Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
TH
MONDAY, THE 7
DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 17TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 11.08.2017 IN SC NO.321 OF 2016 OF HON’BLE
PRINCIPAL
SESSIONS COURT, KOTTAYAM
PETITIONERS/ACCUSED:
V.T.JINU
HEAD CLERK ETTUMANOOR BLOCK PANCHAYATH ETTUMANOOR, KOTTAYAM
DISTRICT
MS VIJAYAN
GENERAL EXTENSION OFFICER, ETTUMANNOR BLOCK PANCHAYATH
ETTUMANOOR, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT
BY ADVS.
SMT.K.G.MARY
SRI.ARUN P. ANTONY
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,HIGH COURT OF KERALA
PIN-682031
DEPUTY SUPERINTENDANT OF POLICE
DISTRICT CRIME BRANCH KOTTAYAM PIN-686001
SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE
ETTUMANOOR POLICE STATION KOTTAYAM
OTHER PRESENT:
PP JIBU T S
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY
25.03.2025, THE COURT ON 07.04.2025, DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
HEARD
ON
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
CR
A. BADHARUDEEN, J
============================
Crl.Rev. Petition No. 15 of 2018
==============================
Dated 7th day of April 2025
ORDER
This Crl. Rev. Petition has been led under Section 397 r/w
401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, “Cr.P.C.”) to
quash Annexure - VII charge dated 11.08.2017 framed by the
Special Court (Principal Sessions Court, Kottayam) under the
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities)
Act, 1989 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the SC/ST PO Act’) in S.C.
No. 321 of 2016, pending therein.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
2. Heard the learned counsel for the 2nd petitioner/2nd
accused, since the 1st petitioner/1st accused is no more. Also
heard the learned Public Prosecutor.
Perused the records
produced along with the petition and also the Case Diary as such
placed by the learned Public Prosecutor in detail.
3. In this matter, the prosecution alleges the commission of
o ences punishable under Sections 294(b), 465, 466, 474 r/w 34
of IPC as well as under Section 3(1)(x) of the SC/ST PO Act by
the accused. The speci c allegation is that, the accused herein who
are aware of the caste identity of the de facto complainant as a
member of the Scheduled Caste community, at about 05.00 p.m
on 07.10.2013, used abusive words by calling her caste name with
intention to humiliate her within public view. Further allegation
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
is that they forged documents to hold that the de facto
complainant misappropriated some amount under 9 CB Bills, and
the same resulted in suspension of the de facto complainant.
4. The rst point argued by the learned counsel for the 2nd
petitioner is that, in this matter, in order to prosecute the 2nd
petitioner/2nd accused sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C. is
necessary, since he is a public servant at the alleged time of
occurrence. Even though the prosecution applied for sanction, no
sanction so far obtained and therefore, the entire proceedings is
vitiated.
In this connection, the learned counsel for the 2nd
petitioner placed decision of the Apex Court reported in 2023
KHC 6628 Amod Kumar Kanth v. Association of Victim of
Uphaar Tragedy, where in the facts are as under:-
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
“An unfortunate and tragic incident led to a criminal
prosecution accused against 16 accused; in which 59 persons
lost their lives and over 100 persons received serious injuries,
while viewing a film sitting in the balcony of Uphaar
Theater. High Court has dismissed the petition filed by the
appellant under S.482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973. Said petition was filed against the order passed by the
Additional Sessions Judge; wherein Sessions Judge confirmed
the decision of Metropolitan Magistrate rejecting the closure
report filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation. Closure
report filed by the CBI was not accepted by the Magistrate,
who instead took cognizance on the protest petition filed by
the first respondent and cognizance has been taken for
offences under S.304A, S.337, S.338 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 and the provisions under S.14 of the
Cinematograph Act, 1952 read with the Rules. Present
appeal is filed against the order of High Court dismissing
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
the petition filed under S.482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973. Main issue for consideration was; whether
said order upholding the order of the Magistrate taking
cognizance and issuing summons was illegal.”
5. In the said case, the apex Court held as under:“ The most important question which must be posed and
answered by the Court when dealing with the argument that
sanction is not forthcoming is whether the officer was acting
in the exercise of his official duties. It goes further. Even an
officer who acts in the purported exercise of his official power
is given the protection under. S.197 of the Cr.P.C. This is for
good reason that the officer when he exercises the power can go
about exercising the same fearlessly no doubt with bona fides
as public functionaries can act only bona fide. In fact, the
requirement of the action being bona fide is not expressly
stated in S.197 of the Cr.P.C., though it is found in many
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
other statutes protecting public servants from action, civil
and criminal against them. Once we bear this cardinal
principle in mind and judge the action or omission on the
part of the appellant, we would think that it cannot be found
that, having regard to the admitted facts, the appellant was
not acting in the discharge of his official functions. All that
happened, under his oversight starting with his notice which
he issued on 28/07/1979, to the counter affidavit which he
filed in the writ petitions, the subsequent show cause notice
which he issued, and thereafter, finally on 24/12/1979,
wherein he directed the removal of a total of 62 additional
seats, all these acts were done in the exercise of his official
duties. As we have already noted, even if it were to be treated
as done in the purported exercise of his official duties, he
would still stand protected from prosecution without
sanction. This must not be confused with the question as to
whether the appellant had committed any offence with which
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
he appears to have been indicted by the Magistrate issuing
summons and the High Court upholding it. The fact that the
appellant had taken a certain stand in the counter affidavit
would not make his subsequent act of acting upon the
recommendations of a committee, an act which is not in the
discharge of his official functions. The findings of this Court
which we have referred to in the decision (supra) would not
mean that, if they are offences committed by the persons
including the appellant, they would not require sanction
within the meaning of S.197 of the Cr.P.C. The subtle and
nuanced distinction between the question as to whether the
offence has been committed and if an offence has been
committed, whether a sanction is required for prosecuting a
public servant who is alleged to have committed the same,
must not be lost sight of. The learned Magistrate and the
High Court would appear to have overlooked this distinction.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
6. According to the learned counsel for the 2nd petitioner,
even in cases involving o ences under the unamended SC/ST PO
Act, prosecution sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C. is
necessary to prosecute a public servant. In this regard, the learned
counsel for the 2nd petitioner placed the decision of the Apex
Court reported in 2021 KHC Online 6319 Indira Devi v. State
of Rajasthan and Another, where in paragraph No.9, the Apex
Court considered the necessity of sanction under Section 197 of
Cr.P.C., where o ences under Sections 3(1)(4), 3(15), and 3(5) of
the SC/ST PO Act were alleged. In paragraph No.9, the Apex
Court observed that:
“9. We have given our thought to the submissions of
learned counsel for the parties. S.197 of the CrPC seeks to
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
protect an officer from unnecessary harassment, who is
accused of an offence committed while acting or purporting
to act in the discharge of his official duties and, thus,
prohibits the Court from taking cognizance of such offence
except with the previous sanction of the competent
authority. Public servants have been treated as a special
category in order to protect them from malicious or
vexatious prosecution. At the same time, the shield cannot
protect corrupt officers and the provisions must be
construed in such a manner as to advance the cause of
honesty, justice and good governance. [See Subramanian
Swamy v. Manmohan Singh (2012 KHC 4072: (2012) 3
SCC 64 : 2012 (1) KHC SN 29: 2012 (1) KLD 327: 2012
(2) SCALE 12 : 2012 (1) KLT SN 90 : AIR 2012 SC 1185
: 2012 CriLJ 1519)]. The alleged indulgence of the officers
in cheating, fabrication of records or misappropriation
cannot be said to be in discharge of their official duty.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
However, such sanction is necessary if the offence alleged
against the public servant is committed by him "while
acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official
duty" and in order to find out whether the alleged offence
is committed "while acting or purporting to act in the
discharge of his official duty", the yardstick to be followed
is to form a prima facie view whether the act of omission
for which the accused was charged had a reasonable
connection with the discharge of his duties. [See State of
Maharashtra v. Dr. Budhikota Subbarao (supra)]. The
real question, therefore, is whether the act committed is
directly concerned with the official duty.
7. In this matter, as per Annexure - VII order, the learned
Special Judge framed charge for the o ences punishable under
Sections 294(b), 465, 466 and 474 r/w Section 34 of IPC against
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
accused Nos. 1 and 2 and also framed charge for the o ence under
Section 3(1)(x) of the SC/ST PO Act against them.
8. Since the 1st accused/1st petitioner is no more, his
contention that he is not a member of either Scheduled Caste or
Scheduled Tribe Community is of no signi cance at present. It is
not disputed that the 2nd petitioner is not a member of Scheduled
Caste or Scheduled Tribe community. However, the question to be
considered is whether, prima facie the o ences for which the trial
court framed charge are made out from the prosecution records.
While framing charge, the essentials to be considered are well
settled. In the decision reported in 2024 KHC OnLine 586
Sandeep G v. State of Kerala, this Court epitomized the
parameters that would govern, when plea of discharge under S.227
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
of CrPC and framing of charge under S.228 of CrPC are to be
addressed, referring the Apex Court verdicts on the point and the
same are as under:
(i) The trial Judge shall look into the materials collected
by the investigating agency produced before the Court, to
see, prima facie, whether those materials would induce
suspicious circumstances against the accused, so as to frame
a charge and such material would be taken into account
for the purposes of framing the charge.
(ii) The trial Judge has to apply his judicial mind to the
facts of the case, with reference to the materials produced
by the prosecution, as may be necessary, to determine
whether a case has been made out by the prosecution for
trial on the basis of charge/final report.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
(iii) Once the accused is able to demonstrate from the
materials form part of the charge/final report at the stage
of framing the charge which might drastically affect the
very sustainability of the case, it is unfair to suggest that
such material should not be considered or ignored by the
court at this stage.
(iv) At the stage of considering an application for
discharge the court must proceed on an assumption that
the materials which have been brought on record by the
prosecution are true and evaluate said materials, in order
to determine whether the facts emerging from the
materials taken on its face value, disclose the existence of
the ingredients necessary of the offence/s alleged.
(v) The defence of the accused not to be looked into at the
stage when the accused seeks discharge. The expression "the
record of the case" used in S.227 CrPC is to be understood
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
as the documents and objects, if any, produced by the
prosecution.
(vi) The primary consideration at the stage of framing of
charge is the test of existence of a prima-facie case, and at
this stage, the probative value of materials on record shall
not be evaluated.
(vii) At the stage of framing of charge, the court has to
form a presumptive opinion to the existence of factual
ingredients constituting the offence alleged and it is not
expected to go deep into probative value of the material on
record and to check whether the material on record would
certainly lead to conviction at the conclusion of trial.
(viii) In assessing this fact, it is not necessary for the court
to enter into the pros and cons of the matter or into a
weighing and balancing of evidence and probabilities,
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
which are really the function of the trial Judge, after the
trial.
(ix) At the time of framing charge, if there is suspicion
which leads the Court to think that there is ground for
presuming that the accused has committed an offence then
it is not open to the Court to say that there is no sufficient
ground for proceeding against the accused. In such case
also charge needs to be framed to permit the prosecution to
adduce evidence.
(x) If the evidence which the Prosecutor proposes to adduce
to prove the guilt of the accused even if fully accepted
before it is challenged in cross-examination or rebutted by
the defence evidence, if any, cannot show that the accused
committed the offence, then there will be no sufficient
ground for proceeding with the trial.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
9. It is pointed out by the the learned counsel for the 2nd
petitioner that, the allegation as to use of abusive words and
calling of caste name of the de facto complainant by the 2nd
petitioner along with the 1st accused was raised as on 07.10.2013,
but as per Annexure - II dated 05.10.2013, the 2nd petitioner
lodged a complaint before the President, Ettumanur Block
Panchayath regarding malpractices done between the Block
Development O cer (hereinafter referred as the BDO) and the de
facto complainant in the matter of payment without quotation
purchase. Thereafter, this case was foisted. The learned counsel
also pointed out that apart from the version of de facto
complainant, CW3 also given statement supporting the
prosecution. But no others in the o ce supported the prosecution
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
case. He also pointed out that CW3 is a temporary employee later
terminated from service and therefore her version also could not
be believed.
According to the learned counsel for the 2nd
petitioner, in fact, the de facto complainant was suspended from
service, and charge memo also issued against her as brought out
from Annexure A3 series, Annexure - IV charge memo and
recommendation to transfer her also was made, though the nality
of the disciplinary action not known to the 2nd petitioner. The
learned counsel for the 2nd petitioner also argued that in order to
prove forgery, no scienti c examination was conducted by sending
the documents alleged to be forged and used as genuine, but
merely statements of witnesses alone are given emphasis in this
regard. According to the learned counsel for the 2nd petitioner,
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
the prosecution materials available are quite insu cient to frame
charge against the 2nd petitioner and therefore, challenge against
Annexure - VII is liable to succeed.
10. The learned Public Prosecutor vehemently opposed
quashement of Annexure VII order. According to the learned
Public Prosecutor, in the instant case, the allegations are not in
connection with the discharge of the o cial duties of the 2nd
petitioner and therefore, sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C. is
not necessary.
Even though the prosecution applied for getting
sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C., the result of the same is yet
to be known. The learned Public Prosecutor has given heavy
reliance on the statements of CWs 1, 2, and 3 to substantiate that
the allegations in the charge are speci cally made out, prima facie,
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
against the 2nd petitioner. Apart from that, the learned Public
Prosecutor has given much emphasis on the statements of CWs 15
to 25 to substantiate that there was fabrication of documents on
the premise of a meeting on 07.10.2013, and the matter would
require trial to prove the same.
11. As regards to sanction to prosecute a Government
servant, as per the unamended penal provisions of the SC/ST PO
Act and for the IPC o ences, sanction under Section 197 of
Cr.P.C is necessary when the o ences alleged against the public
servant are committed by him “while acting or purporting to act
in the discharge of his o cial duty” and in order to nd whether
the alleged o ence is committed while acting or purporting to act
in the discharge of his o cial duty, the yardstick to be followed is
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
to form a prima facie view whether the act of omission for which
the accused was charged had a reasonable connection with the
discharge of his duties. In cases where the act or omission for
which the accused was charged had a reasonable connection with
the discharge of his duties, necessitating such an act or omission,
then sanction is not necessary.
12. On perusal of the FI Statement given by the de facto
complainant,
it is stated that while she was working in the
Educational Department (Government High School, Ayyankavu
Kothamangalam), she was deployed as Lower Division Clerk in the
Block Panchayath, Ettumanur. She dealt with the “General
purchase fund seat” between 10.05.2012 to 22.10.2013, and later,
she started to deal with Census and BPL Sections. According to
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
her, at about 5.00 p.m., on 07.10.2013, while she was engaged in
her o cial duties, Head Clerk V T Jinu of Ettumanoor Block
Panchayath and Sri. M S Vijayan, General Extention O cer
reached her room, and ashamed her by telling that she was the
keep of the BDO, and the speci c allegation against the 2nd
petitioner is that he ashamed the de facto complainant by calling
her caste name, and on uttering that, nobody would question if
something done against her, since she was member of Scheduled
Caste community. The further allegation is that they uttered that
they would teach a lesson to the de facto complainant. When her
additional statement was recorded thereafter by the Deputy
Superintendent of Police, she reiterated the allegations, and it was
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
stated that the accused are not members of the Scheduled Caste or
Scheduled Tribe community.
13. Supporting the statements of the de facto complainant,
she also gave 164 statement before the Magistrate. The prosecution
cited CW3 Mrs. Geetha Rajendran to support the statements of
the de facto complainant. The statement of CW3 is that she
worked as data entry operator on daily wages in between July 2013
to 22.11.2013, and she witnessed the occurrence as stated by the de
facto complainant. Apart from that, prosecution recorded the
statement of CW2
Sri. Renjit, who worked as the temporary
driver of the President of the Panchayath. In his statement how he
came to know about lodging of the complaint by the de facto
complainant alleging the overt acts has been averred. But he didn’t
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
know what exactly said or done by the accused. Insofar as the
allegations under Sections 294(b) as well as under Section 3(1)(x)
of the SC/ST PO Act, these are the statements relied on by the
prosecution. Coming to o ences under Sections 465, 466, and
474 of IPC, heavy reliance has been given by the learned Public
Prosecutor witness statements of CWs 15 to 25, but the
prosecution records in no way would suggest that the alleged
forgery and use of the same as genuine documents, etc proved by
getting expert opinion in any manner. CW15 is cited by the
prosecution to prove that CW15 worked as the driver in block
Panchayath to prove creation of false document to show the
evaluation meeting of ‘gramavikasanavaragosham’. CW16 is cited
to prove that he conducted departmental enquiry against the 1st
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
and the 5th witnesses and led report in this regard, and also to
prove that while encashing 9 CB Bills, Lower Division clerk, Head
Clerk and BDO failed to follow the procedure for money transfer,
and also to prove that the 1st witness misbehaved to the President.
CW17 was cited to prove that there was no meeting on
07.10.2013, and his signature was obtained in a blank paper. CWs
23 to 25 were also cited to prove that there was no meeting on
07.10.2013.
Since the prosecution records would throw light
prima facie regarding the commission of the above o ences, the
trial court framed Annexure -VII charge and proceeded with the
trial, and in fact, the said order is under challenge before this
Court.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
14. On scrutiny of the prosecution records, it could not be
held that the trial court went wrong in framing charge for the
o ences stated in Annexure - VII order.
15. It is relevant to note that though this is a revision
petition led challenging Annexure - VII order framing charge,
the learned counsel for the 2nd petitioner argued the necessity of
sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C. In Indira Devi’s case
(supra) itself, the Apex Court clari ed that the alleged indulgence
of
the
o cers
in cheating, fabrication of records, or
misappropriation could not be said as acts in discharge of their
o cial duties. If so, the allegations of insulting and intimidating a
member of the Scheduled Caste community and fabricating
records to show conduct of a meeting are not matters would come
CRL.REV.PET NO. 15 OF 2018
2025:KER:30632
within the o cial duties of a public servant and therefore in order
to prosecute the o ender though he is a public servant, no
sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C is necessary.
16. Holding so, no interference in the order impugned is
necessary and thus the revision fails. Accordingly, the same stands
dismissed.
The interim stay stands vacated.
Sd/A. BADHARUDEEN, JUDGE
RMV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review