Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 09th January, 2026
Date of Decision :16th January, 2026
+
CM(M) 1762/2025, CM APPL. 57124/2025 & CM APPL.
70629/2025
VANITA BATHLA
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Kirti Uppal and Mr. Anurag
Ahluwalia, Senior Advocates with
Mr. Ankit Banati, Mr. Umang Tyagi,
Mr. Zuber Ali, Ms. Archisha
Satyarthi and Mr. Siddharth Sharma,
Advocates.
versus
SMT. SHASHI BAJAJ
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Roshan Santhalia, Ms. Kavya
Arora and Mr. Himanshu Kumar
Pathak, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA
ORDER
1.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner/defendant under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India assailing the order dated 07th August,
2025 (hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned Order”) passed by the trial
Court in CS (COMM) 364/2023, whereby the trial Court has rejected the
plea raised by the petitioner alleging the non-compliance of the mandatory
requirement of pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘the Act’)
before filing of the suit.
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
2.
Learned Senior Counsels on behalf the petitioner have argued that as
the respondent has failed to exhaust the mandatory remedy of pre-institution
mediation under Section 12A of the Act, and also that the suit does not
disclose any case of “urgent interim relief”, so the plaint is liable to be
rejected in accordance with law. The plaint in this respect is vague, nonspecific, and a mere eyewash intended to circumvent the mandatory
provisions of Section 12A of the Act. The application of the respondents
seeking exemption from pre-institution mediation is still pending which
shows that there is no “urgent interim relief” involved in the suit. It is further
argued that vide order dated 15th April, 2023, the plaint in the suit bearing
no. Civ DJ No. 159/2020 was returned on the ground that the dispute
constituted a commercial dispute and was, therefore, required to be instituted
before the Commercial Court and Consequently, pre-institution mediation
was mandatory before instituting the suit in the Commercial Court.
Per Contra, learned Counsel for the respondent has argued that the
trial Court has passed the impugned order after considering the material on
record. There is no illegality or infirmity in the impugned order. The
arguments of the petitioner are without any merit and the petition is liable to
be dismissed.
3.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties. Record perused.
4.
In brief, the case of the respondent/plaintiff as alleged in the plaint is
that they are the owners of the suit property i.e., Shop No. A-3/264, Eastern
Side, Ground Floor, admeasuring 750 sq. ft., situated at Paschim Vihar,
Delhi, which was jointly purchased by Ms. Shashi Bajaj and Smt. Neelam
Bajaj vide a sale deed dated 28th September, 2009. On the request of the
petitioner/defendant, the respondent/plaintiff vide rent agreement dated 15th
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
April, 2015, leased out the suit property to the petitioner for a period of nine
(09) years only, commencing from 1st May, 2015 till 30th April, 2024. As the
petitioner began committing defaults in payment of rent, so the respondent
in exercise of his rights as per Clause 5 of the rent agreement terminated the
tenancy of the petitioner vide a legal notice dated 08th January, 2020. To the
said notice the petitioner issued a frivolous reply fabricating a false story
that the respondent had executed an agreement to sell dated 07th March,
2015 in favour of the petitioner for a total consideration of Rs.60,00,000/(60 Lakhs). The petitioner has refused to vacate the suit property.
Thereafter, the respondent has filed the present suit claiming the relief of
possession of the suit property alongwith other reliefs.
4.1
Alongwith the plaint, the respondent has also filed an
application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the CPC, in which it is
prayed that ex-parte ad-interim injunction be granted to restrain the
petitioner from alienating the suit property, creating any third-party interest
and/or disposing of the suit property in any manner whatsoever till the
disposal of the present suit.
4.2
It is pertinent to note that the suit was initially instituted by the
respondent as an ordinary suit bearing no. Civ DJ No. 159/2020. In this suit
vide order dated 15th April, 2023, the plaint was returned to the respondent
under Order VII Rule 10 CPC to institute the same before the appropriate
forum.
4.3
Furthermore, during the pendency of the civil suit bearing no.
Civ DJ No. 159/2020 the trial Court referred this suit for mediation vide
order dated 05th April, 2022 and the parties have participated in mediation.
However, the mediation attempts eventually failed and the matter was
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
returned as ‘Not Settled’ vide mediation report dated 04th July, 2022.
5.
To support his argument that the interim relief as sought by the
respondent is not an “urgent interim relief”, the petitioner has placed reliance
on the judgment. of a co-ordinate bench of this Hon’ble Court in Exclusive
Capital Ltd. v. Clover Media Ltd. and Ors., 2025 SCC OnLine 5221, which
held as under:
“53. Thus, it is imperative that Courts remain vigilant
against attempts by unscrupulous litigants to abuse the
exemption under Section 12A by mechanically appending a
plea for urgent interim relief as a façade to circumvent the
statutory mandate of pre-institution mediation. Such
conduct erodes the sanctity of the legislative framework and
subverts the object of reducing the burden on Courts
through alternative dispute resolution mechanisms. The
prayer for urgent relief must be substantiated through
specific pleadings and demonstrable facts and cannot be
allowed to serve as a mere procedural ruse to escape
mandatory compliance. Courts must rigorously assess the
genuineness of the asserted urgency and reject suits where
the plea for interim relief is palpably contrived or
unsubstantiated. …
… 57. Section 12A of the Act fulfils this requirement by
instituting a mandatory pre-institution mediation
mechanism, which serves as a bypass and fast-track route
for resolving disputes without occupying judicial time at the
inception stage. The only exception to this route balances
the right to immediate judicial intervention in genuinely
urgent matters which may be proved by pleadings, cause of
action etc.
58. To sum up, in determining whether a suit contemplates
urgent interim relief, one pertinent consideration is whether
the failure to grant such relief would render the plaintiff's
application for injunction or the suit itself infructuous, or
would create an irreversible or unalterable situation,
thereby disabling the Court from restoring status quo ante
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
at the stage of adjudication of such application. This is one
of the determinative factors, among others, including: (i) the
origin and timeline of the cause of action, (ii) the timing and
manner of the plaintiff's approach to the Court, and (iii)
whether adherence to the pre-institution mediation
mechanism under Section 12A would operate to the
detriment or prejudice of the plaintiff.”
5.1
As noted above, the respondent has filed the suit for possession
of the suit property and an application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of
the CPC.
In the civil suit bearing no. Civ DJ No. 159/2020, the trial Court has
passed the order dated 12th November, 2021 on the application under Order
XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the CPC, which is reproduced as under:
“Plaintiff prays for application under Order 39 rule 1 and 2
CPC on which counsel for defendant submits that defendant
will not create any third party right in the suit property
bearing no. A-3/264, Eastern Side, Ground floor, Paschim
Vihar, New Delhi-110063.
Statement of counsel for defendant recorded in this
regard.
ln view of the statement, parties are directed to
maintain status quo regarding the suit property till further
directions of this court. Accordingly, application under
Order 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC stands disposed off. …”
5.2
In the present suit the trial Court vide order dated 25th
September, 2023 has passed the following interim order:
“Counsel for plaintiff has prayed for interim protection and
it is pointed out that before return of plaint by the Ld.
ADJ05/West/THC/Delhi, status quo order was passed on
12.11.2021.
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
I have perused the record. Considering the prayer
made in the plaint and in interim application moved by
plaintiff, it is ordered that status quo regarding the suit
property be maintained till further orders.”
5.3
Keeping in view the subject matter of the suit, nature of the
relief in the suit and the interim orders as stated above granted by both the
courts, this Court is of the view that the interim relief is an “urgent interim
relief” as failure to grant the interim relief would make the main relief of
possession as sought in the suit as infructuous and also leads to multiplicity
of litigation.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondent has relied upon the judgement of
this Court in Aaone Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. Sabita Jha and Ors., 2025 SCC
OnLine Del 42, to show that pre-institution mediation is not required as the
mediation has already taken place between the parties in the ordinary suit
prior to the return of the plaint for institution of the plaint in the Commercial
Court. In that judgement it has been held as under:
“26. Notably, when the suit was originally filed as an
ordinary suit, there was no occasion for the plaintiff to
resort to pre-institution mediation, as Section 12A of the Act
is not applicable to the ordinary suits. However, before the
conversion of suit to commercial suit on 22.03.2024, the
matter was referred to the mediation, therefore, the
mandatory requirement of pre-institution mediation stood
complied with, since the object of compulsory pre-institution
mediation is only to relieve the courts from avoidable
litigation in commercial matters and the mediation, as an
alternative dispute mechanism, has been identified as a
workable solution for the said purpose.
27. Thus, the mediation having been resorted to prior to the
conversion of ordinary suit to a commercial suit and that
too on a joint request of the parties, which ended in as "not
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
settled", it does not lie in the mouth of the defendants to seek
rejection of plaint and to burden the plaintiff to avail preinstitution mediation all over again and file a fresh suit
thereafter.”
This judgement is applicable to the facts of the present case as from
the record it is clear that mediation has taken place between the parties in the
suit Civ DJ No. 159/2020 at the request of the learned counsel for the parties
and which has ended in as “Not Settled”. Accordingly, the respondent
cannot be burdened again to avail pre-institution mediation all over again
and file a fresh suit thereafter.
7.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Judgement of Dhanbad fuels
Private Limited v. Union of India, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1129, has settled
the law relating to the scope of Section 12 A of the Act and has observed as
follows:
“71. In light of the aforesaid discussion, we summarise our
findings as under:
71.1. The decision of this Court in Patil Automation lays
down the correct position of law as regards Section 12-A of
the 2015 Act by holding it to be mandatory in nature.
71.2. As held in para 104 of the decision in Patil
Automation, the declaration of the mandatory nature of
Section 12-A of the 2015 Act relates back to the date of the
amending Act.
71.3. As held in para 113.1 of the decision in Patil
Automation, any suit which is instituted under the 2015 Act
without complying with Section 12-A is liable to be rejected
under Order 7 Rule 11. However, this declaration applies
prospectively to suits instituted on or after 20-8-2022.
71.4. A suit which contemplates an urgent interim relief may
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
be filed under the 2015 Act without first resorting to
mediation as prescribed under Section 12-A of the 2015 Act.
71.5. Unlike Section 80(2) CPC, leave of the court is not
required to be obtained before filing a suit without
complying with Section 12-A of the 2015 Act.
71.6. The test for “urgent interim relief” is if on an
examination of the nature and the subject-matter of the suit
and the cause of action, the prayer of urgent interim relief
by the plaintiff could be said to be contemplable when the
matter is seen from the standpoint of the plaintiff.
71.7. The Courts must also be wary of the fact that the
urgent interim relief must not be merely an unfounded
excuse by the plaintiff to bypass the mandatory requirement
of Section 12-A of the 2015 Act.
71 8. Even if the urgent interim relief ultimately comes to be
denied, the suit of the plaintiff may be proceeded with
without compliance with Section 12-A if the test for “urgent
interim relief” is satisfied notwithstanding the actual
outcome on merits.
71.9. Suits instituted without complying with Section 12-A of
the 2015 Act prior to 20-8-2022 cannot be rejected under
Order 7 Rule 11 on the ground of non-compliance with
Section 12-A unless they fall within the exceptions stipulated
in paras 113.2 and 113.3 of the decision in Patil
Automation.
71.10. In suits instituted without complying with Section 12A of the 2015 Act prior to 20-8-2022 which are pending
adjudication before the trial court, the court shall keep the
suit in abeyance and refer the parties to time-bound
mediation in accordance with Section 12-A of the 2015 Act
If an objection is raised by the defendant by filing an
application under Order 7 Rule 11, or in cases where any of
the parties expresses an intent to resolve the dispute by
mediation.”
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
As discussed above, the interim relief has been held to be “urgent
interim relief”, so in view of this judgement leave of the court is not required
to be obtained before filing a suit without complying with Section 12A of
the Act. Accordingly, the filing of the application for exemption from preinstitution mediation by the respondent is of no relevance and does not in
any way affect the institution of the suit in the Commercial Court without
compliance of Section 12A of the Act.
8.
In view of the foregoing discussions of facts and law, this Court does
not find any infirmity or illegality in the impugned order dated 07th August,
2025 and the same is upheld. Accordingly, the present petition stands
dismissed alongwith pending application(s), if any.
RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA
JUDGE
JANUARY 16, 2026/nd/isk
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
16:14:50
CM(M) 1762/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review