Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on : 22nd April 2026
Pronounced on : 26th May 2026
Uploaded on : 29th May 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 294/2018
VALISHA BEGUM & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Pankaj Gupta, Advocate.
versus
PAPPU & ORS (IFFCO TOKIO GENERAL INS CO LTD)
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. A.K. Soni, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
The present appeal is filed against the judgment dated 26 th
September 2017, passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT),
North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, in MACT No. 134/15, whereby
the Tribunal dismissed the claim petition filed under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (‘MV Act’) by the Legal Representatives (LRs)
of the deceased, holding that the negligence of the driver had not been
established. However, a sum of Rs. 50,000/- along with interest @ 9% per
annum from the date of filing of the claim petition was awarded under
Section 140 of the MV Act.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
1/14
The Incident
2.
The accident occurred on 25th June 2015 at about 3:00 PM, when
Mohd. Tahir was going towards Loni on his bicycle at a slow speed and
on the correct side of the road. When he reached near Loni, Ghaziabad, a
dumper truck bearing registration no. HR-63A-7784, driven in a rash and
negligent manner, came from behind and struck the bicycle with great
force. As a result, the bicycle fell onto the road, and the front wheel of the
truck ran over the head of the bicyclist, causing fatal injuries.
3.
The deceased was taken to Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital, Dilshad
Garden, Delhi, where he was declared ‘brought dead’. FIR No. 286/2015
was registered against the driver of the offending vehicle, and
subsequently, the driver was charge-sheeted by the police under Sections
279/304-A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
Impugned Award
4.
As regards the issue of negligence, the Tribunal considered the
testimony of PW-2/ Priyant Kumar, who deposed by way of evidence
affidavit Ex. PW-2/A that the truck came from the backside and hit the
bicycle with great force which resulted in the accident. PW-2 in his cross
examination deposed that deceased was going by his bicycle and offending
vehicle was going in the same direction ahead of deceased. He deposed
that he had seen the truck coming in rash and negligent manner in his rearview mirror. Tribunal noted the inconsistent testimony that if truck was
ahead of the bicycle then the question of said truck hitting the bicycle from
the backside does not arise.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
2/14
5.
Further, the Tribunal noted that the site plan prepared by police at
instance of PW-2 also does not support the claimant as it does not show
that the truck had hit the bicycle from behind. On the contrary the site plan
shows that the bicyclist had taken a right turn and for this reason he came
in front of the truck and thus the accident occurred. Tribunal held that
filing of chargesheet against the driver is immaterial as the claim of
negligence has to be established based on cogent evidence, negligence
cannot be presumed solely based on the chargesheet.
Submissions of Appellant
6.
Counsel for appellant/claimant submits that the involvement of the
offending vehicle is not in dispute and the only question which arises for
consideration is whether the offending vehicle was being driven in a rash
and negligent manner at the relevant time. It is contended that the site plan
clearly demonstrates that the offending truck had hit the claimant’s vehicle
from behind, which itself is indicative of negligence on the part of the
driver of the offending vehicle.
7.
It is further submitted that the testimony of PW-2, who is an
independent witness, fully supports the case of the claimant with regard to
the manner in which the accident had occurred. Reliance is also placed
upon the fact that neither the driver nor the owner of the offending vehicle
entered the witness box to rebut the allegations of negligence or to
controvert the testimony led on behalf of the claimant, thereby warranting
an adverse inference against them.
8.
Counsel for appellant further submits that the driver of the offending
vehicle has been charge-sheeted and criminal proceedings arising out of
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
3/14
the accident are pending against him. Reliance is placed upon the decision
of the Supreme Court in ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Rajani Sahoo 2025 INSC 6, wherein it was observed that negligence can
be determined on the basis of the police record available before the
Tribunal and consideration thereof is not inadmissible. Reliance is also
placed on the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Santosh v Ashish &
Anr., 2026:DHC:130 to contend that filing of a charge-sheet against the
driver and pendency of the criminal case are relevant circumstances which
ought to be taken into consideration while determining negligence.
Submissions of Respondent/ Insurance Company
9.
Counsel for respondent/Insurance Company, in support of finding
by the Tribunal that no negligence of driver is established, submits that a
perusal of the site plan would show that the offending truck was
proceeding on the correct side of the road and it was the bicyclist/deceased
who had suddenly taken a right turn, as a consequence whereof the
accident occurred. It is thus contended that the deceased was himself
responsible for the accident and liability cannot be fastened on the driver.
10.
It is further submitted that the testimony of PW-2 is not reliable and
suffers from material contradictions. Counsel for respondent/ Insurance
Company contends that while in his evidence by way of affidavit, PW-2
had deposed that the offending truck came from behind and hit the bicycle;
however, during his cross-examination, he stated that the offending
vehicle was proceeding ahead of the deceased in the same direction and
that he had seen the truck through his rear-view mirror. It is thus argued
that two inconsistent versions regarding the manner of the accident have
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
4/14
been put forth by PW-2, rendering his testimony unreliable for
establishing negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle.
Analysis
11.
The fundamental issue canvassed by appellant concerns the
MACT’s dismissal of the claim on the ground that no negligence on the
part of the driver of the offending vehicle had been established. In this
regard, what requires examination is the testimony of the witness, the
record of the criminal proceedings, the site plan, and any rebuttal evidence
offered by the driver and owner. Since PW-2 was an eyewitness, it would
be apposite to examine why his evidence was not considered credible by
the MACT. Priyant Kumar/PW-2 clearly stated in his affidavit by way of
examination-in-chief that the deceased was riding his bicycle opposite
Sambhav Motors, Loni, Ghaziabad, U.P., when the offending truck, being
driven at a high speed from the Delhi side, struck the bicycle with great
force. The vehicle ran over the head of the deceased, causing crush injuries
to which he succumbed.
12.
In his cross-examination, PW-2 stated that he was running a gym at
Loni, Ghaziabad, and was travelling from his home to Loni on a
motorcycle. He confirmed that both the deceased on the bicycle and the
offending vehicle were travelling in the same direction. However, his
testimony was recorded as “the alleged offending vehicle was also going
in the same direction ahead from the deceased.” This was interpreted by
the MACT as a contradiction, since if the offending vehicle was ahead of
the deceased, there could have been no collision.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
5/14
13.
Further, in his cross-examination, PW-2 stated that the deceased
came under the rear right-side wheel of the offending vehicle. He also
stated that he had not informed the police about the accident, but that the
police had arrived at the spot, recorded his statement, and prepared the site
plan at his instance. The site plan, therefore, requires consideration and is
extracted herein for reference:
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
6/14
14.
The single arrow depicts the movement of the bicycle, whereas the
double arrow depicts the movement of the truck. It is clear from the site
plan that both were travelling in the same direction, and the point of
collision is shown directly in front of the truck’s path.
15.
Counsel for the Insurance Company contended that the arrow
depicting the movement of the bicycle suggests that it was turning towards
the right and that the truck consequently collided with it.
Assessment of FIR and Site Plan
16.
A perusal of the FIR shows that it was registered at 5:30 p.m. on the
very same day, whereas the statement of PW-2 was recorded on spot.
17.
The FIR was registered at the instance of Shamim Ahmed, the uncle
of the deceased. His statement, as recorded in the FIR, states that the
deceased had left at around 3:00 o’clock on a bicycle to purchase
medicines from Loni when a truck coming from the Delhi side struck him
from behind and the front wheel crushed his head.
18.
Having assessed the testimony, the site plan, and the FIR, the
following possible situations emerge:
(i)
First, the eyewitness testimony may not have been credible,
since the witness allegedly saw the accident through his rearview mirror but nevertheless did not report the matter to the
police. The FIR was lodged at the instance of the deceased’s
uncle,
and
the
eyewitness
statement
was
recorded
subsequently.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
7/14
(ii) Second, the eyewitness testimony may indeed have been
credible and authentic, and he may have witnessed the truck
mowing down the cyclist through his rear-view mirror.
Although he did not report the incident to the police, his
statement was recorded and the site plan was prepared at his
instance. He also stated that he had appeared before the Court
at the instance of the elder brother of the deceased.
(iii) Third, there exists the straightforward possibility that the truck
struck the cyclist from behind, as a result of which the cyclist
came under the front wheel of the truck, which is consistent
with the FIR.
(iv) Fourth, it is possible that the cyclist and the truck were
travelling parallel to each other, with the cyclist on the left side
of the truck, and that the cyclist suddenly turned right at the
crossing. Consequently, the truck driver may not have been
able to stop the vehicle in time, resulting in the cyclist being
struck and run over, eventually coming under the rear wheel of
the truck, as stated by the witness.
19.
There are certain inconsistencies within these possible scenarios.
However, what is clear from the FIR is that the offending vehicle was
involved in the accident, since the driver fled from the spot and the truck
was subsequently seized from the place of occurrence
20.
A reading of the FIR, which was registered immediately after the
accident, makes it evident that Priyant Kumar was present at the relevant
time and had stated that he had witnessed the accident. On the basis of the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
8/14
FIR and applying the standard of preponderance of probabilities, the
occurrence of the accident cannot be easily displaced. Considering that the
testimony of PW-2 was recorded nearly one and a half years later, minor
inaccuracies in the recording of his evidence cannot be ruled out. While
the FIR states that the deceased was crushed under the front side of the
truck, the testimony of PW-2 records that he came under the rear rightside wheel of the vehicle.
21.
There may also have been some confusion regarding the meaning
of “agla pahiya/अगला पहिया” as mentioned in the FIR. In any event, it
stands established that an accident involving the truck did occur, since the
truck driver fled the scene and the vehicle was seized. On the standard of
preponderance of probabilities, negligence on the part of the truck driver
in mowing down the cyclist must therefore be inferred.
22.
A bicycle is a slow-moving vehicle, whereas a truck is a large and
heavy vehicle. Consequently, the truck driver, in all circumstances, is
expected to maintain proper control over the vehicle so that even if there
is any wayward cyclist, the truck driver is able to avoid mowing the cyclist
down by keeping the vehicle under effective control.
23.
As regards the issue of negligence, reliance can also be placed on
the judgment of Supreme Court in Ranjeet v. Abdul Kayam Neb, 2025
SCC OnLine SC 497, wherein the Supreme Court noted as under:
“4. It is settled in law that once a charge sheet has been
filed and the driver has been held negligent, no further
evidence is required to prove that the bus was being
negligently driven by the bus driver. Even if the
eyewitnesses are not examined, that will not be fatal to
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
9/14
prove the death of the deceased due to negligence of the
bus driver.
5. In view of the aforesaid facts, we are of the opinion
that the Tribunal and the High Court both manifestly
erred in law in refusing to grant any compensation to
the claimants.”
(emphasis added)
24.
Considering that in this case both FIR and chargesheet have been
filed itself is proof of negligence of the driver.
Contributory Negligence
25.
The only remaining issue is whether contributory negligence can be
attributed to the cyclist, who may possibly have turned right in front of the
truck, as reflected in the site plan and as vehemently contended by Mr.
A.K. Soni, counsel for the Insurance Company.
26.
Since the site plan was prepared at the instance of the eyewitness,
whose testimony this Court finds credible, the aspect of contributory
negligence would necessarily have to be taken into account.
27.
It is possible that the cyclist was legitimately turning right and that
the truck driver either failed to notice him or was unable to control the
vehicle in time. Equally, it is possible that the cyclist turned right without
ensuring that there was no oncoming traffic proceeding straight ahead,
including the truck.
28.
In either event, compensation ought to be awarded to appellants,
who are the Legal Representatives (LRs) of the deceased, subject to
deduction on account of contributory negligence.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
10/14
29.
Contributory negligence, in tort law, contemplates a situation where
a person’s own negligence has materially contributed to the harm suffered,
thereby warranting apportionment of liability to the extent of such
negligence. The Supreme Court in Municipal Corporation of Greater
Bombay v. Laxman Iyer, 2003 (8) SCC 731, explained the term
‘negligence’, ‘composite negligence’ and ‘contributory negligence’. For
ease of reference relevant paragraph is extracted as under:
“6. The plea which was stressed strenuously related to
alleged contributory negligence. Though there is no
statutory definition, in common parlance “negligence”
is categorised as either composite or contributory. It is
first necessary to find out what is a negligent act.
Negligence is omission of duty caused either by an
omission to do something which a reasonable man
guided upon those considerations, who ordinarily by
reason of conduct of human affairs would do or be
obligated to, or by doing something which a prudent or
reasonable man would not do. Negligence does not
always mean absolute carelessness, but want of such a
degree of care as is required in particular
circumstances. Negligence is failure to observe, for the
protection of the interests of another person, the degree
of care, precaution and vigilance which the
circumstances justly demand, whereby such other
person suffers injury. The idea of negligence and duty
are strictly correlative. Negligence means either
subjectively a careless state of mind, or objectively
careless conduct. Negligence is not an absolute term,
but is a relative one; it is rather a comparative term. No
absolute standard can be fixed and no mathematically
exact formula can be laid down by which negligence or
lack of it can be infallibly measured in a given case.
What constitutes negligence varies under different
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
11/14
conditions and in determining whether negligence exists
in a particular case, or whether a mere act or course of
conduct amounts to negligence, all the attending and
surrounding facts and circumstances have to be taken
into account. It is absence of care according to
circumstances. To determine whether an act would be
or would not be negligent, it is relevant to determine if
any reasonable man would foresee that the act would
cause damage or not. The omission to do what the law
obligates or even the failure to do anything in a manner,
mode or method envisaged by law would equally and
per se constitute negligence on the part of such person.
If the answer is in the affirmative, it is a negligent act.
Where an accident is due to negligence of both parties,
substantially there would be contributory negligence
and both would be blamed. In a case of contributory
negligence, the crucial question on which liability
depends would be whether either party could, by
exercise of reasonable care, have avoided the
consequence of the other's negligence. Whichever party
could have avoided the consequence of the other's
negligence would be liable for the accident. If a person's
negligent act or omission was the proximate and
immediate cause of death, the fact that the person
suffering injury was himself negligent and also
contributed to the accident or other circumstances by
which the injury was caused would not afford a defence
to the other. Contributory negligence is applicable
solely to the conduct of a plaintiff. It means that there
has been an act or omission on the part of the plaintiff
which has materially contributed to the damage, the act
or omission being of such a nature that it may properly
be described as negligence, although negligence is not
given its usual meaning. (See Charlesworth on
Negligence, 3rd Edn., para 328.) It is now well settled
that in the case of contributory negligence, courts have
the power to apportion the loss between the parties as
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
12/14
seems just and equitable. Apportionment in that context
means that damage is reduced to such an extent as the
court thinks just and equitable having regard to the
claim shared in the responsibility for the damage. But in
a case where there has been no contributory negligence
on the part of the victim, the question of apportionment
does not arise. Where a person is injured without any
negligence on his part but as a result of the combined
effect of the negligence of two other persons, it is not a
case of contributory negligence in that sense. It is a case
of what has been styled by Pollock as injury by
composite negligence. (See Pollock on Torts, 15th Edn.,
p. 361.)”
(emphasis added)
30.
In view of the above, although the primary negligence rests upon
the driver of the offending truck, who was under a greater duty to maintain
control over a heavy vehicle, the conduct of the deceased cyclist also
contributed to the occurrence of the accident. The site plan indicates that
the cyclist may have turned right at the crossing immediately before the
collision without ensuring safe passage. Thus, on the standard of
preponderance of probabilities, the deceased is also liable to be attributed
contributory negligence to a limited extent. However, considering the
nature of the offending vehicle and the higher duty of care cast upon its
driver, the contributory negligence of the deceased is assessed at 20%.
31.
The only issue that survives for consideration pertains to the
computation of compensation. Considering that the accident occurred in
the year 2015 and the impugned award was passed in 2017, more than a
decade has lapsed since the death of the deceased. In the facts and
circumstances of the case, this Court deems it appropriate to remand the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
13/14
matter to the MACT for fresh consideration on the aspect of computation
of compensation in accordance with the settled principles of law. The
MACT shall endeavour to decide the said issue within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of this order, on the basis of existing
evidence on record. Only if considered absolutely necessary, the MACT
will requisition any additional evidence.
32.
Accordingly, list the matter before the concerned MACT on 10th
June 2026 for further directions.
33.
The appeals stand disposed of with above directions.
34.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
35.
Copy of this judgement be sent to concerned MACT.
36.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
MAY 26, 2026/mk/zb
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
14:53:30
MAC.APP. 294/2018
14/14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review