Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Judgment reserved on
Judgment pronounced on
Judgment uploaded on
16.03.2026
17.04.2026
22.04.2026
APHC010641982025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3328]
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
WRIT PETITION NO: 33200 OF 2025
Between:
1. VAKKALAGADDA RAMYA SWATHI, W/O. SURESH KUMAR, AGED
ABOUT 39 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.6/19, NAIDU STREET, MARKAPUR,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
2. NALI CHINNA KONDAIAH,, S/O. PITCHAIAH, AGED ABOUT 46
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.10-1057-A,
NAGULAVARAM ROAD,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT 3. BUSSETTY NAGESWARA
RAO, S/O. CHENCHAIAH, AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.6298, VADDE BAZAR, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
3. BUSSETTY NAGESWARA RAO,, S/O. CHENCHAIAH,
AGED
ABOUT 61 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.6-298, VADDE BAZAR, MARKAPUR,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
4. SHAIK CHINNA SHAKSHAVALI,, S/O. MAHABOOB SAHEB AGED
ABOUT 56 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.10-1027-1, NAGULAVARAM ROAD,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
5. MARAM REDDY PUSHPALATHA,, W/O. RAMAKRISHNA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.8/129/A, EAST STREET,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
6. DODDA BHAGYALAKSHMI, W/O. NAGI REDDY, AGED ABOUT 54
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.2-99, GORLAGADDA STREET, MARKAPUR,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
7. SHAIK ISMAIL,, S/O. HABIBULLAH, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/O.
D.NO.1-203-D-99E, APSEB COLONY, OPP GEORGE PHARMACY
COLLEGE, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
8. KASSETTY NAGESH KUMAR, S/O. LAKSHMI KONDAIAH, AGED
ABOUT 51 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.7/325-22,
PERAM STREET,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
9. DUDEKULA KARIMULLA,, S/O. NAGURVALI, AGED ABOUT 36
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.10-203-Z-77-10A,
NEAR POWER OFFICE,
THARLUPADU ROAD, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
10. YALAKAPATI HARSHITHA,, D/O. POLAIAH, AGED ABOUT 32
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.1-224,
A.B.M. COMPOUND, MARKAPUR,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
11. KOTTE RAMA LAKSHAMMA,, W/O. VENKATESWARLU, AGED
ABOUT 72 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.7/664-A,
SIVAJI NAGAR,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
12. TARIYAKULA RANGALAKSHAMMA,, W/O. RAVI KUMAR, AGED
ABOUT 36 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.1-216-D-3,
WARD NO.1,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
13. SHAIK PHATHIMA,, W/O. SHAKSHAVALI,
AGED ABOUT 40
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.1-203-C-7B,
POOLASUBBAIAH COLONY,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
14. DUGGEMPUDI JYOTHI,, W/O. YAILAREDDY, AGED ABOUT 28
YEARS, R/O. OBULAKKAPALLE,
PEDDARAVEEDU MANDAL,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
15. BURRI YALLAMMA,, W/O. KATAMAIAH, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/C. D.NO.1-250-1-A2
CHENNARAYUNIPALLE, KETHAGUDIPI
VILLAGE, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
16. SHAIK KUSHEED,, W/O. HABIBULLA, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
R/O. D.NO. 10-761
VIJAYA TALKIES ROAD, MARKAPUR,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
17. SRIRAM SUNKAIAH,, S/O. NAGAIAH, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
R/O. D.NO.1-203-A-30D SC BC COLONY, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT
18. SHAIK NASAR VALI,, S/O. MAHAMMAD BASHA, AGED ABOUT 37
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.10-705L,
ONTEDDU BANDI COLONY,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
19. SHAIK KARIMUN,, W/O. SHAIK MOHEED, AGED ABOUT 31
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.10-936-A,
NAGULAVARAM ROAD, NEAR
JAGADEESWARI HALL, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
20. KOLA BHAVANI,, D/O. VENKATESWARLU, AGED ABOUT 29
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.1-203-D-33-A-1, BAPUJI COLONY, MARKAPUR,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT
21. PINNIKA ADILAKSHMI,, W/O. MALLIKHARJUNA, AGED ABOUT 42
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.515-Y-5-D, ESTATE, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT
22. YAMMANI NAGA ARUNA, , W/O. ANJANEYULU, AGED ABOUT 38
YEARS, R/O. D.NO.10-739-A,
VIJAYA TALKIES ROAD,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
23. AMBADIPUDI BALA CHENNAMMA,, W/O. VENKATESWARLU
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, R/O. D.N0.1-337-Q-2, MATAM COLONY,
RAILWAY STATION ROAD, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY,
MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT,
A.P. SECRETARIAT AT
VELAGAPUDI, AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT
2. THE COLLECTOR AND DISTRICT MAGISTRATE, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT AT ONGOLE
3. THE DISTRICT REVENUE OFFICER, ONGOLE AND PRESIDING
OFFICER FOR CONDUCIING THE MEETING OF
MUNICIPAL
COUNCIL ON NO-CONFIDENCE MOTION, ONGOLE, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT
4. THE MARKAPUR MUNICIPALITY, REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER,
MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
5. CHERLAMCHERLA
BALA
MURALI
KRISHNA,
S/O.
CH.
CHENCHAIAH, AGED 56 YEARS, CHAIRPERSON, MARKAPUR
MUNICIPALITY, MARKAPUR, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, order or direction mostly one
which is in the nature of a Writ of Mandamus declaring the Memo
No.2878186/G/202 5, dt 24.11.2025 of the 1st Respondent as illegal,
irregular, arbitrary, unreasonable, unfair, unjustified and unsustainable and
consequently direct the 1st Respondent to forthwith issue the Notification for
removal of the Chairperson from the office of the 4th Respondent Municipality
and to fill up the resultant vacancy in the same manner as a casual vacancy
and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to suspend the operation of Memo No.2878186/G/2025,
dt.24.11.2025 of the 1st Respondent and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. VARREY VENKATA NAGA VISHNU TEJA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR REVENUE
2. Gudapati Lakshminarayana SC For Municipalities in Rayalaseema
Region
3. SRI VIJAY MATHUKUMILLI
4. GP MUNCIPAL ADMN AND URBAN DEV AP
The Court made the following ORDER:
Heard Sri P. Veera Reddy, learned Senior Counsel representing Sri V.
Venkata Naga Vishnu Teja, learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners, Sri A.
Sreekanth Reddy, learned Government Pleader for Respondent No.1, Sri B.
Ramesh, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Respondent Nos.2 & 3,
Sri G. Lakshmi Narayana, learned Standing Counsel for Respondent No.4 and
Ms. Gandham Papa Kusuma, learned Counsel representing Sri Vijay
Mathukumilli, learned Counsel for Respondent No.5.
2.
The Prayer sought in the present Writ Petition is as under:
“For the reasons stated above, it is prayed that this
Hon‟ble Court may be pleased to issue an appropriate Writ,
order or direction mostly one which is in the nature of a Writ
of Mandamus declaring the Memo No.2878186/G/2025, dt
24.11.2025 of the 1st Respondent as illegal, irregular,
arbitrary,
unreasonable,
unfair,
unjustified
and
unsustainable and consequently direct the 1st Respondent
to forthwith issue the Notification for removal of the
Chairperson from the office of
the 4th Respondent
Municipality and to fill up the resultant vacancy in the same
manner as a casual vacancy and pass such other order or
orders as this Hon‟ble Court may deem fit and proper in the
circumstances of the case.”
FACTS AS PROJECTED BY THE WRIT PETITIONERS:
3.
The facts as projected by the Writ Petitioners (23 in number) are that
about 23 Ward Members of Markapur Municipality (Respondent No.4) have
submitted Form-I (Ex.P.2) by expressing „No-confidence‟ against the
Chairperson, Markapur Municipal Council (the Council), on 12.05.2025
(Ex.P.2); that, on verifying the signatures of the Signatories in Form-I and
having been satisfied about the genuineness, Form-II was issued by
Respondent No.2 to all the Members of the Council on 22.05.2025 proposing
to convene a Council Meeting at 11:00 a.m. on 11.06.2025 in the Office of the
Markapur Municipality (Respondent No.4); that, in this process, the Collector
and District Magistrate, Prakasam District (Respondent No.2), had nominated
the District Revenue Officer, Ongole (Respondent No.3), as the Presiding
Officer to conduct the Meeting of the Municipal Council in accordance with the
Andhra Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1965 (Act, 1965) and the Andhra Pradesh
Municipalities (Motion of No-confidence in Chairperson/Vice-Chairperson)
Rules, 2008; and that, on the scheduled date, i.e., on 11.06.2025, as there
was no sufficient Quorum at 11:00 a.m., the Meeting was adjourned to 3:30
p.m. and was held on the same day as there was sufficient quorum (with 24
members), namely two-thirds of all the members entitled to vote.
4.
It is the case of the Petitioners herein that there are 35 wards in
Markapur Municipality and therefore the Council consists of 35 Ward
Members and one Ex-officio Member (local MLA), thereby totaling to 36
Members who are eligible to vote; that it is stated that one of the Ward
Members died and therefore the total number of Members eligible to vote are
35 members (i.e., 34 Ward Members and one Ex-officio Member); that 24
Members have attended the Meeting at 3:30 p.m., including the MLA of
Markapur Constituency as Ex-officio Member; that the required quorum in
terms of the Statute is 23; that, when the voting was conducted by
Respondent No.3, instructing the Councillors to raise their hands in support of
the No-confidence Motion, 19 Members have raised their hands, including the
Ex-officio Member in favour of the Motion; and that, out of the total 24
Members who attended the Meeting on 11.06.2025, 5 Members, though
physically present in the Meeting, did not raise their hands either in favour of
or against the No-confidence Motion.
Therefore, the Presiding Officer
(Respondent No.3) had declared that 5 members have abstained from voting.
5.
The facts would further indicate that the Presiding Officer/Respondent
No.3, after counting the number of persons who raised their hands in favour of
the motion, had issued Proceedings to the effect that “Motion of Noconfidence against Sri Chirlamcharla Balamurali Krishna Rao, Chairperson,
Municipal Council, Markapur Municipality, is passed”; that the Presiding
Officer, vide letter dated 11.06.2025 (Ex.P.3), addressed a letter to the District
Collector (Respondent No.2) along with the material papers and conveyed to
the effect that: “Hence, the No-confidence Motion on the Chairperson is
approved as per voting”; and that Respondent No.2, in turn, addressed a letter
on the same day, i.e., on 11.06.2025 (Ex.P.4), to the Principal Secretary,
Municipal Administration and Urban Development (Respondent No.1), to the
same effect.
6.
It is further submitted that, since Respondent No.1, who is endowed
with Statutory Functions under Section 46(6) of the Act, 1965, had not issued
any Proceedings, some of the Members who participated in the No-confidence
Motion approached this Court seeking a direction to Respondent No.1 by filing
W.P. No.30459 of 2025; that this Court, vide Order dated 12.11.2025, directed
Respondent No.1 to comply with the mandatory requirement under Section
46(6) of the Act, 1965, preferably within a period of two weeks from the date of
receipt of a copy of the Order; and that, even before the receipt of copy of the
Order, the Respondent No.1 issued the Impugned Memo No.2878186/G/2025
dated 24.11.2025 (Ex.P.1), holding that the No-confidence Motion moved
against the Chairperson of the Markapur Municipal Council on 11.06.2025
does not follow the mandatory criteria under Section 46(6) of the Act, 1965
and therefore the Motion is deemed invalid.
7.
This Proceeding of Respondent No.1 dated 24.11.2025 (Ex.P.1),
bearing Memo No.2878186/G/2025, is challenged by 23 Ward Members,
which include Members who were present during the time of voting and have
raised their hands in favour of the No-confidence Motion, and also those who
had abstained from voting.
CONTENTIONS OF THE WRIT PETITIONERS:
8.
Sri P. Veera Reddy, learned Senior Counsel representing Sri V.
Venkata Naga Vishnu Teja, learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners, has
placed reliance on the Provisions of the Statute and the Rules and would
submit that Respondent No.1 has clearly misunderstood as to what
constitutes “two-thirds majority of the total number of the members
including the ex-officio members as on the date of the meeting”. He had
justified the action of Respondent No.3 in declaring that the No-confidence
Motion has been passed against the Chairperson of the Markapur Municipal
Council. He would submit that the Presiding Officer is required to treat the
Members present in the Meeting for the purpose of constituting two-thirds of
the Members present in the Meeting, and not two-thirds of the total number of
Members of the Council entitled to vote as on the date of the Meeting. He
would also submit that even the Members, who have not raised their hands
shall also be included as part of the two-thirds Members, in view of the fact
that they were the Signatories in Form-I and also in view of the fact that the
present Writ Petition has been filed by such Members in addition to the
Members who have raised their hands. He would also submit that when once
the Presiding Officer had issued Proceedings to the effect that the Motion of
No-confidence has been passed against the Chairperson, the role of the
Government under Section 46 (6) of the Act, 1965 is only „ministerial‟ in nature
because the said Sub-section (6) of Section 46 of the Act, 1965 states that if
the Motion is carried, “the Government shall, by notification, remove the
Chairperson or Vice-Chairperson”, as the case may be, from the Office, and
the resultant vacancy shall be filled in the same manner as a casual vacancy.
9.
By placing reliance on the word “shall,” in sub-section (6) of Section 46
of the Act, 1965 the learned Senior Counsel would submit that the act of the
Government is reduced to a „ministerial function‟ and that the Principal
Secretary does not have the Jurisdiction to re-examine the legality or
otherwise of the Proceedings issued by the Presiding Officer (the District
Revenue Officer), which stood affirmed by the District Collector.
10.
Sri P. Veera Reddy, learned Senior Counsel for the Writ Petitioners has
placed reliance on two judgments. He has relied on the Order passed by the
learned Single Judge of the High Court of Telangana in Para Nos.25 & 41 in
Jakka Venkat Reddy vs. The State of Telangana and Others : in I.A. No.1
of 2024 in W.P. No.21205 of 2024 dated 08.08.2024, wherein the learned
Single Judge had held that only two-thirds of the such Members present in a
validly constituted Meeting is required to pass the motion.
“25. Before adverting to respective contentions, the
provisions and Rules relevant for consideration of the
issue are –
Section 37 of the Act, reading as :
“37. A motion expressing want of confidence in the
Chairperson and/or the Vice-Chairperson may be
made by giving a written notice of intention to move
the motion, in such form as specified under the
Rules, signed by not less than one-half of the total
number of members of the Municipality having right
to vote, together with a copy of the proposed motion,
to the District Collector concerned, in accordance
with the procedure prescribed under the Rules:
Provided that no notice of motion under this section
shall be made within three (3) years of the date of
assumption of office by the person against whom the
motion is sought to be moved:
Provided further that if the motion is not carried by
two thirds majority or if the meeting could not be held
for want of a quorum, no notice of any subsequent
motion expressing want of confidence in the same
person shall be made until after the expiration of one
year from the date of such first meeting.
Rule 3 :
3. A motion expressing want of confidence in the
Chairperson or Vice-Chairperson may be made by
giving a written notice of intention to mover the
motion in Form-I duly signed by not less than onehalf of the total number of members of the Municipal
Council having right to vote together with a copy of
the proposed motion to the District Collector
concerned.”
Rule 10 :
10. (1). A meeting convened for the purpose of
considering a motion under these rules shall not be
adjourned for any reason.
(2). The quorum for such meeting shall be two
thirds of the total number of members.
(3). If within half an hour after the time appointed
for the meeting, there is no quorum, the Presiding
Officer shall adjourn the meeting to some other time
on the same day and notify the same in the notice
board of the Council. If there is no quorum at the
adjourned time also, the meeting shall stand
dissolved and notice given under Rule 3 shall lapse.
(4). As soon as a meeting convened under the
said rule commences the Presiding Officer shall read
to the members present in the meeting, the motion
for the consideration of which the meeting has been
convened and shall put it to vote without any debate.
Rule 11 :
11. When the Motion of No Confidence is put to vote,
the Presiding Officer shall first ask the members to
raise hands who vote for the motion and record their
names with party affiliation in the minutes book.
Similarly, the Presiding Officer shall ask the
remaining members to raise their hands who vote
against the motion and record their names with party
affiliation in the minutes book.
The names of
members who abstain from voting with their party
affiliation shall also be recorded in the minutes book.
The result of the voting shall be recorded in the
minutes book.
41. So far as, the submission of the counsel for the
petitioner that for a meeting to be convened and a
resolution to be passed therein the required quorum was
two thirds of the total number of members is concerned, it
is of consequence to note that this Court in Chella Naga
Bhushanam and another Vs. The State of Telangana,
rep.
by
its
Principal
Secretary
Municipal
Administration and Urban Development Department
Secretariat building Hyderabad while examining the
said issue held that while 2/3rd majority of the total
members is required to constitute sufficient quorum, it is
only two thirds of such members present in such validly
constituted meeting is required to pass the motion. The
aforesaid finding of this Court had attained finality as no
appeal was preferred against the order in Chella Naga
Bhushanam ( supra). Further, the same would be amply
clear having regard to the language used in the second
proviso of Section 37 of the Act read with the Rules,
wherein the word „total‟ was prefixed at places whenever
the same was required, as compared to the omission of
the word „total‟ in other places.”
11.
He has also relied on the judgment of the Constitution Bench of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Para Nos.28 & 29 in State of U.P. and Others vs.
Babu Ram Upadhya (1960 SCC OnLine SC 5 : (1961) 2 SCR 679), to the
effect that when the word “shall” is used in a statute, the Authority is denuded
of the discretionary power and the function of the Authority is merely reduced
to a ministerial functioning.
28. The question is whether Rule I of para 486 is directory.
The relevant rule says that the police officer shall be tried
in the first place under Chapter XIV of the Criminal
Procedure Code. The word "shall" in its ordinary import is
"obligatory”; but there are many decisions wherein the
courts under different situations construed the word to
mean "may". This Court in Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Syed
Ahmad Ishaque dealt with this problem at p. 1125 thus
"It is well established that an enactment in form
mandatory might in substance be directory and that the
use of the word 'shall does not conclude the matter."
It is then observed:
"They (the rules) are well-known, and there is no need
to repeat them. But they are all of them only aids for
ascertaining the true intention of the legislature which is
the determining factor, and that must ultimately depend on
the context."
The following quotation from Crowford on the
Construction of Statutes, at p. 516, is also helpful in this
connection:
"The question as to whether a statute is mandatory or
directory depends upon the intent of the legislature and
not upon the language in which the intent is clothed. The
meaning and intention of the legislature must govern, and
these are to be ascertained, not only from the phraseology
of the provision, but also by considering its nature, its
design, and the consequences which would follow from
construing it the one way or the other...”
This passage was approved by this Court in State of U.P.
v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava. In Craies on Statute
Law, 5th Edn, the following passage appears at p. 242:
"No universal rule can be laid down as to whether
mandatory enactments shall be considered directory only
or obligatory with an implied nulliflication for disobedience.
It is the duty of courts of justice to try to get at the real
intention of the Legislature by carefully attending to the
whole scope of the statute to be construed."
A valuable guide for ascertaining the intention of the
Legislature is found in Maxwell on the Interpretation of
Statutes, 10th Edn., at p. 381 and it is:
"On the other hand, where the prescriptions of a
statute relate to the performance of a public duty and
where the invalidation of acts done in neglect of them
would work serious general inconvenience or injustice to
persons who have no control over those entrusted with the
duty without promoting the essential aims of the
legislature, such prescriptions seem to be generally
understood as mere instructions for the guidance and
government of those on whom the duty is imposed, or, in
other words, as directory only. The neglect of them may
be penal, indeed, but it does not affect the validity of the
act done in disregard of them."
This passage was accepted by the Judicial Committee of
the Privy Council in the case of Montreal Street Railway
Company v. Normandin and by this Court in State of
LLP. v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava.
29. The relevant rules of interpretation may be briefly
stated thus: When a statute uses the word "shall", prima
facie, it is mandatory, but the Court may ascertain the real
intention of the legislature by carefully attending to the
whole scope of the statute. For ascertaining the real
intention of the Legislature the Court may consider, inter
alia, the nature and the design of the statute, and the
consequences which would follow from construing it the
one way or the other, the impact of other provisions
whereby the necessity of complying with the provisions in
question is avoided, the circumstance, namely, that the
statute provides for a contingency of the non-compliance
with the provisions, the fact that the non-compliance with
the provisions is or is not visited by some penalty, the
serious or trivial consequences that flow therefrom, and,
above all, whether the object of the legislation will be
defeated or furthered.”
CONTENTIONS OF RESPONDENTS:
12.
Respondent No.1 filed Counter-Affidavit on 16.12.2025. Respondent
No.4 filed Counter-Affidavit on 02.02.2026. Despite several opportunities
granted for filing Counter-Affidavit, Respondent No.5 (namely the Chairperson
of the Council) had not filed the Counter-Affidavit by February, and when the
matter was listed for hearing on 24.02.2026, the request of the learned
Counsel representing Unofficial Respondent No.5 seeking further time was
turned down by this Court. Although the Counter-Affidavit of Respondent No.4
is not of much significance, the Counter-Affidavit filed by the Principal
Secretary, Municipal Administration and Urban Development (Respondent
No.1) is the one, which is of significance and would be discussed henceforth.
13.
Along with the Counter-Affidavit of Respondent No.1, certain Official
Proceedings originating from Respondent No.3 (Ex.P.3) and Respondent No.2
to Respondent No.1 (Ex.P.4) have also been placed on record. The said
Counter-Affidavit of Respondent No.1 states that Respondent No.3 has
completely misread the Statutory Provisions, particularly Section 46 of the Act,
1965. It is stated that Respondent No.3 fell into error in understanding as to
what constitutes „Quorum‟ and how many votes are required for passing the
Motion successfully. It is stated in the Counter-Affidavit that reliance placed by
Respondent No.3 on the Judgment rendered by the Hon‟ble High Court of
Telangana in W.P.No.2878 of 2024 and in I.A.No.1 of 2024 in W.P.No.21205
of 2024 are also misplaced.
14.
Sri A. Sreekanth Reddy, learned Government Pleader for Respondent
No.1 has placed reliance on the 2nd Proviso of Section 46 (1). He has also
placed reliance on Section 46 (6) and Explanation-I. The learned Government
Pleader would sustain the Order passed by Respondent No.1 and would
submit that Respondent No.3 has wrongly declared that the motion against
No-confidence had been passed by the Respondent No.3 only by misreading
of the Provisions of Section 46 of the Act 1965. He would also submit that the
word “shall” occurring in Section 46(6) does not reduce the function of
Principal Secretary to a Ministerial one but the Government is statutorily
obligated to see whether the Presiding Officer had approved the Motion that is
passed is in accordance with the Statute or not. He would submit that the
intent of the legislature as regards the role of the Government is not merely
„mechanical‟, but at the highest level, the Government is expected to consider
the legality or otherwise of the acts of the executive i.e., the Presiding Officer
(Respondent No.3) and the District Collector (Respondent No.2). He would
therefore submit that Respondent No.1 has merely corrected the illegality that
was committed by Respondent No.3, as confirmed by Respondent No.2. He
would also submit that it is clear from the facts that Respondent No.3 has
misunderstood as to what constitutes two-thirds majority.
STATUTORY PROVISIONS:
15.
The relevant Provisions under the Andhra Pradesh Municipalities Act,
1965 and the relevant Rules are usefully extracted hereunder:
“Section 46: Motion of no confidence in Chairperson/
Vice-Chairperson:
(1) A motion expressing want of confidence in the
Chairperson otherwise than directly elected or ViceChairperson may be made by giving a written notice of
intention to move the motion, in such form as may be
specified by the Government, signed not less than one
half of the total number of members of the Council having
right to vote, together with a copy of the proposed motion
to the District Collector concerned in accordance with the
procedure prescribed:
Provided that no notice of motion under this section
shall be made within three (3) years of the date of
assumption of office by the person against whom the
motion is sought to be moved;
Provided further that if the motion is not carried by
two-thirds majority as prescribed or if the meeting could
not be held for want of a quorum, no notice of any
subsequent motion expressing want of confidence in
the same person shall be made until after the
expiration of one year from the date of such first
meeting;
Provided also that the membership of a suspended
member shall also be taken into consideration for
computing the total number of members and he shall also
be entitled to vote in a meeting held under this section.
(2) The District Collector shall, then convene a
meeting for the consideration of the motion at the office of
Municipal Council on the date appointed by him which
shall not be later than thirty days from the date on which
the notice under sub-section (1) was delivered to him. He
shall give to the members, Chairperson or ViceChairperson as the case may be and the Ex-Officio
Members, notice of not less than fifteen clear days
excluding the date of the notice and the date of the
proposed meeting of such meeting in such form as may
be prescribed by the Government and such notice shall be
delivered as may be specified.
Explanation:- In computing the period of thirty days
specified in this sub-section, the period during which a
stay order, if any, issued by a competent Court on a
petition filed against a notice under sub-section (1) is in
force shall be excluded.
(3) The District Collector or the Revenue Divisional
Officer nominated by the District Collector (hereinafter
referred to as presiding officer) shall preside at such
meeting. The quorum for such meeting shall be two-
thirds of the total number of members. If within half an
hour after the time appointed for the meeting, there is no
quorum for the meeting, the Presiding Officer shall adjourn
the meeting to some other time on the same date and
notify the same in the notice board of the Council. If there
is no quorum at the adjourned time of the same day, no
further meeting shall be convened for consideration of that
motion and the meeting shall stand dissolved and the
notice given under subsection (1) shall lapse.
(4) As soon as the meeting convened under this
section commences, the said presiding officer shall read
only the motion for the consideration of which the meeting
has been convened and shall put it to vote without any
debate. The voting shall be by show of hands duly
obeying the party whip given by such functionary of
the recognised political party in the manner
prescribed
Provided that a member voting under this sub-section
in disobedience of the party whip shall cease to hold office
forthwith and the vacancy caused by such cessation shall
be filled as a casual vacancy.
(5) A copy of the minutes of the meeting together
with a copy of the motion and the result of the voting
thereon shall be forwarded immediately on the termination
of the meeting by the said presiding officer to the District
Collector. The District Collector shall forward the same
along with his remarks to the Government.
(6) If the motion is carried with the support of
two-thirds majority of the total number of the
members including the ex-officio members as on the
date of the meeting, the Government shall by
notification remove the Chairperson or ViceChairperson as the case may be from office and the
resultant vacancy shall be filled in the same manner
as a casual vacancy.
Explanation-I :- For the removal of doubts, it is
hereby declared that for the purpose of this section
the expression "total number of members" means, all
the members who are entitled to vote in the election to
the office concerned including the ex-officio
members.
Explanation II:-For the purposes of the section, in the
determination of two-thirds of the total number of
members, any fraction below 0.5 shall be ignored and any
fraction of 0.5 or above shall be taken as one.
(emphasis supplied)
Andhra Pradesh Municipalities (Motion of No Confidence
in Chairperson/Vice-Chairperson) Rules, 2008 :
Rule 3. A motion expressing want of confidence in the
Chairperson or Vice-Chairperson may be made by giving
a written notice of intention to move the motion in form-I
duly signed by not less than one-half of the total number
of members of the municipal council having right to vote,
together with a copy of the proposed motion to the District
Collector concerned.
Rule 5. (1) After proper verification of the signatures of the
members in form-I, the District Collector shall convene a
meeting for the consideration of the motion at the office of
the municipal council on a date appointed by him which
shall not be later than thirty days from the date on which
notice was delivered to him. He shall give to the members
who are having right to vote notice of not less than fifteen
clear days as provided in sub-section (2) of Section 46 of
the Act in form-II.
(2) The meeting shall not be convened on a public
holiday.
Rule 6. The notice referred to in form-II shall be served on
the members as provided in Section 353 of the Act.
Rule 8. After issue of a notice under Rule 5 by the District
Collector, every recognized political party may appoint a
person on behalf of that political party as whip and
intimation of such appointment shall be issued by the
State President or a person authorized by him under his
seal and such intimation shall be sent to the Presiding
Officer to reach him on or before 11.00 a.m. on the day
preceding the day appointed for consideration of the No
confidence Motion against Chairperson or ViceChairperson.
Rule 10. (1) A meeting convened for the purpose of
considering a motion under these rules shall not be
adjourned for any reason.
(2) The quorum for such meeting shall be two thirds of
the total number of members.
(3) If within half an hour after the time appointed for the
meeting, there is no quorum, the presiding officer shall
adjourn the meeting to some other time on the same day
and notify the same in the notice board of the Council. If
there is no quorum at the adjourned time also, the meeting
shall stand dissolved and notice given under rule 3 shall
lapse
(4) As soon as a meeting convened under the said rule
commences the presiding officer shall read to the
members present in the meeting, the motion for the
consideration of which the meeting has been convened
and shall put it to vote without any debate.
Rule 11. When the Motion of No confidence is put to
vote, the Presiding Officer shall first ask the members
to raise their hands who vote for the motion and
record their names with party affiliation in the minutes
book. Similarly, the Presiding Officer shall ask the
remaining members to raise their hands who vote
against the motion and record their names with party
affiliation in the minutes book. The names of members
who abstain from voting with their party affiliation
shall also be recorded in the minutes book. The result
of the voting shall be recorded in the minutes book.”
(emphasis supplied)
ANALYSIS:
16.A. The facts narrated herein above are not much in dispute. It is a fact that
the total number of Wards in Markapur Municipality are 35 in number.
Therefore, there are 35 ward members in the Council. The local M.L.A is also
the ex-officio member of the Council, thereby making the total strength of the
Council as 36 „who are entitled to vote‟. It is also an admitted fact that one of
the ward member is no more, and therefore, the total number of members in
the Council who are entitled to vote as on 11.06.2025 are 35 in number. It is
an admitted fact that 24 Councilors out of 35 have attended the meeting at
3.30 P.M on 11.06.2025 that was convened for considering the Motion of No
Confidence against the Unofficial Respondent No.5. It is also an admitted fact
that out of 24 members who attended the meeting and were present, only 19
members have raised their hands in favour of the No Confidence Motion and
five members have abstained from raising their hand either in favour of or
against the Motion of No Confidence.
The Respondent No.3 had treated
those 5 members as having abstained from voting (mentioned at Serial No.7
in the Table below). Admittedly, the District Revenue Officer (Presiding Officer
- Respondent No.3) had declared that the Motion of No Confidence has been
passed successfully vide ROC No.939/2025/E1 dated 11.06.2025 (Ex.P.3).
Para No.5 of the said Proceedings of Respondent No.3 dated 11.06.2025
(Ex.P.3) containing the Table is usefully extracted hereunder:
“5. On the same day at 3.30 PM, the meeting is commenced, and
the details of the participation, result and other information are
submitted below.
RESULT OF NO CONFIDENCE MOTION AGAINST SRI
CHIRLAMCHARLA BALAMURALI KRISHNA RAO, CHAIRPERSON,
MUNICIPAL COUNCIL, MARKAPUR MUNICIPALITY
1. Total strength of municipal council including ExOfficio members
Members – 35
Ex-Officio
member - 1
2. Total members of the Municipal Council attended
the meeting
3. Total members of the Municipal Council not 12 (including 1
attended the meeting
died)
4. Quorum required
5. Total members of municipal council voted in the
favour of the no confidence motion against Sri
Chirlamcharla
Balamurall
Krishna
Rao,
Chairperson, Municipal Council, Markapur
Municipality
6. Total members of municipal council voted against
the no confidence motion In Sri Chirlamcharla
Balamurali Krishna Rao, Chairperson, Municipal
Council, Markapur Municipality
7. Total members of the Municipal Council abstain
from voting
8. Result
The Motion of
no confidence
against Sri
Chirlamcharla
Balamurali
Krishna Rao,
Chairperson,
Municipal
Council,
Markapur
Municipality is
passed.
16.B. This indicates that the Respondent No.3 has taken two-thirds of the
total members present in the meeting at 3.30 P.M on 11.06.2025 for the
purpose of the Motion.
16.C. The impugned Proceeding issued by the Respondent No.1 dated
24.11.2025 (Ex.P.1) is usefully extracted hereunder:
“9. The above rule position in the AP Municipalities Act 1965
vide Section No.46 (6) clearly reflects the twin requirement of
2/3rds majority for attaining the quorum and for passing the
motion also. For removal of any doubts on the above, the
explanation I of section 46 clearly clarified that the total
number of members means all the members who are elected
to vote in the election to the office concerned, including ex
officio members.
10. The reliance placed by the Presiding Officer on certain
judgments under the Telangana Municipalities Act, 2019, as
referred by the District Collector in the report have been
examined and it is clarified that the provisions of the AP
Municipalities Act 1965 in Section 46 and in its Explanation-I
thereon, has to be followed in the present case. Reliance on
the Telangana Municipalities Act/Rules and a High Court
order based on that cannot be done in this case.
11. Accordingly, upon careful examination of the facts and
the material on record, Government hereby concludes that
the no-confidence motion moved against the Chairperson of
the Markapur Municipal Council on 11.06.2025 does not fulfill
the mandatory criteria under Section 46(6) of the Andhra
Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1965. The motion is therefore
deemed invalid, and no further proceedings shall be
undertaken for the removal of the Chairperson pursuant to
the said motion.”
17.
The above stated admitted facts are now required to be correlated with
the provisions of the Statue to see whether the action of Respondent No.3 is
in accordance with the Statue and the Rules or not. The relevant Statutory
Provisions and the Rules are extracted supra. Section 46 of the Act, 1965
deals with the Motion of no Confidence in Chairperson/Vice Chairperson. For
the present purpose, all the sub-sections are not required to be discussed
except Sub-sections 3, 4 & 6 and the Explanation-I to Sub-section 6 of Section
46 of the Act.
18.
Similarly, Sub-Rule (2) of Rule No.10 and Rule No.11 of Rules, 2008
are also relevant. In terms of Sub-section (3) of Section 46 of the Act, 1965,
admittedly, two-thirds of the total number of members would be 23 out of 35.
Whereas, on 11.06.2025, admittedly, 24 members have attended the meeting.
Therefore, there is no doubt that the quorum for having a valid meeting on
11.06.2025 was there.
19.
By adhering to Sub-Section (4) of Section 46 of Act 1965 read with Rule
11 of Rules, 2008, the Presiding Officer (Respondent No.3) had requested the
members who are in favour of the Motion to express by show of hands.
Admittedly, only 19 members out of 24 have raised their hands in favour of the
Motion of No Confidence against Unofficial Respondent No.5. Five of the
members who were present did not raise their hands either in favour of or
against the Motion. Therefore, the Presiding Officer (Respondent No.3) had
shown the 5 members as having abstained from voting. In order to understand
whether the Presiding Officer is right in taking two-thirds of the members
present in the Motion on 11.06.2025 as being sufficient or whether it is twothird of the total members who are entitled to vote as on the date of the
meeting that is required for passing a No Confidence Motion successfully, the
key lies in understanding the purport of Explanation-I of Sub-section (6) of
Section 46 of Act, 1965 and it assumes significance.
20.
At the cost of repetition, this Court deems it necessary to extract
Explanation-I of Sub-section (6) of Section 46 of Act, 1965 as under:
“Explanation-I: For the removal of doubts, it is hereby
declared that for the purpose of this section the
expression “total number of members” means, all the
members who are entitled to vote in the election to the
office concerned including the ex-officio members.”
21.
The literal meaning of Explanation-I would make it amply clear, without
any kind of ambiguity, that two-third of the total number of members of Council
who are entitled to vote are required to vote in favour of the Motion of No
Confidence against Unofficial Respondent No.5. Therefore, out of 35
members who are entitled to vote as on the date of the meeting, atleast 23
members, that constitutes two-thirds, are required to vote in favour of the
Motion by show of hands. Admittedly, in the present case, only 19 members
out of 35 members have expressed by show of hands in favour of the Motion
instead of 23, which is the deciding figure.
22.
As stated earlier, the Explanation-I of Sub-section (6) of Section 46 of
the Act, 1965 holds the key as to what constitutes a two-third majority for the
removal of the Chairman/Vice Chairman by a Motion of No Confidence under
Section 46 of the Act, 1965. The said Explanation-I is absolutely categorical
and it would not leave any room for doubt whatsoever that the total number of
members of the Council entitled to vote as on the date of the meeting means
all the members who are entitled to vote in the election to the office concerned
including the ex-officio members as on the date of the meeting.
23.
At this stage, this Court is of the considered opinion that the reliance
placed by the learned Senior Counsel representing the Writ Petitioner on the
Judgment of the learned Single Judge of Hon‟ble High Court of Telangana in
Jakka Venkata Reddy v. State of Telangana in I.A.No.1 of 2024 in
W.P.No.21205 of 2024 is of no avail, inasmuch as the learned Single Judge
has not considered any provision of law which is in pari materia with
Explanation-I of Sub-section (6) of Section 46 of the A.P Municipalities Act,
1965. This apart, even the issue that is framed and decided by the Ld. Single
Judge of Hon‟ble High Court of Telangana is no way related to the issue on
hand. Hence, the issue framed therein by the Ld. Single of the Hon‟ble High
Court of Telangana is usefully extracted hereunder:
“Whether prima facie the 2nd respondent by accepting
Form-1 dated 18.07.2024 could have issued Form-II
(for the 2nd time) scheduling the meeting on
09.08.2024 at 11.00 a.m.”
24.
In this view of the matter, the reliance placed by the learned Senior
Counsel on the Judgment of the Hon‟ble High Court of Telangana in Jakka
Venkata Reddy v. State of Telangana in I.A.No.1 of 2024 in W.P.No.21205
of 2024 is of no avail.
25.
In the light of the above discussion, this Court is of the opinion that
Respondent No.3 has committed a grave error in declaring the Motion of No
Confidence as being passed against Unofficial Respondent No.5 on
11.06.2025. This leads us to the next question whether the illegal action of
Respondent No.3 cannot be corrected by the Government acting through the
Principal Secretary under Sub-Section (6) of Section 46 of the Act, 1965.
26.
Coming to the issue whether the use of the word „shall‟ in Sub-section
(6) of Section 46 of the Act, 1965 is concerned, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the word „shall‟ cannot deprive the Government, which is the
ultimate authority to notify the removal of the Chairman, in rectifying the gross
illegality committed by Respondent Nos.2 and 3. A close reading of Subsection (6) of Section 46 of the Act, 1965 would disclose that the Government
would be mandatorily obligated to issue „Notification‟ removing the
Chairperson only if the 1st part of Sub-section (6) is scrupulously followed as
per the statute. The first part of Sub-section (6) contemplates that the motion
shall be “carried with the support of two-thirds majority of the total number of
members including the ex-officio members as on the date of the meeting”.
Even if the Presiding Officer (Respondent No.3) were to get any doubt as to
what constitutes two-thirds majority, such doubt is clarified by Explanation-I to
Sub-section (6) without any ambiguity (extracted supra).
27.
This Court has already opined that the understanding of the statutory
provisions by the Presiding Officer (Respondent No.3) is contrary to the letter
and spirit of the Statute and the Rules inasmuch as the Presiding Officer
(Respondent No.3) has not complied with the 1st part of Sub-section (6) as per
law. When once the Presiding Officer has not complied with the 1st part of
Sub-section (6) by reading it along with Explanation-I correctly, the Writ
Petitioners cannot insist on the Government to mechanically issue the
Notification confirming the Proceedings of Respondent No.2 and Respondent
No.3 and remove the Chairperson, which is per se illegal.
28.
Government is not expected to act as a mere rubber stamp and notify
even an illegal decision rendered by the Presiding Officer as confirmed by the
District Collector. This apart, this Court is also of the opinion that the very
intent of the Legislature requiring the Government to pass the Final Order
under Sub-section (6) of Section 46 of the Act, 1965 is with a view to enable
the Government to consider the legality or otherwise of the whole process that
is involved under Section 46 of the Act, 1965.
29.
One of the contentions of the Ld. Senior Counsel appearing for the Writ
Petitioners is that about 23 Ward Members have signed on Form-I and that
the present Writ Petition is also filed by 23 Ward Members and therefore,
these facts are sufficient to indicate that two-thirds of the total Members (35 in
number) entitled to vote are deemed to have voted in favour of the Motion for
No Confidence. Having considered this submission, this Court opines that this
plea cannot be considered. There might have been consensus among 23
Ward Members before the Motion, when they signed Form-I and thereafter
when the same set of Members have signed the Vakaltnama for filing the
present Writ Petition. This Court opines that consensus before the Motion and
consensus after the Motion, without there being any consensus during the
actual Motion at 3.30 P.M on 11.06.2025 is a situation which the law cannot
countenance. Any consideration of this situation in a different manner would
be an absolute perversity. View of this Court is fortified by the Judgment of
the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Ramchandra Keshav Adke (dead) by L.Rs v.
Govind Joti Chavare and Others : (1975) 1 SCC 559, wherein the Hon‟ble
Apex Court held in Para No.25 as under:
“A Century ago, in Taylor v. Taylor, Jassel, M.R. adopted the
rule that where a power is given to do a certain thing in a
certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all
and that other methods of performance are necessarily
forbidden. This rule has stood the test of time. It was
applied by the Privy Council, in Nazir Ahmed v. Emperor and
later by this Court in several cases, to magistrate making a
record under Sections 164 and 364 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1989. This rule squarely applies “where, indeed,
the whole aim and object of the Legislature would be plainly
defeated if the command to do the thing in a particular
manner did not imply a prohibition to do it in any other”. The
rule………………………………………………………………..”
30.
In the light of the above discussion, this Court is of the opinion that the
Impugned Order dated 24.11.2025 passed by the Respondent No.1 is
absolutely in accordance with law, and therefore, does not suffer any legal
infirmity. Hence, no interference is called for.
31.
In the above premise, the present Writ Petition is devoid of any merit.
Accordingly, this Writ Petition is dismissed. No Order as to Costs.
32.
Interlocutory Applications, if any, stand closed in terms of this order.
______________________________________
GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD, J
Dt: 17.04.2026
DSV/MNR/JKS
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD
WRIT PETITION No.33200 OF 2025
Dt: 17.04.2026
Note: LR copy to be marked.
B/o. DVS/MNR/JKS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review