Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 15.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 17.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 18.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010412862026
+
W.P.(C) 12760/2026 & CM APPL. 59237/2026, CM APPL.
62726-27/2026
VAASVI KHAITAN MINOR THROUGH HER FATHER
MR VEDANT KHAITAN
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Kapil Modi with Mr. Shiv
Verma and Mr. Shorya Goel,
Advocates
versus
AD-HOC COMMITTEE FOR THE GOVERNANCE OF
EQUESTRIAN FEDERATION OF INDIA
& ORS.
....Respondents
Through:
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
Mr. Tanmaya Mehta, Ms. Niyati
Kohli, Mr. Rishab Parikh, Mr.
Pinank Mehra and Ms. Isha
Kakkar, Advocates for R-1 and R2
Mr. Ruchir Mishra, Ms. Rupali
Sinha, G.P., Mr. Sanjiv Kumar
Saxena, Mr. Mukesh Kumar
Tiwari, Ms. Reba Jena Mishra,
Ms. Poonam Shukla and Mr.
Mukul Yadav, Advocates
Ms. Rupali Sinha, G.P. for R4/UOI
Mr.
Balbir
Singh,
Senior
Advocate with Mr. Kartik Yadav,
Ms. Sumedha Chopra, Mr. Duvva
Pawan Kumar, Mr. Chirag
Madan, Mr. Sai Krishna Kumar
and
Ms.
Shradha
Gupta,
Advocates for R-5
Ms. Manini Brar and Mr. O. P.
Harsh Singh Munday, Advocates
for R-6
Ms. Kumudavalli Seetharaman
and Ms. Geetika Vyas, Advocates
for Indian Olympic Association
CORAM:
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
J U D G M E NT
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
1.
The petitioner has approached this Court by way of the present
writ petition, praying for grant of following reliefs:
“a. issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or
direction quashing and setting aside, to a limited extent mentioned in
prayer (b) below, the Impugned Minutes dt. 24.8.26 & Resolution dt.
27.8.26 (Anx P-1) because they constitute a retrospective change in
the rules of the game after the game was played, by shortening the
established eight-month qualifying/ selection window of 8.11.25–
25.7.26 and replacing it with a new two-month window of 8.5.26–
25.7.26, thereby excluding seven of the Petitioner‟s eight valid
qualifying scores obtained before 8.5.26 from YOG selection, in
brazen violation of Constitution Bench in Tej Prakash Pathak, which
upheld, K. Manjusree (3J.);
b. may please quash and set aside:
i. para 3(ii) of the impugned Minutes dt. 24.8.26, insofar as it
retrospectively introduces 8.5.26 as the opening date and
shortens the established eight-month qualifying/selection
window of 8.11.25–25.7.26 to a new two-month window of
8.5.26–25.7.26;
ii. para 5(iv) of the impugned Minutes dt. 24.8.26, insofar as it
confines the re-tabulation to 8.5.26–25.7.26 and thereby excludes
the valid qualifying scores obtained before 8.5.26 from YOG
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
selection;
iii. the consequential order of merit declared in para 5(vi) of the
impugned Minutes; and
iv. paras 5–6 of the Resolution dt. 27.8.26, insofar as they accept
and
adopt
the
aforesaid
retrospectively
altered
qualifying/selection window, re-tabulation and consequential
order of merit (Anx P-1);
c. issue a writ of mandamus, or any other appropriate writ, order or
direction, directing R-1 to restore and uniformly apply the original
eight-month qualifying/selection window of 8.11.25–25.7.26 and
recalculate the order of merit after including all qualifying scores
achieved by every eligible rider during the said window, including
the seven qualifying scores excluded solely because they were
obtained prior to 8.5.26, strictly in accordance with the criterion
recorded in para 5(vi) of the impugned Minutes dt. 24.8.26, which
states, “... considering all events of 1.30 mt height and above …”;
and, to avoid any ambiguity, further direct R-1, while recalculating
the aforesaid order of merit, to include all similarly situated scores
obtained in similarly situated competitions by all riders, as per the
scores included in Annexure-I to the impugned Minutes (Anx P-1);
d. issue a writ of mandamus, or any other appropriate writ, order or
direction, directing R-1 to publish a fresh order of merit within 24
hours of completing the exercise directed in prayer (c) above and
communicate the same to the Petitioner and all other riders through
all electronic modes;
e. pending disposal of the instant writ, restrain R-1 to R-4 from
forwarding, confirming or acting upon R-5‟s (Sresht) definite entry
for YOG 2026, or direct that any entry already forwarded shall
remain provisional and expressly subject to the orders of this
Hon‟ble Court;
f. direct R-1 to preserve and produce the complete original and
electronic selection record, including representations, emails, FEI
verification material, spreadsheets, score sheets, calculation sheets,
meeting records, metadata, drafts and internal communications; and.”
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
The facts of the case, as discernible from the petition, are that
the petitioner, Vaasvi Khaitan, is a 16-year-old international showjumping athlete who seeks to represent India at the Youth Olympic
Games, Dakar, Senegal, 2026 [hereafter „YOG, 2026‟]. The
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
Fédération Équestre Internationale (FEI) had prescribed the
minimum eligibility requirements for participation in the YOG, 2026,
including the requirement of a Certificate of Capability (COC). The
petitioner states that, between December 2025 and May 2026, she
obtained eight qualifying scores in 1.30 m/1.35 m competitions. On
28.12.2025, the Equestrian Federation of India (EFI) communicated
its Selection Criteria for YOG, 2026, as approved by its Executive
Committee, to the petitioner via email. It is stated that the same
criteria was subsequently uploaded by EFI on 08.05.2026. According
to the petitioner, neither of these criteria prescribed 08.05.2026 as the
commencement date of the qualifying or selection period, nor did
they provide that qualifying scores obtained before that date would be
excluded from consideration. The petitioner‟s father had, on
08.05.2026, emailed EFI and physically delivered her official FEI
record containing the eight qualifying scores obtained prior to that
date. The petitioner thereafter states that EFI, by email dated
10.06.2026, informed her that her COC had been submitted to the
FEI and that she had been approved for consideration. She was also
informed that her latest competition results were required to be
submitted by 25.07.2026. The petitioner further states that she
obtained two additional qualifying scores on 21.07.2026 and
22.07.2026. These results were supplied to EFI by her father on
26.07.2026 and again on 03.08.2026 in the prescribed format, and
EFI acknowledged receipt of the same. Thus, according to the
petitioner, EFI was in possession of all ten of her qualifying scores
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
before the conclusion of the original selection process.
3.
The original selection process was concluded by the Selection
Committee on 06.08.2026 and the result was published by EFI on
10.08.2026 [hereafter „Selection Decision-I‟]. In the said selection,
respondent no. 5, Sresht Raju Mantena, was selected to represent
India at the YOG, 2026, while the petitioner was placed as the
reserve rider. The petitioner states that the Selection Committee,
while recording its findings regarding the relevant cut-off dates,
referred to 15.05.2026 as the deadline for issuance of the COC and
25.07.2026 as the deadline for submission of results, but did not
record any finding fixing 08.05.2026 as the commencement date or
excluding qualifying scores obtained prior thereto. Aggrieved by
Selection Decision-I, the petitioner submitted a representation dated
13.08.2026. Her principal grievance was that the qualifying scores
obtained by her before 08.05.2026 were being excluded from
consideration, despite there being, according to her, no prior
communication informing her that such scores would not be counted
for determining the order of merit. She further raised an apprehension
of bias on account of an alleged sponsorship/benefactor relationship
between EFI and the father of respondent no. 5. Thereafter, on
16.08.2026, EFI issued a Review Notice proposing reconsideration of
the concluded selection. The petitioner also approached this Court in
relation to the selection process. On 18.08.2026, this Court passed an
order in Shubh Chowdhari through his Father v. Equestrian
Federation of India & Ors., W.P.(C) 11935/2026, pursuant to which
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
EFI was required to reconsider the selection. It is stated that the
petitioner thereafter sent reminders dated 18.08.2026, 19.08.2026 and
20.08.2026 regarding her grievances. The review hearing was
thereafter conducted by the Selection Committee on 24.08.2026. The
petitioner‟s father appeared before the Committee and, inter alia,
objected to the exclusion of the qualifying scores obtained prior to
08.05.2026. It was specifically pointed out that the Selection Criteria
communicated in December 2025 were identical to those uploaded on
08.05.2026 and that, according to the petitioner, exclusion of the
earlier qualifying scores had never been communicated to her during
the selection process.
4.
On 27.08.2026, the Ad-Hoc Committee for the Governance of
EFI issued the fresh selection decision, comprising the Minutes dated
24.08.2026 of the Selection Committee, which is impugned before
this Court [hereafter „Selection Decision-II‟], whereby respondent
no. 5, Sresht Raju Mantena, was retained at rank 1, being
recommended to represent India at YOG, 2026, while the petitioner
herein was downgraded to rank 3, from previous rank 2, and
recommended as reserve rider 2, and respondent no. 6, Shubh
Chowdhari, was upgraded to rank 2, from previous rank 3, and
recommended as reserve rider 1.
5.
According to the petitioner, while reviewing the concluded
selection, the Ad-Hoc Committee and the Selection Committee
retrospectively treated the period from 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026 as
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
the relevant qualifying/selection window, thereby excluding seven of
her eight qualifying scores obtained prior to 08.05.2026. She further
alleges that only one of those earlier scores was taken into account
for the purpose of her COC, despite EFI having already submitted her
COC to the FEI.
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the present petition has been filed before
this Court.
RIVAL CONTENTIONS
7.
The petitioner’s case is that the aforesaid approach in Selection
Decision-II effectively altered the basis of selection after Selection
Decision-I had already been concluded and published. According to
her, neither the Selection Criteria dated 28.12.2025, nor the identical
criteria uploaded on the website on 08.05.2026, nor any
communication issued to the athletes before the conclusion of
Selection Decision-I, stated that 08.05.2026 would operate as the
commencement date for counting qualifying scores or that qualifying
scores obtained prior thereto would be excluded from the order of
merit. The petitioner‟s case is also that, if all qualifying scores
obtained during the qualifying/selection period which, according to
her, commenced on 08.11.2025 and continued until 25.07.2026 are
counted uniformly, she would have ten qualifying scores, as against
five of respondent no. 5 and four of respondent no. 6, Shubh
Chowdhari. On this basis, she claims that she ought to have been
placed first in the order of merit and selected as the rider to represent
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
India at the YOG, 2026. Her principal grievance is that the basis on
which her qualifying performances were assessed was altered
retrospectively, resulting in the exclusion of seven of her eight
qualifying scores obtained before 08.05.2026. She accordingly seeks
reconsideration of the selection on the basis of the criteria which,
according to her, were in force when the selection process was
undertaken.
8.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner argues that
the impugned Selection Decision-II is wholly arbitrary and
unsustainable, as respondent nos. 1 and 2, after conclusion of the
selection process on 06.08.2026 and publication of the result on
10.08.2026, retrospectively altered the very basis on which the
candidates had been assessed. It is contended that the Selection
Criteria approved by EFI on 28.12.2025 and thereafter uploaded in
identical form on 08.05.2026 nowhere prescribed 08.05.2026 as the
opening date of the qualifying or selection window, and Clause 6
thereof merely stipulated that the selection process would remain
open until 15.05.2026, aligned with the FEI‟s deadline for obtaining
the COC. It is therefore submitted that there was no basis whatsoever
for the Selection Committee, in the review proceedings undertaken
after the selection had already concluded, to introduce 08.05.2026 as
a new opening date and thereby exclude seven of the petitioner‟s
eight valid qualifying scores obtained prior thereto. The learned
counsel contends that the prejudice caused to the petitioner is
manifest, since, if all qualifying scores obtained during the
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
established period from 08.11.2025 to 25.07.2026 were considered
uniformly, the petitioner had ten qualifying scores as against five
obtained by respondent no. 5 and four obtained by respondent no. 6,
thereby placing the petitioner first in the order of merit. It is further
argued that EFI was in possession of all the petitioner‟s qualifying
scores before the selection process had concluded, having received
the eight earlier scores on 08.05.2026 and the two subsequent scores
dated 21.07.2026 and 22.07.2026 on 26.07.2026, which were duly
acknowledged by EFI. The learned counsel emphasises that at no
point between 08.05.2026 and the publication of the concluded
selection on 10.08.2026 was the petitioner informed that scores
obtained prior to 08.05.2026 would be excluded from the
comparative assessment and, on the contrary, EFI had itself required
the petitioner to furnish her latest competition results by 25.07.2026.
The learned counsel also draws attention to the petitioner‟s COC
dated 20.05.2026, signed by the President of EFI and submitted to the
FEI, wherein the petitioner‟s qualifying result was recorded as the
CSI1* Grand Prix score obtained at Lier on 15.03.2026, and argues
that the impugned Selection Decision-II nevertheless proceeded on
the basis that her result dated 01.05.2026 would be considered as her
COC result, despite the said date not appearing on the actual COC. It
is, therefore, contended that the review exercise was not a bona fide
clarification of an existing criterion but an impermissible alteration of
the selection framework after the relevant performances had been
completed and the comparative consequences of applying the altered
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
criterion had become known, resulting in the petitioner being
deprived of the benefit of seven otherwise valid qualifying scores and
consequently being relegated to the position of second reserve,
despite her otherwise standing first in the order of merit.
9.
The learned counsel appearing for respondent nos. 1 and 2,
i.e. the Ad-Hoc Committee of EFI and the Selection Committee,
opposes the writ petition and argues that the petition proceeds on an
erroneous premise that an established eight-month qualifying or
selection window commencing from 08.11.2025 existed and was
subsequently curtailed by the impugned Selection Decision-II. It is
contended that no such opening date had ever been prescribed in the
Selection Criteria, and that 08.11.2025 was merely the date of the FEI
Jumping World Challenge held at Bengaluru, through which the
India-based riders had obtained their COC, and was not the
commencement of any YOG selection window. The learned counsel
argues that the Selection Criteria uploaded on 08.05.2026 prescribed
the requirement of „recency of results‟ and that the selection process
was accordingly undertaken on the basis of results obtained after
publication of the criteria, with one COC result being considered for
each rider. It is argued that the same methodology was applied both
in the original Selection Decision-I on 06.08.2026 and upon
reconsideration on 24.08.2026, while passing the impugned Selection
Decision-II; consequently, there was no question of any retrospective
alteration of the rules or exclusion of results which had earlier formed
part of the selection process. The learned counsel further submits that
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
the petitioner herself, in her representation dated 13.08.2026 and in
the first writ petition instituted thereafter before this Court, proceeded
on the basis of the methodology adopted on 06.08.2026 and raised a
grievance only with respect to the non-consideration of her result
dated 02.05.2026, seeking application of the tie-breaker so as to place
her first. The plea that an eight-month selection window existed and
that seven additional results ought to be considered has been raised
only subsequently, after the petitioner became aware of the tabulation
and realised that inclusion of those earlier results would alter the
order of merit in her favour. It is therefore contended that the present
claim is an afterthought and amounts to an attempt to enlarge the
field of results after the comparative assessment has already been
undertaken. The learned counsel also contends that the consideration
of the petitioner‟s results on 24.08.2026 was, in fact, undertaken to
her benefit, since the Selection Committee included one pre-window
result for her so as to place her at par with the India-based riders
whose COC results had been considered, and the Committee
accordingly selected her 01.05.2026 result as the more favourable
result for that purpose. The allegation that the said treatment amounts
to fabrication is therefore denied. It is further argued that the
selection of a single rider for the YOG, 2026 involved an assessment
of qualitative factors including recency, consistency, technical level
and championship readiness, and was not a simple mathematical
exercise in which every result obtained by an athlete over an
indefinite period was required to be counted. It is stated that
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
permitting the petitioner to introduce results obtained between
December 2025 and April 2026, when other riders planned and
undertook their international competition schedules in June and July
2026 on the basis of the published criteria, would itself cause
prejudice and inequity to the other participants. As regards the
allegation of bias, the learned counsel argues that the same is a mere
bald allegation and is unsupported by any material, as no member of
the Selection Committee or Ad-Hoc Committee is alleged to have
any relationship with respondent no. 5 or his family, and the order of
merit had been prepared on the basis of results verified from the FEI
database through a uniform methodology. The learned counsel
therefore argues that the petitioner is, in substance, seeking a
direction requiring the Court to substitute its own assessment for that
of the expert selection body and to redraw the order of merit on the
basis of a selection window which had never existed, and that no
ground for interference with the impugned Selection Decision-II is
made out.
10.
The learned counsel appearing for respondent no. 6 argues
that the Selection Criteria was first uploaded on EFI‟s website on
08.05.2026, in accordance with Clause 15, sub-clause 3.2 of the EFI
Statute, and therefore the selection process could commence only
from that date. It is contended that any prior private communication
of the criteria or consideration of results obtained before 08.05.2026
could not form part of the selection process, having not been
promulgated in accordance with the EFI Statute. The learned counsel
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
further submits that the COC itself was required to be obtained by
15.05.2026 and was a threshold requirement for participation in the
YOG, 2026. It is therefore contended that results obtained prior to the
publication of the Selection Criteria, or even prior to the date on
which the riders became eligible through the COC, could not be
treated as part of the selection process. It is further submitted that, in
any event, Selection Decision-I dated 06.08.2026 had already been
withdrawn pursuant to the Addendum dated 16.08.2026 and,
therefore, any challenge based on the manner in which the earlier
decision considered the petitioner‟s pre-08.05.2026 results does not
survive. The learned counsel also contends that the petitioner had a
higher number of disqualifying results involving more than eight
penalties as compared to the other two competing riders. It is
contended that respondent no. 6 had the lowest penalty points
amongst the three riders in the qualifying results and that, in
assessing recent and consistent performance, EFI was required to
consider results obtained during the period from 08.05.2026 to
25.07.2026, in accordance with the Selection Criteria dated
08.05.2026 and 10.06.2026. It is accordingly prayed that the present
petition be dismissed.
11.
The learned counsel appearing for respondent no. 5
contends that respondent no. 5 has been selected to represent India at
the YOG, 2026 purely on the basis of his merit and the assessment
undertaken by the Selection Committee. It is contended that the
original selection was subsequently reviewed upon consideration of
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
the representations made by the participating riders, and the
impugned Selection Decision-II was taken after such reconsideration.
It is therefore argued that no ground for interference is made out and
the present petition deserves to be dismissed.
12.
During the pendency of the present petition, there were some
subsequent developments as well. The learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner argues that a signed record has come to light
showing that the petitioner had already been unanimously selected by
the Selection Committee on 13.05.2026 to represent India at the
YOG, 2026, with Neil Kendall named as the reserve rider. It is
contended that the said minutes were signed by all three members of
the then Selection Committee and were subsequently shared with the
petitioner‟s counsel by its Chairman, Maj. J.S. Ahluwalia (Retd.),
who has stated that he was never informed that the said selection had
been set aside or reopened and is willing to affirm the minutes on
affidavit. It is further submitted that the said selection was made on
the basis of the COC deadline of 15.05.2026 and the petitioner‟s
qualifying results available up to that date, and that the selection
window was thereafter extended by EFI up to 25.07.2026, which the
petitioner also satisfied. The learned counsel contends that, despite
the earlier selection, the same Selection Committee members
subsequently participated in the fresh selection and review
proceedings dated 06.08.2026 and 24.08.2026, respectively, without
disclosing or referring to the petitioner‟s selection dated 13.05.2026.
It is argued that the minutes dated 13.05.2026 were thus suppressed
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
from the petitioner, the subsequent Selection Committees and this
Court, and that the subsequent proceedings cannot be sustained
without examining the authenticity and legal effect of the said
minutes. The learned counsel further submits that the Indian Olympic
Association (IOA), being the National Olympic Committee
responsible for forwarding India‟s definite entry for the YOG, 2026,
ought to independently verify the authenticity of the minutes and the
circumstances in which the earlier selection was disregarded before
any definite entry is forwarded.
13.
The learned counsel appearing for the IOA confirms that the
minutes dated 13.05.2026 have been independently verified and are
authentic.
14.
The learned counsel appearing for respondent nos. 1 and 2,
while not disputing the genuineness of the minutes dated 13.05.2026,
submits that the said minutes cannot be treated as the final selection
of the petitioner for the YOG, 2026. It is submitted that, at that stage,
only two riders, i.e., the petitioner and Neil Kendall, had approached
the Federation expressing their intent to participate, and the
comparison recorded in the minutes was confined to the results
available up to 02.05.2026. The learned counsel submits that the
minutes themselves contemplated that all seven riders who
subsequently obtained their COCs would be placed on the long list,
and that the remaining five eligible riders had not even been
considered at that stage. It is further submitted that the events
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
preceding and following the meeting dated 13.05.2026 are material to
appreciate the nature of the said recommendation. According to the
learned counsel, EFI was, at that stage, proceeding under an
erroneous understanding that the deadline for communicating the
selected rider to the FEI was 20.05.2026. It is submitted that the FEI
had, in fact, sought confirmation of the COCs, and had not
communicated any deadline of 20.05.2026 for final selection of the
rider. Consequently, the recommendation made on 13.05.2026 was
communicated to the FEI on 19.05.2026 and 20.05.2026 along with
the petitioner‟s COC, but on 20.05.2026 the FEI only confirmed
receipt of valid COCs in respect of all seven riders, including
respondent no. 5, thereby placing all seven riders on the long list. The
learned counsel submits that, once the eligibility of all seven riders
was
confirmed,
EFI
consciously
commenced
a
fresh
and
comprehensive merit-based exercise rather than treating the
preliminary recommendation of 13.05.2026 as final. In this regard,
reliance is placed upon the communication dated 10.06.2026
addressed to all seven COC holders, including the petitioner,
whereby each rider was expressly informed that he or she had been
included in the long list and that the final selection would be based
upon an objective assessment of recent performances, consistency of
results, competitiveness at CSI1*/CSI2* events and overall merit. It
was further expressly communicated that the latest competition
results and performance records were required to be submitted by
25.07.2026, which was stated to be the cut-off date for consideration.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
The learned counsel argues that the petitioner herself thereafter
participated in the process on the basis of the communication dated
10.06.2026 and submitted her subsequent results for consideration. It
is contended that she was thus fully aware that the final selection was
yet to be undertaken and that the process was to be conducted
amongst all seven eligible riders on the basis of their recent
performances. The respondents submit that this course was adopted
precisely to ensure that the final selection was not confined to the
petitioner and Neil Kendall, who were the only two riders who had
initially approached EFI, before the eligibility of the other riders had
been confirmed. The learned counsel further submits that there was,
therefore, no question of suppression of the minutes dated
13.05.2026. The recommendation contained therein was placed
before the Ad-Hoc Committee on 19.05.2026, communicated to the
FEI, and thereafter superseded by the subsequent process
communicated to all seven riders on 10.06.2026. It is pointed out that
two of the members who had signed the minutes dated 13.05.2026
continued as members of the subsequent Selection Committees
because of their experience, and that the composition of those
Committees was known to the petitioner, who appeared before them.
It is further contended that the minutes of the Ad-Hoc Committee
dated 10.07.2026 themselves recorded that the final decision
regarding YOG selection was yet to be taken and was required to be
based strictly on the prescribed criteria and current form of the
athletes. The reconstituted Selection Committee thereafter considered
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
the performances of all the eligible riders within the notified period
and, on 24.08.2026, re-tabulated the results against the FEI data. The
learned counsel submits that the subsequent selection was
consequently a fresh, comprehensive and merit-based exercise and
not
a
continuation
or
concealment
of
the
preliminary
recommendation dated 13.05.2026.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
I.
Selection
Performances
15.
Window
and
Consideration
of
Earlier
The first issue which arises for consideration in the present
petition is whether, while undertaking the review which culminated
in Selection Decision-II, the EFI retrospectively altered the basis of
Selection
Decision-I
by
introducing
08.05.2026
as
the
commencement date of the selection window, thereby excluding the
petitioner‟s qualifying scores obtained prior to that date.
16.
At the outset, this Court notes that it is undisputed that the
Selection Criteria for YOG, 2026 was uploaded on the website of EFI
for the first time on 08.05.2026. It is not the petitioner‟s case that the
Selection Criteria was available on the website or otherwise made
available to all the eligible athletes before the said date. The
petitioner‟s case, instead, is that she had been forwarded a copy of
the Selection Criteria by the Acting President of EFI through an
email dated 28.12.2025, and the Selection Criteria which was
uploaded on 08.05.2026 on the website is the same.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
17.
Insofar as this argument of the learned counsel for the
petitioner is concerned, the attention of this Court has been drawn to
Clause 3.2 of Article 15 of the EFI Statute, which provides as under:
“3.2. Selection Criteria will be prepared and forwarded to Executive
Committee for approval. Thereafter it will be promulgated to all
members of EFI, upload on its website and will be strictly adhered
to. For any reason (s) in case the same is required to be amended, can
be done by this Committee based on the suggestion of Executive
Committee and such changes will be recorded. The decision taken by
Executive Committee is final and binding.”
18.
The aforesaid provision contemplates not merely the
preparation and approval of the Selection Criteria, but also its
promulgation to the members of EFI and its uploading on the
website. Thus, while the petitioner relies upon the email dated
28.12.2025 sent to him, to contend that the criteria had already been
communicated to her individually, the fact remains that the criteria
was first made available on the website of EFI on 08.05.2026. In this
Court‟s view, the selection process for YOG, 2026 concerns several
eligible athletes and the criteria was required to be made known to all
participants, and not just the present petitioner.
19.
The material on record further shows that seven athletes had
obtained their COC through results from the earlier period, six of
whom had obtained their COC on the basis of results from November
2025, whereas the petitioner obtained her COC only in May 2026.
Thereafter, as per the further criteria mentioned in email dated
10.06.2026, the eligible athletes were required to furnish their recent
results up to 25.07.2026 for the purpose of the selection.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
20.
Significantly, none of the other athletes who participated in the
selection process has approached this Court challenging the
commencement of the selection window from 08.05.2026, nor is it
reflected from the record that any of them had raised such an
objection before the Selection Committee. This is relevant because
the petitioner herein seeks to contend that there existed an eightmonth selection window commencing from 08.11.2025. However,
there is no document placed on record which identifies 08.11.2025 as
the commencement date of the YOG, 2026 selection process. The
said date was the date of the FEI Jumping World Challenge held at
Bengaluru, through which the India-based riders obtained their COC.
The mere fact that qualifying performances were obtained from that
date cannot, by itself, lead to the conclusion that the YOG, 2026
selection window commenced from 08.11.2025.
21.
On the other hand, as noted above, once the Selection Criteria
was uploaded on the official website of EFI on 08.05.2026, the
criteria specifically contemplated assessment of the „recency of
results‟, and the athletes were thereafter required to submit their latest
competition results by 25.07.2026. In these circumstances, the
Selection Committee treated the period from 08.05.2026 to
25.07.2026 as the relevant period for assessing recent performances,
while also taking into account one result forming the basis of the
COC of each rider. Such an approach, on the basis of the material
placed before this Court, cannot be characterised as introduction of a
new selection window.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
22.
In addition to the aforesaid, the petitioner has also relied upon
the fact that her father had been communicating with EFI officials for
several months and had been forwarding her competition results
obtained prior to May 2026. It is contended that at no stage was he
informed that those results would not be considered for the purpose
of selection.
23.
In this Court‟s opinion, these facts alone do not establish that
EFI had represented to the petitioner that all such results would form
part of the comparative assessment. The mere forwarding of the
results of competitions by the petitioner‟s father to EFI by way of
emails, cannot, by itself, amount to an assurance by EFI that every
such result would be considered for the YOG 2026 selection. There is
also no material to show that the petitioner had, prior to the
conclusion of Selection Decision-I, sought any specific clarification
from EFI as to whether the results obtained before 08.05.2026 would
be included in the order of merit or what the precise selection
window would be. Likewise, there is also no email on record to show
that any official of EFI specifically acknowledged that all the results
submitted by the petitioner during the last several months would be
considered specifically for the purpose of selection of riders for
YOG, 2026. Accordingly, the mere fact that such results were
forwarded to EFI by the petitioner‟s father cannot be construed as
creating any legitimate expectation that each of those results would
necessarily form part of the comparative assessment for selection to
the YOG, 2026.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
24.
However, the principal contention of the petitioner, on which
the present petition has been filed, is that Selection Decision-II
altered the rules which had already been applied in Selection
Decision-I. According to the petitioner, Selection Decision-I had
proceeded on the basis that results from the earlier period could be
considered and that, only in Selection Decision-II, the Selection
Committee introduced 08.05.2026 as the commencement date and
thereby shortened the selection window. However, in this Court‟s
view, this submission is not borne out by the record.
25.
A perusal of Selection Decision-I does not show that the
Selection Committee had treated all the petitioner‟s qualifying scores
obtained prior to 08.05.2026 as part of her „recent results‟ or had
otherwise proceeded on the basis of an eight-month selection window
commencing from 08.11.2025. In fact, Annexure-IV to Selection
Decision-I records the recent results (between period 08.05.2026 to
25.07.2026) of the eligible athletes for the relevant period, along with
one score forming the basis of their respective COC. Thus, there is no
material to establish that the Selection Committee, while passing
Selection Decision-I, had adopted 08.11.2025 as the opening date of
the selection window. Therefore, both selection decisions proceeded
on the basis of recent results during the relevant period, together with
one result forming the basis of the COC. However, concededly, no
COC score of the petitioner was mentioned in Selection Decision-I,
whereas Selection Decision-II included her result dated 01.05.2026
for that purpose.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
26.
It is also pertinent to note that when the petitioner had
challenged Selection Decision-I, by way of filing a writ petition
before this Court, her grievance was not that seven of her earlier
qualifying scores had been wrongly excluded from an eight-month
selection window. The said writ petition as well as her
representations submitted to the EFI principally concerned the nonconsideration of her result dated 02.05.2026 at 135 cm. The petitioner
sought consideration of that result and, in the subsequent review, her
result dated 01.05.2026 at 130 cm, being more favourable to her, was
taken into account as her COC result.
27.
The argument now raised before this Court proceeds on the
premise that all qualifying scores obtained from 08.11.2025 onwards
were required to be considered for determining the order of merit.
However, the record does not disclose that such a selection window
was ever notified or adopted by the Selection Committee in Selection
Decision-I. The Court is also unable to accept the submission that the
review proceedings, leading to Selection Decision-II, by treating
08.05.2026 as the commencement date for consideration of recent
results, amounted to a retrospective alteration of the rules. There
would have been a case of retrospective alteration if the Selection
Committee had, after the original selection, introduced a new criteria
and applied it to performances which had already been assessed
under a different notified criterion. However, the record shows that
the Selection Criteria had been uploaded on 08.05.2026 on EFI‟s
website, and the riders were thereafter called upon to submit their
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
latest results by 25.07.2026. The same period was considered while
undertaking the comparative assessment.
28.
In view thereof, this Court finds that the foundational premise
of the petitioner‟s challenge – that an eight-month selection window
commencing from 08.11.2025 had been prescribed but the same was
subsequently
shortened
to
a
two-and-a-half-month
window
commencing from 08.05.2026 while passing Selection Decision-II –
is not borne out from the record.
29.
This Court, therefore, finds no merit in the petitioner‟s
contention that Selection Decision-II altered the rules of the game by
changing the commencement date of the selection process from
08.11.2025 to 08.05.2026. The challenge on this ground is
accordingly rejected.
II.
Effect, if any, of the Minutes of the Selection Committee
dated 13.05.2026 on the Subsequent Selection Process
30.
The second issue that arises for consideration before this Court
is whether the minutes of the meeting of the Selection Committee
dated 13.05.2026, recording the selection of the petitioner, have any
bearing on the validity of the subsequent Selection Decision-II,
particularly in view of the petitioner‟s contention that the said
minutes demonstrate that results preceding 08.05.2026 were also
taken into consideration.
31.
Before examining the effect of the minutes dated 13.05.2026, it
would be appropriate to notice the relevant timelines governing
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
participation in the YOG, 2026. As per the FEI Regulations for the
Youth Olympic Games, 2026, Article 8, which deals with the
deadlines for selection of Nations, eligibility standards and
Certificates of Capability, prescribes 31.12.2025 as the deadline for
National
Federations/National
Olympic
Committees
to
gain
eligibility to participate in the Youth Olympic Games. The deadline
for submission of the COCs was 20.05.2026, whereas the final entry
deadline was 25.09.2026. The Information Pamphlet issued in
relation to the YOG, 2026 also indicates that the SEQ system for
NOCs to finalise their entries was to open on 24.08.2026, with the
deadline for Sport Entries being 25.09.2026. Thus, the dates relating
to COCs and the date for submission of the final entry were distinct
and operated at different stages of the process.
32.
It is, however, clear from the record that the minutes of the
meeting of the Selection Committee dated 13.05.2026 did record a
decision to select the petitioner herein as the rider to represent India
at the YOG, 2026. This position is also borne out from the
correspondence exchanged between EFI and FEI between 13.05.2026
and 20.05.2026. The genuineness of these minutes is also no longer
in dispute.
33.
At the same time, it cannot be ignored that the said minutes
themselves record that, at that stage, only two riders, i.e., the
petitioner and Neil Kendall, had reached out with the intent to
participate in YOG, 2026. Although seven riders had obtained their
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
COCs, there is nothing on record to show that, prior to the meeting
dated 13.05.2026, all seven riders had been called upon specifically
to express their interest in participating in the YOG, 2026. The
remaining eligible riders were, therefore, not part of the comparative
exercise undertaken on 13.05.2026 by the then Selection Committee.
The respondents have also explained that the petitioner‟s name was
thereafter communicated to the FEI in the context of the COC
submission process. It is also not disputed that the deadlines of
15.05.2026 and 20.05.2026, relied upon in the correspondence/email
exchange at that stage, related to the COC process and not to the final
entry of the Indian contingent for the YOG, 2026. As noted above,
the FEI Regulations and the Information Pamphlet make it clear that
the final entry deadline was 25.09.2026. The record also does not
show that, after 20.05.2026, the FEI treated the communication of the
petitioner‟s name as the final and irrevocable entry for the YOG.
34.
More importantly, much has transpired between the meeting
dated 13.05.2026 and the present stage of the proceedings. On
10.06.2026, the EFI communicated to all seven eligible COC holders,
including the petitioner, that they had been included in the long list of
riders under consideration for selection to represent India at the
YOG, 2026. The same communication expressly stated that the final
selection would be based upon an objective assessment of recent
performances,
consistency
of
results,
competitiveness
at
CSI1*/CSI2* events and overall merit. The riders were also
specifically required to submit their latest competition results and
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
performance records by 25.07.2026, which was mentioned as the cutoff date for consideration.
35.
The petitioner thereafter participated in the said process along
with the other eligible riders. The riders participated in international
competitions, submitted their subsequent results and appeared before
the Selection Committee. The petitioner also submitted her
subsequent results for consideration. Thus, irrespective of what was
recorded in the minutes dated 13.05.2026, the position that emerged
after 10.06.2026 was that all seven eligible riders were being
considered for the final selection, on the basis of the criteria
communicated to them and the results submitted up to 25.07.2026.
36.
There is yet another aspect which this Court cannot lose sight
of while deciding the present case. The final entry deadline for the
YOG, 2026 is 25.09.2026, and only about a week remains before the
said deadline. In these circumstances, it would neither be possible nor
appropriate to remit the matter once again to the Selection Committee
for commencing a fresh exercise on the basis of the material and
events which existed several months ago. Such a course would
require the Court to disregard the entire process undertaken after May
2026, in which all seven eligible riders participated, including by
travelling to different countries, participating in international
competitions, submitting their subsequent performance records and
making their respective representations before the Selection
Committee.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
37.
The Court must also remain conscious of the practical realities
of selection for an international sporting event. The present case
concerns equestrian sport, where the rider and horse combinations
may be located at different places and participation in international
competitions involves considerable logistical arrangements. The
Division Bench of this Court, in Anush Agarwalla v. Ad-Hoc
Committee for Governance of Equestrian Federation of India and
Others: 2026 SCC OnLine Del 4965, while dealing with the selection
process for the Asian Games, was faced with a similar constraint of
time. The Division Bench noticed that, having regard to the
impending deadline, it was logistically impracticable to conduct a
further competition within the available time, particularly when the
riders and horses were located at different places across the globe.
The Court, therefore, refrained from interfering, keeping in view the
larger interest of the sport and the participation of the Indian team.
The relevant observations in this regard are as under:
“55. Accordingly, while we do not find any infirmity in the
preparation of the list of Probables in terms of Clause 13 of the
Selection Criteria, we are of the view that the requirements
prescribed under Clauses 15(a) and 15(b) of the Selection Criteria
were not duly complied with.
56. Having regard to the deadline of 15-7-2026, it is logistically
impracticable to conduct a further competition within the time
available, particularly since the riders and horses are located at
different places across the globe and transporting horses from
different locations to a common venue for conducting a competition
amongst all six (6) Probables would not be possible in such a short
span of time.
57. Having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
present case and considering the limited time available before the
deadline of 15-7-2026, we are constrained to refrain from interfering
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
with the Impugned judgment. Such restraint is warranted in the larger
interest of the sport and to avoid any adverse impact on the prospects
of the Indian Team participating in the Dressage Event at the Asian
Games.
58. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present Appeals are
disposed of without interference with the Impugned judgment, with
direction to EFI to strictly comply with the Selection Criteria
henceforth.”
38.
In the present case as well, the original selection was made on
06.08.2026, followed by the review process pursuant to which
Selection Decision-II was taken on 24.08.2026 and adopted by the
Ad-Hoc Committee on 27.08.2026. The seven eligible riders had
participated in the process during this period. To now set the entire
process aside and require a fresh selection exercise, particularly when
the final entry deadline is 25.09.2026, would cause further
uncertainty and leave very limited time for completion of the
formalities necessary for India‟s participation in the YOG, 2026.
39.
This Court is, therefore, of the view that, in the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the present case, notwithstanding the existence
of the minutes dated 13.05.2026 and the fact that those minutes
recorded the selection of the petitioner at that stage, it would not be
appropriate to remit the matter for any further selection exercise. The
said minutes have to be viewed in the context in which they were
prepared and cannot be treated as determinative of the final selection
process which subsequently commenced with all seven eligible riders
being placed on the long list and being called upon to submit their
latest performances up to 25.07.2026.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
40.
While observing so, this Court also remains conscious of the
fact that the learned counsel for the petitioner herself, during the
course of arguments, has not claimed that the petitioner ought to be
declared selected merely on the basis of the minutes dated
13.05.2026; rather it was argued that the reliance upon the said
minutes is essentially to demonstrate that the Selection Committee
had, at that stage, considered results from 2025 as well as 2026 and,
therefore, according to the petitioner, the subsequent exclusion of
results preceding 08.05.2026 was impermissible. However, this Court
has already, for the reasons recorded hereinabove, rejected the
petitioner‟s contention that the selection criteria prescribed an eightmonth selection window commencing from 08.11.2025, or that all
qualifying results preceding 08.05.2026 were necessarily required to
be considered.
41.
Accordingly, the reliance placed by the petitioner on the
minutes dated 13.05.2026 do not persuade this Court to interfere with
Selection Decision-II dated 27.08.2026, at this stage.
42.
The grounds raised by the petitioner in this regard, as well as
the challenge to the exclusion of results preceding 08.05.2026, are
accordingly rejected. The impugned Selection Decision-II is
accordingly not interfered with.
C.
Before Parting: Observations for Future Selection Processes
by EFI
43.
Before parting with the case, this Court is constrained to
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
take note of the manner in which the selection process has
unfolded in the present case. Though this Court would not ordinarily
enter into the domain of policy formulation, it is considered
necessary by this Court to make certain observations for the
consideration of the Equestrian Federation of India, with a view to
bringing greater clarity and uniformity in future selection processes
and avoiding any uncertainty amongst eligible athletes. The manner
in which the selection process has evolved in the present case,
particularly the existence of the minutes of meeting dated 13.05.2026
of the earlier Selection Committee, is a matter which this Court views
with concern. While this Court has refrained from interfering with the
ultimate selection for the reasons recorded hereinabove, such
uncertainty in a selection process involving athletes representing the
country ought to be avoided. Therefore, to prevent such situations
from arising in future and to ensure that future selection processes are
conducted with greater clarity, transparency and consistency, the
following suggestions are made for the consideration of EFI:
(i)
First, the EFI should, henceforth, consider prescribing,
in clear terms, the selection window and the relevant timelines
for each stage of the selection process, including the date from
which performances would be considered, the cut-off date for
submission of results and the date by which the final selection
is proposed to be made. This would avoid any ambiguity as to
which performances are eligible for consideration.
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
(ii)
Second, while selection criteria necessarily requires a
degree of discretion and flexibility, an endeavour should be
made to make such criteria as specific and transparent as
reasonably possible by setting out, wherever feasible, further
particulars regarding the manner in which factors such as –
recent performance, consistency, level of competition and
other relevant parameters are to be assessed. This would ensure
that the athletes are aware, in advance, of the basis on which
their performances are likely to be assessed and would reduce
the possibility of the interpretation of broad or open-ended
criteria being left entirely to the discretion of the members of
the Selection Committee at a later stage.
44.
These observations are intended only to facilitate greater
clarity, transparency and uniformity in future selection processes by
the EFI.
45.
The petition, alongwith pending application, if any, is disposed
of with above observations.
46.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026/A
W.P.(C) 12760/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:52:59
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review