junction Toll Plaza at AdityapurKandra Road Section of State Highway No.5.
3. An agreement dated 15th September, 2003 was entered into
between
Petitioner
and
Respondent-Executive
Engineer,
wherein the contract entered with the Petitioner was for a
period of two years and was expiring on 03.10.2025.
4. Despite the fact that agreement was expiring on 03.10.2025
and Petitioner, on several occasions, wrote to Executive
Engineer for taking over the Toll Plaza, Respondent-Executive
Engineer, vide Letter No. 1089 dated 27.09.2025, extended the
tenure of the agreement up to 03.04.2026.
5. Petitioner objected to said unilateral extension of tenure,
which was contrary to Clause 2(ii) of the Agreement dated 15th
September, 2023, which reads as under ""(ii) The period of contract shall be Two years.
However, in case of urgency, the Authority reserves the
right to increase the contract period mutually agreed
upon but limited to 6 months."
6. It is an admitted fact that in Adityapur-Kandra Section of
State Highway No. 5, there is no facility installed for collection
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
of toll through FASTag.
7. The Toll Plaza, which was handed-over to Petitioner, was not
having FASTag system which is compulsory as per Ministry of
Road Transport and Highways and Petitioner, immediately
upon taking over of Toll Plaza, requested Respondent-State of
Jharkhand vide its Letter dated 17th October, 2023, to install
FASTag system for toll collection.
8. Again on 25th October, 2023, Petitioner filed reminder
representation for installation of FASTag system and it even
obtained a tentative quotation for installation of FASTag from a
vendor, costing about Rs. 72.00 Lakhs, and requested
Respondent-authorities
to
grant
necessary
approval
of
installation of FASTag, but no approval was granted.
9. Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, vide Notification
dated 2nd November, 2017 issued under Central Motor Vehicles
Rules, 1989, amended Rule 138A of Central Motor Vehicles
Rules, 1989, which reads as under:"138 A. Fitment of FASTag,-- Categories M and N
motor vehicles sold on and after the 1st December,
2017, shall be fitted with FASTag as may be specified by
the Central Government, from time to time, by the
manufacturer of the vehicle or its authorized dealer, as
the case may be:
Provided that in case of any vehicle which is sold
in the form of drive-away-chassis without windscreen,
FASTag shall be fitted on the windscreen by the vehicle
owner before the registration of such vehicles.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this rule, FASTag
means an onboard unit (transponder) or any such
device fitted on the front windscreen of the vehicle."
10. Further, vide Notification dated May, 2018, under Section 9
of National Highways Act, 1956, amendment was carried out in
National
Highways
Fee
(Determination
of
Rates
and
Collection), Rules, 2008 and Rule 2(1)(hd) was inserted, which
reads as under"(hd) "Electronic Toll Collection Infrastructure"
means set of equipment comprising of hardware and
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
software which shall facilitate electronic collection of
user fees."
11. Further, in Rule 6(3), following proviso was inserted,
namely;-“Provided also that if a vehicle user with a valid,
functional FASTag or any such device with Electronic
Toll Collection infrastructure, is not able to pay user fee
through FASTag or any such device owing to
malfunctioning of Electronic Toll Collection
infrastructure, the vehicle user shall be permitted to
pass the fee plaza without payment of any user fee. An
appropriate zero transaction receipt shall be issued
mandatorily for all such transactions."
12. A bare perusal of the said Rule would reveal that any
vehicle, which is fitted with FASTag and, if at the Toll Plaza,
there is no facility of collection through FASTag, said vehicle
would be required to pass without payment of user fee.
13 Aforesaid statutory Notification constitutes 'Law of land and
is required to be followed, and, if it is not followed, the same
would not only be violative of mandatory requirement of law,
but would also have material bearing on effective collection of
toll.
14. Ministry of Road Transport and Highways has further
issued Notification dated 15th May, 2020, wherein, in exercise
of power under Section 9 of National Highways Act, 1956,
under Rule 6 of the Rules of 2008, following proviso has been
substituted, namely."Provided further that user of the vehicle not fitted with
"FASTag" or vehicle without valid, functional
"FASTag" entering into "FASTag lane" of the Fee
plazas shall pay a fee equivalent to two times of the fee
applicable to that category of vehicles as per sub-rule
(2) of rule 4."
15. Thus, aforesaid provisions would clearly show that not only
that Toll Plazas are required to be fitted with equipment for
facilitating collection of toll through electronic means i.e.
FASTag, but even vehicles not fitted with FASTag, are liable to
pay fee equivalent to two times of the fee applicable.
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
16. The FASTag system was primarily required in India to
streamline toll collection and enhance travel efficiency, which
serves following purposes, namely:(a) Faster movement at toll plazas;
( b) Reduces waiting time & fuel consumption;
(c) Transport toll collection;
(d) Helps the government to monitor road usage:
(e) Reduces cash handling at toll plazas.
17. Under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, Insurance Policy
cannot be issued to Motor Vehicle unless it necessarily has
FASTag installed and this requirement was made mandatory
with effect from 1st April, 2021.
18. Despite the statutory mandate, at Toll Pláza of AdityapurKandra Section of State Highway No.5, no FASTag system was
installed which prevented the Petitioner in view of statutory
mandate from collecting toll from such vehicle which was fitted
with FASTag, especially because, as per law of land, Petitioner
could not have collected toll from vehicles fitted with FASTag
at a Toll Plaza which was not having device collection of toll
through electronic mode.
19. Petitioner, time and again, represented to Respondentauthorities that due to non-installation of FASTag collection
mechanism, vehicle owners are not making payment of cash at
the Toll Plaza and approximately within a week period, 1800
vehicles are passing through Toll Plaza without paying
prescribed toll, by stating, inter alia, that in absence of FASTag
mechanism, they are not required to pay toll at Toll Plaza.
20. Petitioner, vide several representation, brought to the notice
of Respondent-State of Jharkhand the perpetual effect of nonpayment of toll by several vehicles resulting into lessor
collection of toll at the Toll Plaza. In fact, Respondent-State of
Jharkhand itself was aware about aforesaid facts and the
Engineer-in-Chief, Road Construction Department wrote a
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
letter to Chief Engineer regarding necessity of installation of
FASTag at the Toll Plaza.
21.In fact, in subsequent tender being N.I.T. dated 02.05.2025
(Annexure-22), Respondents have themselves mentioned that
electronic device should be installed at the Toll Plaza enabling
collection of toll through FASTag.
22. Despite such representation, no heed was paid by
Respondent-authorities and, accordingly, Petitioner invoked
Clause 25(c)(v)(iii) of the Agreement giving notice for
termination of the contract, but neither Respondents settled the
claim, nor relieved the Petitioner from liability towards
collection of toll.
23.Petitioner filed repeated representations, dated 17th April,
2025, 25th August, 2025, 2nd September, 2025 and 22nd
September, 2025, stating, inter alia, that it has a claim of Rs.
5,34,96,913/- as on 31.08.2025 and requested the Respondents
to settle the said claim and further stated that since the contract
is expiring on 3rd October, 2025, it may be relieved from the
Toll Plaza operation.
24. However, Respondents never settled the claim and even
unilaterally extended the tenure of the agreement up to
03.04.2026.
25. The contract entered by Respondent-State of Jharkhand
with Petitioner is contrary to statutory mandate under Section
23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Further, the contract of
Petitioner stands frustrated in terms of Section 56 of the Indian
Contract Act due to event of impossibility of performance.
26. Under Clause 25 of the Agreement, being Clause 25(b)(i)
following events have also been treated as Force Majeure
events, namely:
(b) FORCE MAJEURE EVENT
Except as stated in Clause (a) above, Force Majeure event
means an event or circumstances or a combination of
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
events and circumstances referred to in this clause which
are beyond the reasonable control of the Party or Parties
to this Contract and which party could not have prevented
or reasonably overcome with the exercise of its reasonable
skill and care in relation to performance of its obligations
pursuant to this Contract and which are of the nature,
without limitation of those described below:
(i)Publicly declared strike by registered and
recognized association of Transporters
exceeding 7 days. The date of going on strike
and withdrawal or start of movement of
traffic will be inclusive for the purpose of
calculation of 7 days under this clause.
27. Strike was started from 02.01.2024 and continued till
27.01.2024 and due to said strike toll collection was materially
affected and Petitioner made Force Majeure claim of Rs.
42,83,090/28. In response to the said claim, Respondent-Executive
Engineer, vide Letter No. 137 dated 07.02.2025, directed the
Petitioner to submit proof of the fact that there was a strike
called by publicly recognized registered Association of
Transporters, so that its claim for Force Majeure can be
considered.
29. Petitioner produced letter of Jamshedpur Truck and Trailer
Owners Association, bearing No. 3839 certifying the fact that
there was strike by Transport Owners Association between the
period 02.01.2024 to 27.01.2024, but despite such letter being
produced, no decision was taken by Respondents.”
3.
On the above basis the petitioner has made the following claim:
1) Proportionate reduction of User Fee due to noninstallation of FASTag.
2) Claim under Clause 25(b)(i) due to Transporters strike
being an admitted Force Majeure event.
3) Treating the Petitioner as an Agent of Respondent-State
of Jharkhand after expiry of the period of contract i.e.
03.10.2025.
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
4) Refund of Bank Guarantee No. 014GTO2232440004
dated 01.02.2023.
4.
This Court vide order dated 06.12.2025 has formulated four
issues, which reads as under :
a. As per the agreement, who has to construct the toll
plaza, whether the authority or the contractor/the
petitioner?
b. Whether the petitioner can collect the toll from a
vehicle fitted with “Fastag”.
c. If the provision is not there for collection of the
Fastag, then who is at fault?
d. If the respondents are at fault, whether the
petitioner can be punished for that or not?
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent-State has submitted that
there is no provision for fitting equipment for collection of toll
through Fastag, so far as contract is concerned. The non-collection of
the amount due to the Fastag shall be determined by taking evidence
by the competent authority. In the absence of necessary evidence/
material on record, this amount cannot be ascertained by this Court.
6.
It has been further submitted that it is a contractual matter and
the Commercial Court is the proper forum.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of
the record it appears that:
i. Petitioner has been appointed as an agent for collection of toll/
user fee.
ii. The toll plaza has to be constructed by the department and not
by the agent/petitioner.
iii. As quoted hereinabove, the law has been declared that the
petitioner was not authorized to collect toll from the vehicle
fitted with Fastag rather it is admitted position that no
collection has been made from the vehicle fitted with the
Fastag.
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
2026:JHHC:121
iv. Thus, the non-collection of toll/user fee by the petitioner is due
to operation of law and for this the petitioner cannot be
penalized.
8.
In view of the above discussion, it is hereby declared that
petitioner has to be compensated for the non-collection of the user fee
by the vehicle fitted with Fastag. This required determination by the
authority.
9.
So far as transporter strike is concerned, that is also to be
compensated by the authority.
10.
In view of the above discussion, the matter is remitted back to
the respondent no. 3- Chief Engineer (Communication), Road
Construction Department for determination of the loss incurred due to
non-collection of the toll from the vehicle fitted with Fastag and also
for the transporter strike period.
11.
Needless to say, that the authorities are supposed to come out
with proper procedure i.e., by looking into the toll collection from the
near by plaza who was equipped to register the vehicle with Fastag.
The authorities are further free to put into service other parameters for
determination of the amount due to strike and non-collection of the
toll as no provision has been provided in the toll plaza.
12.
The above exercise must be completed within a period of 3
months from the date of production/ receipt of the copy of this order.
After determination of the amount the follow up action will be taken
by the authority including return of the bank guarantee.
13.
With the above observation and direction, the writ petition
stands disposed of.
(Rajesh Kumar, J.)
06.01.2026
A. Mohanty
Uploaded
____/____/2026
W.P.(C) No. 5863 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review